◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)◆NEWSPirates, Chas McCormick Agree To Minor League Deal
◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)◆NEWSPirates, Chas McCormick Agree To Minor League Deal
Reinold Navarro has one of the most electric fastballs in the Pirates’ farm system, perhaps even one of the best in the minors. The 19-year-old left-hander is overpowering Florida State League hitters, but nearly a walk per inning remains a massive concern. Jim and Anthony Murphy break down Navarro’s unusual pitch traits, improving changeup, extreme strikeout numbers and whether his long-term ceiling could be an elite late-inning reliever in Pittsburgh.
Watch or listen to the full breakdown.
Comments· 0
The Debate
Should the Pirates keep developing Reinold Navarro as a starter instead of moving him to the bullpen now?
From Jim Rosati’s take on the show
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.
With Jim Rosati and Anthony Murphy.
Chapters
Key takeaways
1
Navarro's fastball is so good that if you went into a lab to build the perfect lefty fastball, you'd struggle to match it. It may be the best pitch in all of minor league baseball.
Jim Rosati
2
On raw talent, Navarro's fastball is an 80-grade pitch. You probably knock it down to a 70 because of the command.
Jim Rosati
3
Navarro will never have good control. If he even gets to 40-grade control, he's probably a late-inning reliever or even a closer.
Jim Rosati
4
Navarro's upside is one of the best closers in baseball. The walks are the only thing keeping him from being a top-100 prospect in all of baseball.
Jim Rosati
5
With the new changeup, keep developing Navarro as a starter. Only move him to the bullpen once he's close to the majors, and not before.
What's going on, everybody? Welcome to the North Shore Nine podcast presented by FanDuel. This is another episode of Bucs On Deck. I'm Jim. With me is Anthony Murphy from Bucs On Deck. Murphy, I'm excited to talk about our player this week.
Jim Rosati
Oh, yeah, me too. This is one of my favorite players in the entire system to watch. So I'm excited we're going to do this today.
Jim Rosati
Yeah, we're talking about 19 year old left handed pitcher, Reinold Navarro. He was signed out of the Dominican Republic two years ago in the 2024 international class. And Murphy, like we'll dive into it. But this dude stuff is just off the charts. But yeah, let's give us a quick 60 second, 10,000 foot view of who Navarro is. And then we'll start breaking things down here.
Jim Rosati
Yeah, left handed pitcher, like you said, signed as an international free agent, spent one year in the Dominican made actually made the Dominican Summer League all star team baseball America actually rated it gave him the supplier ranked the his fastball the best fastball in the in the DSL all star game. And we see why already but lefty simple pitch fastball slider change up control issues. But like,
Jim Rosati
when it's when it's near the zone, it's almost like, when it's near the zone, it's almost like, untouchable at that point. But I'm mixing back and forth between using them as a starter and reliever thing.
Jim Rosati
Probably a reliever long term, but obviously, with that stuff, you want to give it as much of an opportunity to see if something clicks with them.
Jim Rosati
Yeah, you mentioned the stuff like it's just nasty, this fastball coming from the left side, with the type of spin that he generates on it, the induced vertical break, like it is a, it is a nasty pitch.
Jim Rosati
It grades out well, the fact that he's in the Florida State League, like there's stack cast for all, for all these guys now.
Jim Rosati
So like, you can see like, just how nasty this guy is.
Jim Rosati
So let's dive into that fastball.
Jim Rosati
What is it that makes it so, what is it that makes it so nasty?
Jim Rosati
It's, so like you said, from the left side, like he can touch the upper nineties with it.
Jim Rosati
I think, according to savant, like it was like 98, nine, the hardest that he's thrown.
Jim Rosati
He's averaging 96, but like you said, it gets plenty of induced vertical break, which is like.
Jim Rosati
The absence of like drop.
Jim Rosati
So it gives it like the carry or the rise effect, the ball doesn't actually rise.
Jim Rosati
But it gives explaining that.
Jim Rosati
Yeah. Like what exactly does that mean? Right. Yeah.
Jim Rosati
Yeah. It's just, it gives like the higher, the induced break there's two parts of looking with induced vertical break.
Jim Rosati
there's the number, obviously the higher, it allows it to play up in the zone better.
Jim Rosati
Cause it's going to give it like the rise effect thing.
Jim Rosati
But also you have to look from it from like the arm angle too.
Jim Rosati
Cause like the lower, the arm angle, the less natural carry it's going to, going to get.
Jim Rosati
So like people throwing from like a higher arm slot is going to naturally get a little more carry on the ball.
Jim Rosati
He throws from like about three quarters, a higher three quarters and all that.
Jim Rosati
So, but like he averages over 20 inches of induced vertical break, which is top of the line, a lead on it.
Jim Rosati
He averages about 24, 2,500 RPMs a spin, which for a fastball is again, plus elite.
Jim Rosati
And then there's also, like the vertical approach angle, which gives like the angle that the fastball like crosses the plate like the flatter it is.
Jim Rosati
Like with the natural, like up uppercut that a lot of swings get with the bat, the flatter the approach in the harder it is for the hitter to barrel up the baseball.
Jim Rosati
So his again, so like, just, it's like a perfect combination and everything I mentioned on like on my writeup for the mid season update.
Jim Rosati
Like I, if you were to take like, go in a laboratory and try to build like the perfect fastball, like I feel like they would struggle to put that, to recreate what Navarro was able to do with his fastball from the left side.
Jim Rosati
and it's a picture he throws up 70% of the time and like hitters just don't have like a chance to touch it.
Jim Rosati
So, yeah, another thing that you mentioned in your update is that, not only is that fastball the best pitch, but it may be the best pitch in the system and it may be the best pitch in all of minor league baseball is what you've got put in here.
Jim Rosati
generates nearly a 50% whiff rate, which, again, for a fastball is crazy, especially when you're throwing it as often as he does.
Jim Rosati
talk to me about the secondary stuff.
Jim Rosati
Cause yeah, he throws the fastball a ton, but like, what's that, it, what's that slider look like?
Jim Rosati
Because, a fastball is great, but as we've seen with some pitchers, like you need something else.
Jim Rosati
So like, tell me a little bit about that, about the slider and the changeup it's the slider is like, it's not a horrible slider.
Jim Rosati
It's a slider that I probably wouldn't expect him to get a lot of outs with against righties as he moves up lefties.
Jim Rosati
It will, it will, it'll be a problem for lefties going all the way up because they have to worry about the fastball and stuff like that.
Jim Rosati
So it's like, it's more of a short, like downward action with it.
Jim Rosati
He can manipulate it a little bit to like mess with it a little bit here and there, but it's at its best when it's like short and like, just like a sharp, like downward break to it.
Jim Rosati
that pitch itself is getting about 40, it has like about a 40% whiff rate as of right now.
Jim Rosati
the changeup, I feel like the changeups come on a lot.
Jim Rosati
And actually when I was down there in Bradenton, like, obviously like I, we know the fastball I've seen the fastball, we just talked about the fastball.
Jim Rosati
The changeup was actually like stood out the most just because like, I didn't expect it to him to show that feel for it.
Jim Rosati
And he got quite a bit of misses with it.
Jim Rosati
And like, he's running a whiff rate of over 50% with it right now.
Jim Rosati
So I think that is a big reason to why, like the walks are still like really high this year, but like the reason for his like big success is the fact that he's had that changeup emerge.
Jim Rosati
To help isolate like right-handed hitters more.
Jim Rosati
So it's not just, it really is just the fastball really, cause throwing it that much, but he also has this, he can wrinkle in as well against righties.
Jim Rosati
Hitters this year are striking out at a 38% clip against him.
Jim Rosati
They have a one 50 batting average against.
Jim Rosati
Yeah.
Jim Rosati
Like they're just, they're having a really hard time hitting this guy.
Jim Rosati
and he seems to be I wouldn't really call another gear cause we'll get like the second half of this.
Jim Rosati
We're going to talk about why, Hey, like if this dude's throwing 96 miles an hour with a, with a unicorn fastball that was made in a lab, like, why is he the number 16 prospect in the system?
Jim Rosati
Murphy, like we're going to talk about why he's the number 16 prospect and not the number two or three here in a bit.
Jim Rosati
but he's been like you mentioned, bouncing back from starting to relieving.
Jim Rosati
But even when he comes out of the bullpen, it's a bulk inning role.
Jim Rosati
Like he's typically going three to four innings when he, it looks like those past seven or so appearances though, you've got, five scoreless outings.
Jim Rosati
The two games that he did give up a run were, four innings, one run, four innings, one run.
Jim Rosati
And so he, at 19 years old, he's even with these flaws, the strengths are strong enough that he's overpowering Florida state league hitters right now at a really young age.
Jim Rosati
Yeah.
Jim Rosati
And I remember it was, it was John Jackard that told me one time that like lefties naturally have an advantage in these lower levels because some, there's so many kids at that point who haven't seen a lefty that can throw strikes.
Jim Rosati
It's there, like, he's not necessarily a guy who gets those strikes, but they haven't seen lefties to this like skill level throughout their lives.
Jim Rosati
So they're throwing off and they're adjusting.
Jim Rosati
So he already has like a leg up on some people, but then you factor in the fact that like his fastball is like, it's probably like, depending on how much you factor in like fastball command into whenever you're grading a pitch, it's an 80 grade pitch.
Jim Rosati
Like it's a top of the line, like elite pitch.
Jim Rosati
You probably knock it down to like a 70 because of the command, but like on a Ross, raw talent wise, that this is an 80 grade pitch.
Jim Rosati
We're talking about.
Jim Rosati
Well, that's exciting.
Jim Rosati
That's exciting.
Jim Rosati
when we get back, we're going to talk about what's maybe a little bit to, why we're pumping the brakes on the bar a little bit and not just saying, Hey, this guy's a future hall of fame.
Jim Rosati
All-star so this episode is brought to you by IQ bar, our exclusive snack hydration and sponsor IQ bar, protein bars, IQ mix, hydration mixes, and IQ Joe mushroom coffees are the delicious low sugar brain and body fuel.
Jim Rosati
You need to win your day.
Jim Rosati
The ultimate sampler pack is a great way for you to try all IQ bar products and flavors.
Jim Rosati
You get nine IQ bars, eight IQ mix sticks and four IQ Joe sticks.
Jim Rosati
All IQ bar products are clean label certified and entirely free from gluten, dairy, soy, GMOs, and artificial ingredients.
Jim Rosati
With over 20,000 five-star reviews and counting, more people than ever are fueling their lifestyles with IQ bars, brain and body boosting bars, hydration mixes, and mushroom coffees.
Jim Rosati
The ultimate sampler pack includes all three.
Jim Rosati
My personal favorites so far have been the almond butter chip and the iced tea lemonade hydration mix.
Jim Rosati
It's just really full of flavor.
Jim Rosati
I love starting my day with it.
Jim Rosati
And I couldn't imagine starting my day with anything else other than IQ bar products.
Jim Rosati
Right now, IQ bar is offering our podcast listeners 20% off all IQ bar products, including the ultimate sampler pack, plus free shipping.
Jim Rosati
To get your 20% off, text MLB to 64,000.
Jim Rosati
That's MLB 64000.
Jim Rosati
Message and data rates may apply.
Jim Rosati
See terms for details.
Jim Rosati
All right, Murphy.
Jim Rosati
So, 40 and a third inning so far on the season for Varro.
Jim Rosati
He has struck out a total of 66 batters in those 40 and a third innings.
Jim Rosati
That's a 14.7 K per nine rate.
Jim Rosati
Last year, it was even higher.
Jim Rosati
32 innings and 61 strikeouts.
Jim Rosati
That was 17.2 strikeouts per nine innings, which is just an absurd number.
Jim Rosati
But, there's a big but here.
Jim Rosati
40 and a third innings, also 39 walks this year.
Jim Rosati
That's almost nine walks per nine innings.
Jim Rosati
And last year, in 32 innings, he walked 40 batters, which was 11.3 walks per nine.
Jim Rosati
So, Murphy, this is clearly why he's not being talked about as the second coming of Billy Wagner or Randy Johnson right now.
Jim Rosati
But, is this an issue that, when you've seen him, is it more of a just, hey, he's really young.
Jim Rosati
He needs a feel for this stuff.
Jim Rosati
Or, like, is this a guy who could just never find his command and he flames out in high A because you can't walk a batter in inning and expect to really do anything at any level other than this level, really?
Jim Rosati
Yeah.
Jim Rosati
So, I will say, like, I've noticed that a lot of the times when he has, like, those big – a lot of it's, like, big blow-up innings to where, like, just – it just – he'll be firing in all cylinders and then one walk and then will turn into two walks, will turn into three walks thing.
Jim Rosati
So, maybe it's – it gets the feeling that maybe it is just, like, he's 19, he's young.
Jim Rosati
He has this – almost like the Bubba Chandler thing to where, like, his fastball is so good that sometimes it's just – it's hard to harness it sometimes.
Jim Rosati
And so, he's 19, trying to learn how to harness this 80-grade pitch that moves like no other fastball moves.
Jim Rosati
And so, he's sitting here and trying to figure it out.
Jim Rosati
And, like, I don't think he'll – I don't think we're ever going to be talking about someone who's going to have, like, good control.
Jim Rosati
We're probably not even talking about someone who – to where it's going to be, like – if you're getting to, like, 40-grade control, then, like, you've probably done something pretty good.
Jim Rosati
And he'll probably end up being, like, a late-inning or pitcher, closer even, if he can get to that.
Jim Rosati
So – but I think just, like, more time, maybe.
Jim Rosati
Like, as he pitches more, like, he's – like you said, he's still 19.
Jim Rosati
This is his third year in pro ball when you go back into – go back to the Dominican League.
Jim Rosati
So.
Jim Rosati
Yeah.
Jim Rosati
that's obviously the red flag here, right?
Jim Rosati
Is, like, how – not only how effective can you be, but, like, how far can you even advance in a minor league system with these types of walk numbers?
Jim Rosati
So it's definitely something that we'll have to keep an eye on.
Jim Rosati
Again, the walk percentage this year is 22.7%.
Jim Rosati
That is down from last year.
Jim Rosati
Last year it was 26.8%.
Jim Rosati
But, you're talking about – you're walking one out of every four batters right now.
Jim Rosati
You're walking a batter an inning.
Jim Rosati
Yeah, you just can't do that.
Jim Rosati
And, like, the ERA, like, it's – the stuff's so good that he's getting away with it right now.
Jim Rosati
He's got a 2.01 ERA, right?
Jim Rosati
But, last year, again, it was still nasty stuff, and he was in the complex.
Jim Rosati
And, I guess it was 2.81 in the complex, and he blew up in Bradenton a couple times.
Jim Rosati
But, yeah, it's an interesting prospect because of the upside here, right?
Jim Rosati
Like, it's a big if, right?
Jim Rosati
But if he can dial in that control just a little bit – it doesn't have to be outstanding, right?
Jim Rosati
We've seen how effective someone like Aroldis Chapman has been in his career with pretty poor command until just recently.
Jim Rosati
I guess apparently someone – I guess someone just told him to start throwing strikes, and he just started doing it, like, this year.
Jim Rosati
And so now he's doing it.
Jim Rosati
Word of revelation.
Jim Rosati
Throw strikes.
Jim Rosati
Yeah, maybe – have the Pirates – maybe this is a question to ask.
Jim Rosati
Have the Pirates tried telling Reynold Navarro to throw strikes?
Jim Rosati
Yeah, – you never know.
Jim Rosati
You never know.
Jim Rosati
Maybe they just got to do that.
Jim Rosati
Yeah.
Jim Rosati
Maybe that's all we need.
Jim Rosati
it's better if you throw it in this strike zone right here, in this little box right here.
Jim Rosati
Just throw it there.
Jim Rosati
You know where the catcher's sitting, like where he's squatting right there, like in the glove?
Jim Rosati
Just throw it right to his glove.
Jim Rosati
You'll be fine.
Jim Rosati
Yeah.
Jim Rosati
They're not going to hit it.
Jim Rosati
You mentioned, most likely late-inning reliever if he reaches, what he can be.
Jim Rosati
The Pirates are – they're stretching him out.
Jim Rosati
He's going for five innings sometimes here.
Jim Rosati
How long does that – how long does this last?
Jim Rosati
Like, at what point do the Pirates just go, you know what?
Jim Rosati
The Pirates is so nasty.
Jim Rosati
Like, this one pitch is so nasty.
Jim Rosati
Let's just figure it out.
Jim Rosati
But let's do it in, like, small spurts.
Jim Rosati
Because he does have the – like, he has the look of – I know he's only 19, but – and you want to try to see if someone can be a starter.
Jim Rosati
But, like, how much longer can you go here and just say, you know what?
Jim Rosati
Like, let's just throw an inning at a time and just see how nasty you can be.
Jim Rosati
Because maybe the velocity gets higher.
Jim Rosati
Like, that fastball gets even nastier.
Jim Rosati
Like, who knows?
Jim Rosati
I don't really know what the – like, the ceiling here is, like, just an elite lefty closer.
Jim Rosati
It's – the upside is one of the best closers in baseball with that fastball and the slider that can get lefties out.
Jim Rosati
And then, like, yeah.
Jim Rosati
It's – his upside is one of the best closers in baseball.
Jim Rosati
Now, the walks – the walks issue is what brings the – and that's what brings him down from being, like, a top three or a top 100 prospect in all of baseball all the way down to the middle of the pack here.
Jim Rosati
But then also, too, like, it's fun with that because on the flip side, if you were to just tell me that there's this low-A reliever that is walking, like, a batter per inning, like, I'm not even giving him a second look to put him on a list.
But the stuff is so good and the upside is so good that all of a sudden it just catapults him to where you have to put him somewhere in your list because, like, the upside is that immense with it.
Jim Rosati
So, I think just because of that upside and how good that fastball is and the fact that he's developed a changeup, like, I'm giving him, like, all the time.
Jim Rosati
Like, I think eventually, like, when you start talking about, like, he gets close enough to – and, like, we're talking, like, roll five stuff, then maybe you go ahead and make that move and just switch him there.
Jim Rosati
But, like, I don't see a reason why you do that any time before that.
Jim Rosati
Yeah.
Jim Rosati
just – and you're not the only one noticing him, obviously.
Jim Rosati
Buck's on deck.
Jim Rosati
You guys just did your midseason update.
Jim Rosati
You got him 16th in the organization.
Jim Rosati
FanGraphs just did their list.
Jim Rosati
They have him 22nd.
Jim Rosati
MLB Pipeline has him 24th.
Jim Rosati
Baseball America actually has him the highest at 15th.
Jim Rosati
So, he's getting noticed by everyone.
Jim Rosati
And, like you said, typically relief pitching prospects who are walking this many people don't get this type of attention.
Jim Rosati
But the stuff is just so loud that it's impossible to not pay a little bit of attention to him because of, yeah, just, like, what he could be.
Jim Rosati
Like, again, it doesn't have to be elite command when you have this type of stuff.
Jim Rosati
It just has to be a little bit better than what it is.
Jim Rosati
Yeah.
Jim Rosati
Yeah.
Jim Rosati
Yeah, and you see stretches now to where it looks – it looks really – the game that I went down there, it was just a dominant outing.
Jim Rosati
He only – I think he only walked, like, one, maybe two and over, like, four-plus innings that he threw.
Jim Rosati
It was just – and I was there at the complex for his stateside debut.
Jim Rosati
And, like, he only walked, like, one or two and struck out, like, eight guys over four innings.
Jim Rosati
So, like, it's there.
Jim Rosati
He has stretches with it.
Jim Rosati
And then it just – he just loses it from time to time.
Jim Rosati
Hey, this past week, 11 strikeouts and two walks.
Jim Rosati
Yeah.
Jim Rosati
Maybe he's on to something here.
Jim Rosati
So, well, that's Raynal Navarro.
Jim Rosati
Again, number 16 prospect in the pirate system, according to Bucs On Deck.
Jim Rosati
You guys do outstanding work over there.
Jim Rosati
If you're not subscribed to the Bucs On Deck substack, make sure you are.
Jim Rosati
It's awesome.
Jim Rosati
Just amazing daily coverage of the organization, top to bottom.
Jim Rosati
Outstanding stuff.
Jim Rosati
So, Murphy, appreciate you hopping back on here again.
Jim Rosati
This is our weekly show.
Jim Rosati
We do this every week.
Jim Rosati
We highlight a new prospect.
Jim Rosati
I don't know how many of these we've done so far.
Jim Rosati
Maybe, like, ten or so for the season.
Jim Rosati
Getting up there pretty quickly.
Jim Rosati
Yeah.
Jim Rosati
We're covering a lot of people.
Jim Rosati
So, this was a fun one.
Jim Rosati
Navarro's a fun prospect to watch.
Jim Rosati
Make sure you check him out.
Jim Rosati
I think he's starting today when this podcast comes out on June 27th.
Jim Rosati
So, yeah.
Jim Rosati
Check it out on the North Shore Nine app where you can check out the Bradenton Marauders score.
Jim Rosati
We've got StatCast on there, too.
Jim Rosati
But, yeah, Murph.
Jim Rosati
I'm excited to see if he can figure it out.
Jim Rosati
Because if he can figure it out, then we've got something special here, I think.
Jim Rosati
But, yeah, appreciate you coming on and talking about him.
Jim Rosati
Yeah, of course, man.
Jim Rosati
All right, guys.
Jim Rosati
Well, this was the North Shore Nine podcast presented by FanDuel.
Jim Rosati
This is our weekly installment of Bucs On Deck.
Jim Rosati
We'll be back next Saturday with another prospect to cover in the system.
Comments· 0
Should the Pirates keep developing Reinold Navarro as a starter instead of moving him to the bullpen now?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.