The Pittsburgh Pirates are facing two important offseason decisions: whether to bring back Brandon Lowe and what to do with Mitch Keller. On today’s OffBeat, Alex Stumpf examines the first wave of MLB moves, from Dustin May‘s contract to the Maikel Garcia trade, for clues about each player’s market. Why might a four-year deal make sense for Lowe? And is Keller’s contract really a problem, or could Pittsburgh be better off keeping him?
Mitch Keller Is Worth More Than Pirates Fans Think

With Alex Stumpf.
Chapters
Key takeaways
- 1
Alex is against a salary dump of Mitch Keller: the Pirates would have to bring in another starter anyway, and that would use up almost all the money they saved.
Alex Stumpf - 2
Keller is due for a bounce-back after his down 2026. He was the Pirates' most valuable trade chip at the 2025 deadline, so letting him go just for salary relief would be a bummer.
Alex Stumpf - 3
Keller's contract isn't the disaster some fans say it is. It's pricey for Pittsburgh, but as a free agent he'd probably sign a two-year deal for about the same money, because that's what pitching costs right now.
Alex Stumpf - 4
On the back of the baseball card, Keller compares well with Dustin May, who just got 3 years and $52.5M. With two years left on Keller's deal, the Pirates could find a taker if they really wanted to move him.
Alex Stumpf - 5
A four-year deal for Brandon Lowe that spreads the money out would be better for the Pirates than a three-year deal in the $60–70M range, even if they end up paying for a year where he's worth less.
Alex Stumpf
Players discussed
Full transcript193 paragraphs · show
What have been the two most discussed potential transactions for the Pirates this winter?
It has been the pursuit of re-signing Brandon Lowe in the theoretical option of trading Mitch Keller.
We don't know if either is going to happen, if both are going to happen.
There is still plenty of off-season to go, even if this is all going to be shut down in less than two weeks.
We are starting to get some moves across the league that while it may be an apples to oranges comparison, I think we can gleam a little insight to what is going on across the league.
And what value these two important players might actually have.
Good morning, and welcome to OffBeat here on North Shore Nine.
My name is Alex Stumpf, and this is a daily look at your Pittsburgh Pirates.
We've had a smattering of moves of late.
Especially on Wednesday.
We did a podcast episode a couple weeks ago about how the projected timeline was, whenever we get to the back half of November, we're finally going to start seeing some moves.
Players are going to want to sign contracts before the lockout happens, try to get something grandfathered in the event that there might be a cap and floor established.
But this is our first real handful of moves.
And I've got to say, I'm interested.
And it's not just, the qualifying offer, Brandon Lowe rejecting it, but David Bednar taking it from the Yankees.
That's one thing.
I'm talking, like, negotiated contracts.
Because there are two on the position player side that struck me.
The first is the Jake Bauers contract.
We're rewinding a little bit.
We're going back a couple days here.
But he signed for four years and $58 million with the Red Sox.
And that was surprising to me.
Because he had a qualifying offer.
And he seemed happy in Milwaukee.
He seemed loved in Milwaukee.
And yeah, it was just a qualifying offer.
We don't know if they had discussed long-term deals or whatever.
Maybe he just wanted the certainty.
This was a player who almost retired a few years ago.
But then had this great bounce back.
So maybe it's just like, look, I need to take whatever the most actual dollars on the table is.
But that struck me.
Because he had $123 million as a bird in the hand.
And he took $458 million.
It's like, that's essentially a three-year, $35 million contract.
that's not bad.
But for someone who had the year that he just had and was an NLCS MVP, I think he would have gotten more.
Even the contract he's signed now, it's less than $15 million as an annual average.
That surprised me.
And my first reaction from that was like, okay.
Teams are still going to sign long-term deals.
They're going to spread money out.
They're going to get the AAV spread out.
That'll be better for a potential ceiling, a cap.
That, okay, this is, we're spreading this money out.
Maybe he would have taken $350 million.
But, that's almost $17 million in AAV.
Now it's $14.5 million.
That's creating a little bit of breathing room.
Just spread out the money that way.
And then the Royals, a little later, floated, hey, need starting pitching.
Mikel Garcia, good young player, who, yeah, had a down year a bit in 2026, but was an all-star in 2025.
It is on a team-friendly long-term deal.
Interested in him.
And I will admit, my brain did spin of, like, do I trade one of the, untradeable guys in Pittsburgh for him?
Not Paul Skenes, but, like, ooh, would I do Braxton Ashcraft for Mikel Garcia?
That might be a podcast episode.
And then they just trade him to the Mariners.
They traded him to the other nautical-themed team.
And they get Bryce Miller and other pitchers back in return.
That also struck me.
That, wow, this is a commodity.
Hitters on controllable, long-term deals.
Whenever a player is traded, it's how much money is left over.
That's the AAV they acquire.
So it makes sense.
Not saying that the Mariners are necessarily up against a cap, or a theoretical cap.
If there is a cap, far from a guarantee.
But that type of contract is desirable.
I look at Brandon Lowe, in this case.
Someone who is going to get a multi-year deal.
How long do you want to spread that money out?
We talked about, he's someone who, is this a three-year deal?
Is this a four-year deal?
I think the way that the market is, if we could gleam anything from the market so far, is that hitters, they want to spread some money out.
They want to lower that hit.
They want to...
So far, that seems to be valuable.
That doesn't necessarily mean it's going to apply to every hitter.
But it does strike me as a very early trend.
I wonder if that's going to apply to him.
One of the better hitters on the market.
Who, in a normal year, maybe would be more looking towards, a three-year deal.
This year, this winter, this uncertainty, if he wants a little more certainty, pushing for a fourth, there might be a good market for that.
We're going to get to the pitching side in a second.
But first, I'd like to thank today's sponsor, Larine Co.
We all know nicotine pouches are popular, and part of it isn't so much the nicotine as it is the routine.
Loreen just launched a pouch that keeps the routine, but leaves the nicotine out.
Larine Co pouches swap out the nicotine and give you clean focus and support your enamel the whole time they're in.
It works like the pouches you've seen before.
Just tuck one in and go about your day.
Each pouch has a half cup of coffee's worth of caffeine, plus L-theanine and alpha-GPC for a smooth, steady focus with no energy crash, and it gives your teeth daily enamel support in between brushings.
It comes in mint, cinnamon, and mango, and it's nicotine-free, always.
It's doing something good for your teeth, and it gives you smooth energy and focus without those jitters.
Every other pouch out there makes you pick between something that helps you focus and something that's actually good for your teeth.
This is the only one designed to do both, and it comes from a brand that's leading the way at supporting your oral health.
Give Loreen a try.
Right now, Larine Co is offering our listeners up to 50% off at buyloreen.com slash northshore.
That's buyloreen, L-A-R-I-N-E dot com slash northshore for up to 50% off.
So on the hitting side, so far we've seen extended contracts be very valuable.
Those are the moves that have been done so far.
On the pitching side, it's been shorter-term deals.
And I get this is an extremely small sample size.
I am looking at two hitting transactions.
I'm looking at two pitching transactions.
But on the pitching side, Dustin May signs for three years, 52.5 million, and Sonny Gray signs for two years, 55 million.
Now, Sonny Gray, with an opt-out after the first year, Sonny Gray's contract is...
I'm going to call it aggressive for Minnesota.
I don't know if there's a better way to say it.
I don't want to call it an overpay.
And he is obviously someone who...
He was an all-star there.
He has worked there.
This is a team that showed at the trade deadline that they really wanted to reverse course from what they did in 2025.
They want to try to win with Derek Shelton's club.
He's someone who does help that team immediately.
And if things do go haywire and he pitches well, he's a good trade chip then.
But the structure of that contract with the opt-outs and the player option, it's a pretty bonkers deal.
High-value deal.
Dustin May.
Someone who...
Yeah, there's...
The fastball's alive.
It's an electric fastball.
But the results have never really been there.
Here on North Shore Nine, they posted a graphic comparing Dustin May's, I believe, last two or three years to Mitch Keller's last two or three years.
And they were virtually the same.
In terms of ERA, war, innings pitch.
They were very remarkably similar seasons.
Yes, Mitch Keller had a very down year in 2026.
But this goes back to what I talked about earlier.
How Mitch Keller...
I think there would be a market for him.
Even if it is just to get out of the contract.
Because we have two pitchers here.
Sonny Gray, obviously, coming off a really good year.
But he's older.
There's a lot of risk variance in both terms of just the player in his age, but also the structure of his contract.
If he's not good, he could just opt in.
If he's really good, you are paying a lot of money for him to go.
Dustin May, a lot of risk assumed there.
He has not really put it all together, but there is stuff.
And I get there's all the difference in the world between Dustin May averaging 97 miles per hour in his fastball and Mitch Keller's average fastball velocity dipping to 93.
But if you just trust the back of the baseball card, they're not bad comps for each other.
So Keller having two years in 38 on his contract left, it's like, yeah, I think the Pirates could find a taker if they really wanted to heavily pursue salary dumping him.
I'm against a salary dump of Mitch Keller because I think you would have to bring in another starting pitcher anyway, and that's going to eat up almost all the revenue or the extra cash that you freed up.
Also, I think just in general, he is due for a bounce back.
I think he can bounce back.
This is someone who was your most valuable trade trip in the 2025 trade deadline.
Letting him go for just salary relief would be a bummer.
But people in Pittsburgh, those claims of like, oh, this is a horrible contract.
The Pirates need to get out of it.
Not really.
It's pricey on the Pittsburgh side, but it's not a terrible contract.
I think if he was a free agent, he would sign a two-year deal that was probably in the ballpark of that.
This is just the price for pitching right now.
And the league, again, very early moves.
Scoble's going to get a long-term deal.
I get it.
But as it stands right now, this tier of pitcher, it's affordable.
They want the shorter-term deals.
They'd rather pay money up front.
Hitters, they want to spread out the money so far.
It's intriguing.
I want to see if the market continues to develop this way.
And if it does, how does it impact the Pirates?
I think a four-year deal where they can maybe spread out some money with Brandon Lowe would be advantageous rather than trying to find like a three-year deal that's in the 60-something to $70 million range.
That'd be a big pill to swallow if they could spread out that money for a fourth year.
Yeah, you're going to be paying for a year, Brandon Lowe, where he's not worth the same.
But hey, you still have him now.
And if Bob Nunning really does think there's going to be a cap and a floor, well, then you could absorb that.
cost a whole lot easier.
As for Keller, if this is the asking price, if Dustin May is $352.5, if I was another team, I would maybe look at him as an option rather than committing more money
for an extra year for a pitcher who has posted similar, if not slightly worse, results.
It's going to be a very interesting two weeks we're going to see if these trends continue.
And I would like to thank you for listening to OffBeat here on North Shore Nine.
If you haven't already, be sure to subscribe wherever you find podcasts or check us out on YouTube if you want to see my smiling face.
And Friday is our mailbag episode.
So if you have a question about the Pirates and would like to be featured in it, leave a comment down below.
Thank you so much for listening.
We will talk again tomorrow.
All right.
That wraps up this episode of North Shore Nine.
Thanks so much for tuning in.
Whether you're listening on the podcast or catching us on YouTube, if you enjoyed the show, please give this video a thumbs up.
And don't forget to hit that subscribe button if you haven't already.
It really helps us grow.
And if you're listening on the podcast, a quick review goes a long way in helping others find the show.
Plus, be sure to tell a friend about us.
There's always room for more here in the NS9 community.
And for those looking to support us a little more, consider joining our Patreon, become an MVP member, and get exclusive perks while helping us continue to bring you more of the Pirates content you love.
Thanks again for all your support and let's go Bucs.


Comments· 0
Should the Pirates salary-dump Mitch Keller to free up money this winter?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.