◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
The Pirates ended April with a 5-game losing streak, a Cardinals sweep at home, and a very different feeling than they had just one week ago. At 16-16, they’re not buried, but this stretch exposed how thin the margins are for this team. On this episode of NS9LIVE!, we discuss Paul Skenes not stopping the skid, Oneil Cruz, Bryan Reynolds, the bullpen, Don Kelly’s decisions, and whether this is real concern or just one brutal week.
Watch or listen now.
Comments· 0
The Debate
Should the Pirates move Oneil Cruz out of the leadoff spot until he snaps out of his slump?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.
With Anthony DiNardo, Tyler Sweeney and Jim Rosati.
Chapters
Key takeaways
1
Oneil Cruz has collapsed after his record 9-homer, 10-steal April start: .164 with a 44.4% strikeout rate and under a 50 wRC+ over his last 66 plate appearances. That's 'not MVP caliber,' and it looks like last year's fade.
2
Cruz is the catalyst, but he's never on base right now and the team starts every game with an out. It may be time to move him out of the leadoff spot, possibly putting Horwitz there, until he fixes things.
3
The season is in trouble because the roster badly lacks depth, especially in pitching. Mlodzinski and Chandler can't go deep, middle relief is a revolving door, and with only Triolo and Jared Jones on the IL, the injuries that will come could sink them.
4
The bullpen is the problem. Santana has an expected DRA over 5 and isn't missing bats, the middle relief is 'atrocious' and gave back two comebacks against St. Louis, and outside of Wilber Dotel there's no help coming from AAA.
5
The power is real. They're on pace for 170 homers, 53 more than last year's 117, and that alone should turn some of last year's 2-1 and 3-2 losses into wins.
Yo! Welcome to the North Shore Nine Podcast presented by FanDuel. This is NS9 Live. I'm your host, Anthony DiNardo. With me, we have Ty, we have
Jim and fellas. How are you all doing? I was better after a road series win against Milwaukee. I'm with Jim. I felt better about five games ago. Yep. Yes. I think we all agree. It is not fun getting swept by the Cardinals at home. Not at all. Yeah. Yeah. life's starting to suck again, boys.
Yes. Yes. I was going to say, don't you remember on Monday, we were talking on Bucco Brew, the Pirates, six and three against the NL Central. They've won every series and they're all been away. So, taking care of the Cardinals at home, they should be able to take two out of three, right? They got swept.
In three out of four. They got mopped, I believe is the phrase. Four game sweep at home. Yeah.
Just terrible. Yeah. I think it was Ryan who tweeted it out the other day. Like, you lose this series and you lose all the good stuff that just happened.
And, four game, four game sweep, five in a row. You were 16 and 11 before this. And now, before you know it, you're 16 and 16. And the rest of the NL Central just won't freaking lose a game.
The Cincinnati Reds are 20 and 11 with a negative run differential. They're somehow winning these games. And yeah, there's some space now between the Reds and the Cubs and the Pirates. It's, it sucks. It sucks.
It's been a very frustrating stretch here. And it's also frustrating when I think we came in today thinking you have Paul Skins on the mound. He's a stopper and it just didn't go that way. So, getting swept by the Cardinals. When you have Paul Skins in that mix, that hurts, man. It hurts.
That's what really sucks. I think I did the post game show on Monday when it was rumored that, Braxton Ashcraft was probably going to start on Tuesday. Like, it wasn't absolutely determined that it was going to, but it was likely to happen.
Then we were talking about back then, like, Hey, Paul Skins is a stopper, but Braxton Ashcraft has been, really just every bit as good as Paul Skins this year, almost. And, like, I feel like you can, you can count on Braxton Ashcraft to certainly be a stopper.
It was two losses at a time. The first time they've lost two in a row since the opening day series. The last first two games against the Mets. It's like, you know what? We get back into, back into, back in line with things. And they lost that game in a bad way. And they lost the next one. And then, okay, at least Paul Skins is here, right? Hey, the stoppers here. We're not going to lose the series guys. Right? Right.
Right. Yeah. We thought so. Right. We thought that, at the very least, I think we all assume that at least get one out of this thing, especially with Paul Skins going again.
And I said that, but at least after Monday, during Monday, you think during that game, you think that's a game that should be in the bag and you're starting off the series.
Well, and then about, I don't know, nine o'clock on Monday night, shit, it's a fan.
Yeah. right here, Brian says like, if it could go wrong, it went wrong.
Like Monday was a game that you could have stole with that bullpen game.
Like, I feel like you were like, all right, let's just get through this.
they got through it with a lead.
They were pitching a perfect game into the seventh inning.
everything was going swimmingly.
and then your closer, who's just been lights out ever since arriving here, gives up four runs and then boom, there you go.
the series was off to an awful start.
Then you had the Braxton Ashcraft game where, it was him and Barco were like the only two pitchers available that day.
And so those two guys went nine innings, Barco coming off bereavement list.
So you just, his routines off, he didn't look like his normal self.
Barco got shelled and you scored, you scored some runs that game, but you also gave up a bunch.
yesterday, you're a foot away from a walk-off homer yesterday.
So like, it's just, there's so many little things that happened in this series today.
They got blown out plain and simple today.
They got blown out, but yeah, they did try coming back though too.
And a lot of stuff went wrong.
Yeah.
I don't know how this is going to work.
breaking news.
We got a voicemail from Bucko Mike.
Let me see if this.
See if you work technology.
I don't know if it'll work.
This message is for Anthony DiNardo.
Paul Skenes, his own, is the Cardinals own Paul Skenes.
I just need you to know that.
Sincerely, Bucko Mike.
Have a good night.
Have a good night, fellas.
How about Bucko Mike?
Bucko Mike making the appearance.
he's right.
The Cardinals are the, Paul Skenes is Owen five against the Cardinals.
You guys.
Yeah.
That's amazing.
Insane.
There's only two teams that he's Owen two against.
That's the Brewers and the Cubs.
And then he's Owen five against the Cardinals.
I just say, Oh, and two, there's only two teams.
He has two losses against.
That's what I meant to say.
Yep.
Shout out Bucko Mike.
He's out of the hospital, out of, out of rehab.
So hopefully he's doing a lot better.
Pirates aren't helping him, but glad he's out and about.
Pirates haven't won a game since Bucko Mike's been released from rehab.
It's the Bucko Mike is free curse is what we're going on.
It was what we're going with right now.
I'm good with that.
Go get unhealthy again.
Bucko Mike.
No, stay healthy.
But no, stay healthy.
We need you, bud.
We're going to need Bucko Mike for the stretch run.
but no, it was, it was a terrible series.
I said, we had, we had four post game shows about it.
All of them were a couple of brutal games.
Today's was, it was what it was, but yeah, some brutal, some brutal losses this week.
And they gotta, they gotta stop it.
Like this train can't keep rolling.
They need to stop it.
They got to get a win.
Cincinnati's coming to town.
They're 20 and 11.
They're in first place and their fans are dunking all over pirates fans on Twitter.
I've noticed that like they're the Reds fans have been waiting for this opportunity all off season and they're taking it.
So yeah, the pirates need to win some games this weekend.
You got to win this series.
You got to stop the bleeding right here.
I have to, you, I thought we were on the right track here after getting the first two in Milwaukee, the house of horse negativity was just thrown out the window.
And then that Cardinal devil magic just came back and my God, it was devil magic, a lot of nights, but they also got their teeth kicked in for a couple of games.
Yeah, it's, this sucks right now, guys, this sucks right now should have been an enjoyable April.
They finished at 500.
You got, you got to keep battling through, I guess.
still 500 after April is not the worst thing in the world.
some we'll get to the rest of it, I guess, but some other things could happen and just shower.
Well, I guess, as Clint hurdle says, I'm going to take a ton of showers.
Like how many showers do you got to take?
my God.
Yeah.
They got to win a game or a lot last night.
They've got to win a game.
Like just freaking win a game.
Somebody can win a game.
Like you said, Tyler, that was something that you go into Milwaukee and you did what they did.
that was, I felt like that's a huge turning point.
this is like, this is showing the legitimacy of this team.
You know what?
This is something they just cannot do.
And they went into Milwaukee and they semi embarrassed them at home.
And then you go home facing the St.
Louis Cardinals who are more or less, rebuilding and then they sweep you at your home and four games, not even three with Paul Skenes being in one of them.
So yeah, this is bad.
Now to your point, right?
Like think about this.
If it was a month ago and we said like, don't finish April 16 and 16, I don't think any of us would be feeling any way.
Okay.
that's pretty much like about where we felt they were, give or take a few games here and there.
We know the schedule, the early part was, it was tough.
So like if they're 16 at the end of April, okay.
there's no doom and gloom there at all.
Yeah, no, it's, if you would have told me at the beginning of the year, 16 and 16, you take it.
you take it, you're in it.
I think you also would assume that if you're 16 and 16, you're in it.
You're not in last place, right?
So that's a, and it's early.
Like we're, looking at standings this early is silly, but it's just, it is a little deflating to see that, you didn't have a bad first start first month of the year.
It was okay.
But everyone else had a better one than you.
So we're going to get into a few things.
I think each of us prepared one reason.
there's a, I think the fun thing about baseball and you could say it's fun, you could say it's also just grueling and excruciating is that there's 162 games.
And if you're, if, when you're 500, that's just like the worst, because it's just a roller coaster.
There's wins, there's losses.
Like you never really get too high.
You never really get too low.
You're trying to figure out like who you are.
we're low right now.
There was a five game winning streak earlier in the year, the five game losing streak now, but there's still 162 of these.
So you got to remember, Hey, there's still a lot of baseball to be played, but at the same time, you're in last place.
You just lost five in a row as pirates fans.
We just have this PTSD because we've seen this happen a bajillion times where it's like, Oh, we're looking pretty good.
We're looking pretty good.
Boom.
Fall off.
Right.
So you see these five games and you're like, here's the fall off season's over, right?
It's April 30th season's over.
So we're going to, we're going to talk about reasons why the season is over, but we're also going to talk about reasons as to why we might need to chill a little bit.
Yeah.
You talk about the highs and the lows.
That's the thing about the 500 is you're equally, it's not like chill.
you're equally high and you're equally low.
At least if you're winning, it's like, okay, there's more highs when you lose.
I think it's like, we live in a society now.
Everything's instant reaction, right?
Every instant gratification.
So when you lose the world's falling, right?
When you win, you're the best.
Issue is when you win more than not, when the world's falling, it's like, okay, well back tomorrow, you're, everything's great again.
There's some perspective, but yeah, we have the, we have all the motions.
And so this whole rollercoaster just evens out where we're the best, we're the worst, we're the best, we're the worst.
It's everywhere.
And that's, what's frustrating.
Cause it's like just yesterday, just last week, we're talking about, can they win the division?
And now it's like, will they even sniff the playoffs?
Yeah.
Like literally on Monday, we were talking about you go five and two this week.
And all of a sudden, like you're looking really good.
And now we, here we are four days later and the sky is falling.
So how do we want to do this?
Do we want to go, do we want to start with the bad and end with the good?
Is that how we want to do this?
I didn't think that part through.
Did we all bring like five bad things and one good thing?
Or am I the only one that's like super negative right now?
I brought two of each.
I brought, I brought two of each.
Yeah.
You're the only one who brought five bad things and one good thing.
Well, I really had to dig to find some good right now.
We're going.
But that is on ramp.
You know what, let's start with, let's start with the bad and then let's end with the positives here.
Right.
So let's each go around and we can discuss, our issues here, but let's each give one reason why this team, this team ain't it.
Like this last five games, this stretch, this is a, this is the beginning of the end.
Let's do those reasons.
So who wants to start?
I brought five so I can wait.
Okay.
I'll, I brought two.
So.
All right.
DiNardo, you go.
I don't know which one I want to do.
All right.
Well then I'll go.
Let me do this one then.
This is why the world is falling.
Besides all the real reasons the world's falling and we're all going to probably die before the season's over.
Cause the world's going to be destroyed.
We're going to have aliens, invading us.
We'll have world war three.
Right.
Like everything's none of the season matters because the world's going to end.
But besides that, are you referring to the earthquakes at area 51?
There's that thing too.
It is funny.
Like, every day I feel like there's new alien information.
We're just like, all right, whatever.
it was just recently we're talking about Oh, no Cruz.
And the thing about this year is Oh, no Cruz and Bryan Reynolds need to perform.
Regents trade acquisitions.
Great.
But if Oh, no Cruz and Bryan Reynolds are performing, this team's really not going anywhere.
And Oh, no Cruz is performing and like counting stats.
Like he has, he's got the home runs.
He's got the stolen bases.
Jimmy had the tweet out there.
The first time in LB history, someone had, what was it?
10 and 10, nine homers and 10 stolen bases.
Yeah.
Nine homers and 10 stolen bases before the month of May.
Yep.
There it is.
He made history.
This guy could be an MVP caliber.
he's just doing everything until he stopped.
And, yeah, on Bucco Brew, that is something we talked about.
Oh, no Cruz.
And it's like, are there some worries with Oh, no Cruz.
And, you talked about a gym and I agreed with it.
And, we're seeing that right now is past 66.
One more time, 66 plate appearances.
He's batting one 64.
Striking out 44.4% of the time.
Fellas.
That's not MVP caliber type of baseball.
He's got under a 50 weighted runs created plus in that timeframe.
I'm not here to say, of course, like it's all doom and gloom and they're going to, but, yeah, it's not looking good.
And like, that's what happened last year.
He had a hot start and it fell apart.
And that's like you said, Jim, like he's done this before.
That's why I'm not going to sit here and say like, yeah, there are some things to worry.
I don't know if this goes as thing.
Fellas.
Oh, no.
Cruz is bad right now.
Like really bad.
Yeah.
He has four homers in those timeframe in that timeframe.
In those 66 plate appearances, 40% of his hits are home runs.
Makes you wonder.
Yeah.
And I think the other part of that is something we're seeing here.
And we see the pirates fight back later in games and the offense come alive.
But I think we're also seeing that because first, second inning, these guys just aren't performing.
And that starts with the Neil Cruz.
He's hitting lead off every day.
He's not on base ever.
Last week, he's last 66 plate appearances.
He's not on base.
So it's taking them a little while to get more into the game.
Offensively put runs on the board, have base runners.
you're starting the game with an out every game.
He's got to get going.
Yeah.
the offense is just goes, it goes so much, so much smoother when cruises, when cruises on, he is, as you call him, Leonardo, he is the catalyst.
When he's on the offense is on.
It's hard not to be.
he turns.
Yeah.
He turns a little dribbler into a double.
He has that talent.
Problem is none of those things are happening.
He's just not hitting the baseball at all.
I don't even know.
They sit on the post game show, but the going into that net, not turning a dribbler into a double, whatever, but like today, him tagging up from first to second on a fly off to center field.
Like that was huge.
Cause that's what gave run around is the two.
I went at could have just been one.
It could have been a five, two game.
Now it's five, three.
And again, that's what I said earlier.
they weren't striking distance.
Like they did try to come back and they let it all go again today.
But like, yeah, like those are the good things that Oh, no cruise is capable of.
that is why I don't have the catalyst.
And I do like him in lead off role, but he's not performing right now.
And yeah, like maybe it's time that, okay, like let's get you back there.
Like, I don't know who would be in the lead off role.
Maybe it's Horwitz or something, but like maybe this is not the opportunity for no cruise to be a lead off.
Maybe he does need to stay back a little, get things right again.
Cause it's not pretty again.
The strikeouts are, you can live like a 30% strikeout rate, 32, 33 for Oh, no cruise, but like 44.
No.
Yep.
All right.
Anything else to add on cruise?
I just hope he turns it around very soon.
We can't have another three month stretch.
No, absolutely not.
We're already close to dip and blow 800 OPS.
Jim, we were just talking maybe a week or a week and a half ago, where is he a 900 OPS guy?
And we got our answer.
No.
All it takes is another next week.
Yeah.
That's the thing.
Who knows?
Who knows?
But yeah, these last couple of weeks haven't been good.
All right.
You want me to go?
You can go ahead.
The reason why it's over for the Buccos is because this team is severely lacking depth,
specifically on the pitching side, but really just depth overall.
We've already seen a lot of shuffling around in the bullpen and there haven't even, it hasn't even been an injury yet.
Like, but we've seen people having to be shuffled in and out in and out.
We already know that the starting pitchers are limited when it comes to their innings.
Like how many innings is Carmen Mlodzinski going to pitch this year?
And in fact, how many innings he's going to pitch in any given game that he takes, right?
Who struggles to go a second or third time through you've got Bubba Chandler who has so far shown that he hasn't been able to go deep into games.
You've got a middle relief that is just a revolving door at this point, throwing guys at the wall and seeing who sticks.
You've already had to use an opener for Maginski a couple of times.
You've already had to use a bullpen game.
And all this guys with zero injuries, like they have been extremely lucky up to this point when it comes to the injury bug, Jared Triolo's on the IL and Jared Jones is on the IL.
That's it.
That's it.
What happens when the pirates, just like every other team, a starting pitcher goes down and then a reliever goes down and then an outfielder goes down and then another pitcher goes down.
That's when I get really concerned because it's not a matter of if that's going to happen.
It's a matter of when it's going to happen.
The pirates aren't going to be the first team in the history of the sport to not have pitchers go on the IL.
Right.
And I think what's frustrating is you've been able to, you've been lucky up to this point where you've maintained your health.
we're 32 games in no one who you're really counting on has gotten hurt.
Right.
Triolo is a role player on this team.
He's a supporting cast member.
None of your, none of your stars, right.
If you were making a movie poster of the Pittsburgh pirates, everyone who's on that movie poster has been healthy.
16 and 16.
You look at the rest of the division though, the Cubs, the Cubs, do you know how many pitchers the Cubs have on the IL right now?
I do.
10.
The Cubs have 10 pitchers on the IL.
10, three starters and seven relievers.
Imagine if the pirates had 10 guys on the IL.
Like who you'd be starting.
Noah Davis would be like your number two starting pitcher at this point.
So it's a concern for me that the pirates have been really lucky up to this point.
The Cubs, meanwhile, have been bit with this injury bug by a lot.
They are 19 and 12 with all of these injuries.
You look at the Brewers.
The Brewers have three lefty relievers on the IL.
Three lefty relievers on the IL.
Plus a starting pitcher.
Plus they're two best hitters in Jackson Churio and Christian Yelich.
They're above you in the standings.
And then we go to the Reds.
The Reds are 20 and 11.
They have a restarting pitchers on the IL, a reliever on the IL.
Their best lefty reliever, by the way.
And, Oh, that guy we all wanted to sign over the off season, a Eugenio Suarez also on the IL.
And they're 20 and 11.
So it might, my concern here is just at some point, these injury injuries are going to start popping up for the pirates.
And the rest of your division has already been bit with that bug.
And they're still outplaying you right now.
Can I pal on there?
With all those injuries.
Also, their pie tag Brewers, 18 and 12.
So like, it's, they're doing this and it looks as if it's legit.
Cubs, 19 and 12.
Also like they're doing this and it looks legit.
Reds.
Not so much.
We talked about 15 and 16 though.
So.
Even they level off though.
They have such a good early jump on the, in this that even they level off, it's still going to take time for the pirates to catch there.
Even the, even the Cardinals 15 and 16 as well.
So like, even with all those injuries you talked about, like they are playing well and it is also pretty legit.
So like what happens when those teams also get healthy?
Do them and come baby.
Yeah.
one of my points was taken there of why the sky is falling.
And that's really the point of the margins are so thin with this team.
A lot of things have to go right for them to be good this year and to make the playoffs to this point, pretty much everything has gone right.
Like you said, Jim injury wise, and we're still talking about a 16 and 16 team.
That's a problem.
Like things can't go wrong with this team.
Guys have to overperform a little bit.
We've seen some of that, but we haven't seen the injuries issues pop up.
Like guys have played probably close to their level and they're a 500 team.
They set themselves up to have margins thin to the point where everything has to go right.
And for the most part, things have gone well and it's still not good enough.
Nailed it.
One more, one more reason why it's over Tyler.
Yeah.
One more reason it's over here.
And my point was going to be that the margins are so thin and it's just as tie into it as well.
I'm going with the bullpen.
And the bullpen, the bullpen's a problem here guys on Monday.
I know I was on Twitter telling everyone chill out.
Like Dennis Santana is really, he's a really good closer.
Everything's fine.
He just had a bad night.
Dennis Santana has an expected DRA of over five.
Now he's not striking guys out.
He's not missing bats.
He's not dope as Cody would refer to him as he's walking too many guys.
And then you run into the day where Isaac Mattson has an absolutely atrocious day.
Those are two of the three guys you expect to lock down the eighth and ninth inning at the very least seven, eight, nine.
Mattson's a guy that I think you, I love the guy, but I don't think you can expect him to be a dominant reliever.
Dennis Santana doesn't have like blowout stuff where he's going to lock down teams all the time, at least just looking at it, my test wise, but you expect better from them.
Soto has been good to this point, but then you go down the line here.
There is not much here.
Middle relief is atrocious.
And we saw it rear its head here during this Cardinal series.
There were two games where they fought their way back into it, but the middle relief could not keep them in the ball game.
There's no help coming.
There's really not much there in AAA that's going to come up and help.
We saw Wilber Dotel throw a pretty good game in the bullpen game.
But aside from that, there's not much help coming here.
You said earlier, throw it at the wall and see what sticks.
They're at that point here.
And we're tomorrow will be May 1st.
We're already trying to figure out who the hell is going to be the middle relief in this bullpen.
It's been a concern all offseason.
I think it's a really big concern right now.
You can't give yourself a chance to win.
If you're starting pitching just struggles out the gate and they're going to do that from time to time.
If your offense battles back into it and your middle relief can't just close the door and put up a zero here and there, you got major problems.
And right now, they don't have guys that can do that.
The bullpen's an issue.
Well, you saw that exact issue happen three times this series where, the starter didn't really get it done.
You needed that bull.
You needed that middle relief to really execute and give you some quality innings because the offense did eventually get to the Cardinals.
And really, every game, the series outside Monday, they got to the Cardinals bullpen.
They got to the they chase the starters early.
Like even, Kyle Leahy, I was making a joke, but like they chased him early.
Like they got three runs off of them.
And so they were able to get to the Cardinals pitching staff.
It's just yeah, every time they came back and got themselves back into the game.
The middle relief gave it right back.
And yeah, you need you need those guys to come through every now and then.
For all these discussions we talked about, because I him coming back with whatever his role is going to be is I feel like it's going to help this bullpen out as long as everyone's healthy by then.
Yep.
I think the room there, though, real quick is.
Don't know if Don Kelly's really done a great job of managing it the last five games either.
Just as a little bonus issue, if we're going to sky is following it the whole way.
I was like, I came with five.
I'm getting a couple of these off guys.
One more.
Just one more.
Right.
Yeah.
He did a couple of things that I probably I probably wouldn't have done.
I'm not necessarily going to blame this four game, this five game losing streak on Don Kelly.
Like at the end of the day, you're guys got to get it done.
But I think there are one or two things I would have done a little bit different.
Yeah, that's fair.
All right.
We ready to talk about why it's not over.
And, there's it's still early.
It's April 30th.
There are one hundred and thirty baseball games still remaining.
And you know what?
Fangraph still thinks the Pirates are going to have the second best, win loss total in the NL Central.
So do we want to do we want to maybe turn this thing around?
We just talked about all the reasons why this season was over.
Let's talk about why.
Let's pump the brakes.
It's April 30th.
There's still a lot of baseball.
And there's some there's some positive signs here.
Let me let me do this.
I'm gonna go a little different route.
I feel like then we probably all are going to take on this.
I know it's early.
But I think there's some meaning to this.
The Phillies are 12 and 19.
The Mets are 10 and 21.
I feel like that actually means something for the Pirates all offseason.
We're talking about you got to get it done in this division because are you going to sniff this wild card with these other teams that are out there?
like how many is the NL Central going to get in?
Phillies are off to a bad start.
Mets even worse.
Now, here's the thing.
I'm not writing them off.
The Mets have a much tougher time.
the Phillies, though.
I want to put something out here.
Since the wild card era.
Has begun.
The Phillies on April 30th being 12 and 19 six games out of the wild card.
Only one team.
Since the wild card era began has been in that hole and has made the playoffs.
And that's the 2024 Houston Astros.
I'm not, again, like wanting to write off the Phillies.
But they're in a hole.
And my positive to this is this whole NL Central is still wide open.
Like they're all jumbled together.
If the Pirates go out there and handle their business against the division.
They have a shot.
Like they have a shot.
They're all, they're all here.
they're not out of it by any means.
Everyone in the NL Central is right there.
It's in striking distance for anybody.
And I do firmly believe they're better than the Reds.
And I do firmly believe they're better than the Cardinals.
If they go out there and they do their job.
There is absolutely a chance that they get in by a wild card.
Without winning the division.
You know?
Every other, you look at that, the NL East.
There's, let me go to the divisions now.
There's, yeah.
There's one team above 500 right now.
And that's the Braves.
Like Miami's in second place because of how bad the Phillies and the Mets have been.
that's the perspective I want to put on here.
I don't think it's so much now.
Like it's division or bust.
I think that you could have one or maybe even two wild card teams from this division right now.
So, take care of business at home.
Yeah.
that's a, that's a good point.
Because, in the expanded wild card era, there's three, there's three wild cards.
So, you don't even need to be the second best team in your division.
You really don't even need to be the third best team in your division.
You just need to be better than, what's the math?
You need to be better than nine other teams in the National League.
You need to be a, you need to be a top six team, right?
So, you need to beat nine other teams.
And, yeah, you start doing the math.
And the Phillies and the Mets were two teams that you absolutely, going into the season, were like, those are two teams that you've, you're going to be fighting.
And, I'm not saying they're out of it, like, just like you said, like, it's baseball.
Like, the Phillies went 19 and, 11 and 19.
They could go 19 and 11 and be right back to the 500 in 30 days, right?
Same with the Mets.
Like, the Mets are talented enough.
They could go 21 and 10 over the next 31 games and be 500.
Like, but they are in a pretty big hole.
And, you haven't put yourself in a hole.
You're right where you began.
You're just standing on level ground.
You're treading water at this point.
And, like I said, it's a long season.
You just, you gotta outlast a lot of teams.
And, there are a few teams that have zero shot of making the postseason.
And the Pirates are not one of those teams.
The Pirates do have a chance.
And, like, they haven't really done anything to lower their chances over the course of this season.
you look at.
Oh, I got swept with the Cardinals.
But, like, if you, if you look at where they were on opening day and you look at where they are now.
Opening day, they started off with a 45% chance to make the postseason, according to fan graphs.
Right now, 46%.
So, like, they're, it went, it went like this.
And, but they're standing right back where they were at the beginning.
so, yeah, that's a good point.
Yeah, and I think to add to that, like, the Reds are playing good ball right now, but the Reds are not.
Nine games over 500 throughout April.
Good.
Like, Sal Stewart, Ellie De La Cruz are playing really well.
Some guys are hitting really well.
But their pitching staff, I think, is going to show some issues here as the year goes on.
They're going to go through a skid.
The Cubs are going to have issues.
Like, the Pirates just went through their skid a little bit early, I think.
Hopefully.
But, like, there's a lot of teams that are probably playing a touch above their head right now.
It's not crazy to think in two weeks we could be talking about this in a completely different light.
In either direction.
But, you're right.
God, I hope it's not the bad one.
But, no, you're right.
it's still so early.
you go through the NL Central, like, yeah, it's, like, the Cardinals aren't a good baseball team.
They're not a good baseball team.
Cubs are going to have some issues.
The Brewers are good, I think.
But, some things will start to even out, I think, a touch.
You just hope you have the better version of the Pirates while that happens.
Yep.
Yep.
I'll go.
One thing that I love seeing is the power so far.
And let me take you back to last year.
Last year, the Pirates, at this point, had 23 homers.
They were on pace for 120 on the year.
They finished with 117.
That was 31 homers behind the 29th most powerful team, which were the Cardinals.
So, they just, they had no power last year.
They had no ability to really go out there and put up offense quickly.
And, it led to a lot of really frustrating losses because the offense wasn't good enough to string together hits.
And, the offense wasn't good enough to hit the ball over the fence to score runs quickly.
This year, it's been different.
Through 32 games, they've homered 34 times.
They're on pace for 170 homers on the season.
That's 53 more home runs this season than they hit last year, just at that pace.
That's significant.
that's, that will win you games just in and of itself, being able to just have instant offense like that.
Because, over the course of the year, how many times did we have the exact same show last year, our post-game shows, where we came on, Pirates lost 2-1, Pirates lost 3-2, Pirates lost 3-1.
This team's on pace hit 50 more home runs.
That means some of those 2-1 games turned into 3-2 wins.
Some of those 3-2 losses turned into 4-3 wins.
Like, the ability to just put instant offense on the board is huge.
Yeah, it's definitely aided by, like, a few guys, but that's fine.
Cruz has 9, Brandon Lowe has 8, O'Hearn has 5.
This was the first time in Pirates history where you had 3 players put up 20 RBIs or more in the month of April between Cruz, O'Hearn, and Brandon Lowe.
So, like, you're scoring more runs, you're hitting the ball over the fence, and over the course of 162 games, those 50-ish more home runs you're hitting is gonna translate to, like, real wins that you just didn't see last year.
I think to add to that, you mentioned all the guys that are up there in home runs.
I still believe that Marcell Ozuna, at some point, is going to turn this thing around.
I'm with you, DiNardo, fingers crossed here, but at the very least, he's going to hit the ball over the wall a little bit more, I would think.
There are still some guys in this lineup underperforming.
Like, we talked about the guys that are playing at their level, but there are some guys that could pick it up a little bit more.
Konnor Griffin, another guy, two home runs in the month of April, essentially.
I know he didn't play the entire month, but I think you expect the ball to go over the wall a little bit more than him.
Henry Davis, my God, I think at some point you hope he starts to homer a touch.
And the one that I'm waiting on, and I think it's coming soon, is Nick Gonzales.
Like, he's going, I think he is a 10 home run guy.
So, there's some guys in there that I think you can get a little more pop out of them.
I think there's more power here than we've seen recently.
Maybe he's more of a nine-and-a-half home run guy.
Sure.
That one would have been really nice.
But, yeah.
Yeah.
The powers also all come from the left side for the most part, too.
And, like, I'm looking at the team now, I'm just like, that's that.
That's amazing.
And I think that's one to add in here, too.
Like, that's why I feel like it's night and day from last year.
I wanted to, part of the talk I wanted to talk about was the pitching.
that's why I think this team is not gloom.
they had the starting pitch.
I know they didn't do it in the Cardinals series.
Like, they have stoppers.
Like, that's the one thing, we've talked about early on.
It's like, I don't foresee losing streaks to be prolonged with this team.
They have pitching to get it done.
But at the end of the day, they did last year, too.
So, how can I say that pitching is going to be the reason why they'll be good?
Because it was there last year, and they sucked.
It comes down to the offense.
It comes down to the offense.
Because the offense is adequate enough.
The pitching is still going to go out there and do their job.
It's like you said, Jim.
And I agree.
Like, that is absolute truth.
They have options.
Even though they're struggling right now, every team is going to go through ups and downs.
This is the Pirates' time that you went through the down.
What they need to do is, of course, right, not allowed to prolong, shorten them up.
But, like, they've proven over the month of April, like, they have offense.
They can get it done.
So, yes, Jim, those three to two losses can be four to three wins right now.
That is absolutely a reason why to think about this team being good.
That's how many one-run games were the last year.
it was a ridiculous amount.
This team has an offense now to make those a good, sizable amount of those to wins.
That takes 71, easily to 81-plus.
Yeah, last year, the Pirates were 25 and 35 in one-run games.
Boom.
Boom.
Extra 10 wins.
Boom.
And they don't need to have them as one-run games.
that's just the thing.
All right.
Is it my turn?
Are we done on that one?
Mm-hmm.
Yep.
All right.
I'm just going to take us a step back and maybe fill us just a touch with hopium here.
Just a touch of hopium.
I know it's been a rough stretch.
It has been five games of hell.
Just take a step back.
Just take the step back with me here.
We go back to Monday.
If Dennis Santana just does his job, they start the series off with a win.
Skip forward two days.
Nick Gonzales falls about a foot short of a walk-off home run.
The reason I bring those things up are because the Pirates are two and three in the stretch if just two things just go a different way.
The timing of it happening and when it happened at the end of this month causing them to be 16 and 16 at the end of April I think is putting in a little bit extra like pressure on it and a little bit extra negativity that we have towards it.
Because in all reality, it should have been a better month.
If this happens April 14th, we might not be as angry about it.
A couple things just change.
And we're talking about an 18 and 14 ball club.
I don't want to overreact here.
I know those things didn't go their way.
But even one of those things goes right.
And there's still a game over 500.
And maybe we're not freaking out as much.
A sweep is what really just makes this feel bad.
Five in a row is what makes this feel bad.
One thing going right.
One thing falling the right way.
This might be a different show right now.
Look at Ty put in perspective on this to wrap it all up.
The voice of reason.
Tyler Sweaty.
I don't know why I said that.
This team stinks.
No, yeah.
And that's, I feel like that's how a lot of their losses have been this year too.
Like they've had some excruciating losses where it was like, man, if it weren't for that one thing, they would have won this game.
Like there's at least five losses out there where it's like, man, they should have won.
They should have won that game.
So you do look at it in, and you're like, those are things that can either just go your way or can be cleaned up.
Like it was just like mistakes, right?
Sometimes there was just mistakes.
They're not far off from being pretty good.
I think like, but they, those, they got to start doing those little things, right?
And all those things have fallen right for the rest of the division.
Yeah.
And let me add something here too, because I'm going to say the inverse to this, because this comment is completely correct.
Qtrip says a good coach ball club wins those games.
And that's accurate.
The same time they've won the equally amount of games they've lost this year because they did win some of those games.
Like how many, how many times early in this postseason we talked about 2024, 2025, those teams don't win this game.
This team did.
I'm not here to say this is a good coach team.
I'm just here to say like same time.
I'm not, I think there's a lot of doom and gloom on Don Kelly and he's cost this team already eight wins and something absurd, right?
Yes.
There are some things we've questioned.
Yes.
The bullpen management is certainly something you can talk about, but at the end of the day too, they have absolutely won games that a good ball club wins.
they've done that too this year.
They've just also equally lost games that you should.
That's why they're a 500 team.
They're not a great team yet, but they have won those games too.
And again, like that is also why we can sit here and say like, it's not all doom and gloom.
They have looked like a team that can win.
They know how to win.
They've shown those glimpses.
They seem to consistently do it more often than not.
Yep.
It's just, you look at it in perspective too.
Like it's 32 games.
If this were an NFL season, you would have just wrapped up week three.
And as a Dolphins fan, it's over.
And as a Steelers fan, that's also over.
There you go.
We're going to be back next week.
We're so back next week.
That's it.
That's life of the podcast.
We're not every week.
We're so back.
As we just mentioned, the show started off, right?
The highs and the lows.
Next week, we're winning, we're winning the world series again, baby.
And if you're a Louisville football fan, you're out of the race already.
Just extended our coach.
Proud of you.
Go get them tiger.
Does that wrap up our show?
I think that wraps it up.
Red's coming into town.
Three game set.
You got, you got, you got to win two out of three of these.
You just, you have to figure out a way to win two out of three of these games.
And you know what?
We could be having Bucco Brew.
And if it's after a sweep, we'll be riding high.
But yeah, you got to, you got to figure out a way to end this losing streak and win two games this weekend.
You can't lose tomorrow.
I guess as much as I don't want to call May 1st, they must win.
You can't lose tomorrow, man.
That's going to hurt.
What was the deal?
Had a good tweet the other day where it was like the Pirates are Owen 24 and must win game.
So for my own mental health, they cannot lose tomorrow.
Let's put it that way.
Right.
I'm on the post game on Sunday.
It's a long day over.
Yeah.
Me too.
Is it me and you tomorrow, DiNardo?
I think it's my omelet.
I think it's me and you, Tyler.
Okay.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Sure.
Sounds right.
Yeah.
Let's win it.
Let's win that one.
Let's win it.
Yeah.
Give away some sandwiches.
Hoisting the cone all-star with Cincinnati.
So let's bring it full circle.
They come into town.
Let's get those cones hoisting once again, get back in that wind column and do what we did the last time to the Reds fans.
Beat them up.
Physically and mentally.
You can do both with the cones.
Hit them in the face.
Am I condoning violence?
No.
Don't do it.
You are.
Yeah.
I think you are.
Yeah.
You did.
That's not what I said.
That was AI.
All right.
Appreciate everybody watching.
Everybody listening.
You guys are awesome.
This was an outstanding month for North Shore Nine, by the way.
And so that was, we had a tailgate.
And I thank me.
We had a nice, great tailgate.
We're going to have another tailgate on June 13th.
So make sure you, save the date there.
Should have a link out for tickets there soon.
So if you weren't able to make it to the first one or you were able to make it and you left because the skies opened up and, it was like the great flood 2.0.
Yeah.
Let's hope we don't have that this next time.
So yeah.
June 13th.
Hope to see everybody out there.
I'm really excited.
I'm really excited.
I hope they're still in it.
Yeah.
Me too.
But that's going to be fun.
That's going to be fun.
And I don't know.
We got something cooking in the background too.
I'm not going to release it and say it, but I'm excited for something else.
Yes, we do.
Yes, we do.
We have many things cooking.
We do.
Yeah.
We're always cooking.
See us in the kitchen.
Yeah.
All right.
Is it stir fry?
Yep.
Migos are reuniting, which John Cole and myself say.
I think we're good for the day.
Yeah.
Let's get out of here.
How do you reunite?
Anyways.
Okay.
Let's get out of here.
All right.
We'll see you guys later then, I guess.
Bye-bye.
Like the video.
Subscribe to the page.
Let's Go Bucs.
All right.
That wraps up this episode of North Shore Nine.
Thanks so much for tuning in.
Whether you're listening on the podcast or catching us on YouTube, if you enjoyed the show, please give this video a thumbs up.
And don't forget to hit that subscribe button if you haven't already.
It really helps us grow.
And if you're listening on the podcast, a quick review goes a long way.
And helping others find the show.
Plus, be sure to tell a friend about us.
There's always room for more here in the NS9 community.
And for those looking to support us a little more, consider joining our Patreon.
Become an MVP member and get exclusive perks while helping us continue to bring you more of the Pirates content you love.
Comments· 0
Should the Pirates move Oneil Cruz out of the leadoff spot until he snaps out of his slump?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.