◆NEWSPirates Notes: Keller, Pitching Pursuits, Lineup◆ROSTERSigned free agent RHP Enmanuel Nunez to a minor league contract◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
◆NEWSPirates Notes: Keller, Pitching Pursuits, Lineup◆ROSTERSigned free agent RHP Enmanuel Nunez to a minor league contract◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
The Pirates beat the Tigers in just over two hours thanks to eight stellar innings from Braxton Ashcraft in a 4-1 win Tuesday night. Ashcraft gave up just one run on five hits while striking out four batters and walking none. His eight innings came on just 80 pitches in another incredible efficient outing. DiNardo and Tyler (and then Doug) recapped this one on the NS9 Postgame Show powered by Primanti Bros. You can watch or listen here:
Remember that old Rolaids commercial from the 70’s and 80’s…”How do you spell relief? R-O-L-A-I-D-S.” Well, how about how do you spell ace? I spell it A-S-H-C-R-A-F-T. Braxton Ashcraft followed up his complete game masterpiece with another fabulous outing and nearly a second straight complete game. He finished with eight innings on just 80 pitches and could have pitched the 9th, but Don Kelly decided to go with Mason Montgomery to close it out. Ashcraft has been the best pitcher all season for the Bucs and while folks were worried about his innings total, he’s getting stronger as the season inches toward the finish line. He’s your stopper and he’s your ace in 2026.
Ashcraft started the game with three straight 1-2-3 innings. He gave up singles to Kevin McGonigle and Colt Keith in the 4th inning, but got an inning-ending double play in the next at-bat. In the 5th inning, he surrendered a two-out solo home run to Brett Callahan for the only run for the Tigers in this game. In the 6th inning, he gave up one single to Gleyber Torres and got the next two outs, he went 1-2-3 in the 7th inning and then gave up a leadoff single in the 8th inning and got the next three outs to finish his start on a strong note. If you’re going to give up a home run, solo ones are the ones to give up and besides that it was all singles. I’ve said this throughout the season and it’s held true here in his last two outings: Ashcraft has a pitched a bunch of low-stress innings because he just hasn’t allowed many hits or much traffic on the base paths.
Ashcraft has made 25 starts this season and he failed to go at least five innings in just two of them. And he’s gone more than five innings in 16-out-of-25 starts. His season ERA is now down to 3.68 and he improves to 13-5. Ashcraft had a couple rough outings in July, but he has certainly righted the ship and looks better and the efficiency has been fantastic. He’s not worried about striking everyone out, he’s pitching and getting outs. Though he can strike a lot out as evident by his complete game start last time out when he struck out 10. It’s been a truly impressive run by a starting pitcher who’s in his first full season in the Majors.
We last saw Oneil Cruz on June 7 before he was scratched from the lineup the next day and then hit the IL with a fractures in two of his fingers. He began a rehab assignment two months later on August 7, went to two levels, played two levels and didn’t hit real well at Indy and Altoona. He was activated before Monday’s game, but didn’t play at all which was a little worrisome like is 100% healthy? But it was nice to see him back in the lineup and center field Tuesday night, and it was really nice to see him belt a Keider Montero 2-2 knuckle curve into the seats for his 15th home run of the season to give the Pirates a 2-1 lead and turn the whole game around. CRUZ MISSILES ARE BACK…
And that’s the fun and power of Cruz. This lineup has missed him and it’s good to have him back and picking up right where he left off. Just because he’s back, though, doesn’t mean the Pirates playoff hopes are back on. I just want to see him have a nice month and a half to finish off the season. And with him back, you can get a little more flexible and play Mangum at one of the corner OF spots to rest Valdez or give Reynolds a chance to DH like in this game. It just makes the team better all around. The Pirates are now 10-4 in games when Cruz homers. Welcome back, Oneil!
Nice Short Game
Another added benefit of Braxton Ashcraft starts recently is that the game flies by. Tuesday night’s game was a nice 2:02 game time. That’s just fine by me! Nice quick win and you have the rest of your night to relax and enjoy the win. This was the shortest game of the season for the Pirates with four minutes to spare. The previous shortest game? May 3’s 1-0 victory over the Reds pitched by none other than Braxton Ashcraft. Yeah, he’s making a fan out of me with more than one way. A two hour win in the dog days of August with the way this team has been playing recently? Sign me up all day for that.
Comments· 1
The Debate
Should Mason Montgomery be the Pirates' set closer, with Luke Weaver locked into the 8th, instead of a closer-by-committee?
normo0066NS9 Legend· 85d ago
Ashcraft with another masterclass performance without question best pitcher on the Pirates right now !!
With Doug Ford and Tyler Sweeney.
Chapters
Key takeaways
1
Braxton Ashcraft is the Pirates' ace. He has 13 of the team's 62 wins, and the real value is that he pitches deep enough to spare a thin bullpen at a time when Mitch Keller and Paul Skenes haven't.
2
Ashcraft isn't injury-prone. The only reason to worry about his innings is that he has never thrown more than about 120 in a season, and his velocity hasn't dropped at all.
3
Oneil Cruz will probably need about two weeks to get his timing back after only six rehab games. He should work through that in the majors rather than the minors, and a strikeout rate near 35% is worth it for his production.
4
Bullpen roles matter more than a closer-by-committee. Make Mason Montgomery the closer, with Luke Weaver, possibly the best setup man in baseball, pitching the 8th.
5
Don't take Paul Skenes at -148 against the Tigers. Based on what he has shown lately, that line isn't worth betting.
He came into this season, I think, with what, 118 innings pitch last season.
So again, you understood that the innings limits were going to be there.
But he's been the guy that's been going the distance.
He's been giving this team length.
And you just wonder, at what point are they going to maybe not shut him down, but slow him down?
And he goes the distance last game.
And this game, he goes eight with 80 pitches.
The thing is, too, is like, he's giving this team a lot of innings, but he's not throwing a lot of pitches.
Yeah, that's the big thing, is he's just not really taxed when he's going deep in the games.
Like, every time he goes seven, eight innings, and even going back to early in the year, when he was going deep, it was because he was so efficient.
Like, there are no high-stress innings.
Sure, he had that stretch there in the middle of the summer where things got a little bit rough, and he got beat around a little bit.
But for the most part, every time out there, it's relatively stress-free baseball.
I guess the only thing you could say is stressful for him was they didn't score any runs through five.
So, he might have had the mentality, like, I have to pitch really well, and he gives up the one home run.
Like, that was the most stress, I guess, you could equate.
Like, it had been more of a mental stress than anything, because he was pitching so effectively physically.
The other, like, we're not seeing the velocity tick down either.
Like, we haven't seen that all year, and of course, that's been a major concern with basically everybody that pitches on this team, is the velocity dip.
We haven't seen that from him.
Like, whenever he struggled, it was basically command issues.
Like, the velocity has not dipped at all today.
It was actually up today a decent bit.
He's got the body type that he can really handle a bulk of innings, I think.
Jared Jones doesn't seem like the type of guy that's going to give you 200 innings.
If you just look at Braxton Ashcraft, that's a dude that looks like a workhorse.
I know he's got the injury history, but he just looks it.
Yeah, and like, about the injury history, I don't know if you, like, the thing about it is, like, I don't look at him as an injury-prone pitcher, and that's why I'm worried about innings.
He's had injuries in the past, which has limited his innings, which is why you're worried about the innings, because he hasn't gone out there and pitched more than 120 innings.
He hasn't pitched to the level where you then look forward and say, OK, I'm good with giving you 180 this year.
he hasn't gone to that.
So that's why you worry about the innings.
It's not so much because, like, this is a guy who's probably going to be injury-prone for his career.
But Braxton Ashcraft looks the part, and he's certainly playing the part.
He also gets lefties out.
He gets everybody out.
All right.
So I mentioned it's been 17 innings for Braxton Ashcraft his last two starts.
He's thrown 165 pitches.
If you give Carmen Mlodzinski 165 pitches, how many innings is he going?
I hate you so much because you said the 17 innings, the last two starts.
And you know where my mind went to right away?
I immediately said, Carmen has half the innings in three starts.
And then that's, of course, how you phrased that question.
I don't know.
Is that the rest of the year?
It might be.
He might get nine innings in.
Unreal.
Just an unreal stretch he's on right now.
And I know two games.
But what it reminds me of, weirdly, just watching, and I know it's a different hand, but watching him pitch right now reminds me of Jay Happ when he was on that run.
And what by that, Flores did not move his glove all night.
And that's what it was like with Happ.
You set up.
He's going to locate it exactly where he wants it.
That's what he looks like right now.
He can throw the ball wherever he wants to throw it.
And what I'll allude and say to that, he didn't look nasty in a swing and miss.
The pitches were nasty, though.
Yeah.
this is one of those starts, like, he wasn't racking up the whiffs, and that's why the pitches looked nasty.
The pitches were still equally as nasty, though.
Like, you talk about location.
he was throwing for strikes, obviously for strikes, right?
61 strikes and 80 pitches, though.
He was clearly throwing a lot of caught looking.
Like, his stuff was just so good tonight.
We have Doug, who has entered the comments because he's pulling his own Carmen Mlodzinski, and he'll appear whenever he feels like it.
Well, at least he's determined he's not a starter.
He might come in for relief today, but he's not a starter.
I'll tell you what, these young guys, you bring them in, and then they get a little bit arrogant.
He's acting like he's in a contract here, DiNardo.
Yeah, well.
Love you, Doug.
Can't spell DFA without D, like Doug.
But Ashcraft, again, he finished with 12 ground outs.
Yeah, 12 ground outs to three fly outs.
Kept the ball on the ground.
The only person that really was able to square him up was Cole Keith tonight.
It was basically just weak contact.
At one point, it felt like we might have, we joked that we might have a Braxton Ashcraft no-hitter.
Is that a little peek behind the curtains there?
Just a little peek.
Yeah, Alex finished recording his podcast.
He's like, all right, it's ready for tomorrow, which, by the way, for members, it's already out there.
He's like, all right, it's already ready for tomorrow unless Braxton does something I got to record another show for.
And, man, I'm telling you, I wished, I really wanted to make Alex have to record another show.
And it was looking that way.
But then he gave it the home run.
It's like, all right, yeah, this isn't going to be podcast number two worthy.
But you're right, man.
It was rolling that way for a little bit of time.
Outstanding again.
What more can you say about the guy?
He's efficient, good, nasty.
I love watching him pitch.
I really do.
It's crazy.
And, like, again, it's not like it's a high ERA.
Like, we're not talking about a guy who has, like, in the fours ERA, but he has a 368 ERA now.
Perfectly fine.
But I guess this is, like, the contrast to Paul Skenes's.
Because I made that joke a little bit on Buck and Brew.
Like, they both had the same ERA at that point.
It was a 3.88.
Although Braxton's lower today because they changed one to an error.
Or I forget which game or who it was.
But today they just changed a hit to an error and that lowered his ERA.
However, I don't, like, how is this ERA this high?
You know what?
Like, I know he had some struggles, but it's like those struggles were just so minute.
And it's just, I don't, he's not a 368 ERA pitcher.
You know?
Like, don't you get that?
Like, it's just like, he should be, like, at three because of those struggles.
Right.
Like, it feels like he's a sub three.
Right.
Like, he's been good, must watch for the majority of the year that it's like, where'd the 368 come from?
I don't know.
Because when it was ballooning to four, it was like, this doesn't feel right.
Right.
But Ashcraft, good.
Good to see him good.
It's nice to actually have an ace.
I know I joked about this a bit.
Before we go, though, I know I joked about this, but isn't it ironic?
And I know it's a joke and in jest, and I love the guys for doing it, whatever.
But you had a little bickering and back and forth with Paul Skenes and Bubba Chandler about who's going to be the opening day starter.
And like you said, he didn't have, like you guys were saying earlier, he didn't have his best stuff.
It wasn't all swing and miss.
He just throws strikes and gets outs, man.
It's just fantastic.
You said it early in the season.
It's more fun watching him pitch than watch Skeen's pitch, right?
Just because just the way he just gets after it, fills up the strike zone, gets outs, keeps things moving so fast that this game finished in like 27 minutes.
I thought you guys were playing it on one and a half or something.
So, it really got me there, Braxton.
But, man, what a, yeah.
And it's, I'm with DiNardo.
I don't think he's injury prone.
I think he had injuries, right?
He just had injuries.
He's overcome that.
He is right out of central casting for a starting pitcher.
Big old strong kid from Texas.
But, yeah, just what more can you say?
Tip of the cap.
You guys covered it quite well.
I can hardly wait until his next start.
You know what I'm saying?
It's like in a season that there's not much, to care about.
I want to see how he finished.
I want to see what he does.
And I'm really looking forward to what he does next year with maybe some of the restrictions come up because he'll have his innings in.
That thing.
I also just add on to that.
I know you mentioned the pitcher wins, but, and I'm not a pitcher win guy either.
But when you go deep in the games like Ashcraft has, that's where pitcher wins actually matter to me because he's legitimately going out and winning games.
He's going seven, eight innings.
Right.
But I don't know the breakdown of his 13 wins, but I would venture to guess probably half of them.
He's gone pretty deep into the game.
Right.
Right.
that's exactly it.
It's not the W that he gets, in his record.
It's the fact that on a team that did not have much of a bullpen, he was avoiding, having to use them.
That was, that was his big value.
It's that you didn't have to bring in a guy, maybe until the, eighth inning or sometimes, because he went seven innings a couple of times, went in, pitched into the seventh, that thing.
Right.
And that's, he's not being pulled in the fifth when they're up by 10.
For sure.
For sure.
And he's not, Mitch Keller was supposed to give us innings and he did not.
And schemes was supposed to give us innings and he did not.
And so the fact that Ashcraft did, it's just been a huge boost for this team.
He, man, his last two starts, he's needed one inning of relief and I'm not sure that he needed that.
He had any pitches like he could have gone, you know.
Cause I wouldn't, I like him in that ninth inning slot.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Let's cement him there.
Cause he looks good.
Yeah.
Well, we'll get to him as well.
but real quick, just to finish up the, offense here, Spencer Horwitz added the Pirates third run with a single.
And then in the eighth, Bryan Reynolds gave a little bit of insurance run or a little bit of insurance there, with a single to score tree.
Although offense really wasn't that magical today, but they did just enough to win the game.
Six hits.
this is what we thought we were going to see.
Right.
This is the, this is what we thought was going to be this team's formula for wins this year was that you would get good starting pitching.
The offense would score just enough runs and, then you'd close it out with, Dennis Santana and other people that are no longer around.
So yeah, it's a good win.
it's, again, it's pretty much how they planned it.
It's not how it's gone this year, but, it was nice to see the offense score a few.
It's nice to keep, see them keep adding on, which is, which is good.
And, nice to see production.
let's face it.
If Cruz had gone home for four today, this entire chat would be saying he's a bum and he should not be back.
So, right.
So the home run was nice.
That was a nice return.
It's nice to see Horwitz back.
Yeah.
So.
And then talked about the offense there.
The other guy that was brought up early.
And I do want to talk about a little bit here is Mason Montgomery.
He has been absolutely lights out.
Lights out.
Nasty.
The fastball is insane.
When he throws strikes, he is unhittable.
Yeah.
Flat out unhittable.
And he's been throwing strikes.
Yeah.
Yeah.
It's a, what a trade, right?
If we would have traded Michael Burroughs and got Mason Montgomery back, we'd all be happy with the results right now.
Had we traded Mason Montgomery and got Brandon Lowe back, we'd all be happy right now.
Had we traded, Mike Burroughs and got Jake Mangum back.
I think we'd all be happy.
And we got all three.
It's so out of character for Ben Sherrick to trade.
It's stunning.
usually they hang around for five years.
And then we finally, we finally give up on them.
Although we should have given up on them after the first, season or whatever.
So, yeah.
Montgomery looks good.
He looks calm and collected.
Right.
He doesn't seem to, be bothered by too much.
It's yeah.
It's just, he looks like a closer right now.
He's not shying from the moment.
That is for sure.
And I think that's something you do worry about.
I know there's the thought about the closer by committee thing.
I still think there is something to be said about just knowing your role and knowing that ninth inning is mine.
And I think there are only certain people that can handle that as well.
Some guys, you put them in the ninth inning, they crumble.
It is what it is.
We've seen that over the years through all of baseball.
Absolutely.
Tony Watson was a lights out setup, man, but wasn't a closer.
you see it and we see the need for roles.
when guys, who's normally your closer, you bring them in the eighth inning, they give up two runs, because they're not there.
you see a guy who, bats second all the time, suddenly get moved to fourth or something.
Baseball players are creatures of routine and they like knowing the roles.
They, it's part of what, has Mijinsky.
So, bunched up, it's like, I want to know my role.
I want to do that.
I want to do this.
I want to blah.
But yeah, I like, and again, I'm not against, Montgomery doesn't have to close out every game.
Some, if we need him tomorrow, if you go with, I'm not mad that they're ever going to throw the Weaver.
Sometimes you'd go with best matchups, but generally speaking, Luke Weaver is one of the best setup men in all of baseball, maybe the best.
And Mason Montgomery looks like a, and Mason Montgomery looks like a lights out closer right now.
That's a pretty good eighth and ninth.
And they'll both be on the team next year.
So if there is a next year.
Right.
And Mason Montgomery has not given up on their own runs since July 26th.
Pretty good.
That's, that seems like a long time.
Pretty good.
It is now August 18th.
20.
That's more than three weeks.
And it's not like he's not pitching.
Yeah, exactly.
It is not like they are not using them because they don't, they didn't have much else there.
He's.
He's been awesome.
Flat out.
Awesome.
One of the few relievers I've enjoyed watching for the most part of this year, there was a stretch there early in the year where he was a little bit frustrating, but.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Early on, he didn't have his command.
And, we had no idea.
She was going to find him.
And.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Does Billy Murphy get credit?
Does Billy Murphy get credit?
I think you have to give him credit there because something did click with Mason Montgomery throughout this year.
And he looks like a legitimate top flight reliever.
It's not.
Like, this is his, this is his first full season, right?
Yeah.
We have him for a while, right?
This is like very encouraging.
And it is not fluky.
As you said, unhittable when he's in the zone.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Let's give out some sandwiches.
All right.
Make sure we get the hashtag raises here into the comments.
And as soon as Doug, tell him what I'll do.
Listen, you've got to like, you've got to subscribe.
You've got to tell a friend.
You've got to, hype the video.
You've got to listen to Alex Stumpf Monday through Friday.
First thing in the morning.
You've got to listen to Bucco Brew on Mondays.
You've got to listen to North Shore Nine Live on Wednesdays or Thursdays, depending on the boys' schedule and the baseball, the team's schedule.
You've got to go.
You've got to get our app.
Our app gets better.
It just keeps getting better.
Again, hats off to DiNardo.
Thank you so much for filling in for me today.
And thank you so much for what you've done with that app.
Check out the blog.
Neil and Ryan are crushing it.
there is stuff, baby.
There is stuff.
I think that's everything.
I think you covered it all.
Good luck to everyone here.
Our first winner is going to be.
Oh, so close.
Kyron Mason, send us an email at NorthShore9 at gmail.com with your email that's associated with your Primarity Brothers account.
Congratulations.
And winner number two is going to be.
Drop the drum roll.
All these American League teams.
Jordan L, same thing.
Send us over an email to NorthShore9 at gmail.com.
That's NorthShore9 and nine is spelled out.
With your email associated with your Primarity Brothers account.
Congratulations.
Both are winners there.
It's nice to give away sandwiches.
It is.
It is.
Yeah, we had a lull there where it was let them eat cake, but not let them eat sandwiches.
Well, the Pirates will try to get another series against the Tigers tomorrow where FanDuel has them favored at minus 148 with Paul Skenes's on the mound.
Sounds like a bet I would not take.
No.
Gosh, no.
You can't do it right now.
Right?
You just can't.
you'll say darn after if he, goes out and throws seven shutout innings.
But right now, you can't give up 148 to get 100 on what we've seen.
Yeah.
It's going to be a no for me, dog.
All right.
Appreciate you all for hanging out.
We'll be back with you tomorrow.
Doug and Cody.
Me and Cody.
I'll be on time.
I'm not leaving the house tomorrow.
So there we go.
I will.
Appreciate y'all for hanging out.
We'll be back with you tomorrow.
Peace out, Girl Scouts.
All right.
That wraps up this episode of North Shore Nine.
Thanks so much for tuning in.
Whether you're listening on the podcast or catching us on YouTube, if you enjoyed the show, please give this video a thumbs up.
And don't forget to hit that subscribe button if you haven't already.
It really helps us grow.
And if you're listening on the podcast, a quick review goes a long way in helping others find the show.
Plus, be sure to tell a friend about us.
There's always room for more here in the NS9 community.
And for those looking to support us a little more, consider joining our Patreon, become an MVP member, and get exclusive perks while helping us.
Continue to bring you more of the Pirates content you love.
Thanks again for all your support, and Let's Go Bucs.
Comments· 1
Should Mason Montgomery be the Pirates' set closer, with Luke Weaver locked into the 8th, instead of a closer-by-committee?