Alex Stumpf breaks down the three biggest reasons the Pirates could miss the playoffs in 2026, from workload concerns in the rotation to bullpen volatility to real defensive questions.
Watch or listen to OffBeat with Alex Stumpf on North Shore Nine.

Alex Stumpf breaks down the three biggest reasons the Pirates could miss the playoffs in 2026, from workload concerns in the rotation to bullpen volatility to real defensive questions.
Watch or listen to OffBeat with Alex Stumpf on North Shore Nine.
With Alex Stumpf.
The young rotation doesn't have the workload history to cover a full season. Chandler topped out at 131.1 innings, Ashcraft at 118, Barco at 102.1 and Mlodzinski at 114.2. Stumpf expected the Pirates to sign a starter and thinks the innings crunch will show up in August and September.
Dennis Santana is the only reliever with two solid years behind him (2024–25). Lawrence, Mattson, Montgomery and Soto are all wild cards, so the bullpen could go off the rails.
Don Kelly is right to use Santana by leverage instead of as a strict ninth-inning closer. Stumpf doesn't want to lose a game with Mason Montgomery pitching in the seventh or Justin Lawrence in the eighth.
Signing Azuna and moving Ryan O'Hearn from first base to right field is a mistake. O'Hearn was brought in to lead, and Stumpf saw him as a possible Gold Glove nominee at first.
This could be the worst Pirates defense Stumpf has covered. The projected lineup comes out to -13 outs above average, compared with +9 last year, and that hurts a team built on its pitching.
Opening day is finally right around the corner. In the next two days, we're going to do a two-part podcast here.
We're going to give all the reasons why the Pirates will make the postseason and why they won't make the postseason.
Good morning and welcome to OffBeat here on North Shore Nine presented by FanDuel.
My name is Alex Stumpf. I am going to be in New York for opening day this year.
Looking forward to it. And before we get there, I think we have to just take one more look at this Pirates team.
We saw what happened in the offseason. We saw what happened in spring training. We know the moves. We know the 26 guys they're heading north with.
Did they do enough? Because the goal this offseason was to build a team that was going to make the postseason, period, full stop.
I don't think you have to squint too hard to see how this could work out.
I don't think you need to be that pessimistic to see how this won't work out.
So a lot of the projections I see have the Pirates around 80, low 80 wins, and maybe that's a wild card.
But let's just look at it. Brass tacks.
I'm going to give you three reasons today why they will not make the postseason.
And then on opening day Thursday, I'm going to give you three reasons why they will make the postseason.
We'll end on the positive going into opening day with hope.
Because you know that hope springs eternal.
So there we go. We're going to start off with three reasons why they won't.
And I'm going to be a buzzkill here.
And I'm going to talk about the starting pitching.
Now, spoiler, tomorrow's list is going to start with the starting pitcher also.
And it's, going to be the reasons why they're going to make the playoffs.
You know how good it is.
I have just one big point with this pitching staff that I think really needs addressed.
And that's workload.
That's innings.
Paul Skenes, we saw last year, he was able to go, flirt with 200 innings.
He was able to do the full season.
He was able to take that big leap.
But there was also a period where he was doing five and dives.
There was a period where he was just trying to manage the innings midseason and at the end of the season.
So that was just one pitcher, though.
One big notable pitcher.
There's a couple guys here that I'm just looking back at the envelope here.
I don't know how they're going to bridge all these innings.
Because you got Skenes, you got Keller.
I'm not really worried about those two guys.
But then you got Bubba Chandler, who is maxed out at 131 in a third innings as a professional in a season.
Taking both the major leagues and minor leagues.
That was last season.
That's a decent enough workload that you can do the 20%-ish, inning jump.
And it's not, that catastrophic.
And it's also what you would expect from full season.
So, okay, that's good.
But Braxton Ashcraft maxed out at 118.
And that was last year.
And that was after he pushed that he could go more than, what was originally planned.
Like, he did more innings than the Pirates had initially planned last year.
Okay.
Hunter Barco has maxed out on 102 in a third innings.
That was last year.
He's going to be starting the bullpen.
I talked about it yesterday.
How he needs to pitch six months in a season.
And maybe pitching out of the bullpen in a little bit is a way for him to get used to pitching six months.
But also manage the innings.
Still going to be asking for a lot of innings out of him.
Carmen Mlodzinski maxed out at 114 in two thirds.
Yurkiti, 111 in a third inning since 2022 across the major leagues or minor leagues.
Yeah.
There's not a lot of guys here that I feel really good about the workload they're going to give.
And that's why all offseason I thought they were going to sign a starting pitcher.
Like, they did get Yurkiti at the end.
But, like, that wasn't really what I thought they were going to do.
They put more eggs and resources into hitting.
And it's hard to argue with that.
But I think you also need just those guys that you feel comfortable that they can go five, six innings.
They're not going to put the bullpen in a tough spot.
They can protect these young starting pitchers.
This is something that I think is going to really rear its face around August and September.
And they could supplement this by acquiring a starting pitcher at the deadline, a veteran.
And that's also resources, going to something that I...
It's the team's strength.
Everyone knows this team's strength is the starting rotation.
If this team is going to be good, it is going to be on the back of these young pitchers.
I just don't know how much workload they could actually take on.
And that transitions to the second point here of why they will not make the postseason.
And it's the bullpen.
I feel good about Dennis Santana.
I think Dennis is a really solid guy to put in the back-ending games.
He's not going to be strictly the ninth-inning guy.
That's something I was teasing this offseason.
Don Kelly said it to reporters in Bradenton.
He's not going to be the sole closer.
they could go by leverage.
They can go by opportunities.
That's good.
I don't know about the rest of the bullpen, though.
Like, I like Justin Lawrence.
I think he offers a unique arm angle.
I think he offers a pretty good pedigree here.
But he was also a waiver claim last year and then missed a lot of last year with that shoulder injury.
I personally really like him, but he is a wild card.
Isaac Mattson, a guy I really like.
I really like the fastball shape, the way that he just attacks hitters, the way that he's developed some off-speed stuff to go with it.
But, just someone who is coming in with a different arm angle and just pounding the strike zone.
And, okay, well, that's good.
But he also came out of nowhere last year.
And it raises the question, like, well, what do you do there?
How much can you count on him?
He's a wild card.
Mason Montgomery, that fastball velocity is great.
It's elite.
He also had a really rough season last year.
He is a wild card.
Gregory Soto, former two-time All-Star, solid guy a couple years ago, but has struggled a bit the last couple years.
He is a wild card.
And then you put in the two middle relievers and then, like, a Yohan Ramirez.
And you just look at this rotation, or this bullpen, I'm sorry, and you're like, I could see this going south.
I could see, it being good that, if, like, a Brandon Benoit comes up or anything.
But, again, rookie.
Hasn't pitched in the majors.
Wild card.
There are just not a lot of certainty in this bullpen right now.
And I don't say that out of malice.
I just say it as fact.
Dennis Santana is really the only guy who has two solid years of track work.
Like, he's in 2024 and 2025.
He's the only guy who's coming in here with two solid years as a head of steam.
I think he is a fine guy to have in the ninth inning, or if you want to chase, leverage spot with him.
If the biggest out of the game is going to be in the seventh or the eighth, I'm fine with that.
I applaud Don Kelly for being willing to use his best pitchers in the biggest spots.
That's something that I think a lot of managers wish they could do.
But, the history of the closer spot, you always try to have that guy in the back end there.
I don't think they need to do that there.
And I think they need to take that approach because I don't know if I want to lose a game with Mason Montgomery in the seventh inning.
I don't know if I want to lose a game with Justin Lawrence in the eighth.
I'm fine with using Dennis Santana in those big spots.
There needs to be more leverage arms that emerge here or firmly establish themselves in the case of, like, Mattson and Lawrence.
And there needs to be a couple guys in that middle relief or that, up-down role who take that next step forward.
Now, I say this.
They're not all going to bust.
Like, it's as simple as that.
Like, some of these guys are going to take a step forward.
Like, I wouldn't be shocked in the least if Isaac Mattson has another good year.
If he has another year with a two-something ERA, he keeps showing that fastball, he goes, that's great.
But bullpens are volatile, and one good year doesn't necessarily guarantee anything.
Having really good stuff like a Mason Montgomery doesn't necessarily guarantee anything.
Bullpen has a lot of question marks.
It could be a strength of this team, but we're going to see.
I think there's a lot that could go off the rails here.
I'm going to throw it to Cody here for a minute, then I'm going to come back with my third reason.
This episode is brought to you by IQ Bar, our exclusive snack hydration sponsor.
IQ Bar protein bars, IQ Mix hydration mixes, and IQ Joe Mushroom coffees are the delicious, low-sugar, brain and body fuel you need to win your day.
The Ultimate Sampler Pack is a great way for you to try all IQ Bar products and flavors.
You get nine IQ Bars, eight IQ Mix Sticks, and four IQ Joe Sticks.
All IQ Bar products are clean label certified and entirely free from gluten, dairy, soy, GMOs, and artificial ingredients.
With over 20,000 five-star reviews and counting, more people than ever are fueling their lifestyles with IQ Bar's brain and body boosting bars, hydration mixes, and mushroom coffees, the Ultimate Sampler Pack includes all three.
My personal favorites so far have been the Almond Butter Chip and the Iced Tea Lemonade Hydration Mix.
It's just really full of flavor.
I love starting my day with it, and I couldn't imagine starting my day with anything else other than IQ Bar products.
Right now, IQ Bar is offering our podcast listeners 20% off all IQ Bar products, including the Ultimate Sampler Pack, plus free shipping.
To get your 20% off, text MLB to 64000.
That's MLB 64000.
Message and data rates may apply.
See terms for details.
So he's talked about the starting pitching depth and maybe not having enough innings to bridge the whole year.
Talked about the bullpen question marks, but there's one other thing here whenever I'm really looking at this team that is led by pitching, that is going to need their pitching to succeed, to be a good club.
This isn't a good defense.
Like, I think this defense is, it has the potential to be the worst defense that I have personally covered for the Pirates.
And yeah, trading Ke'Bryan Hayes is going to be a big part of that.
I get, he's, you lost a Gold Glover there.
Jared Triolo won a Gold Glover, won a Gold Glover as a utility player.
He's got to play shortstop for a little bit.
I imagine he's got to go back to third base whenever Konnor Griffin is called up.
That could be a good left side of the infield.
Defensively, Konnor Griffin, a minor league Gold Glover.
Jared Jones, utility Gold Glover, best at third base.
Okay, that's good.
What about the rest of the diamond?
Brandon Lowe had negative 10 outs above average last year.
And yeah, injuries were part of that.
He talked about that in his introduction to the team.
That's fine.
He feels he can do better.
He feels he's in a better spot physically.
But last year was really bad.
Last year was really bad.
I thought Ryan O'Hearn was going to be the first baseman whenever they signed him.
And he offers so much at that position.
And then they signed Azuna.
And that means that O'Hearn has to go to right field.
And it just hasn't really sat well with me because he was brought in to be a leader on this team.
And part of that leader is you have to see him succeed on the field.
That's how you earn that credibility.
That's how you maintain that credibility.
And he is not going to be in the best spot defensively.
Now, I think he could handle right field.
And he's still going to play some first base.
But he's someone who I thought could have been a Gold Glove nominee at first base.
And they're putting him in the corner outfield.
That also means that Bryan Reynolds, who did not grade well last year defensively, is going to go over to left field.
Which is far more cabiness and bigger.
he's done it before.
Maybe he could do it again.
But, yeah, I think Bryan Reynolds' best defensive days are behind him.
And he's going to be covering a whole lot more ground in 2026.
And then Oneil Cruz worked with Kevin Kiermaier.
Maybe he could be, an impact outfield right there.
But he graded out positively via OAA.
I think he will again this year.
But I'm just looking at it.
A starting rotation, or starting lineup, I'm sorry, of Joey Bark behind the plate.
Horwitz, Brandon Lowe.
We're going to go with Triolo at shortstop.
Nick Gonzales and Nick Yorke, I'm basically counting as a wash zero at third base.
Even though they're both playing out of position, I feel like I'm being generous with that.
Bryan Reynolds, Oneil Cruz, Ryan O'Hearn.
That's negative 13 outs above average.
Where last year, they were plus nine.
That's a big swing.
And that hurts the pitching staff.
And that is the part of this team that needs to succeed for this team to succeed.
So, we'll see.
I just see some red flags.
But you know what?
Tomorrow, it's only going to be the green flags.
We're going to look at the three reasons why the Pirates will make the playoffs next year.
Be sure to subscribe to North Shore Nine presented by FanDuel so you can check it out.
Thank you so much for listening.
We'll talk again tomorrow.
All right.
That wraps up this episode of North Shore Nine.
Thanks so much for tuning in.
Whether you're listening on the podcast or catching us on YouTube, if you enjoyed the show, please give this video a thumbs up.
And don't forget to hit that subscribe button if you haven't already.
It really helps us grow.
And if you're listening on the podcast, a quick review goes a long way in helping others find the show.
Plus, be sure to tell a friend about us.
There's always room for more here in the NS9 community.
And for those looking to support us a little more, consider joining our Patreon.
Become an MVP member and get exclusive perks while helping us continue to bring you more of the Pirates content you love.
Thanks again for all your support.
And let's go Bucs.
Thanks again for all your support, and let's go Bucs.
Thanks again for all your support, and let's go Bucs.
Thanks again for all your support, and let's go Bucs.
Thanks again for all your support, and let's go Bucs.
Thanks again for all your support, and let's go Bucs.
Thanks again for all your support, and let's go Bucs.
Thanks again for all your support, and let's go Bucs.
Thanks again for all your support, and let's go Bucs.
Thanks again for all your support, and let's go Bucs.
Thanks again for all your support, and let's go Bucs.
Thanks again for all your support, and let's go Bucs.
And let's go Bucs.
Thank you.
Comments· 0
Was it a mistake to move Ryan O'Hearn off first base to play right field?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.