◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
Bucco Brew dove into two of the Pirates’ biggest late-camp storylines: Konnor Griffin being sent to Triple-A and Carmen Mlodzinski winning the fifth starter job. The episode breaks down why Griffin’s demotion is understandable, but still frustrating given the Pirates’ shaky left-side infield situation, while also making the case that Mlodzinski earned his spot with a revamped arsenal and strong spring. They also touched on Hunter Barco making the Opening Day roster and what it all means heading into the season.
Grab some coffee at De Fer Coffee & Tea with promo code NS930 for 30% off, then watch/listen and get ready for Opening Day.
Comments· 0
The Debate
Will Braxton Ashcraft have a better season than Bubba Chandler?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.
With Anthony DiNardo and Jim Rosati.
Chapters
Key takeaways
1
Even with a 28% strikeout rate and a sub-.200 spring, Konnor Griffin still makes the Pirates better. Anyone who thinks a roster without him is better is out of touch with reality.
2
If Griffin's problem is major league pitching, AAA may be the wrong place to fix it. He won't see that caliber of pitching there, and struggling in the majors is part of how prospects develop.
3
The 8-year, $110M offer isn't enough for Griffin, since Roman Anthony got $130M. Still, it shows both sides want a long-term deal, and the Pirates would be better off waiting until after he debuts.
4
The left side of the infield is 'just really bad.' Failing to land a third baseman this offseason (Okamoto, Suárez, even Moncada) moves a Gold Glove-caliber Triolo off third and puts Gonzales and Yorke there instead.
5
Braxton Ashcraft looks so good this spring that he could have a better season than Bubba Chandler.
Yo. Welcome to the North Shore Nine podcast presented by FanDuel. This is Bucco Brew powered by Defer Coffee and Tea. I'm your host, Anthony DiNardo. With me, we have Jim Rosati. Jim?
Jim? Baseball? For real. For realsies happens this week. How are you doing this morning?
I'm doing outstanding. And yeah, baseball's right around the corner. The games start counting here very soon. And we have a lot to discuss this morning.
Tons. Like, we need to just get into it right now.
Yeah.
Yeah. And I think the first thing we need to talk about is Konnor Griffin is not on the opening day roster.
100%.
99.9% confirmed right now.
something could happen in between.
Yeah. he was reassigned to minor league camp over the weekend.
There are 27 active players remaining in big league camp, and he is not one of them.
So, Konnor Griffin was sent to minor league camp. Reports are that he will be starting the season in AAA.
So, if you're an Indianapolis Indians enthusiast, good for you.
You get to see a little bit of Connor.
If you're a Pittsburgh Pirates fan, definitely a little bit of a bummer, right?
I think we were all hoping something like something.
It would have been an incredible, just an absolute incredible achievement if Konnor Griffin made this team out of spring training.
Again, no one this young has made their opening day roster since Ken Griffey Jr. has.
So, it's been a long time.
35 plus years is what we're talking about here.
And he had a chance.
Like, he had a legitimate shot at doing it.
But in the end, he gets sent to a minor.
So, we're going to have to just wait a little bit longer for that Konnor Griffin debut.
What is your reaction to this?
And I want to set this up because I think both of us thought it was very much an outside chance that Konnor Griffin makes the opening day roster coming into this season, right?
As the season ended last year, heading into the offseason while we're in the offseason.
That was part of the talks.
But the Pirates did say, like, they're going to give him a shot.
Like, he has an opportunity to make the team.
Started off looking pretty hot.
And even throughout all of spring.
when the kid connected, he connected.
Hard hits.
Hard exit velocities.
But the batting average wasn't there.
But not just the batting average itself.
Like, it's not just empty batting average.
the strikeouts were there.
Walks weren't really there.
He makes it to basically the very last week of camp.
And he gets called, sent down.
So, I do want to know, what is your initial reaction to seeing the news?
Initial reaction is, damn, that sucks.
It's because the story would have been so cool, right?
I think there's a lot of reasons why Konnor Griffin being on the opening day roster would have been nice.
But, like, him making his debut opening day alongside an opening day start of Paul Skenes's, oh, and it's on national TV.
This game's on NBC.
Like, this would have been a showcase.
It would have been the talk of Major League Baseball for the days leading up to opening day, right?
So, it sucks that's not happening.
And, yeah, there are levels to this.
I think it also sucks because even though we can have the discussion that maybe he's not quite ready for Major League Baseball, he still would have been the best option for the team, like, right now.
So, I know the stats weren't outstanding in spring training, 28% strikeout rate, the batting average was below 200.
But you look at the alternatives on the roster, and I think you'd have to be incredibly misaligned with the reality of the situation.
If you think that any situation that doesn't involve Konnor Griffin is a better situation for the Pirates.
Right.
He makes the team better.
Now, going to the flip side, is he ready for Major League Baseball?
And I think this is where you can have that conversation where, yeah, like, maybe some time in the minors makes sense for him.
He started off spring super hot.
And, you know what, if he would have continued that, then he really would have forced the Pirates' hand here.
But Colin Beasley was on our show right at the beginning of spring training, and we asked him, like, what does Konnor Griffin have to do to make this team?
And he said he has to leave no doubt that this is the decision the team needs to make.
And at the end of the day, he just didn't do that.
the 28% strikeout rate, the sub-200 batting average, the 87 weighted runs created plus.
he hit 171.
He just, again, small sample size and spring training stats don't matter.
But at the end of the day, he had to make it so that the Pirates didn't really have a choice.
And he didn't do it, which is fine.
He's a 19-year-old kid.
So, like, this is an understandable demotion.
And I wouldn't even really call it a demotion.
Like, this is what we all expected was going to happen.
And there's other reasons why, he's, it makes sense for him to not start in the majors.
But at the end of the day, like, he didn't show in the 46 plate appearances that he had that he was absolutely, like, ready to roll.
And I think that's what ultimately made this decision.
Yeah.
you're right.
That is the thing.
Like, I wanted him to make the team.
I was pulling.
best case scenario, like, he makes the club.
And for all the exciting reasons you want him to, I wanted him to.
I was biased.
I want him to.
I'm also biased in the sense that I do like to push prospects, that mindset.
he killed everywhere he was.
Now, he was in AA for a small sample.
20-some games plus the playoffs.
And he did crush it, though.
I want to point out a few things here.
Because, again, I do think the demotion is, and again, air quotes demotion.
He was never actually on the major league team to be demoted.
But being sent to AAA to start the year is a fair argument on both sides.
I think you can swear on both sides.
he mentioned he didn't give no doubt.
But you're doubting.
Is he ready or not?
I don't know.
this wasn't great.
Now, it's not as if, like, the 13 strikeouts is totally egregious in the 16 games that he played.
it's not that it's just so much as, like, oh, my God, he just absolutely looks obliterated out there.
he's so lost.
It's not good, though.
especially I felt like as it progressed.
more recently, he was striking out more than before, right?
So, there's a case that, maybe he didn't need to go to AAA, just get more reps in, find himself, call him up.
Now, also, and we'll get more into this, but is that a week?
Is that two weeks?
Is that two months?
I don't know.
We'll debate what that should be.
But I also want to point this out, too.
Like, it is spring training.
Spring training numbers don't truly matter in the grand scheme of things.
Like, how does the player look?
The player looked good, right?
Now, Alex talks on Offbeat quite a bit about hitting the fastball, and that's something he struggled on.
So, that's what the Pirates like to do.
The Pirates like to say, can you hit the fastball well before making promotions, and he wasn't doing that, so that's why they wanted to promote him here and there.
Okay, cool.
But, like, I also want to point this out, too.
Prospects tend to struggle, like, hands down when they make the major leagues, you know?
And, like, I want to put that into key and focus here, also.
Like, Julio Rodriguez struggled.
Like, his first 70-plate appearances, a sub, I think, 150 batting average at the point of time.
like, even Roman Anthony, when he made his call-up last year, his first 55-plate appearances, like, a 171 batting average.
Like, the prospects, Oneil Cruz, prospects tend to struggle.
And then one thing about this, too, is the demotion to AAA best for Konnor Griffin's development?
I think that's a real question.
Now, again, I'm not here to debate and say this was the wrong move, but I want to put in perspective if the struggle is hitting major league pitching.
And, again, he's a talented player.
It's not that he was completely lost.
he didn't have, like, 22 strikeouts in 39-plate appearances.
he was 13.
If the struggle is major league pitching, does it get developed in AAA?
again, as I keep pointing out, sometimes you need to fail.
Failures help you develop.
Failures let you see your opportunities, and then you can practice and hone those skills to master that quest.
So, if major league pitching is a struggle, and you don't see major league pitching in AAA, is AAA the right place to have you develop?
I leave it at that, because, like, that's a good question.
Yeah, you're not going to see the same caliber pitching in AAA as you are in the major leagues.
It's actually not even close.
It is substantially worse.
If you're a good pitcher and you're in AAA, you're probably not actually a good pitcher.
Otherwise, you'd be in the majors.
There's a few people who are going to be down there for a few starts before they make their debuts.
But, for the most part, your pitchers in AAA are your guys who just simply aren't good enough to make major league rosters.
So, yeah, that's a valid argument.
I think we can, like I said, we can debate this all day, and there's other topics we want to discuss.
We've talked Konnor Griffin just at length for about a month now.
So, I think we've said everything there is to really say on this topic.
But, yeah, he has less than 100 plate appearances above high A ball.
He didn't light the world on fire in spring training.
He showcased his talent.
Like, that's for sure.
Like, if you watch the spring training games, it was quite clear this is a very talented individual.
But, you know what?
I am – it's – it just stinks because it would have been fun to see him on this opening day roster.
And I still think he's the best option for shortstop on this team.
But, at the end of the day, the Pirates chose to go the safer route.
And I can't entirely blame them for this particular transaction.
We can blame them later in this episode for what the left side of the infield is going to look like because of what they did this offseason.
So, we'll go into that.
But, in terms of sending a 19-year-old kid down who is 21 games above high A ball, who had a sub-90 weighted runs created plus in his limited time in spring training.
Like, I can't fault them too much for that particular move.
Now, yeah.
How long does he stay down there?
I think that's up to Connor.
If the Pirates call him up before April 9th or by April 9th, his PPI eligibility is still intact.
He can still get a full year of service time, which means if he excels and wins the awards, the Pirates can still be rewarded with that extra draft pick.
So, there's some timelines to this where, okay, is he down for two weeks?
Is he down for two months?
It's going to be interesting now to see, okay, how does he instantly, make the adjustment to AAA and what does he have to do there to show that he is Major League ready and what that timeline looks like next, right?
So, like, there's the PPI eligibility is still in the mix.
Then you run into, Super 2 situation.
The Super 2 situation hasn't really been a thing the Pirates have cared much about the past few years.
You saw that with, Paul Skenes's getting called up well before his Super 2 date.
So, it sounds, it seems like the Pirates are calling these mega prospects up when they feel like they are ready.
And Super 2 hasn't really played a part in that in these past couple years.
That's true.
And, Super 2 doesn't really play a part, if he's not an extension.
I'm just putting that out there.
if he just signed an extension, you don't have to worry about Super 2.
Pittsburgh.
So, that being said, yeah, I agree.
again, like, I'm not totally up in arms about this.
I wanted to see him.
He didn't do enough to prove himself.
And it is what it is.
Now, I would also really like to see him go down on AAA and tear it up.
And then he has to call up on April 9th.
I want to see the opportunity.
I'm still on that side even today.
Like, I'm fine with him starting on AAA, but I still want to see him up by April 9th because I want to give him that eligibility.
You know what?
I want to be PPI eligible.
Go ahead and get that bonus.
Go ahead and Pirates get the draft pick.
Do all the perks.
Like, try it.
Again, you can always send him back down.
That's perfectly okay.
It's perfectly okay.
And if he does come up and he struggles a bit, that's also perfectly okay because for the same reasons I talked about.
They need to see Major League Pitching in order to be able to hit that slider low and away.
You're not seeing that in AAA.
so there's going to be a learning curve most likely.
Let's go ahead and get to the next topic here.
because not just before that, you mentioned one way to take Super 2 out of the other.
The equation is with an extension.
And I do want to bring up Post Gazette.
Noah Hiles just dropped an article this morning that says that the Pirates did offer Konnor Griffin an eight-year contract worth $110 million.
The deal also included a ninth-year option.
A couple things on this deal, like $110 million.
Not only would that be the largest deal the Pirates have ever signed a player to, That would also, if signed before his debut, that's significantly higher than the record that Jackson Churio holds,
which is an $82 million extension.
That's the largest deal ever given to someone who hasn't debuted.
So the Pirates put out an eight-year $110 million option with a $110 million contract with a ninth-year option.
Now, some other things.
If the extension is signed before he debuts, then PPI is ineligible.
You are no longer eligible for PPI if you sign an extension before your debut.
And also, I don't think $110 million is enough for Konnor Griffin.
You look at what Roman Anthony did, and Roman Anthony's was, I believe, $130 million.
It was eight years, $130 million, plus some options.
So, I take this as just a really good sign that the Pirates seem to be very open.
Like, $110 million is a very real contract offer.
It shatters.
If that would have been taken, it would have shattered the previous record for a player who hadn't debuted.
I don't think it's going to be enough, and I think the Pirates are in a better position to wait like a week until after he debuts to do this.
But what this shows me is that the team is serious about locking Konnor Griffin up long-term.
And then the even more important part of this is that it also sounds like this is what Konnor Griffin's camp also wants and that they are very willing to get something done.
So, eight years, $110 million, it didn't get done right now.
But I take this as a really positive sign that these two sides are going to continue to work together, and something will eventually get done.
I hope so, but it is definitely a positive step in the right direction here.
The fact that they offered one, and again, like, I don't think $110 is enough.
I think we both agree on that.
But $110 isn't a laughing offer, especially at first.
again, like, this is how negotiations happen.
Like, yeah, sure, I'll give you $110.
Will you take it?
Let's start there.
Is it $130?
Is it $140?
Is it $150?
we'll find out, hopefully.
But the fact that they are doing it, and again, like you said, like, that shatters the record.
That's a legit offer.
It's a legit offer.
It's not enough to get it done, but it is a legit starting point.
So, yeah, so that's exciting stuff.
All right, so, yeah, let's talk about more.
Before we do, of course, let's tell you about Defer.
Defer is a family and employee-owned and operated business.
They believe that coffee and tea are one of life's simplest and most accessible pleasures and what it enjoyed thoughtfully can open your eyes to the here and now.
They have five locations across the city of Pittsburgh, including their flagship in the heart of Pittsburgh's historic Strip District.
Don't forget to stop by Defer's new location downtown on Penn Avenue, right across from the Benetton.
Grab a cup and fuel up on your walk to PNC Park.
Mobile ordering is available.
Check out their Instagram for more details.
And, of course, Jim, tell everyone how they can save themselves 30% by going online.
Yeah, if you go to Defer.coffee, D-E-F-E-R.coffee, load up your cart, put in promo code NS930.
You'll get 30% off your entire order.
I've got my Defer brewed up this morning.
So, yeah, I'm ready to roll.
Same.
So, not only did Konnor Griffin get sent down to AAA, just as a note, I just want to put a note.
We're not going to discuss too deep in this, but also Alika Williams.
So, I think the thought process was, if it wasn't Conor, it was going to be Alika.
It's not Alika also.
But let's talk about the fifth starter to some level here, because that's been a hot debate.
Is it going to be Irkidi?
Is it going to be Clevenger?
Is it going to be Barco?
Or, hey, wait a minute, Karam Majenski is potentially going to be in the rotation.
He's going to get stretched out.
He's going to give an opportunity once again to win this job.
Well, that opportunity was seized.
Jim, Karam Majenski announced as a rotation piece.
He's going to be starting on Sunday versus the Mets.
Is this the right decision?
Yeah, I think it is.
He's looked the best out of all of the options available.
And you always talk about you're willing to give somebody a chance or things get interesting if there's fundamental differences from what happened before.
This isn't just like, this isn't Karam Majenski starter experiment 2.0.
It doesn't sound like it's that.
He's a different pitcher now than he was at this point last year.
He added some pitches to his arsenal.
He's attacking left-handed hitters a different way.
Again, if you haven't checked it out, I highly recommend the offbeat episode that Alex put out on Karam Majenski about a week ago where he really just dissects how different of a pitcher
he is now.
And particularly against left-handed hitters, that was his problem before was left-handed hitters.
Not only overall, but that second time through the order is when they started giving him a lot of trouble.
Well, since then, he's added the splitter.
He's attacking with the curve.
He's going more north-south against lefties and it's working for him.
So I think if you're looking at the available options on the table, like Karam Majenski looks like a pretty strong fifth starter option at this point.
Again, he's a different dude than what we saw the first half of last year.
And we saw it the second half of last year.
Now, he was pitching pretty much exclusively out of the bullpen the second half of last year.
Right.
But he was really good.
Like, he was really good.
He was...
You could argue he was the best pitcher on the team the second half of the year.
And that includes the best pitcher I've ever seen in my life.
Right?
Like, his numbers the second half of the season were incredible.
I think it was a sub 1.3 ERA, like, whip right around one.
Like, he dominated the second half of the year.
So, yeah.
Give him a shot.
Give him a shot.
If it doesn't work, there's other options.
But I think out of all the available guys, Karam Majenski deserves this look.
He deserves to see if he can do this with his new pitch arsenal.
And I'm excited to see what he's got.
I think, out of all those available options we talked about, like, there's plenty of upside with Karam Majenski.
Like, there's...
The stuff is there.
We have all seen his stuff.
So, if he can just piece that together over five innings on a semi-consistent basis, like, there's a starting pitcher in here.
Yeah, I was absolutely opposed to the idea of Karam Majenski coming back.
And, again, I think this is the right move for two reasons.
It's the right move because no one was winning it.
he is the best pitcher.
And, as we talked about last week, that's still 20% of your games.
Like, that's your fifth starter, right?
Someone's going to be out there 20% of the time to pitch every fifth day.
What is more impactful, that guy or the ball guy?
And that's a real argument.
and again, I still think Karam Majenski, his highlight, his best usage is that ball guy.
he is a pure weapon right there.
But, who is starting every fifth day in the fifth starter role?
Karakidi looked awful.
early in camp, I was, it is really early.
It doesn't mean too much.
And it's like, as long as he's healthy, I feel like he's going to win this job.
But he looked bad, and he looked bad at, I think, I felt like he got worse.
Is that how you felt about him?
Yeah.
Yeah, I just, I actually don't remember ever leaving a José Urquidy outing and being like, man, he looked good there.
Like, I, he just didn't impress me all spring.
So, and then like this last outing, he comes in out of relief.
He came in the eighth inning against guys wearing 70-something, not named Konnor Griffin, and gave up two earned runs in one inning.
You know what?
Like, he just looked bad.
Clevenger, again, to me, like, it wasn't good.
But at least Clevenger, to me, like, he still has some swing and miss stuff in him.
But also, like, with that, like, is he more best suited for a bullpen role?
Like, what he was doing, you know?
And you could easily make that argument.
Hunter Barco, we understand, like, the talents there.
He is a lefty.
But obviously, he's, he barely made it to 100 innings last year.
Like, he can't have a full workload ahead of him.
Like, you could make him the opening day roster and he's the fifth starter.
But, like, you're probably looking to say, at some point in the season, we're going to shut you down.
And then maybe ramp you back up.
And, like, is that also the best move?
is it also, is it really smart to shut someone down, make them step away from the game for a while, then bring them back?
I don't know if that, I don't like that.
I understand the logic behind it sometimes.
But, like, I don't like that.
Get the guy in the groove and get him going.
So, like, I would prefer the Paul Skenes's route, almost like the Bubba Chandler route to some degree, ramp them up, and then just let them go.
Karamazzy looked the best.
Like, he did.
He looked the best.
He makes sense to put him in here.
But also, and you took my words, and I'm not saying against it, but, like, this is exactly why I'm okay with it.
This isn't just running it back.
There was something fundamentally different.
And, Alex, once again, on Offbeat, highlighted it more.
You hear about the splitter, you hear about the curveball, the pitch mix and stuff, and just, like, he is a different pitcher today.
He's not the same Karamazzy that was pitching last year.
And that's why I'm open to it, because for the reasons that he struggled the second time through the lineup, the third time, you would imagine it's not going to be the same because he has a different repertoire behind him that you would assume could help prevent that.
like, the pitchers aren't going to see the same two pitches every time.
And because of this, I'm more open, and you guys can flame me out there.
I know a lot of people are really against this because it's the same old Pirates.
It didn't work last year.
Why are you going to do it again?
Like, this is why, because it's not technically running it back.
The name's the same, but the pitcher's different.
And this is a starting pitcher repertoire.
This is someone who has honed his craft to do that.
Let's give it a shot.
And, like, worst-case scenario, Jim, Jared Jones is probably coming back in two months.
Todd Tomzik's been pretty delightful in his injury news this year, especially around Jared Jones.
So, like, worst-case scenario, he goes back in the bullpen.
Yeah, I think this is the right call.
As far as, like, the rest of the pitching staff and how it's going to, wind down, like I said, they've got 27 guys in camp who are active, 26 spots.
So, you essentially have to choose two of Clevenger, Urquidy, and Barco to round out this bullpen.
And, yeah, like, Urquidy just hasn't been impressive.
I think right now, like, we'll probably find out here in the matter of the next few hours, but if it's me, I'm bringing Clevenger and Barco north with me.
I think we talked about this on NS9 Live last week.
Like, with Hunter Barco, you're looking to limit his innings a little bit.
Do that in the majors as a reliever.
Let him pitch out of the bullpen for the first half of the season.
Use him in that bulk inning role.
Like, he would make a perfect counter to Mlodzinski.
Like, if you're worried about Mlodzinski's longevity and saying, like, hey, he's a starter, but probably not a six to seven inning guy.
Maybe more of a four or five inning guy.
Then go ahead and go Mlodzinski and then Barco.
And then next thing it's the seventh inning.
And, you've given up one or two runs because, you've deployed people in a way that works best.
So, that's the way that I would go right now.
I just, I have this feeling.
I put it in the Discord last night where it's just, I just, I don't know.
My gut is saying that Hunter Barco is going to make this team.
And I'm also thinking that José Urquidy is not.
Which means, does Urquidy get optioned?
Even though he's out of options?
Did he give advanced consent to that?
Does he get DFA'd?
I don't know.
That's what I think is going to happen, though.
I think that's where we're at.
And I think if you're the Pirates and you're looking at what these other guys bring you, I feel the best out of, I feel the best about Barco than those three.
Like, if you're saying, okay, pick one, Barco, Clevenger, or Urquidy, I'm picking Barco 10 out of 10 times.
And then the other two, honestly, it's a coin flip.
I'm not impressed with either.
But if you need a 13th pitcher, so be it.
Whatever.
Yeah.
I like that idea a lot.
and you brought it up when we did discuss it to a little bit of a degree on NS9 Live.
But I think, like, mentally, I've been going into this season thinking, like, it's just not going to be Mlodzinski.
And, that's why I've been not really on board with Hunter Barco starting the year.
Like, it just makes sense.
It's going to be AAA.
It's going to be AAA.
Ramp them up.
But with Mlodzinski making it now as a fifth starter for sure, now you've lost that guy.
Like, especially, this guy that you're worried about innings with finishes development in the major leagues.
Do it in the bullpen.
like, with Ashcraft, he could be a real weapon.
He could replace Mlodzinski.
So, like, this, to me, makes the Mlodzinski as the fifth starter a little bit better because, like, it's not Arkiti.
and that's why I believe you, too.
Like, I think it's going to be Clevenger, too, because I think Clevenger is more fit for a bullpen role than Arkiti is.
it's like the Bailey Falter discussion.
Like, Bailey Falter, if he doesn't succeed as a starter, like, he's just probably not going to succeed at all because his repertoire, like, his stuff doesn't.
Like, fit the bullpen.
So, like, well, if you are a failed starter, you'll be in excelling at the bullpen role.
Like, no, Bailey.
You're probably not.
That's what I look at with Arkiti.
Like, he's not really fit for the bullpen.
But Clevenger is.
I can see Clevenger, at least for, like, a two-month stretch, giving this team enough innings to look okay enough.
You know what?
Like, not hurt them.
Probably more mop-up, than, like, the Yohan Ramirez role to some level.
But, like, I find him, like, better in that role than Arkiti, though.
So, I'm on board with Hunter Barco, and I think it does make a whole lot of sense.
Especially, like, right now.
Like, he can fill that two-inning, potentially three-inning gap when they need it here and there.
Maybe it is a Brzezinski start.
But hopefully not.
But, you know what?
Like, I think this makes a lot of sense to have Barco there.
We need somebody to go out there and pitch three innings.
Like, let him be that guy.
Don't put Mike Clevenger anywhere near high-leverage situations.
But let him be that mop-up guy.
Everybody needs one.
Let him be it.
Right.
But, yeah.
I like Barco starting out of the bullpen.
I like him.
You can use him in a few different ways.
You can use him in a piggyback situation.
You can use him as a lefty reliever, right?
And so you've got a few options and different ways to use him.
And I think there are ways that you can build him up throughout the year where if you want to get him into that starter's role, then you just transition him into that like I said, same way that they did with Ashcraft, same way they did with Burrow.
Like, both of them went through that same reliever to starter transition during the season.
You can give somebody, you can have somebody be a two-inning reliever, and then the next time he goes out, he pitches three innings.
And then the next time he goes out, he pitches four innings.
Like, you can do that.
You can build up a guy in the bullpen.
Yeah.
Or, like, and do it, like, in a piggyback situation.
Like, so Carmen's starting today and Barco goes three.
And that's what helps him build up.
So that way it's like, boom, now you have the transfer or whatnot.
Yeah.
Yeah, absolutely.
Enough of that.
We're going to go on to some of the issues here.
Yeah.
Let's talk about the, I guess, the problems that arise now that.
Before we do, let's hear from Cody.
But, yeah, we'll come back and we'll talk about the issues on the left side of the field right now.
This episode is brought to you by IQ Bar, our exclusive snack hydration and sponsor.
IQ Bar protein bars, IQ Mix hydration mixes, and IQ Joe mushroom coffees are the delicious, low-sugar, brain and body fuel you need to win your day.
The Ultimate Sampler Pack is a great way for you to try all IQ Bar products and flavors.
You get nine IQ Bars, eight IQ Mix sticks, and four IQ Joe sticks.
All IQ Bar products are clean label certified and entirely free from gluten, dairy, soy, GMOs, and artificial ingredients.
With over 20,000 five-star reviews and counting, more people than ever are fueling their lifestyles with IQ Bars' brain and body boosting bars, hydration mixes, and mushroom coffees.
The Ultimate Sampler Pack includes all three.
My personal favorites so far have been the Almond Butter Chip and the Iced Tea Lemonade Hydration Mix, it's just really full of flavor.
I love starting my day with it, and I couldn't imagine starting my day with anything else other than IQ Bar products.
Right now, IQ Bar is offering our podcast listeners 20% off all IQ Bar products, including the Ultimate Sampler Pack, plus free shipping.
To get your 20% off, text MLB to 64000.
That's MLB 64000.
Message and data rates may apply.
See terms for details.
So, the thing about Konnor Griffin going down to AAA to start the year, we both agree there's not a huge argument that's supporting the side.
it is what it is.
It's fair, right?
But I think the problem with this is, so as mentioned earlier, Alika Williams didn't make the team either.
So it's Jared Triolo, who's going to be playing short most of the time.
Therefore, it's going to be Nick Gonzales and Nick Yorke splitting duties at third.
And I'm sure there'll be some, Nick Gonzales, I'm sure, will probably see some time at short also here or there.
But that's the left side of your infield right now.
That's the problem with sending Connor down.
And that was the argument.
Like, does it make the team better or worse to send him down?
It clearly makes them worse.
Here's why.
Even if Connor was doing what he's doing right now, even if Connor is batting to 200, striking out 27% of the time, but slugging 470, like doing it's still probably better than what you're going to get out of this.
So, Jim, talk to us.
Yeah, this is the problem that you ran into by not going out there and getting a single left side of the infield guy over the offseason.
They had many targets that they were apparently, quote unquote, in on, right?
But they didn't land any of them.
They didn't land Kazuma Okamoto.
They didn't land a Uenio Suarez.
They didn't even land Yohan Moncada, right?
So, like, all these guys that were out there to fill some hole that was going to be on this left side, they didn't get them.
So, with Konnor Griffin not making the team, you've got to now pivot to, okay, how do we how do we defend this left side of the infield and who are we putting there?
And so, now you are taking your extremely talented defensive third baseman and you're putting him at his second position, which would be shortstop.
Jared Triolo is a perfectly capable shortstop, but he's, like, almost gold glove caliber third baseman.
So, you're moving him off of his biggest strength and you're making him a shortstop, which is okay.
Like, I think, I think we all could have lived with Jared Triolo being opening day shortstop, right?
For sure.
But we were all under the assumption that they were going to do something at third base.
Instead, they're taking their second baseman from last year who had an 82 weighted runs created plus and didn't play a very good second base.
And they're now shifting him and putting him at third.
Oh, and by the way, Gonzalez will also play shortstop.
He's basically the backup shortstop if Triolo needs a day off.
But you're going to have Gonzalez now playing third, which is a position that he got some playing time at in spring training.
He's played two games there in the major leagues.
He's played 19 games there in his minor league career.
So, it's a position that, like, it's not going to be entirely new to him.
But, like, he's not a third baseman, right?
Right.
You're also putting Nick Yorke in there, which Nick Yorke had a really hot start to spring.
He was hitting the ball all over the place, but then he cooled down.
he finished spring with an 85 weighted runs created plus.
Didn't hit the second half of spring.
He's not the best fielder in the world.
He can play multiple positions.
You can put him at third.
You can put him at second.
You can put him at first.
You can put him in the corners.
He just can't really do any of those that well.
He can just be there.
And he is yet to show, unlike Nick.
Nick Gonzales has at least shown that he has the capability to be, like, an average-looking major league hitter at times.
Like, last year, he wasn't that.
But in 2024, he put up a pretty average major league season at the plate.
Like I said, Jared Triolo as a stopgap shortstop is perfectly acceptable in my mind.
But that came with the thought that, well, they're going to get a third baseman.
they traded Cabrian and A's.
So, they're going to reallocate this fund and get a third baseman, right?
No, I was wrong.
So, now it's like it's Jared Triolo at short, which, again, I'm fine with, but that is out of position.
like you said, he could potentially win a gold glove.
Like, Cabrian's still in the NL Central, so it's probably going to go to him.
But, like, Jared Triolo will contend, most likely, for a gold glove at third base.
You're taking that strong suit, lessening it just a tad, just a tad at short.
I think he's capable of short, but you lessen his value a little bit by doing that.
And then you're putting Nick Gonzales at third, which, again, you're probably lessening his value because he's probably not that good at short, or I'm sorry, at third base either.
And his value isn't that high to begin with.
So, this left side of the infield is just really bad.
Just really bad.
And I'm just afraid of how it's going to get exposed.
So, yeah.
Yeah, like, this is also why it's like, okay, Connor, crush AAA.
April 9th.
Please be here.
Please be here.
We need you, buddy.
And then get this thing going.
Because I'm okay with Jared Trill as a third baseman if Konnor Griffin's that short.
So, yeah.
This is going to be a struggle.
It's going to be interesting.
Nick Yorke and Nick Gonzales have combined for one, two major league starts at third base.
And the two of them combined have played 21 games at third base in the minors.
Nick Yorke, in particular, two games at third base in his minor league career.
One start in the majors at third base.
So, it's just, and in that one start, he got an error.
So, yeah.
It's going to be interesting.
It's going to be interesting.
And, yeah.
So, hopefully, Konnor Griffin is available just as soon as possible.
Also, we've got some breaking news.
Colin Beasley just reported that Hunter Barco has made the Pirates opening day roster.
That's per Colin Beasley of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.
I think we nailed pretty much all of it that was needed.
Anything else that you wanted to make sure we hit on before we wrap this up?
Ooh.
I'm sure we missed something, right?
But, I think we talked about a lot in our 47 minutes on air.
It's, yeah.
I said, baseball's four days away.
Like, real games that matter.
One of my favorite episodes of NS9 Live of the season is coming up on Wednesday.
We'll do our prediction episode, our over and under.
So, make sure you check that out.
We're going to have Offbeat every day this week and every week to come after that.
So, make sure you're checking out Alex's stuff.
Alex's stuff has been really good.
I know it's new to the channel and you got to get used to having that every morning show.
But, check it out.
Make that part of your daily routine to just check out what Alex has going on.
It's super easy to consume.
It's 15 minutes a morning and it's good stuff.
So, I highly recommend watching and or listening to that every morning.
Tailgate, April 18th.
The tailgate's free.
We've got group tickets available.
There's about 40 group tickets left.
So, just make sure you grab those.
They come with $10 in loaded value.
You get a ticket in the bleachers with the rest of the NS9 crew.
We're doing a picture on the game after the game.
And, we...
Yeah, it's going to be a lot of fun.
It's going to be a lot of fun.
So, make sure you pick up your ticket for that.
But, yeah.
I'm excited for baseball to start, dude.
Off-season always seems like this long, treacherous journey where we're just talking about rumors and roster decisions and what the team's going to look like.
And we finally have an idea of what that team looks like now.
And now it's just a matter of going out there on the field and seeing if it's good enough.
And this is the first year that I've been doing this podcast since 2020 where I'm like, this team might actually be good enough for a playoff appearance.
Like, this is the best team on paper that Ben Cherington has ever deployed.
And that's what I was going to say.
it's a long off-season for nothing because this team still isn't that good.
So, whatever.
And, like, this is the first year it's like, you know what?
There might be something exciting this season.
I think this team will be interesting at the very least.
it's good enough to at least be an interesting season.
They shouldn't suck.
Right.
They shouldn't suck.
Right.
So, there's at least that.
But, yeah.
I think this team can actually contend to some level.
there's still a trade deadline.
There's still things that can happen.
Games need to be played.
But this pitching staff looks nasty.
we talked about it, Tyler and I, on the breakout game as far as prospects.
But even this Major League team, everyone knows about Paul Skenes.
Comments· 0
Will Braxton Ashcraft have a better season than Bubba Chandler?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.