◆NEWSPirates, Chas McCormick Agree To Minor League Deal◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSPirates Want To Limit Ryan O'Hearn's Outfield Reps◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
◆NEWSPirates, Chas McCormick Agree To Minor League Deal◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSPirates Want To Limit Ryan O'Hearn's Outfield Reps◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
The Pirates had one of baseball’s best offenses in the first half. Since the All-Star break, they’ve been the worst. Jim and Tyler examine the massive drop-offs from Bryan Reynolds, Spencer Horwitz and nearly everyone else in the lineup, along with Pittsburgh’s continued struggles against lefties. They also discuss Endy Rodriguez’s latest major injury, Rafael Flores’ opportunity behind the plate and MLB’s newest CBA proposals.
Watch the full episode of NS9LIVE!
Comments· 0
The Debate
Should the Pirates trade for or sign a catcher this offseason instead of rolling with Rafael Flores Jr.?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.
With Jim Rosati and Alex Stumpf.
Chapters
Key takeaways
1
Spencer Horwitz batting leadoff in seven of his last nine starts while carrying a .411 second-half OPS is 'unacceptable'. Putting him there sets the lineup up to fail, even though the players are mainly to blame for the slump.
2
Lineup protection is real but it isn't the main reason for the slump. Injuries to Griffin, O'Hearn and Cruz don't explain why Bryan Reynolds has an OPS under .600. If he needs those guys around him to clear .600, he's not the player we thought he was.
3
Even after hip surgery that will keep him out until about next July, the Pirates should still tender Endy Rodríguez in arbitration. It won't cost much and there's enough promise to keep him around.
4
Rafael Flores Jr. has hit well, but the Pirates have to go get a catcher this offseason. There's still no proof he can handle catching every day for a full season.
5
MLB's proposed free-agency quiet period and Dec. 21 signing deadline are probably bad for players, but they would make a boring MLB offseason far more exciting for fans.
Welcome to the North Shore Nine podcast presented by FanDuel.
This is NS9 Live.
I'm Jim.
Joining me tonight is Tyler.
Tyler, how you doing?
Another week.
We're missing somebody, but you know what?
The Iron Man's still here.
That's true.
You really are.
You are the Iron Man.
No DiNardo tonight.
He's out gallivanting the world, apparently.
Yeah, shocker.
Yeah.
Just like him.
Who plans a vacation the week before Labor Day weekend?
That's what I want to know.
You know what?
Like, I've thought about that, but at the same time, it might not be the worst thing in the world because it is the weekend before college football.
So if you're going to have a vacation, like it kicks off the fun of the fall.
However, DiNardo is notoriously not a ball watcher.
No.
DiNardo couldn't name 10 college football teams.
No, not a chance.
I guess you could just start naming states and that would work.
That would suffice eventually.
I don't know if you can name that many states.
Yeah.
10 states might be pushing it.
Pennsylvania, Florida.
There's one.
Yeah.
I guess you could count Penn and Ivy League, right?
Yeah.
Well, yeah, it's just the two of us tonight.
So hopefully this won't be like an hour and a half long show.
We just did the postgame show yesterday.
Pirates took the series in San Diego, but lost the finale.
Their playoff odds right now, Tyler, sit at 0.9%.
So we're going to talk about, what happened here?
Colin Beasley of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette put out a really nice article today.
And I really want to just discuss what he broke down.
And really it's just a matter of this offense.
The first half of the season was so good.
Second half after the all-star break just completely fell apart.
So we're going to dissect that a little bit.
We're going to talk about the N.D.
Rodriguez injury a little bit.
If you haven't had the chance, make sure you check out Alex Stumpf's episode of Offbeat from this morning.
Really cool insights there.
A fun story about how the Pirates acquired N.D.
Rodriguez.
And it goes into his thoughts on what N.D.'s future may be.
But we're going to, we're going to talk that, talk about that.
And then the Major League Baseball, Major League Baseball put out some new proposals today for their upcoming collective bargaining agreement.
That's due this off season.
So yeah, some interesting things that got brought up today by Major League Baseball.
So we're going to talk about that too.
So yeah, those are our topics for the night.
Yeah.
We're going to have plenty to talk about coaching staff, decision-wise throughout the rest of not even this year, but during the off season, I feel like we're going to have a good bit of time to talk about some things.
So we are, we're going to have a lot of time to talk about a lot of things because I think this team is pretty much, pretty much out of it.
just based off of, what, how they've been playing, the second half.
So let's dive into this.
So like, so again, Colin Beasley, Pittsburgh Post Gazette writes an article today.
It's titled the Pirates offense has disappeared since the all-star break, tanking their playoff hopes, pretty much hitting the nail on the head there.
he goes on to say that, heading into the all-star break, the Pirates offense was, I believe they were third and weighted runs created plus, on the season.
they were, second and run scored.
They were, they were doing everything, doing everything right.
They had the issues against left-handed pitching really all year long.
but for the most part, this offense was really carrying this team.
trade that, the all-star break happens, they come back and they're just a completely, a completely different team.
Tyler, since the all-star break, this offense has been pathetic.
to just to put it, put it, tightly, they've been shut out seven times in the 38 games since the all-star break.
they're averaging 3.71 runs per game.
they were averaging 5.32 prior to the all-star break.
their strikeout rate has jumped, their batting average has dropped.
Their slugging percentage has dropped.
they've just, they've just been a bad offensive team since the all-star break.
And it's not just like one or two or three people.
It's pretty damn near the entire team.
For sure.
And like, we can't discount losing Konnor Griffin, losing Spencer Horwitz, losing Oneil Cruz.
Like, those are three catalysts of your offense.
So obviously you lose those guys and you're going to take a hit, but like you mentioned, and like Colin mentions in the article, the guys that just fell off in the second
half of the year, like that includes Brandon Lowe.
And he's had a really good year, but he's been a lot more, just pedestrian in this been, he's been average.
He's been fine, but he had weeks where he absolutely carried this offense and not just him, Bryan Reynolds as well.
He had a month where he carried this offense.
And we saw Esmerlyn Valdez carry this offense, a lot of guys just were able to step up during the first half of this year or just put the team on their back for a period of time.
You lose three major players in that, you're going to take a hit, but nobody else really just took that step forward and put, just put this offense on their back for,
a series at a time or got hot for a stretch.
That hasn't happened this entire second half.
Part of that's the way they're constructed where they have to have somebody do that because when injuries like that happen, they're not deep enough for the entire lineup to just push ahead.
You need somebody to step up.
And unfortunately, nobody really did that.
Just nobody did it the second half.
Nobody.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Just to dive in a little bit more of the numbers.
I've got the individual numbers too here that I want to share, but as a team for the first half, 110 weighted runs created plus that was tied with the Cubs for the second best in all of baseball.
Only behind the Dodgers as a team OPS 768 second in all of baseball behind only the Dodgers.
Since the all-star break that way, it runs created plus is now 76.
That is the worst in all of baseball.
They have been the worst hitting team in all of major league baseball since the all-star break with a 76 weighted runs created plus and an OPS of 642, which is second worst in all
of baseball.
And again, it's not just one or two or three people.
And I also understand that, yeah, like the injuries, the injuries affect this.
Absolutely.
Right.
But I want to point out here, and I'll take the overlay off so you can see this a little bit better.
The people who just need to be performing are also not performing.
So if we go through this chart, you'll see here the only hitter who's playing better the second half as opposed to the first half is Jared Triolo.
And it's not like, this is any impact, right?
608 first half OPS, 657 second half OPS.
He's the only position player with over 50 plate appearances in both halves that has been better since the all-star break.
Everyone else has been worse.
Nick Gonzales, you can say, has pretty much been the same.
There's a nine point difference in his OPS, 761 to 752.
But everyone else, we're talking about a pretty steep drop.
Brandon Lowe, 803 first half, 741 second half, 741.
He had a 501 second half OPS before he got injured.
And then worst of all, Spencer Horwitz, 841 first half, 411 second half.
He's had a 430 point drop in his OPS from first half to second half.
Like these are, I know we can talk about Cruz and we can talk about Konnor Griffin and we can talk about, Ryan O'Hearn.
O'Hearn's part of this because he wasn't performing, but when he got hurt.
But like, you're looking at six and a half regular players here, like everyday players.
And they're all worse.
Just top to bottom, this team, when the game started mattering more, the hitting just, the hitting just disappeared.
And I don't really know what to chalk this up to.
I think there, like I've, there's a few theories out there and you brought up the one, like, obviously there's, there have been some injuries, right?
But like, how much does Konnor Griffin being out since the start of July or since the start of June, how much does Oneil Cruz being out since the start of June, how much do those two things affect this?
Like these are, this is the middle of your lineup, like Valdez Reynolds, O'Hearn Horwitz.
These guys have all essentially gotten an average hitters worse.
Like they've, they've gotten so much worse the second half and Valdez is still above average.
So, I'll give him that.
like this isn't a knock on Valdez.
He's a rookie.
He's going through, the league adjusting to him.
and he's still putting up above average offensive numbers.
This is more on the other guys who you just need to perform and they, and they haven't.
so one of the things that I wanted to talk about was, yeah, like lineup protection, lineup protection.
Is it real one and two, does it, is it affecting these guys?
I'm curious your thoughts on it, but I personally, I do think it's real.
I think it's a real thing.
I think it's, I think it's real as well.
It's real.
Yeah.
Like now to the extent where Spencer Horwitz is 115% or whatever phrasing, it would be worse than he was in the first half.
No, it's not worth that amount, but it's definitely a thing.
I don't think you will talk to a pitcher in baseball who will say they don't at least look at who's on deck or pitch differently, depending on situations.
I think that anybody who thinks it's not a real thing bought into say, or into analytics a little bit too hard.
It treats players like a robot a little bit too much.
But yeah, it's real.
Is it the main culprit for these issues?
I don't think it's one, two or three, but it's on the list.
Yeah.
I'm with you there.
I, it's absolutely a real thing.
Right.
And you hear the players talk about it too.
Like when things were going well and everybody was healthy, they talked about how it's, it just allows you to, it allows you to be looser.
It means pitchers need to attack you a little bit more.
They don't need to be as careful around you.
so yeah, it matters.
but I agree with you too.
Like that's not the main culprit here.
Konnor Griffin being injured, Ryan O'Hearn being injured, Oneil Cruz being injured.
If Bryan Reynolds needs those guys to have an OPS above 600, then he's not the player we thought he was, the Spencer Horwitz needs those guys to have an OPS over 411.
but that, but does that play a part?
I think it does.
another thing I wanted to look up, was we obviously know this team struggles with left-handed pitching.
since the all-star break, Tyler, this team has, faced left-handed pitchers the second most in all of baseball.
So like, it is a factor of you've got some injuries, your main weakness, which is left-handed pitching.
You are facing lefties.
What seems to be a lot more now than before.
Now this isn't an excuse, right?
Because this is going to go back to what we talked about on our trade deadline show.
We knew that this was a problem and Ben Cherington chose not to address it, but that is, I think has, it does have to be addressed where this team is facing a lot more left-handed pitching right now than any other team in the league.
Now, should that result in a weighted runs created plus of dead last in baseball?
No, but it was something I was curious on.
And when I looked it up, yeah, they have faced left-handed pitching the second most in major league baseball since the break.
Now, is that starters or is that just innings pitched?
That's, that is at bats, at bats versus left-handed pitching.
Okay.
They are second in major league baseball.
And now it doesn't result.
Yeah.
I'm not talking like, starters or anything like that, but just total at bats.
They're second.
Right.
And then at the same time, adding on to what you're saying about knowing it's an issue at the deadline.
Other teams obviously know it's an issue as well, because you're facing that many lefties because they're going to the lefties in the bullpen.
They're bringing lefties in for a reason.
It's because you can't hit them.
And also with that said, like lefty starters go deeper in games because they can't hit them, which means it's been an issue for your bullpen.
Yeah.
Yeah.
It, like you said, it's been an issue for the entire season.
It was an issue at the trade deadline.
Didn't address it.
And it's still an issue.
Yeah.
Progies with a nice stat right here.
So they faced more left-handed starters before the break 25 to 19.
But you also have to remember before the break, they played a hundred games.
And after the break, they've played 38.
So, what that shows me is like before the break, they were playing a lefty, like one, every four times or so.
and then after the break, they're facing a lefty, almost 50% of the time.
I think at the deadline, all the teams decided we're going to line up our lefty starters to face that pirate series.
Well, whatever it is, it has worked.
it does feel like they face a lefty every day.
It does.
It does seem like they're doing that.
another theory that I had Tyler, and this is more of the, this is more of the conspiracy theory.
Okay.
All right.
So we talked about the average and all that before the break, before the break, this was the second best hitting team in baseball.
After the break, they were the, they're the worst hitting team in baseball.
Do you know what happened during the break, Tyler?
Tell me.
Major league baseball banned the use of AI on the iPads that players could use in the dugout.
So again, correlation doesn't always equal causation, but if you want to go like tinfoil hat here, major league baseball made a rule change right at this time.
And the pirates at that rule change went from the second best hitting team in baseball to the worst hitting team in baseball.
So I, my tinfoil hat here is where these players just like using AI to figure out, I don't know, maybe pitch mix arsenal, what do pitchers throw at what counts?
Like maybe there was a little bit, maybe there was a little bit of extra help going on the first half of the year that they're no longer in whatever that was.
It does correlate exactly with that time period.
It happened.
What on July 15th?
July 15th.
July 15th is when AI was banned in major league dugouts.
And that night they scored two runs in Colorado.
Two runs in Colorado.
That's not good.
You might be onto something, Jim.
like.
Yeah, there's a thought there.
There is definitely a thought there.
July 15th was the all-star break, by the way.
I think you're looking at June 15th, maybe or something, but July 15th was an off day.
That was, they made the change.
Yeah, I'm looking at the, my bad, my bad.
Yeah, I was, I was trying to look up the date on that.
That was OG.
OG calls it cheat GPT.
Any, yeah.
Ethan with, Hey, Claude, how do you hit a curve ball?
It does make you wonder.
something fell off a cliff here.
And at the same time, like I think Spencer Horwitz in the first half is expected numbers were a lot worse than he was performing.
I think it was the same with Ryan O'Hearn injuries happen.
Like there are enough reasons for them to fall apart offensively.
But when you see the level, it's fallen off.
I don't think it's crazy.
The question, if there's something else, I don't think it's crazy.
That's all I'm saying.
I think it's, I think it's a topic worth exploring.
That's all.
And again, it wasn't illegal before.
Like teams were allowed to use that in the dugout prior to July 15th.
As soon as it was taken away, as soon as it was taken away.
And you know what, if it was that big of a help for the pirates, cheat.
They should have just figured.
Just cheat.
Find a way to freaking cheat.
Figure out a way.
Yeah.
I'm tired of everybody else cheating.
You guys do it.
That's my tinfoil hat theory there.
But I think, I think really what it is.
I think it's a little bit of all of this adding up to what's happened.
But I think more than, more than anything, you just, you had your players who quite frankly have had a really good first half, right?
Like let's Spencer Horwitz, Bryan Reynolds, Brandon Lowe even had really good first halves Esmerlyn Valdez.
You can throw him in the mix there too.
Really good first halves.
And they're just not, they're not doing that now.
I wouldn't really say it's regression to the mean because the mean isn't Spencer Horwitz putting up an 11 weighted runs created plus.
The mean isn't, Bryan Reynolds with a sub 600 OPS, but yeah, it's been awful.
This offense, the starting pitching has been bad.
The offense has been bad.
And now that the bullpen is good, it hasn't mattered.
Yeah.
And there's no floor when this team scuffles.
Like they don't hit a rock bottom.
They blow right through it.
Like Spencer Horwitz floor should be like a month of a 70 weighted runs created plus.
Instead.
It's like a four.
There's a, they just blow right through the floor when they're bad.
They're God awful.
And it just all happened at once.
Yeah.
It's the definition of the loser rant.
It's a bunch of losers that don't know how to just scrap their way out of it.
There is something there, right?
you're dealing with a lot of people like Bryan Reynolds has never played in a big game since Vanderbilt basically.
And now, and then all of a sudden when the game started getting bigger, plays like crap.
The moment gets bright and nobody is stepping up.
Nobody.
Again, like it's no, nobody is.
No, they just don't have that person.
And I thought it would be Paul Skenes and I know he doesn't hit, but I thought it would be him that you give the ball to in these moments.
And every fifth day you're going to win.
And unfortunately we're talking about the offense, but when you talk about the struggles, there's part of it on pitching as well.
And you, I think just looking at where they're at right now, you would think you can hand the ball to Paul Skenes every fifth day and he's going to give you eight innings.
He's going to have that run because the light is shining the brightest and we have not seen that.
Whatever it is.
It tanked the year.
Sure did.
it definitely aided in tanking the year.
Whenever you just add that with everything that happened in the first half with the bullpen, everything that's been going on with the starting pitching staff, they just, they just haven't been good enough and they got really bad at a bad time and they've played
themselves out of contention.
So anyways, for one of the, wanted to just share that, the offense, I knew it was bad.
I didn't realize it was that bad until I, until Colin's article today and, digging a little bit deeper and just going through each and every player.
It's rough.
It's rough to see again, Jared Triolo is the only player performing better.
And it's not like, and again, he's not performing well.
He's just the only player performing better this half than the first half.
So, yeah.
Yeah.
He went from bad to less bad.
He went from bad to less bad.
Yeah.
All right.
what else sucks parts catching situation because they drafted someone who can't hit a baseball from Louisville.
I said earlier in the year, like I wrote off Andy.
It was like, whatever you get from him is just a bonus at this point.
Bart goes down and he gets and all of a sudden he like, he looks like the guy that you were just hoping he would be when he was, a top 100, top 50 prospect in baseball.
Just hitting the ball hard, hitting the ball over the fence, 159 plate appearances.
He homered seven times.
His slugging was 467, 132 weight runs created plus decent defense.
It wasn't like awful.
It was decent.
1.2 war that he put up in his 45 games.
And just, he gets injured.
It's a hip injury.
And it's just, this is now a pattern we've seen with Endy Rodríguez where he just can't stay healthy prior to this.
He, we hadn't seen any success at the major league level, but now we're seeing the major league success and it's yet another injury that ends his season.
And it's not a small injury either.
this is hip surgery, Tyler to repair the labrum in his left hip.
It's a seven to nine month rehab just to get back to baseball activities.
So, baseball activity still means you got to go through a spring training.
Like we're saying we're looking at next July essentially before we may ever see Andy again.
And it sucks.
Cause like, I feel bad for him.
It, this catching situation with this team.
It's a weird, it's a weird situation.
Rafael Flores has certainly looked strong in his limited playing time.
I've pretty much given up on as in terms of like, is he going to be a good hitter?
I just, if he is at this point, it's a surprise, right?
At this point he is what he is.
He's probably just going to be a really good defensive catcher who isn't going to hit and he'll be a backup, he'll be your backup catcher, which sucks that's the result of a first overall pick, but that's pretty much who he looks like he is.
And he was the wild card in here where it was okay.
If Andy can continue doing this, then, maybe you found your answer here and this one sucks because he's going to be arbitration eligible this off season.
he's not going to play next year for the most part, the pirates are going to have a decision to make on whether to even tender this guy.
I think you still, I think you tender him.
it's not going to be a ton of money and I think he's still, there's enough promise there to worth keeping him around.
But yeah, this one sucks, Tyler.
It really does because we all love Indy.
Like he's an easy guy to root for.
I think the fan base likes Indy.
It's like I said, he's an easy guy to root for and you see the upside with him.
And we've he was first or one of the first guys in this Ben Cherington wave of prospects.
So he's, we've rode the tide with them.
I don't know how he can really get back here from this.
And I wouldn't be shocked if he plays more major league baseball games for the pirates, but being a regular, it's hard to imagine at this point.
I think just based on three straight years of three or four, I don't even know how many years we're on now.
A lot of extreme injuries.
And this is another one that's not good for a catcher at all.
A hip surgery at 26 years old.
It's not exactly encouraging for, especially a guy that plays like him.
Like he's a fast twitch guy.
He's athletic.
Every time you have one of these, he's going to lose a bit of athleticism.
This year felt like catching lightning in a bottle with them where everything was just, everything was working out for Andy.
And like you said, it just sucks.
It just sucks for him.
It sucks for us too.
Like, let's feel bad for ourselves as well.
We can't have nice things.
Yeah.
Cause it, like it did seem like he finally turned that corner because he was an exciting prospect.
Like we've been doing this show since 2020, you and I.
and so Andy's, and he's been along for the ride the whole time.
And he was an exciting player to watch coming through the minors and, debuting.
And you didn't see what you wanted to see right away.
And then the first injury happened.
And then another injury, it was an ACL injury at first.
Then it was an elbow injury.
Now it's the hip injury.
between 2024 to 2025, Endy Rodríguez played a total of 36 games and two years.
This year, he was at, let's see, 91, 80.
Yeah.
Nine, no, 81 games.
And he finally looked like it was, it was coming together.
so yeah, it's, it sucks.
I think in terms of like, in terms of the future here, I think you still, you tender Endy Rodríguez.
I don't think, I don't think you're cutting bait with him just yet.
Alex brought up a good point on his show.
What the timing of this is rough too, because on December 2nd, if the lockout happens, the pirates will no longer be able to have any contact with Endy Rodríguez.
Right.
So now you're looking at, his entire rehab, essentially, depending on how long these CBA negotiations take place and the team's not going to be able to monitor him, give him feedback, do testing.
Like it's all going to have to be outside of the Pittsburgh pirates realm.
so hopefully it just, it goes well.
Right.
But, I feel like I'd be a little more comfortable if it was like, okay, Andy, here's your program.
Here's what you got to do.
You're doing it in Bradenton.
You're doing it in pirate city.
We've got our trainers all around you.
And like, that's not going to be the case starting December 2nd.
it definitely opens the door for more opportunities for like a Rafael Flores type, like Flores.
Flores has now a month to show us what he can do.
Yeah.
Do we need to, Rafael Flores, are you going to be something that we can just roll with going into next year or are we going to have to bring somebody in?
Yeah, I think it, you definitely see what you can have in Flores, but I definitely think you have to go get a catcher now.
That's almost like a wait and see approach.
Like what if Flores just keeps doing what he's doing for another moment?
I just don't love him behind the plate.
That's fair.
That's really what it comes down to.
Yeah.
Even if he hits well enough, like you need to see growth behind the plate with him.
And I think we've seen a little bit, like, I think he has gotten better as this year's gone on, but can he stay back there for an entire season and play there every day?
That remains to be seen.
Yeah.
metrics don't hate him either.
he's positive one defensive run saved back there.
Negative one fielding run value.
He hasn't had a lot of success, getting base runners out.
He's three, four, 22.
so yeah, definitely want some improvement there though.
That is, that's for sure.
but I want to see him a lot.
Like I want to see Rafael Flores a lot down the stretch here.
Yeah, you have to, but we don't need to see much more Henry Davis at this point.
No.
And thankfully they play enough lefties like every week that Flores is in the lineup almost every day.
Cause everyone's a freaking lefty.
That's a good point.
anything to add on the Indy situation?
Just sucks.
Yeah, it really does.
It really does.
It just, it, he's also just, yeah, that's the thing too.
It like you, as we've done this, we've got to spend more and more time around the team and the players and it's just, and these, that guy who is always smiling.
He's always joking around.
He's always having fun.
Like he is such an easy person to root for.
so it sucks.
It sucks.
It does.
Rooting for him.
Hope he can bounce back.
I hope he can too.
I hope he can too.
But like at this point it's, you can't, I'm back to where I was this last off season where like anything from Indy going forward is a bonus.
I can't expect anything out of him going forward.
And I definitely can't expect anything out of him as a catcher.
Like if you do get him back, he's just, he's coming off hip surgery is catching like, I'm not a doctor.
I don't know what the impact of having hip surgery at age 26 is going to have to Endy Rodríguez, his future as a catcher, but I can't imagine it's good.
Like, I can't imagine that's a good thing.
So it's like, okay, well, how do you protect Andy going forward?
Do you make him an outfielder?
Is he, do you stick him in a corner?
Do you put him at first base?
Can he hit well enough to do those things?
Right?
Like, cause he was certainly hitting well enough to catch, but is he a good enough hitter to play first base?
Is he a good enough hitter to play right field?
I don't know that.
Yeah.
And then like his other upside was that he could play second base too.
Like he did in the minors.
Yeah.
He hasn't done that in a while, but like, this is not that I thought he would have done it again, but it was an option.
I think hip surgery, light catching, that's a lot of movement.
That's a lot of lateral movement.
And it's also nine months and not swinging a bat when he finally got back into a groove.
Like he's not going to be able to swing for a long time.
You're not going to see live pitching for a very long time.
Like real live pitching.
Yep.
Let's move on to the CBA stuff because I think a lot of really interesting things got proposed today.
And I want to talk about them.
So, I'm actually going to share Mark Feinsen's article on the screen here.
So we can go through this as we're, as we're doing things, now get that off.
There we go.
I don't know if you can see that or not.
You know what?
Let me do this.
Try to make it bigger.
Just so people can see a little bit better.
All right.
There we go.
That's better.
Okay.
so major league baseball proposed some new things today.
all of it is contingent on a cap and floor system.
so if you see on here, all of that is still contingent on that happening.
so a couple of things here, one, like major league baseball is still operating under the impression, like, Hey, we're going to, we're going to give all these things and all of these things that came out today, they get framed as pro player.
And a lot of them are like, if you go through a lot of this, a lot of this is pro player.
There's some cool stuff for the fans too.
so I want to go through that a little bit.
but for the most part, major league baseball is putting out these extra things, right?
Where it's like, Oh, this sounds pretty cool.
This sounds pretty cool.
But all of it is still contingent on a cap and floor system.
So, first things first, weekly rosters, weekly rosters.
So, this one's interesting to me because we do see a lot of just like shuffling back and forth daily, especially like that eighth guy out of the bullpen, right?
You're just seeing them constantly being shuffled back and forth.
Baseball is saying on every Monday, you set your 26 man roster for the week, you're allowed exceptions for injuries, bereavement, paternity trades, waiver claims, things like that.
On top of that, the injured list is changed from a 10 days or 15 days to one full week or two full weeks.
So if you're a position player, you get one week.
If you're a pitcher, you have to be on there for two weeks and it's defined as in like Mondays.
So if you get in placed on the injured list on a Wednesday, it's Wednesday through Monday.
And then you got to wait till the next Monday before you come off.
Active roster remains a 26, but you're also allowed to carry 14 pitchers instead of 13.
Reason why that is interesting is because the average number of pitchers used by teams this season on a week, on a weekly average is 13.9.
Because we see that again, pirates are shuffling relievers back and forth all the time.
If they had to, if they had to have eight relievers for a week, I don't know if they could do it.
So it allows them to carry an extra pitcher, but that also means one less position player on the roster.
And they're saying that they do this for just more roster consistency, less shuffling back and forth.
Like you're not in the majors for one day, right?
Fans can build deeper familiarity with players.
They throw that in there.
I don't really know how much that matters.
But yeah, what do you think of this particular proposal?
Because there's some things I like about it.
There's some things I don't like about it.
Yeah, I don't, I don't know if I like or dislike it.
It's different.
I would, I guess I would lean that I like it just to avoid the whole shuffling of players up and down.
I'm not quite sure where this falls into being player friendly.
I feel like it's just I guess I can see if you're talking about guys having to come up, down, up, down.
But even that's not super often.
Like, we call it up and down so often.
I, as a Pirates fan, I think I would like it just knowing who the hell's on the line and on the roster for a week.
But yeah, aside from that, like I'm not, it's more just different, I guess.
It's really different.
Personally, I'm not a fan of this one.
This was the one thing that they, that they proposed.
And I was just like, I don't really like it.
Mostly because I hate, I hate the extra pitcher too.
Like there's one thing if there's the, if there's my biggest like old man yell at cloud take about modern baseball is that there's too many relief pitchers.
Like the big starters don't go deep enough as is, and I feel like allowing you to carry one extra reliever is just going to incentivize that even more.
Like if it were me, I would reduce the size of the pitching staff.
So you're forcing your starters to throw more innings.
But that's me.
I do like the IL thing is interesting to me because, it allows you to maybe a little bit quicker turnaround time with people.
depending on when they get injured, right.
It's one week, two weeks.
And I wonder if a lot of this has to do with just like how easy the, like this makes, I feel like this makes accounting maybe a little bit easier.
So like Ethan, I think you're in the comments there, this would make Ethan's job a little easier because instead of having to figure out, okay, well, was he up for one day or two days?
It's a week.
The guy got a week of major league pay, right?
he's up there for the full week.
So maybe it helps with the whole cap system better knowing exactly like where you're at.
but yeah, it's an interesting proposal.
It's different.
I don't really know if it solves any problem that's necessarily happened.
in baseball, but it's different.
And I think one thing I don't like now, I'm just digging into it a little more and thinking about it.
Like if you have a guy go down, that's going to have a day-to-day injury, put you in a weird spot.
I don't know.
Probably just the same spot you're in right now.
Really?
Yeah.
Yeah.
But you can maneuver some things like depending on how your lineup is constructed.
Like if you have a righty bat and you just have an extra guy hanging around and you want to send him down and get another righty bat up.
Yeah.
It definitely doesn't allow for as many like day-to-day changes.
That's for sure.
Yeah.
And I do like just having that random guy, get a cup of coffee for a day.
I don't really care either way about this one.
I don't, it's eh, it's, it doesn't move the needle either way.
And I don't know if it, I think the players probably look at this and go, who the hell cares?
I think the players look at it and they, I think the players will like this in the sense of, you know what?
If I get called up, I'm there at least a week.
Like I get a week of major league pay.
There's no catching a flight at 6am from a small town in the Midwest.
you're not, you're not hopping on a 6am flight in Omaha connecting through Chicago.
So you can be in Pittsburgh by 7pm on Monday night.
Right?
Like that doesn't happen as much anymore here.
And then you're not having to just go around and do it the next day.
Right?
Because right now that happens.
It's like you have guys who are sitting in Omaha playing the storm chasers or whatever they're called.
And they get called up and they got in that night.
And then if they play, they play.
If they don't, they don't.
But then they got to go back to Omaha the next day.
Like that doesn't happen under this, which I think is probably a good thing for the players.
So, yeah.
This is one of those that I feel like would just end up being hidden in the CBA agreement and be like, oh, that's different.
Yeah.
And I wouldn't think twice about it.
Yeah.
Good point.
OG says, it's hard to predict if a role like give a Sean Ross type person a full week in the majors, or does it just mean he never gets called up at all?
That's a good point, too.
I don't know.
Yeah.
Obviously, the players would prefer that he gets a full week instead of two days.
Right.
So, I don't know.
It does seem just to be like a change for the sake of change, though.
Yeah.
This is the one that I think would stir up the most craziness.
Not talking about the offseason calendar is going to be fun, too.
But the role five draft changes just seems fun.
One, they're going to make you eligible for the role five draft a year earlier.
So, that means if you became a pro before you were 20, you need to be added to the 40 man after four years or you're eligible for the role five draft.
If you're over 20, it would be three years.
So, you get the chance to be moved quicker.
If your team's just stashing you away, you have the opportunity to just go to another team a year earlier.
So, this is certainly a player-friendly initiative.
You get a chance to be added to the 40 man roster a year earlier with this role.
This is the fun part, though.
Right now, everybody knows, if you're drafted in the role five draft, you have to stick on the major league roster.
Or you get returned back to your old team.
Under this new role, players selected in the role five draft would be eligible to be optioned to the minors.
So, what that means is, like, take the Pirates this year, for example.
Axial Plotz, right?
He's their number six prospect, according to some publications.
He's role five eligible.
But are you adding Axial Plotz to your 40-man roster?
Maybe not, because you just know no one's going to roster Axial Plotz for a full season.
Right?
Under this role, though, all you got to do is add him to your 40-man.
You can option him.
So, like, that means a player like Axial Plotz is getting added to the 40-man roster.
Jose Soriano could still be a Pirate.
Jose Soriano could still be a Pirate.
You're right.
I do like this one.
I do.
And I'm a big fan of anything that forces teams to push their real talent towards the major leagues quicker.
And I do think Major League Baseball has at least shown a little bit of flexibility to push their teams to do that a little more.
Yeah, I'm a fan of this one.
I like being able to send them to the minors.
I just like it.
I just like this one.
I like it.
I think this should happen no matter what.
Yep.
I like this one a lot, too.
And, again, like, combined with the first-year player draft and international amateur talent system proposals, it means that most college players could be Rule 5 eligible up to two years earlier than they currently are,
while the time loan for international players would remain status quo.
Because of the, again, like, they're combining this in with the other things that they've already offered.
So, yeah, it's fun to think about because it makes you, it does, it makes you push that, those talented guys a little bit more, right?
How many Dodgers would be drafted?
Yeah, like, think of that.
Like, how many Dodgers would be Rule 5 eligible?
They just stash away forever, right?
This would, I think this would allow, I think, one, you'd see a much more fun Rule 5 draft.
Like, instead of teams passing and only, like, three guys getting picked, you're probably, like, getting a full draft of guys.
Like, if you could pick from the entire, if you could pick a lot of people out there and you don't have to devote a 26-man roster spot to them, you just have to devote a 40-man spot, like, you're going to have a lot of teams picking guys.
So, it's just, it makes that draft more relevant than it is today.
Yeah, it's definitely a quiet way to distribute some talent across the league.
Yeah.
Yeah, I like it.
This one is also fun because we talked about this last offseason where, like, how can you make Major League Baseball's offseason more exciting?
Because right now, it just seems like there's a lot of dead time.
So, in this proposal, there would be a window from the end of the season to Monday of winter meetings, which is usually around the first week of December, where it's a quiet period.
You can negotiate with players, but they can't sign on a new team.
They can sign on the team that they were on, right?
So, it's almost like a restricted free agency period where, like, you can sign with your old team, but if you want to go to a new team, you got to wait until 12 p.m. on the Monday of winter meetings.
You can still negotiate.
You just can't actually sign anything.
I think this would do a couple of things.
One, it would make winter meetings a lot more exciting because you'd have everybody on that Monday at noon.
Okay, now you're eligible.
And you'd probably see a bunch of signings, like, early on.
That seems fun to me.
It makes it more of an event.
And then the other thing it does is it has that free agency window up until December 21st.
So, like, you've got a two-ish week signing period where you got to get everything done.
If you're not signed by December 21st, there's a frozen period.
And then nothing happens from December 21st to the first Monday in February.
That means no transactions involving any major league player.
And then the first Monday in February, trades and signings will once again be permitted.
So, it adds, it adds a, it adds a deadline to the offseason, essentially, where this probably isn't good for players.
Like, let's be real.
This minimizes your window to do things.
But I think this is good for fans.
Like, it makes the offseason more exciting.
Because one thing that a lot of people hate is, like, the NBA offseason, the NFL offseason.
Like, the NBA offseason is electric, right?
Yeah.
Major League Baseball offseason is boring as hell.
This makes it a little bit more exciting.
we do a podcast here.
I'm all for this.
Yeah.
This gives us some terrific topics.
It makes shows awesome.
And as a fan of baseball, I love it.
Back when I used to watch the NBA, I loved when free agency started.
And I'd sit there and watch ESPN and just wait for the signings to come in.
It's fun.
Is it good for the players?
I'd agree with you.
Probably not.
I don't know how you could spin this to be good for them.
You're just minimizing the time to have them negotiate and putting the deadline on them.
So, that's not going to probably be good for them.
But entertainment-wise, I love it.
Yeah.
No.
I think from an entertaining standpoint, from, like, again, from a podcasting standpoint, it makes winter meetings a lot more exciting for us.
It makes, like, December 21st, there's a deadline.
So, it's almost like you've got another deadline.
Like, maybe we do a free agency deadline show where a bunch of stuff happens the last five minutes of free agency, just like a trade deadline does.
I don't know.
I don't know how this would go about.
But all I know is that deadlines and windows are good for conversation.
Because it's something that, okay, well, now's the time for this.
So, we need to talk about this.
And when that happens, it makes us excited.
It makes all of you excited.
It makes you spout your opinions.
It makes us spout our opinions.
It makes for really good conversation around a topic where, right now, the Major League Baseball offseason, it doesn't have that.
It's a period.
It just lugs on.
Every once in a while, something will happen.
But this certainly encourages conversation.
It encourages action.
It encourages just talking about the offseason, which doesn't happen right now.
Right.
It's the MLB offseason is incredibly boring.
It's just a whole lot of waiting around.
This would make it more entertaining.
And whether it's good or not, I really don't care.
I'd like to be entertained a little in the offseason.
Until the Pirates make a bad move that is caused by this, then I'll be mad.
Yeah.
I'm to the point now, Tyler, where I'm not pro-player.
I'm not pro-owner.
I'm pro-me.
Exactly.
I'm pro-me as a fan.
What's good for me?
This is entertainment.
Entertain me.
And so, do whatever is best to entertain me.
And if a signing moratorium on signing players makes the offseason more exciting, then just do it.
Do it.
Yep.
I don't care.
It might be selfish.
It might be selfish.
But this is entertainment.
I want to be entertained.
I'm 100% selfish.
I don't give a shit.
I'll do whatever.
I said earlier, the Pirates should cheat.
I don't care if it's bad for the sport.
I'm pro-me.
I want to win.
I want my team to win.
I want them to cheat to do it.
I don't care.
If you ain't cheating, you ain't trying.
No, you're not.
And apparently the Pirates are trying because they don't cheat.
Find a way.
Maybe they can find a way tomorrow to cheat with a plus 116 odds on the money line against the Cardinals, according to FanDuel here.
I thought it was minus 116.
I thought they were favored.
Actually, they are minus 116 and the Cardinals are minus 102.
I just can't see that far, Jim.
You're right.
Yeah.
Pirates are favored tomorrow.
Yeah, they're both minus, actually.
They're both minus.
Huh.
I don't see that every day.
Well, by the way, the Players Association already responded to this, and they hated it.
Yeah, well, it's going to be a fun offseason of just back and forth with the owners saying stuff and the Players Association saying stuff.
Yeah, we're going to have a lot of CBA talk, I think, going on.
I think, Ethan, no one is going to answer me.
I don't know what your question is, Ethan.
Don't all NBA and NFL free agents sign in two days?
I think a lot of them do.
Yeah.
Pretty much, yeah.
For the most part.
Yeah.
It's fun.
Which makes it exciting.
Yeah.
It's a really fun couple days.
Yeah.
You have anything else to add?
Start cheating, Pirates.
Hey, they got to go, like, 24 and 5 or something like that.
You're not doing that.
You're not doing that.
Just playing straight up, that's for sure.
That is for sure.
No.
I don't even think you could cheat your way to that.
I don't think there's any possibility at that point.
But hopefully they at least make it fun for us this last month.
Play some good ball.
Win some games.
Cheat.
Or throw a guys.
I don't care.
Do something.
Make it entertaining.
I'm pro me.
Just like Jim.
There you go.
Pro Tyler.
We are pro Jim and Ty here.
Yep.
All right, guys.
Well, I appreciate each and every one of you.
Like the video.
Subscribe to the page if you haven't.
The comments.
The commenters don't like the cheating, Tyler.
Yeah, well.
Yellow beard's never for cheating.
Greg's.
Yeah.
Cheating's not an option.
Yes, it is.
Or maybe it's just.
There you go.
Jim says Houston cheated and they won.
Yeah.
Guys, I got a college degree.
You think I did that with this brain?
Nope.
Pro cheating.
If it works in my favor.
Statue of limitations are up on that one.
Yeah, I'm not.
I'm not encouraging cheating.
But it would be fun, I guess.
It'd be a fun story.
It'd be cool to be the bad guys for once.
That's true.
We're not, we're just, we're just bad right now.
Yeah.
Yeah.
It's probably better to be bad guys than just bad.
Because you're the bad guy for a reason.
It's because people don't like you.
Right now, no one, no one doesn't like us.
Everybody likes us because we're bad.
Nobody cares about us.
That's true.
We're just there.
All right.
New offbeat tomorrow.
Make sure you check that out.
Post game show tomorrow.
We'll have the St.
Louis series at coming at you all weekend long.
So make sure you tune into that.
But also, like I said, we talked about ND a lot earlier today.
If you haven't checked out Alex's offbeat from this morning, make sure you do it.
It's good.
Yep.
Always listen to Alex.
Yep.
All right, guys, that's all we got.
This was NS9 Live.
Appreciate all of you.
Watch, listen, like, subscribe, all that good stuff.
We'll see you tomorrow.
Peace out for Scouts.
All right, that wraps up this episode of North Shore Nine.
Thanks so much for tuning in.
Whether you're listening on the podcast or catching us on YouTube, if you enjoyed the show, please give this video a thumbs up.
And don't forget to hit that subscribe button if you haven't already.
It really helps us grow.
And if you're listening on the podcast, a quick review goes a long way in helping others find the show.
Plus, be sure to tell a friend about us.
There's always room for more here in the NS9 community.
And for those looking to support us a little more, consider joining our Patreon, become an MVP member, and get exclusive perks while helping us continue to bring you more of the Pirates content you love.
Thanks again for all your support, and Let's Go Bucs.
Comments· 0
Should the Pirates trade for or sign a catcher this offseason instead of rolling with Rafael Flores Jr.?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.