◆NEWS2026 Non-Tenders: National League◆ROSTERRHP Noah Murdock elected free agency◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSPlayers Avoiding Arbitration Prior To The 2026 Non-Tender Deadline◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers
◆NEWS2026 Non-Tenders: National League◆ROSTERRHP Noah Murdock elected free agency◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSPlayers Avoiding Arbitration Prior To The 2026 Non-Tender Deadline◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers
The Pirates best chance at winning a game in this international series came crashing down as Paul Skenes gave up four runs on nine hits in five innings to hand the Pirates another loss 5-2 to fall back to .500. Bryan Reynolds had two hits and Marcell Ozuna drove in both of the Pirates runs in the losing effort. Tyler and Doug recapped this one on the NS9 Postgame Show powered by Primanti’s Bros. You can watch/listen here:
Paul Skenes had a 67.50 ERA after that absurd Opening Day where he didn’t make it out of the first inning thanks to some timely hitting and defensive mishaps. Since that performance in his next eight starts, he allowed just one run or less in seven starts. He posted back-to-back eight shutout innings to open May and lowered his ERA to his usual 1.98. Since those two 8.0-inning performances though, he’s run out of gas in his last two starts including Saturday giving up nine earned runs in his last two starts to balloon his ERA to 3.00. This is the problem with Skenes…he’s so good that when he has a couple mediocre outings, you start wondering what’s up with him? Both starts have starting off fine, but he suddenly hits a fall in the 5th-6th inning. In this game as well he only struck out two batters, his lowest total since that Opening Day fiasco.
I would normally say it happens, flush it and move on but this start was almost exactly like his last one and you just don’t see two bad Skenes starts in a row. So what’s up? Is this just a bad stretch for him? Are teams figuring something out with him that they are taking advantage of or is he experiencing a tired arm as he gets deeper into games after consecutive eight-inning performances? That’s the million dollar question. Hopefully it’s not a tired/dead arm or something where he isn’t 100%. Skenes tossed 187.2 innings last season and never really gave the impression that he was overworked. If anything, he’s one guy that looked and felt like he could pitch 200+ innings where he went 120+ pitches every game like a throwback starting pitcher did back in the day. But these last two starts has me worried about that a bit. Is he really low on gas already in May this season? Doesn’t seem possible, but hopefully he knows himself and will figure it out or speak up if something isn’t right with himself.
Two Steps Forward, Two Steps Back
Every time this team gets a couple games above .500 and on a little bit of a run, they fall right back down to .500. They were 16-11 on April 25 and lost five straight to end April at .500. Then rolled out to 24-21, lost three straight to .500. Then won the next two in St. Louis to go 26-24 and then lose the next two in Canada. This team isn’t bad, but they’re incredibly frustrating because it looks like they’re going to hover around .500 all season. They’ll put some good games together to make you think a big run is coming, but then suddenly come crashing back down to Earth. The offense looks great in St. Louis and then can’t hit anything against the Blue Jays.
I think this team is a year away…they’re definitely better than we’ve seen in a while, they have some young pieces in place but lack of depth, lack of strong bullpen arms and probably running out of innings from their young starter arms is probably going to cap this team in 2026. Maybe I’m wrong, maybe this team will get hot in June or July and rip off 10 straight or 12-out-of-13 and be sitting in first place of the NL Central. But as we continue to watch this team, it just feels like they’re a year away to me.
To Stop the Pirates Offense, Just Start a Southpaw
Literally any southpaw will work too. Saturday, it was lefty Patrick Corbin‘s turn to mow the Pirates down. Corbin is 36, had a 4.23 ERA coming in with just 5.9 K/9 and he looked like Warren Spahn in this game. Corbin not only outdueled Skenes, but he goes six strong with just one run allowed and seven strikeouts, his high of the season. Which leads to this incredibly bad, hard-to-believe stat from Colin Beazley and Jason Mackey.
Seven starts against those lefties and they had a 0.40 ERA against the Pirates bats in 45.1 innings. That’s stupid. This lineup’s kypronite is lefty pitchers. It’s a serious problem. They are basically uncompetitive against them. Just like trying to fix a bullpen problem in May, I’m not sure there’s an answer here to make them suddenly better against lefties. They are what they are at this point.
Comments· 0
The Debate
Should the Pirates sell high on Oneil Cruz or Bryan Reynolds to give Valdez and Garcia everyday at-bats and extend Brandon Lowe?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.
With Doug Ford and Tyler Sweeney.
Chapters
Key takeaways
1
Don Kelly should stop sitting Brandon Lowe against lefties. Even lefty-on-lefty, Lowe's power gives the lineup more than Jared Triolo, and right-handed relievers show up by the sixth inning anyway.
2
Oneil Cruz's 7th-inning strikeout looking was 'one of the most putrid, uninspiring, pathetic at-bats' ever. He has hit .214/.277/.357 since April 17 and the Pirates are running out of time to wait for him to figure it out.
3
Calling up both Valdez and Garcia hints at a trade. Sell high on Cruz and/or move Bryan Reynolds, play the kids every day, and use the money saved to extend Brandon Lowe.
4
Endy Rodríguez should get the lion's share of the catching if he stays healthy. Henry Davis's swing produces only pop-ups and foul balls, which makes him unplayable even with his better defense.
5
No panic on Paul Skenes after back-to-back bad starts (5 IP, 4 ER, 2 K today). Expect him to bounce back against the Cubs, but if it happens a third time, fatigue becomes a real question.
Alright, what's going on, beautiful people? It's the North Shore Nine podcast presented by FanDuel. I'm Tyler. Doug is currently having some technical difficulties, but you're listening to the North Shore Nine postgame show, powered by Primanti Brothers, and speak of the devil, there's my guy, Dougie Fresh.
Doug, the Pirates lose this one, 5-2. Paul Skenes's got the start on the mound. It went very poorly. Basically, everything went very poorly today, including your internet situation today. Like, nothing's going our way, my man.
I tell you, it's a struggle pouring down rain here. Let's see if I get this light back on and get the shadows off this beautiful face that needs to be in high depth.
Exactly. Yeah. Paul Skenes's wasn't good enough today. The offense wasn't good enough today, especially with runners in scoring position. The umpires weren't good enough today, not being able to, tell when a guy swings at a pitch thing.
So, yeah, it, just, it was bad. It was, it was bad. It was just, nothing like extraordinary or anything. but, when Paul Skenes's gives up the most extra base hits, he's ever given up a game, most hits he's ever given up in a game, you're more than likely going to lose, especially when you can't hit with runners in scoring position.
It wasn't very fun. And I was about to do that there, Doug. Shout out to Michael here for the donation mentions that the team stinks. The lineup was terrible when sitting low was ridiculous.
Oneil Cruz needs to be traded. Don Kelly and Ben Cherington need to be fired. I don't know if I agree with all of that, but definitely.
That might be a little overreactionary, but there's some merit to it. Yeah. But there was a game here today. Like I mentioned, and coming into today, you have Paul Skenes's on the mound. You have Patrick Corbin across the diamond pitching for the blue Jays. Patrick Corbin is not a good pitcher. Patrick Corbin stinks.
Yes. But he's owned the pirates in those years when he was at Washington and his ERA would be 6.7. He'd come in and go eight shutout innings against the pirates. Now those were some bad pirate teams, but he is just, he is the perfect pitcher.
again, he had his, he tied his season high in innings and, set his season high in strikeouts. that I get to say that almost every time I'm on the show that some pitcher, some journeyman pitcher, some guy coming off injury has done those sorts of things. even with the better offense, we still seem to make guys that are at the end or have never been that good. Look fantastic.
Corbin goes six innings strikes out seven that lowers ZRA below four. Again, he is not good. He's terrible, but he throws with his left hands and which is something the pirates do not hit. Well, so maybe I need to go pitch against the pirates. Regardless, Paul Skenes did get to start today. I like your chances. Like I mentioned, you look at this on paper, the pirates have skeins going Corbin already mentioned what I think he is.
This should be a win. This is back-to-back starts where Paul Skenes just did not look, has not looked good.
No, I'm, he looked bad today. He looked, concerned isn't the right word, but it's like, yeah, he just didn't have it today. He, this was a, late August, Mitch Keller type start, just, hard hit ball after hard hit ball. He gives up the solo home run, then four straight,
balls to walk somebody. And, we're two batters in and I'm like, this is not going to go well. And again, he is so good and he is so special that he can navigate it part of the way, but he didn't have it today. You knew early on, he didn't have it. And, then the offense refused to, get any hits with runners in scoring position. And so that is a recipe for failure.
And again, I'm with you, Doug, I'm not panicking about Paul Skenes. I'm not concerned about Paul Skenes. It is back to back starts that he hasn't been very good right now.
It's going to sound a lot more harsh than I really mean it to be, but right now he looks like Garrett cold as a pirate. These last two starts. Yeah, that's how it looks. Yeah. Yeah. That's a good time. You get every single out. He could not put anybody away today. And a lot of that's because his sweeper just didn't work. he had to go primarily fastball sinker today. Sweeper.
Just could not command it whatsoever. No, he was wild with it. it wasn't close. Right. And even when he was able to get into like a one, two count, get two strikes on a guy, it was three, two, right before you knew it. And he's battling, just trying to get an out in that spot.
It just wasn't Paul Skenes the way we've come to know Paul Skenes. Right. Right. as a guy that we watched, went, 35 innings with one walk. Right. he was, he was going, five and six innings of no hit baseball and, often perfect baseball. And, yeah, then suddenly these last two darts starts, he's looked very human.
I don't know who the next start is, but, hopefully he bounces back and gets on another one of those freaks where he's just unhittable, but yeah, last two. again, last two, he had just got his ERA under two again, and now it's up to who knows what it is now.
It is at three. Yeah. that doesn't sound.
Yeah. It's three, but yeah, it's just been a little bit of a battle.
It's been a battle.
These last couple games for schemes.
and with all that being said, the game did start with a home run by George Springer.
Looked like it might get ugly early, but aside from that, even without missing bats today, he gave up one run going into the sixth inning.
He was, he's still so good that he's able to get guys out and limit damage as well as anybody can in major league baseball.
And sixth inning comes around, however, they start tagging him a good bit.
It just sucked today. It just, yeah. Today was, today was shitty.
I'm psyched. I'm pumped to see a Paul Skenes star. And that's not what I got. Right. I feel cheated. Right.
And even as he don't, like I said, he don't give it up run, but it was, it just, he did not look like the Paul Skenes that we're used to seeing.
and yeah. And then like I said, that sixth inning was his downfall.
Yeah. It gives up three runs there in that sixth. some of those, well, I think one of them was inherited. It was a double play.
Yoan Ramirez got, I don't remember who to, I think it was Jimenez into a double play. They did score a run on that. The final one that closed the book on Skenes, a five inning for earned run performance only strikes out to, which is just unheard of with this guy.
I have a sneaking suspicion that his next start will be pretty darn good.
And that's just because his name is Paul Skenes. And he usually does that.
And yes, he takes this stuff really personally, so I get the feeling that you're right, that he is, Ooh, let's see. That should be against the Cubs.
We could really use that start against the Cubs. So the one thing to note about Skenes.
Is I think we had a maximum velocity today of like 98.2.
It's not significantly lowered or anything, but it's just, we're not seeing him really ramp up and hit triple digits anymore too often, but.
No, he doesn't do that too much. He's definitely take something off of it. but my frustration with that is that's fine.
Then, throw more strikes. You're still going three and two on everybody.
even when he's in his, when he's pitching great, he does tend to, throw a lot of pitches.
And if you're, if you're not, you're going to be blown by guys and striking them out, like, Oh, Ray Sears, let's get that three pitch outcome.
Go to Ray Miller, work fast, throw strikes, change speeds, whatever, any of these little pitching cliches.
But, yeah, I guess it's not really out of line of where he has been this year.
yeah, it's 97 on the fastball today, but I don't know.
I'm, I think I'm just used to seeing him ramp it up a little here and there, at least still.
It's like, it's right.
It's nice to know that he's got it when he needs it.
Right.
That he can just, all right, I'm going to hit one Oh one.
Good luck with that.
I've been throwing at 98, 99 all day, but it's a big moment.
All right, whatever there's two on, I want this out, see if he can hit gas, you know.
Instead today was gas as in, they just look like they passed gas.
Yeah.
But like I said, I just need suspicion that Paul Skenes will bounce back here.
okay.
So let me ask you this.
What if he does, sir?
What if he has another five run for a five inning for four run start next time, will you start to be concerned?
Well, you think, is it fatigue?
Is it something or, I think it depends how he looks while doing it.
Yeah, that's fair.
if it's, if it's more similar to the last outing where the inherited runners are what comes up to, but yeah, because the bullpen can't get anybody out.
But in that six inning too, if they would have just called, a swing on Jesus, but said, Jesus got a miracle.
That is very true.
You know what I'm saying?
He gets out of that.
Right.
And it was an obvious swing.
Yeah.
that was a swing.
It was swinging from his heels.
right.
nothing has held up.
That was ankles, knees, hips, bat all going forward.
I don't see how I guess they got the, you can review that in the minors now and it'll be coming our way soon.
I would have liked it today.
Yeah.
That should be there soon.
I saw it in the Arizona Foley.
I don't know how much I trust it, but we'll see what happens with that.
Offensively, this team continues to not be able to hit left-handed pitching and Don Kelly continues to sit Brandon Lowe against lefties.
And I'm getting a little bit irritated by it.
I don't care if he doesn't hit lefties that well throughout his career.
I don't care what the numbers are.
I don't care.
Generally speaking, him left-handed is better than the other option that you're putting out there, right?
Because basically what happened is Triolo took his place.
Triolo played third and, I would rather have left-handed batting or, lefty on lefty Brandon Lowe than Jared Triolo, you know?
And I, and I love Triolo defensively.
I, and there's a, there's a spot for him on his team.
I don't want to, but he really shouldn't be hitting that much until August, you know?
So, and I would just assume, like I said, run Brandon Lowe out there because Brandon Lowe does run into, and again, with that power, he does run into one once in a while.
Triolo's not going to run into any, so.
And that's really been the Buccos' problem lately is they're not hitting the ball over the wall.
It's hard.
It's really hard to string together enough base runners to put a lot of runs on the board without hitting homers.
It's hard to do that.
People don't hit 280 and 300 anymore.
So, yes, it's hard to get four guys in a row to get four singles in a row to get some runs in and then, maybe a double or something.
You don't, because there's just so many strikeouts.
The pitching is so good.
The advanced scouting is so good.
And the hitting is just so bad.
They're just so overmatched now.
It's hard, especially when nobody knows how to bunt or any of that stuff, to string together enough stuff to have anything other than maybe a one-run inning.
You need, like I said, you've been saying this the whole time you've been on the podcast.
You have to put the ball over the wall.
It's not a style of baseball.
I liked the old, hit and run and, that stuff.
I don't like sacrifices.
Jim Leyland used to drive me crazy, always using J-Bell to sacrifice.
But, that being said, I do like the aggressive, just trying to get to the next base thing.
And, but it's baseball now, or it's certainly pirate baseball.
It doesn't matter if we have G1 Bay up, Jared Triolo up, or, Ozuna or Cruz.
Everybody's swinging for the fences now.
So, and if you're swinging for the fences and not reaching the fences, things get a little ugly, a little bogged down, and very low score.
Yeah, especially when you have Nick Gonzales in the lineup, who has traded any ounce of power he has for contact this year, which is fine.
It gets rung up on almost the same exact pitch as that first called strike that was also three inches above the zone.
Cruz stands there just blankly staring again.
I don't like to really criticize effort too much and will and things like that in baseball because it's really hard to tell.
That was one of the most putrid, uninspiring, pathetic at-bats I've ever seen in my life.
And he legitimately looked like he wanted nothing to do with playing the game of baseball today.
And that one just pissed me off a good bit.
I felt the same way.
Was he pouting because he didn't start?
You just wonder.
And that's the problem with Cruz.
Cruz is emblematic of this team.
When he looks good, he looks better than anybody in the world.
When he looks bad, he looks like the worst player in the world.
And you don't want him on the team, as evidenced by everything in our chat today.
Like they now just hate him and want to run him out of town and all that stuff.
And, again, this is – I say this all the time now.
We come to these games with baggage.
And the baggage with Cruz is that last year he didn't look like he was focused, giving full effort, and was terrible from this time on for the rest of the year.
Was just about the worst hitter in baseball for the rest of the year.
went weeks without stealing a base and just, whatever.
So here we are again.
And he's been better.
He's been better.
But that looked just awful today.
he just – he just – like I said, it looked like he was pouting.
It looked like he didn't want to play.
it's like, why are you making me come – that thing.
And, again, I don't know what's in his head.
And, I hate trying to, infer things from someone's facial expressions and body language.
But, man, focus a little on optics there, buddy.
You realize that just looks bad to all of us.
and while we're going through these losses and these pathetic offensive performances and you look like you just – I'm just going to stand here and let them strike me out.
it's like – it's almost like he tells the pitcher, hey, just throw it down the middle.
I'm cool.
Don't worry.
Let's get this over with.
Start this year up until April 17th, he was hitting .313 with a .382 on base percentage and a .588 slug.
Since then, this was coming into the day, .214, .277, and .357.
He has one home run in the month of May.
Again, I don't really like to get into the, effort level because it's baseball.
Baseball is hard to tell.
But at least be a little bit engaged here, man, because there are way too many times where this guy is just not engaged in the baseball game.
And it's a problem.
it's his biggest issue, right?
It's his biggest issue.
It's not his physical ability.
It's not – I really don't think it's his work ethic.
It's just he doesn't seem to be, frequently does not seem to be engaged, in focus, involved in a game in any way, shape, or form.
someone suggested he be a receiver because, I guess he's got the diva tendency.
But maybe he should be a receiver because he only has to play once a week.
And you can focus once a week, but to having to do this every day, it's a grind, I imagine.
It's very challenging, facing these pitchers and all, everything working against you in that regard.
But it's the life you've chosen, as we, said in The Godfather, this is the life we've chosen.
So – It's getting very frustrating because it's the same thing over and over.
We did this last year, too.
I feel like we do this damn near every year with him.
And eventually, I do wonder when it's just enough is enough.
Right now, enough can't be enough because he's too important to this team, and they need him to be a good baseball player.
Hell, they don't have another center fielder, really, other than Garcia.
But we're running out of time for him to figure this out.
I'm – it's getting real old.
It's starting to get really old.
Yeah, for me – and I put this in the chat on you and Donato's show on Thursday night, and it's an N9 live.
Like, I'm wondering if they're looking to trade him or Reynolds.
If Valdez is up here, he needs to be getting at-bats.
If Garcia is up here, he needs to be getting at-bats.
So, I wonder, if they're considering something, if they're looking into something.
And I said early in the season that if Cruz starts out hot, I would strongly consider trading him.
And while I realize how good he has been, has contributed to the winning, I just wonder if, like, sell high, get something back in return, put a better defensive player in the outfield, a younger guy.
And my other thought is that, say you trade Cruz and Reynolds both, you play Valdez and Garcia, you just saved a bunch of money, and maybe you extend Brandon Lowe.
I don't know.
It's just some thoughts.
It just seems odd to me that they brought up both young guys because I don't think they're going to sit Bryan Reynolds.
So I don't know that, you're going to sit him some, but you're not going to sit him every day either.
Well, Doug, you mentioned the young guys there.
We're going to talk about them here next, but before we do that, let's hear from Cody and our friends over at IQ Bar.
Love, Cody.
I need a brain.
This episode is brought to you by IQ Bar, our exclusive snack hydration sponsor.
IQ Bar protein bars, IQ Mix hydration mixes, and IQ Joe mushroom coffees are the delicious, low-sugar brain and body fuel you need to win your day.
The Ultimate Sampler Pack is a great way for you to try all IQ Bar products and flavors.
You get nine IQ bars, eight IQ Mix sticks, and four IQ Joe sticks.
All IQ Bar products are clean label certified and entirely free from gluten, dairy, soy, GMOs, and artificial ingredients.
With over 20,000 five-star reviews and counting, more people than ever are fueling their lifestyles with IQ Bar's brain and body boosting bars, hydration mixes, and mushroom coffees.
The Ultimate Sampler Pack includes all three.
My personal favorites so far have been the almond butter chip and the iced tea lemonade hydration mix.
It's just really full of flavor.
I love starting my day with it, and I couldn't imagine starting my day with anything else other than IQ Bar products.
Right now, IQ Bar is offering our podcast listeners 20% off all IQ Bar products, including the Ultimate Sampler Pack, plus free shipping.
To get your 20% off, text MLB to 64000.
That's MLB 64000.
Message and data rates may apply.
See terms for details.
So, if you've since Garcia has been here just about a week now, Valdez gets his second start in a row.
Both of them in the lineup here today, Garcia with a hit, and then Valdez does go 0 for 2.
What have you seen so far out of the young bucks here, Doug?
Well, Garcia, in particular, has looked pretty good, right?
he's having good at bats.
He's playing the field well.
What is he hitting?
313?
Yeah, he's hitting 313.
again, what is that?
Over, 16 at bats or something along those lines.
But, yeah, he doesn't look outclassed or overmatched or anything.
So, similar to what we're seeing with, like, Conor.
Conor came up.
It was a lot of singles early on.
But now, he's made of his adjustments.
He's learning on the fly.
He's hitting the ball a little harder.
We're seeing more doubles.
We're seeing more hard hit balls, that thing.
I wouldn't be surprised to see similar from Garcia.
The Pirates are not favored tomorrow, according to FanDuel.
So, I guess maybe a little bit of value there, possibly.
Dylan Cease is on the mound for the Blue Jays.
It's going to be a tough ask.
You got to try to salvage one here.
Yeah.
Yeah.
You just, you can't keep, bookending three and four game losing streaks in between, with two wins.
you need, you need to, you need to get back to winning series.
You need to get back to, playing better baseball.
And they're not.
Right now, they're like, they're, they are, as to quote old Bill Parcells, we are what a record says we are, you know.
And they're a 500 team, right?
They have some moments, but they can't do it on a consistent basis.
They can't do it in crunch time.
it's something will always fail them.
If the, if the starter isn't great, or if the starter is great, the bullpen will fail.
If the starter isn't great, the offense, just there's something, there's always something.
Hopefully they can get back on track tomorrow so they can head into a Cubs series where the Cubs are Cubs are in a free fall and hopefully they can jump on them.
And you know what the Cubs are saying, what they're saying on NS and Cubs right now is on Wrigley, NS9 Wrigley.
They're saying, well, the Pirates are coming to town soon.
So all our pitchers are going to look great.
Get back on track.
Hopefully we get some momentum.
so hopefully not.
Yeah.
We will be back with you folks tomorrow.
Appreciate you all for tuning in.
Doug, any last words?
I really wanted to give sandwiches way folks.
I'm sorry that we couldn't, but hopefully tomorrow come back and join us three weeks from today.
I believe we will be in Pittsburgh.
We will be in one of those lots.
I should know which one, but I believe we're doing the same lot.
We did last time.
Right.
I don't know the name of it.
I can't remember.
Just follow us on socials.
I will have more to be in the bio here.
Get some tickets.
Come join us.
Come join us.
Give me about five minutes.
I'll add that link into the bio.
We're out of here.
Appreciate you all for hanging out.
Thanks guys.
Let's go Bucs.
Peace out, our Scouts.
All right.
That wraps up this episode of North Shore Nine.
Thanks so much for tuning in.
Whether you're listening on the podcast or catching us on YouTube, if you enjoyed the show, please give this video a thumbs up.
And don't forget to hit that subscribe button if you haven't already.
It really helps us grow.
And if you're listening on the podcast, a quick review goes a long way in helping others find the show.
Plus, be sure to tell a friend about us.
There's always room for more here in the NS9 community.
And for those looking to support us a little more, consider joining our Patreon, become an MVP member, and get exclusive perks while helping us continue to bring you more of the Pirates content you love.
Thanks again for all your support, and let's go Bucs.
Comments· 0
Should the Pirates sell high on Oneil Cruz or Bryan Reynolds to give Valdez and Garcia everyday at-bats and extend Brandon Lowe?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.