What if Ke’Bryan Hayes and Bryan Reynolds play all of the 2024 season like they played in August and September of 2023?
What if Mich Keller’s 2024 season matches is equal to his May of 2023?
What if Endy plays like he did as a Minor Leaguer when he won MVP at two levels?
What if Henry Davis hits like he did in Altoona last year?
What if Jack Suwinski hits six home runs each month and never goes more than three games without a hit?
What if Oneil Cruz is a viable MVP candidate?
What if somebody, anybody can play a good defensive 2B and just be an average MLB hitter?
What if the Pirates trade for Dylan Cease and sign Jack Flaherty?
What if Johan Oviedo has 20 games of one run or less instead of the 15 he pitched in 2023?
What if a bullpen that looks intriguing is actually elite?
What if Paul Skenes is called up May 1st and pitches his way to Rookie of the Year?
What if at the trade deadline the Pirates acquire an impact player?
What if ownership and management decides to win and not just compete?