◆NEWS2026 Non-Tenders: National League◆ROSTERRHP Noah Murdock elected free agency◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSPlayers Avoiding Arbitration Prior To The 2026 Non-Tender Deadline◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers
◆NEWS2026 Non-Tenders: National League◆ROSTERRHP Noah Murdock elected free agency◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSPlayers Avoiding Arbitration Prior To The 2026 Non-Tender Deadline◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers
This is getting old. Pirates rally twice just to lose to the Cardinals in a 9-6 wild affair in 10 innings. This makes the Pirates losing streak four games and drops them to 0-5 versus the Cardinals this season. Mitch Keller was pulled with two outs in the 6th inning at 83 pitches and Evan Sisk immediately served up the go-ahead home run to Nolan Gorman. The Pirates fall to .500 now with a 24-24 record. DiNardo and Doug break this one down on the NS9 Postgame Show powered by Primanti’s Bros. You can watch/listen here:
I tweeted this out before first pitch: “Let’s see how much fight this team has.” And despite the loss, I will give them credit that they battled back twice. After being lifeless against Matthew Liberatore through four innings, they got to him in the 5th inning for four runs and chased him from the game which was so satisfying to see. And then after the bullpen blew it again, the Pirates lineup came through again to score two runs in the 9th inning to tie the game and force extras. The overall result was still a loss, but I do like how they showed fight and the offense did produce and bounce back after being shutout the past two games against the Phillies.
The bats outhit the Cardinals 12 hits to 9, but the difference was the Cardinals hit four home runs and the Pirates hit none. In fact, they only had one extra-base hit—Bryan Reynolds big two-RBI double in the 5th inning to tie the game for the Pirates. That was a huge hit, but the Pirates needed one more to come through in this one.
Don Kelly had a couple questionable decisions in this loss. The first one was in the bottom of the 6th inning when Mitch Keller got Jordan Walker to pop out for the second out and one on, Kelly decided to pull Keller at 83 pitches. He went with the lefty lefty matchup and called on Evan Sisk to face Nolan Gorman. Well, Gorman took him deep of course. Last week, Kelly stayed with his starter and it burned him and naturally he makes the move Tuesday night and it doesn’t work out either. That’s the kind of stuff that just happens against the Cardinals. I won’t crucify him for this decision as much, but you know me…my starting pitcher is only at 83 pitches and has been pitching fine since early in the game, he’s not laboring and my bullpen has shown that aren’t very good in high leverage lately…I’m going to just stick with my starter to get through the inning. Kelly thought differently and Sisk let him down with the go-ahead home run to Gorman.
Then there’s the 9th inning. Cardinals closer Riley O’Brien is melting down. Nick Gonzales leads off with a single, then O’Brien hits Konnor Griffin and Bryan Reynolds with the pitch to load the bases with no outs. Marcell Ozuna is up. Ozuna hasn’t been good all season. He was 0-for-2 to this point. Why not pinch hit for him here and bring Spencer Horwitz to bat? Instead, Kelly doesn’t make the move and Ozuna grounds into a double play. A run scores but now there’s two outs. Oneil Cruz works a walk on a great at-bat and then Kelly bring Horwitz off the bench to pinch hit for Jhostynxon Garcia. Horwitz comes through with an RBI single to tie it, but just think it he singles with the bases loaded and still no outs. The Pirates would have had a real chance of taking the lead and winning the game.
Then in the top of the 10th inning with the ghost runner on second, Kelly brings Jake Mangum to pinch hit for Jared Triolo. Triolo had three hits in the game, but he came up favoring his leg after diving to first earlier in the game so I believe he came out due to injury. But with Mangum up, runner on second, why not bunt him to third? No bunt happens and you can easily predict that Mangum strikes out. Endy Rodriguez flies out and Nicky G grounds out and you don’t score in extras and lose five minutes later.
I get it, it was one of those games but I wouldn’t put this game on Don Kelly’s managerial resume any time soon.
Someone Send Help to the Bullpen Please
Fixing a bullpen in May is near impossible, but can we please get Wilber Dotel or someone up here? The pen gave up five runs in this one (four earned) as their struggles continue. Sisk served up a two-run blast where one run was charged to Keller. Brandan Bidois gave up a run on the home run to Alec Burleson and then Mason Montgomery went single and mammoth HR given up to finish the game in the 10th inning for the loss. Only Gregory Soto looked solid when he struck out the side on 13 pitches in the 9th inning to send the game to extras.
This pen is in a bad place right now. You don’t feel comfortable with any of them besides Soto at this point. Carmen Mlodzinski starts Wednesday and if he only goes five or less, look out…it could be another long, frustrating night for the Pirates in St. Louis.
Comments· 0
The Debate
Bases loaded, nobody out, down two in the ninth: should Don Kelly have pinch-hit Spencer Horwitz for Marcell Ozuna?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.
With Doug Ford and Anthony DiNardo.
Chapters
Key takeaways
1
Pulling Mitch Keller at 85 pitches for Evan Sisk was the wrong call. With this bullpen, Keller is better than any reliever, and the host tweeted that before Sisk threw a pitch.
2
Even if Sisk vs. Gorman was the right matchup, Don Kelly still needed 10 outs, and this bullpen can't get them. You ride Keller to shorten the game.
3
Marcell Ozuna should not be batting cleanup in any lineup at any time.
4
With the bases loaded and nobody out in the ninth, Spencer Horwitz (135 wRC+ vs. righties) should have pinch-hit for the slumping, slow Ozuna. A double play was the one thing they couldn't afford.
5
With the bullpen failing, call up arms who are pitching well at AAA. Someone like Arkady might catch lightning in a bottle.
Yo, welcome to the North Shore Nine podcast presented by FanDuel.
This is the NS9 postgame show powered by Primanti Brothers, and I am your host, Anthony DiNardo.
And with me, we have our boy, Dougie Fresh on with us.
Doug, Pirates lose today seven, I'm sorry, nine to six.
Yeah, not a, not a, another, total team loss, everybody contributed, the management, the bullpen management, the hitting, lack of timely hitting, pitching, golly, the pitching is just awful.
So, yeah, you can't expect to win baseball games when you're not doing anything well, right?
the, it's the starting pitching has not been as great.
The relief has been awful.
And, again, they scored six runs.
I don't know.
So, I guess that's fine.
Right.
But not enough.
There's a lot of things that happened in today's game.
And I want to start off by saying so much happened that I think we forgot that this Pirates team looked like they were ready to lay down quite early on.
Matt Libetor pitches today.
Now, Matt Libetor, not the greatest pitcher in the world.
he's a serviceable starter.
I think it probably like the fifth starter on most teams with this Cardinals staff and the way the team should be, he's top of the rotation.
He comes in and Doug, you know what?
I'm not still going to steal your thunder.
You love, would you please?
Yeah.
Please tell us.
Yeah.
So, Libetor reached a career high in strikeouts with two outs in the fourth inning.
He didn't have to, he didn't have to pitch a complete game to achieve this.
He did it in the fourth inning.
this team could strike out now it's, that's for sure.
We, again, we take pictures who, as you said, should be a fifth starter and make them look pretty good.
And, we did it, God, we did it nearly every game last year.
It hasn't been as frequent this year, but it rears its ugly head enough.
And, I said this, I think on Sunday with Tyler is that, we bring a lot as fans, we bring a lot of baggage, into our viewing experience.
And, a lot of the stuff it was, for the first time, it's like, we were down to nothing and I was sure we were going to lose.
And I haven't felt that with it, then it went three, nothing.
And then we got to, we had the classic Brandon Lowe and, Triolo go back to back singles.
We have two on with nobody out and, just had to get to Henry really, gosh, he's a good defensive catcher.
but I don't know if you can be good enough defensively to overcome a one 40 batting average, right?
it's, this isn't Austin hedges.
This is, this is Doug Ford behind the, at the plate.
it's terrible.
yeah.
And the thing about Henry Davis is, yes, like he is not playing well.
It's, defensively, sure.
Offensively is bad.
Like you said, it's Austin hedges level that does the defense actually make up for the problem is what are the options they really have?
they have the gap here right now because Joey Bart's on the IL who really wasn't performing either, but Andy, Endy Rodríguez also like put some perspective on this 20% below league average hitter in AAA before he's call up, he was bad at the answer here either, unfortunately.
but I do want to say this.
So again, like, either catcher role today, wasn't the problem, but again, the way the game started, like you mentioned, it felt that way for the first time this year.
I felt like, yes, when it was two, nothing, I thought, you know what, this team is like, it starts out Nick Gonzales strikes out Konnor Griffin grounds out.
Then Bryan Reynolds strikes out, starts off the first inning again, Matt Liberatore out the second and he comes up.
He strikes out the side.
Oh, Zuno goes down.
Cruz goes down.
the password Garcia goes down.
Third inning starts.
Brandon Lowe singles.
Okay.
There's some light Jared show those singles.
Okay.
There's some light, as you mentioned, what happens after that Henry Davis gets struck out.
and then Gonzalez grounds into a force out and then Konnor Griffin strikes out just all the strikes out.
And we know this team has had a problem against lefties.
So like you mentioned, it just seemed as if today is like, you know what it's done.
It is done.
They're cool.
They came into the game, 29th in, with an OPS on the road, so that, so, right.
They're on the road against the, just a team that has always just always beat them just at least in the past, 30 years or this century.
I did.
Yeah.
It just, it felt done, and then they get back into it and they take a lead and Donnie Kelly can't wait.
Just can't wait to run a reliever out there.
Just can't wait, cause Hey, we got, we can cover four innings.
I, when they tied it back up, I still thought we were going to lose because I'm like, there's no way Mitch Keller can pitch 11 innings.
And that's most likely what it's going to take.
And he couldn't even pitch six.
So, well, that's the other caveat.
So Mitch Keller gives up a home run to their rookie, Pittsburgh fans know him pretty well, but JJ where the whole, he gives up a home run.
He had two hits on the days batting two 39, but a seven to 82 OPS on the year.
That was his ninth home run on the season so far, but like it happens, like Mitch Keller didn't have a good start today.
It wasn't a terrible start.
He does go 5.2 85 pitches, had three earned at the time.
Here's the first thing I want to talk about, because there was a lot of, I think things that were debatable, questionable on down, Don Kelly's part.
And I'm not here to say they're all wrong.
I'm not here to say they're all good, but let's talk about them.
Well, I tweeted out before Evan Sisk threw a pitch.
All right.
Somebody should tell Donnie Kelly, his bullpen is not that good.
to me, it was, I look, he's, the old proverbial caught between a rock and a hard place.
Right.
That might've been a spot to bring to pull Keller, but not with this bullpen.
Mitch Keller is better than any reliever they have with 85 pitches.
It's that simple.
I understand.
I understand the matchups.
I understand all that stuff that you would do if you were a normal team in a normal situation with a normal bullpen.
Right.
It's one of the, again, it's another one of those things about advanced analytics that bothers me because it's like in this situation, you should do this.
But this includes all the stats of all the players of all the times in this situation.
So sometimes that means it's including Shohei Ohtani pitching or Shohei Ohtani batting.
And sometimes it's Henry Davis batting, you know what I'm saying?
It's like, you also have to put some human analysis into it.
You have to say, you're right.
If we had the nasty boys to come into the bullpen, you easily make your bullpen.
If Dennis Santana was pitching like he did last year, Soto was pitching like he was at the beginning of the year.
If Madsen was pitching like he was last year, easy call.
You go to your bullpen, but that's not the situation we have.
We have a bullpen here.
That's not very good and worn out already.
we haven't got to June yet and the arms are falling off that thing.
People have been used too much.
And so heads are falling off.
Yeah.
So I, it, to me, it was a simple, he's got 85 pitches, which means to me, he's got 15 more, which is this out.
And then maybe another inning, or at least maybe, this out and then two outs in the next inning, that thing.
And you have to take the chance.
And I understand if you didn't pull Keller there and then he gives up the home run, we'd be saying, why didn't you pull Keller there?
The matchup dictates.
So he's not in a good situation, but I, to me, to me, it was an easy choice.
There was no way I, and again, I immediately tweeted, I tweeted out before Evan Sisk threw a pitch.
this was not second guessing.
I was first guessing this shit and I thought it was a bad call and, Evan Sisk, gave me anecdotal evidence there to support my, Evan Sisk has been okay.
He's not, I, no one's clamoring to make him the closer.
Right.
So here's what I want to do.
Cause I, this is one of those situations too, where it's like, I understand why now I'll give, I'll give what I would have preferred, but like, I understand the reason.
I know it was just 85 pitches and I'm not going to say Mitch Keller was cruising today by any means.
It's like, again, he gave up the three, he had the home run.
It wasn't his best outing, but again, like it wasn't bad.
not to a level, but like, that's why like Paul Skenes on Sunday, it's like he wasn't cruising by all means too.
We gave up five earned runs, but like he was pitching better than five earned runs.
I felt like on the day and like with Mitch Keller today, again, he wasn't cruising.
he does go 5.2 innings today.
does only allow four hits one walk, you know?
So like that's effective, but the three runs at the time.
He does have the guy on.
All right.
Evan Sisk, 19 innings pitch this year, 1-4-2 ERA, 14 hits, zero home runs, five walks.
He's done his job when he's been called upon this year.
He is a lefty.
Gorman's up to bat.
Burst lefties this year, 208, 286, 250.
Good for a 57 weight runs created plus.
Lefty on lefty opposed to Mitch ready on lefty, right?
I understand the reasoning.
The matchups there, you have a guy who is performing, the guy who's not performing against that lefty.
I understand why go out there.
Let's get this out.
That's maybe in your mind, the best call, but this is where I side with you, Doug.
And it's not even so much that matchup.
It's not even so much that one in particular.
It's the fact that Don Kelly needs to find 10 outs.
He needs to find 10 outs.
Even if that's the right matchup, you need nine outs afterwards.
And this bullpen's not good, to your point.
So I still feel like I'm riding with Mitch then because, again, it wasn't like it seemed at the end he was wearing down.
Again, it wasn't a fantastic start by him, but it also wasn't like, oh, man, he looks bad now.
Let's get him out of here.
It was just 85 pitches.
He still looked just as serviceable right now as he did the first, second, and third.
I'm keeping him in there because I still need, after this out, nine more.
Right.
That's the reason you do it because, again, they're not going to get you three and a thirds outs.
They're just not going to.
You don't have it in that bullpen.
It's not there right now.
And not all Donnie Kelly's fault.
Kelly's in a bad spot.
He's in a bad spot.
But ultimately, he's the one that has to know that bullpen's not getting you 10 outs without giving up another run.
You don't have 10 more outs.
So if you can get it down to maybe only having to get six more outs or seven maybe, that thing, fine.
But that's why you go with Mitch Kelly.
You're right.
You're right.
Don Kelly can sit in a press conference and say the matchup's dictated.
But, all of that.
He can answer why in that specific situation he did that specific thing.
But that only gets you out of the sixth inning.
Right.
So now you've got, like, as you said, nine more outs to get.
And this bullpen's not going to do that for you.
Right.
They don't have it.
And honestly, right, they're going to have to sort it out mostly with this bullpen.
There is no great move coming now, anyway.
So, again, you, Arkady's pitching okay at AAA.
Maybe you can bring him up.
And I know it's the same thing we were saying last year with all the hitters.
It's like, bring up Gorski.
He can only be as bad as Swinski.
Right.
Well, I'm not saying he is Willie Mays coming to rescue us.
Just if you have a bunch of guys that are doing really poorly, maybe bring someone else up.
Maybe you catch lightning in a bottle.
I don't know.
But we know for sure that this bullpen with these guys right now is not being very effective.
So, what's his name?
Bo Burrows.
Somebody, I don't know.
Bring somebody just to see.
it might only be for four games that they help you until you bring somebody else.
But we need, we need something.
We need somebody.
And, they've got, he's got to figure it out with this bullpen.
Therefore, I would ride with my starters a little longer.
I just would.
And, because I'm, because I'm me in September when the starters are all tired, I'll be saying he didn't take care of the starter.
you can't win.
You can't win, but you have to do.
And that's the thing.
There's a lot of, like, when you are the manager, there's a lot of, there's a no win situation.
And, like, this certainly could have been one of the two because he could have left Mitch in.
And Mitch could have given up that home run also.
And now you're looking up, well, there's a typical Mitch Keller star.
Mitch is back.
Five earned in 5.2 winnings.
like, now this looks even worse on him or whatnot.
And again, I know this is a lot of, like, what about isms in that.
But, like, but again, the matchup looks and says, this guy is pitching well.
He's a lefty.
This guy doesn't hit lefties well.
This is a big moment here.
It's a tight ball game.
Let's make sure we get this out and go forward.
He can talk like you mentioned that in the press conference and he can make sense of it.
And again, I can understand and make sense of it too.
But I do think this is a situation, again, I go back to the Brandon Lowe part where, like, Nick Yorke pinch hit for him in that situation.
It's like, analytics are good.
I keep, I'll keep, I'll keep saying it.
Analytics is just information.
It's good to know this stuff.
But the same side, it's also good to know I cannot trust this bullpen.
And right now there's a reason why Mitch Keller's on this baseball team.
Just the same reason that Paul Skenes's on this baseball team.
I think even in that moment, he probably has just as good as a chance, even how good Sisk is pitching.
And again, even if it's not that situation, you still need to find nine more outs.
Even if I trust Sisk in that situation, I don't know who I'm trusting in the seventh, in the eighth, and in the ninth.
Probably Gregory Soto, which he did.
But he's been shaky of late, you know?
So, like, I still got to live for another day.
I need Mitch to get this out for me.
I'm riding and dying with Mitch, like how I prefer to ride or die with Brandon Lowe in that situation.
Even though it was a lefty off.
Right.
I have more faith.
This is the first questionable one of the day that we can do.
Right.
I know what the matchups say with York and Brandon Lowe.
I have more faith in Brandon Lowe, right?
He's got more experience.
He's seen more pitches.
He understands pitching sequences better.
There's a bunch of other reasons, right?
Sure.
And it's the same thing.
At this point in the season, where we are with our lineup, construction, our roster, that thing, I'd rather ride with Paul Skenes, Mitch Keller, and Braxton Ashcraft than anybody in our bullpen.
Right?
And like I said, that specific matchup for that next pitch may dictate that you would go with the reliever.
But, again, I feel more confidence in Mitch Keller than I do in Evan Sisk.
And, again, you have to know, and it's not just Evan Sisk in that at bat because he's going to have to pitch to a couple more guys and then, on and on down with whichever relievers you bring in from there.
Brandon Boudoir, who doesn't look ready yet, right?
Alex pointed that out in one of his offbeat.
it's – again, you don't have a lot of great choices, Donnie.
But so who do you go with?
You go with your guys, your dogs, as you said.
You go with the dogs.
And, again, I feel confident.
I'd rather run Keller out there.
It's just that simple.
Yeah.
I think it's fair.
Absolutely fair.
Let's go ahead and kick on with Cody, and we'll talk more about this loss.
This episode is brought to you by IQ Bar, our exclusive snack hydration sponsor.
IQ Bar protein bars, IQ Mix hydration mixes, and IQ Joe mushroom coffees are the delicious, low-sugar brain and body fuel you need to win your day.
The Ultimate Sampler Pack is a great way for you to try all IQ Bar products and flavors.
You get nine IQ Bars, eight IQ Mix Sticks, and four IQ Joe Sticks.
All IQ Bar products are Clean Label certified and entirely free from gluten, dairy, soy, GMOs, and artificial ingredients.
With over 20,000 five-star reviews and counting, more people than ever are fueling their lifestyles with IQ Bar's brain and body boosting bars, hydration mixes, and mushroom coffees.
The Ultimate Sampler Pack includes all three.
My personal favorites so far have been the Almond Butter Chip and the Iced Tea Lemonade Hydration Mix.
It's just really full of flavor.
I love starting my day with it, and I couldn't imagine starting my day with anything else other than IQ Bar products.
Right now, IQ Bar is offering our podcast listeners 20% off all IQ Bar products, including the Ultimate Sampler Pack, plus free shipping.
To get your 20% off, text MLB to 64000.
That's MLB 64000.
Message and data rates may apply.
See terms for details.
So yeah, ultimately, we know what Evan Siss did.
Like I said, I gave you the stats early.
He comes in today.
He goes one inning.
Gave up two hits, two walks.
Had that home run.
Didn't look good.
But again, as I stated on NS9 Live, I do think he's earned the right to get more opportunities.
And of course, as it goes, he earned himself opportunities.
He was given opportunity, and he didn't succeed.
So again, that Thursday night show is just not aging well for any of us and all the things that we talked about.
But then, yeah, Brandon Bidwa comes in.
So he gets Sisk out of a jam.
So two outs in the next inning.
Bidwa comes in.
And what you said, Doug, sure, he's not ready.
But that out that he made, three straight pitches, three straight strikes.
He looked good that out.
He saved that inning to live for another day.
But then the next inning comes, and he got a home run crushed on him.
Yeah, he barreled that one up.
Yeah, it's tough, man.
It's so hard to, just there's the pirate, that pirate-itis cloud that hangs over.
And it's going to be tough to overcome the past seven years, basically.
And that's what they're going to have to do.
And they're going to have to dig out.
They're .500 right now.
somebody in that bullpen needs to step up.
Somebody in this lineup, needs to step up.
And we need to realize that Ozuna should probably not be batting cleanup in any lineup at any time.
it's going to be tough without O'Hearn.
But, again, if Ozuna would just hit like he hit in the past.
Even if he hit like last year, which was a down year.
Now, he caught it, but it looked like the ugliest catch in the outfield you've ever seen.
Oh, no.
Cruz didn't realize there was two outs.
He stands on second base.
So, like, all this stuff was happening earlier that you thought, again, now they tied up.
It's a brand-new ball game.
The offense starts coming alive.
And, again, it's been some questionable decisions by Don Kelly.
So, I want to go to the next one here.
So, speak about the offense coming alive.
Even with Vidwa getting up the home run.
Even now, it's two runs.
It's the ninth inning.
This Pirates team needs to come back.
They're down two.
And the one thing we've talked about this team, other than, as you mentioned, we started the game, or started the postgame, today's game, when it looked like, okay, they're done.
Almost every game, you've never felt they're out of it.
And this was like that moment.
It's like, all right, earlier on, I thought they were out of it.
But now they're showing some life.
They need two runs in the ninth, and it's the top of the lineup.
I do recall Jim Rosati saying he's probably going to be the best hitter on this team.
hey.
Was that said on NS9 Live Thursday, too?
Yeah, it was probably at the Thursday show.
Which, speaking of, yes.
And shout out to Steel City DW for the 10 gifted memberships.
And then also shout out to Sean Hooper for the 10 gifted memberships.
You all just got a membership for all the new cool emojis.
And then shout out to DJ Quimpy for becoming a new YouTube member.
Yeah, join us.
Join us.
The therapy.
The therapy group.
We're here.
So I'm going to hand it over to you.
Again, bases are loaded.
There are zero outs.
And you're a designated hitter.
You're very well compensated for the Pittsburgh Pirates.
Designated hitter.
Also, clean up.
You're a clean up hitter, right?
Why should we even question this?
Yeah.
Yeah.
I've been really patient with him.
I just, the track record, the resume has been too good.
They moved him down.
Donnie moved him down in the lineup.
Which I thought was good.
And for some reason today, he's got a bad clean up.
I realize O'Hearn is gone, but I don't know what, again, Cruz, Brandon Lowe, all these guys seem to be, better hitters suited for that situation.
He hits into a double play.
It shouldn't have been a double play, but Ozuna is as slow as I am, maybe slower.
And yeah, I think he, I think he might be.
I would challenge him to a race.
Yeah.
just awful, just awful.
Like, you just needed to get the ball.
And yeah, you know what I'm saying?
Like he should be a good enough hitter to make a better out, that it's, again, we're not even asking at this point.
We're not, we're not asking for the grand slam.
We're not asking for a basis clearing double.
We're just like, man, don't hate to do a double play, you know?
So, and again, it's, we all had mixed emotions about the signing of the person, but we all agreed he was going to be, a pretty good hitter and man, whoo, have we been wrong?
And it's, we're a third of the way or nearly a third of the way through the season.
This is no longer, Hey, he's got to get his timing down.
Hey, no, he's stumped and, he's had like two good weeks.
I think.
Yeah.
Well, I, yeah.
Like, I do want to bring this up in the month of May.
He's had coming into this game, but one 24 way to runs created plus like he has hit better in total, like for the month of May.
Yeah.
No, you're right.
I want to get to here.
Yeah.
But he has, he had eight strikeouts, eight at bats, all strikeouts, six coming into the game.
The first two at bats were strikeouts as well.
So we had a streak of eight straight at bats, all strikeouts.
And then the next two again, he didn't strike out.
Didn't strike out.
So still no hits.
Yeah.
So I guess my thing is if we're talking about the Mitch Keller situation and Evan Sisk, right?
Bringing in Sisk is getting cute there.
Wouldn't technically pinch hitting for your designated hitter, your cleanup hitter also be cute to have like a Spencer Horwitz coming off the bench?
Yeah.
Yeah.
it's right.
It's not a bad idea.
I just did look though, that Ozuna is hitting, 40 points higher, 42 points higher than Henry Davis at this point.
And like you said, Ozuna's got like 17 straight strikeouts in a row and he's still better.
Golly.
Yeah.
again, it's Donnie's hard to figure because he really wants to use that lineup.
He loves using pitch runner runners, pitch hitters, like in the sixth inning, when you know that guy, when you're taking out a Brandon Lowe, because he's facing a lefty or what have you.
And it's like, yeah, but he's going to come up.
He might come up two more times.
He's going to come up at least one more time.
And that could be against a righty.
it's, you got to look at what's, it's like Donnie's managing.
Like this is the last play of the game.
So since this is the last play of the game, I will bring in this right-handed hitter to go against this left-handed better.
And I'll put my best, sit my best hitter down that thing, but it's not the last play of the game.
There's three innings to go.
We might need this guy again.
And, by then he's brought in Billy cook to be a pitch runner.
We were, we, Reynolds is out this guy.
And so, yeah, but then it comes this chance where if you're going to be cute and if you're going to use the whole loss roster, you're going to use everybody on the team.
This guy struck out eight, nine times in a row.
And this is it.
You could win the game here type thing.
And, now just let him ride, let him ride.
And, you don't even get the strikeout.
You get the, you get the double play.
And again, like you talk about getting cute, your dogs and stuff.
And again, like, this is your designated hitter.
This is your cleanup guy that you can make the argument.
Like, well, if you bring in Spencer Horwitz, that's getting cute.
But again, I, a lot of it comes down to feel and such too.
Like there are analytics.
There also is feel.
And then again, like, I know Ozuna has been fine for the month of May.
He's been good.
But again, of recent, not.
And before May, he was horrible as well.
One guy who's been steady.
like maybe, okay, maybe like the first week and a half, he wasn't really.
Yeah.
Well, first week has been slow, but Spencer Horwitz has been good this year.
And now again, he doesn't really face lefties.
That's why he was in a lineup today.
He's on the bench, but there's a ready out on the mound.
There's Marcell Ozuna who is struggling right now.
And again, I know he's your cleanup guy.
I know he's your designated hitter.
But Spencer Horwitz on the year, 286, 388, 446 with a 135 weight runs created plus against righties.
This isn't just like the first time we saw what he did last year.
He saw what he did in the small spurt of time.
He was with the Blue Jays and the majors.
Like this is something that he is a hitter, but you know what?
He also isn't fast, but you know who he's faster than, and you know what?
He's not like Marcell Ozuna also is just a double play merchant.
So that's the thing too.
It's like not even so much of like just your doesn't hear.
Like this is a situation where the last thing you really want to do is hit a double play.
You have a real opportunity.
Like even a sack flies fine.
Yeah.
Marcell Ozuna is capable of hitting into double play often because that's, he gets the ball on the ground there and he's just so slow.
And like in that ball too, that was hit.
the fact that he was thrown out at first, like that was just, that's an indictment to how slow he was like that to me, it was a point.
It's like, let's go win this game.
Let's get Spencer in here.
That's the best opportunity to me.
And it wasn't done.
And again, it counter contradicts the whole Mitch Keller thing.
Like that was cute, but this is also in a sense getting cute, but I think this one makes sense.
Yeah.
That's the thing.
It's been real inconsistent.
There are times, like I said, we didn't have a single pitcher go over a hundred pitches for, we were the last team in the major leagues to have pitched a hundred pitches and it was Bubba, right?
Like, you know what I'm saying?
It's like, wait a minute.
Like this is, this is the guy that you're going to, it's not Paul Skenes.
And they both had opportunities that they could have gone another inning to do.
So there's some strange time.
And again, I'm all for you looking at the analytics and said, you know what?
No, I got a hunch.
I, this guy that whatever, I, he's, he's feeling it lately.
He's had, he's had good at bats.
He's hit the ball, whatever you want to, however you want to rationalize it.
But then, and yeah.
And then sometimes he just, he's like, no, man, I, that's my cleanup hitter, man.
That's our designated hitter.
I can't, I can't pitch it for him.
Well, if you can pull Mitch, and if you can, if you can pitch hits for Brandon Lowe, who is the best hitter, on the team right now, or at least amongst them, then why can't you pitch it for Ozuna?
And I understand you should not be worrying about impacting Marcelo Ozuna's confidence, right?
Like, oh, I don't want to, he's 107 years.
He's almost my age, right?
Or, he's, he's had tons of success.
He should be able to bounce back from being pulled for a pinch hitter.
Right.
quite frankly, get it too.
Like he talked about the booze earlier on.
Like it doesn't affect him.
Like he deserves them.
Like, yeah, he seems to get it.
Yeah.
He knows.
Right.
Exactly.
again, if after this game, they come to Mitch and say, should they have pulled you?
he can't say there is no way you should have pulled me in this situation.
Right.
it's, he didn't look pleased either.
Yeah.
Yeah.
So yeah, it's right.
It's, it, there's merit to that decision that there was a lot of merit to pinch hitting for Marcell Ozuna.
If for no other reason that, to put a guy that's got a little better wheels that like, all right, the last thing we can afford here is hitting into a double play.
Yeah.
Yeah.
That's the last thing we can have.
Right.
Ironic enough, what happens, he hits a line drive, single scores, gets the R but the thing is like, had that happened in the Ozuna at bat and it gets, it's all revision.
Sure.
You know what?
Like that might not have happened then, but again, that's why I can give you a better chance.
But like, if that would have happened in Ozuna spot, where there's no outs and the bases are loaded, that's two runs right there.
Ozuna scored one because obviously bases were loaded.
Right.
So, that guy's coming in, but two outs are made.
Horwitz gets that two runs score because there's a guy in second.
So now it's still, there's still zero outs and it's a tied ball game.
You still have three opportunities to go out there and basically try and win this game, which Soto comes in and nails this down the ninth inning to go into extras.
like there was a real opportunity here and they don't capitalize on it.
They did tie it.
Like they do end up tying it because of Horwitz afterwards.
Right.
But that could have, that could have tied it earlier on and you still have three more opportunities to try to win.
Right.
Did you think for one second we were going to win an extras?
Because I did it.
Well, because again, Soto comes in there at nine.
He cleans it up.
He looked excellent.
And now again, it's this bullpen that you don't trust.
Which is why maybe you go to Mitch earlier.
Well, and then we don't score a run.
We don't move Brandon Lowe off second base.
Right.
Three straight outs.
We don't even move the runner.
Cruz did walk afterwards.
Oh, that's right.
I'm sorry.
Cruz did walk.
Right.
But like, isn't that maybe a Cenk Mangum bunting situation?
My bad.
Yeah.
I'm talking, yeah, I'm in extra innings now.
And I'm just wondering, it's like we didn't even, no threat, man on second, no outs.
And yeah, you could have put him on, you could have put him halfway to home.
He still wouldn't have advanced on any situation.
So, right.
Yeah.
Mason Montgomery comes in, gives up a hit and then a home run, which made it nine to six.
Yeah.
Cause why wouldn't he?
Cause he was starting to look good there for, because we mentioned him on NS nine live also, how he's looking good and he's earning some opportunities and here you go, kid.
Here's your opportunity.
Yeah.
Four runs from those guys earning opportunities that we talked about.
Yeah.
Yeah.
That's the bullpen.
But again, like that's also why I don't blame too much on dumb Kelly because these guys aren't producing.
It doesn't matter, but there are some things that you can discuss and talk.
And again, that Mitch Keller one, I would have preferred him to go off there.
Yeah.
We could definitely question the decisions, but ultimately he, I feel like Neil defending Derek Shelton, like who else, who's he going to put in this
situation?
Right.
it's every guy in our bullpen right now is shaky.
There's nobody.
Everyone gave a run today outside of Gregory Soto.
Four pitchers really came in for relief.
Everyone gave up at least one run outside of Soto.
And again, Soto is the only one that you feel any resemblance of confidence in.
Last Tuesday, you and I, and I said, who do you trust in the bullpen?
It's Soto.
And you're like, well, Soto in Montgomery.
And I'm like, yeah, that's fair.
Montgomery.
And, it's seven days later.
We don't trust them.
Soto was great today.
And hopefully that's a sign of things to come, but things have not gotten better in the past week.
Right.
I don't have any more confidence in anybody now.
And you can't run every starter pitcher out there, eight innings.
You can't have Gregory Soto pitch 162, one inning games like you need to have more in this bullpen.
It just is what it is.
Right.
Someone's got to step up.
Some, somebody has got to start being effective again.
all the numbers are in your favor as a pitcher, right?
if you could just throw some strikes, not walk people and, just, yeah, well, tomorrow, like mentioned, Carmen Mlodzinski starts.
I don't know how that's going to go.
There are two lefties in the top three of this lineup.
He's scheduled to start.
They haven't announced any type of opener.
Again, I, his starts tend to go better with an opener.
I would like to see that tomorrow.
According to FanDuel right now, Pirates are plus 106.
So FanDuel isn't like this either for the Pirates.
They've already lost four in a row.
they're now at 500, threatening to be under 500.
The first time the NL central has had teams under 500 for what a month.
they've all been over 500 almost essentially for the beginning of the season, at least after the past year, first series.
So there's going to be a team in the central under 500.
It's going to be the pirates, right?
it's just, yeah, who else would it be?
Well, not the Cardinals apparently.
So that is that we'll be back again tomorrow.
any last words for we got out here, Doug?
Your boy Triolo had three hits today.
He did.
He did.
And it looked like he got hurt.
Maybe he's pulled out of the game.
Of course.
Of course he did.
Of course.
Of course he got hurt.
He's just starting.
He's starting to hit.
He almost had a fourth hit.
He almost had a fourth hit.
Yeah.
All right.
No.
Yeah.
Beyond that, join us after the game tomorrow.
Hopefully we'll be giving sandwiches away less than a month to the tailgate.
like subscribe, post a review.
Give a review after this show.
Talk about what a fine job Donato did.
so.
Yeah.
All right.
Well, we love you guys.
We appreciate you all for coming on.
We'll be back again tomorrow night.
We'll see you there.
Group therapy tomorrow night.
Tomorrow morning.
Alex for another offbeat.
I'm sure that's going to go swell.
Yeah.
He's got some subject matter.
Yeah.
So we'll see you guys then.
Bye-bye.
All right.
That wraps up this episode of North Shore Nine.
Thanks so much for tuning in.
Whether you're listening on the podcast or catching us on YouTube, if you enjoyed the show, please give this video a thumbs up and don't forget to hit that subscribe button if you haven't already.
It really helps us grow.
And if you're listening on the podcast, a quick review goes a long way in helping others find the show.
Plus, be sure to tell a friend about us.
There's always room for more here in the NS9 community.
And for those looking to support us a little more, consider joining our Patreon, become an MVP member, and get exclusive perks while helping us continue to bring you more of the Pirates content you love.
Comments· 0
Bases loaded, nobody out, down two in the ninth: should Don Kelly have pinch-hit Spencer Horwitz for Marcell Ozuna?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.