Three small-market teams and the Dodgers remain standing. Alex Stumpf breaks down Guardians-Rays and Brewers-Dodgers, including Jose Ramirez carrying Cleveland, Tampa Bay’s ridiculous organizational depth and why Milwaukee may be uniquely built to attack Los Angeles. Alex is sticking with the World Series matchup he picked at the start of October: Brewers vs. Rays.
Can the Small Markets Take Down the Dodgers?

With Alex Stumpf.
Chapters
Key takeaways
- 1
The Rays will win their third pennant, beating Cleveland in five. Stumpf says Tampa Bay is so deep that losing Brandon Lowe, Jake Mangum and Mason Montgomery to the Pirates barely registered.
Alex Stumpf - 2
Milwaukee beats the Dodgers in six. The Brewers' all-star-quality relievers (Ashby, Megill, Uribe) plus a rested Chad Patrick mean the longer the series goes, the more it favors the Brewers.
Alex Stumpf - 3
José Ramírez is a future Hall of Famer who belongs with George Brett and Adrián Beltré among the best third basemen in AL history. Stumpf says his ALDS also undercuts the idea that small-market teams can't keep their franchise icons.
Alex Stumpf - 4
Stumpf isn't sold on the Dodgers. Shohei Ohtani hasn't homered since mid-August, Edwin Díaz 'hasn't been the same guy,' and the bullpen is a liability once the starters are out.
Alex Stumpf - 5
We're still headed for Milwaukee vs. Tampa Bay in the World Series, which would match the two best teams in baseball.
Alex Stumpf
Players discussed
Full transcript206 paragraphs · show
So I went 2-2 with my Division Series picks, but the two teams that I said were going to play in the World Series both advanced.
Am I going to move off of those guys? Not at this point.
Good morning and welcome to OffBeat here on North Shore Nine presented by FanDuel.
My name is Alex Dunf and this is a daily look at your Pittsburgh Pirates and today the rest of Major League Baseball.
So far I have been 5-3 with my playoff picks.
Just to recap real fast in the Division Series.
A couple really tough losses in Milwaukee for San Diego, but if it's two coin flips, went Milwaukee's way both times.
I think they were the better team.
They'd win a full five-game series if it had to go to that point.
I get why they could be a little bitter, but stuff happens.
That's baseball.
That's the approach I have is I watched the White Sox, one of my misses, blow a 2-0 lead to the Guardians.
It was, I thought they had control of the series and they just fumbled at the end.
They couldn't put them away.
I think a lack of pitching really hurt them in the end and an offense that is very boom or bust, busted against a good Guardians pitching staff.
I'm not sold on this Dodgers team.
I missed there.
I thought Atlanta was going to advance, but you know what?
They're back-to-back champions for a reason.
I get it.
And then Rays-Yankees, that was a butt-whooping.
Maybe things would have been different if the Yankees had Aaron Judge, but all year, from the start of March to the end of the regular season to their playoff series,
the Rays were the better ball club, and they demonstrated that.
So now we have Guardians Rays and Dodgers Brewers.
These are, again, just my baseball thoughts.
These aren't necessarily endorsements.
These are just my thoughts.
And just for the sake of transparency, I am recording this on Sunday afternoon before the Dodgers and Brewers play.
So I don't know the Game 1 results whenever I'm recording.
Barring some serious injuries or something catastrophic happening in Game 1, I don't think the results of that are going to change how I feel about the series.
But we're going to start with the American League first of Guardians versus Rays.
And I'm going to give some kudos here to the Guardians.
Never say die.
They were down.
Would have been real easy to just throw in the towel.
But coming back from 2-0, having to play Game 3 and 4 on the road, I get that White Sox team was far from complete.
I get they were young, stupid, further ahead in a rebuild than they probably should be.
Any circumstances, you come back from 2-0, you show something.
And you know who was leading the charge?
You could say Gavin Williams, but it was Jose Ramirez for me.
Effectively hit for the cycle across Games 3 and 4.
And then in Game 5, he hits the go-ahead 2-run homer.
For all this talk we're going to get in this offseason about how small market teams have no chance of competing in this economic clodet.
And how they cannot keep their franchise icons.
It was, I will admit, I did smile a little, seeing future Hall of Famer and forever Cleveland baseball player Jose Ramirez.
Power his team to the ALCS.
And he is the biggest factor here for the Guardians.
This, after six years, since 2017, we had a top five finish in MVP.
And for the first time in his career, Shohei's in the other league.
Aaron Judge is hurt.
It was the first time really in his career where he'd say, hey, you've got a path to finally getting your MVP, man.
And he had a down year.
This was not his best season.
He still stole 30-something bags, but only 12 homers.
Offensively, it was just above average.
It wasn't his best year.
You wouldn't know that watching that divisional round.
That looked like the Jose Ramirez that we have seen for years.
The guy who was going to go into Cooperstown one day.
One of the better third basemen in American League history, in my opinion.
I think he is in that tier right now where he is in the conversation with, like, the George Bretts, the Adrian Beltrace.
Like, he is among the very best at his position in his league all time.
And whenever it's all said and done with his career, maybe just one of the best third baseman period.
If this Guardians team is going to move forward, he is going to be the one leading the way.
Because I don't think this is a deep lineup.
I have some concerns with the rotation.
The bullpen does great things there.
But, like, if Gavin Williams isn't beating you, and I don't know how he pitches in the first two games of the series, maybe out of the bullpen.
We'll see.
But, like, I think the biggest weapon that the Rays have to worry about pitching-wise is neutralized.
The White Sox did their job and took the best pitcher out for, or at least he won't be maximized the same way that he was in the divisional round.
Meanwhile, this Rays team, 1-26, seems like any single night someone can make a play.
That game three in Yankee Stadium, Ryan Vallade hits a big home run.
And I've got a Ryan Vallade story, believe it or not.
It was spring training 2023.
The Pirates had claimed him off waivers.
He was someone who, I just chatted around in the league.
And they're like, yeah, he hits the ball hard.
He just hits it into the ground.
And I remember in spring training 2023, him just begging, a locker mate of his, being like, I know I can elevate the ball.
How do you elevate the ball?
I got to figure it out.
Like, he's really just trying to ask a teammate, asking for advice.
And the teammate didn't have really anything for him.
In fairness, he was asking Ke'Bryan Hayes, who was someone who may have been known as hitting really hard ground balls.
But even that little interaction, right there, it's like seeing him hit that home run.
It's like, man, I know it was a good year for him.
He wasn't a main character for this team.
But it's like, I felt good for him.
I felt good for him.
Seeing him years later, get the type of swig that I knew that he knew he had at him.
People like him, people like Victor Mesa Jr., what he was able to do that series, what they're able to do with the bullpen.
There's just too much talent on this Rays team, in my opinion.
There are sexier teams.
There are teams with more superstars.
But this is a team that 1 through 9, 1 through 26, someone can make a play.
Someone can impact a game.
It is as deep an organization in baseball.
as good as the Brandon Lowe trade was for the Pirates, and it was a great trade.
Brandon Lowe, what he meant.
Mangum, being a good guy for this team.
Montgomery, the step he took for it and what he could represent moving forward.
Rays didn't miss a beat losing those guys.
That just shows how deep they are.
That they were like, yeah, we lost someone who maybe could be one of the best left-handed relievers in 2027.
Oh, well.
We still are good enough talent-wise that it's just a blip on our radar.
This is a team that has been for years near the top of the league.
I think they win their third pennant.
So I have the Rays winning in five.
Before we keep going, I'd like to thank today's sponsor, Larine Co.
We all know nicotine pouches are popular, and part of it isn't so much the nicotine as it is the routine.
Loreen just launched a pouch that keeps the routine but leaves the nicotine out.
Larine Co pouches swap out the nicotine and give you clean focus and support your enamel the entire time they're in.
Just tuck one in and go about your day.
Each pouch has a half cup of coffee's worth of caffeine, plus L-theanine and alpha-GPC for a smooth, steady focus with no energy crash, and it gives your teeth daily enamel support in between brushings.
It comes in mint, cinnamon, and mango, and it's nicotine-free always.
It's doing something good for your teeth, and it gives you smooth energy and focus without those jitters.
Every other pouch out there makes you pick between something that helps you focus and something that's actually good for your teeth.
This is the only one designed to do both, and it comes from a brand that's leading the way at supporting your oral health.
Give Loreen a try.
Right now, Larine Co is offering our listeners up to 50% off at ByLoreen.com slash North Shore.
That's ByLoreen, L-A-R-I-N-E dot com slash North Shore for up to 50% off.
In the other league, we've got a rematch.
We've got a rematch of Brewers versus Dodgers, and this is a rematch in name only.
This is a different Brewers team.
Last year, I was at the NLDS.
I saw a Brewers team that was on fumes.
They had that really long winning streak at the end of 2025, but they went into postseason.
They didn't have the pitching.
They were exhausted.
It had been a long time since they had just advanced in the postseason.
They had a lot of one and duns, and just getting over the hump, beating their bully in Chicago.
It took everything they had.
It took every single thing they had, and whenever they got to L.A., it's like, we're empty.
And that Dodgers team got to rest going into that series, and they swept them.
I get that.
This is a different Brewers team, and I don't think it's the same type of Dodgers team.
I've voiced concerns about the Dodgers' bullpen.
The guy in that graphic right here, Shoei Ohtani, he's not having the type of year that we've been accustomed to seeing.
Injured for a lot of September.
He hasn't homered since mid-August.
Like, watching his at-bats against Atlanta, he's had better swings.
This Dodger rotation is full of demons.
I am not going to deny that.
But you know what?
So is this Brewers' bullpen.
And one of the things that I don't think people give the Brewers enough credit for is Ashby, McGill, Uribe, their best relievers, all of them, all-star quality in my opinion.
They could go multiple frames.
Chad Patrick is someone who didn't appear in the divisional round, but whenever I was at that series last year, I remember hearing from pretty much everyone in Milwaukee.
It's like, hey, this guy is so important.
This guy could be a starting pitcher, but he is 100% buying into the bullpen.
And he made such a difference in that divisional round.
They probably don't beat the Cubs last year in the divisional round if it wasn't for Chad Patrick.
He's rested.
He's a secret weapon.
I want to see how he's deployed, how he attacks this Dodger team.
I think the deeper these games go, the more the arrow swings in favor of Milwaukee.
I'm going to give the same scouting report that I gave Atlanta, going in.
It's like, find a way to get these starting pitchers out of games.
And that's what this Brewers team does.
They're pesky.
They draw walks.
They have long at-bats.
They don't make quick outs.
That's the type of thing that if you could get these starting pitchers out in the sixth inning, I think Milwaukee wins.
Like, Skubal is great.
Skubal is great.
But if you can have him throw a couple 20-pitch innings, it's like, all right, deal with him for five and two-thirds.
I'll take my luck with Edwin Diaz in the ninth.
He hasn't been the same guy.
I'll take my luck with that entire Dodger bullpen.
Maybe the Dodgers, as the series go on, deploy their starters in more bullpen roles.
But, man, it's – I think this is something that the longer this series goes, the more in favor it goes to Milwaukee.
And I think this will be a long series.
I think both teams are going to throw some punches.
And I think Milwaukee, just the depth of their roster, the depth of their bullpen, they are more well-positioned to absorb those punches.
So I have Milwaukee winning in six.
It's a big series.
It's literally David versus Goliath.
look at these last four teams.
It's three Goliaths – or three Davids, excuse me, one Goliath.
I don't know if anyone outside of Los Angeles or if you own a Major League Baseball team is going to be rooting for the Dodgers.
This is going to be a fun championship series.
And I think it's going to still be what I called at the start of the postseason.
I still think we are barreling towards Milwaukee versus Tampa Bay.
And if that happens, it will be – I think it will be the two best teams in baseball.
Which is what you want for a World Series, right?
That's what we want.
We want the best teams to meet up.
You could say these are the top two teams.
But seeding-wise, in each league, I think the cream has risen to the top this year.
Thank you so much for listening.
We'll talk a little buckos next time.
We'll talk again tomorrow.
All right, that wraps up this episode of North Shore Nine.
Thanks so much for tuning in.
Whether you're listening on the podcast or catching us on YouTube, if you enjoyed the show, please give this video a thumbs up.
And don't forget to hit that subscribe button if you haven't already.
It really helps us grow.
And if you're listening on the podcast, a quick review goes a long way in helping others find the show.
Plus, be sure to tell a friend about us.
There's always room for more here in the NS9 community.
And for those looking to support us a little more, consider joining our Patreon.
Become an MVP member and get exclusive perks while helping us continue to bring you more of the Pirates content you love.
Thanks again for all your support, and let's go Bucs.


Comments· 0
Will the Brewers' bullpen depth carry Milwaukee past the Dodgers in the NLCS?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.