◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)◆NEWSPirates, Chas McCormick Agree To Minor League Deal
◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)◆NEWSPirates, Chas McCormick Agree To Minor League Deal
The hellish skid from playoff prominence continued on Thursday night as the Pirates lost to their division rivals the Cincinnati Reds 3-2. Despite the bullpen doing an admirable job to keep the Reds at bay all game, the offence capitulated yet again and couldn’t capitalise on facing one of the worst starters in baseball. The team went 1-7 with RISP, including not scoring with the bases loaded in the 7th inning. The Bucs have now fallen to .500 and are in danger of becoming sellers if the ship isn’t turned around fast. Watch Tyler and Jim break down the game in detail here:
This Team Can Never Be Good at Everything
If the Pirates had this kind of bullpen performance in April and May, the team would’ve been 10 games over .500 and comfortably in a playoff spot heading into the deadline. Instead, as soon as the bullpen starts pitching well for 2 weeks, the offense suddenly vanishes into thin air. Gregory Soto was not good, but a bullpen game surrendering 3 runs over 9 innings is a win for this team. Especially when facing Rhett Lowder, who has an era in the mid-5s, you would expect this to be an easy win for the Pirates. The reality was that the Pirates offense couldn’t get anything going yet again, scoring only 2 runs. The team has consistently had 2/3 of a playoff team, whereas the other third has sunk their ability to go on prolonged winning streaks. It now threatens the team’s ability to buy at the deadline because of 5 other teams fighting for the same playoff spot.
This Team Lacks a Clutch Gene
Statistically, the Pirates are clearly one of the best teams in baseball. They have accumulated the top 5 WAR in the league, as well as being one of the best run generators in the sport. They have gotten elite performances from some of their starting pitching and have some guys who are statistically reliable. Yet this has not translated into wins that reflect these stats, because they have struggled all year to close out close games. This team is not good at coming through in high-leverage situations, including both the bullpen and the offense. The team had 7 at-bats with runners in scoring position tonight and only delivered a hit a single time. Gregory Soto only surrendered a single hit, but because he can’t control his pitches, he basically walked home the winning run tonight. It has been great fun to watch this team effortlessly dump double-digit runs on opponents repeatedly this season. However, I would happily forgo those wins if they could learn how to close out games like this and during the Diamondbacks series. The season depends on it.
Jacob Gonzalez Is Ben Cherington’s Poster Boy
Ever since the Cleveland series, Jacob Gonzalez has been pretty much worthless in terms of offensive output. He only got one at bat tonight, and has been rarely used since arriving in Pittsburgh. He is slashing .219/.212/.438 and has an OPS+ of 72 in a Pittsburgh uniform. Ben intentionally decided to not help the bullpen by acquiring Brooks Raley (sub 2.50 ERA) from the Mets and instead went for pure value. Gonzalez has not been able to show that value on a consistent basis when the offense needed him the most. He could be the offensive spark that is needed to pick up a slumping Bryan Reynolds and Ryan O’Hearn, and instead he’s a bench bat that occasionally replaces Jared Triolo. It’s not fair to lay most of the blame at Gonzalez’s feet, but it is a good microcosm of how Cherington operates. He is always playing for next year and not addressing the current needs to the team. He did it in 2024 where he barely committed to buying, and unless he radically changes his approach in the next week we will see something similar at this deadline.
Comments· 0
The Debate
After a 7-pitch 8th inning, should Mason Montgomery have stayed in to pitch the 9th instead of handing it to Gregory Soto?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.
With Jim Rosati and Tyler Sweeney.
Chapters
Key takeaways
1
Jhostynxon Garcia looks overmatched at the plate and doesn't look like he belongs. He was called up to hit lefties and struck out in both of his big spots against them.
2
Mason Montgomery needed only 7 pitches for the 8th, so he should have stayed in for the 9th to face the top of the Reds order. That would have saved Gregory Soto for extras on a bullpen day.
3
Pinch-running Billy Cook for Esmerlyn Valdez in a 2-2 game was a bad trade-off. Valdez is in the 68th percentile in sprint speed and already scores from second, Cook never tried to steal third, and in extras Cook would have been batting third.
4
The bullpen game wasn't why the Pirates lost. Allowing 3 runs at Great American is a winning effort, and the offense is to blame.
5
Garcia's value has dropped since the Pirates acquired him, but after a strong month at Indianapolis he could still be trade bait if he looks halfway decent.
You're listening to the North Shore Nine podcast presented by FanDuel, and this is the NS9 Post Game Show, powered by Primanti Brothers.
I'm Tyler.
Live from Great American Small Park is Jim.
Jim, that was frustrating, man.
Yeah, it really was.
Bullpen game for the Pirates today.
The results were there.
It wasn't necessarily the prettiest pitching performances, outside maybe Mason Montgomery and Yohan Ramirez looked good, but overall, the bullpen game did fairly well, but the offense just couldn't get the red louder, and then they couldn't really add on against the Reds bullpen.
It was a little frustrating.
Pirates lose this one in walk-off fashion, 3-2 on an infield single, because why the hell not?
Let's just make it even more painful.
Like you mentioned, a bullpen game against Rhett Lauder, who is absolute dogshit, couldn't score any runs off of him.
The pitching performance, as you mentioned, effort was there.
you give up three runs throughout a game.
You expect to win that game.
Was it pretty?
Absolutely not.
It was quite ugly to watch, to be honest with you, but they gave up three runs.
What was uglier was this offense.
This offense was absolutely atrocious again.
Yeah, back to 500, which is unfortunate, because going into that homestand last week, they were, what, three games over 500?
Yeah.
And so now, you've lost five of seven.
And yeah, back to 500.
I don't know what Arizona's doing right now.
I don't know what everybody else is doing right now.
But if Arizona wins, then you're now three games back of them.
And when, three days ago, you were in possession of the last wild card.
So yeah, it's been a frustrating last few days for this Pirates team.
And, you felt good going into this game against Rhett Lauder.
The Pirates offense has played really well against right-handed pitching.
They hit Lauder a ton earlier this year, but they just couldn't really get to him today.
They got two runs across in Lauder's six innings of work.
But they really weren't able to do a whole lot of damage against them.
Yeah.
when you're in Great American Ballpark, you need to hit the ball over the wall.
We saw that one time today, and we'll get to all that.
But real quick, got to give a shout-out to our guy, Michael B., as per usual.
Michael B. says, fire Don Kelly.
He pulls Valdez for the Cone Man.
He takes out Montgomery after only seven pitches for really no reason at all.
Don Kelly sucks.
I definitely want to talk about that pinch running appearance.
It ultimately didn't matter, but that one was a little mind-boggling to me.
I think there were a couple Don Kelly things that happened today that I would like to talk about that didn't really bite the pirates in the butt, but there were some questionable decisions made.
One of the questionable decisions, I don't know if it's really questionable here, was the way they went about this game, Jim.
They come out, push everyone back a day, go with a bullpen day.
Yohan Ramirez gets the start on the mound.
Yohan was good, Jim.
Yeah.
As much as you just hate bullpen games, right?
I despise them.
The strategy worked today for the most part.
Like I said, they only gave up three runs, which you'll take that pretty much every day in this ballpark.
They were lucky, I think, to be facing one of the worst offenses in baseball in the Cincinnati Reds because this pitching staff, they did keep some runs off the board, but they didn't, again, it didn't look, they didn't look very pretty in doing so.
But, yeah, I don't really fault the decision to do a game like this.
They've played a lot of double headers.
They've played 17 games in 17 days.
I'm fine.
It's, what is it, July.
It's hot.
I'm cool with doing a game like this.
And, again, like the reason why they lost today wasn't because of the pitching.
So, like, they held up their end of the bargain today.
I would agree with you.
And, again, it wasn't pretty.
You give up three runs in nine innings.
I think a lot of times you expect to win that game.
And, Yohan Ramirez was the starter that.
He goes two innings, strikes out four.
A little bit classic Yohan to start the game all over the place a bit, but he settled in nicely.
And what are the recent stats here, Jim, for Yohan?
Yeah.
Since June 3rd, Yohan Ramirez was a 0.39 earned run average.
I think that's over his last 18 games.
That's a little bit over 23 innings in that time period.
So, he has been far and away the most effective Pirates reliever over the last, month, really two months, essentially.
And, yeah, he gets the ball today, opens up, and leads off the game with a walk of Eli De La Cruz.
And so you're like, all right, here we go.
Yohan Ramirez experience.
But, yeah, then he settled down.
Got the next three batters there in the first.
He gave up another leadoff base runner in the second with a double to Nathaniel Lowe.
But then fly out, strike out, strike out.
So, two innings, two scoreless innings for Yohan Ramirez.
Can't ask for much more than that.
And he's been really good lately.
As crazy as it seems every time he pitches, the results have been good for Yohan Ramirez the last two months.
For sure.
And, like, even with the walks that you mentioned there, like, for the most part, he's even looked good.
It's not like he's dancing through raindrops or anything or battling with the bases loaded.
He's missing bats.
He's throwing strikes.
The walks haven't been, they're not good, but, like, they haven't been insanely bad.
he's pitching his tail off right now.
And of all the bad things that have been happening here lately, he has been a nice bright spot.
And good for Yohan because he deserves it.
Yeah, and, again, starting this game off with two scoreless innings, that was big.
You would have hoped the offense would have capitalized on that a little bit earlier.
They weren't able to.
But, yeah, great start to the game for Yohan Ramirez.
I said, danced around some trouble that was self-inflicted, but got the job done.
Making his first appearance since, I believe, April 28th, maybe, somewhere in that ballpark.
It was late April.
And Hunter Barco picks up right where he left off.
Gives up two runs.
Yeah, it wasn't pretty.
It wasn't pretty for Barco.
He, like, gives up a single to McLean in his first at bat, double to Ellie, and then a single.
So, single, double, single to start off the game.
But I think Hunter Barco owes Endy Rodríguez, like, a steak dinner or something, because this game could have gone off the rails in this three-inning span that Hunter Barco pitched in.
But Endy Rodríguez with a cot stealing of Sal Stewart in the third, and then another cot stealing of J.J. Bleday in the fifth.
Hunter Barco, Tyler, Hunter Barco gave up eight base runners, eight base runners, five hits and three walks in his three innings of work.
Somehow, only two of those runs crossed the plate.
And a large part, you got to give a shout-out to Endy.
I got to give a shout-out to Endy there.
I'm glad you did that there, because there was also something that you weren't able to see it in the ballpark.
But the Reds burned up their challenges very early in this game, one of them being by Sal Stewart, who is just a big, dumb bitch.
I cannot stand that guy.
Sal Stewart was annoying tonight.
He was quite annoying.
Yeah.
I know that the daughter threw the B-word around a lot last night.
He should have saved it for Sal Stewart, because that dude is a turd.
An absolute turd.
He was very adamant in the first inning that he did not strike out.
That ended up being a lost challenge.
And then he gets caught stealing in that third inning, and he's immediately like, no, go to replay, go to replay.
And he was dead.
He was dead to rights.
And then late in the game, he almost runs into the tarp, which I really wish he would have been running harder at it.
There was that, too.
Yep.
But all that said, with those challenges being gone, Endy was getting the buck of some calls there.
Hunter Barco got probably three or four calls that were a good bit off the plate or below the zone that Endy just straight up stole, and the Reds could not do anything about it.
So, Endy had a great day.
At least behind the plate.
Yeah, great day behind the plate.
He also probably should have had a third caught stealing in that same, what was that?
That was the, which inning was that?
That was the fifth when Ellie De La Cruz stole third, and it was a great throw.
I thought he had Ellie by a step there, at least if Nick could have gotten a quicker tag down.
Yeah.
Shout out, Endy.
Two caught ceilings behind the plate, and he also stole two bases on the base pads today, too.
Yeah.
Really nice day from Endy.
But back to Barco.
he does only give up the two runs through the three innings of work.
It was one of the ugliest three innings of work I think I've ever seen.
And hopefully we don't see much more Barco here for a little while.
But he leaves with them still in the game.
That's my take from it is, yeah, it was not pretty.
he, I got eight base runners over those three innings, but he only allows those two runs.
They were in that first inning.
It was a big zero that he put up in the fourth, a big zero that he put up in the fifth, because that did allow the Pirates to come back and tie this game in the sixth.
by the time that he got taken out of this game, it was a tie ball game.
Yeah.
So I guess, with that being said, Barco was, he was Barco.
Yeah, he wasn't, he didn't look good at all.
And even if you look at the stat line, he still gave up two runs in his three innings.
You could have hoped to maybe get a fourth, like, you would have hoped to have gotten a fourth inning out of him, but he was not very efficient.
He threw a ton of pitches, bunch of balls, and he wasn't necessarily, and he was getting hit pretty hard, too, at times.
So, yeah, he just, he just got lucky today.
And, we'll take it.
He probably should have given up more than two runs.
I don't know what his FIP was on the day, Tyler, but I'm sure it was, it was quite a bit higher than six, which is what his ERA was.
But, yeah, we'll take, we'll take that outing from Hunter Barco, I think.
And we'll take that outing, and you just mentioned his six ERA.
It's now over seven.
So his ERA still went up today.
There you go.
No, it went down.
Oh, if his ERA is over seven, and he had a six ERA today, that means it went down.
He had a six ERA before his outing today.
Right, but today, two runs in three innings is a six ERA.
Well, his ERA is 736 now.
Yeah, so it went down today.
Yeah.
Six is less than seven.
I got to see what his ERA was before today, I guess.
I will guarantee you it went down.
If his ERA is in the sevens, it went down today, Tyler.
I don't actually know what it was coming into today, to be honest with you.
Anyhow.
The Pirates do get on the board there in the fifth inning.
And Jacob Gonzalez was with a sacrifice fly to bring him in.
Something happened in between there.
Was it Endy or something?
Now I'm drawing a blank here, Jim.
Yeah, Nick Gonzales led off the inning with a double.
Endy singled and stole a base.
And then, yeah, Jacob Gonzalez hit him in with a sacrifice fly.
So, you ended up – that was an opportunity, too, for the Pirates to add on because they hadn't really – that was the first time they'd gotten anyone into scoring position all day.
But that was the first of two Jhostynxon Garcia strikeouts in big spots.
And then Jake Mangum flies out to end that inning, so they leave that runner on second.
It would have been nice to push across that third run there.
But, yeah, Jhostynxon Garcia came up in two pretty big moments today.
And strikeout.
Yeah, and then that one in particular, it's a ball.
Dead dick down the middle.
Yeah.
Neither of those two strikeouts were stellar at bats.
Yeah, he just plain and simple looks overmatched at the plate.
He does not look like he belongs at this point.
Yeah.
He did get a base hit in the ninth.
So, two outs in the ninth, he got a base hit.
But he looked – those two at bats were rough.
They were quite bad.
Yeah.
Pirates do score another one there in the sixth on a Brandon Lowe home run.
His 23rd of the year.
Thank God for Brandon Lowe.
That's really all I got to say about him.
he – there's a part later in the game where he comes up with the bases loaded and strikes out.
We'll just – we'll wait to get to that.
But, yeah, we're in a lot of this time of the game up there.
And that's, again, like when you're down 2-0 in this ballpark with this offense, I didn't really feel comfortable, but I also wasn't, like, panicking.
I was like, two runs is nothing for these guys.
Right.
I wasn't expecting the pitching to hold them at two.
But they did a good job through those middle innings to keep the Reds at two runs.
And, yeah, Brandon Lowe home run, he crushed that ball too.
That ball was a no-doubter.
That was – no matter what ballpark they were playing in, that was going to go over the fence.
So, yeah, Brandon Lowe, 23rd home run.
And I want to say, is that one away from the Pirates' second base home run record?
I don't know what Neal's was.
23 may tie it.
But he's very close to putting up, one of the best offensive seasons in Pirates' second baseman history.
And with the tie game, the Pirates' go-to recently called up Noah Murdock, who – I'll be honest with you, Jim.
I was interested in seeing him a little – just a little bit.
Like, I – I get it, yeah.
I wasn't jumping up and down to see him.
It was different.
He's a guy that – It's a new guy.
Yeah, it's a new guy that showed a good bit of swing and miss in the minors.
The walks weren't outrageous.
I was interested to see him.
I'm no longer that interested to see him, Jim.
He doesn't give up any runs, but it was not a pretty outing.
Yeah, he danced out of some, again, like, self-inflicted trouble.
His problem in his previous time in the major leagues was walks.
It was something he got under control this year.
He started the season off in Altoona, actually, had a really good – did a really good job there for the curve, got promoted to Indianapolis, has been, fine there.
And so, yeah, he's gotten a few shots.
He's been the 27th man, I think, two or three times already, but hasn't actually gotten in a game.
So, today he gets his first game action, which was planned.
The plan was to go Ramirez, Barco, Murdock, and try to get through as many as they could.
I was – you know what?
I'll say this.
Gutsy, you want to say gutsy is the word here because he did give up two hits and three walks, but he was at a ton of pitches.
The Pirates, I was surprised they left him in as long as they did because that second inning of work, Tyler, he goes, what, walk, strikeout, single, walk.
Loads the bases with one out.
He's sitting there at, like, 45 pitches, and that's – this isn't a guy who's typically throwing multiple innings.
And, like, when I say he throws multiple innings, he'll go two innings in the minors, but he normally doesn't go that far.
And so, he's at 45 pitches in his first major league game of the season, high-stress pitches every single one of them.
And, man, that double play that he induced for Eugenio Suarez to get out of that – that was the seventh inning that he got out of.
I thought right there that was going to be the game.
Suarez, up to bat, bases loaded, tie game, in this ballpark.
Tyler, I've seen that movie five or six times.
I was – I saw – I know how this story ends typically, and it normally doesn't end like that.
it was a – he had a couple rough moments earlier in the game, but that was an outstanding play by Nick Gonzales to turn that double play and get out of that with no runs.
That was a huge play.
Yeah.
Maybe the best play he's made at third base this year.
Not to mention, I was fully prepared to jump on here just bitching up a storm because Noah Murdock was still in the game at that point.
I had no idea why he was still in there.
I don't know what they're doing.
I don't understand why he was still in there, and nobody was in the bullpen warming up.
I think at that point – yeah, you know what?
I'm pretty sure at that point no one was warming up.
I don't think they were.
They were just riding Noah Murdock there, which is – It was his game right there, yeah.
That's a decision.
It worked.
It is a decision.
One that I do not agree with, but real quick, another guy who doesn't agree with many of Don Kelly's decisions.
We've got to give another shout-out to our guy, Michael B. here.
He'll say it now.
If Kelly used Barco yesterday, used Mlodzinski today for five or six innings, the Pirates win 2-1 or 2-0.
Just pure, stupid decision.
I can't really disagree with that.
Hindsight's 20-20, but it worked out the way it worked out, I guess.
I don't think pitching was the reason they lost today, though, at any rate.
No, I don't think it was.
Before we move forward here, let's kick it over to Cody and the folks at IQ Bar.
This episode is brought to you by IQ Bar, our exclusive snack, hydration, and sponsor.
IQ Bar protein bars, IQ Mix hydration mixes, and IQ Joe mushroom coffees are the delicious, low-sugar, brain and body fuel you need to win your day.
The Ultimate Sampler pack is a great way for you to try all IQ Bar products and flavors.
You get nine IQ Bars, eight IQ Mix sticks, and four IQ Joe sticks.
All IQ Bar products are Clean Label certified and entirely free from gluten, dairy, soy, GMOs, and artificial ingredients.
With over 20,000 five-star reviews and counting, more people than ever are fueling their lifestyles with IQ Bar's brain and body boosting bars, hydration mixes, and mushroom coffees.
The Ultimate Sampler pack includes all three.
My personal favorites so far have been the almond butter chip and the iced tea lemonade hydration mix.
It's just really full of flavor.
I love starting my day with it, and I couldn't imagine starting my day with anything else other than IQ Bar products.
Right now, IQ Bar is offering our podcast listeners 20% off all IQ Bar products, including the Ultimate Sampler pack, plus free shipping.
To get your 20% off, text MLB to 64000.
That's MLB 64000.
Message and data rates may apply.
See terms for details.
I know you mentioned there that it felt like that was the spot where this game was just going to get out of hand.
You've seen that movie a bunch of times.
But earlier in that inning, it felt like a spot where the Pirates really could have broke that thing open.
They have the bases loaded.
And they have Brandon Lowe up.
Doesn't go their way, I guess.
Just a day of missed opportunity.
Not even like a lot of missed opportunities, to be honest with you, Jim.
They really didn't have that much traffic today.
They did have some opportunities, right?
And that seventh inning was definitely their biggest one.
So, like, the Pirates got three guys on the bases that inning.
They didn't actually get a hit.
Nick Gonzales was the only one who put the ball on play.
And that was a fly ball to center field.
And, yeah, this is just one of those situations where Brandon Lowe, as valuable as he's been to this team, he does have a pretty big weakness.
And if he's facing a pretty decent lefty specialist out of the bullpen, sometimes he just doesn't look good, right?
And this was one of those opportunities where, like, he had a chance to do something there against a tough lefty with the bases loaded and couldn't come through.
So, yeah, that was unfortunate.
But, I think even bigger, though, before that is you did have two guys on for Jhostynxon Garcia where, like, you specifically called this guy up yesterday to start against a left-handed pitcher.
You're now getting a perfect opportunity for him to face another left-handed pitcher in a big spot in today's game.
And he strikes out swinging on, not a great at bat either.
So, that was discouraging.
I don't expect Brandon Lowe to come up big against a lefty every single time.
You'd like it to happen every once in a while.
But I think the real issue with that inning was, like, Garcia.
he's the guy that you called up to hit lefties.
And he hasn't done it, at least so far in the last two days.
Yeah.
Strikes out on three pitches.
First pitch of the at bat is a slider that's just hanging at the top of the zone, doesn't swing at it, and then he's just hacking after that.
Again, he looks overmatched pretty often.
You mentioned that he's up here to face the lefties, essentially.
And he's got to start coming through here.
Yeah.
I don't know how much time he's going to have because he's had a couple opportunities this year, and he just hasn't taken advantage of them.
Right?
And you see what has Esmerlyn Valdez has done with his opportunities.
He didn't seem like he was going to get a lot of opportunity.
Yeah.
But he just took it and ran with it.
We have not seen that from the password yet.
No.
And, like, you really would like to see it because, like we talked about last night on NS9 Live, like, the one thing this team could desperately use right now is someone that they can rely on to hit left-handed pitching consistently.
It doesn't really get much better than that, right?
I guess you could have an immaculate inning, but is this even better than an immaculate inning because he got one of the outs just on one pitch?
I don't know.
You could argue that it is.
Yeah, he was just lights out.
a pop-up to the second baseman and then a strikeout swinging and then a strikeout looking.
I guess if you could, like, if there was something to complain about here, right?
He faced 7-8-9.
Would you have rather gone Soto in the eighth to face 7-8-9 and then Montgomery in the ninth to face the top of the order?
Who knows what that eighth inning would have looked like, if Soto would have had it?
But that is, like, another nitpicky thing here that you could say is, like, Mason Montgomery, I've got more confidence in him right now than Gregory Soto.
So, maybe, like I said, I see both ways there because you want to keep the game tied going into the ninth, but at the same time, you look at the matchups and, maybe if you reverse those two, we're still playing ball.
I think if you're going by feel and what you've seen of late and how they've thrown, Montgomery's probably the guy you want facing the better bats in the Reds lineup.
I don't think that's a question.
I can understand going with Soto just because of the track record and just, he has the experience in those situations.
I think there's also a third scenario here where you look at it and go Mason Montgomery through seven pitches.
Let's ride him out a little bit longer here.
Just maybe give him a batter there in the ninth, see what it looks like, and go from there.
I think that might be the option I would have gone with.
That's another, yeah, that's a scenario where, yeah, the dude's thrown seven pitches.
you have pitchers throw that in one single at bat, right?
If he would have gone, if he would have started that inning with a seven pitch at bat, you would have still kept him in to finish the inning, right?
So what's the difference if he just starts the ninth with seven pitches?
So, yeah, that's another good point.
that, in hindsight, probably should have done that, right?
Because it didn't end up working out for him.
Yeah, and then I think the other part of it is that you're in a tie game at that point.
It's a bullpen day.
You're going to be short on arms here.
Probably stretch it as long as you can here.
If you can get an extra inning out of Montgomery and you're going to extras, you have Soto there in the 10th.
I think that's the move I make there.
Again, hindsight's 20-20.
But seven pitches, with how good he looked, I have a hard time pulling him there.
And especially, like, coming up against the top of the order.
you want your best to face their best.
And Soto's been one of their best this year.
As unreliable as he's been at times, he's still been one of their best.
And, yeah, that's the route they went, and it didn't work.
It did not, but Montgomery was awesome.
He was, yep.
Pirates went down with a whimper there in the 9th.
You mentioned the Garcia single.
Yeah, I guess Emilio Pagan, too.
Which, I don't know if any of you have been to a game at Great American Ballpark.
Let me tell you this.
Emilio Pagan is trash.
He's awful.
I think he entered today's game with a 5.1 ERA, something like that.
He's a terrible closer.
Like, one of the worst closers in Major League Baseball.
The light show they have for this guy at this ballpark, Tyler, it astounds me.
It's the way that they treat this guy with a 5-plus ERA, it's incredible.
Absolutely incredible.
You'd think that Jesus Christ was coming in to close this game with the way that they do these light shows here.
Good to know.
But anyways, he shuts the Pirates down in the 9th, so maybe the light show worked.
I don't know.
Yeah, maybe the Pirates need to get a light show for Gregory Soto.
That's better.
That's good. Yeah.
Maybe we need more light shows.
Maybe that's what we need.
Well, and then they went to Gregory Soto, and he immediately gives up a double to Ellie De La Cruz.
Ellie killed him today, though.
We got to take a second there, I think, to talk about Ellie.
Walk, stolen base, double, stolen base, double.
he was – Ellie won the game for him today.
And, he's probably the best guy on this field.
if you just look at it from a pure talent standpoint, the Reds don't have anyone else on their team that I think I'd take over, the Pirate at their position.
But Ellie is really good, and he took over this game.
They intentionally walk Sal Stewart after that.
Soto does bounce back with a strikeout of J.J. Bladet.
But then the Gregory Soto that pops up now and then pops up again, and he walks Tyler Stevenson.
You can't walk, guys.
And Nathaniel Lowe grounds to Triolo, who's just not able to turn a double play there.
Yeah, and that walk to Stevenson was huge, right?
Because you had runners on first and second, like a ground ball, right?
Like a weekly hit ground ball, like low hit, doesn't score a run with runners on first and second.
You get an out of it, and then, you move on.
But that walk to Stevenson hurt because it moved that game-winning run to third base.
And now all you had to do was what they did.
Soto made a good pitch.
He got low to do what he wanted him to do.
It was a chopper up the middle.
Triolo, it was, I think Triolo and Lowe both made like a valiant effort on that play to do what they could do.
But it was just a little bit too slow-moving of a hit to turn the double play.
And yeah, that walk of Stevenson really came back to bite him.
Yeah, it's a similar thing that happens to Soto a little bit too often.
He just, free bases too often.
And I think on the walk-off, it is what it is.
Just a slow grounder.
I don't know if anybody on this team, and not many guys in the world, are going to turn a double play there.
I would have been shocked if they had turned two there.
Just with the way, like the ball was taking Triolo towards first base.
He had to spin around, throw it to Brandon Lowe.
Brandon Lowe was off balance, going that direction.
So I think it was a really tough play to turn.
And they almost made it.
Like, they almost made it.
But Brandon Lowe beat it by just a step.
Yeah.
And that's the way the cookie crumbles, I guess.
I guess so.
Pirates lose it 3-2.
Real quick.
I know you mentioned the pinch run.
I glossed over that.
They're in the...
That was the 8th inning.
That was in the 8th, yeah.
Esmerlyn Valdez with a one-out double in the 8th of a tie game 2-2.
Valdez doubles there.
And Don Kelly goes to Billy Cook as a pinch runner.
I wanted to tweet out questioning that.
But I'm going back and forth on that, Jim.
I don't know if it was the right call or not.
It didn't matter at the end of the day.
If you get a base hit, Billy Cook runs really well.
I understand it.
I just don't...
I think where I'm at with it is if the Pirates had been up 3-2 in that position.
And you're doing it to, expand the lead and then hold the lead later on.
I'm all for that move.
In a tie game, like, you still have to take the lead here.
I think what I'm curious, and I tweeted this out because I think the only way to really find out is if you just manually go through and look at all the plays.
But I'm curious how many times Esmerlyn Valdez hasn't scored from second base on a base hit to the outfield.
Because I'd venture to say it's not many times.
Like, I would say, like, the percentage of Valdez scoring on a base hit from second base is quite high.
He's not that slow.
So, I wouldn't have made that move because, then that puts you in the peculiar situation where, had this game gone to extras, again, it didn't.
But had this game gone to extras, you would have had Brandon Lowe leading off the 10th with Bryan Reynolds on deck and Billy Cook batting third.
Right?
So, that's the issue, right?
Like, they didn't have a lead.
They were tied.
If they had the lead and then extras were a thing that would only happen if the Reds scored, go ahead and do it.
I wasn't a huge fan of the decision, mostly because I don't know how much you gain there for how much you potentially lose later in the game.
It's, I would, I really want to know how many times Valdez just hasn't scored on a base hit from second base.
I can't, off the top of my head, I can't remember it happening often.
I'm sure it has, but I can't remember it happening too often, Tyler.
Yeah.
And I think one of my, like, one of the reasons I didn't really dislike it right off the bat was I want Cook to steal third there.
And according to FanDuel, the pirates are favored at minus 126 on the money line.
So Hunter Green and Paul Skenes, I believe tomorrow.
Yep.
Should be a good one.
Hopefully the pirates can come out on top on that one.
Really?
Yeah.
Going to have to hit.
Let's get the bats to wake up a little bit.
Fingers crossed.
All right.
Appreciate you all for hanging out with us.
We'll be back tomorrow with more.
Catch y'all later.
Peace out, Gros Scouts.
See you guys.
All right.
That wraps up this episode of North Shore Nine.
Thanks so much for tuning in.
Whether you're listening on the podcast or catching us on YouTube, if you enjoyed the show, please give this video a thumbs up.
And don't forget to hit that subscribe button if you haven't already.
It really helps us grow.
And if you're listening on the podcast, a quick review goes a long way in helping others find the show.
Plus, be sure to tell a friend about us.
There's always room for more here in the NS9 community.
And for those looking to support us a little more, consider joining our Patreon, become an MVP member, and get exclusive perks while helping us continue to bring you more of the pirates content you love.
Comments· 0
After a 7-pitch 8th inning, should Mason Montgomery have stayed in to pitch the 9th instead of handing it to Gregory Soto?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.