The Pirates spent the offseason looking for ways to improve their roster. But what if their biggest potential addition is already in Pittsburgh? On Monday’s OffBeat, Alex Stumpf revisits Paul Skenes‘ 2026 season, including the Pirates’ 15-17 record in his starts and how his struggles coincided with a narrow playoff miss. Alex also looks ahead to the 2027 rotation, with Jared Jones, Braxton Ashcraft and Bubba Chandler helping shape what could still be an elite staff.
Did Paul Skenes Cost the Pirates a Playoff Spot?

With Alex Stumpf.
Chapters
Key takeaways
- 1
The Pirates missed the postseason by six games, and Skenes' WAR fell by nearly five (8 to 3.3). Stumpf says that is not a coincidence.
Alex Stumpf - 2
Skenes wasn't a stopper in 2026, and the Pirates went 15-17 in his 32 starts. Detroit went 22-10 in Tarik Skubal's starts, and Stumpf thinks the Pirates could have landed in a similar spot to the Tigers.
Alex Stumpf - 3
Bubba Chandler has the best chance on the staff to beat his 1.8 WAR Steamer projection. If his head is right, he could be a 3-4 WAR pitcher.
Alex Stumpf - 4
Stumpf can't in good conscience project Mitch Keller for more than 1.5 WAR. Getting back to an average starting pitcher would be a really good outcome for him.
Alex Stumpf - 5
No trade or free agent beats 2025 Paul Skenes walking back through the door. Another 2026-level Skenes doesn't kill the playoff hopes, but it puts the load on Chandler or Jared Jones taking a huge step.
Alex Stumpf
Players discussed
Full transcript149 paragraphs · show
We've spent a lot of time this offseason talking about Brandon Lowe, do the Pirates have a legit chance of bringing him back? How do you improve this roster in general? How do you get this team into the playoffs? And that discussion has largely been external additions, moves that they can make.
because that's honestly what they can control right now. And the idiom, the expression I hear all the time is, you have to control what you can control. One thing they can not really fully control is how will Paul Skenes bounce back after a disappointing 2026 campaign? I think he'd be pretty hard-pressed to say it was a bad season, that he was a bad pitcher.
But for someone who was the Cy Young in 2025, it was not the same level of performance.
And as we talk about how does this Pirates team get this roster better? How do they get into the postseason?
You have to ask yourself, is there any path without Paul Skenes pitching like a number one again?
Good morning and welcome to OffBeat here on North Shore Nine. My name is Alex Stumpf and this is a daily look at your Pittsburgh Pirates.
Like I said, Paul Skenes did not have a horrendous 2026 campaign.
He still struck out 200 batters. He still pitched 174 innings. A 382 ERA isn't that bad at the end of the day.
But for someone who had posted sub-2 ERAs his first two years, it was a pretty stark difference.
And we could get into the hows and whys and how we don't know fully.
He did an interview with Colin Beasley of the Post-Gazette at the end of the year where he said, "Hey, my routine changed."
I had the World Baseball Classic that had long been speculated.
I wrote a couple pieces for Book Rule Bucks where I looked into the analytics and the mechanics and what the data was showing me.
And I think I pinpointed a couple things.
You can read them there. I don't know how well it's going to translate to audio form a couple months after publishing.
But this really is the centerpiece of this team.
This is the guy, in the 2025 offseason, whenever the Pirates were making the Brandon Lowe trade, whenever they were signed Ryan O'Hearn, the mindset was we have to maximize the time where we have Paul Skenes as a Pirate.
The year prior, whenever they only traded for Spencer Horwitz, the main, complaint was, you only have Paul Skenes for so long. And this isn't the best roster you could have built to take advantage of that.
And the cheap years of Paul Skenes are behind them. He is arbitration eligible now.
He is under team control for three more years, and he is going to get more expensive every single year.
They could obviously afford him in 2027. They can afford him in 2028, in my opinion, regardless of what the economics of the sport look like. If there is a cap or floor, if it's going to be
something that more closely resembles what we have operated with before. But that last year, you don't know how long Paul Skenes is going to be here and you don't know what level of Paul Skenes
you are going to be here and you don't know how long he is going to be here and you don't know how long he is going to be here.
He's going to be here and he's going to be here and you don't know how long he is going to be here and you don't know how long he is going to be here and you don't know how long he is going to be here and you don't know how long he is going to be here and you don't know how long he is going to be here and you don't know how long he is going to be here.
And I looked at the data and I took the five starters that they listed up top and then the starter who pitched the most outside of that, who was Braxton Ashcraft in that case.
And those six pitchers, their top six combined for 14.7 war with Paul Skenes accounting for eight of it.
In 2026, I took their top six guys and they combined for 11 war with Paul Skenes accounting for 3.3.
Pirates missed the postseason by six games and that's nearly a five game drop from your top pitcher.
It's not coincidental.
I, whenever I look at Paul Skenes' season, there are two long areas of struggle that really stand out.
The first was that nine game losing streak that started in mid-May and extended on into July.
A stretch where he pitched to a 536 ERA.
The thing during that nine game losing streak is even on that day whenever the Pirates lost his ninth straight start, they were still only three games out of a postseason spot.
Going just four and five, going 500 in that stretch would have had him in what would have been a theoretical wildcard spot.
He had another long losing streak.
His last 11 games, he went one and three with a 458 ERA with a 435 FIP.
The first four starts of that, the Pirates were still very much in the postseason picture.
They were two games back.
At the end of a four game skid that he went on, they were six games back.
And yeah, they were shut out against the Marlins in that stretch.
And it's very tough to win a baseball game, whatever your offense does not score a run for you.
But four starts and 15 runs allowed, that's not exactly showing up in a key part of the season.
And as bad as that stretch was in general, they were basically keeping pace with the rest of the league in that wildcard chase, except for the skiing starts.
The expression, a stopper, is so valuable.
It's maybe the most valuable title a starting pitcher could have, like that or ace.
And sometimes it's interchangeable.
But it's the guy that whenever you, your team is struggling, they maybe lost a tough series.
Maybe they got swept.
Maybe they've dropped four in a row or whatever it is.
Be like, but you know what, this guy is going to take the mound and we are going to have a good chance of winning.
This is going to be our chance.
This is our get right pitcher.
Everything could go better.
And Skenes was not that this past year.
He made 32 starts and the Pirates went 15 and 17 in them.
Previous two years in Detroit, like Tarek Skubel.
That was a Detroit team that barely made the postseason in both of those years, but they went 22 and 10 in Tarek Skubel starts.
That's a seven-win difference of the Tigers winning seven more games whenever Skubel started versus how many games they won whenever the Pirates won, whenever Skenes started in 2026.
Pirates missed the playoffs by six games.
I can't help but feel like they could have been at a very similar spot to Detroit.
So how does this rotation get better?
We're going to get back into that in a second.
But first, I'd like to thank today's sponsor, Larine Co
We all know nicotine pouches are popular, and part of that isn't so much the nicotine as it is the routine.
Larine just launched a pouch that keeps the routine but leaves the nicotine out.
Larine Co pouches swap out the nicotine and give you clean focus and support your enamel the whole time they're in.
It works like the pouches you've seen before.
Just tuck one in and go about your day.
Each pouch has a half cup of coffee's worth of caffeine, plus L-theanine and alpha-GPC for a smooth, steady focus with no energy crash, and it gives your teeth daily enamel support in between brushings.
It comes in mint, cinnamon, and mango, and it's nicotine-free always.
It's doing something good for your teeth, and it gives you smooth energy and focus without those jitters.
Every other pouch out there makes you pick between something that helps you focus and something that's actually good for your teeth.
This is the only one designed to do both, and it comes from a brand that's leading the way at supporting your oral health.
Give Larine a try.
Right now, Larine Co is offering our listeners up to 50% off at buylarine.com slash northshore.
That's buylarine, L-A-R-I-N-E dot com slash northshore for up to 50% off.
I took a look at some steamer projections for 2027, and I'm going to start this half of the show by saying I do not like Fang Graff's pitching war.
I can't believe that you're still using fifth-base war in 2026, but you get a gist.
We'll get a gist.
And their projections for next year are Skenes at 4.7 war, Ashcraft at 3.8, Jared Jones at 3.3, 1.8 for Bubba Chandler, and Mitch Keller at 1.5.
For reference, Paul Skenes in his Cy Young year was 6.5 war.
Last year was 4.2.
So they are projecting a year that is closer to the 2026 results than the 2025 results, which honestly, for someone who didn't go on the injured list, that's probably what a good model should do.
A good projection model.
Because Skenes' fifth went up, his expected ERA went up, like everything went up.
It wasn't just all bad luck, men being left on base at a far lower clip.
It was a lot of metrics that didn't trend the right direction.
I will say, though, of that projection, that's still 15 pitching war from your top five guys.
That's right back to 2025.
I get it's apples and oranges of baseball reference war to Van Graaff's steamer war, but that's comparable.
And it's without Paul Skenes carrying the brunt of the load.
I look at how can this rotation get better in 2027.
With respect to Ashcraft, I think we saw the pitcher that he could be.
And that is an all-star.
That is a really good pitcher.
The only thing I think at his point is just throwing more innings.
Jared Jones, same spot, I think.
Throw more innings, be a little more consistent.
That guy that we saw in September was a demon.
Like, that was some of the best pitching we've seen over the course of a month I've ever seen in a pirate uniform.
I'm not saying he's going to do that over the course of six months, but, like, there's a monster in there.
Even if there's some up and down, like we saw in 2024, yeah, I could see him being an impact pitcher.
Bubba Chandler, I think he's the guy here who has the best chance of beating this projection.
Just because I think he had a really solid rookie year.
I know I've said that a couple times here.
I know the results aren't all there, but I think the process that he went through, I think the mindset of getting better.
He wore some stuff.
I think if his head is in the right spot, then the right arm will follow.
He is someone who I think could end up being worth, like, three or four war.
And Mitch Keller, it's banking on him, being more like that guy that we saw for years and not the 2026 version.
But, again, I can't in good conscience project more than 1.5 war.
I think that would be a really good outcome for him to be, like, an average starting pitcher again.
So I look at this rotation, three guys, I don't see much of a path of them beating their projections.
Bubba Chandler, rookie going into his second year, he could.
It's skeins.
If this rotation is going to beat projections and really be great, get better than 2025, which was a big goal of 2026 that they didn't accomplish, I think it runs through him.
And I don't think that's that hot a take, that your best pitcher has to pitch close to his best form of himself.
We talk about chasing wins and war and free agency and trades, and can you recreate Brandon Lowe in the aggregates if he ends up departing?
But it's like, there's no better addition this team could make than 2025 Paul Skenes's walking through that door again.
That would be huge.
That would fix so many problems.
It would mask some other problems.
Like we, like I brought up, there were times whenever this team was in free fall, they were having some bad luck.
But if Skenes was pitching, even if he was winning even half of his starts in these really ugly stretches, they would be in a playoff spot.
At that portion of the season.
I think that's significant.
They need him to be that stopper.
They need him to be that guy.
They need him to be, as the kids say, him.
And if he is more or less the 2026 version again, I don't think it puts a death knell into any playoff hopes.
But the path becomes a lot harder, and you are banking on other players like Bubba Chandler or Jared Jones taking a huge step again.
I think the better path is the guy who already has those shoe prints out in front of him.
Just follow that.
Thank you so much for listening to OffBeat here on North Shore Nine.
If you haven't already, be sure to subscribe to Revified Podcasts, or check us out on YouTube if you want to see my smiling face.
Thank you so much for listening.
We will talk again tomorrow.
All right.
That wraps up this episode of North Shore Nine.
Thanks so much for tuning in.
Whether you're listening on the podcast or catching us on YouTube, if you enjoyed the show, please give this video a thumbs up.
And don't forget to hit that subscribe button if you haven't already.
It really helps us grow.
And if you're listening on the podcast, a quick review goes a long way in helping others find the show.
Plus, be sure to tell a friend about us.
There's always room for more here in the NS9 community.
And for those looking to support us a little more, consider joining our Patreon, become an MVP member, and get exclusive perks while helping us continue to bring you more of the Pirates content you love.
Thanks again for all your support, and let's go Bucs.
Bye.


Comments· 0
Do the Pirates need 2025-level Paul Skenes to make the playoffs in 2027?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.