◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
Opening Day is here, and NS9LIVE! kicked off the 2026 season the only way it could: with bold Pirates predictions nobody can take back. DiNardo, Jim, and Ty Ty went through their annual over/under showdown, covering everything from Oneil Cruz’s power-speed season to Paul Skenes’ ERA, Bubba Chandler’s Rookie of the Year case, Konnor Griffin’s arrival, and Don Kelly’s ejection total. They also gave their final win predictions for the 2026 Pirates and laid out why this season feels different. It was a fun, chaotic, hopeful start to what should be a wild year.
Watch or listen now and join the ride.
Comments· 0
The Debate
Will Braxton Ashcraft get Cy Young votes in 2026?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.
With Anthony DiNardo, Jim Rosati and Tyler Sweeney.
Chapters
Key takeaways
1
Braxton Ashcraft will get Cy Young votes in 2026 and post a better ERA than Bubba Chandler. Later this was called the key to the whole team.
2
Konnor Griffin won't debut before May 1 and could be held until June. He's only 19, and if he struggles out of the gate he won't get called up.
3
The Pirates will go 87-75 and take the third wild card. The pitch: a full year of Donnie Ball, a strong pitching staff and four All-Stars added this offseason.
4
The Pirates will miss the playoffs by one game, and they'll regret letting Andrew McCutchen go to Texas while Billy Cook and Nick Yorke fill a bench that 'flat out stinks.'
5
This is an 83-win team, average to slightly above. It would look better if Konnor Griffin were already up, Nick Gonzales weren't starting every day, and Carmen Mlodzinski weren't the fifth starter.
Yo! Welcome to the North Shore Nine Podcast presented by FanDuel. I'm your host, Anthony DiNardo. With me, we have Ty, we have Jim, and fellas, it is opening night of baseball!
Pirates are going to be playing baseball in, well, less than a day. Half a day, basically. What is going on? How's everyone doing tonight?
Hope springs eternal, you guys. Opening days tomorrow. Yeah, it doesn't get any, it doesn't get much better than this.
Yeah, I'm excited to stop talking about the hypotheticals. And naturally, tonight's going to be all hypotheticals, but I'm excited to just talk real baseball. We're going to do that 162 times this year, at least. At least. 162 plus. That's right. Plus. Love that.
Well, it depends. We'll see where we're over on their scale.
So I broke out the jersey again. I realized when I put this on today, I was like, I feel like the only time I wear this is once a year and it's for this show.
So here it is. Here it is. Here it is. Break out the pirate script. It's not the new City Connects that were leaked. How about those?
But yeah, tomorrow, baseball begins. We're going to have post-game shows powered by Primanti Brothers giving away potentially, well, we will be giving away four sandwiches on every win to two winners.
Just, man, this day could not have come quick enough. And like, there's good baseball potentially to be played.
Yeah, I think that's the thing. Like, this is the most exciting I've been going into a season in quite some time. So yeah, hopefully we see, like, let's just see some competitive baseball this year. That's all.
And this is one of my favorite episodes of the year that we do. Like, we each have five topics where we're going to ask the other two.
We're essentially going to pick out a stat line. We're going to go over. We're going to go under.
And then we're going to revisit this at the end of the year and see who knows ball the most.
It'll probably be me.
It'll probably be me.
Wasn't it me last year?
I think it was Tyler last year, but it's been me like the last four years prior.
So yeah, but we've proven that you've cheated.
It's a proven fact.
Yeah, you're a cheater.
Kentucky people cheat.
How so?
That doesn't matter.
You're from Kentucky.
Whole thing.
Feeling my sources.
All right.
Well, do we want to get into this?
Yes.
So as always, how we get into it is we ask us a really stupid question, right?
Is that not how we get into things now?
Let's do it.
Let's ask the stupid question and we'll jump right into this.
Did I lose?
Oh my gosh.
Where's the wheel?
Oh, no.
Hold up.
There we go.
Let's see.
Now you got to put the right overlay in.
Yeah, you were in the wrong thing there.
Let's play it and then I'll do this.
I want to ask you a bunch of questions and I want to have them answered immediately.
Yeah.
The co-host is going to ask a really stupid question and that the stupid coast is me.
Just so everyone knows.
Make that clear.
All day to prepare for this.
Had it wrong.
I put it on the bruise.
While you're bringing up the wheel.
So we're going to, we're going to spin the wheel.
We're going to ask one person a really stupid random question.
We're going to hope that they answer while we're live and we will unveil their answer while we are live.
So while DiNardo brings up that wheel, I'm going to go ahead and read the question while he's spinning it.
But the stupid random question for today is what's the most useless thing you've ever spent money on?
So what is the most useless thing you've ever spent money on?
And we are going to ask Colin Moran.
Don't you know?
You know what?
That's fitting though.
Colin Moran.
Just an opening day monster, right?
So, all right.
I am going to send this to Colin Moran while you clean up the overlay there, DiNardo.
You got it.
And Tyler, why don't you go ahead and preview this next segment?
Well, before we do that, let me just tell you how much I loved Colin Moran to the point where I bought a jersey for Colin Moran after the trade just because I knew how much people hated the trade.
I was a Colin Moran guy coming out of the draft.
Maybe I don't know ball because it didn't work out.
But I did buy a Colin Moran jersey.
It's in my closet still.
But yeah, we're going to get into the over-unders here.
Naturally, I won that one last year.
Jim and DiNardo suck at this so bad, guys.
Why?
Why do I suck at this so bad?
I dominate this every year when there's not a cheater involved in this.
DiNardo's terrible at this.
Bull.
I think he's been shut out.
Am I wrong there, Jim?
I don't remember.
Yeah, I don't think DiNardo's ever won this before.
I don't remember DiNardo winning.
Yeah.
Maybe we just had better questions.
Yeah.
Jim cheats.
So we're going to go through.
We've got five questions apiece.
We're going to roll through.
So that's 15 questions total that we'll have for the show.
And then at the end of the show, we'll do our actual season predictions in terms of wins and losses.
And yeah, that's the tiebreaker.
I believe we've used that as a tiebreaker in the past.
So who wants to start?
Knee broken.
Well, I'll put it this way.
I've gone ahead and just put just how we're going here.
Jim, myself and Tyler.
So let's just go ahead and start with Jim.
So you'll ask the question.
So again, all of us will ask five questions and I'll dominate this and we'll go from there.
All right.
I, let's go ahead and start with this one.
All right.
newly acquired Brandon Lowe.
I feel like he's a guy, he's a guy that, during spring training, we haven't really talked a whole lot about him, a quiet spring had a little bit of an injury issue there towards the end of it, but, played the last
couple of games.
All right.
So Brandon Lowe over or under 24 and a half home runs as a pirate.
can I throw a challenge flag?
What if he gets signed for a second year as a pirate in 20, 26, but we know Jim, he's going to try to find like a way out of this.
Like all of a sudden at the end of the year, over under 24 and a half homers.
He had 31 last year.
You want to go or you want me to go to Nardo?
I strategically, I want you to go, but I can go.
I can go.
Don't worry.
I'll give you the benefit of the doubt.
You've never won before.
I know how that feels.
I'm a winner.
You're not.
I wasn't a winner till I was, but now I'm a winner.
I'm going under and I'm only going under because I just don't know if he's going to play enough games.
I could see 22, 23, 21, and he's only hit over 24 twice in his career last year, being one of them.
I think the amount of games played is going to hurt a little bit.
I'm going under there, but I still think he has a good year.
He's like five foot three.
Is that what it's now been officially revealed as since all the weights and measurements are at the hundred percent accurate?
I think he's officially five, nine.
He's five, nine.
He's like five, nine, one 70 something.
Isn't he?
I don't know how he does it.
And it's funny because that was like the talk during spring training.
I can't tell you how many times Gorman I felt like had to bring it up in every press or what not.
Like, how does he do it?
And I agree with him, but he does it.
He does it.
Like you said, he hit 31 last year.
I felt PNC might be a little tougher for him.
I feel like again, like, is that an anomaly?
No, but 24 and a half.
I'm going to go under, but just ever so slowly.
Like if he hits 23 home runs, that's a good year from him.
Probably.
That's such a good number.
Damn you, Jim.
I think 20, like two and a half would have been a really good number here.
But I could see us both being wrong here.
You could hit 24.
Not sure.
For sure.
If you're both wrong, that's good for me.
Obviously it is.
But there's also, like you said, like injury risk.
There's some like, will he just take some days off?
You know what?
That's the wild card of a number here.
I will say that was one of those guys that was difficult to hammer down a number for me because I just, I couldn't figure it was the games played part of it.
I couldn't figure out where to go with it.
So I just left that one off.
Comments here.
We've got Steel City says, man, I would have literally said 24 over, but like 25 under.
If he gets to 20, it's all gravy.
He'll hit 23 under.
So.
All right.
It seems like that's a pretty good number.
Yeah.
All right.
So I guess it's my turn then.
Yep.
Let's do.
Let's do this.
Let's get this one out the way as well.
I'm going to own this person.
Oh, no, Cruz.
Now, last year I did a combination home runs and stolen bases.
And man, he put up them stolen bases to help out.
Let's do something a little different here, but close to it.
We know he's going to steal some bases.
We know he's going to hit some home runs.
Last year we're talking about could be a 30-50.
Who knows?
So I'm going to ask you, over and under, 24 and a half home runs and 24 and a half stolen bases this year.
Hold on.
That's two.
That's two over and under.
No, this is the over and under.
No, it's not.
Like, you have to combine them.
So you're saying, does he do 25-25?
Oh, I guess.
Okay, yeah.
Yeah, my bad.
Just all in all.
Does he do 25 and 25?
So over and under 49 and a half?
No.
Just because theoretically he could have 50 stolen bases and zero home runs.
So yeah, over and under a 24 and a half, 24 and a half season.
Obviously, if he gets 30 and 20, that's not an over.
Who's up?
I'll go since you went first last time.
24 and a half is a lot.
I did.
FanDuel has his home run set at 21 and a half.
Let me just double check that because I bet it.
FanDuel has him at 21 and a half.
And I took the over there.
But 24 and a half, that's a few more.
I'm going to say this is the year that Oneil Cruz finally puts some stuff together.
And I'm going to go over.
Barely on the homers.
But I'm going to say over.
Let's just go ahead and let's go for it.
I'm also going to take the over.
The reason I'm taking the over is, last year, it felt like it was a 30-30 season in July.
And then August 1st started and he hit three home runs the rest of the year.
He was there last year.
He just really struggled down the stretch.
I will take the over here.
Lots of overs in the chat, too.
We've got an over.
Over both.
Yes.
Should be 30-30.
Over.
Over.
One under.
Over.
Over.
Over.
Yeah.
So, it feels like we're pretty high on Oneil Cruz right now.
So, at least a 25-25 season.
So, I'm saying yes on 25-25.
Yep.
I love it.
I love it.
I think the stolen bases aren't really a question.
I agree.
All the end up, it's weird how that's how he's become.
I feel like we've all been getting Braxton pilled this spring.
So, I thought this was like a really good question.
He just, he looked so good last year.
Well.
And he looked really good this spring.
Like, yeah.
Really good.
Yeah.
He's really good.
He's good.
He's healthy.
Yeah.
Okay.
Tyler.
All right.
You know what?
Let me just drop it to the low of our grad.
Love it.
I'm keeping these ones simple.
I don't need like the whole spiel like DiNardo does.
But Henry Davis over under 219 and a half batting average.
Is he going to hit 220?
That's a good number.
That's a good number.
God, I won't.
Perfectly done.
Call Moran has responded.
Jim, can you tee up the question once again?
Yes.
So, the question is, what's the most useless thing you've ever spent money on?
And I think as we all can agree, if you've played any 2K games, myself, definitely NBA 2K.
VC on 2K.
Who doesn't want the new Jordans?
That's a good answer.
Really?
Who has not spent.
Currency on any game at all.
Right.
That's a pretty good answer.
Yeah.
Who has not spent more money on fake clothes, virtual clothes, than actual real clothes?
Yeah.
You've got to look fly in the game.
Good answer, Colin Moran.
Colin Moran.
Good answer.
Yep.
I was going to say the keyboard piano that I have in my bedroom that I bought when I had a few too many drinks one night, but that's a good answer, too.
Have you set that up yet?
No, it's still in the box.
Just to take 15 seconds out.
Tyler literally just texted us one night.
He's like, I bought a piano.
Yeah, I had too many drinks that night.
Out of the blue.
He did get really excited about that piano.
Yeah.
Yeah, it's still in the box.
Jesus.
That was like five months ago.
The VC, yeah.
That'll do it for you.
Good stuff, Colin.
All right, Jim.
Where were you at on your Louisville grad?
You know what?
I love you, Henry Davis, but the odds are not in your favor here.
I got to take the under.
I got to take the under.
I hope to God it's over.
And if it's over, then that's a really good thing.
But 213, 144, 167.
That's what he's done so far.
Like, I can't take the over.
Jim, you and I have agreed on every Tyler question.
I can't play strategy and go different here.
I saw him in spring.
I'm not taking the over.
I'm going under as well.
I'm sorry.
Now, Henry, buddy, if you could hit over 220, that would be fantastic.
I hope you do.
I want to be wrong.
But unlike Paul, I am going to bet against you.
We're talking about a 220 batting average.
I know.
That's all.
That's all.
Yeah, we are.
Like, he can't hit under 200.
He can't hit like he did last year.
It's not.
They can't.
But he can't hit 210.
Well, last year it was way under 200.
I know.
But like, he cannot do that again.
Yeah.
No, he can't.
He can't do that.
He can't do that again.
It needs to be a little bit better.
But 220 would imply it's 64 points higher.
How many hits?
Real question.
Real question.
If we move the decimal point over to the left, who has a higher number?
Paul Skenes's ERA or Henry Davis's batting average?
The bad thing is, I thought about making it the Mendoza line.
I also said I'm not going to bet against Henry Davis.
But for this stat, for this year, I will.
Well, that's right.
Please prove us wrong, Henry.
Please prove us wrong.
Seriously.
All right.
This is all my fault, though, guys.
If I just had taken the video instead of snapping a picture, it would have changed Henry Davis' career all around.
That's a good point.
Thanks.
We're through three rounds of this.
We each have two more.
Let's go ahead and throw this over to Cody, and we'll be back with the rest of them.
This episode is brought to you by IQ Bar, our exclusive snack hydration and sponsor.
IQ Bar protein bars, IQ Mix hydration mixes, and IQ Joe mushroom coffees are the delicious, low-sugar brain and body fuel you need to win your day.
The Ultimate Sampler Pack is a great way for you to try all IQ Bar products and flavors.
You get nine IQ Bars, eight IQ Mix Sticks, and four IQ Joe Sticks.
All IQ Bar products are clean label certified and entirely free from gluten, dairy, soy, GMOs, and artificial ingredients.
With over 20,000 five-star reviews and counting, more people than ever are fueling their lifestyles with IQ Bars' brain and body boosting bars, hydration mixes, and mushroom coffees, the Ultimate Sampler Pack includes all three.
My personal favorites so far have been the Almond Butter Chip and the Iced Tea Lemonade Hydration Mix.
It's just really full of flavor.
I love starting my day with it, and I couldn't imagine starting my day with anything else other than IQ Bar products.
Right now, IQ Bar is offering our podcast listeners 20% off all IQ Bar products, including the Ultimate Sampler Pack, plus free shipping.
To get your 20% off, text MLB to 64000.
That's MLB 64000.
Message and data rates may apply.
See terms for details.
Will, David's hit 64000.
Six, that would be outstanding.
All right.
None of us have really talked too much about this yet, so let's just go ahead and get it out of the way.
Comments· 0
Will Braxton Ashcraft get Cy Young votes in 2026?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.