◆NEWSPirates Want To Limit Ryan O'Hearn's Outfield Reps◆ROSTERSigned free agent RHP Enmanuel Nunez to a minor league contract◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
◆NEWSPirates Want To Limit Ryan O'Hearn's Outfield Reps◆ROSTERSigned free agent RHP Enmanuel Nunez to a minor league contract◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
Don Kelly has become an easy target as the Pirates fall short of their playoff expectations, but Alex Stumpf believes the blame goes much deeper. Between injuries to key players, an inconsistent pitching staff and players simply underperforming, Kelly was dealt a difficult hand. Alex breaks down Kelly’s mistakes, what he’s done well and why bringing him back for a critical 2027 season still makes sense.
Watch or listen to the full episode of OffBeat on North Shore Nine.
Comments· 0
The Debate
Should the Pirates bring Don Kelly back as manager for 2027?
From Alex Stumpf’s take on the show
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.
With Alex Stumpf.
Chapters
Key takeaways
1
Kelly isn't blameless for Saturday's Gregory Soto call, but saying he's a main reason the Pirates are missing the postseason goes too far. Injuries and players who underachieved did more damage.
Alex Stumpf
2
Pinch-hitting Nick Yorke for Brandon Lowe against a lefty in April may have been right on paper, but Stumpf would always leave his best hitter in for the biggest at-bat.
Alex Stumpf
3
If the Pirates miss the playoffs in 2027, they may have to think about a rebuild. By then Oneil Cruz will have only one year of team control left, and Skenes and Jones will have two.
Alex Stumpf
4
Firing Kelly would be cutting off your nose to spite your face. Teams like the Mets would want to talk to a manager who ends the year around .500 with a small-market club.
Alex Stumpf
5
The Pirates could do a lot worse than bringing Kelly back for 2027, and Stumpf would keep him even if that's not a popular opinion.
On Saturday, Don Kelly made a questionable decision by putting Gregory Soto into the eighth inning and then leaving him out there admittedly too long.
Alex Stumpf
It ended up backfiring, Pirates end up losing, and a lot of people put a lot of this season's failures on him in the subsequent hours after that loss.
Alex Stumpf
And while I don't think that he is guiltless for Saturday or for some other losses over the course of the year, I think it might be exaggerating a little bit to say that Don Kelly is one of the main reasons why this team isn't going to the postseason.
Alex Stumpf
Good morning, and welcome to OffBeat, here on North Shore Nine, presented by FanDuel.
Alex Stumpf
My name is Alex Stumpf, and this is a daily look at your Pittsburgh Pirates.
Alex Stumpf
There's been a lot of criticism surrounding Don Kelly of late, and some of it is founded.
Alex Stumpf
I'm going to start off with that.
Alex Stumpf
Some of this is founded, and I, at the very least, will also get the frustration.
Alex Stumpf
Because this was supposed to be the year.
Alex Stumpf
Playoffs, period, full stop.
Alex Stumpf
And while the Pirates don't have an E next to their name yet, and they're still technically in it, the Fangraph's odds are 0%.
Alex Stumpf
It would be nothing short of divine intervention from the baseball gods for the Pirates to get the number six seed this year.
Alex Stumpf
And that's very disappointing.
Alex Stumpf
Because there were a lot of high expectations for this team.
Alex Stumpf
And this is one of the most talented rosters we have seen in a while.
Alex Stumpf
Easily the most talented roster they've had since 2015.
Alex Stumpf
They should have done more.
Alex Stumpf
And whenever you have a team that underachieves, manager is usually going to be one of the first, if not the first, person people look at.
Alex Stumpf
There's blame to go around, and he's one of them.
Alex Stumpf
And I get some of that is on him.
Alex Stumpf
But also, and I think people in the clubhouse would say that, he's not the one running in between the lines every day.
Alex Stumpf
Some of this is on the players.
Alex Stumpf
Some of this is on the managers.
Alex Stumpf
Some of this is on the GM.
Alex Stumpf
Some of this is on the culture that has been built from the president.
And then he gets hurt, Oneil Cruz gets hurt, Ryan O'Hearn gets hurt.
Alex Stumpf
And it's just a long list of injuries.
Alex Stumpf
And just right now, they're playing their best ball of late.
Alex Stumpf
They won five straight series before they went into Chicago where they dropped two of three.
Alex Stumpf
But, last six series doing really well.
Alex Stumpf
They're making what in a lot of circumstances would be a really good September push towards the postseason had they not dug themselves in that deep a hole.
Alex Stumpf
And that hole is partially the injuries, partially underachieving players.
Alex Stumpf
And yes, in a small part, some questionable managing in some games.
Alex Stumpf
I've talked about a few times that in April, whenever they pinch hit Nick Yorke for Brandon Lowe against a left-handed pitcher.
Alex Stumpf
That might have been the right move on paper, mathematically speaking.
Alex Stumpf
But I would always take Brandon Lowe in that situation.
Alex Stumpf
Give me my best hitter in the biggest spot, even if it's a bad matchup.
Alex Stumpf
If you're in that spot, roll with it.
Alex Stumpf
There's that, there have been some bullpen moves.
Alex Stumpf
I get that.
Alex Stumpf
But I think where Don Kelly is best as a manager is the stuff you don't see behind the scenes.
Alex Stumpf
Because there are a lot of times this year where you could have seen this team throw in the towel.
Alex Stumpf
And to their credit, they're still playing hard in September.
Alex Stumpf
They're playing winning ball in September.
Alex Stumpf
This team, again, outside of Divine Intervention, isn't going to be making the playoffs.
Alex Stumpf
But they have cared all year.
Alex Stumpf
And they're still playing hard.
Alex Stumpf
And it still should be, at the end of the day, a 500 or winning season.
Alex Stumpf
It's a long way to go.
Alex Stumpf
It's short of what they want.
Alex Stumpf
But it could be viewed as a stepping stone for 2027.
Alex Stumpf
And that is going to be such an important year for this franchise.
Alex Stumpf
Because if they don't make the playoffs in 2027, I really don't know what's next.
Alex Stumpf
At that point, Oneil Cruz will have only one year of team control remaining.
Do you have to start thinking rebuild at that point?
Alex Stumpf
There are a lot of question marks around there.
Alex Stumpf
But, hey, if 2027 is the absolute we have to do it this year, at least a winning season could be a stepping stone toward that.
Alex Stumpf
Any momentum is appreciated.
Alex Stumpf
Because there was none coming in whenever Don Kelly inherited this job.
Alex Stumpf
That's what bad culture looked like.
Alex Stumpf
the last month of the Derek Shelton era.
Alex Stumpf
There was a lot of apathy around there.
Alex Stumpf
And Don Kelly just surviving that year.
Alex Stumpf
I think sold for me.
Alex Stumpf
Like, yeah, he could probably do it in Pittsburgh.
Alex Stumpf
It's a long way to go.
Alex Stumpf
But you still see some of those glimmers.
Alex Stumpf
We have more to talk about in a second.
Alex Stumpf
But first, I want to talk about today's sponsor, Larine Co
Alex Stumpf
As we all know, nicotine pouches are popular.
Alex Stumpf
And part of it isn't so much the nicotine as it is the routine.
Alex Stumpf
Larine just launched a pouch that keeps the routine but leaves the nicotine out.
Alex Stumpf
Larine Co pouches swap out the nicotine and give you clean focus and support your enamel the whole time they're in.
Alex Stumpf
It works like the pouches you've seen before.
Alex Stumpf
Tuck one in and go about your day.
Alex Stumpf
Each pouch has a half cup of coffee's worth of caffeine, plus L-theanine and alpha-GPC for a smooth, steady focus with no energy crash.
Alex Stumpf
And it gives your teeth daily enamel support in between brushings.
Alex Stumpf
It comes in mint, cinnamon, and mango.
Alex Stumpf
And it's nicotine-free, always.
Alex Stumpf
It's doing something good for your teeth, and it gives you smooth energy and focus without those jitters.
Alex Stumpf
Every other pouch out there makes you pick between something that helps you focus and something that's actually good for your teeth.
Alex Stumpf
This is the only one designed to do both, and it comes from a brand that's leading the way at supporting your oral health.
Alex Stumpf
Give Larine a try.
Alex Stumpf
Right now, Larine Co is offering our listeners up to 50% off at buylarine.com slash North Shore.
Alex Stumpf
That's buylarine, L-A-R-I-N-E dot com slash North Shore for up to 50% off.
Alex Stumpf
Whenever Kelly became manager last year, I think there was more public perception, media perception from people who weren't necessarily beat writers, who were willing to dub him,
Alex Stumpf
oh, he's this.
Alex Stumpf
He's this type of manager.
Alex Stumpf
He's not just going to, read off of the percentages and just go off of that.
Alex Stumpf
And it's like, that's no manager in today's game is throwing out the analytics, the analysis, the data.
Alex Stumpf
Every decision that is ever going to be made in baseball history from henceforth from any manager is going to have some level of data factored in.
Alex Stumpf
That might be upsetting to some people just to hear that, but it's just the truth of the matter.
Alex Stumpf
You're going to be mindful of what type of matchup am I getting here?
Alex Stumpf
What is the left on left here?
Alex Stumpf
Is this a left on left where he's going to try to be working away, run away from him?
Alex Stumpf
Or is it North-South and maybe you can still get him inside and, pull something for a hit?
Alex Stumpf
Which one matches up with my left-handed hitter?
Alex Stumpf
Which one does my left-handed pitcher?
Alex Stumpf
What zones are going to be, working here?
Alex Stumpf
How often has this pitcher been used lately?
Alex Stumpf
How much has that going to impact how his pitches go?
Alex Stumpf
He's down one mile per hour.
Alex Stumpf
Do we have to adjust the game plan off of that?
Alex Stumpf
There is always going to be that data and decision, that goes into the decision-making nowadays.
Alex Stumpf
So I feel Don Kelly got hoodwinked whenever he got the job and people were championing him of being something that there's just, not...
Alex Stumpf
There's no guy like that in today's game in 2026.
Alex Stumpf
If you want him to be a Jim Leyland, I promise you, if Jim Leyland was still managing in 2026, he's still going to have this data.
Alex Stumpf
It might not be every decision that he makes, is based off of it in the same way that not every decision Don Kelly makes is based off of it.
Alex Stumpf
Look in Chicago on Sunday.
Alex Stumpf
Kyron Mlodzinski was thrown into a spot with the bases loaded, something that he hadn't done all year, and there were a bunch of lefties coming up where he traditionally has struggled.
Alex Stumpf
On paper, it wasn't a great matchup, but it was him throwing his best pitcher in the biggest spot that he could, and it worked out.
Alex Stumpf
See yesterday's episode about how impactful that inning was.
Alex Stumpf
So as bad as, Saturday's managerial decision was, I could make a case that, Kelly putting Mlodzinski in that spot on Sunday played a big part in them winning that game too.
Alex Stumpf
It's a mixed bag.
Alex Stumpf
I think any manager, you're going to have a mixed bag.
Alex Stumpf
And I know there are a lot of people calling for him to be fired because there are people who are very disappointed in this year.
Alex Stumpf
And I don't blame anyone for being disappointed.
Alex Stumpf
Because we were told, playoffs, period, full stop.
Alex Stumpf
And in year seven, if you say earnestly, okay, this is the year, guys, we mean it this time, and then you don't, people are allowed to be pissed.
Alex Stumpf
At some point, whenever you do say, for real, guys, this year, and you don't, people are going to be calling for heads to roll.
Alex Stumpf
And I get Don Kelly is a very popular guy here for those calls.
Alex Stumpf
There are a lot of people who want him fired.
Alex Stumpf
And you know what, I have nothing to report there.
Alex Stumpf
I'd be surprised, though.
Alex Stumpf
That's just my opinion.
Alex Stumpf
Don't take that as reporting, just take that as an opinion right now.
Alex Stumpf
If he was to be fired.
Alex Stumpf
If he was to be fired, I think he'd be very popular out on the open market.
Alex Stumpf
You telling me the Mets, who need, their culture shaken up, they wouldn't jump on the opportunity?
Alex Stumpf
They wouldn't bring him in for an interview?
Alex Stumpf
Depends on what's going on with the Red Sox and Tracy.
Alex Stumpf
What's going on?
Alex Stumpf
There are going to be openings this winter.
Alex Stumpf
And someone who has now shown that he's done the job for a year and a half, who will, at worst, at the end of this year, be 500-ish.
Alex Stumpf
For a small market team like Pittsburgh, that will draw attention.
Alex Stumpf
I get why people are calling for him to be fired, or anyone, really, for that matter, right now.
Alex Stumpf
But I can't help but feeling, firing Kelly would just be cutting off your nose to spite your face.
Alex Stumpf
The number one thing Kelly did in year one, in my opinion, was just survive.
Alex Stumpf
Just what he inherited, clubhouse-wise, culture-wise, just being able to get through that year with everyone still standing, was big.
Alex Stumpf
And there are a lot of challenges this year that are out of his control.
Alex Stumpf
He's getting criticized.
Alex Stumpf
Why'd you take Paul Skenes out after 80-something pitches?
Alex Stumpf
Well, because Skenes hasn't looked like Paul Skenes all year.
Alex Stumpf
And if you try to push that, the 2026 version of Paul Skenes, like 2025 Paul Skenes, don't know what's going to happen to 2027 Paul Skenes.
Alex Stumpf
Could be hurt.
Alex Stumpf
There are a lot of restrictions that are around right now.
Alex Stumpf
These pitchers were not prepared, it looks like sometimes, or not fully built up, or whatever the case may be.
Alex Stumpf
I don't know.
Alex Stumpf
This has been a rough year.
Alex Stumpf
And some of it was, young Bubba Chandler, Braxton Ashcraft, being asked to go six full years as a starter in the majors for the first time.
Alex Stumpf
That's one thing.
Alex Stumpf
There's been a lot of speculation about, what Bill Murphy's impact has been around the team.
Alex Stumpf
I get all that.
Alex Stumpf
It's, I'm just telling you, I'm not putting a lot of this on Don Kelly.
Alex Stumpf
Some of it is, because there's plenty of blame to go around whenever you miss the postseason in such an important year.
Alex Stumpf
But I don't think it's, he's a public enemy number one, like the way we've seen him discussed recently.
Alex Stumpf
This is a big year where they didn't make the postseason in 2027 is going to be one of the most important years in franchise history.
Alex Stumpf
Because if they don't make the playoffs, don't know what that 2028 team looks like.
Alex Stumpf
But as it stands right now, I think he could do a whole lot worse than bringing him back.
Alex Stumpf
I would.
Alex Stumpf
And that might not be the most popular opinion, and I get why people justifiably want heads to roll.
Alex Stumpf
But I don't think he could just be swinging blindly right now.
Alex Stumpf
Thank you so much for listening to OffBeat here on North Shore Nine presented by FanDuel.
Alex Stumpf
If you haven't already, be sure to subscribe wherever you find podcasts, or check us out on YouTube if you want to see my smiling face.
Alex Stumpf
Thank you so much for listening.
Alex Stumpf
We'll talk again tomorrow.
Alex Stumpf
All right, that wraps up this episode of North Shore Nine.
Alex Stumpf
Thanks so much for tuning in.
Alex Stumpf
Whether you're listening on the podcast or catching us on YouTube, if you enjoyed the show, please give this video a thumbs up.
Alex Stumpf
And don't forget to hit that subscribe button if you haven't already.
Alex Stumpf
It really helps us grow.
Alex Stumpf
And if you're listening on the podcast, a quick review goes a long way in helping others find the show.
Alex Stumpf
Plus, be sure to tell a friend about us.
Alex Stumpf
There's always room for more here in the NS9 community.
Alex Stumpf
And for those looking to support us a little more, consider joining our Patreon.
Alex Stumpf
Become an MVP member and get exclusive perks while helping us continue to bring you more of the Pirates content you love.
Alex Stumpf
Thanks again for all your support, and Let's Go Bucs.
Comments· 0
Should the Pirates bring Don Kelly back as manager for 2027?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.