◆NEWS2026 Non-Tenders: National League◆ROSTERRHP Noah Murdock elected free agency◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSPlayers Avoiding Arbitration Prior To The 2026 Non-Tender Deadline◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers
◆NEWS2026 Non-Tenders: National League◆ROSTERRHP Noah Murdock elected free agency◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSPlayers Avoiding Arbitration Prior To The 2026 Non-Tender Deadline◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers
Jhostynxon “The Password” Garcia is starting to make real noise in the Pirates’ system. Jim and Anthony Murphy break down his power surge, defensive value, center-field ability, and how he could fit into Pittsburgh’s 2026 outfield plans. Is he a fourth outfielder or something more?
Watch or listen to the full Bucs On Deck episode now.
Comments· 0
The Debate
Should the Pirates call up Jhostynxon Garcia now to take lefty at-bats away from Jake Mangum and Billy Cook?
From Jim Rosati’s take on the show
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.
With Jim Rosati and Anthony Murphy.
Chapters
Key takeaways
1
Jhostynxon Garcia's three homers came off left-handers, and that's his ticket: to carve out a big-league role he has to be a reliable outfield glove who hits lefties.
Jim Rosati
2
Spencer Horwitz doesn't play against lefties. Instead of running Jake Mangum or Billy Cook out against a southpaw, the 2026 Pirates should use Garcia, who has a 1.700 OPS against lefties this year.
Jim Rosati
3
Even though ZiPS sees only a below-average bat (.684 OPS this year), Garcia's floor is high: he'll be a major leaguer at minimum, as a fourth outfielder who can platoon at all three spots.
Jim Rosati
4
A rival-team scout thinks the worries about Garcia's contact rates are a bit overblown. They're still a concern, but manageable enough for him to carve out a role in the majors.
Jim Rosati
5
Prediction: give him about a week after the rehab stint to show he's ready, and Garcia is in the majors within the next month.
Good morning, everybody. Welcome to North Shore Nine podcast presented by FanDuel. This is your weekly installment of Bucs On Deck. I'm Jim. Joining me today is Anthony Murphy from Bucs On Deck. Murphy, you're in Bradenton right now, huh? On location.
Jim Rosati
Yeah. On location. Taking in a lot of baseball the last couple of days.
Jim Rosati
Well, I appreciate you taking, 15 minutes out of your busy schedule to talk about the password. Jhostynxon Garcia is who we're going to talk about, this week. He is, 23 years old, acquired from Boston over the off season. He was in the Yohan Oviedo trade. he started the season off in Indianapolis, was injured, had some time down in Bradenton on his rehab,
Jim Rosati
hit the ball really well there. He's back in Indianapolis. I just saw him earlier this week, hit three homers and three at bats Murphy, which I don't know if I've ever seen that before from anyone, at any level. So that was pretty fun. So it was like, yeah, you know what, let's talk about the password this week. And, yeah, why don't, why don't we give a little bit of rundown on Jhostynxon Garcia and who he is?
Jim Rosati
Yeah. outfielder acquired from the, Red Sox and the Yohan Oviedo trade, big physical guy.
Jim Rosati
I think when I first saw him, it's like, I just thought he was like a corner outfield, big power hidden guy, but then, you dig into it and like, there's some speed there. There's great defense in center field. So just like a physical type of player, who can do a little bit of everything.
Jim Rosati
You mentioned, and I think when you acquire somebody like this and someone who like, looks like this a bigger guy, he's, he looks like he's someone who can punish a baseball. Right. But then you dive a little bit deeper and you're like, Oh, this guy can play center field and he can do it quite well. He can move around. He can play all three outfield spots. He hits the ball hard. It's he's more of a complete player.
Jim Rosati
He's more of a player than I thought he was when the pirates originally acquired him at the time of the trade. I was a little iffy on the acquisition. I was like, you know what? Overall, this seems like a pretty decent baseball trade, but there's still a lot of question marks in Joe Simpson Garcia's game. one of which is like, he's, he chases a lot. he chases a lot. He swings and misses, more than you would like him to see.
Jim Rosati
but I think the positive here is even if he can't reach his ceiling offensively, the ability to play good defense at three different positions, be able to man center field and do it quite capably. it provides him a pretty high floor.
Jim Rosati
Yeah, absolutely. And I think we, I think we've seen as we've watched the pirates this year, just how valuable, good outfield defense can be, cause there's been times where we haven't exactly seen the best outfield defense for, so having someone who has the baseline of going out there and being able to provide above average defense.
Jim Rosati
And even if like the average isn't great, cause he goes out of the zone a lot, there's a lot of raw power there that where he does get ahold of one. Like he certainly has the ability to put it over the fence. And I think the best thing about the power is like, he's being able to show the power over, like he can hit the ball over the fence, any part of the field.
Jim Rosati
Like he uses all parts of the field. So yeah. Yeah. Absolutely crushed. And he had a rough start to the season. let's start there. Our first look at him was in spring training this year. And I liked what I saw out of him in spring training. And it really just came down to like, I think he was, he was competing for a spot on this team during spring training, but it came down to, Hey, like, what would you rather have?
Jim Rosati
Would you rather have Garcia as a fourth or fifth outfielder, playing sparingly because the pirates have three outfielders that you pretty much have to play every day. So, and a full-time DH. So they're like, there really wasn't a whole lot of room for Joe Simpson Garcia. but in spring training, he was impressive. he had a four Oh five average. He had an OPS, over a thousand, 180 weighted runs created plus he hit two homers. He stole three bases. He was just like
Jim Rosati
doing everything. He goes to triple A and just everything we saw in spring training just like, wasn't there. just started off the year really cold. comes out that he had a back issue. So, he gets put on the IL. He goes to Bradenton for a week, on a rehab assignment and down in Bradenton. It was like he had never
Jim Rosati
left spring training. He just started, he was crushing the ball again, which you would hope of, he's a fringy top 100 prospect. You would hope, 23 years old going to the Florida state league that he's going down there and mashing, but that's exactly what he did. he, in his week on rehab, he had an OPS over 1200.
Jim Rosati
Yeah. It was just, you get the feeling that maybe like how you wonder how much like the back, the back thing was playing into maybe to slow start, maybe it'd been lingering or even maybe it just came down to him. Like maybe.
Jim Rosati
Was hoping to make the team out of camp and he didn't make the team out of camp. So maybe he was pressing a little bit to be like, Hey, don't forget about me, even though I'm here in AAA thing. So it could have, it felt like it could have been like any combination of a bunch of things. Cause once he came back from the injured list, he's just been.
Jim Rosati
Seeing exactly why the pirates, acquired him in that in a trade for an arm that they clearly liked. Cause they acquired, Oviedo and another trade previously.
Jim Rosati
Yeah. Since coming back to Indianapolis. So as I saw him, his first game back, he went five for five with three homers and his first three at bats, that raised his OPS in the, like 250.
Jim Rosati
Points just in one game. So he's on the right, he's on the right track. I'll say this, like the three homers were, they were impressive. just all of them crushed. and what was, what was interesting is they were off of left-handed pitchers, which is something where I think if he's going to carve out a role in the majors, like that's gotta be it.
Jim Rosati
It's gotta be this guy who you can rely on to put in the outfield play competent outfield defense, but like, he's gotta hit left-handed pitching.
Jim Rosati
I think in order to like really carve out a role.
Jim Rosati
Yeah. And I, and I think you saw, like you mentioned with like them adding like a Ozuna and now they have like a full-time DH so that made things let the picture a lot less clear, but you saw a path to some playing time out of camp beforehand.
Jim Rosati
Like, with Cruz's clear struggles with lefties and stuff like that going into the year, it's like, okay, well maybe there's a scenario to where you can platoon Garcia there in center against lefties and then, get him some time in the corners on other days.
Jim Rosati
But then like they sign a Ozuna. So there's like one less spot. And then like Cruz comes out and like, he's mashing lefties now all of a sudden.
Jim Rosati
So it's like, okay, well we don't really need a platoon guy. And so now it's, now it's just like, okay, well we, now there's even less at bats to go around.
Jim Rosati
So let's just get him as much playing time as possible.
Jim Rosati
This episode is brought to you by IQ bar, our exclusive snack hydration and sponsor IQ bar, protein bars, IQ mix, hydration mixes, and IQ Joe mushroom coffees are the delicious low sugar brain and body fuel.
Jim Rosati
You need to win your day. The ultimate sampler pack is a great way for you to try all IQ bar products and flavors.
Jim Rosati
You get nine IQ bars, eight IQ mix sticks, and four IQ Joe sticks.
Jim Rosati
All IQ bar products are clean label certified and entirely free from gluten, dairy, soy, GMOs, and artificial ingredients.
Jim Rosati
With over 20,000 five-star reviews and counting, more people than ever are fueling their lifestyles with IQ bars, brain and body boosting bars, hydration mixes, and mushroom coffees.
Jim Rosati
The ultimate sampler pack includes all three.
Jim Rosati
My personal favorites so far have been the almond butter chip and the iced tea lemonade hydration mix.
Jim Rosati
It's just really full of flavor.
Jim Rosati
I love starting my day with it, and I couldn't imagine starting my day with anything else other than IQ bar products.
Jim Rosati
Right now IQ bar is offering our podcast listeners 20% off all IQ bar products, including the ultimate sampler pack, plus free shipping.
Jim Rosati
To get your 20% off, text MLB to 64,000.
Jim Rosati
That's MLB 64000.
Jim Rosati
Message and data rates may apply.
Jim Rosati
See terms for details.
Jim Rosati
Yeah.
Jim Rosati
I'll say this.
Jim Rosati
he's in AAA now.
Jim Rosati
If he can show that he's healthy and he can hit left-handed pitchers really well, which this year so far, the splits are outstanding.
Jim Rosati
I was looking at this because I was curious heading into this podcast because I feel like this is going to be a big part of whether or not Joe Simpson Garcia is just going to be your average fourth or fifth outfielder, or if he can be something bigger than that.
Jim Rosati
Last year against lefties, OPS of 857, there really wasn't a crazy split between righties and lefties.
Jim Rosati
He slugged lefties a little bit more than righties, but he hit them at a similar clip.
Jim Rosati
This year, I know it's super limited playing time, but he's got a 1700 OPS against left-handed pitching right now.
Jim Rosati
He's hitting 529, so that's the thing I want to keep an eye on with Garcia is can you continue to mash lefties, and if so, this is where he can make an immediate impact to the 2026 Pittsburgh Pirates because you brought up Oneil Cruz who's hitting lefties now.
Jim Rosati
So, yeah, you don't really need a platoon for Oneil Cruz, but Spencer Horwitz doesn't play against lefties.
Jim Rosati
Ryan O'Hearn has been hitting lefties just fine this season, but this is the opportunity where, okay, now instead of having to play Jake Mangum or Billy Cook against a lefty, what if you had this guy who could crush lefties, and his name was Joe Simpson Garcia?
Jim Rosati
So, I think this is where Garcia can really carve out a role on the 2026 Pirates.
Jim Rosati
Absolutely, and I think you, obviously we're seeing a lot more power from this lineup this season, but imagine someone who still has, injecting another guy who has the potential to, at his best probably hit 20 to 25 home runs too, has that power.
Jim Rosati
So, you add that into the mix as well, and that just adds even more depth to the lineup.
Jim Rosati
Yeah.
Jim Rosati
We talked a little bit about his defense before.
Jim Rosati
Like I said, that looks good.
Jim Rosati
Do you have any idea why, so one question that I had for you is when the Pirates acquired Garcia in December, he was a top 100 prospect on MLB Pipeline.
Jim Rosati
Now he's nowhere to be seen on top 100 lists.
Jim Rosati
What happened?
Jim Rosati
Like, what's the concern here?
Jim Rosati
Because, like, there was some pretty good prospect hype with Joe Simpson Garcia, like, towards the end of last year.
Jim Rosati
He actually debuted with the Red Sox last season for about a week or so.
Jim Rosati
Like, what changed with his prospect status here?
Jim Rosati
I think a lot of it came down to, like, the swing and miss once he got into, like, the chase once he got into the upper levels.
Jim Rosati
Because, like, the zone contact rate and the contact rates weren't really, like, ideal.
Jim Rosati
And it pointed towards, like, a below average hit tool.
Jim Rosati
And I think once you start talking, and then I think what it comes down to probably at that point is how you feel about him in the outfield.
Jim Rosati
If there are any concerns at all about him being in center field, which I haven't, I don't see anything that makes me say that, like, he can't play center field.
Jim Rosati
But then, even in, so, like, swing the contact rates, and, you mentioned, like, a platoon-ish type of guy.
Jim Rosati
And, he's on the wrong side of the platoon thing there, too.
Jim Rosati
So, if there's thought that he could be, like, a platoon or a part-time guy going forward, then that generally dings you pretty hard on prospect list.
Jim Rosati
Yeah.
Jim Rosati
I'll say this, like, Zip's three-year projections, they don't love them, but they don't necessarily hate them.
Jim Rosati
Like, they look at him as a fourth outfielder, a 684 OPS this year, which is below average, 707 OPS in 2027 at age 24, which is still below average, and then a 724 OPS in 2028, which is pretty much average.
Jim Rosati
So, there's not a, the projection systems don't see a lot of upside here, but at the same time, like, he's, they also have him over one war in each of those seasons.
Jim Rosati
So, again, I think, I think we're dealing with someone with a relatively high floor.
Jim Rosati
Like, I think he's going to be a major leaguer at a minimum.
Jim Rosati
He's a fourth outfielder who can platoon and can play all three outfield spots.
Jim Rosati
It's really going to come down to, like you mentioned, can he make enough contact and can he generate enough power to be an everyday player?
Jim Rosati
If he can do that, if he can, like, be that third outfielder, because I say even now, even a corner outfield, like you plug him into a corner, you're still probably going to want an above average hitter in that spot.
Jim Rosati
So, like, that's who he's going to have to turn into, turn into, in order to hold down that spot on a good baseball team.
Jim Rosati
Yeah, absolutely.
Jim Rosati
Absolutely.
Jim Rosati
And I think, I think this, the Pirates feel like a pretty good, I think a lot of the focus with the Pirates is, like they want, like their left-handed bats because PNC Park, favors.
Jim Rosati
But like, with the way, with Cruz and like O'Hearn and stuff like that, he's fit in perfectly to where, and like Horwitz, like you mentioned at first, he fits in perfectly to where like, he fits just perfectly in, like, I feel like on this roster as like the fourth outfielder.
Jim Rosati
And it gives, I just, I love the power potential there.
Jim Rosati
Even then at PNC Park, he's a guy who can go the opposite way and put it over the fence and stuff like that.
Jim Rosati
So, yeah, it really just comes down to like, how much he's chasing going out of the zone.
Jim Rosati
If he can somewhat keep that on there.
Jim Rosati
And I know, I talked to someone, talked to someone and, I talked to a scout for another team and they, and they felt like the contact rates thing was a tad overblown with him.
Jim Rosati
it was still like a concern, but they do, they thought it was, it was manageable enough to where it should allow him to cart a role out in the majors or at least to keep it under control.
Jim Rosati
Yeah.
Jim Rosati
So it's going to be, it's going to be interesting to see how they approach this because right now it's a matter of, how much, how much of a development do you need to give this guy?
Jim Rosati
Like how much are just every day at bats important versus like he does fit in well with this major league team.
Jim Rosati
And this is a major league team that's trying to win right now.
Jim Rosati
So do you sacrifice those every day at bats?
Jim Rosati
He could be getting in triple a to be that fourth outfielder on a good baseball team.
Jim Rosati
because yeah, they could, I think this pirates team could absolutely lose guards, could absolutely use Josephson Garcia right now.
Jim Rosati
now I wouldn't, I wouldn't give them like a week or so.
Jim Rosati
it's still after the rehab assignment to show that he's ready.
Jim Rosati
but yeah, I think we see Josephson Garcia sometime in the next month and the major leagues.
Jim Rosati
That probably wouldn't surprise me at all, especially if he keeps hitting like this, like we're just it's somebody, I feel like at some point is going to start like trying to knock the door down and be like, Hey, like get me some playing time up there.
Jim Rosati
And I think, I don't think we're too much, we can't be too far away from like some short shakeup being needed to just get things going at some point.
Jim Rosati
And who better than someone who can play above average defense outfield defense, where that's one of the been your struggles this year and also has above average to plus for all power.
Jim Rosati
Yep.
Jim Rosati
All right.
Jim Rosati
Well, that's a, that's a, that's Joe Simpson Garcia, the password.
Jim Rosati
I said, I think we'll be seeing him in Pittsburgh sometime soon, pay attention to what he's doing in AAA, off to a hot start after his rehab assignment.
Jim Rosati
So yeah, if he keeps this up, I expect to see him in black and gold fairly soon.
Jim Rosati
But, yeah, this was your week's, installment of Bucs On Deck.
Jim Rosati
I'm Jim.
Jim Rosati
That's Murphy.
Jim Rosati
I'm excited to hear back from your Bradenton trip.
Jim Rosati
I know we're going to have some fun conversations about some folks that you saw while you were down there.
Jim Rosati
and everybody can catch your work.
Jim Rosati
You've been putting out some great stuff, especially this week, on your Bucs On Deck sub stacks.
Jim Rosati
Make sure you subscribe to that if you're not.
Jim Rosati
but yeah.
Jim Rosati
Yeah.
Jim Rosati
Anything else to add Murph?
Jim Rosati
20% off a yearly subscription right now on Bucs On Deck while I'm down there.
Jim Rosati
So I usually do that on trips that I'm at.
Jim Rosati
So when I give it a shot, now's a good time to do it.
Jim Rosati
Worth every penny.
Jim Rosati
Worth every penny.
Jim Rosati
All right, Murph.
Jim Rosati
Well, I appreciate you.
Jim Rosati
we'll be back next.
Jim Rosati
We'll talk about, somebody who you saw this week.
Jim Rosati
Yeah, me too.
Jim Rosati
All right.
Jim Rosati
I'll catch you guys later.
Jim Rosati
Like the video, subscribe to the page, leave a review, all that good stuff.
Comments· 0
Should the Pirates call up Jhostynxon Garcia now to take lefty at-bats away from Jake Mangum and Billy Cook?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.