◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
This episode of Bucco Brew dives headfirst into the frustration surrounding the Pirates missing out on Eugenio Suárez and what it says about the organization’s direction. Hosts Anthony DiNardo and Jim Rosati break down why a one-year, $15 million deal going to a division rival feels like a turning point for fans and why it stings even more given Pittsburgh’s limited options moving forward.
The conversation expands into larger questions about culture, competitiveness, and why free agents continue to pass on Pittsburgh. The guys also discuss Oneil Cruz’s offseason work with Kevin Kiermaier and what it could mean for his development in center field, offering a rare moment of optimism. From roster construction to payroll concerns and playoff projections, this episode captures the emotional state of Pirates fans heading into spring training.
Before you go, don’t forget to support our partners at De Fer Coffee & Tea. Visit defer.coffee and use promo code NS930 to save 30% on your order.
Watch or listen to the full episode now on YouTube and your favorite podcast platform, and join the conversation with North Shore Nine.
Comments· 1
The Debate
Will Andrew McCutchen be back with the Pirates within two weeks?
r🐣Prospect· 290d ago
idiots
With Anthony DiNardo and Jim Rosati.
Chapters
Key takeaways
1
Suarez not wanting to come to Pittsburgh is no excuse. The front office's job is to convince him, and it could have offered more than the Reds to make it a hard decision, but it didn't.
2
The Pirates are about $25M short of the $120M payroll this team needed to be really good. As built, it's a middle-of-the-road team, and FanDuel sets its line at 77.5 wins.
3
If the Pirates were willing to offer Suarez $15M or more, they have $15M to spend and must use it to reach the playoffs. That is separate from extending Konnor Griffin, which they should also do.
4
Signing Marcell Ozuna would wreck the roster: he can only DH, and the outfield would become O'Hearn, Reynolds and Cruz. Reynolds was baseball's worst defensive outfielder in left in 2024.
5
Andrew McCutchen will be a Pirate within two weeks. With the Suarez money still available, expect a pitcher, a bench bat and Cutch.
Yo. Welcome to Bucco Brew. This is the North Shore Nine podcast presented by FanDuel. I'm your host, Anthony DiNardo. This is Jim Rosati. And also, yeah, Bucco Brew powered by
Head of Hair, Coffee, and Tea. Happy Monday, Jim.
Happy Monday. Lots to discuss this morning, DiNardo.
There is... Man, this one stings. I feel like this is... This is the moment of the offseason where we've been pretty positive.
we've been talking along this entire offseason how the moves they made have been good, right?
They've been positive. They're in the right direction.
They're not done yet. We're not completed. What's the next move?
I feel like last night was a turning point where Pirates fans are truly starting to feel like, oh boy, here we go again.
Yeah, I don't know if just like reality is hitting where they had to get significantly better this offseason.
And like, they did. They got quite a bit better this offseason.
But they were so far behind. They had a really low starting point.
And not only do you have to get better, but you have to get better than other teams.
Like, that's the other thing. Like, other teams are also going to try to get better here.
And so, yeah, Eugenio Suarez signing a one-year deal, $15 million with your division rival, Cincinnati Reds, who you're going to be competing against.
Or for one of those wildcard spots is what most of us are assuming right now.
So, he goes there instead of coming to Pittsburgh, which, let's be honest, like, we didn't think he was coming to Pittsburgh.
I don't think at any point any of us believed that Eugenio Suarez was going to come here.
But I think this would have been a little bit more, this would have been a little bit easier for fans to swallow had he gone to Boston or had he gone back to Seattle.
And maybe the deal was two years, $45 million, or the three years, $60 million that people were projecting him to get.
Like, if it was that type of situation, I think people could have maybe accepted this outcome a little bit more.
But the fact that it's a one-year deal for $15 million going to a team that you're directly competing against in the NL Central, that stings.
It stings a lot. It sucks.
It does.
And like you're saying, it wouldn't have stung as much if it was a team like Boston, was a team like Seattle.
It doesn't sting as much because we didn't expect him to come here, right?
And I did it.
things were looking hopeful.
He's still out there.
If he is going to come here, this is what needs to play out, you know?
If he signs in December, like, there's probably no chance.
But if he's signing in February, you could talk me into there might be a chance the Pirates could sign on this offseason, knowing that he's going to wait that long.
And that's what, and it's not in live.
We talked about this whole situation.
And it's like, if there's a scenario where the Pirates are going to sign him, this is it.
This is it.
again, the market's falling.
And I discussed, could they extend themselves, like, I felt like the 15 million a year mark is like that point where it's like, okay, this is a little bit more than we might be comfortable with.
For him, let's do it.
For him, let's do it.
And, I was talking a two-year, $30 million deal.
And days later, essentially, that's what happened.
It was a one-year, $15 million deal.
Like, it was that.
It was right on the money at 15 a year.
It was also a year less.
The second year comes as a mutual option.
A mutual option.
Jim, it was even more beneficial than the two-for-30 I discussed.
It was a one-for-15 with a mutual option.
Yes, that's exactly what stings.
Because this went from three-for-63 projected signing.
It's a projected deal for Swervers this offseason, right?
And that's just outside the Bucs norm.
but it's such a good fit.
Can that happen?
Can they push?
Push.
We go from $63 million to $15 million.
And it's like the Pirates still can't make that happen.
And if they can't make that happen, what hope do these fans have?
I think the last sentence there is, saying it correctly.
I don't know what's going on with my camera here, but my microphone can just still be working at least.
Yeah, like at this point, if you weren't able to do this, then I feel like, at least for me, like, I just feel hopeless right now.
I feel hopeless that this team is going to be able to accomplish anything at all, because seemingly this was a perfect fit.
And everyone agreed, right?
Every single national pundit, every single national reporter, everybody who was speaking about this was like, you know what?
The Pirates are the perfect fit here.
And even with the perfect fit, even with the perfect scenario, like you laid out where, hey, no one else apparently wanted to spend a lot of money on this guy.
It was between you and one other small market team who doesn't even have a local TV deal anymore.
They lost their TV contract over the offseason.
So it's like it's between you and them and you still couldn't get it done.
Now, by all accounts, it seems like Eugenio Suarez just simply did not want to be here at, like, he did not want to come to Pittsburgh.
But guess what?
Like, that's not an excuse.
Your job is to make the team better.
Your job is to sign players like Eugenio Suarez.
Your job is to convince Suarez that it's worth coming here.
And guess what?
If he didn't want to come here for whatever reason, I don't know.
If I'm a player and I've got another offer from somewhere else, I'm probably going somewhere else, too, because guess what?
The Pirates have been a complete laughingstock for the majority of my life.
So why the hell would I want to go there anyways?
all things being equal, which it sounds like they were.
Yeah, I'm going to go somewhere else.
I'm not going to go to the team that is constantly in the news about just being a national embarrassment.
I'm going to go to the team that was in the playoffs last year.
And that's what happened.
So I think the Pirates' ineptitude as an organization, top to bottom, had a role in this.
I think the Pirates' inability to go above and beyond had a role in this.
You can tell me all you want.
Eugenio Suarez loves Cincinnati.
Eugenio Suarez didn't want to come to Pittsburgh.
Well, guess what?
Like, make it a really hard decision for him.
I don't care that you offered the exact same amount of AAV in years as the Reds and you were willing to go higher.
Well, guess what?
You didn't.
You didn't go higher.
You could have made this a very uncomfortable decision for Suarez.
You could have said, hey, you know what?
I know you don't want to come here, Suarez, but here's what we're going to do for you.
And they didn't do it.
They didn't take that extra step.
They just did the same thing that they always do.
And just like they always do, they come up short because no one wants to play here.
No one wants to be a Pittsburgh Pirate.
The only players on this team were here because they got traded or they were drafted by this team.
Outside, there's a couple people who came here willingly because we're exchanging money.
For their services.
And it's a, it's a, it's a pretty good deal, but like for the most part, players just don't want to come here.
And the Pirates have no one to blame, but themselves for that.
Yes.
Yeah.
I do agree.
I do want to get this part out of the way.
And so again, double down what you said, but also a little more understanding.
Like it does take two to tango, right?
He has to come here.
Pirates have to be willing to want them.
Sounds like the Pirates willing and wanted him to some level, to some degree.
Right.
But he talked about his kids.
They always talk about when they want to go back to Cincinnati.
he did have his career there.
He definitely started there, but the majority of his career was spent there coming up.
So, you could understand why the ballpark fits.
Like there's a lot of reasons that you could understand why he wants to go back to Cincinnati.
They're essentially the same situation as the Pirates.
Also, they did make the playoffs last year, technically, but I think everyone look at them, say maybe they're about one player away, right?
Talking about the Reds and the Pirates.
So like solidify themselves as truly a playoff team.
I don't think the Reds are late years ahead from the Pirates.
I don't think the Pirates are late years ahead from the Reds.
I think they're both very evenly looked at and arguably looking, trying to get into the playoffs.
But the problem exists.
Like you mentioned, Jim.
Why was Cincinnati so much far ahead?
It's going to be like that, it's not going to be perfect for everybody, but why is Cincinnati this destination?
Why can't Pirates?
And the other thing too, is why is this now the fifth time we're hearing this from a third basement?
Like essentially, like this isn't even just like a whole round of free agents and this is the fifth region, this higher, like, it seems like this is like from a third basement.
Like how many third basements specifically has it sound like the Pirates have been on, but they just missed out.
Well, that doesn't get you anywhere.
and it's one thing when you hear the first one, the second one, like you can excuse the, Hey guys, like not everyone's going to want, there's different scenarios, different situations.
People are looking for not every single one, right?
Until every single one, that's the problem.
And like you're saying, like, then these are just excuses at some point in time.
I want to go back to a tweet from two years ago where I said, remember when the Nationals were criticized for spending so much money, as much money as they did on Jason Wirth, sometimes you need to invest to create that culture that will in turn create
solutions to help your self-inflicted problems.
Stop with excuses, demand results.
And like, why is that so relevant?
Because we were talking about this scenario two years ago that, sometimes you need to build a culture that players are willing and wanting to come to.
And if for so long, all you've done is bottomed out this payroll, added your Josh Van meters and said, let's go to work kids.
People don't want to come here.
If you build something, they will come.
The Pirates have yet to do that.
And seven years into this rebuild, they decided, you know what guys?
Maybe we should do that.
Maybe it's time to win.
Well, you didn't do anything to prelude this.
You didn't do anything to make anyone buy in.
You won 71 games and said, Hey guys, my line, my job's on the line.
I'm desperate here.
Can you come help save my job?
And they're like, no, I'd rather go to Cincinnati.
No, I'd rather go to the white socks.
no, I'd rather go to Toronto.
No, I'd rather go to the Mets.
No, I'd rather go X, Y, Z.
You know what?
And that's what happens.
Now you're stuck holding the crap that you've laid out.
And here we are.
So maybe the excuse, like maybe, sure, this offseason, right?
In this moment, there's some valid excuses that happen.
Like, oh, you can't blame the Pirates.
This offseason, you can't blame the Pirates to the furthest extent that Suarez signed with Cincinnati.
But you can blame the 2024 Pirates.
I'm sorry, you can blame the 2025 Pirates.
You can blame the 2024 Pirates.
You can blame the 2023 Pirates.
You can blame the 2022 Pirates.
You can blame the high regime leading up to this point to make it this scenario.
That's the problem.
And I know this is, like, focused on one move and one guy who said no.
But this is more than just Suarez saying no.
This is the entirety of how many players have said no over the lifetime of this regime.
Yeah, it's a frustrating morning.
It's a frustrating morning because I feel like I said, they did a lot of good things this offseason.
I'm not going to fault them for too much of what's happened this particular offseason.
But they needed to do, like, they needed to do one more big thing.
And this was seemingly the one more big thing that you could have done.
And they didn't do it.
And again, Jim, the one more big thing was a one-year, $15 million deal.
That was the big move that couldn't get accomplished.
Again, it's why it stings so hard.
It stings.
I think I said it, earlier in the offseason.
But I was just like, this team has, there's a path for this team to being, like, pretty good.
But I think I said payroll, like, the payroll would have to get to, like, $120 million.
If you can figure out a way to do that, then there's a way this team could be really good.
And here they are sitting on February 2nd.
And they're about $25-ish million or so short of that number.
And, yeah, I think this team is competitive, by the definition of the word.
And that, this is a middle-of-the-road team.
I don't think they stink.
I don't think they're outstanding.
I think they have a chance to be in the playoff race, at the trade deadline.
And then they can maybe do something there.
Like, I think, like, there's still a chance here, right?
Right.
It's not a great chance.
Fan duels, latest odds, have the Pirates at 77.5 wins.
77.5 wins isn't going to get it done.
And that number's creeped up a little bit over the last couple weeks, too.
But all projection systems out there that I've seen pretty much have the Pirates as the 13th best team in the National League.
Now, that's not to say they can't figure out a way to somehow be sixth.
Because that's what they got to be, is sixth.
It means they got to be better than the Reds.
They got to be better than the Giants.
They got to be ready than the Diamondbacks, the Braves, the Mets.
Like, they've got to figure out ways to be better than these things.
And if you're just looking on paper right now, like, they aren't.
Now, stuff happens over the course of the season.
We'll see what happens.
It's 162 games.
But, like, as of right now, this team, they're in a better position now than they were at this time last year.
But they're still not in a great spot.
I agree.
And there's no one else.
This was the last remaining move.
According to FanGraphs, there are no more free agents out there projected to give you over two war.
So, yeah.
Could you sign a useful role player here?
Could you get a useful role player there?
Sure.
Those guys are out there.
But, like, there are no more guys out there to move the needle for you.
Suarez was hit.
Right.
Right.
And now he's gone.
Now he's to the team that you were pretty much neck and neck with going into the weekend.
we said, like, hey, the Brewers and the Cubs look better than the Pirates.
But the Reds and the Pirates, they're in the same boat.
Well, now they're not in the same boat anymore.
The Reds are above the Pirates.
Yeah.
You could argue maybe they're about in the same boat.
The Reds, though, are just sitting up in the front seat of the boat.
But that's still a problem.
You don't go into the playoffs by being in the same boat as the Reds.
You get in the playoffs by being better than the Reds.
And like you said, better than the Braves.
Better than the Mets.
Better than the Padres.
Better than the Diamondbacks.
Better than the Giants.
Like, there is a lot of teams that are on that boat.
And they're sitting...
Quite a bit further than you right now.
So, again, like, that's just...
Man, yes, that is what stings.
Like, this was the last impactful bat that the Pirates could just sign for money.
Now, they can still make trades.
And I guess that's maybe where they're going to have to turn their heads to.
To solve and improve that third base situation.
But that's not...
That's not anything guaranteed either.
Because, there's a lot of speculation.
I was one of them.
And I talked about, like, Alec Bohm early on in the offseason.
Like, does some trade make sense there?
Dombrowski's basically come out.
And, like, especially at this point.
Like, if they do trade Boehm.
Like, who are they really replacing him with either?
You know?
So, like, I don't see that as a viable trade option for anybody.
You know?
Not just the Pirates.
Like, he's not moving.
He's staying in Philadelphia, at least for now.
Are the Mets an option?
Is Paredes an option in Houston?
You know?
Like, it's possible, if they want to trade.
But also, that's something we talked about, too.
If they do want to trade, it sounds like they're probably more interested in Major League talent.
And the Pirates have purged all the talent they can on the Major League to get rid of.
So, that doesn't make sense.
And, again, going back to this whole Reds trade, or signing, I should say, it would have felt better if it was, like, the Red Sox because it's not in division.
Like, you and the Reds are still where you're at, right?
The Reds didn't improve.
But, like, I felt like the one thing about the Red Sox is, like, they're entertaining the idea of a third baseman.
That's been talks.
I know they've mentioned Marcelo Meyer recently.
But I'm not sold on that.
the Red Sox could still potentially make a deal for a third baseman.
So, there's another team that you're maybe competing with for those services.
like, the next thing we're going to see is, Parades gets traded to the Red Sox.
And it's like, well, now everything's gone.
You know?
So, it's like, there's nothing guaranteed in the trade market at this point in time that's actually available that want players that you're, offering.
And then, again, there's teams out there that might still want a third baseman that are competing with you as well.
So, yeah.
Like, that's, again, there's so many reasons why this one just stings.
And I think that's why all the emotions are coming out.
it's not like Suarez was the make or break.
Like, this team needs Suarez or bust.
It's just at this point in time of the season, with what's available, it does feel that way.
Yeah.
As I said, it's a rough morning.
It's a rough morning.
I was not happy last night when this news came out.
I think, like I said, I think it could have been a lot easier to swallow if it were the Mariners or the Red Sox.
But with it being the Reds, like, that just, it hurts.
It hurts that it's the Reds and it hurts that it's this deal.
Yeah.
And then the whole Pirates PR machine going out there and trying to spin this so that it's not their fault.
It's like, nah, man, like, this is your fault.
Like, Suarez may have not wanted to come here, but that's your fault.
That's your fault.
Yeah.
All the places that I don't want to go, all the people who I don't want to see, it's those people's fault.
Like, they could have changed my mind on that many years ago, or they could have, maybe had a better reputation.
That's it.
That's it.
Yep.
That's another thing to talk into here.
So quick.
It was so quick to come out.
The Suarez pass and tweet dropped.
We're scrambling to try to process that.
And then boom, by the way, by the way, I want everyone to know we did offer the same amount.
We're willing to go higher.
A couple of things on that.
Well, of course, of course, like every, everything that's come out this off season, we were there.
We were there.
It's not our fault.
And like I said earlier, and I just want to stress it again, like I did say earlier, like, technically speaking, there probably wasn't much you could do to convince him.
it seemed like the writing was on the wall.
He didn't want to come here.
It seemed like Cincinnati, after it's all said and done, what you're hearing from the camp was Cincinnati, again, like his children, they always ask, like, when we go back to Cincinnati, they love it there.
He spent his career.
Like, I look at this to some degree, like the catch thing, like he's going back to Cincinnati, it's a little after.
If it's a feel good story, going back home, it's a comfort level.
Let's go back there and finish the job.
I was able to do, you know what?
There's a whole lot of things in that, but again, yeah.
Hey guys, it wasn't our fault.
It was again, maybe not this off season, maybe not this year per se, but like it is because this is the culture you guys have.
The culture you guys have is nobody wants to be here.
That's your culture.
And when you do have people here, you want to DFA them for plate appearances before they get a bonus.
That's your culture.
That's your culture.
Now to stress on that.
I think the route of things blown up.
People aren't coming here specifically because of that.
But again, that's part of your culture.
That is part of the culture you have created.
We are so money conscious that if you're going to get a bonus, we're going to cut you.
That's your culture.
That's what you're known for.
That is part of it.
The culture is not winning.
It's not winning.
The culture is not winning.
You haven't done so.
Well, you, I guess, technically had one winning season since 2015.
You haven't been to playoffs in over a decade now.
You could care less about winning for five years.
Even when you say it's time to win, you go out there to win 71 games because you didn't do anything in the off season to try to actually win.
So here you are.
This is the bed you've made and you got to lay in it.
And so, again, that's what we're tired of, the excuses.
Sure, there could be some validity to them at this point in time.
But that validity is only there because the culture you created to bring to where you are today.
And this literally is a make it or break it year for a lot of people, period, full stop.
And here we are.
It was a nice December.
Let's all tell our children about that in 20 years.
The December of 2025, kids.
Let me tell you all about it.
It was a time to remember.
A December to remember, some might say.
Let's tell you a little bit about Defer Coffee and Tea as well before we move forward.
Defer is a family and employee-owned and operated business.
They believe that coffee and tea are one of life's simplest and most accessible pleasures and when enjoyed thoughtfully, can open your eyes to the here and now.
They have five locations across the city of Pittsburgh, including their flagship in the heart of Pittsburgh's historic Strip District.
Don't forget to stop by Defer's new location downtown on Penn Avenue, right across from the Benetton.
Grab a cup and fill up your walk to PNC Park.
Mobile ordering is available.
Check out the Instagram for more details.
And Jim, of course, tell everyone how they can save themselves 30%.
Yeah, go to Defer.coffee.
That's T-E-F-E-R.coffee.
Load up your cart, put promo code NS930 in the promo code link there, and yeah, save 30% off your entire order, whether it's one bag of coffee or 100.
Four.
Sure.
Get yourself 30% off.
There you go, Bob Nutty.
Maybe you could afford a Huonier Suarez if you save 30% off on your coffee every single day.
Good point.
Yeah.
Do we want to move on?
No.
I don't want to.
I do want to get to this Oneil Cruz thing, but before I do, I feel like, as I said, vibes are low.
Vibes are low right now.
I don't, like I said, there's nothing out there from a free agency standpoint that's going to get me excited at all.
There are certain things that you could do that make sense to make this team slightly better.
But nothing left here is much of a needle mover.
So, the only way that you're going to change vibes at this point, I think, is extending Konnor Griffin.
Make sure that, I don't know, give us something to be happy about here.
I don't know, Jim.
I got to push back on that.
I'm sorry, but two things can and should be done.
Konnor Griffin should not have to be part of the outcome of this offseason.
That can separately be done while you're also looking to build for this year.
I just want to end it with this.
If you so much say that you were in on A, Huionio Suarez, and you're willing to offer even more, that means, to me, you have $15 million that you're able and willing to spend.
You better do that, then.
This team isn't there yet.
This team is not there yet.
Like, you need to make sure you're in the playoffs this year.
There's no question.
That is the goal.
We've heard.
That is the goal.
You need to get there.
The options are limited.
You've made this harder on yourself now.
But that's not an excuse of why you didn't get into the playoffs.
You can't tell us, when you win 81 games next year, that the reason you get there is because, well, guys, we tried.
And it wasn't our fault.
They wouldn't come to us.
That's not going to happen.
You need to find a way.
You got $15 million.
That's what I heard.
You got $15 million.
You better use it.
You better do something.
You better figure it out.
And you better go into the season with a solid team.
Definitely a polarizing figure in the Pirates fan community.
A lot of every time we post about Oneil Cruz on social media, there seems to be, 40 to 150 people or so talking about how he can't hit or that he's too lazy or he can't really do anything.
That it really great article from Colin Beasley for the Post Gazette.
Kevin Kiermaier.
One of the best centerfielders of all time.
I think we can pretty much all agree with that from a defensive standpoint.
Multiple gold gloves, platinum glove winner.
came out over the offseason and was like, hey, like.
I'm I want to teach people how to play better outfield.
And as I said, go to the Post Gazette, read the article here.
But yeah, Oneil Cruz has spent some time working with Kevin Kiermaier, which I am a big fan of.
I think at the end of the day, we all.
As talented as Cruz is, there are times where he looks like he's disinterested or he's not trying hard enough.
And I think this is a good, at least a good way to be like, hey, like I need to get better at center field.
I'm going to do this.
I'm going I'm going to be a better center fielder next year.
And he has to be like he's going to have to be a better center fielder.
So he spent some time with Kevin Kiermaier over the offseason.
And yeah, we'll see.
We'll see how it looks.
I don't think this can hurt by any means.
But yeah, Oneil Cruz getting some tutelage from one of the best out there.
100 percent, man.
Like this was very encouraging to hear because from Colin's story, you do hear how it was almost immediately.
this wasn't something like they just called and set up today when Kiermaier more or less announced all of that.
Sound like his agent was on the phone with him just like days after.
Let's get O'Neal out there with you working out together.
And now they have been.
And like you mentioned, like this isn't going to hurt.
I'm encouraged that happened.
For all the people that hate on Oneil Cruz because it ain't going to work out.
What do you think it's going to take for it to work out?
like there's still a lot of talent.
And that's the talk about Oneil Cruz, even from us.
like last year was terrible.
He's very talented.
That's why I'm not giving up on him.
He's shown signs that he can do this.
There's a lot of talent there.
And if he's going to be the player that you really want him to be, he needs to do necessary steps to get there.
This is one of them.
Now, I'm not here to tell you that this is the reason why he is going to be good this year.
This is the reason why he's going to rebound.
This is the reason why he's going to be a really good defender.
But what I am telling you is if that scenario exists, this is the steps you need to take to do it.
He's at least doing that.
You haven't heard much from Oneil Cruz all offseason.
Coming towards Pirates Fest, going to the WBC with Dominican Republic.
you have heard him now speak a little bit how like he was, there was no time off.
When he went home, he got to work.
Now, I don't know what's happening.
I don't see him posting on Instagram every day his workouts.
I can't validate that or whatnot, but I can take his word for it.
at least what he's saying, he's saying the right things.
But with that, now you're seeing him taking time out to work with Kevin Kiermaier one-on-one.
And like you mentioned, if there's a guy that you're going to work out with, it's him.
That's what you want to see.
for one, a voice outside of the organization.
And this isn't a trash in the organization statement I'm making, but a fresh voice, a player's perspective, one who recently played, all the gold gloves, all the platinum gloves, right?
Just a fresh perspective of a guy who knows how to do it.
And what he says, a different way of thinking about it.
Love it.
Love it.
Love it.
Still, like Bryan Reynolds' talks and Mackie's, latest article, like, we're not going to know until I see 97 at me.
we're not going to know until he's staying in center field what happens.
But these are the steps that you want to see him take or any player take to get to where they need to be a better player.
Because if he, if Oneil Cruz comes out here and turns into a pretty decent defender, there's going to be a lot of interest for Kevin Kiermaier.
Yeah.
I think what's interesting about this piece is, Kiermaier obviously, addresses, like, this dude is talented.
Like, he's talented.
He's athletic.
He's a freak.
But he does harp a lot on, hey, we blend some good technique and focus and determination, talking about intent, talking about holding yourself accountable, talking about always being ready for every pitch.
He talks about, at the end of the day, drills are, drills are great, but it's going to be up to Oneil Cruz and how he wants to apply himself.
So, a lot of this, I don't, I don't know if it necessarily reinforces what a lot of people are saying, but it's like, hey, like, yeah, this dude's a freak.
He's going to be good, but it's going to be up to him how good he is.
And he says a few times here, like, it's a mindset.
A lot of times, guys are like a mindset away from really allowing themselves to take the next step, is one of his quotes here.
So, yeah, it sounds like Kiermaier is trying to drill it into Oneil Cruz that, hey, like, you've got all the tools.
You have to put it together.
You have to stay focused on every pitch.
You have to be the one to follow through on all this stuff.
And, yeah, I said, it's a good sign that Cruz did this.
Apparently, his agent reached out to Kiermaier to arrange all this.
Cruz has, met with him in person on three separate occasions already this offseason.
So, yeah.
Kiermaier lives in Tampa, so not far from Bradenton.
So, it's a semi-easy trip for Cruz.
And, yeah, hopefully this continues a little bit more.
But, yeah, I like that this is, Cruz putting in extra work, which I think we all need to.
I think we all agreed needed to happen this offseason.
Yeah, absolutely.
Right.
But that's, like, the downside, too, is, and all the things you mentioned, with Kiermaier, this is a crash course.
he's got to teach Oneil Cruz everything about defense in just a few limited days, you know.
So, I think that's why he's also hoping and looking forward to, like, hey, when spring opens up, like, can I knock on the door and come in and keep working with Cruz?
Also, maybe keep working with other guys.
So, but, again, like, as mentioned, this is something you want to see, even if it is just a few days, crash course, whatnot.
him getting in the work, him learning that.
And, yeah, Kiermaier did stress that.
Like, you go all out in every single drill.
You go out now and practice.
You do it now in practice.
So, that's, like you mentioned, something that Oneil Cruz has been scrutinized for.
is he in it mentally all the time?
So, yeah, it's going to be on him.
But, either way, hey, defensive run saved, it was a zero last year.
I'm sorry.
Out above average last year was a zero.
Defensive run saved, negative 14.
I think we all can agree the defense started to look better as the season progressed.
Until it just seemed like Ono wasn't really in the season too much mentally.
But, I do have hope for Oneil Cruz to, again, because especially the talent.
But, there's things that you saw last year.
If Oneil Cruz is in it, I feel like he can be a good enough defender to play center field.
So, hopefully, that is what we see.
And, hopefully, Kevin Kiermaier can help with that.
And, then, hopefully, Kevin Kiermaier can take off and do what he needs to do.
Because, it is interesting.
I'm talking more about Kevin Kiermaier on this and some things.
But, it's interesting what he wants to do.
like, he doesn't really want to work for a team.
He just wants to be a consultant for, like, everybody.
So, I'm really interested to see what he does, with MLB and his next step of his career.
Yeah, it sounds like he, these things already are out there for pitchers and hitters.
Like, you've got, you've got Tread.
You've got, like, you've got these types of places that exist that teams essentially outsource their coaching to.
Right.
But, yeah, if you can do something for outfield and it's like, hey, do you teach this guy to be a really good outfielder and it works?
Then, yeah, we'll see.
Like, if Oneil Cruz goes out there this year and has a really good defensive season, I think Kevin Kiermaier's stock is going to go up.
Oh, yeah.
And, really, the Pirates might need him there because, at this point in time, they might really need to be having a workout with Ryan O'Hearn, I don't know, Spencer Horwitz maybe.
There might be a lot of guys who need to learn some new positions in the outfield.
Who knows what this lineup's going to look like because, yeah, you guys are having the conversation in the comments right now and we haven't even really talked about it.
But, there is probably one hitter out there who is impactful.
The problem is he can't play defense.
No.
And that's Marcell Ozuna.
He hasn't played defense in three years.
So, like, he's not going to start now.
So, like, if that's a bat that you bring in, and Jason Mackey wrote last night that was someone the Pirates may be pivoting to, Andrew Filippone put something out there, but who knows?
Pony just said stuff for random times.
He may just be repeating Mackey.
I don't know what's going on there.
But you look at, if you bring in Ozuna, then it's like, where do these players fit?
Because you've got to get O'Hearn in the lineup every day, Reynolds needs to be in the lineup every day, and Horwitz needs to be in the lineup every day, and all those players play two positions, basically.
So, like, how do we make this work?
essentially, the only way it's going to work, if you go that route, is someone's going to play left field a lot, who you're not really all that comfortable with playing left field.
That's what it means.
It means you're either moving Bryan Reynolds back to left field, or you're putting Ryan O'Hearn out there.
That probably is the solution.
And, the last time Bryan Reynolds was a left fielder, I want to say he was the worst defensive outfielder in baseball.
Yeah.
That would have been 2024.
He had negative 10 fielding run value, negative 9 outs above average, negative 5 defensive runs saved.
He was bad out there, and they moved him to the right.
And in right field, he's basically an average right fielder.
So, yeah.
if you're looking for offense, and you're like, hey, I'm going to sacrifice defense for this, Ozuna is an option for you.
the way this roster looks, too, there's currently no domestic abusers on it.
So, getting Ozuna would also let Ben hit his quota of one of those every season.
But, I don't want Ozuna on this team, quite obviously.
But, he is the one bat remaining.
It's just, if you bring Ozuna in, then it just, it makes things real weird from a roster construction standpoint.
It does.
It really does.
Like, we say Cutch can't play outfield.
Cutch has shown he can do it, just on a limited basis.
Ozuna can't do it.
At all.
And if you want to make the excuse of, there's a, Ozuna's a better head than Cutch.
Let's get that out of the way.
I'm not here to tell you differently.
But if you're also saying the excuse for Cutch is there's nowhere that he fits on this roster, this team can't fit another DH, that's what you're doing with Ozuna.
So, again, like, the fit is just, it's not great.
It's not great.
I guess having him here and having O'Hearn play outfield is better than not having him here in what exists, I guess, maybe.
But, right, like, the fit's not, the fit's not good.
You basically just acquired a bunch of DHs this offseason and said, let's go to work, guys.
But, at any rate, yeah, I guess, like you said, that's the one bat.
I didn't really mention it too much earlier because, again, I don't know, man.
I don't know.
I don't know.
I don't.
The fit, man, it's just, it's so hard.
It is so hard.
We transitioned this way from the Cruz talk.
Cruz wasn't good in center field.
Reynolds was the worst left fielder.
Now, you're putting Ryan O'Hearn, like, this is just a bad outfield.
A bad outfield.
We're worried about Cutch.
We're worried about if Cutch can play right field.
Man, like, doing this is just a bad outfield.
Yeah, and that's why, like, I'm going to bring this back to Cutch, right?
Like, Cutch, great.
Cutch definitely isn't a great fit on this team either.
But it's Andrew McCutchen.
He's a right-handed bat, which you need.
And Andrew McCutchen makes more sense in a bench role because, he's I think he would accept that.
And if you have to play him in the outfield every now and then, like, he could do it.
Like, he's shown he can do it.
I said, Ozuna just pigeonholes you into, he can only DH.
And then, like you just mentioned, then you're looking at an outfield of O'Hearn, Reynolds, and Cruz.
And yikes.
Like, yikes.
Kevin Kiermaier better be a miracle worker.
Like, Oneil Cruz better be the best center fielder since Kevin Kiermaier, or that outfield is going to be rough.
That's what I'm saying, man.
Bring in Kiermaier to camp.
You got a lot of guys you can work with.
So, we'll see what happens there.
I'm curious if they go that route.
it definitely would, like, Ozuna can hit.
Like, he's probably the best right-handed hitter left out there.
It's just, from a roster construction standpoint, then you're getting real weird.
If you bring in Ozuna, then you're definitely not bringing Cutch back.
Then there's absolutely no room for Cutch.
Like, none whatsoever.
So, yeah, we'll see how it goes.
There's pitchers and catchers report in nine days?
Nine days.
Like, crazy.
It's crazy how this is creeping up on us.
Yeah.
Well, you mentioned Cutch.
So, maybe to talk a little bit about him before we wrap this show up, too.
Yeah.
I don't know.
Like, I don't know what happens with him at this point.
Like, does them missing out on Suarez hurt or help his potential comeback to the Pirates?
I don't know.
I don't know.
Excuse me.
Because, like, you mentioned that if they do pivot with Ozuna, like, there definitely is no fit.
But it was – I only heard this by one person.
Andrew Filippone talked and tweeted out there that Adam Crowley, through a source, found that Cutch and Bob met.
And this was on Friday, I believe.
So, I guess Thursday, maybe, they met.
I don't know what to take from that.
apparently, the two of them met.
But it was also ironic that the next day, Cutch posted videos of himself hitting.
There's a lot of animosity between the two.
And, according to Ben, like, they're trying to make the team better.
He didn't commit to Cutch, but he also didn't decommit to Cutch and say it's not happening.
Cutch found his way on this roster because he went to Bob to begin with.
Bob came out and said he's a Pirate until he doesn't want to be.
And, supposedly, they met on Friday or, I guess, Thursday.
So, I don't know, Jim.
What do you make of that?
And what do you make of Cutch with his teams as of today?
Yeah, I think at the end of the day, Andrew McCutchen is going to be a Pirate.
Do you really?
I do.
Because, now, if the Pirates had gotten Suarez, maybe not.
But now that they seemingly have $15 million available, I think they add a pitcher, I think they add another bat, a bench bat, and I think they add Cutch.
Like, I think you probably are adding a few more people to this roster.
And maybe that looks like Tyler Anderson, Andrew McCutchen, Mike Tauchman, or Tyler Anderson, Andrew McCutchen, Tommy Pham.
I don't...
Like, something like that.
Mm-hmm.
But, yeah, I think he ends up on this team before...
Yeah, within two weeks.
Fair enough.
That's just the hype that I've got.
Yeah.
I really don't know, man.
Unless they get Ozuna.
if they land Ozuna, that's not happening.
Then there's just...
Then there is no room for them.
I would say that they probably are as well, if I could have to bet today.
But, I just...
I don't know.
I don't know if they're going anymore.
If, like...
I'm going to be rather upset.
And it's just going to...
I'm going to be rather upset if the Pirates are like, Cutch, we don't have room for you.
We just signed a 35-year-old domestic abuser who doesn't fit our roster.
Like, if that happens, I'm not going to be very happy.
Let's just say that.
Okay.
Well, here we are.
February 2nd, Groundhog Day.
To remind us all that it's the same thing each year.
We are very hopeful in December.
It's now been, like, what, 37 days since the Pirates added a Major League talent to the team.
They really haven't done anything since Ryan O'Hearn.
Like, nothing.
There was a lot of hype, a lot of hope.
And it just started dwindling.
And now, as of today, Suarez is with the Reds.
The Indivision Reds.
Where you have two teams certainly looking better than you on paper.
The Cubs and the Brewers.
The Reds are neck and neck with you.
Who just got better?
And there's not much out there.
Bradent-wise and even trademark-wise, it looks, to really improve this team to get you to where you need.
So, here we are.
That's how we feel.
Anything else before we leave?
Are we done?
I think we're done.
Yeah.
pitchers and catchers report next week.
So, just some finishing touches to this roster now.
And we'll be in Bradenton soon.
We will.
As disappointed and frustrated we are today, I'll be very excited when we are in Bradenton.
I can't wait.
I still can't wait for it.
It doesn't matter.
I can't wait for it.
I can't wait for Jack Suwinski to hit three home runs in a game.
Comments· 1
Will Andrew McCutchen be back with the Pirates within two weeks?