◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
Alex Stumpf makes the case that Carmen Mlodzinski deserves a real look in the Pirates’ fifth starter battle. In this episode of OffBeat, Alex breaks down why Mlodzinski’s first shot at starting unraveled, what changed in his pitch mix, and why the splitter could be the key to turning him into a more legitimate rotation option. It’s a thoughtful look at development, adjustment, and whether the Pirates should give him another chance to prove he can stick.
Watch on YouTube or listen wherever you get your podcasts.
Comments· 0
The Debate
Should Carmen Mlodzinski open the season in the Pirates' rotation instead of the bullpen?
From Alex Stumpf’s take on the show
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.
With Alex Stumpf.
Chapters
Key takeaways
1
The new four-seamer/splitter/curveball mix held lefties to a .179 slug in relief, compared with .320 in his best stretch as a starter. Stumpf reads that as a reason to try Mlodzinski as a starter again, not as more proof he belongs in the bullpen.
Alex Stumpf
2
The Pirates have no lefty starter and need someone who can handle left-handed hitters. Stumpf thinks Mlodzinski's splitter could make him close to a lefty specialist by attacking hitters north to south.
Alex Stumpf
3
Mlodzinski was set up to fail as a starter in 2025: wrong pitch mix, little experience and a short leash. Derek Shelton pulled him after 4 2/3 innings before he faced the lineup a third time.
Alex Stumpf
4
Stumpf now believes Mlodzinski could be a really solid major league starter, something he says he wouldn't have believed in May 2025.
Alex Stumpf
5
If it were Stumpf's call, Mlodzinski would open the year in the rotation, ahead of the other fifth-starter candidates.
This is Offbeat, a daily look at the Pittsburgh Pirates brought to you by North Shore Nine presented by FanDuel.
Alex Stumpf
Hello, my name is Alex Stumpf, and I would like to talk about the Pirates starting rotation.
Alex Stumpf
not the reigning Cy Young winner, not the pitcher who has the most wins in PNC Parks history, not the pitcher who is a Rookie of the Year contender this year.
Alex Stumpf
No, I would like to talk about someone who is competing for the fifth starter job that I think a lot of people would prefer he stay in the bullpen, and that's Carmen Mlodzinski.
Alex Stumpf
To properly tell this, I think we have to go back in time a little bit, a little preamble here.
Alex Stumpf
Carmen Mlodzinski was drafted as a starting pitcher, spent most of his time in the minors as a starting pitcher, got called up in 2023 as a reliever, and did really well.
Alex Stumpf
Really solid showing, looked like someone who could contribute either as a multi-inning arm or someone who has the potential to slot into a back end of a bullpen.
Alex Stumpf
Same thing happens in 2024, used more in the middle relief role, but someone's like, yeah, he could be a setup man one day.
Alex Stumpf
2025, Jared Jones gets hurt during spring training, and Carmen Mlodzinski was stretching out anyway to potentially start.
Alex Stumpf
He ends up winning the fifth starter job, and it doesn't go well.
Alex Stumpf
It was a rough situation for him to come in whenever he did.
Alex Stumpf
not a ton of experience in this type of role in the upper levels.
Alex Stumpf
Not a lot of experience going through a lineup a couple times in the upper levels, and it really showed in the majors.
Alex Stumpf
He would be really solid for an inning or two, or one trip through the lineup in particular, and then the second time through, the wheels would come off.
Alex Stumpf
I want to look at left-handed hitters, how they performed against the righty here.
Alex Stumpf
Last year, whenever he was a starting pitcher, Carmen Mlodzinski, first time through the lineup, hitters hit .220, .264 OBP, .320 slugging percentage.
Alex Stumpf
That's pretty good at the end of the day.
Alex Stumpf
Now, everyone does their worst as a hitter the first time through the lineup.
Alex Stumpf
Pitchers usually do better the first time through than the second time.
Alex Stumpf
They tire.
Alex Stumpf
Hitters get to see everything they have.
Alex Stumpf
It usually gets worse the second and third time through the order.
Alex Stumpf
Mlodzinski, it got pretty horrible the second time through the order.
Alex Stumpf
Hitters hit .220 the first time through the order.
Alex Stumpf
Left-handers the second time through the order, .318.
Alex Stumpf
Slugging percentage for a left-handers first time through the order, .320.
Alex Stumpf
Second time, .614.
Alex Stumpf
This is why Carmen Mlodzinski didn't stick as a starting pitcher and why they pulled the plug on this in mid-May.
Alex Stumpf
He just couldn't get hitters out the second time through, and that's really what differentiates someone from a relief pitcher and a starting pitcher.
Alex Stumpf
I will admit, whenever it happened, watching it live, it's like, well, he's a reliever.
Alex Stumpf
And there's nothing wrong with being a solid major league reliever, which is what I thought his trajectory would be.
Alex Stumpf
Goes down to the minor leagues, comes back up, pitches really well out of the bullpen again.
Alex Stumpf
And it's like, well, okay, that just further establishes this guy is a relief pitcher, not a starting pitcher.
Alex Stumpf
It wasn't the same guy that we saw, though.
Alex Stumpf
Like, whenever he went down to the minors, he said he really wanted to reevaluate what pitches he was using, what he could do differently.
Alex Stumpf
And his takeaway was the splitter.
Alex Stumpf
This is a very intriguing pitch for me, for a multitude of reasons, the big one being what we saw last year with the splitter.
Alex Stumpf
Whenever he was a starting pitcher facing left-handed hitters, he used the splitter about as often as a sweeper and his slider.
Alex Stumpf
Now, the slider was a really good pitch whenever he was in the early stages of the minors, but he was also pitching it off of a sinker.
Alex Stumpf
Mlodzinski uses a four-seamer a whole lot more in the major leagues.
Alex Stumpf
Those pitches don't tunnel.
Alex Stumpf
So that pitch was going naked.
Alex Stumpf
And it was going up against left-handers.
Alex Stumpf
And the sweeper and the slider, without something to tunnel off of, that's just a breaking ball that is breaking in towards left-handed hitters.
Alex Stumpf
And the results speak for themselves.
Alex Stumpf
A 6-14 slugging percentage, second time through the order.
Alex Stumpf
I need to keep hammering that point home.
Alex Stumpf
I don't think it's a necessarily bad pitch.
Alex Stumpf
I don't think either one was a necessarily bad pitch.
Alex Stumpf
But without anything to tunnel, it just wasn't going to work, in my opinion.
Alex Stumpf
And I think the data backs that up.
Alex Stumpf
Mlodzinski goes down to the minors.
Alex Stumpf
He comes back up to the majors.
Alex Stumpf
And second half of the season, he doesn't throw sliders or sweepers to left-handers.
Alex Stumpf
His mix now is four-seamer, splitter, curveball.
Alex Stumpf
He is working north to south.
Alex Stumpf
He is not trying to get beat inside against left-handed hitters.
Alex Stumpf
Left-handed hitters the second half of the season facing that new pitch mix.
He was used exclusively as a reliever during that.
Alex Stumpf
So, if you want to say, well, yeah, you're just further cementing this guy should be a reliever, not a starter.
Alex Stumpf
Okay, that can be a takeaway here.
Alex Stumpf
I take it the other way.
Alex Stumpf
That he used this new pitch mix.
Alex Stumpf
And his slugging percentage against left-handers, first time through the order as a reliever, second half of the season, 179.
Alex Stumpf
Whenever he was a starter, 320.
Alex Stumpf
He did significantly better with this new pitch mix than he did even in his best-case scenario whenever he was starting the year.
Alex Stumpf
This is an intriguing pitch.
Alex Stumpf
It is going to dive south.
Alex Stumpf
It is going to make him work as a north-south pitcher against left-handers, which is what I think he needs to do.
Alex Stumpf
I think that's the only way he can be really effective.
Alex Stumpf
He could work side to side and use the east to west against right-handers.
Alex Stumpf
Have a pitch that runs away from him.
Alex Stumpf
Have two.
Alex Stumpf
Like, that's fine.
Alex Stumpf
Have those waste pitches.
Alex Stumpf
Have pitches that you can throw in, the outer part of the zone to right-handers.
Alex Stumpf
But if you can avoid those with the left-handers and just attack in a way that doesn't make him comfortable, I think that makes him a much more intriguing starting pitching candidate.
Alex Stumpf
Then I went down to Bradenton earlier this month.
Alex Stumpf
And he didn't have a great start.
Alex Stumpf
He did not have a great start whenever I saw him there.
Alex Stumpf
But he put it together as the outing went on, and he really leaned on the splitter.
Alex Stumpf
And he talked afterwards about how he noticed he didn't really have the fastball, so the splitter became his go-to pitch.
Alex Stumpf
And it worked.
Alex Stumpf
And he was throwing it to both right-handers and left-handers.
Alex Stumpf
He was getting good results against both batter-handedness.
Alex Stumpf
It was that.
Alex Stumpf
I could look at the metrics.
Alex Stumpf
I could look at the data from last year.
Alex Stumpf
But it's the feel for me that whenever he was presented with a tough opportunity, even in a spring training game, I know it doesn't count.
Alex Stumpf
But, I think it's telling that it's like, I don't have my stuff today.
Alex Stumpf
What am I going to go to?
Alex Stumpf
He felt confident that he could go to the splitter and that the splitter yielded good results.
Alex Stumpf
This episode is brought to you by IQ Bar, our exclusive snack hydration and sponsor.
Alex Stumpf
IQ Bar Protein Bars, IQ Mix Hydration Mixes, and IQ Joe Mushroom Coffees are the delicious, low-sugar, brain and body fuel you need to win your day.
Alex Stumpf
The Ultimate Sampler Pack is a great way for you to try all IQ Bar products and flavors.
Alex Stumpf
You get 9 IQ Bars, 8 IQ Mix Sticks, and 4 IQ Joe Sticks.
Alex Stumpf
All IQ Bar products are clean label certified and entirely free from gluten, dairy, soy, GMOs, and artificial ingredients.
Alex Stumpf
With over 20,000 five-star reviews and counting, more people than ever are fueling their lifestyles with IQ Bar's brain and body boosting bars, hydration mixes, and mushroom coffees.
Alex Stumpf
The Ultimate Sampler Pack includes all three.
Alex Stumpf
My personal favorites so far have been the Almond Butter Chip and the Iced Tea Lemonade Hydration Mix.
Alex Stumpf
It's just really full of flavor.
Alex Stumpf
I love starting my day with it, and I couldn't imagine starting my day with anything else other than IQ Bar products.
Alex Stumpf
Right now, IQ Bar is offering our podcast listeners 20% off all IQ Bar products, including the Ultimate Sampler Pack, plus free shipping.
Alex Stumpf
To get your 20% off, text MLB to 64000.
Alex Stumpf
That's MLB 64000.
Alex Stumpf
Message and data rates may apply.
Alex Stumpf
See terms for details.
Alex Stumpf
This is something that I think really needs to be considered whenever we're looking at this fifth starter competition that we got in camp right now.
Alex Stumpf
there's Clevenger.
Alex Stumpf
There's Urequidy.
Alex Stumpf
There's Barco.
Alex Stumpf
There's other options.
Alex Stumpf
Like, Mijinsky isn't here as solely the only option to be the starting pitcher.
Alex Stumpf
And that's fine.
Alex Stumpf
He shouldn't be.
Alex Stumpf
There is also the theoretical chance the Pirates could sign someone.
Alex Stumpf
it's still not outrageously deep into camp.
Alex Stumpf
Okay, it's pretty deep into camp.
Alex Stumpf
But there's still some time that if they wanted to bring someone in and build them up, it's not out of the realm of possibility.
Alex Stumpf
I'm growing pretty doubtful of that at this point.
Alex Stumpf
But they don't have a left-handed starter in this rotation.
Alex Stumpf
You don't need one, in my opinion.
Alex Stumpf
Even if you have one, there are going to be plenty of series where you're just going to throw three right-handers.
Alex Stumpf
That's fine.
Alex Stumpf
But I think you always need that pitcher who could handle left-handers.
Alex Stumpf
And that's, why the Southpaw was such a, staple in this rotation for years.
Alex Stumpf
the veteran Southpaw, the Tyler Anderson, the José Quintana, the Rich Hills, the Marco Gonzales's.
Alex Stumpf
like those, the Andrew Heaney's, those type of guys are always in an opening day rotation.
Alex Stumpf
Really don't have one right now.
Alex Stumpf
Maybe Hunter Barco wins the fifth starter job or gets called up at some point and becomes that guy.
Alex Stumpf
I think he has that potential.
Alex Stumpf
But they don't have that guy right now.
Alex Stumpf
I would like someone who can handle left-handers.
Alex Stumpf
And I'm not counting like Paul Skenes who just handles everyone.
Alex Stumpf
I think Leginski's splitter makes him someone who can't handle left-handers.
Alex Stumpf
Someone who last year, the starting pitching experiment failed because he couldn't handle left-handers.
Alex Stumpf
Could be like a semi-left-handed specialist because of this splitter and how he uses it and how he is going to attack hitters north to south.
Alex Stumpf
We have to see him do it two, three times through a lineup.
Alex Stumpf
That's fine.
Alex Stumpf
We're not going to really know that until the actual results.
Alex Stumpf
And if he ends up going to the bullpen, what I'm saying I think could really apply still well.
Alex Stumpf
Like I think he could still be a very solid major league reliever in all of this.
Alex Stumpf
But if you have a chance to have a quality starter, that's worth more than a quality reliever.
Alex Stumpf
Like last year, if he would have been just a starting pitcher, he probably would have thrown like 50, 60 really good innings that first time through the lineup.
Alex Stumpf
And then 100 mediocre ones, the second or third, mediocre to bad, maybe even subplacement level.
Alex Stumpf
At that point, it's like, well, what are you doing here?
Alex Stumpf
You're just having 100 mediocre innings out here.
Alex Stumpf
Just have him be a reliever and have him throw 60 good innings.
Alex Stumpf
I get that argument.
Alex Stumpf
I don't think this time it's the same though.
Alex Stumpf
I don't know if he was put exactly in a good position last year to start.
Alex Stumpf
I feel like there was a little bit of a doom to fail trait with this because of the pitch mix, because of the lack of experience, because of the fact that he didn't really get a lot of leash in a lot of starts.
Alex Stumpf
A lot of starts, he was pulled after 18 batters.
Alex Stumpf
His last start in the Derek Shelton era, Shelton pulled him after four and two thirds innings because he was about to face the lineup the third time through.
Alex Stumpf
Now, from a pure analytical standpoint, yeah, that might have been the right call, but from a machismo, from a do right for the player standpoint, no, you let him try to get that out and you let him try to qualify for a win.
Alex Stumpf
I feel like there was a little bit of a doom to fail trait with everything that he was doing as a starting pitcher last year.
Alex Stumpf
I don't see that this year.
Alex Stumpf
I see this as a more competitive ball club.
Alex Stumpf
I see this as a young pitcher who learned from those mistakes last year, applied himself in AAA, worked hard, got another opportunity in the majors, maybe not in the role that he wanted.
Alex Stumpf
everyone knows he wants to be a starting pitcher.
Alex Stumpf
I don't blame him at all for that.
Alex Stumpf
I don't fault him at all for that.
Alex Stumpf
You should want to be the best version of yourself.
Alex Stumpf
But the opportunity was in the bullpen.
Alex Stumpf
He was happier to be in the majors.
Alex Stumpf
He pitched well on that.
Alex Stumpf
I think Karvin Mlodzinski could be a really solid major league starter.
Alex Stumpf
And I don't know if I would have believed myself if I would have said that in May of 2025.
Alex Stumpf
I think the failures that he endured, he took good lessons from it.
Alex Stumpf
And he's got a really good pitch here that he's utilizing in a brand new way.
Alex Stumpf
I would like to see how this turns out over a course of a full season.
Alex Stumpf
I really like what I've seen from a lot of the guys competing for the fifth starter job.
Alex Stumpf
But if it was me, I think I would start the year with him in the rotation and see where he can take you.
Alex Stumpf
Thank you so much for listening to OffBeat.
Alex Stumpf
If you haven't already subscribed, you can wherever you find podcasts or here on YouTube.
Alex Stumpf
Thank you again for listening.
Alex Stumpf
This is Offbeat presented by North Shore Nine, presented by FanDuel.
Alex Stumpf
We'll see you all on Monday.
Alex Stumpf
All right.
Alex Stumpf
That wraps up this episode of North Shore Nine.
Alex Stumpf
Thanks so much for tuning in.
Alex Stumpf
Whether you're listening on the podcast or catching us on YouTube, if you enjoyed the show, please give this video a thumbs up.
Alex Stumpf
And don't forget to hit that subscribe button if you haven't already.
Alex Stumpf
It really helps us grow.
Alex Stumpf
And if you're listening on the podcast, a quick review goes a long way in helping others find the show.
Alex Stumpf
Plus, be sure to tell a friend about us.
Alex Stumpf
There's always room for more here in the NS9 community.
Alex Stumpf
And for those looking to support us a little more, consider joining our Patreon, become an MVP member, and get exclusive perks while helping us continue to bring you more of the Pirates content you love.
Alex Stumpf
Thanks again for all your support, and Let's Go Bucs.
Comments· 0
Should Carmen Mlodzinski open the season in the Pirates' rotation instead of the bullpen?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.