The Pirates appear to be heading toward one of their biggest offseason decisions: whether Ben Cherington returns for an eighth season as general manager. DiNardo, Jim and Tyler debate whether the progress made in 2026 outweighs seven seasons without a winning record or playoff appearance. They also discuss whether finishing .500 matters, what another Cherington offseason could look like, and prospects Wyatt Sanford and Easton Carmichael heading to the Arizona Fall League.
Ben Cherington Year Eight? Pirates Face a Massive Decision.
With Anthony DiNardo, Jim Rosati and Tyler Sweeney.
Chapters
Key takeaways
- 1
A Pirates team one game under .500 in Ben Cherington's seventh year is at best an average job, and that should not be enough to keep his job.
- 2
There's no good reason to bring Cherington back. If the worry is that a new GM would tear it down, just tell them not to. Their job would be to take Skenes and Griffin and make the playoffs.
- 3
Cherington has made one good trade in seven years, the Brandon Lowe deal, so he shouldn't be the one trading players near the end of their contracts, like Oneil Cruz.
- 4
The Pirates are worse than the Cleveland Browns, and probably the worst franchise in professional sports.
- 5
If losing the last nine games raised the odds of Cherington being fired, it would be worth it, because a different GM gives the team a better chance to win sooner.
Players discussed
Full transcript1000 paragraphs · show
Yo, welcome to the North Shore Nine podcast presented by FanDuel, this is NS9 Live, I'm your host, Anthony DiNardo, with We Got Jim, We Got Ty, fellas, how y'all?
What are y'all doing tonight? Full crew tonight. It's been a while. Look at that. Has been a while. For real. This team is just so exciting to talk about currently that we all made time for this. Yeah. Canceled all of our plans. I was going to be in Costa Rica. I was like, nope, can't do it. Yep, we were all just yearning for another opportunity to talk about our 2026 Pittsburgh Pirates.
Yeah. Yearn. Yearn is a good word to use. Yeah. Yeah. How about that? What a big eventful night, too. We got football back. Thursday night football is on. Pitt's apparently playing tonight also. But again, things got to stop. We got to talk about the Pittsburgh Pirates.
Naturally. Naturally. Yeah, nobody wants to watch that stuff anyways.
Yeah, who cares about football in mid-September?
No, I just, I just win fantasy games. That's all. I don't have to watch the games out of windows.
Yeah.
But anyways, yeah, we definitely should talk some things here. There's only now, what, nine games left of the season.
Again, coming quickly.
Can't believe it. we're already talking Arizona Fall League and our plans for that. And it's just like, I thought we just had spring training.
But there's nine games left in the season.
And there's already some off-season potential news creeping up here. Buster Olney has reported.
Jason Mackey, I believe, on the fan was talked to ask this question as well.
Both perspectives, they envision Ben Cherington being back next year.
Year eight, 2027.
So that's going to be a big topic tonight on our show, along other things.
So, fellas, you just want to kick it off and get into this?
Let's just get into it. Yeah.
Buster Olney yesterday, the wording he used was, it would be a surprise.
This is a quote.
It would be a surprise at this point if there is a change at general manager for the Pirates.
And he basically cites that Pittsburgh has clearly improved this year.
They're bringing back a talented group of young players, including Konnor Griffin.
And, they were, they were in the wildcard race for a good chunk of the season.
So, yeah, he says it would be a surprise at this point.
I think Mackey's words were pretty similar.
Like, I think he fully expects Ben Cherington to be back in 2027 was his words.
So, yeah, it hasn't really like been come out yet.
Like we haven't heard anything from the team as of yet.
I know last year when it came to this decision, we heard like the last homestand of the year.
It was like, hey, everybody was told they're coming back.
So we haven't received that yet from the team, but all signs are pointing to everyone who has said anything on the topic is pointing towards, everybody sticking in their spot.
So, yep, that's what it sounds like.
It just, even the way they've operated seems like a group that isn't exactly on the hot seat.
we didn't, we saw a little bit of urgency during the trade deadline, but throughout this year, I don't think we've seen a ton of urgency from this team or this front office.
we saw what I'd say is a, like, I think we'd all agree.
It was a much more aggressive off season.
and it did seem like a group that was on the hot seat, but the way that they have operated since basically spring training seems like they were pretty safe.
So as frustrating as it might be, or at least in my opinion, very frustrating, I don't know that it's the biggest surprise in the world, but you never know.
Things could change.
Like I thought Neil Huntington would be back eight years ago or whatever it was as well.
So you never know.
But as of now, it's not the biggest surprise in the world.
It just, it's definitely frustrating.
Yeah.
Like you make a good, a good point too.
They could essentially say, he's safe.
That was what happened with Huntington, right?
Hurdle got the ax.
We know the infamous riding out on the golf cart last game.
He had the opportunity to say, Hey, do you want to manage this last game?
He was like, Nope.
See y'all later.
And he left.
And then they came out and said that, Kunle and Huntington will be back.
And they were until they decided that, you know what, we're going to change our minds here and ax them.
And then in November, that's when they hired Ben Cherington and everything else follows afterwards.
So, yeah, you make a good point.
They could right now, here's the rumbles, I'm not going to, that's going to happen, of course.
Right.
But, we haven't heard anything as of yet, but I even internally feel, I think we talked about on Bucco Brew, that I'm ready that he's going to return.
I would, I would be more shocked to hear, honestly, I would be more shocked to hear that he was fired and others opposed to coming back.
Doesn't mean I side with that, but that's where I feel this regime and Bob Nutting and company is probably going to go.
Yeah, I'm at the point right now where I expect everybody to return.
And what's, what's interesting about this situation is if this were like any other year, like if this were 2023 and the pirates were in this position, I'd be like, okay, I'm feeling pretty good about 2024.
Oh yeah.
Like they're clearly making improvements.
This team is in a much better spot right now than they were previously.
Even if you look just into like the players returning for next year, what you've got going on, like this pirates team, like you don't have to do too much.
This obviously don't think like you got, you've got to make some additions.
You've got to make some changes here and there, but like, this isn't like a massive overhaul that needs to be done.
Like we're talking about adding a player here, adding a player there, and you look like you're in a pretty good spot.
The problem here is two years ago, we were told that Ben Cherington was going to be retained along with Derek Shelton and that they would be accountable together.
the results would matter.
They would be accountable together.
Well, guess what?
They weren't only one of those per, only one of those people was held accountable.
And that was Derek Shelton.
He was fired a month and a half into the next season, Ben Cherington somehow stuck around this off season.
Travis Williams says, yeah, playoffs period, full stop.
This team got better this year.
That's undeniable.
This team got better this year, but they're not making the playoffs, which makes 11 years in a row without making the playoffs.
So it's just, you're not in that situation where, all right, yeah, this is year three or four of Ben Cherington and we're feeling pretty good.
We're on the upswing.
This is year seven of Ben Cherington.
We haven't had a winning season yet.
We're still below 500 as of now.
We're one, the tragic number is one, right?
So one Padres win away from officially being eliminated with the E next to your name or one Pirates loss from officially being eliminated.
Like this has been, this is a failure.
They failed yet again for the seventh year in a row.
And you can, you can argue maybe the first four years, they didn't really try, but whatever it was the last three years, they were trying and they failed and then they failed.
Ben Cherington has done a good job.
These last 12 months or so.
Like, I think he's done a pretty decent job, but like at what point do your words matter?
Cause they didn't matter two years ago and apparently they're not mattering now.
So next year, whenever you say, whenever the question is, Hey, like what's the expectation?
What's the goal?
And you still like, if you don't meet it next year that like, am I supposed to believe you next year that winning actually matters?
Because so far you've told me the last few years that it's time to win and you're going to be held accountable if you don't win.
And that hasn't happened.
So it's like, at what point do we stop believing you?
At what point do we just say like, does those winning actually matter to you, Bob Nutting?
Or does it not matter at all?
Just to, and this is more of a nitpick and it's more of what I think we've heard from Pirates fans in general and what Jim just said about Ben Cherington doing a good job in the last 12 months.
Cause we've heard a lot of that and that's truthfully probably why he will be back is because there's a belief that he's done a good job over to this last calendar year or whatever it is.
There's still a game below 500.
That's not a good job.
That's not good enough.
You're on year seven.
That's a below average job.
And maybe he did an average job by the end of this year.
Cause at most, we're looking at a 500 baseball team, but there's a lot of thoughts of, and truthfully, a lot of the credit goes to the fact that they drafted Paul Skenes.
They traded for brand allow little things that they have.
Help this team.
And he did acquire some good baseball team, baseball players.
At the same time, there's still a game below 500 with nine left to play.
Results matter.
That's not a good enough job.
That's not a good job.
That is at best an average job.
And that should not be good enough to keep your job.
Right.
I say time and time again, this is a results oriented business.
Mostly, when it comes to sports, it's usually if your team's good, you have more fans.
And if your team's not good, you have less fans.
Unless you're the Cleveland Browns who are just a bunch of people that live in Cleveland and guys, we experienced Cleveland and that place is psychotic.
So I guess I get it that as the place is dumb and stupid as Cleveland, they still like the Browns.
But most cases, like they call them fair weather fans.
And that's the thing.
Like you need all types of fans.
You need your diehards.
You need your fair weather.
You need everything.
Because when you are good, you need those guys to come back to the park.
And when you're a really good team and good organization, those guys are at the park.
Because, yeah, you're good.
You're good.
And when you're bad, they disappear.
It's results oriented.
You need to strive to be good.
That's good business.
And the results that truly matter are the results on the major league field.
And this current regime has failed those for now seven years.
I know this is unfinished.
They could be above 500 as this arbitrary number, right?
But the goal, again, was playoff.
And the goal always should be playoffs.
Now, I understand when you're rebuilding.
Like, the goal is playoffs, but there's a path to get there.
That path shouldn't be eight years.
Like, I really don't care.
The path shouldn't be eight years.
Ben Cherington said himself that it's not going to be when he told all the parts fans that it's going to be a lot quicker than you think.
That was in 2021.
That's when Bryan Reynolds is a ripe 24, 25 years old.
And you decided to keep him.
And that's why I'm going to bring this back up as a topic.
And I'll bring it up more later.
But again, like, the decision of keeping Bryan Reynolds and then therefore extending him was a sign of, well, this isn't an eight-year plan.
If it's an eight-year plan, you trade Bryan Reynolds after a six-war season.
You get players going to help him be in the prime in year eight.
Not 33-year-old Bryan Reynolds now making $18 million a year.
So, again, there's a lot to talk about here.
We have a whole show.
But, right, the big part of it is, yes, this is year seven now.
You have gone through all these years, all the talk, all the, we're attached to this tip, this means something, that means something, that means something, this is accountable, that is accountable.
When does accountability actually matter?
When you are both accountable, accountability matter for Derek Shelton, but not for you, apparently, even though you attach yourselves.
And then this next year, you're still not at the goal.
Denard does not go back to the culture, though.
Like, if this is acceptable to go into year eight of this, how do you expect to be a winning organization?
If you consider this acceptable, you will remain losers for life.
And plain and simple, Bob Nutting is a loser.
That's all he knows how to do is lose.
Loser.
You're all a bunch of losers.
I was waiting on it.
Yeah.
Yeah, this is, I keep going back to just this organization.
The whole history of the pirates during the majority of our lifetimes.
Saw a tweet today that someone was 33 years old.
And they've seen, and I was like, I wish eight postseason games.
They've been, they've been to the playoffs three times and they've never made it past the divisional series in those 33 years.
you take it, you take it all the way.
Like this is, this is now going to be 34 years, 34 years.
And in that 34 year, you had 34 years, you had a 20 year postseason drought.
Followed by three fun seasons where you had good baseball teams, but they fell short in the postseason all three years.
And now we're on year 11 of the next drought.
34 years and you've been to the postseason three times.
I don't think like, and I think this is the part where like the people who are out there defending Ben Cherington and there aren't a lot of them anymore, but there are a few.
If you bring Ben Cherington back next year, I don't know if Ben Cherington is going to be any better or any worse than any other person that you bring in.
Right?
Like, I don't know what his replacement would do.
I don't know who his replacement would be.
But like at some point you just, you just have to switch it up.
You can't just say, all right, let's just continue to run this back again.
Ben Cherington next year could take this team in the postseason.
He very well could.
If he has another offseason like this year where he like stacks two really good offseasons together, I could see it happening.
But what makes you think that just another person also couldn't do that who hasn't lost seven years in a row?
Comes back to the track record.
Like what you mentioned there, Jim, like, yeah, Ben Cherington could come back next year and put together a playoff team.
We don't know.
But based on his track record, he's not going to because he's never really done that in his entire career.
He was in Boston and couldn't do it.
He did it one time.
He's a last place GM.
It's what he is.
And this year with all the bells and whistles and all the improvements he made and all the celebrations we had about how great of an offseason Ben Cherington had.
It's a 76 and 77 team.
Not good enough.
You failed.
You get fired for that.
Jim, what was your tweet again?
How many GMs have kept their jobs with this type or these types of results?
So since 1950, there have been a total of two other instances where a general manager of a non-expansion team.
So it happened with the Expos and the Rays, but non-expansion teams, it's happened twice where a general manager had seven straight losing seasons and then was retained for the eighth year.
The first instance of that was Cam Bonifay, who everybody is well aware of if you're watching this show.
If you're younger, maybe you're not aware of Cam Bonifay.
Even the 33-year-old.
Yeah.
But Cam Bonifay was terrible.
He was retained in eighth year and he was fired about two months into the season.
The other time it happened was Rick Hahn, Chicago White Sox.
From 2013 to 2020, he was retained that eighth year in 2020 and the White Sox did make a postseason in that shortened COVID year.
Then they went back to sucking in 2021 and he was fired.
So, like, there's not really any like, success story that you can point to for bringing a guy back for year eight after seven bad seasons.
And, like, again, I just want to stress, it just has to come down to it.
There just has to be a point.
Like, I'm sure all the others as well, it's like, well, there's light.
I promise I'm going to be there.
Well, you've had years of saying that I promise next year is the case.
And, again, all three of us can understand this right here.
If you have an employee who's failing, is it not typical there's a, like, a one, two, three performance plan?
there's a, okay, here's a warning, here's a written, here's, like, a final.
And then it is out the door.
It doesn't matter when you get that final written that's like, but I promise next year's going, I promise next month's going to be the ninth month.
Like, look how I progressed.
Like, sure, you have progressed.
But you needed to progress.
Like, this was your final.
This was it.
You know?
Period.
Full stop.
Like, I get you're doing better this month than you were last month.
You've made improvements.
That's great.
But these improvements still are not acceptable per our standards of the culture that we've created.
And you know what?
Like, I'm glad you improved.
Like, that's nice.
And I'm glad you were taking the time to dedicate, things towards your development and whatnot.
But it just isn't – it's just not enough.
There's just not enough there.
And I'm sorry, but today we just have to part ways.
You just aren't a fit for what we're trying to do here.
And is that next person I hire going to be the person that comes in to be better than you?
I don't know.
But what I do know is I set out expectations, and you didn't reach them.
And I've given you time.
You had the tank.
In season four, you had 76 wins.
Like, that was a – and again, we argue they should have been doing what they did in season four, maybe season three, as far as, like, adding some actual veterans here to start building this winning culture and such.
But regardless, in year four, you got 76 wins.
In year four, you had a – I think all of us can probably say the second best offseason of this tenure.
This was the best.
Hands down.
That one was probably the second best because you brought Cutch.
You brought Troy.
You brought Santana.
You brought Rich Hill.
And again, that's – we're talking that was the second best offseason, those names.
But regardless, that almost sent, like, a message.
like, okay, you're making some actual additions to this team.
Maybe you're trying to change something.
You went to 76 wins.
And like you said, Jim, this was year three.
We're talking about this one.
Like, that's what that was.
Like, okay, this is something to build from.
This is actually something to build from.
You're no longer in tank mode.
You're in.
Let's start building towards winning.
That was year four.
Year five.
76 wins.
Okay.
Okay.
That's not what we wanted to be at.
You guys added the deadline.
You saw the collapse.
Maybe it's reminiscence of 2012.
Year six.
You went down.
You went from 76 to 71.
You got worse.
And now it's year seven.
And you might be fighting for 500.
That's where we're getting at.
Like, at what point are you going to stop selling us the future and say, well, no, guys, I got it now next year.
Look what I have here behind me.
That's what you told us.
This is now the fourth straight year of being told that.
No, I promise I'm building it.
We're here.
Sorry.
This was your final written period full stop.
You didn't cut it out.
Here's your severance package.
We need to part ways.
I need to go on indeed.
I think there comes a point where it just gets stale as well.
Like seven years is a really long time.
And when you're not winning with it, right.
But when you're not winning along with it gets really stale really quickly.
Ask Brian, Jim and I, Jim and I are Steelers fans.
And there's a lot of Steelers fans thought that Mike Tomlin got stale at some point.
And you can have arguments either way, but at least the results were there.
And I think you can definitely argue that got stale.
At this point, we're talking about a bad baseball team.
Who is just keeping it together for continuity sake.
Like, I don't actually have a good reason for why you would bring Ben Cherington back.
I can't think of a single good reason to bring this guy back.
Not one.
Not a single reason.
Because you're afraid the next GM is going to tear it down.
Tell him not to.
Well, that.
There you go.
Fixed.
Can we just hire him?
Bring me a new one.
I think that is something that people are seen on Twitter today also.
Just like, well, my fear is like the new GM comes in and tears out.
That's not the task.
The task this new GM has given will not be, well, what do you want to do?
The task is, I'm Bob Nutting.
This is my organization.
I need to make money.
And to make money, I need fans and a winning product.
And I need you to do that.
There is Paul Skenes here.
That is Konnor Griffin.
Go ahead and finish the job.
Yeah, I think that hesitation in terms of I don't want to bring somebody in because they could tear it down.
Like, that's not an option.
You just tell them that's not what we're doing here.
We have a core in place.
Your job is to take this core and your job is to make them a winning team.
Like, that's the job, right?
Like, you get to write the job description here.
It's not build your own franchise.
It's take what you're given and go make the postseason.
That's the job assignment for 2027.
And yeah, Tyler, I'm with you.
I.
I'm struggling to come up with a reason why Ben Cherington should be allowed to continue to be the general manager of this team.
Did he do some things better towards the end of his tenure than he did towards the beginning of his tenure?
Absolutely.
Absolutely.
Time for someone else to try.
You haven't gotten the job done.
Maybe you should have waited till year seven.
Yeah.
And like and like, here's the deal.
Like, if Ben Cherington is retained and he comes back, I'm going to hope he has a really good offseason.
Right.
Because like, I don't want like I want I want this pirate team to do well.
So it's like, yeah, go ahead and get the job done, Ben.
But.
We've been telling you to do this now for years.
You had a good offseason this last offseason.
I'll give you credit for that.
I told him that I told him that.
Hey, I had spring training.
I was like, hey, good offseason, Ben.
If he comes back, you better do it again because they're going to need it again because you can't just we just saw we just saw a Brewers team take two out of three against the Pirates and they're 20 games better than them.
That Brewers team, they're just going to run it back.
So that's 100 win Brewers team.
How are you going to get better than the Brewers?
Is it even possible at this point?
I don't know.
But like, that's your goal.
Same Brewers team had to deal with the constraints of we got to trade this guy.
We got to trade that guy.
Same Brewers team.
They're able to sustain it, not just even build through windows.
They're sustaining it at.
Great degree.
Best team in baseball degree.
Not.
Hey, guys, the reason I need to is because in my best year, we were almost hanging around for the third spot in the wild.
That's where the bar's at.
That's the argument here to bring him back, because, guys, look, we were almost there for when MLB.
Expanded us to three wild cards now.
We were we were almost there.
I think I've probably gotten better as a podcaster over these last seven years.
That doesn't mean I shouldn't be fired.
I should be also fired.
When you suck at something, you should just get fired.
You can't get out of this that easy, Tyler.
Damn it.
The problem is there's three MLB GM jobs in the world.
People want them.
That's not how this works.
We had to have an NS9 Idol just to have our other co-host on this show.
There aren't too many people who want to talk about the pirates nonstop every day for free.
So I guess my question to you is this, because this is this is honestly, this is what I just I don't know, Murphy's law, whatever.
Ben comes back.
This pirates team they finished this year.
Let's say they finish the year 80 and 82.
Ben comes back.
They go 85 and 77.
It's an improvement.
It's a five game improvement.
But there are two games to the playoffs, but they're two.
They go 32 and 28.
Yeah.
But let's say they don't make the postseason.
Right.
Like, I guess my question is, like, at what point does that matter?
Like, if Ben comes back next year and they continue to improve, but they don't make the postseason, like, do we just have this exact same conversation again?
Jim, did you not see what Curiel did in Greensboro this year?
It's coming.
Once they trade Paul and get that package and Oneil Cruz, because now next year, he's a he's a free agent.
He's becoming a free agent.
You're going to have to trade him now.
that window's gone.
It's fine.
Cruz can be replaced.
You can get that package.
Wait till 29, baby.
Yeah.
Alex is off.
It's cooking sad because he basically he did point out that Ben the builder.
Next year is likely Oneil Cruz's last season as a pirate, which makes me sad.
All right.
That's cool.
That is the other like part of this concern, though, is that I don't want Ben Cherington making the trade of a lot of these guys that are coming up at the end of their deals.
I don't want that guy making that deal.
He's shown us time and time again.
He can't do it.
Like, are you going to let him dig you out of whatever hole you were in, which truthfully wasn't that big of a hole whenever he took over?
They weren't the worst team of all time.
When he took over, he just depleted them and burn it to the ground and got nothing out of it.
And then slowly build him up with top five draft picks year after year after year by being terrible.
Do I want him to give away any of the talent that was here that's here right now?
No, because he's just going to hand it over for nothing because the guy's an idiot.
He can't make trades.
I don't know what more needs to be said.
He's made one good trade.
Brandon Lowe.
He deserves his applause for that.
Good for him.
It was a fleece job.
It was absolute fleece job.
Good for him.
He made one in seven years.
Congrats.
As the pirates go one game under 500.
Like, that's the other thing.
That's the other thing.
I know this is one account that bothers all of us, but regardless, like, just.
How can you, how can you celebrate all these are the guys that Ben brought in?
How can you celebrate them?
Like Ben made that trade.
Right.
As the team goes 76 and 77.
Right.
Like it's the Ohtani and like trout thing.
Like they had those two guys on their team and they couldn't build a winner.
Like a great.
Yes.
As a GM, you can do some nice things.
The goal is to win.
That's what sports is about.
Sports is about winning in entertainment.
Right.
It is an entertainment business.
I need to be entertained.
And the most likelihood of being entertained in sports is having a winning product.
Go out there and see a winner to be part of that, to go to the postseason, to, experience that and be part of that.
And then shit all over your friends who aren't that team fan and talk ish on them.
Right.
Like that's the, that's what's fandom is.
And it brings us all together as pirate fans.
We can celebrate this and be in it together.
Right.
Or just sulk in our misery together.
But we're in this together as fans and such.
And they, this is entertainment value.
And again, entertainment in sports, the big part of it is success and winning.
And if you're a general manager, there's things that you have to do that can correlate.
I shouldn't say correlate that can help for success.
Right.
Building a farm system.
That's part of what you need to do to probably create success, but it doesn't correlate an equal success.
Like having a good farm system does not equal success.
Success on the baseball field, the major league level is what determines a good GM and a bad GM.
If you can't do it, you can't do it.
And back to Tyler's point, he has demonstrated more often than not every year, except for one, that he just can't do it.
And at what point do you just finally say you're not the guy?
Because to be honest, I think either one of us could be the GM next year and have a good chance to make this team a playoff team.
It's there.
But are you still trusting the guy who just has not been able to close the deal?
No.
I don't have much else to say on the, on the topic.
I think, I think at this point, like if he comes back, it is what it is.
It's one of those deals where like, it's going to be extremely frustrating because this organization has shown time and time again, that's just winning is not the priority.
It seems.
and that doesn't like, that's not me saying that the people there don't want to win.
Like Ben Cherington wants to win everybody in the, in the baseball ops team wants to win.
but what I'm saying is it's not as much of a priority to the person who's in charge.
And that's Bob nutting.
Like Bob nutting doesn't care enough.
To hold these people accountable for not winning.
I, it comes back to Bob.
He's in charge.
He's the one who owns the team.
This is his team.
Everything trickles down from him.
And so far he's showing to be a loser who accepts losers and accepts losing and winning.
Isn't the most important thing to him because we haven't seen, we haven't seen him act like winning is important ever.
It was masked when he did fire crudely in Huntington.
It wasn't because of winning because everyone was talking ish on his franchise, the most pathetic.
And there was maybe a little bit of pride there.
You finally saw maybe a little bit of pride.
And it's like, God, I'm tired of being the laughingstock of sports now.
So now I'll fire them.
Cause again, you guys remember that post season.
That was the post season of the ex pirates pitchers right and left.
Every game, the national broadcasters were just dogging the pirates.
Everyone was dogging the pirates.
Not even that aspect, but just personal conduct reasons.
They're dogging the pirates.
There was a lot of reasons to dog the pirates.
And Bob just was like fed up with it.
And that's why I say masked in winning.
I don't think it was really masked in the winning part.
It was just, I got to save some base here.
I got to do something.
I don't like being, I can handle Pittsburgh hating me, but like nationally, this is too much.
Let's turn over a new leaf.
Let me go see what corn fair is up to and give me someone else.
And then here we are.
And again, there's not a whole lot of public outcry.
Like that's the difference right now between like Huntington in that situation.
When you're talking about firing a regime.
nationally, everyone's cool with the pirates.
They're not the laughing stock of baseball.
they get their grace, their moments, right?
We get that MLB tweet that says, Hey, the pirates are at 500.
Thank you.
MLB.
Celebrate that.
Hey guys, the pirates have won the Brewers season series for the first time since 2000, I think 15.
Like these are our moments, I guess that we get, but again, that's what pirates fans get these days.
Not, Oh, look at Gerrit Cole.
Look what he's doing.
Oh, there's Tyler glass.
Now, look what he's doing.
So Bob can handle this.
The last general manager was fired one season removed from the fourth best year.
That 33 year old I was talking about has ever seen your guys.
The fourth best year that 33 year olds ever seen one year removed from that.
The entire front office got canned.
And here we are seven years into this one.
They haven't had a season close to the pirates 2018 year where they still miss the playoffs.
And we're talking about them coming back.
Yeah.
It's, it sucks.
It sucks being a fan of this team.
Like I just honestly, like it's being a fan of this team sucks.
Like I know we're all Pittsburgh sports fans here.
So we all dog the Cleveland Browns, the Pittsburgh pirates are worse than the Cleveland Browns.
They are worse.
I still say that's too far.
No, they're worse.
Absolutely.
Objectively worse.
No, this is the, this is probably the worst franchise in professional sports.
I'll make that argument.
It is.
It is.
It's the worst.
And I would probably argue it's the worst.
Now, with all this being said, and everything you guys just said about Neil Huntington as well, and what it took to get him fired.
I am not saying, or I'm not telling anybody to go out and maybe believe Bob, not, I'm not telling you to do that.
If you want to do it though, I could look the other way.
Like if we all wanted to band together and maybe bully Bob into getting Ben fired, I, would that be the worst thing in the world?
We do need the sell the team people.
They did ease off this season.
Maybe it's time for them to come back.
I don't know.
I'm typically one of those people that it doesn't matter.
We're fans.
They're going to do what they do.
Bob has shown a tendency to maybe, get a little bit irritated when they're being criticized heavily.
So if we want to maybe notch it up a touch on the criticism, like maybe blow the roof off this bitch and just criticize the hell out of them.
Would it be the worst thing in the world?
Tell those six home games left.
Oh, we got an off season for this.
There's going to be a lockout.
You know how much complaining we can do.
We're not going to move the needle.
I'm just, I'm just throwing it out there.
Like, but like, I'm glad you do mention that too, because I think this does play a part.
We've touched us a little bit and I know we're going 40 minutes in here.
We'll move on to the next topic here shortly.
But I think, again, I think that is also something that certainly plays into this with 2027.
He's still under contract for another year.
We don't know what's happening in 2027 as far as MLB goes.
I'm sure that's also part of a factor.
It's not urgent right now.
Again, this isn't the Huntington-Kunley situation.
It's a completely different situation.
He could probably just simply be like, there's a lot of uncertainty this year.
Like, we'll just, status quo is fine.
And that's a problem.
Well, the status quo has been pretty bad.
Well, the standard is the standard.
It's just some standards are different than other standards.
Anyways, do you guys want to talk about something more fun?
Sure.
A lot of people that I know use nicotine pouches.
And the part that missed most isn't so much the nicotine as the routine.
Larine just launched a pouch that keeps the routine but leaves the nicotine out.
Larine Co Pouches are pouches that swap out the nicotine and give you clean focus and support your enamel the whole time they're in.
And because this is Larine, every pouch also has nano hydroxyapatite, the mineral your teeth are made of, so it gives you daily enamel support in between brushings.
Every other pouch out there makes you pick between something that helps you focus and something that's actually good for your teeth.
This is the only one designed to do both.
And it comes from a brand that's leading the way at supporting your oral health.
Give Larine a try.
Right now, Larine Co is offering our listeners up to 50% off at buylarine.com slash northshore.
That's buylarine, L-A-R-I-N-E dot com slash northshore for up to 50% off.
And again, guys, I said it on the post-game show once again.
I'm using these pouches every day now.
When I pop that pouch in, I do get a nice boost of energy.
And it's like very natural and just subtle.
I'm just like a more alert.
It's cool.
Yeah, I've been chewing the gum.
The gum has been my preferred product of choice.
Show them off.
Anyways.
Have some, Ben.
Next topic.
Does 500 mean anything to either of you?
They're one game under right now.
There's nine to go.
Five and four makes them 81 and 81.
Six and three makes them 82 and 80.
Pirates haven't had a 500 season since 2018.
Does that number matter?
Is that something that we should be striving for?
Is that important to either of you in any way whatsoever?
No.
No.
And you guys briefly discussed this on Bucco Brew a little bit.
Listen to that as well.
But no.
And I am that 33-year-old that went, I think I was turning 21 as they broke 500.
And at that point, yes, it did mean something to me because I had gone my entire life without watching the Pirates have a winning season.
At that point, yes, it meant something.
Now, what about the 11-year-old watching this show, Tyler?
I don't give a shit about that 11-year-old.
God bless his soul.
He should have had a better dad to raise him to be a Yankee or Dodger fan.
Honestly, yeah, I blame the parents.
That's a terrible parent.
That's a parental issue there.
Yeah.
Because they knew what they had there.
You knew better.
In my case, the Pirates were coming off Barry Bonds.
I just happened to be born and they sucked immediately.
So at that time, yes, in 2013, hitting the 500 mark, that meant something.
Because it hadn't been done in so long.
Now, absolutely not.
Truthfully, irritates me we're even talking about it as like a benchmark for this team.
Because I know there's people out there and there are Pirates fans out there who are going to give Ben Cherington credit for hitting the 500 mark.
And that's just simply disgraceful.
That should not be a benchmark at all.
That's a joke.
Complete joke.
And truthfully, in 2013, if Neil Huntington goes 82 and 80, he probably should have been fired.
Because that would have been how many years of not making the playoffs?
Seven.
Seven.
There we go.
Interesting.
He should have been fired then too if they would have went 82 and 80.
So, no, it means absolutely nothing.
DiNardo?
So, I want to word it in this way.
Both sides of DiNardo, right?
So, it means something in this way.
It means something for talking points.
And, again, this isn't meaningful.
But it means something in talking points because you're going to have people say, well, with seven years of this regime that they've been under 500.
You can't use that if they're at 500, right?
It's more meaningful is I want them to be over 500 in the sense of they're still players.
So, regardless, we were talking about the tank years.
Players don't tank, right?
Managers don't tank.
Front offices tank.
I still want these guys playing hard.
I still want to see Connor doing what he does.
I still want O'Neill doing what he does.
Like, I want everyone out there performing and they're still ball to play.
I don't want those guys giving up and just saying, well, this season's over.
I'm quitting.
I'm packing it in, right?
Because that's a loser.
I don't want those guys on my team, right?
I want them to still out there performing.
And so, if they're out there performing, especially with a set schedule, like, I could see them being above 500.
So, I would want them to be above 500, but I don't think it means anything.
Like Tyler says, I don't think there's actual meaning behind it where you should see any video of the Pittsburgh Pirates regime celebrating because they won the number one pick for being the worst team in baseball.
You know what?
Like, this organization shouldn't be fist pumping because they are above 500.
That's not what this is about.
So, it's not meaningful in that sense.
It's meaningful that this team still played.
They still fought.
We talked about their resilience and they still show that.
And I like that about this team.
If there's an identity that carries over to 2027, we can still use that.
This is a very resilient team.
I like the backbone of what they have in that clubhouse, you know?
That's where the meaning, I guess, comes from.
But the number itself is arbitrary.
And no, I don't think there's any meaning behind the 500.
If that should be, if that makes this year successful or any type of accomplishment or anything, this team is what it is.
If it wins 81 games or 79, that's not going to change my mindset, nor should it change anyone's mindset in there.
No, I think you put it pretty much the same way I'm thinking this.
Would I prefer them to win 82 games over 80 games?
Yeah.
Like, I would rather watch this team go 82 and 80 than 80 and 82.
I want to see these last nine games.
I want to see the players play well.
I want to see them win some ballgames.
Will I feel any different about this season, whether this team is 82 and 80 or 80 and 82?
No.
Like, no, not at all.
Like, this team's not going to be any different in terms of, like, how I feel about them, whether they're one game above or one game below 500.
It's, it, that's meaningless.
That's not the goal that's, that wasn't the goal going into this year.
It shouldn't be the goal now.
when I prefer it, yeah, doesn't change my thoughts on this season whatsoever.
Ready for a hot take.
I'd be okay with them losing out if it meant that it was a better chance of Ben Cherington losing his job.
So I was going to ask you that, like, do you think these last nine games have any bearing whatsoever on Ben Cherington?
Like, does a week and a half of baseball matter to this decision that we just spent 40 minutes talking about?
Like, if the Pirates do, like, they're what, 76 wins right now after today?
76, 77, right?
If they go 76 and 86 and they lose out.
76 again?
Does Ben, do all these, do these signs that Ben is coming back, does it actually happen?
Or at that point, is it like, okay, you know what, you peaked and you still couldn't even beat what you did in 2024 when you had a three-man rotation half the year?
Yeah.
I think it's a, I think it probably, I think a much, I think it would change something.
Like, I, there's a big difference between 76 wins and like 80 wins.
Because then the 76, like, okay, we still haven't seen any improvement from you, from your peak.
This is this the best you can do is 76 wins?
That, it might, it might switch things up.
Now, I'm not, I know, I'm not cheering for the Pirates to go 0-9 the rest of the way.
I do want this team to finish the season strong, but it is, it is possible that all these signs that we're seeing, it could change.
If this team just completely tanks the last week and a half, it could change.
Yeah, I guess like where I'm at, I think Tyler's very clear.
So I'll talk here because Tyler's like, yes.
I think that absolutely is a group of fans that want to see, they had that mindset.
I want, for the better of my team, I want to sacrifice my entertainment, to see this team lose out.
Because if they are at 76 wins, then I feel this GM might be gone.
And I guess the difference is, I would only imagine that would help that case.
If your case is to get this GM fire, you want to see the GM fire.
That would only help the case.
Like it wouldn't hurt it.
Right.
You wouldn't say, Oh, 76 Wednesday.
Absolutely.
You're coming back.
Right.
It would only help that case.
I just don't think there really is much of a case at this point in time.
Like again, like that's why I talk about the meaningful, the 500 such like the season is what it is.
Like, I think, what this team is, I don't think the last week of this year is going to change your mindset on this team and this regime.
To me, if the 500 number is an arbitrary number, as I put, so is the 76 win to some level, that doesn't really change what I think this team is in this regime, this organization, because the last week, also to like, they're just not, if we, you believe in the rule of probabilities.
And like, this team was out of the playoffs a month ago, like this team's also not tanking the last nine games.
Like, it's just, it's just not going to happen.
Like this team is better than that.
It's not going to happen, but even if it did, I don't think that's necessarily going to change anything.
It does suck.
And it brings up bigger talking points.
Like I mentioned with the 500 thing, that's talking points.
You can say if they were or not a 500 team for seven years in a row or whatnot.
Well, if they won just 76, then they, you had a talking point, like Ben can't do any better than 76, 71, now 76.
That's why you got to go.
But again, I think the minds are probably made up.
Now, if you're on the fence, then maybe, but I guess that you have to believe this ownership is on the fence.
And I don't think so.
Here's how I'd put it.
If you could tell me that losing these last nine games of the season would increase the odds that Ben Cherington gets fired.
I'd be okay losing the last nine games of this season because getting rid of Ben Cherington raises the probability of this team being better sooner.
A different GM gives this team a better chance just based on his track record.
So if that's what I got to do, lose the next nine games, damn it.
I'll do it.
I'll lose the next 11.
I don't care.
I'll lose 12, 13.
Well, there's only nine.
If they won 60 games this year.
If they lost or if they won 60 games, lose the games next year.
So just add them to this year.
I don't give a shit.
Whatever it takes to get rid of him.
Fine by me.
Don't care.
Give me the best odds of being the best baseball team possible next year.
And I'll take them.
Don't care.
82 wins means nothing to me this year.
Whatever it takes to be a better team sooner.
And to me, that means getting a different GM.
So I'll do what it takes in my little hypothetical world here.
Unfortunately, we can't guarantee any of that.
So I guess.
Yeah, I guess for me, it's not happening anyways.
So.
What's the point of even discussing it?
I really don't think that a decision is going.
If the decision hasn't been made after 153 games.
The decision.
Like what games 154 to 162 isn't deciding anything.
I think this is a decision that's likely already been made.
And we may or may not know about it yet.
But yeah, I don't think these last nine games has any bearing whatsoever on the future outlook of this administration.
I do think if they lost nine in a row, it would.
I think that would.
That might move the needle.
Like DiNardo said, they're 76, 71, 76.
That could do it.
It's maybe.
Yeah, it's also not happening.
Like this team's not going 0-9.
No.
But in my hypothetical world, if that is an option.
And you're telling me the probability that he gets fired is like 95% if they lose out.
I'm hitting that button every day of the week.
And again, that's fine.
Because people had a hypothetical world that this team was going to be in the playoffs.
A few weeks ago.
So.
Yeah, those people are dumb.
We'll allow both sides to have their.
Third case.
Arizona Fall League rosters were announced this week.
Yeah.
I just want to say that.
Because there's no comments.
And of course, I didn't play it.
But I just read.
I just read it.
And no.
Guys, there is no Bucko Mike voicemail.
It's not happening.
I just read it.
Absolutely not.
Bucko Mike, you are bang.
It is not happening.
I haven't seen the voice.
I entertained it.
No.
No.
I would have ended the stream.
If you would have started playing it, I would have just ended the stream.
I want to hear it.
No.
Should.
Absolutely.
Absolutely not.
Absolutely not.
I've been seeing what Bucko Mike has been putting in the discord all day today.
He is in a mood today.
We do not need any Bucko Mike voicemails tonight.
It was going so well, too.
It was going so well.
And then he just had to Bucko Mike it.
So, yes.
Arizona Fall League.
Arizona Fall League.
Eight Pirates are heading to be Glendale Desert Dogs next month.
Some highlights.
Obviously, probably the most interesting name on the list.
Top catching prospect.
He's had a really good year between Greensboro and Altoona.
Johnny Severino.
Top 30 guy.
Rule 5 eligible this offseason.
Hit a ton of home runs for Greensboro this year.
I think 31 homers for Greensboro.
So, those are the offensive guys.
Brandon Kane.
Relief pitcher.
Cameron Keyshock.
Interesting starter with some pretty good stuff.
Hasn't really shown the results yet.
Zander Mueth, who was hyped up going into the draft but has been injured a lot lately.
So, he's going over there.
Christian.
Jason Tortosa, who's a left-handed reliever.
Good stuff, too.
Michael Walsh, right-handed reliever.
Again, good stuff.
pitched at all levels this year, too.
So, yeah.
Interesting crop of guys.
Obviously, I think Sanford, Carmichael, headline this group in terms of the position players.
For the pitchers.
For the pitchers, Keyshock, Meath, obviously still very interesting.
You're not going to see any of those guys on top 30 prospect lists right now.
But they're both pretty interesting.
And then Brandon Kane's a guy, too.
Like I said, I saw him pitch for Greensboro this year.
And the stuff is enticing.
So, yeah.
We're going to see some pretty good stuff on the mound.
And then it'll be cool to see Sanford.
He missed some time this year.
So, get him some at-bats against some premier competition in front of an audience.
And, yeah.
Well-deserving trip for Easton Carmichael, too.
So, that'll be a fun one.
And we're going to be there.
We're going to be there next month.
Second annual Arizona Fall League trip.
I know you are going, DiNardo.
I know I am going.
And there may be one or two additions to that group.
TBD.
TBD?
TBD.
But, yeah.
Looking forward to that.
But, TBD.
Ty burned up all his vacation doing all of our other trips this year.
You know what?
Ty, the way that it lines up.
I'm only using a half day of vacation this whole time.
Because we're three hours behind.
And I'm going to work during the day and go to games at night.
I don't get that option.
Yeah, I'm using four.
But, anyways.
Yeah, I'm excited to go out there.
But, also, like you mentioned, Jim.
I'm actually, I am.
I'm excited about this crop of guys.
Last year, Esmerlyn and Tony Blanco Jr. were the talk of the NFL.
rightfully so.
Because, Esmerlyn was just, he tore it up.
And he wants to talk about someone who's put on the map, right?
And we were talking about him for a few years.
Last year, things seemed to start clicking for him.
And the Arizona Fall League, he just showed out.
On, like, the national stage, as nationals, you get for minor leaguers in the AFL.
But, everyone was talking about him.
But, everyone was also talking about Tony Blanco Jr.
Just simply because of, he's unreal.
Now, it's not so much because he's going to be this fantastic player.
TBD on him.
But, he was putting out a show off there, right?
This year, I feel like, and this isn't to take away from those two, especially Esmerlyn.
But, like, Wyatt Sanford and Eason Carmichael, I'm really excited about those two as far as prospects.
What they'll be.
we were talking about being Wyatt Pillar earlier on this year.
and I know he didn't have a full season.
That's why he'll be here.
But, there's some interesting things about him.
Now, I know the strikeout rate's...
It's a little high.
It's a little high.
So is Esmerlyn's.
And it worked out.
it improved upon.
There's still enough talent with Wyatt Sanford as well.
But, Eason Carmichael also, like, that was an interesting pick, a catcher.
And he's really shown, at the professional level, he's been productive.
And this organization has a little bit of a crop of young catchers coming up.
I know the last one in the Deval trade.
But, they have a nice little core of young catchers that have been developing.
And, Eason Carmichael is certainly one of those.
And, you would imagine he's maybe a year or at least two away from making his, like, debut.
So, yeah.


Comments· 0
Would you accept the Pirates losing their last nine games if it made it more likely that Ben Cherington gets fired?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.