The 2025 season is finally in the books, and on this episode of Bucco Brew the North Shore Nine crew digs into what went wrong from the very start. Anthony and Jim unpack the revelations in Noah Hiles’ explosive Post-Gazette article, which paints a candid picture of a clubhouse that sensed the year was lost before April ended.
They cover the pressure on Derek Shelton during a “must-win” sixth season, the disconnect between players and front office, and the scathing anonymous quotes that call out organizational complacency. From players frustrated by a stagnant offseason to concerns over analytics resources and even complaints about PNC Park’s batter’s eye, the episode highlights a team that never found its footing.
The guys also lighten things up with their annual Pirates Sporcle quiz, testing whether they can remember all 57 players who suited up in 2025.
Grab a cup of De Fer Coffee & Tea and listen in. Use promo code NS930 at defer.coffee for 30% off your first order. Watch or listen now and join the conversation—Pirates fans deserve answers before 2026 arrives.
North Shore Nine 
Leave a comment