◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
The NS9 Report is the start to your week. Posted bright and early every Monday morning, I’ll break down the three things that I’m looking for each week in Pirates land.
Games Start February 21st While it’s always fun to get those cell phone videos from the beat writers of Konnor Griffin hitting a car in the parking lot and the pitchers firing a bullpen, the spring training games get going this week with the first game on Saturday against the Orioles in Sarasota at 1:05PM. The Pirates play a total of 32 games this spring. Thirty one of those games will be in the Grapefruit League and one game on March 3 is against Team Columbia before the World Baseball Classic starts.
The Pirates will play the Orioles the most of any one team this spring with five games against Baltimore. They also play the Braves and Tigers four times apiece, the Rays and Red Sox three times each and then they’ll have two games each against the Phillies, Yankees, Twins, Astros, Cardinals and Blue Jays.
We’ll have you covered for the first two weeks of games beginning with the opener at LECOM Park on Sunday, February 22 versus the Rays. The boys will be in Bradenton at NS9AirBnb churning out plenty of content for the first two weeks of games. I’ll be making it down there myself from March 4-7 and can’t wait to catch some warm sunlight and baseball. Here’s the full broadcast schedule for this spring.
AJ Burnett in Camp On Sunday the Pirates players were greeted by a visit from AJ Burnett. Pirates Manager Don Kelly extended the invite for Burnett to come out to camp for several days and talk shop with the boys and Burnett took him up on it. Fans have hinted for years that the Pirates should bring AJ in to be a coach for the team, and I always thought it was silly because he’s shown no desire to pursue coaching at a professional level, doesn’t have any coaching expereience and seems to be having fun with his kids since his retirement. But seeing him in camp Sunday talking with the boys, giving advice and insight to the pitchers and whoever else is interested is pretty cool. I’m all for anything AJ Burnett wants to do.
AJ talked about what it means to win in Pittsburgh per Jason Mackey’s tweet above and he’s 100% correct. We haven’t seen this very often where more recent Pirates alumni are there hanging out in camp so it was a good move by Don Kelly to invite him to camp.
I’m looking forward to seeing how this week goes with him there, what pitchers gravitate to him and anyone that maybe surprises him after spending days with the guys. And who knows, maybe this will eventually lead to something like a more permanent position with the Buccos that would make my Twitter timeline very happy. DiNardo and Jim talked about AJ Burnett’s presence in camp as well on Bucco Brew Monday morning so check out their takes on that and all things spring training here:
DH Position and Roster Move When the Pirates signed Marcell Ozuna, who hasn’t played the outfield since 2023, it seemed like it was settled that Ozuna would be your main DH and played 140 games there, but last week Ben Cherington said something that would make that statement not the case.
Now that confuses me a bit. He continued to say that Kelly wants the DH spot to be available to players to rotate through. Now ideally that was going to be the plan with the DH position, but I thought everything changed with the Ozuna signing. Ozuna is strictly a DH…right? So what’s happening here? Ozuna is no spring chicken himself and at 35, was there possibly a discussion about him playing less games, say maybe 120 this season instead of the last three seasons where he played 145, 162 and 144 games. I wouldn’t think they’d want him to play less games considering he signed for $12.0M. Or is there a chance Ozuna plays the field a bit to allow other players to rotate through the DH role? We saw Andrew McCutchen jump in and play the field last year for a handful of games even though it wasn’t ideal but it is possible. Maybe Ozuna has expressed interest in jumping back into the field once a week if need be. But this is one of the developments I’m keeping an eye on as spring training progresses. Once games start up this weekend and we get more quotes from Donnie, we’ll hopefully have some more light shed on this situation.
Ozuna reported to camp yesterday so once he speaks with the media we may get his thoughts on what his expectations are with games played and if he’ll be fully playing the DH position. Also, the Pirates still haven’t officially announced the signing yet so they’ll need to make a roster move to clear a spot for Ozuna on the 40-man so that should be coming early this week. They will need to either DFA someone on the 40-man, make a small trade or move someone to the 60-day IL spot so look for that as well.
Comments· 1
The Debate
Should Carmen Mlodzinski be the Pirates' fifth starter, or stay a multi-inning bullpen weapon?
lisamenfinger🐣Prospect· 276d ago
Great column! It will be interesting to see what Donnie does.
With Anthony DiNardo and Jim Rosati.
Chapters
Key takeaways
1
Jack Suwinski, not Billy Cook, will be DFA'd to make room for Marcell Ozuna. Suwinski is out of options and unlikely to be claimed, so he can be sent to AAA as depth, while Cook still has options.
2
Stretching Carmen Mlodzinski out as a starter has no downside: if he doesn't win the fifth spot, he's already built up as a bulk-innings reliever. His revamped arsenal (1.63 ERA, 58 K, 14 BB over his last 23 outings) makes him worth another try.
3
Mlodzinski is a true weapon as a multi-inning reliever, Chris Devenski style. The question is whether he holds up the second and third time through a lineup, and his value may be greater in the bullpen.
4
The offseason moves don't matter unless Bryan Reynolds and Oneil Cruz get back on track. Cruz is the one hitter with a 5–7 WAR ceiling.
5
If Konnor Griffin is ready, the Pirates should put him on the Opening Day roster. A team trying to win this year shouldn't let service time or extension costs decide.
The reason why I think it's Jack Swinski is because, since he signed that contract, he's making a little bit more money.
He doesn't have any options.
So, I just, I feel like, and Billy Cook has options left.
I feel like Jack Swinski just has a really low shot of actually getting claimed by another team.
So, yeah.
I'll go, I'll go Jack.
I think it's going to be Jack.
like he's mentioned, like, this is why you gave him that contract.
Like, this is why you did what you did.
And I understand, like, that's not the first move you make.
But at this point in time, it's like, I feel like you've exhausted all the natural moves that just make sense.
Now it's going to be someone who you, air quotes, want on your 40 man.
Like, even like your Billy Cooks, you know what?
Like, you mentioned, there's still options.
Like, you still want him.
You made that trade for him.
You still want him on your 40 man.
You believe you can sneak Jack through, especially this time of the year.
So, I feel like it's going to be Jack.
Jack's going to be in camp the entire time.
Not on the 40 man.
You're going down the AAA, buddy.
And then your depth.
And honestly, he could make the opening day roster at this point.
He could.
Still could, but.
He could.
He's going to trick us again.
He's going.
Yeah.
Oh, what'd he do about like 440 last year?
I don't think it was that good.
He does always seem to have a pretty decent spring though.
He does.
Anyways, we have a pack to show for you today.
We're going to talk about AJ.
Batman returns.
Batman was in camp.
A lot of, a lot of stuff being talked about with him.
He seems to be very happy about being back in, with the Pirates organization and doing stuff.
and we have some takeaways.
We're each going to give our three things that we want to see in spring training as it opens up now.
So let's start of course, with Batman, AJ Burnett announced it's going to be in Bradenton pirate spring training for about four to five days starting yesterday.
Yes, it was day one and it seemed as if it was like an introduction.
He was hanging around watching pictures, talking to some guys, just a lot of good stuff.
A lot of good vibes, a lot of good vibes happening.
So what was your takeaway from day one?
They want to be AJ being there.
Yeah.
one thing that I remember Michael McHenry.
saying on our show about a month or so ago was that he wished the Pirates would do more of this.
And I asked him, I was like, why?
Like what actual good does this, does this do?
Right.
And, he mentioned just like having people around who have been there before, who you can take feedback from, who's not necessarily your coach, he's not necessarily your manager,
but like almost more like a, like a peer that you just look up to.
Because I don't know.
We've all had we've all had jobs like that, or we've all in just in real life.
Right.
Like if your boss says to do one thing, maybe it's like, yeah.
But like if your coworker who's like having success is like, this is what I do.
It's like, maybe I'll try doing that.
Right.
And so like it, that's, that's where this is.
I don't think there's a whole lot to it other than just.
Seeing someone who knows what they're doing, right?
Like someone who's been through it before.
I think that's really the most important piece.
but at the end of the day, like the players still need to go out there and perform at a high level.
Like you can't just bring AJ Burnett to camp and say, Hey guys, here's AJ Burnett.
He was in the playoffs.
you can go to the playoffs too.
Right.
But it's like, you still have to actually be good.
but I, but I think what's cool about it is one thing that is missing on this team because it's been so long since this team has had any success.
Like how many, how many players on the Pittsburgh pirates even remember the pirates having post-season success?
like you even look at the older guys on the team, like Bryan Reynolds, like Bryan Reynolds, even when he was drafted, that was still Bryan Reynolds was drafted in 2018.
I think that was three years after the last pirates.
The last time the pirates were in the post-season.
So like there's, there aren't a whole lot of people on this team who knows what winning baseball looks like in Pittsburgh.
And if they do, it was a while ago.
So every once in a while I see that it's, a little bit, it's nice to have people around who aren't, Steve blasts where like, love Steve blasts, but you look at Steve blasting, but like, Oh, you want a world series 50 years ago, 60 years ago.
Like that's a lot different than someone like AJ burnout, who they may look at as more of a peer.
Yeah, I agree.
And I'm going to go back just to the fourth thing he's been talking about that for years.
I remember actually you got you two going in on that.
not in, but like debating, talk about that.
It was a while.
It was one of the first shows I feel like he was on because like you mentioned, like why?
Because the buyers don't have any winners, like who are they going to bring back?
Right.
Who's done it?
The closest you have is guys that have just won a wildcard game essentially, but I'm with you, like I do think there is value in guys.
And then AJ is a perfect example of that.
he's one, but he's also one elsewhere, but he's just endeared among Pittsburgh and he just loves, himself with the parts organization and such.
And he's a character and he has something I think this team needs.
And, like Paul said, like being surrounded by winners is a good thing and you should.
And again, like he's one elsewhere.
It's not just, Pittsburgh and those quick playoffs or just the wildcard.
How do you want to phrase it?
he's gone off and he's done some tremendous things.
Like Paul said too, he's like, I didn't even know about the perfect game like that.
That's awesome.
I take a look at this and just say like Donnie's first spring training as the manager, right?
He's been the manager, but this is his first spring.
This is the first year heading into the year.
He is the manager and day one, he's bringing in AJ Burnett.
And that is something that this like Derek Shelton never did any of that.
it just seemed like, we know the parts organization is very tight lipped, but it seemed as if like spring training was almost cut off to outside people.
Also, and again, from day one, Donnie's like, Hey, AJ, why don't you come down, see the boys, talk with them, and they did.
And AJ was very welcome to it.
And it's like, Hey, I'm here.
I'm not going to make a spectacle of it, but like, I hope you guys pick my brain and ask me stuff.
That's what I'm here for.
I'm not here to change lives.
I'm not here to, coach someone, but like, I'm here to hang around and pick my brain.
Use me.
That's what I'm here for.
And it seemed like they did.
And Jared Jones, Jared, that's the one I was interested in too.
I think he says like, yeah, I'm a hot hit on the mound.
He is too, from what I know of, we might have some things in common, but I love the idea of it.
And I'm curious if there is going to be any more, like who is maybe next.
So yeah, I am glad that Don Kelly did this and it seems like he's open to doing this.
It's not like, this is our way.
I want no outside voices in here.
It's like, no, man, we need some of this.
We need some of these guys back.
AJ did win here.
Maybe there's something he can lend to you guys.
Yeah.
Listen, at the end of the day, it still falls on the players, but it's I'll always go back to that, you know?
Well, of course it does.
But I remember, yeah, I remember 20 years ago, the entire 1979 World Series team would come down to spring training every year back in the 90s and the 2000s.
And that didn't help because the players stunk.
Right.
So you still need good players, but it is cool to see.
I agree.
Mm.
Absolutely.
So, yeah, there's that.
Outside of that, again, the spring training technically starts today.
Pitches and catches reported.
So we did all that.
Was there anything else that you wanted to talk about that's, happened in spring as of now?
No, we'll get to we'll get to like the thing now that full squads in camp, we're going to have a pretty lengthy segment at the end of this as far as, what we want to like the specific things that we are looking for this spring.
We'll talk about that later in the show.
But as far as stuff that's gone on so far, it seems like it's just been a lot of bullpens, live BP.
That's where we're at right now.
There's nothing too crazy going on currently.
Right.
Well, then we'll bring up one thing before we do that.
Tell you about Defer coffee and tea.
So Defer is a family and employee owned and operated business.
They believe that coffee and tea are one of life's simplest and most accessible pleasures.
And when enjoyed thoughtfully, can open your eyes to the here and now.
They have five locations across the city of Pittsburgh, including their flagship in the heart of Pittsburgh's historic strip district.
Don't forget to stop by Defer's new location downtown on Penn Avenue right across from the Benetton.
Grab a cup and feel up on your walk to PNC Park.
Mobile ordering is available.
Check out their Instagram for more details.
And of course, the website is Defer dot coffee.
And Jim, tell everyone how they can save themselves 30 percent.
Yeah, go to Defer dot coffee, load up your cart and enter promo code NS930.
That's NS930.
And you'll save 30 percent off your entire order.
Boom.
There it is.
Which, once again, in my mug, in my buckaroo mug.
So good.
I've got Sons of Vulcan this morning.
Okay.
That's my fair flavor I've got.
I'll be honest with you.
I don't remember what I even have right now.
Is that bad?
I just get it.
Again, that's what's cool about Defer.
You can ship like what style of coffee, like dark roast, light roast.
And they'll just give you, a random one every month of your subscription.
I have a subscription every month.
I get some coffee.
And I don't recall what this one is.
The last one was light up night.
Got it.
This one.
I don't remember.
I haven't had that one.
Oh, well.
I'm sorry to fair.
It's good.
It's good.
But yes, so I do want to talk about one thing, one bit of news that came out, while pitchers and catches report and stuff, but I do think it's interesting because there's this battle for the fifth starter, to maybe touch on that just ever so slightly right now.
But Karmamijinsky voice, more or less that, he's open to wanting to be a starter again.
And we know we entertained it last year.
Sure.
Makes some sense.
Fine.
Why not?
Let's see what happens.
Well, we saw what happened and it wasn't too pretty.
It was back to the bullpen and he was just the dominant force once again.
So heading into this, heading into this offseason, I think you and I are basically like on the stance of just be a bullpen guy.
Just be a bullpen guy.
Do what you do.
Do what you do.
Well, that's what you've done.
Well, just stay there.
And Karmamijinsky voiced again that he wants to be a starter.
So I'm going to put this back onto you.
What are your thoughts?
Yeah.
Well, first thing I want to say is this isn't necessarily Karmamijinsky saying I want to be a starter.
Of course he wants to be a starter.
Everybody wants to be a starter.
But the Pirates have told him, we want you to work out as a starting pitcher this spring.
So this isn't like a last year.
It felt more like Karmamijinsky reported to camp and was like, hey guys, I want to be a starter.
Right.
Right.
This year, it seems to be the Pirates saying, Hey, Carmen, we want you to work out as a starting pitcher.
And we'll see.
We'll see how it goes.
There's a few reasons for this.
I think one is with the world baseball classic going on.
You do actually need probably a few more starters than normal throughout spring training, just to like cover some innings.
because you're going to have skeins gone.
You're going to have dotel gone.
You're going to have Urquidy gone as well.
So you're going to have three fifths of your current projected starting rotation, like not in camp.
So you need, you need starters, but two, the way, the way I like, I like the reason why I like this is because I don't, I don't know if Carmen Mlodzinski is going to be the seems to the starter, but I think you still, you treat it like he's competing for it.
Like you want this to be a competition for this fifth spot.
The more people that you have competing for it, the better.
Eventually the cream is going to rise to the top and you're going to figure out who that fifth starter is.
If Carmen Mlodzinski doesn't win the spot, then he's your bulk inning reliever who you can put in a game.
He can get you six outs.
He can get you seven outs, whatever it is.
He's already, he's already stretched out.
You don't have to worry about anything.
Like he's just good to go.
So like, there's no harm in doing this.
In my opinion, the only thing that could happen here is a good outcome.
and I know we did this experiment last year and last year I was against it last year.
I was like, this does, I don't, I don't like this.
And then once you shifted to the bullpen, you saw the success.
So last year it was like, why are we doing this?
I'll say this.
Last season at the beginning of the year, he didn't look good.
Didn't look good as a starter.
When he came back though, he really found his groove.
And it wasn't that he was like, he wasn't starting any games.
He started a few, but it was more in that opener role.
But as few, a few of those games, like he did, like he did go pretty deep for a quote unquote opener.
It's not like, it's not like he only went like an inning or two either in all those games.
So he consistently went two plus innings.
Like, I'm just to shout out some of these, like on August 17th, he went four innings, August 9th, three innings, July 11th, three innings, June 29th, three and two thirds innings.
So like he was giving you length even after that bullpen.
So the problem before was you could get through that first time through the rotation, but then it just started unraveling.
He went back to the bullpen and he showed that he fixed it all.
he came back, he scrapped, he basically stopped throwing his slider and his sweeper, which weren't working for him.
He threw his splitter more, which was a new pitch.
He debuted a brand new curve ball.
He essentially just, he revamped his arsenal.
He came back a different guy than he was before.
And I want to just point out a couple stats here.
Like in his 23 final appearances, he threw 55 and a third inning.
So he's averaging almost two innings per appearance.
He struck out 58.
He only walked 14.
He only gave up one Homer.
He had a 1.63 earned run average and a 1.03 whip.
He was dominant.
Like just shut down, shut down arm.
And so, you know what?
Yeah.
Let's see if you can get it for five or six innings instead of two or three.
I'm all for this.
If you can, if you can stretch him out a little bit and he can remain effective, then cool.
Let's do it.
So like, as opposed to last year, last year, I was like, what are we doing this for this year?
I'm looking at it and I'm saying, you know what?
Karin Majenski is a different pitcher now on February 16th than he was last spring.
And you know what?
I want to see what this looks like.
So let's go for it.
If it doesn't work, then put him back in the bullpen where he's clearly awesome.
Yeah.
So my takeaway on this is similar in the sense of, well, hey, it's spring.
This is where you get weird if you're going to do anything.
I'm not saying Karin Majenski being a starting pitcher is weird, but this is where you're going to do it.
Let's see if this is something.
Because for all the things you mentioned, it's true.
And he comes out and says, it's like, I haven't pitched.
I haven't been a starter for like how many years, you know?
So like going that deep was something I had to focus and worry on.
It affected the pitch shape.
I didn't have the right pitch mix.
And like you mentioned, like when he came, but yeah, he was working on that splitter.
It was like a brand new pitch.
He was picking David Bednar's head, working on that.
He finally felt more comfortable as he went to the bullpen.
Like you mentioned, he brings the curveball into and stuff like.
So he was a different pitcher.
He was dominant.
But isn't that why you want Karin Majenski in that role?
Because like, look how good you were.
You are a force.
And this bullpen can use a ball guy.
This bullpen can use a guy because you have Braxton Ashcraft and maybe Barco coming in and other younger arms.
Like there's a need for a bulk guy in the bullpen.
And if you can have one as good as that, we have a guy named Chris Devenski in this, in this organization now.
And he thrived at being a reliever who pitched 100 plus innings in a year.
And he was, you could argue he's the MVP of that Houston Astros team in the World Series because of what he did in that series.
And that's really good.
So, part of me is like, this is a real weapon, a true weapon on this team.
Karin Majenski is a weapon, not just a middle reliever.
This is a true weapon of how you can utilize him.
And this gives Don Kelly a lot of stuff to work with by having that.
So, that's like the give and take.
And, again, it's like, are you taking, like, he was really good in that role.
And, yes, all those numbers looked good.
They looked great because he only had to go two innings, right?
He only faces the lineup once.
Like, where he struggled was once he faced the lineup, the second, and, of course, the third, if he ever got to the third time.
Like, he just fell apart.
And part of that, I felt like he even admitted, was like he has to go deep in the games and just affect, like, the pitch shape.
Like, he just wasn't as effective going that deep in the games.
Can he do that?
That's what ultimately comes down to it.
It's not so much, like, are you a good pitcher and do you have this stuff?
Like, I think it's proven he's a good pitcher and has this stuff.
Can he do it throwing more than 50 pitches in a game?
Can he do it when he faces the lineup for the second time?
That's the biggest question.
I know he's really good.
Those numbers prove it.
That's what makes him so good in that role.
So, I don't know, man.
as the fifth starter, does he bring more value to this team?
Or does he bring more value being this lights-out, dominant force of a reliever that's going to give you two, even three innings at a time, if needed?
Again, it's spring.
I'm willing to see it.
The other sad part of this, too, is you're not going to see that until, like, the last week because you need to build up to get to those innings.
You know what?
It's not like the first three times you see him start, you just say, okay, you know what?
I'm comfortable being the fifth starter.
You just say, okay, so far he's done what I know he's good at.
Yeah.
You'll probably figure it out by, like, week three or so.
And it's not necessarily a matter of effect of, like, it's not a matter of, like, the results in spring training.
Like, we know that.
Like, they're going to be looking at, all right, is his stuff holding up throughout his outing?
Is his velocity holding up?
Is his, are his pitches not looking as good later in his outing as they are early in his outing?
Because, fatigue happens the same regardless if you're working up or working out.
Like, if you're stretched out to two innings, then you should be hitting your limit there at two innings, right?
So, yeah, we'll see how it works.
Like I said, spring's weird because it's hard to, it is really difficult to figure out.
Like, if you just, like, the naked eye, sometimes it's hard to figure out, like, if a guy's got it or not.
Because, one, he's sometimes facing inferior competition.
And it's just, it's just different.
We've all seen it.
We've all seen people have really good springs.
And then as soon as the season starts, it's like, boom, you suck.
Then we've seen the complete opposite.
We've seen people have really bad springs.
And then as soon as the season starts, it's like, well, flip a switch, we're on.
Like, we've seen both sides.
So, it's difficult to look at spring training results and really come to any conclusion.
You're going to have to dive a lot deeper into, like, what's going on here in order to make up your mind on this.
But, yeah, I don't think there's some comments in here.
Murphy says there's nothing to lose and a bunch to gain by letting him try it.
Bucko Commish, like, is there a zero to lose?
Because you can't have a first month like you did last year.
And I think the answer is just, like, you can't have a first month like you did last year.
No.
But also, Karnamajinsky is a different pitcher now than he was last year.
So, give him the shot in spring training to show it again.
And, you look at the fifth starter options right now, and unless they bring another veteran arm in, like, right now it's Urquidy versus Mlodzinski versus Barco.
That's basically the competition.
Yep.
So, again, I'm fine with it.
I just also, for one, don't think you're going to see what you want to see until later in spring anyways.
and so at that point in time, it's hard.
Again, like, this whole competition, it's just hard because, like, again, what you want to see from Mlodzinski to say and be comfortable with that you're the fifth starter is length.
And you're not really going to get length until late into spring.
So, we'll see what happens.
We'll see what happens.
I'm intrigued.
But, again, I just look like, again, I love him in the role that he's currently in.
I just, I love him in that role.
It's a big ups for the bullpen.
And is he going to be that much better than the other guys?
Well, I guess we'll find out.
But, at any rate, they're going to give him the opportunity.
I'm okay with it.
We'll see what happens.
I'm sure we'll be talking much more about this throughout spring.
But something to keep an eye out for.
For sure.
All right.
So, let's move on to our three things that we want to see from spring as it starts.
You want to start this one?
Sure.
I'll go with a guy who we haven't, I feel like we haven't talked about at all this offseason.
And it's Isaac Mattson.
Ooh.
He just came out of nowhere last year, right?
And we saw him the year prior pitch a little bit.
But, he was this 28-year-old journeyman reliever.
Oh, he used to play for the Washington Wild Things.
This is a cute story.
And then 2025 happens.
And he's awesome in AAA.
He gets called up.
And he's just a dog.
Just a dog.
And so, now he's to 30.
He's got almost a full year of major league experience under his belt.
We all know relievers can be volatile.
Like, that's just the name of the game here.
I want to know.
I want to see Isaac Mattson look as good as he looked last year.
Because this is where you look at the bullpen and you think it.
Right now, looking at the bullpen, it's like, this bullpen's not too bad.
But that's also assuming Isaac Mattson is 2025 Isaac Mattson.
And Isaac Mattson's only been that guy one time in his entire professional career.
And there's, 10 years to look at.
And so, that's my, that's something I want to look at is, how does Isaac Mattson look?
Does he still have that same swing and miss on the fastball?
Because I feel like that's what just, that was his thing last year.
Like, he was like, here's my fastball.
Try to hit it.
And they couldn't.
So, yeah.
Is that, will that be maintained this year?
Like, when he's throwing that fastball right down the middle, are people still just missing it?
Because that's how he got outs last year, was just attacking people with that fastball.
And so, that's the storyline that I want to look into is, yeah.
Does Isaac Mattson's fastball still look nasty?
if it's, if it's March 20th and he's throwing fastballs and they're getting, they're getting crushed, maybe it starts making me worry a little bit just because we haven't seen the track record from him.
I love Isaac Mattson.
I think he's going to be a big part of this bullpen.
But again, like, Santana, Soto, you trust those guys more just because you've seen it multiple times.
Mattson, we've seen it once.
And it was rather late in his career.
So, it's like, is that who he is right now?
Or did we just see lightning in a bottle, right?
So, Isaac Mattson's a storyline I'm looking at.
I like it.
And two, because we didn't really know how it was happening.
Like, it defied us.
Like, we don't understand it, but it's working.
So, like, yeah, is that magic still going to be there?
I do like that because he's a big part of this bullpen.
The thing I'm looking forward to this spring training is trash cans.
where does Oscar the Grouch live?
In a trash can.
And they took Oscar and they threw him away.
This rotation, this bullpen, apparently, this entire organization said, we want to do better than Oscar.
We're going to throw him away like Oscar the Grouch.
So, the Pirates just threw him out there in the trash can.
And while they're out there, they saw a group of people banging on some trash cans.
And that was interesting.
So, they walked over to the guys banging on trash cans, and they found former Astros pitching coach Bill Murphy.
And like, you know what?
We're going to take you home.
So, they found so much trash to bring their treasure.
I'm interested in what Bill Murphy is going to do with this pitching staff because a lot of praise.
He's coming from a good organization, did a lot of good stuff with pitchers.
And apparently, the Pirates said, Oscar is trash.
They had the sixth best rotation last year.
They had a good pitching staff.
And they said, no, we can do better.
So, I wanted them to prove it to me.
I'm interested to see what this guy and Billy is going to do with this pitching staff.
What's his stamp?
What's he going to do differently?
what's funny was like when Brent Strom came in, of course, he didn't get to show us anything because he got injured.
But it's the same dynamic, and we're not going to see it right away.
But like, Jared Jones, like, can Bill Murphy unlock this third pitch for Jared Jones to make him a true force?
that was something we were looking at last offseason, with Jared.
Hey, who knows?
With Isaac Mattson, is there maybe something he can unlock that's more than just a fastball?
So, he has another trick up his sleeve to get past hitters.
I'm really interested to see what Bill Murphy does to stamp this pitching department and turn this already really good staff into this fierce force that they believe they can be.
So, trash cans.
Yeah, that was interesting, right?
Like, I think at the end of last year, you would have thought, hey, if there's one thing that's working on this team, it's the pitching staff.
So, you would just assume that Oscar Marin would be retained.
But like I said, this is Don Kelly's coaching staff.
The pitchers, apparently, were like, I think we can all be a little bit better.
And so, they went a different direction.
And they went with the younger, up-and-coming guy in Bill Murphy.
He's had some experience with a couple of these arms in the past.
So, yeah, that's an interesting pick.
I don't know how much we're going to learn from a pitching coach over the spring.
Well, I guess I look at it this way, too.
It's like, you really haven't heard much from him.
Now that he is there in spring, I'm sure you'll hear a lot of more interviews, a lot of more quotes, people, maybe even players, talking about him and such.
So, I'm interested to learn more about, like, what he is going to do.
what is his philosophy?
What is he trying to do to unlock these guys, make Carmen Mijinsky an effective fifth starter?
Yeah.
the last time José Urquidy was a good pitcher was with Bill Murphy, too.
So, maybe he can unlock something there again.
Okay.
I like it.
I'm going to go with the, if you remember back in December, excuse me, if you remember back in December, there were a lot of guys added to the roster to protect them from the Rule 5 draft.
It was way more than we expected to.
I think we were all on board that, Valdez was going to be protected.
We were all on board that Kelly was going to be protected.
Otel, another name that we thought.
And then we were like, eh, maybe Bidwa, maybe Harbin.
But they protected all of them.
They protected all of these guys.
On top of that, they also protected Jack Branigan, who we haven't really seen a lot of because he got hurt early last year.
And when he was playing, it's not like he was doing anything spectacular in Altoona.
So, I'm going to be looking at all those newbies to the 40 man that they protected.
But, like, Bidwa, Harbin, their stuff's going to be electric all spring.
I think we're just, like, just be, just expect that.
Dotel, Kelly, they're going to get some time.
Neither of which I think are going to make the team.
But I am very interested on just, like, how Jack Branigan looks.
Because I would not have put this dude on the 40-man roster at all.
I don't think anybody would have selected him.
Like, he has 59 games in AA.
He's 24 years old, turns 25 later next month.
There's, like, nothing that jumps out the charts at you as to why Jack Branigan was protected.
But there's a reason Jack Branigan was protected.
So, yeah.
The fact that he can play shortstop probably means he's going to get a little bit of playing time this spring, too.
Because with Gonzalez playing for Team Mexico, your shortstops are, you got Triolo, Gonzalez, and Branigan.
Like, those are the three guys who are even capable of playing the position.
And you expect Triolo's going to get a lot of time at third base, too.
So, we'll probably see a good amount of Jack Branigan this spring.
And he's not going to make the team.
Probably not going to make the team.
But, yeah.
Like, how does Jack Branigan look?
Like, how does the glove look?
How does he look at the plate?
Because, like, we all know the glove's good.
Like, that's been his calling card.
But he showed some power in Greensboro.
And, like I said, adding him to the 40-man, it means there's something there that they see in him.
And so, I would like to see what that is.
Because, up to this point, I haven't seen it.
So, yeah.
Jack Branigan in particular, but that whole group of the new 40-man guys.
I like that for sure.
Because all of them, maybe Jack Branigan a little less, but all of them could certainly have some impact this year.
But, Brenigan, this could be a big year for him to make him, like, hey, this is why I'm on the 40-man.
Surprise.
I'd love to see that.
I just don't really know if he has it.
But we'll find out.
Okay.
So, the thing I want to see.
You know what?
It's not so much seeing.
I want to hear it.
I want to hear it.
In spite of justice, De LaSantos.
John Fogarty.
Centerfield.
Great song.
Especially for spring training.
Centerfield.
Put me in, coach.
Cruz is ready to play.
Look at he.
He can be centerfield.
He's working out with Kevin Kiermaier for a little bit.
For a little bit until Kevin apparently got hired by the Rays right away.
Because he's like, none of that.
None of that.
You're helping other guys?
No.
We're going to hire you now.
you hear a lot of good stuff about him on this offseason.
For whatever you mean by the way here.
he's been working out.
He's been working hard.
Don Kelly's been hyping up and talking about him.
as soon as he left, he's been going to work.
We heard Kelly say that at the winter meetings.
You've heard Kelly say that, as pitchers and catches report with O'Neal himself and his agents.
Right.
When Kevin Kiermaier announced that he wanted to do this, like he want to work with players specifically.
The next day, O'Neal's agent was on the phone with Kevin Kiermaier arranging that, hey, you're going to work out with Oneil Cruz.
And we know Oneil Cruz had a terrible season last year.
Offensively, defensively, within the margins, like in every possible way outside of stealing bases, essentially.
I want to see how he looks in center field this year.
because, you saw last year, of course, he's so athletic.
He can make up for it.
Right.
But it wasn't pretty.
And certainly at the beginning of the year, like it wasn't pretty.
Has anything changed?
he'll have minimal opportunities, but he'll have enough.
does he look different out there?
Does he look more comfortable?
What's his mindset?
I want to see, is he more aggressive at the plate this year than he was last year?
I want to almost, it's weird to say this, but like, I want to see vintage Cruz back.
Better pitch selection.
But like, I want to see him more aggressive at the plate.
I want him up there.
Like, I want to do damage.
I feel like that's the best version of, oh, no Cruz.
Now, yes, don't swing at the slider a foot off the plate away from you.
Right.
Do better there, which he was getting better at.
But it's like, maybe not watch strike three go by so often.
get aggressive early in accounts, on the pitches that you can do damage on.
I'm focused on center fielder, oh, no Cruz.
He's going to be a big part of this team if they're good.
Tyler says it more often than not among all of us.
All these moves are great, but they really don't do much unless Bryan Reynolds and Ohno Cruz get back on track to what they could be and have been in the past.
So, a lot of eyes for me is going to be on Ohno Cruz.
Is this a different player?
Is this a guy who's ready to come into 2026 and compete?
Yeah, that's a good one because a lot of the season rides on him.
Like you said, it was like Tyler, you it's like the Wayne Gretzky, Michael Scott.
But yeah, a lot of the moves that they made, they don't matter.
Like they don't matter unless Bryan Reynolds and Ohno Cruz do better.
Those two have to do better.
And Ohno Cruz still is the one guy who has the ceiling because you just see it.
You see the athleticism, you see what he's capable of doing out there on the baseball field.
His ceiling is still higher than any of these guys that they brought in.
Like Brandon Lowe is very capable of putting up, a 30 plus Homer season.
So is Ozuna.
Ryan O'Hearn could probably hit you 20, 25 in a really good year.
But like Ohno Cruz, we saw it for a month and a half last year, right?
Like where he's pacing to be this 40 guy.
That's the upside he has.
Now, it's a matter of can he actually do it?
Because we haven't been able to see him do it for an entire year at that level.
We saw him do it in parts of one year and then parts of another year where if you look at these arbitrary endpoints, it looks really nice.
But like we still haven't seen him put together like a full, complete, awesome season.
And maybe we'll never see it, right?
That's a, that's a possibility.
We might never see that happen from Ohno Cruz, but he is, he is the one offensive player on this team who is capable of giving you that five, six, seven war season that we've kind
So yeah, now the chances of that happening are low.
Like that's his 90th percentile outcome, but he, we've seen it from, we've seen it from him in stretches that he can just absolutely dominate on the baseball field.
So I like that one.
The one thing I'll point out defensively, it's going to, it's hard to outfield defense is tough down there in Florida.
we've seen it's sometimes even more interesting.
Yeah.
It's like games to be the baseball.
So, there may be times where he looks very silly out there because that's just how everyone looks.
But think about this too, right?
Cause balls fly there and like word.
He looked the most uncomfortable balls at the wall.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Anyways.
Yeah.
All right.
I'll end it with my third thing that I'm looking for and I've got, I've got two that I'm teetering back and forth on.
I'm just going to go with the obvious.
I'm going to go with the biggest storyline this spring, in my opinion.
if Konnor Griffin truly has a chance to make this team, I expect him to take that opportunity and absolutely run with it.
Now it's possible.
He couldn't, he could go out there and he could, he could not have a great spring.
It's a small sample size.
It's possible.
You can go out there and not look that great.
The best competition he's ever played against.
I don't expect that to happen.
I expect him to go out there.
If he's competing for a job, I think he's going to go out there and he's going to look like the best player on the field.
And I think he's going to put together a spring that makes the pirates have a really tough decision at the end of it.
And hopefully that tough decision is just, we've got to bring him up because he's the best option.
And hopefully it's not, oh, well, if we bring him up now, it starts his clock and raises his value.
So if there are extension talks, it's going to be that much more.
Like, I just hope that doesn't happen.
cause like if he's ready, you're trying to win this year, like make it happen.
But I'm going to be like, I, obviously that's going to be the biggest thing I'm looking at this spring is Konnor Griffin.
And it's not even really just a numbers thing.
It's how does he look?
How does he look at shortstop?
How does he look at the plate?
Is he, does he seem overmatched in any way?
Or does he seem like he's having, like, is he controlling at bats?
Is he making adjustments?
Is he doing these things that you want to see someone do, where, if you're 19 years old, you're so far ahead of where you should be that it makes you think this kid's just, he's just special.
He's going to be something special.
And I think we all know he's going to be something special, but this will be the first time we really get to see it over like a full spring against better competition.
Like, Hey, show us, show us how special you are.
Maybe.
Yeah.
That's, I had him on list too.
I say this at the end also, because I'm like, we know we both have Konnor Griffin on here.
So I'll let Jim decide if he's going to take him.
If not, I'll ensure I have him.
Yeah, absolutely, man.
Because like, my last one was Oneil Cruz difference maker, but like, if there was a true difference maker on this team, it's not actually Connor.
The feelings I want to catch is good vibes on these catchers.
Because that's a pretty important position on any team.
And that's one of this team has a lot of question marks and they invested a lot into one of them when Henry Davis is our number one overall pick who was the can't miss hitting prospect.
Now, can he field?
We'll find out, but he can't not hit.
Turns out it's quite the opposite.
He's one of the best defensive catchers on this team in this org and he can't hit.
It's been abysmal.
And every year so far, even last year with a good defensive metrics, the hitting was so poor.
He's yet to put up a positive war season.
According to fan graphs at four.
He's a guy that you don't want to doubt.
He's a hard worker.
Has he maybe just invested so much work into the defense to get it?
I'm not looking forward to him like, oh, is he going to make the roster?
But again, as we've seen year after year, you need more than two catchers on any team.
Endy and Henry were going to be difference makers.
Is Endy back to like, hey, can he be part of his organization?
Or is he just the leftovers of what could have been?
Is he healthy?
He's going to be a big part because he has those vibes, too.
I love I love Endy.
the first day of Pitching and Catching, you saw a video of him and he's talking about the password.
He's like, oh, the password, because I'm the username.
I'm just like, this guy's just so great for this team.
And again, not stopping there, like Rafael Flores.
They made a trade with David Bednar.
You traded and got this guy.
you can't not miss on that.
Like, show me the reason why he was the guy.
We know there's a lot of swing and miss in his game.
Right.
And again, like, I understand it's spring training.
Right.
But like, I want to see how he looks.
Is that cleaned up?
Is he potential to be on this roster at some point in time to be, a factor?
So pretty much everyone but Joey Bart.
I'm looking forward at the catcher spot in this offseason to see, like, who they are.
Yeah.
Joey Bart, I think, is what he is at this point.
I think he's a league average hitter, below average defensive catcher.
He's fine if he's on your team.
Maybe he lacks.
He might not even be on the team.
Come on.
Might not even be on the team.
But no, it's a good.
It's a good thing.
You need, you really could, like, if one of those three guys can, like, really, truly step up and turn themselves into a legitimate major league catcher.
And when one of those three guys, Davis, Andy, and Flores.
You've invested a lot into all of those guys, really.
One of them you used a first overall pick on.
The other one you traded your hometown all-star closer for.
The other one you traded a starting pitcher who was, like, the only good piece you had left in the best starting pitcher you had this century before Paul Skenes when, trading him.
So, yeah, you've got a lot invested into that position, and you need one of those guys to hit.
Yeah, for sure.
Hopefully it's Henry.
Literally.
hopefully it's all three.
But, like, one of them has to figure it out and become a legit MLB player.
Yes.
So we just haven't seen it yet.
Yep.
Unfortunately, that one has been very redundant.
That's what I'm looking for.
I think all of us every spring training.
Yeah.
Yeah.
But, again, seeing how we never, well, I'll exclude you from this.
We never thought Henry Davis would be a good catcher.
We felt he might be adequate.
And he's done wonders there.
So, like, why doubt on that he can't focus and do that on the bat as well?
At least we knew that was in him at one point.
Yeah.
Yeah.
And when he was drafted, he was expected to be a hitter.
We just haven't seen him yet.
Right.
At the major league level.
So there's all of our three things we're looking forward to this spring.
Which, by the way, Jim, we'll be starting to see them in less than a week.
Yeah.
Saturday, my plane lands down there.
Next Sunday, we'll be doing a live show from Lee Com Park.
That's the home opener for the Pirates down there.
So we'll be down there for that.
We'll be down there for every other home game after that for two weeks.
So, yeah, looking forward to that.
Our next Bucco Brew will be live from Bradenton.
So next Monday morning, we'll be live from Bradenton.
We'll have already seen a game, too.
So there'll be plenty to talk about.
But, yeah, looking forward to the trip.
Should be a lot of fun.
spring training is just the best.
I love it.
It is.
It is.
And, again, as I've talked about before, two weeks.
We'll be there for two weeks.
Now, I'll be there the first weekend.
I'll be there Saturday and for the game on Sunday.
Then I'm coming back home, driving back up here.
Week one is going to be you, Tyler, Cody, and Doug.
So they got you guys covered.
They'll be in Bradenton for the whole first full week.
And then on Saturday, we're doing a switch.
That's when I come back in.
A line change.
Yeah.
There it is.
A line change.
Yeah.
Out goes Sidney Crosby and Malkin.
In comes whatever us losers would be.
I don't know hockey that much.
Obviously.
But, anyways.
Yeah.
So then I'll be coming in.
Neil will be coming in.
Nathan will be coming in.
Ryan.
And I said Neil, huh?
Yeah.
Ryan, at some capacity, we'll have different dates and all that.
But we'll be down there for two weeks covering you all.
We'll be eight full games at Lecom that we'll be doing shows at.
We'll be there for.
Lots of cool content coming.
I can't wait.
I'm excited.
Do we want to actually make the announcement here about the thing that we had Cody make last night?
Yeah.
Why not?
Why not?
Why not?
I was also on IG, Facebook, post on Twitter as well.
Comments· 1
Should Carmen Mlodzinski be the Pirates' fifth starter, or stay a multi-inning bullpen weapon?