◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
Bucco Brew is back with Anthony DiNardo and Jim Rosati breaking down three of the biggest storylines in Pirates camp: whether Oneil Cruz is finally ready for a true breakout, how real the Konnor Griffin Opening Day conversation has become, and which roster battles are starting to take shape as spring rolls on. The guys dig into Cruz’s offseason work, why Griffin feels different from most prospects, and how names like Jose Urquidy, Mike Clevinger, Nick Yorke, Billy Cook, and Tyler Callihan fit into the roster picture. They also touch on Paul Skenes taking the ball for Team USA in the World Baseball Classic and preview Alex Stumpf’s new daily NS9 show, Off Beat.
Grab your coffee from De Fer Coffee & Tea and use promo code NS930 for 30% off. Watch on YouTube or listen now wherever you get your podcasts.
Comments· 0
The Debate
Should Konnor Griffin be the Pirates' Opening Day shortstop at 19?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.
With Anthony DiNardo and Jim Rosati.
Chapters
Key takeaways
1
2026 is make-or-break for Oneil Cruz. If he repeats last year, it's probably time for the Pirates to move on from him.
2
Konnor Griffin is major-league ready right now. If the Pirates made him the Opening Day shortstop at 19, he could handle it.
3
Starting Griffin in Triple-A is understandable, but the call-up has to come fast. Holding him until June or July to game Rookie of the Year would deserve criticism.
4
Hunter Barco won't open in the majors. He threw about 102 innings last year, so the Pirates will want to manage his innings in Triple-A early.
5
Mike Clevinger has been 'healthy and awful' while José Urquidy was simply hurt, so Clevinger has to do much more this spring to win the No. 5 job.
But there's just a lot of things going around the Oneil Cruz stigma and situation that makes you feel like, you know what, can this be the year?
So I want to ask you, do you think this can be the year?
It definitely could be.
Again, it's spring training.
It's two weeks of spring training, if that, because he'd leave a little bit early.
But the things that everybody's saying and talking about, I feel like is a little bit different than what we've seen in years past.
Like, in years past, it's always been like, yeah, can this be the year he puts it all together?
But hearing everyone talk about what he did over the offseason, it does seem like, I guess the biggest thing here is like all those folks who say he doesn't care.
And he put in a lot of work this offseason to make sure that doesn't happen again.
You could say, why didn't he do this before?
I don't know.
But reading what's going on with him right now, reading what he did this offseason, he clearly wants to tap into that potential.
And so now it's a matter of, like, can you can you take it from spring training and can you can you apply it during the regular season?
But like you mentioned, like working with Kevin Kiermaier, like that's a big thing.
Like he clearly needed some help in center field.
And you heard some of Kevin Kiermaier's quotes about that, where like he can be as good as he wants to be, essentially.
There's been a lot of stuff written and talked about with his relationship with Marcell Ozuna so far this spring training, where he's like really clung to him and vice versa.
And hopefully that pays dividends as well.
The fact that he worked relentlessly, with batting practice versus left handed pitching all offseason, like that was a clear weakness of his last year.
And he came into spring training saying, hey, like, I'm I worked on this.
I worked on this one thing that was not that was not working well for me.
And again, super small sample size this spring, but he's looked really good against left handed pitching so far.
So, again, like it's hard to say that all of this is going to translate to the regular season because you just never know.
It's two different animals spring training in the regular season.
But I think for the first time, like going into a season, like you can clearly see the work that he's putting in and again, like the will to really want to tap into all that potential that we've talked about.
So, yeah, now it's now it's up to him.
Like, can this translate to the regular season?
If it does, then this team can be a lot better.
they added a lot of offensive help and Oneil Cruz going from the hitter that he was last season to someone closer to who we all hoped he could become is a is a powerful weapon in any offense.
Like we've seen what this team looks like when Oneil Cruz is firing on all cylinders like there.
He can take over a game by himself.
Like it's just him.
He gets on base.
He steals a base.
He causes an overthrow.
He's wreaking havoc on the base paths.
He's scoring runs seemingly by himself.
The fact that potential is there and if he's able to tap into that more consistently and then, oh, yeah, by the way, they also got Brandon Lowe, Marcell Ozuna, Ryan O'Hearn, Jake Mangum.
Like they've got all this other help.
Yeah, it's hey, it could happen.
This could be the year it all comes together.
Yeah.
Yeah.
I know.
I want to understand why I'm putting this out in her perspective, because like I don't want to say this and like lump him as like.
A prospect is he's far from that.
But the reasons I do like advancing prospects, the reasons I'm not afraid of them failing is because you learn a lot from failure.
And I think a lot of prospects can, they need to face adversity to improve.
You can't just baby and baby and baby and try to make sure that they're in the most perfect situations that come up and just hit because the likelihood is they're not.
They've never seen majorly, pitching to that level.
They've never seen a lot of this stuff.
They need to face that adversity to overcome it.
Right.
You need challenges.
So, again, I'm a big proponent of pushing people a little bit so they can face that adversity, to overcome it and move forward.
Again, oh, no, Cruz, not a prospect.
However, he certainly faced a lot of adversity last year.
by far his worst season.
And to me, what matters the most is how you overcome that.
Now, granted, like you said, you can argue it should never got to that point.
And I agree.
I think that's why a lot of us were we're hard on to know Cruz, because it just seemed as if he may have looked checked out.
Now, it doesn't necessarily mean that he's lazy.
It doesn't mean that he doesn't care to some level.
But that team sucked and it just seemed as if with the team going downhill, so did his performance in play.
This year could be a different year.
This year seems like it should be a different year.
Like you mentioned, the players is a lot of a lot of protection.
No one had a pitch to either of them because it was the worst offense in baseball.
So with a little bit more a lot of protection, that's in his favor.
and I do feel that there was some reflection, as you mentioned.
This is coming from just my perspective on things, but it was a bad year.
Does he want to be bad?
Does he want to?
he's friends with Tatis.
He's friends with Guerrero.
He's friends with all those guys on the Dominican team.
Does he want to be the cast off the guy who sucks?
do you don't like you're around your friends?
Don't you want to be part of them?
Don't you want to be as good as them?
Isn't there a little bit of like friendly competition as well?
Do you just want to be the dude that sucks while the rest are like future Hall of Famers?
there's some of that.
Like, I do feel.
Hearing things like, we mentioned like when he goes home, like I went right to work.
You're seeing that he's going to work.
He's working with Kevin Kiermaier.
He's doing certain things, right?
It does make me feel a bit different this year, like you mentioned, than past years.
That's all you have right now.
It's all we have right now.
But so far with what we have right now, that's the vibe I'm getting.
He has to put it together.
We know he has the tools.
the fact that you mentioned, I think you said this, though, but regardless, like the fact that he was like when there was a Montgomery's a pitch, like there was a lefty up there.
He wants to face them.
He wants to be challenged by lefties because that's something he knows he needs to get better at.
And so far.
He's been doing better facing lefties in spring training.
So it's like all these things that you're seeing that, encouraging for us.
We know that talent's there.
That's I think that's why we're talking about this.
We know the talent's there.
So if he's in that mindset, he's doing all the right things.
I do think the talent can translate and you can have at least a 2024 type of season, which would be very good for this team.
So, yes, again, maybe the WBC happening is also good for him because he's in that environment.
Also, again, you're seeing you're with those dudes.
It's your hometown.
There's a little bit of that pride and such, having some of that and now hitting that home run.
Like, I'm sure that really helps him, his confidence and such.
I don't know if the Oneil Cruz we hoped and imagined for the perennial five war type player is in him.
But I do think that there is a good enough player who can certainly have some highlights.
We'll have some struggles like at the end of the day will certainly be a player that can help this team win.
Yeah, that player exists because we've seen him already.
I think the one bummer of this situation with the World Baseball Classic is he's not a regular on that team.
Like he's not going to be getting regular at bats in that tournament.
He's had one so far and he's homered.
He may get, a few pinch hit appearances here and there.
But I hope it doesn't I hope it doesn't mess with just his overall timing and getting ready for the for the regular season.
I have a feeling.
It could.
But also you hope that like just the experience that he gets from being around all those guys and playing in big time baseball games and just being a part of that atmosphere.
And you hope that maybe resonates more than, not having live pitching that you're going up against every day, multiple times a day.
You hope that one outweighs the other.
Hopefully he's still, taking batting practice and things like that.
But there isn't really any substitute for just like live pitching in a baseball game.
And so he is going to go like two weeks without seeing all that much of that.
So that I guess is like my only concern is like once he gets back from this, like making sure that he's ready to roll for opening day.
Right.
And I'll say this at the very least, I feel like.
He could probably get a hit off of a 17 year old, so he's already a step ahead of Aaron Judge.
That's true.
you really put things in perspective.
He's probably much better than Aaron Judge at this point.
So that's a good point.
That is a good point.
Very much.
But anyways, yeah, I think this can absolutely be a big year for Cruz.
It's it probably is.
It needs to be some type of a big year for him.
But is there anything else that you want to talk to discuss about?
Oh, no, Cruz before moving on to the next subject.
No, it's just like he can take this.
I think if he just goes out there and he performs like regular Oneil Cruz, career right now, he's a career 100 way to runs creative.
Plus, if he goes out there and just does that, I think this team's got a shot to be pretty good.
But if he can go out there and do what we hope he can do, like 120, 125, he's never done that before.
But if he can go out and do that, then he takes his team to another level.
But especially with the stolen base threat, he's now become since last year, which seems like it's translating over to spring.
And, before we do, I want to bring this up.
And the reason I want to bring this up is, again, with him being the WBC, I didn't really get the chance to see him.
But this has been something I've noticed a bit of a talk.
So, Hamilton asks here in the chat, did Cruz put on muscle?
He looks bigger.
you're seeing him, I'm sure, a bit up close to some level.
Do you think that is the case?
Did he look bigger?
I feel like he's always been just a big dude.
I don't, after seeing him up close, I don't, I didn't notice anything different.
I think he's just, I think he's in good shape, whereas like the grind of a regular season can certainly take some off of that.
But I don't, I don't think there's much of a difference in his physical conditioning from like this year to last.
Just based off personal observations.
Yeah.
And that's what I want to ask, because I will only be seeing it the same way everyone else asking sees it as well.
Awesome.
All right.
Well, then let's move over to our next topic.
Before we do, I'll tell you a little bit about the sponsor of the show.
So, Defer is a family and employed and owned operated business.
They believe that coffee and tea are one of life's simplest and most accessible pleasures.
And when enjoyed, thoughtfully can open your eyes to the here and now.
They have five locations across the city of Pittsburgh, including their flagship in the heart of Pittsburgh's historic Strip District.
Don't forget to stop by Defer's new location, downtown on Penn Avenue, right across from the Benetton.
Grab a cup and fuel up on your walk to PNC Park.
Mobile ordering is available.
Check out their Instagram for more details.
And of course, if you go to the defer.coffee.
Jim, tell everyone how they can save 30%.
Yeah, go to the defer.coffee, load up your cart, NS930.
Use that promo code and you'll get 30% off everything you buy.
There it is.
Absolutely.
All right.
Next topic.
Talking about guys who could have a big year this year.
again, we know the talk is an extension happening.
Is he going to be on opening day roster?
How good is he going to be?
we see all the comps.
All he does is hit home runs, apparently.
So, we got to not bring him up because of his batting average.
Yeah, man.
I guess it's like, what's your vibe overall?
And especially with Ben talking yesterday, do you think this kid is going to be starting on opening day or not?
Man, that's a loaded question.
I still don't know.
And.
First off, I just want to say.
Let me ask you.
Let me say this.
I think, I think if the Pirates started Konnor Griffin at shortstop opening day, he would be ready to go.
Like, if you're asking me, is Konnor Griffin major league ready?
I think the answer to that question is yes.
Now, that's with, what, 100-ish plate appearances above high A.
And, Ben Cherington mentioned this yesterday in his press conference, how, like, yeah, like, he's impressive.
He's an impressive kid.
You also have to remember, he's 19.
He's played in 21 games above high A.
98 plate appearances above high A.
So, 98 double A plate appearances.
Zero triple A.
that's three weeks.
He's played three weeks in double A.
So, you do need to take a step back and just assess this, like, are you putting Konnor Griffin in the best position by putting him at shortstop on opening day?
And I think that's a debate.
Like, you could, you, I think either side of that debate, like, holds merit right now.
Like, there is, I'm as much a proponent of, like, getting your, getting your studs to the majors as quick as possible.
But, like, even I can look at this and say, man, this is fast.
Like, it's really fast.
And Major League Baseball is a whole other animal as opposed to the Eastern League, right?
It's a different animal as opposed to the International League, and he hasn't even played there yet.
We've seen players over the last five years make that jump from the minors to the majors, and it hasn't worked out very well.
It's a big jump.
So, can he do it?
Does it put him in the best position to do it right now?
I'm not really sure what the answer to that question is.
And I don't know.
What I do know is that just based off of what I've seen of him, what I've heard of him, is if the Pirates wanted to make that jump and put him on that opening day roster at 19 years old, I think he could do it.
I think he could do it.
I don't think it would clearly be a it would clearly be a challenge for him, but I think he's mature enough on the field, off the field, however you want to put it.
I think he's mature enough that leap is possible for a guy like Konnor Griffin.
And there's not too many people you can say that's possible for.
But I do think that if the Pirates were like, you know what, Connor, you're the opening day shortstop, it's something that he could handle.
And I think he could handle the struggles that come with Major League Baseball at a young age and be able to make adjustments, learn on the fly and just continue to become a better baseball player.
He's an impressive individual, like I said, both on and off the field.
He I don't know if there's a moment that's too big for him necessarily.
Like he's.
He's.
He's.
He's impressive.
And if there if there was a guy that you were going to put in this situation.
Like he's the guy.
Like he's the guy that's it that is it I for one to go back to go back to all the years talking about prospects again, I would much rather have them up.
To face adversity, if you feel and understand where I'm coming from, like, I'm not like, I don't think they're ready.
So I want to push them up there to face it.
You know what?
Like, there's also like, OK, I think he can come up here and do something right.
Like, they're not just totally below the level, like, I understand he's only had three weeks in AAA, but he dominated it, like if he struggled there, I'm sorry, in AA, if he struggled in AA, I wouldn't just be like, all right, we'll just push him like he's ready, like whatever.
Like, he's dominated everywhere he's been.
So.
Adversity is some of the best teachers out there, the struggles are some of the best teachers out there.
I always will talk about that.
You haven't had any adversity.
Maybe sometimes you need to face some of the adversity to get better.
And is Connor going to see what he needs, even in AAA?
Like, that's where we're at.
Like, is he even going to see in AAA what's going to prepare him for the major leagues?
That's a fair question, you know?
So, there's that part of it.
I agree with everything that you mentioned as well.
I think physically, you talk about on and off the field.
I want to word it this way.
Physically, he has all the tools.
He's exactly where he needs to be in my mind that he can handle major league as well.
it's just funny.
Like, last year, when he was just 18, I think our biggest takeaway from spring training, and we've talked about it, was just he doesn't look like a kid.
This is a man child.
Like, our first impression of Connor was, oh, my God.
Like, that's not an 18-year-old kid at all.
And now, a year later, this is a 6'4 tight end who's playing shortstop.
physically, he's mature.
I think the tools stand out that he's matured as well.
everything that you, I don't want to say worried about, but it's like, okay, if Connor's going to succeed, he needs to clean these things up.
And we saw that after, week one of the season last year.
He's done all the things that you would imagine that you would need to do.
I think it only, I think it only comes down to mentally.
Is he capable of doing it?
And that's where I think Connor sets himself apart from a lot of people is, again, my perspective, what you hear, none of us know Connor that's well, personally, in a sense.
But he carries himself differently.
when you're getting comped to, like, Willie Mays and all this, there's a lot of pressure on this kid.
And he seems to handle it quite well.
And at 19, when Paul Skenes's is talking about your maturity, that says a lot.
So I'm with you in the sense that I'm okay to some level on either side, because it's, to some level, it's very much like the Paul Skenes situation.
like, we were fine with Paul Skenes's not starting an opening day.
Like, I can make sense of it.
And I can make sense of this one as well.
So maybe just let him relax a little bit.
Take some of that pressure off.
Like, here, go to AAA for a few weeks.
Take a breath.
You'll come up here.
Let's get you adjusted.
Let's take some of that pressure off.
I could see that.
But I also, this is a pivotal year.
And if there is a kid that can do it is you.
So you know what, kid?
Come do it.
And come earn yourself.
again, this is more for them.
But by him starting opening day, it's like they can get that draft pick if he gets rookie of the year.
Like, all the implications of this.
like, it's in the Pirates' favor to potentially start him on opening day.
I think he can handle it.
And if you think he can handle it, again, mostly mentally on that side, then go in and do it.
Just go and do it.
And I think he can.
So I'm with you.
I don't know what – I could say I think he is.
I could say not.
I don't know.
I have no idea what's going to happen.
But me personally, I would start him opening day.
Yeah, and there's actually some nuance to this as well.
Like, you brought up the PPI stuff.
Like, if you have him up, you are, allowing yourself to potentially get these rewards that come with a really good player.
Keep in mind, the PPI requirement is that they accrue 172 days of service time.
You can still do that and be sent down.
Like, he doesn't have to actually start the year on the Major League roster.
He can be called up after about two weeks.
And he still qualifies for that because he'll still be getting that full year of service time.
And you saw the Orioles did that very similar thing with Jackson Holiday a few years back where they started him in the minors.
And then before, I want to say the Orioles did it where they did it like right before that cutoff, they called him up.
Now, I think they had to send him back down because, he struggled a little bit early.
But that's how they handled that situation.
So, yeah, if you're the Pirates and you do want to be like, hey, go to Indy for a week or two, you can actually double dip here and do that and still maintain his PPI eligibility.
Again, you've got you've got roughly about two weeks there to play with.
So I could see that maybe happening.
Like you mentioned, it maybe takes a little bit of pressure off.
Hey, go to Indy.
You're playing in front of 10,000 people instead of 35, 40, 45, 50,000 people like you're going to be playing in New York on opening day.
go to Indy.
Get your swing down.
Play a few games in cold weather.
Get acclimated to it because that's the other thing, too.
He's never done that before.
He's from Mississippi and he's been playing in Bradenton, Florida, for the first parts of the season.
So, yeah, so I could see that being a thing.
Now, I'm still inclined to say, like, I think he's ready.
Like, I think he's ready.
I think he can handle it.
If you want to do that, just to, like, make sure I get it.
But if you're going to send him down and he's every bit the same guy he is in AAA as he's shown us to be in spring training, which is, one of the best hitters on this team, you got to get him up as soon as possible.
Yeah, to go back.
So, you were correct.
I just want to give a date.
Yeah, it was April 10th when Jackson Holiday made his actual debut.
And you are.
they did send him down.
I think a lot of people were shocked.
But then it was it was right back up to ensure that he was in line to for all the PPI stuff.
And again, like if the Pirates go that route also, like I would be OK with it.
Again, it's understandable.
I am not going to hammer the Pirates for not starting the 19-year-old who has exactly just one year of professional baseball under his belt opening day.
But it's got to be quick.
Like this also can't be like we're home down till June because of all these reasons.
Like also, and again, I don't think they're going to.
But, that this is where I would be upset in hammering the Pirates if it's like, well, we've learned from Paul Skenes.
So we have to hold him down till like July because he could still win rookie of the year if we do it in May or June.
So, that's where I'm going to fight.
If it's April 10th, he comes up or even if, which, again, I'll give some pushback.
Like, why did you wait this long?
Even as the end of April.
I can understand starting him off in AAA.
I just disagree that he needs to be started off in AAA.
Much like I understood why Paul Skenes didn't start opening day.
I just disagree.
He probably could and should have.
Yeah, I think skeins is a totally different situation, too, because he's a pitcher and like he had an innings limit.
Like, I don't really compare the two too much.
I think a lot of it, too.
Like, hey, there's still two more weeks of spring training.
Like.
If Konnor Griffin does over these next two weeks what he did the first two weeks, let's say he finishes spring with six homers and an OPS over a thousand.
I don't I don't I don't know how you can send them down like you're a team.
Batting average is two thirty.
Right.
Yeah.
you're a team who is coming off this historically bad offensive season.
And if he can be one of your best hitters on the team, then like you that makes the decision a lot harder for me is like if he if he keeps this up, if he keeps hitting the ball hard, he's hitting the ball harder than anybody on the team right now.
And he's 19 years old, he leads the team in homers.
If that continues through spring.
Like, just do it.
Just do it.
I'll wait to.
So I said there's still two weeks left.
We'll see what we'll see how that goes.
But right now, I have I guess before it was more.
Like, can he do it?
Like, is he in a position where you can do this?
I think the answer is, yes, he can do it.
It's just is it going to be best for him now?
And Ben said the same thing this weekend was like he's an impressive individual.
If there's anybody who can do it's him.
But like, is it best for him?
And I think I think where things stand right now.
If you're if you're like making me decide, is it best for him?
Sure.
Yeah.
Like, I think I think it is.
I think it is.
Ask me again next week in the week after.
But I think right now I'm going to go ahead and say, yeah.
All right.
Love it.
Well, let's go ahead and get on to our last subject here.
Talk about some battles.
Before we do, we'll hear from our sponsors again.
This episode is brought to you by IQ Bar, our exclusive snack hydration and sponsor.
IQ Bar protein bars, IQ Mix hydration mixes, and IQ Joe mushroom coffees are the delicious, low sugar brain and body fuel you need to win your day.
The Ultimate Sampler Pack is a great way for you to try all IQ Bar products and flavors.
You get nine IQ Bars, eight IQ Mix Sticks, and four IQ Joe Sticks.
All IQ Bar products are clean label certified and entirely free from gluten, dairy, soy, GMOs, and artificial ingredients.
With over 20,000 five-star reviews and counting, more people than ever are fueling their lifestyles with IQ Bar's brain and body boosting bars, hydration mixes, and mushroom coffees.
The Ultimate Sampler Pack includes all three.
My personal favorites so far have been the almond butter chip and the iced tea lemonade hydration mix.
It's just really full of flavor.
I love starting my day with it.
And I couldn't imagine starting my day with anything else other than IQ Bar products.
Right now, IQ Bar is offering our podcast listeners 20% off all IQ Bar products, including the Ultimate Sampler Pack, plus free shipping.
To get your 20% off, text MLB to 64000.
That's MLB 64000.
Message and data rates may apply.
See terms for details.
So now we have this battle going on.
Again, with the fifth starter, that's been prominent.
We've been talking about that, down there.
And also, like, with that being said, it seems like everyone who's in that battle for the fifth starter is doing well, is doing what they need.
It's making it that much more challenging and tough to separate.
And then there's some position battles as well.
obviously, if Konnor Griffin starts, I think that settles and helps out some situations.
But if not, how deep are you carrying infielders?
Is there, this fifth outfielder spot and such?
I think some guys that we're looking at is, like, Nick Yorke, Billy Cook, the newly acquired Tyler Callihan.
Let me talk about him to some level.
But, and again, I'll separate Callihan because he's recently acquired.
But so far, they're all maybe not as, maybe not so level as the guys are battling for the fifth starter.
But guys battling for this roster on the hitting side, they're all doing a bit of a departure to say, like, hey, maybe add me, maybe make me the guy.
Yeah, there's still, I think what's nice about this is, like, they're, the battles for roster spots are, they're not necessarily your, like, super important pieces, right?
we're talking about, like, the last two bench players, right?
We're talking about the number five starter.
We're talking about some bullpen arms.
And yeah, like, so far, every, like, the Pirates are having a really good spring training just as a whole.
And everyone who's competing for a job is doing, like, exactly what you want them to do.
But even like this, like even Mike Clevenger, I think a lot of us was like, eh, whatever.
But, you know what?
He's solid.
the swing and miss stuff's there.
The velocity's there.
He wasn't one time a really good pitcher with Cleveland.
even as close as a couple years ago, he had some, a solid season.
maybe Mike Clevenger adds to that as well.
So, I think there are some options for this fifth starter that allow, the ideal person who's going to be the best of that Hunter Barco to be down there in the minors to monitor those innings.
And you can get by with either Arquidy and or Clevenger in the meantime.
So, that way, like this fifth starter isn't much of a pressing issue.
It's funny.
It's funny because we had this debate on NS9 Live, I feel like, a month ago.
And I was like, you have to.
and you're like, I think the depth is there.
And the way I feel with Clevenger and Arquidy right now in camp, maybe the depth is there.
because, again, you're not relying on those two to win you anything.
You just need an arm, essentially, that's capable.
And I think they're showing that they could be capable to this point.
I know it's early, but health seems to be on both of their sides at this point in time.
And, again, what's nice with Clevenger is you're starting to see some of that swing and miss stuff with him in camp.
So, I think I'm okay at this point in time with whoever gets the fifth starter role and Barco being in the minors.
Yeah, I'm not really moving from my stance and thinking that, like, they have to go out there and get somebody.
I think it would just be, it would be a little bit better.
I haven't been super impressed with Mike Clevenger, to be honest with you.
I think the stuff looks a little good, but he's walking a lot of people and the command seems to be off.
And he still also hasn't been able to get anyone out for a couple of years now.
So, I'm going to take that over eight innings of spring training.
Urquidy's a little bit different for me in that, like, he's had past success in the season.
He's just been injured the last two years.
Like, it's not like Urquidy's just been healthy and awful the past couple of seasons.
He's been hurt and hasn't played.
Whereas Clevenger has been healthy and awful, right?
So, like, Clevenger's going to have to do a whole lot more to impress me in spring training than Urquidy.
Yeah, there's a question here, too, where, like, would we, would I feel any different if there was maybe just another lefty in this rotation?
Like, if Braxton Axtracht just threw left-handed, would we be, would we be fine?
And I think, yeah, like, I do like having a lefty in there.
Like, I don't, I know it's not necessary.
Like, you don't, it's not, like, and it doesn't really make a whole lot of sense.
Like, you're a new team every day.
I think for me, it's just, like, if you're going to go out there and you're going to find a guy, a lefty makes sense because they overperform a PNC part, typically.
So, you can usually get pretty good value there.
But, yeah, I think right now I'm okay with where their pitching is at.
The depth is a little, I think the depth is there.
Like, I think it's good enough to get them through as long as long as the top of that rotation stays healthy.
Like, if the top of the rotation is staying healthy and you're able to get 30 starts out of those guys, then that fifth starter can just, like I said, it can just be a guy.
So, I'm good with where they're at right now.
I would welcome another pitcher with open arms if they wanted to bring somebody in.
But, I, yeah, I haven't really changed my thought process and, like, they're, I think they're okay where they're at.
All fair.
I'll say this, though.
I haven't talked about, we haven't talked about Tyler Callihan either.
So, if you want to just mention him real quick.
Well, I want to go to the hitting side of things.
Yeah.
Yeah.
For sure.
Yeah.
He's a guy who I've seen a little bit in the, just being in a Reds minor league town.
I've been able to watch him very sparingly.
But, like, when watching Louisville play, it was pretty clear that Tyler Callihan was one of the better players on that team when he was here.
I'm not sure if he's necessarily going to make this team.
I think this is, I think this has gotten to be a pretty interesting position battle now.
The one thing that's almost going against him is you want some righty bats on that bench because your lineup is super lefty heavy.
so, like, would you, like, cause right now I feel like Callihan is in a direct battle with Nick Yorke, or, and, or Joe Simpson Garcia, or depending on what they do here with Konnor Griffin.
Like, yeah, if Konnor Griffin's the starting shortstop, then Callihan probably makes this team.
I think, I don't think they're going to keep Garcia around as a fifth outfielder.
so yeah, I think, I think right now, actually, I think right now in either scenario, I think Callihan's probably on this team.
I think Callihan's on this team.
He's versatile.
He can play a lot of different positions.
He's got some power.
His swing should play fairly well at PNC park.
and if you look at him versus the other left-handed bench option that you have in, and Manuel Valdez, like I'd like Callihan better than Valdez defensively and offensively.
Like, I want to be fair.
I don't know that much about Callihan to have like this real formidable opinion on like who I truly like better.
but I guess I look at this in my mind too.
Like I feel like if Connor does start in triple a Callihan is on the team, I think that's where it definitely comes into play, cause it just makes the most sense.
Like you just, you shift, triolo to shortstop, maybe Callihan's playing third, in that meantime, cause I'd rather have him there.
I think that Nick Yorke now Nick Gonzales is like an argument.
But maybe then therefore that's why Callihan's on the bench at that point in time.
if Connor does make the team, I think then it's like, is it Nick Yorke you'd rather have or Callihan on the bench?
And I don't know, like, honestly, I don't know.
I feel like I would prefer somebody else than Nick Yorke to be on the bench, but I'm not here to tell you like, it's that's Tyler Callihan.
It could be, it could be.
but as you mentioned too, like is the righty lefty, a difference maker or not?
Nick Yorke so far offensively having a solid spring, one of my takeaways from seeing Nick Yorke is it's not that he's going to hit 20 plus home runs.
Right.
But it seems to be hit the ball harder than I expected.
the ball's coming off the bat.
Yeah.
pretty well, the numbers reflect that, but it's not like he's dinking and dunking his way to, those numbers are like, and the one against Columbia, like he had us, he smoked the ball to center field and just got robbed.
Great catch.
so he's in the ball pretty well, defensively, not so good.
That my takeaway defensively, not so great.
so what does that, what does that mean?
I don't really know.
I don't think he's blown anyone away, defensive wise, it's not like you're like a tree.
Although he's belongs to the major cause that glove is going to play, like Nick Yorke, I feel like you're going to have to hit to some level to do so.
So, I don't know how, I don't, I'm not here to tell you that Callihan is a great glove either great bat, but with Nick Yorke, he's hitting the ball a little bit better than I anticipated.
He would, but it's still in my, like my eyes, Nick Yorke, I would prefer something better.
So if Tyler Callihan is that guy, I'm perfectly okay with it.
Yeah.
I think that's all fair.
this is certainly, like I said, a position battle though.
Like he's definitely in the mix here for a bench spot.
And I said, if you don't know a whole lot about him, he can play left field, he can play third base, he can play second base, he can play first base.
he can also play right field.
He hasn't really done that, but, he could definitely play corner outfield.
So, someone you can plug into a few different positions.
there certainly is some power there.
The hit tool isn't outstanding.
Like there's going to be some swing and miss here, but he's got, he's got a little bit of pop.
and yeah, I feel like just the swing, the swing plays well.
I've seen him hit like nukes before, I guess.
And, so that's something that's something now who was in the minors off of triple A pitching, but I've, I have seen it happen.
in my, in my very limited time scouting Tyler Callihan, he stood out when it came to the Reds triple A baseball club.
And I guess to be fair about this, a player who cannot hit nukes is Kyle Nicholas.
So all fair.
Good point.
Also, Kyle Nicholas blew up against great Britain yesterday.
I didn't even notice that.
Did he did the, did the Kyle Nicholas thing, walk a bunch of people, gave up two runs.
Yeah.
I'll say this.
it's, I wish it would have worked out.
Kyle Nicholas's stuff is awesome.
The slider.
we've talked about the slider a lot where like it grades out as one of the best pitches on the entire team.
It's just, there's always, there's always something with them where like, he just can't find the strike zone.
And you did see him put it a little bit together towards the end of last year where he put like a few outings in a row, like stacked really good outings.
so it sucks.
He's now in the division.
So hopefully he never throws another strike again, like just all balls from this point forward and just walks every pirate he faces for the rest of his career.
There it is.
Yeah.
I was going to say it's all perspective.
If it sucks or not, it could be very good.
Thanks.
Yeah.
yeah, I said my piece about the trade and such, but now Tyler Callihan is in here.
I think he's certainly in that mix, but ultimately, Nick Yorke's doing his thing.
And I think maybe Billy Cook could provide almost like the Hunter Barco thing.
It's like, you want Garcia to have every day at bats.
And I brought this scenario, I think, cause like we're talking about behind the scenes, like the Doug and such.
And like, I felt like if no, this isn't a jinx, please don't make this happen.
But like, I felt like if Ryan O'Hearn went down for an extended period of time, I feel like, you know what?
Garcia coming up makes a lot of sense.
Cause he'll get every day at bats.
He is performing well this off, this spring and such.
So maybe he's ready.
we're talking about that, but because I felt like, okay, he's the plug and play.
You put him in left field or right field or whatever.
I feel like if Jake Mangum got hurt, maybe like a Billy Cook makes sense in that regards, because you're probably not playing every day with Garcia.
You still want to maybe down there.
So Billy Cook is still somewhat important in this.
And so far he's having a productive spring.
So that's how I looked at it.
So to bring up Billy Cook's, name here, I don't think he's really in the running for opening day, but I think those like the scenarios I'm looking at or Billy Cook could come up before Garcia.
Even because I think Garcia makes the most sense.
Like he's next man up, but like, if maybe your fourth outfielder gets hurt, like a Mangum, maybe cook makes more sense at that point of time.
If it's April.
Yeah, I could see that.
I could see that.
Yeah.
And right now, like the good news is that everyone seems to be performing.
And again, it's spring training, so it's hard to, it's really hard to distinguish any of this because especially some of these guys like Billy Cook's been getting a lot of innings against He's been getting a lot of playing time against like the back end guys.
And so who's to know how good any of these guys are.
Comments· 0
Should Konnor Griffin be the Pirates' Opening Day shortstop at 19?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.