Jake Bauers‘ four-year, $58 million deal with Boston could have major implications for Brandon Lowe and the Pirates. On today’s Bucco Brew, DiNardo and Jim discuss what Bauers’ contract means for Lowe’s free-agent market and Pittsburgh’s chances of retaining him. Plus, the Pirates face important Rule 5 protection decisions with two open 40-man roster spots, Tim Hill signs with the Yankees, and MLB’s looming lockout continues to raise questions about the offseason and 2027 season ahead.
Is Brandon Lowe About to Price Out the Pirates?

With Anthony DiNardo and Jim Rosati.
Chapters
Key takeaways
- 1
Jake Bauers getting 4 years, $58M after one big season, while Brandon Lowe has 21.8 career WAR, makes the reported 4-year, $80M range for Lowe '100% in play.'
- 2
Jim Bowden's predicted 3-year, $45M deal for Lowe isn't happening. Bauers' contract is the floor, and Lowe's deal won't come in lower than it.
- 3
Tim Hill at $2.25M would have been a letdown. Pirates should target a Gregory Soto-type lefty in the $6–8M range, not long multi-year reliever deals.
- 4
Protect four for Rule 5: Axiel Plaz, Termarr Johnson, Mitch Jeb and Derek Diamond. Make room by dropping Akil Baddoo, who has no options, and Ronny Simon.
- 5
Brandon Lowe will sign before the lockout, but not with Pittsburgh. The Pirates' offer will get leaked as the highest AAV while another team wins on years.
Players discussed
Full transcript840 paragraphs · show
Yo, welcome to the North Shore Nine podcast. This is Bucco Brew, powered by Defer Coffee and Tea. I'm your host, Anthony DiNardo. And with me, we got Jim Rosati. Jim, how you doing, buddy?
I'm doing all right. How about you? Good morning.
we go and I was like, I'm really tired, but I'm so awake right now.
Yeah.
It's not the case today.
I feel tired.
I feel tired.
Yeah.
Well, as you can tell, I'm not in my normal podcast studio.
I'm on the road.
I'm in the central time zone, so it's only 6 a.m. here, Sonardo.
It's only 6 a.m. Wow.
Yeah.
Yeah, that's rough.
But anyways, here we are.
Once again, here we are.
Here we are.
Yep.
I, this is an interesting football weekend, wasn't it?
For you?
I guess.
you guys had a brawl.
it wasn't that big of a deal.
It was like a little five-second thing at the end of the game.
Not to.
I was mad at North Carolina in the moment, but that is what it is.
We won the game.
It's all that matters.
All right.
No, it was funny.
Like, again, I don't really pay much attention to college football, except when I'm playing the video game and winning, like, last night in our league.
That's right.
That's right.
But, no, I just, I think they're trolling you about, what was happening after the game, and I saw what was happening.
So, I just trolled you, too, and I just quote tweeted the brawl and said, like, never loved Bill Belichick more than I did tonight.
Just to be stupid.
It was just to troll.
It was just to be funny for you.
And it's got 400,000 impressions right now.
So, I'm like, oh, okay.
Although, people may have taken that the wrong way, because Bill Belichick played, like, a huge role in breaking up the fight.
Like, he got his guys.
Oh, really?
Yeah.
So, like, there was a whole story about it after the game, where, like, Bill Belichick was, like, so maybe people took it in the way where they thought you were respecting, like, actually respecting Bill Belichick for, cleaning up the actions of his team.
I'm so ignorant of the entire situation.
I was just like, oh, this is just an easy way to poke the bear at Jim.
That's all this was.
And I was like, oh.
Which it wasn't, because we won the game.
I know.
I know.
I'm like, oh, if you're going to lose, go and fight Louisville players.
I'm good with that.
All right.
Yeah.
But, and then I won my fantasy league by, like, less than two points last night.
Thanks to Aaron Rodgers.
Thanks, buddy.
Yeah, it was a rough Steelers game last night.
I had a travel day all day yesterday, and so I was out of it in terms of keeping up with things, and I got off the plane.
And this whole FAA airline or airline thing, like, it's a mess, because, like, apparently there's no rental cars, like, anywhere, because everybody's had their planes canceled the last
two days.
They rented cars, and so, like, if you didn't reserve your rental car, like, enough in advance, you just, like, don't have a car this week if you needed to rent a car.
But luckily, my car was there, but, like, half the people in the facility, like, didn't have a car, because they reserved their cars on, like, Friday, and they just had to, they had to, they had to give them up.
So, yeah, it was a wild travel day, a bunch of delays, got in late.
I get to my hotel room, I'm like, okay, let's go watch some Sunday night football, turn the game on, and it was 31 to 3.
I was like, that can't be right.
I didn't look at my phone at all.
I was just like, what in the world?
Yeah, so, rough day for Steelers fans.
Yeah, that sucks.
Yeah, I didn't think about you with traveling, so, my wife, Junkle, actually went home, too.
She was going home Saturday.
Her flight was 7.55 a.m.
Saturday to Pittsburgh, and it was just like, we had no idea if it's going to be there.
Honestly, smooth traveling for her.
She got delayed a little bit in Baltimore, I think, like, an hour, because they didn't have a crew.
But that's all they were waiting for.
Luckily, that's what they were waiting for.
Both of my flights were delayed, and the first time was because, like I said, there was crew that they had to move, so they needed people to give up their seats on the plane.
They were offering $1,500 vouchers to give up your seats yesterday on this flight.
So, I'll bet they were giving up money for John Will, too.
She didn't get it, did she?
Anyways, we're five minutes in here.
Let's talk some baseball.
It's the off-season.
There's not much to talk about.
But no, I figure, again, there really isn't a whole lot to talk about.
Parts related specifically that we haven't discussed ad nauseum.
So, maybe some part of it's important news to talk about.
One of them being the fact that, it's in division, so that matters some.
The World Series champions, right?
The Milwaukee Brewers.
They just lost their first baseman.
Not surprising.
Not surprising.
you heard during the World Series, basically, like, hey, have fun in New York.
But Jake Bauer signs with the Red Sox.
$58 million deal.
And I figure that's something to talk about.
Because, not only is it, though, the Brewers losing players, right?
They're getting worse, technically speaking, as of right now.
But that's a guy who had basically, the trade to Milwaukee was outstanding.
he goes there and he turns into a monster.
But it was like one season.
He got $58 million.
And we're talking about Brandon Lowe, who also had a qualifying offer that deadline's coming up.
What he's going to make.
I figure, like, this is like a little nice.
I'm not, like, saying, like, Bauer sets the price for Brandon Lowe, whatever.
But this is a nice contract to look at.
like, what is Brandon Lowe going to make?
Well, if you're hesitant, if he's going to make a $45 billion deal, no.
Yeah, it's interesting.
Because I think if you look at the, like, the 2026 season, Brandon Lowe is a top five player from the 2026 season.
That's now a free agent.
And I'm talking about, like, top five hitter.
Like, and he's probably top.
He's more like top three.
Right.
Maybe even top two.
But Jake Bauers is also in that top five.
So, and he's one of the few people who got a qualifying offer this year, like Brandon Lowe did, turned it down.
He gets a nice, yeah, four-year, $58 million deal from the Red Sox, $14.5 million each year there, AAV.
But, yeah, I think you look at this, and Bowers quite a bit younger than Brandon Lowe.
He's two years younger.
But, yeah, like, Brandon Lowe has shown over the course of his career that he, has been effective over a long period of time.
Brandon Lowe's issue is being on the field, for more than 110 games at a time.
That's his issue.
That's really the one red flag you can look at Brandon Lowe and say that may be a reason why a team may be hesitant to give him a big contract.
It's just that, he played 150 games last year.
It's the only time he's ever done that.
Ever.
He's never done that before.
So, you look at Bowers, and, he played 144 games last year.
That's the most games he's ever played.
But that has more to do with he just wasn't an effective player before this year.
You look at his page, and it's zero war, negative 0.8 war, negative 0.3 war, negative 0.3 war, 0.1 war, 0.8 war.
Like, this is the first year he's ever put up, like, an actual season.
And he turned it into a lot of money.
So, yeah, good for him.
Gets him out of the division, which is nice.
You mentioned just getting him off of the Brewers is a good thing.
He was a really important part of that lineup.
Now, it's Milwaukee.
I fully expect them to just replace Jake Bauers.
Next thing like, Luis Lara will become this monster out of nowhere or something like that.
But, no, it's good to get him out of the division.
But in terms of what it has to do with Brandon Lowe, I think it certainly says that, like, Brandon Lowe will get at least that.
I wouldn't put Jake Bauers in the same level of free agent caliber of Brandon Lowe.
In terms of, like, offensive production last season, they were very – Bowers actually had the better offensive year.
But just in terms of track record, you would think that Brandon Lowe, is getting more money than Jake Bauer.
So, you look at $58 million over four years, it makes me think that, the four years, $80 million-ish or so that we've been hearing, what Brandon Lowe could get.
It makes me feel like that's 100% in play.
Yeah, that's how I want to look at this, too.
Like, absolutely.
it's still going to be a question mark.
People are still wondering, like, what he's going to be worth and the Pirates can entertain that and such.
And, yeah, I think this just does all but confirm, like, it's probably four years, $80 million at that ballpark at least, because – I think you're right.
Like, Bowers had a great year last year offensively, but, like, so did Brandon Lowe.
they're both coming off their best seasons.
So, like, they're both at high points.
you can say, like, well, Bowers had an excellent year last year, so he deserved a little – so did Brandon Lowe.
The difference, though, too, is when Jake Bauers put up a 3.6 season last year, that brought his total career war to 3.2.
He was a negative player before this year.
like, that's what we're talking about.
Like, he basically had one season.
He capitalized on it.
Like, good for him, right?
And also, maybe he's just a late bloomer and Milwaukee unlocked something, and this is what he can be going for, at least close to it.
And so, like, also, like, good for him, and he deserves that money and such.
But, like, Brandon Lowe, who's also coming off his best season, 4.9 war, that improved his career war to 21.8.
It's like, you know what you're getting in Brandon Lowe also, and it's also a really good player.
So – and also, too, like, the position.
he's coming off of a Gold Glove caliber season.
when the award is nominated, it's a second base.
it's more of a premium position than first base also.
So, if it's like four years, $80 million for Brandon Lowe, we figure that's the ballpark, and I just think this reassures that.
this isn't going to be like, can he be a 3.45?
No.
It's four years, and it's $20 million a year, basically.
if Bowers is getting 15 for a first baseman, yeah, $20 million a year for Brandon Lowe at seconds, which probably in the future will be like a DH or something, but so will Bowers.
You know?
Yeah.
you could even throw Brandon Lowe in a corner outfield if you stick him in right field for a little bit if you need to.
it's one of those things where, yeah, I think this certainly, like that three-year, $45 million offer you brought up that Jim Bowden predicted, like, I think we can all say there's no way that's happening right now.
No way.
Now, I don't think $5 for $150 million is happening either if we're going to go the other extreme.
Yeah, I would be shocked if someone does that, but I think this is like, there's no way it's lower than this.
There's no way.
No.
No.
Yeah.
So, like, there's just that right now.
Bowers, this signing opens your eyes to see, like, okay.
Brent Allows' market's probably going to be about the $480.
So, hearing Colin, you don't have to go deep into this.
We already talked about it, but Colin said, like, that is their plan A, so we'll find out what happens.
Free agency's been, I guess, let me ask you this before we get into the next thing.
Like, free agency, about what you expected so far or maybe a little bit slower?
I'd say it's about what I expected.
we haven't seen a ton, but I think you started to see a little bit of movement this weekend on some guys, right?
even just last week in general, they said you saw Bowers come off the board.
You saw Emilio Pagan come off the board.
So, like, there's a few guys who have come off.
Evan Phillips going to Atlanta.
So, some pretty decent reliever contracts, right?
Phillips getting over $11 million a year.
Pagan getting over $11 million a year.
a lefty reliever, which is something the Pirates are certainly in the market for.
Tim Hill, he gets signed yesterday going back to the Yankees.
Certainly more on the cheaper side, but as I said, he's locked up.
So, yeah, I think you're starting to see things pick up a little.
I expect a lot more this week than last week because last week, with it being the GM meetings, it's again, years past has been laying the groundwork for what comes later.
With teams operating maybe a little bit quicker this season, that groundwork culminates into something maybe a little bit quicker.
But I don't expect those big names still to come off the board until, like, the very end.
Like, I'm talking November 31st, December 1st, like, right at the deadline.
But, yeah, I think we're going to start seeing some guys come off the board like we did this weekend.
Yeah, just curious because, again, this is going to be an interesting short offseason.
There's only just a couple weeks left, more or less, until it's going to be all stopped.
And as Colin expressed, right, a lot of guys think that there's going to be an active free agency before the lockout, like how in 2021, 2020-21.
So, nothing huge yet.
Ours, I think, obviously was the biggest one.
And it's not surprising.
Like, he quickly turned and cashed in.
Like, that's a guy that you expect, like, too.
It's like, I'm going to capitalize off this season.
Let me cash in.
And they're like, oh, the Red Sox is going to need $60 million?
Yeah.
Let me sign up.
Well, what's funny is, like, you referred to the, like, right after World Series, that famous Pat Murphy clip where he's saying, when you're rich and playing for the Yankees or whatever, remember this.
And then Bowers said, you're not getting rid of me that easy.
And Bowers was the first, like, big name off the board.
So, I guess they did.
I guess it was easy.
Yep.
Yep.
It just took $58 million.
But again, like, Milwaukee, we jokingly said, not really jokingly, but the thing about Milwaukee is they're going to have a nice cash influx after this World Series.
And they decided to let him walk, too.
Because, like you said, Jim, they'll just find another guy who's in arbitration.
that's what.
He was a big prospect that just never panned out when we just mentioned all those seasons.
And the Brewers got their hands on him in a trade.
And here we are.
So, yeah, they'll just do it again.
Well, they get a pick at the end of the first round, too.
I'm sure that guy will turn into a stud just because it's the Brewers.
Yeah, of course.
But let's go ahead and tell you a little bit about today's sponsor.
Defer is a family and employer-owned and operated business.
They believe that coffee and tea are one of life's simplest and most accessible pleasures and, when enjoyed thoughtfully, can open your eyes to the here and now.
They have five locations across the city of Pittsburgh, including the flagship in the heart of Pittsburgh's historic Strip District.
Don't forget to stop by Defer's new location downtown on Penn Avenue, right across from the Benidum.
Grab a cup and fill up on your walk to Pianzio Park.
Mobile ordering is available.
Check out their Instagram for more details.
And, Jim, as always, let everyone know how they can save themselves 30%.
Yeah, go to Defer.coffee, load up your cart, whatever you want in there, put in promo code NS930, and you'll get 30% off your entire order, first order.
There it is.
That's right.
So make it count.
So, you mentioned Tim Hill.
That's also something that Colin mentioned.
I think a lot of people speculated, right?
The left-hand pitching market, that's a priority for the Pirates this year.
Ben Charington said that is a priority.
Tim Hill signs the one-year $2.25 million deal to go back to the Yankees.
that's a cheap deal.
Tim Hill, lefty.
He had a 460 ERA last year, a 114 whip.
He shut down, left-handed pitching for sure, 6'11 OPS.
But, again, like that type of a pitcher, is this the type that Pirates should be enticed to go after?
Or is it, like, Evan Phillips who signs a big multi-year type of deal?
I don't think the Pirates need to be doing multi-year deals for, like, for relievers, unless it's somebody you really like.
I would say Tim Hill's also on the lower end of caliber, a reliever that you're shooting for.
very old.
He's been in the league forever.
But he's not really coming off that great of a season.
He doesn't strike anybody out.
He does get a ton of ground balls and deuces weak contact, things like that.
Had a little bit of a home run issue, yes, last year.
That's what led to that ERA being as high as it was.
But, historically, he's been a pretty decent pitcher.
But I think if you're the Pirates… He doesn't have a home run problem in New York.
Yeah.
I think you're looking for someone, though, a little bit higher caliber.
I said, the left-handed reliever market is pretty good right now for the Pirates.
Like, if you're the Pirates and you're looking for a lefty reliever, you've got yourself quite a few options, between AJ Minter and Taylor Rodgers and Jojo Romero and Brooks Raley and Jose Alvarado and Brent Suter and Brock Burke
and Stephen Oker and Alex Vestia and Gregory Soto even.
Like, there's a lot of names out there where if you want to grab a pretty solid lefty reliever, I think you can do it.
Tim Hill, I think, is still, like I said, a little bit lower caliber of a guy than I think you need to be shooting for.
So, now, what's nice to see is, he came pretty cheap, right?
So, that's good.
You look at a guy like Soto, and that's the caliber of lefty pitcher that I want is a Soto-type guy.
I know there's been some projections out there that Soto's, teams may be offering him over $10 million a year, coming off this season with multiple years.
I don't know if I'd go that high, but if you can get somebody in that same range as you got Soto last year, like, in that $6 to $8 million range for a year, or if you need to
throw in a second year, if you like the guy, go ahead.
I think that's more what you're looking for.
So, if I'm looking at, like, the lefty reliever market, I'm looking at the mentors, the Romeros, the Burks, the Okerts, I'm looking at those guys.
Yeah.
I'm with you.
Excuse me.
I really just don't think relievers' position that this team should be, like, truly investing into, considering what their payroll is and what they're probably going to spend on payroll this upcoming season, but they can't just, like, punt it.
Like, that's what I'm about.
Like, Tim Hill isn't the sexiest.
like, one point or one year, $2.25 million.
It is cheap.
But, like, when you look at them, too.
Like, the numbers were fine-ish, per se.
But, like, that's I can envision Evan Sisk doing this.
That's what you have.
Yeah, absolutely.
You know?
Like, you're still trying to improve what Evan Sisk is, and I don't know if Tim Hill truly does that.
Now, again, like, we're not, we, you don't need a closer.
You don't even, like, truly need a sit-up guy.
Like, you need someone in the middle inning.
So, right, you're probably not investing too much on, like, one of those top tier.
a Joe Romero would be awesome.
he's also just not.
I would enjoy him in this bullpen on this team and to talk about him.
But, yeah, I'm with you there.
I'm not like, oh, man, they should have got Tim Hill at all.
also, he's going back to the Yankees.
There's some familiarity.
But I guess that's where I'm at, too.
Like, I don't, the $7 million range is, like, where I want them to be at.
Like, there's certainly, you want to improve on Evan Sisk.
And, again, I don't think Tim Hill does.
But they don't need a closer.
They don't need a sit-up, man.
Like, they need to see a guy in the middle innings there that's going to make this bullpen, shut down, as it was, after the trade deadline last year once Weaver got rid of the bees.
Yeah, and if you think, like, your 8-9 is set.
Yeah, like, if your 8-9 is set with Weaver and Montgomery, like, yeah, you need somebody that you feel comfortable with going to in the seventh inning.
Or if one of those guys are down for the day because they've pitched back-to-back days, you're comfortable putting them in the eighth inning, right?
So, yeah, I think you're looking for somebody who's had some success.
I don't think you're necessarily looking for somebody with closer experience.
I don't think you need that.
Again, I would welcome Soto back.
I think a lot of people would.
I think a lot of people wouldn't.
Like, there's some people who definitely didn't enjoy their time watching Gregory Soto.
I think he's a perfectly fine option for this team right now with the way that the bullpen's constructed.
But I also think, like I said, he may even be on the more expensive end.
And you mentioned it, like, I don't know if you need to invest a ton of money in this bullpen because the way it's set up right now is, like, it's pretty solid.
You just need a lefty.
You need a lefty that you feel comfortable with.
And like I said, the good news is that there are a lot of options out there.
I expect them to get one of those options out there.
But if they would have gotten Tim Hill, I probably would have been a little disappointed.
Like, I would have hoped for something a little bit sexier than Tim Hill.
I'm not saying they need to go out there and get Adrian Moore home or anything like that.
But, yeah, I would have certainly wanted something a little bit more appealing than Tim Hill.
Alex Vessi, another one that, Bucko Mike put in here in the comments.
I think he'd be a great choice as well.
Yeah, Vessi, also another one.
Also, TFL Marlin, guy in our strat league.
I own him.
Yeah.
Lots of options there.
So, I feel like the Pirates, if that's what they're targeting, which I would imagine that's what they're targeting, they should be able to land somebody reasonably good.
Yeah.
Like, you make a good point here that this isn't the sexiest free agency.
But, for left-handed pitching, it's the market that Pirates are looking for.
So, yeah.
There's certainly options out there, yeah.
Tim Hill, obviously, off the board.
But, again, that's okay.
That's okay.
Let's move on.
Unless there's anything else you want to talk about with left-handed pitching?
No.
I know that they're also in the – like, I know that they've also kicked tires on a lefty starter.
So, that's also a possibility.
maybe – I know Alex did a show a little bit ago about – and he mentioned Ryan Yarbrough, right, as someone who – another lefty, but also maybe someone who could start if you need him to,
stretch him out as a starter, and maybe that's a way to pick up a really cheap left-handed starter is, hey, this guy you're going to pay reliever money for, but maybe you could make him a starter.
So, yeah, like I said, there's a lot of stuff that they can do out there to get creative, I think.
But, yeah, I would fully expect them to get one of those lefty relievers on the board.
And I think they're going to do it relatively soon.
You know what?
I'm going to say this.
Lefty reliever coming to the Buccos this week.
I'm going to call it.
This week?
This week.
The Ochre Emergency Podcast this week is what you're calling it?
It might be this week.
I'm traveling so that it makes sense, right?
Because it means, like, I won't be able to do it.
But, yeah.
It's going to happen Wednesday night.
It'll be, like, a Wednesday afternoon.
It'll be, like, Nathan and Cody will do the emergency pod.
Doug will be out on, like, a two-hour Uber ride somewhere.
All of us will be available.
It'll be Cody and Nathan.
Yes, of course.
Naturally.
But there is another deadline coming.
We talk about the qualifying offer.
There's also the Rule 5 protection.
We've alluded to, like, not sure if they're going to have a draft, but you operate as if they are because you don't want to be caught, right?
Like, oh, we just expected not to have a draft.
So we didn't do any preparation, and now there is one, and we're screwed.
I guess you have to some level, act as if there's going to be a draft to protect your guys you want to protect.
So, this makes an interesting conversation here because that is upcoming.
I believe tomorrow, right, is when they have to – tomorrow at 6 p.m. is when they have to be protected, and that's the 40-man.
There's two spots available right now.
There's 38 on the 40-man roster.
And there's quite a few players that, are left hanging right now.
Do you want to protect?
And like you mentioned, we talked about Axioplaz to somewhat of a level, on with Colin there.
But I think, like, he is certainly a talking point here.
But there's – again, there's two spots.
If there's more that you want to protect, you've got to purge someone on the 40-man beforehand also.
So let's maybe, like, talk about to some level here.
Like, who do you envision the Pirates protecting them?
There's some top prospects that are available, run down, like Axioplaz, your Donnie De Los Santos, Termarr Johnson, Lonnie White, Tony Blanco Jr., Johnny Severino, some of the guys that we saw at the fall league here.
What do you envision here?
Yeah.
just sticking with some of those guys that you named, because I think there's a few other guys that you didn't name.
But sticking with the guys that you named, I think – Those were on the top 30.
Yeah.
Yeah, I think you're pretty safe not adding most of those Greensboro guys, right?
Like, your Donnie De Los Santos, I can't imagine, is being picked up by any team, right?
There's just too many issues in his game right now.
He's too far away from Major League Baseball.
He's an infielder.
Like, he's not really someone that you can just, like, hide on your roster or someone who would be, worth that roster spot, really.
I don't expect any team to have him on their radar.
Lonnie White Jr. is another one where I liked what we saw out of him last year, but that was also, like, the first time that we ever saw that out of him.
And he's still striking out at an enormous clip.
you're striking out 32% of the time in AA.
That's just not a guy that you can reliably put on a Major League roster either.
So, like, I think you're looking at, like, Lonnie White Jr., you're safe.
You're Donnie De Los Santos, you're safe.
Johnny Severino, you're safe.
Tony Blanco Jr., even as, I feel like every time that we go out in the world and we talk to people who, like, don't exclusively cover the Pirates, they always bring up Tony Blanco Jr.
Like, he's a freak, right?
But also, like, you're not rostering Tony Blanco Jr.
He has absolutely no position versatility.
He's a right-handed hitting DH who strikes out 30% of the time in high A.
Again, not someone that you can roster.
Plaz is the one guy that I'm a little bit concerned with just because while I don't think he's someone that can be in the Major Leagues next season, he's so talented that I think you protect him just because you can't even afford to lose him.
I think there's just too much impact in the back that you got to add him to the 40-man.
I would add Axial Plaz out of that Greensboro group.
Then you look at Indy, and there's a few interesting names there.
Like, there's no tippy-top prospects up there, but there's guys who are pretty close to Major League ready, have decent pedigree, and you got to look at it and say, hey, this is somebody that, I want to go ahead and add to the 40-man so that I can use them as depth for next year.
And I think there's three names in Indy that you can look at.
One is Termar Johnson, one is Mitch Jeb, and one is Derek Diamond.
Those three are the guys that I'm looking at where I think all three of those guys are ultimately going to be in the Major Leagues at some point.
I think all three of them could realistically be on a roster next year.
So if you're a team out there and you like what you see out of any of those three guys, a Rule 5 pick is something that you could throw at them.
So I'd add all three of them.
I would add all three of those guys.
I think we've seen the Pirates.
I think we've seen the Pirates be aggressive at adding people like this in the past.
Especially last year, they added a bunch of players to the 40-man that we weren't expecting.
So if I'm the Buccos, I'm adding Plaz.
I'm adding Termar.
Even with the injury, I think that even makes them more appealing to teams, honestly, because they can just hide them on a 60-a-day IL for a while.
Right.
I'm adding Mitch Jeb just because I like what I saw out of him last year, to be honest.
And he looks like a perfectly fine fourth or fifth outfielder.
And I'm adding Derek Diamond.
I think he's had a really good season, won the Reliever of the Year award, and is someone who could be effective out of a bullpen as depth.
Okay.
So four guys.
I'm adding four guys.
Yeah.
And one of them being Mitch Jeb.
Interesting.
Interesting.
I'm adding Mitch Jeb.
I'm adding Mitch Jeb.
It's his arch enemy.
He wishes Mitch Jeb would just go.
No, I'm joking.
But who thought the day would come that Mitch Jeb would be talked about by Jim Rosati being added to the 40-man roster?
You know what?
There's a time and place for everything, I guess.
Yep.
There it is.
This is interesting, though, because I'm with you, too, man.
Like, for the Greensboro ones especially, there's enticing players there for sure.
And again, a lot of those, the names I mentioned were all top 30 prospects, so, like, they're ranked up there.
Like, you mentioned about Tony Blanco.
Like, absolutely.
I guess, like, the one thing with Tony Blanco is because he's just a DH, like, you don't have to worry about grooming.
Like, you could just, if you wanted to, if you were one of those crazy teams, it was like, if we want to get our hands on this talent, you just pop him a DH.
Like, he's not hurting yourself anywhere on the field because he's not there yet.
He's just going to strike out 50% of the time.
So, he is hurting.
he's hurting you, probably.
Well, I'm saying he's going to hurt you just in one place, right?
Where you've got to, like, if you're the Rockies, what I'm alluding to, like, you just think of a DH and say, here you go.
We got your system.
Now, let's see if we can do something.
But, again, because that pit toll is so bad right now where he's at, I don't think it translates into going to be a successful season in the majors.
Like, yes, I think he's going to be safe.
I don't want to lose Tony Blanco.
He's certainly not a sure thing to be a major leaguer.
But, yeah, I don't think he's getting added by any team here.
again, the one is certainly Axial Plas because for the same reasons, like, he's as far away along, too.
Like, I don't think it's going to translate.
I don't think it's a guy that you bring up, especially if he's a catcher.
Like, it's a guy you want to develop both ways.
You want to keep his defense developing and his offense.
He's so far away, but that's such tremendous talent that it's like, if he's exposed, the risk-reward, like, you know what?
Maybe let's get our hands on him.
Might stun his development, but if he can be 75% of the guy that he could potentially be, we got him.
So, like you said, like, it's just not worth unprotecting him to potentially lose him.
So, I think you're just doing that.
And, man, I'm with you.
I guess Tamar, I'm iffy on.
And you make a great point, though.
Like, he's probably more attractive because you could just go ahead and add him, and then once, you're able to put guys on the 60-man, he's there, and that frees up your 40-man spot, and he's not playing anywhere.
Like, you're not really stunting him anywhere because he's not going to play regardless for quite some time because of that injury.
So, he's getting picked up.
He's getting picked up.
I guess I'm just at the point where do you want to lose a 40-man?
Because you're doing four.
You got to cut two guys here.
And that's what we'll talk about lately here as well.
So, Tamar, I'm shaking on Mitch Jeb, though, too, and Derek Diamond.
Like, that makes sense.
I'll do this, though.
We'll go four because I'm cool with Tamar.
You're protecting him for those reasons.
There's still talent there.
I'm just – I think we're all souring on the talent that he truly is.
But, at any rate, still could be there.
Still young enough.
So, we have four guys.
So, the 40-man is now at 42.
So, what two guys are you removing from the 40-man now to go ahead and protect these four that you want?
Now, I've got to pull up a 40-man roster.
Well, let's start here.
You've got Mitch Jeb, you're adding.
Yeah, I've got Axel Klaas as a catcher.
they just picked up Badu.
Are you just saying, well, it was nice this week?
Probably, yeah.
Like, I may be trying to sneak Badu back through waivers.
Yeah, I think that's one.
That's certainly a guy that can be dropped off of a 40-man.
I think if you're looking at the pitchers, Noah Murdock, a guy who could certainly, he's probably the first pitcher to go off of this list that I'm looking at.
Again, Badu, Ronny Simon's another guy who you could always take off.
even Tyler Callihan, I don't think you're quite giving up on Nick Yorke yet, but his time's growing thin as well.
there's certainly, I think you've got options here.
But if you're asking me what two guys go off, I'm going to go ahead and say Akil Badu and Ronny Simon.
So two hitters.
Yeah.
Yeah, I'm good with that.
So I think the one thing about this exercise is there's certainly options.
Yeah, like this whole Tamar situation, it's like, again, I'm not sure really what he's going to be.
I'm not sure of the talent anymore.
He's not that surefire.
He has this great hit tool.
He's going to be a good hitter and such.
We're not really sure about that.
The strikeouts are there with him also to some level.
But you just name those guys at the cost of one of those.
Maybe I'll go ahead and protect them.
Maybe I'll go ahead and protect them at least at this point in time.
So yeah, there's certainly options again, but do makes a whole lot of sense, which also is wild because it was like, hey, they claimed him and they had like this like little press conference to some level.
Like, let's introduce Badu.
And then I get to a week later.
It's going to be like, all right, well, your time here was nice.
Bye-bye.
Yeah, Akil Badu is the first to go, in my opinion.
There's just no, I don't see, I don't see why he's here.
And I also think that if you do DFA Akil Badu, he has no options.
Like, he's not that attractive of a guy on your 40, man.
Like, if you have Akil Badu on your roster, he has to be on your major league team.
He's basically a role five pick, right?
If you look at it that way.
Which he also already was.
Yeah.
So I, he's the first one to go for me if you need a spot.
Yeah.
No, makes perfect sense.
I agree.
I'm with you as also.
I'm cool with, like, they added him.
He's depth.
And like, the thing about him is, we're talking about role five.
Like, that's his story.
He was a successful role five pick.
he was added to Detroit Tigers.
And he had that solid season.
Season.
Singular.
But he did.
he did.
So maybe there's something still there.
And like, now's the time.
Let's add him now for the four or five.
Everyone gets their role five protection done.
Forty mans are set.
And maybe, like you're saying, like, that's the way the pirates can go ahead and DFA him once again.
Sneak him through him and get him back in his system.
Not on a 40 man.
So he's still in there for depth.
So, yeah.
I think that makes a whole lot of sense for him.
I would go with Noah Murdock.
But, again, at either rate.
Ronny Simon, also fine-ish.
But maybe there's something to keep him for.
We'll see.
he did have an outstanding AAA season.
Murdock had a really good year this past season in the minors.
the stuff is pretty decent.
And, yeah, like I said, he was getting AAA hitters out.
He started the season in AA.
Did really, did okay there.
But, he did an okay year.
I don't know if he survives the 40 man the entire offseason.
But, is what it is.
Thomas Harrington's another guy on that pitching staff where it's like, yeah, he's technically starting depth.
But every time you've seen him, he just hasn't looked good.
Yeah.
And so how viable of a guy is he?
I could see him getting removed at some point, too, maybe.
Cool.
Well, Jim, a lot of people that I know use nicotine pouches.
And the part that missed most isn't so much the nicotine as the routine.
Larine just launched a pouch that keeps the routine but leaves the nicotine out.
Larine Co
Pouches are pouches that swap out the nicotine and give you clean focus and support your enamel the whole time they're in.
And because this is Larine, every pouch also has nano-hydrooxapetite, the mineral your teeth are made of.
So it gives you daily enamel support in between brushings.
Every other pouch out there makes you pick between something that helps you focus and something that's actually good for your teeth.
This is the only one designed to do both, and it comes from a brand that's leading the way at supporting your oral health.
Give Larine a try.
Right now, Larine Co is offering our listeners up to 50% off at buylarine.com slash North Shore.
That's buylarine, L-A-R-I-N-E dot com slash North Shore for up to 50% off.
Yeah, so that wraps up the Rule 5.
Again, we'll find out tomorrow by, what did I say, 6 p.m., is it?
Or is it 7, one of the two, the Rule 5?
So tomorrow at 4 p.m., Brandon Lowe needs to make his qualifying offer decision.
Tomorrow at 6 p.m., Rule 5, people need added.
Yeah.
There it is.
Yeah, so tomorrow will be a big day to some level about news, I guess, not true action.
So there is that.
And outside of that, man, anything else really that we need to discuss?
No, we've got, what, two weeks remaining, essentially, before the lockout starts, right around two weeks.
So, yeah, you've got two weeks to do stuff before you can't do anything for a while.
So I do expect the Pirates to do something.
I don't know if they're going to make a big splash or anything, but I would expect a lefty reliever to be signed in the next two weeks.
I think Brandon Lowe will be signed before the lockout, right?
Is that a prediction?
I think Brandon Lowe will be signed before the lockout.
Is he going to be a Pirate?
No.
I'm still there, too.
I think it happened before.
I think he's a perfect candidate for a guy who wants to know where he and his family are going to be next year.
He's going to have plenty of offers.
Again, the Jake Bauers thing tells us he's going to have offers.
He's going to have money thrown at him.
He's going to be comfortable and set.
So let me just know where, and I can have a very Merry Christmas, enjoy the holidays, and come back whenever the hell I'm supposed to come back.
But I know where I'm coming back to, and I don't think it's the Pirates either.
Yeah, and we just saw too many big-name teams are being named in terms of being linked to them.
It's like all the teams that have money, except the Dodgers, are being included, and Brandon Lowe would be a good fit for these guys.
So I think the Pirates are going to try.
I think they're certainly going to try, but I don't think they're going to be successful.
I agree.
They'll try.
They have their own little cap that they implement.
They'll try.
It's not going to be enough.
They're not going to be comfortable with the amount that's going to be thrown his way to make it happen, I feel.
I wouldn't be surprised if you remember last year at the winter meetings, it came out that the Pirates had the highest AAV offer.
It was like they beat the Phillies by like $0.4 million a year or something like that, but the Phillies gave an additional year.
I think I could see that being the case here with Brandon Lowe.
I could see after the fact, someone leaks the Pirates figure to make it seem like, hey guys, look, we really did try here.
And it's going to come out that the Pirates AAV figure is the highest, but I think someone will beat them on years.
So they can do like a three-year, $62 million deal.
I could see the Pirates being like, yeah, we gave them three years, $66 million, and then he signs for four years, $84.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah.
I can see that.
I can see that too.
I don't actually know if I can see that.
I don't know if they knew that.
Hey, they offered it to Schwarber.
They did, but then they lost out and they made all the other moves on top of it, but those moves are, they exist.
Yeah.
That payrolls are, that's $100 million right now with Mitch Keller.
That's my, no, that's my prediction now.
My prediction is he'll sign somewhere for maybe even five years.
He'll sign somewhere though.
Pirates AAV will be the highest in terms of leaked.
The Pirates will have offered him a higher AAV than what he signs for.
Honestly, I like that.
I never thought about it in that sense.
I wasn't really thinking, but absolutely that will happen.
Yeah.
It might even be leaked as it's going on.
Who knows?
Cause that whole Schwarber stuff was, most like real time as far as like money and dollars and such.
Then obviously it came after like, again, the Phillies offered that extra year and all that, but yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah.
That's going to hit so hard.
That's what it's going to have.
That's what it's going to have.
Cause that's going to have the fan base.
So split, right?
The guys that are always, Oh, you do is you're so pessimistic.
It's like, Oh, here we go again.
And the guys are all optimistic.
The other side of you be like, yeah, see, we had the, we had the most, we had the biggest annual value.
We were, they were doing it.
It's like, well, not really.
There's a difference between trying and doing there is.
it's a, there's a big difference between trying and doing.
there is, we try to have a good podcast.
I feel like, I feel like that's going to end up on a quote card this week.
Yeah.
Maybe do like, there is no try only do, and then have like the Yoda and then Jim Rosati.
Like have it like the, like the Michael Scott, Wayne Gretzky quote.
There it is.
All right.
We out of here.
Yeah.
Let's get out of here.
make sure you're checking out offbeat every day this week.
We've got NS9 live on Wednesday.
We got a guest on, I guess, WNS9 plus on Wednesday.
Zips figures just dropped early.
Zips figures this off season.
so Dan's and Borski will be joining us on Wednesday.
always one of our favorite shows of the off season.
So we'll dive deep into the 2027 projections, which look pretty good.
2027 protect projections.
They look pretty good.
so yeah, excited to dive into those.
Yeah.
Always love the show with Dan Ziporski, but I do have some beef and unfortunately I won't be on the show.
I don't, I mentioned my wife, right?
I got to pick her up that night from the airport.
So I won't be on the show, but Dan, yeah, we had this whole lockout coming.
Like this is supposed to be good lockout.
We have no baseball to talk about content.
You had to do it while the season's off season was still live.
Like this would have been in December or January.
Yeah.
Come on, Dan, you're hurt.
You're killing us.
I guess we could always talk about it then, but then it'd be old news.
We're just going to have Dan on every week to just update the Zips roster.
That doesn't move.
Right.
Yeah.
I'm good with that.
All right.
Yeah.
Tune in.
And then again, download that app.
We've had a lot, a lot of downloads happening.
Well, again, we have the new NS9 play all the trivia games, different type of, the games we have going on right now, a lot of great feedback and people keep playing it.
They keep saying it's fun and we keep making those some tweaks and some stuff.
So you can now play the lineup draft over and over and over again, not just one time.
So it doesn't count for points, but download the app or go to the website.
Northstar9.com forward slash play.
It's fun.
It's, it is fun.
I'm not going to lie.
It is fun.
It's a true when I wake up and get to play the game.
It's part of my morning routine.
Now, every morning I make my coffee, I make my Defer coffee in my kitchen, boot everything up while I'm playing the games.
I listened to a show so I can listen to a show, but also bank an extra pack in the card game because you get a reward for just watching or listening to a show.
So I'll usually, what I'll do is I'll open up the computer.
I'll listen to offbeat, play the games, and then I've got another pack to open at the end of the show.
And if you, if you want to say Northstar9 cheats for any reason, I just want to say something here.
The card league, again, we developed this.
We developed this.
As the very first person in the league, I've, no one has played more games than myself.
I could build up all these packs, all this.
I am four and fricking 10, Jim.
I did not win in this damn card league.
Nathan beat me last night.
If you listen to his, him and Cody have a new show, which also check that out.
It's really funny.
It's a whole different take.
I wish you'd particularly hear from us.
They talk about power Twitter and just the random things.
But yeah, like Nate has an issue with me because I have an issue with Android users because Android users are well, stay quiet.
But anyways, Nate is the only person in our group that has an Android.
He's the reason why we have green bubbles and we hate Nate.
We hate Nate.
And he beat me last night and he has not stopped talking about it.
And we might have to remove Nate from Northstar9.
That's all I have to say.
Android takeover, I guess.
We're all going to have to get the Android.
Nate beat me, so I'm now four and 10.
So join the league and do better than me.
The bar's not high.
Yeah, you stink.
I do.
I do.
I do fairly well at the draft.
I had the highest score this week on one of the days.
There you go.
I do fairly well at the draft, the card game.
That ain't for me, I guess.
But it could be for you.
So download it.
Again, we've had a lot of new users, a lot of new people joining this week because of the play and a lot of good feedback.
So don't miss out.
All right.
Yeah, it's a lot of fun.
We will see you guys later.
We love you all.
Bye-bye.
See you guys.
All right.
That wraps up this episode of North Shore Nine.
Thanks so much for tuning in.
Whether you're listening on the podcast or catching us on YouTube, if you enjoyed the show, please give this video a thumbs up.
And don't forget to hit that subscribe button if you haven't already.
It really helps us grow.
And if you're listening on the podcast, a quick review goes a long way in helping others find the show.
Plus, be sure to tell a friend about us.
There's always room for more here in the NS9 community.
And for those looking to support us a little more, consider joining our Patreon, become an MVP member, and get exclusive perks while helping us continue to bring you more of the Pirates content you love.
Thanks again for all your support.
And Let's Go Bucs.
Bye.


Comments· 0
Will the Pirates make Brandon Lowe the highest AAV offer and still lose him to a longer deal?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.