North Shore Nine

Tonight’s NS9LIVE! delivered everything from chaos to clarity as DiNardo, Jim, and Tyler debuted a brand-new segment, “Ask Someone Something Stupid,” and got Pirates prospect Antwone Kelly to answer within minutes. The guys then welcomed MLB.com’s Alex Stumpf, whose recent Reddit AMA comments about Andrew McCutchen sparked a full-blown storyline after Cutch himself responded on Twitter with, “Wow that’s news to me.” Alex broke down what he actually meant, why frustrations existed on both sides in 2025, and why a Cutch return is far from guaranteed. From there, the show shifted into heavy offseason talk, including why the Pirates must make a statement at the Winter Meetings and which trade targets—Steven Kwan, Yandy Díaz, Brandon Lowe, and others—could reshape the lineup.

Want the full breakdown, laughs, drama, and analysis? Watch or listen to the full episode now.