North Shore Nine

Ryan and DiNardo dug in on a packed agenda for the latest Bucco Brew, tackling the biggest storylines shaping the Pirates’ present and future. They opened with Paul Skenes’ eye-opening challenge to his teammates, as the rookie ace called on everyone to “look in the mirror” and recognize the sacrifices needed to win at the highest level. The hosts broke down how Skenes’ words reflect a growing leadership role and the urgency inside the clubhouse.

The conversation shifted to Andrew McCutchen, whose emotional at-bat at PNC Park could have been his last in a Pirates uniform. Ryan and DiNardo weighed whether the franchise icon should return for 2026, balancing sentiment with roster needs and what his presence means to the fan base.

Next up was GM Ben Cherington, who confirmed he’s operating as though he will return next season. He highlighted a much-improved farm system, hinting that it could be leveraged in offseason trades to upgrade the major league roster. The hosts explored how this depth could reshape the Pirates over the winter.

Finally, the crew contrasted Pittsburgh’s managerial choices with the Cincinnati Reds’ bold decision to hire Terry Francona. Projected as equals before the season, the two NL Central rivals have taken dramatically different paths—a reminder of how impactful leadership hires can be.

From Skenes’ leadership to McCutchen’s future and Cherington’s trade plans, this episode delivers a candid look at where the Pirates stand and where they’re headed.

? Listen now and join the discussion—available on YouTube or your favorite podcast app.