◆NEWS2026 Non-Tenders: National League◆ROSTERRHP Noah Murdock elected free agency◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSPlayers Avoiding Arbitration Prior To The 2026 Non-Tender Deadline◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers
◆NEWS2026 Non-Tenders: National League◆ROSTERRHP Noah Murdock elected free agency◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSPlayers Avoiding Arbitration Prior To The 2026 Non-Tender Deadline◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers
The Pirates gave away the fourth and final game of a home series vs. the Cardinals, where they were swept. The Pirates poor pitching this series continued to haunt them, as the Cardinals pulled away in the 8th inning after the Bucs tried to stage another comeback. The Pirates are now on a 5-game losing streak and have fallen to 16-16 on the season, good for last in the NL Central. The Pirates will look to rebound against divisional rivals the Cincinnati Reds tomorrow at home for a three-game set. Cody and Doug attempted to lay their thoughts out on the NS9 Postgame Show powered by Primanti’s Bros. You can watch or listen to the show below…
The Pirates Got Beat Today, But Threw Away 2 of These Games
When Paul Skenes gives up five runs like he did today, it is hard to expect the team to come out with a victory. However, Monday and Wednesday nights were games that the Pirates should have won and won them comfortably. Dennis Santana giving up four runs in the 9th inning on Monday was a tragic collapse that shouldn’t happen. Wednesday, the Buccos gave the Cardinals the game by leaving 12 men on base and going 1-12 with RISP. When the team has the chance in all three of the last innings to take the lead and never come away with it, it is a sign the team threw that game away as well.
The Pirates are a solid team; however, they will never be able to reach a playoff spot if they continue to hand away these winnable games so that today’s loss doesn’t feel like such a gut punch. It has been hard to complain about results up until now despite them consistently claiming defeat from the jaws of victory, but now being under .500 is looming and they need to clean things up now. This clubhouse has a lot of soul searching to do before the Reds come into town Friday.
Defense is Optional Here
Everyone knew the defense would be rough this season, and so far the offensive output has been good enough to deal with defensive mishaps. However, today Bryan Reynolds managed to out do this despite his contributions to the offense. Reynolds did have two doubles, knocked in two runs, and scored one himself in this game. His defense was a disaster, directly leading to helping chase Skenes early with his noodle arm. He continued to struggle with his glove and officially helped the game be put to bed after he missed a ball in the 7th, and Nathan Church knocked home two more runs to push the deficit to three runs. No one is expecting this team to be good defensively, but until the team (and in particular, the outfielders) fix the basic mistakes that keep happening, they are going to lose games they shouldn’t. The Pirates had a legitimate shot to win today’s game and gave away four runs because of sloppy play in the outfield.
We Still Are Not at Panic Time
This series was a really hard watch; getting swept by the Cardinals, of all teams, is a miserable experience to sit through as a Pirates fan. It confirmed most of the flaws this team had all put into one series against a bitter rival. However, the Pirates are still in a solid spot and have shown with the stats that their early season success is something that can be sustained. The Pirates lost two games in no small part to bullpen blowups from two of their more reliable arms (Santana and Mattson). The offense has continued to put up numbers despite not always being the most efficient with RISP this series. The Pirates are top 10 in terms of WAR produced for their team as well and are in the top half of the league in both pitching and hitting value. I also think that if you asked any Pirates fan before the season, they would be .500 after April, there wouldn’t be a single fan who wouldn’t say yes. They have to rebound and end this 5-game skid, no doubt, but the 2015 Pirates team did start 18-22 after 40 games. There is still time to turn the ship back around, even as defeated as I feel after that series sweep.
Comments· 0
The Debate
Should the Pirates move Bryan Reynolds from right field to first base?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.
With Doug Ford and Cody Kohlman.
Chapters
Key takeaways
1
With the bullpen this thin, Paul Skenes can't waste pitches nibbling. He should throw competitive strikes early and work 7–8 innings instead of burning 102 pitches in five.
2
The bullpen problem is mostly how it's been managed. Pulling starters early in April burned it out, and Yohan Ramírez's arm is going to fall off by June from overuse.
3
Bryan Reynolds isn't a right fielder anymore and has asked to play first base. Keeping him in the outfield is a management failure that cost runs today.
4
The $12M Ozuna signing handcuffs the roster. His inability to field turns the Pirates into a team of five DHs and forces bad outfield defense.
5
Ben Cherington built this flawed roster and should be on the phone now trading for relievers, starting with NL East teams that are falling apart.
But the thing is he plays it like he wants to, he wants to see, what are you going to do?
Like, if I do this, what are you going to do?
It's like, no, like, get to checkmate already because we know you can do it in, like, two turns.
You know what?
Like, he's the guy that can shut this thing down, but he, like, I had the numbers up.
He did start with, let me see.
Let me get the number right.
There he is.
First pitch strikes.
I had the average here.
But anyway, the average of his first pitch strikes was, it was higher than I expected it because it seemed like every time he started in a bat, there's a ball outside the zone.
And I get it.
You don't want to throw a ball down the pipe to a guy.
But when you have the stuff like Paul Skenes does, when you have the splinker, when you have all these pitches that everybody drools over, and you're like, let me throw outside and see what he does, and then I'll play off it.
Yeah.
Like, no, like, I get it.
Play off your pitches, but let's throw competitive pitches first.
No, you're right.
But, yeah, like, look, he shouldn't be wasting any pitches, especially with the state of our bullpen.
Right?
Like, his best chance at securing a win for this team and, a win for his one loss record is pitching eight innings, right?
seven innings at least.
And you're putting way too much in the hands of bad decisions by Donnie Kelly and bad performance by middle relief by only being able to pitch five innings, throwing 102 pitches.
You've got great stuff.
You've got otherworldly stuff.
You've got all-time stuff.
Throw strikes.
Yeah.
I'm not saying groove it down the middle.
Hit those corners, right?
hit that little outline that they've got there on the screen.
throw, strike, so.
And you touched on the bullpen there.
And I know this is something I wanted to get into later on in the show, but I'll just talk about it now.
The management of the bullpen is bad, not because the bullpen is bad.
The bullpen's not great.
I won't say that they're phenomenal.
But the management of the bullpen is bad because they've chose to pull our starters early in games to begin this year.
I remember the first or second post-game show I did this year.
I said, you know what?
Don't worry about pulling Paul Skenes in the fifth inning.
It's okay.
Like, we're just ramping them up.
Now, hindsight, it's 2020.
What were you doing?
You've ruined this bullpen.
And sure, Ashcraft going on bereavement was unforeseen.
But those are the things that happen to every major league team, right?
That's part of the season.
Right, this happens to everybody.
That's part of why you can't just burn out your bullpen in week one.
Exactly.
Exactly.
And that's what they did.
And that's why this bullpen is shaky now.
And sure, it was a little shaky to start, but it feels like they've been asked to do more than they should have been asked to do in April.
Like, down the line, sure.
But it's April.
It's technically the second month of the season here, Doug.
Right.
And they've been asked to do the Lord's work.
Yeah.
Specifically, Yohan Ramirez, who continues to play well.
Yeah.
He's pitching well, but his arm's going to fall off.
For what he does.
Yeah, his arm's going to fall off in June.
And right, he's going to revert back to some of his poor pitching.
And we're going to blame it all on him.
But, it's the fact that he's been pitching, way too much.
Way too soon.
Way too often.
Exactly.
But, yeah.
Pirates just couldn't – or Paul Skenes just couldn't get it going today.
he's still – it's wild.
It baffles me.
He still gets nine strikeouts today.
He, obviously, we said he had four earned runs, 16 whiffs, 13 called strikes, and five innings pitched.
And in that first at bat, Doug, a new pirate killer, I think, was born.
Oh, my God.
J.J. Wetherholt.
Just has to be.
J.J. Wetherholt from Mars, PA.
And it's always – and Doug, it's always a guy from the area, right?
Yeah, it's Ian Hap's nephew, you know.
Right.
J.J. Wetherholt, just a phenomenal series.
I think it was his third home run in these four games.
it's just – the cycle continues.
The Red Bird devil magic just continues to kill the pirates.
It's just an awful thing.
I had a video I put out about the pirates being cursed with the whole thing with Ashcraft and Barco having a five-hour delay on his flight.
And it's like, no wonder this happens to the pirates.
I think we're just cursed, Doug.
I think we're cursed.
I've been thinking about that a lot lately.
Like, is it the Bobby Bonilla curse?
Like, he wanted five years, $25 million, and the pirates would only offer five years, $20 million.
Like, Bobby Bonilla for an extra million dollars a year.
Like, the Mets have been paying him a million dollars a year for 30 years.
Like, we couldn't have done it for five more to keep that team together.
I'm like, is it the Bobby Bonilla curse?
Is it, is it the Dave Parker curse that things have not been good since we treated him so poorly?
I don't know.
But there's something.
Something is going on.
Something is going on.
It just doesn't make any sense.
we explain it a lot of times.
It's a very piratey thing that they just did, you know?
And it's, that's not a recent phenomenon that's been going on now for some, 30 plus years or 40 maybe.
I don't know.
But it's just, it's really frustrating.
It's just things that seem to happen to us happen to no other teams.
And, again, like the Cardinals graphic kid in the eighth round, he comes up after three seasons in the minor.
He's fundamentally sound.
he's hitting the ball to all fields.
He doesn't get thrown out on the bases and, we bring somebody up and he hits 167 and, you have to pinch hit for him every game.
And, it's just, yeah.
I, is it Bob Nutting and his leadership and, his not really care if the team is good as long as they, I feel like that's a cop out answer.
No, I know.
But I'm saying, things start as your opinion.
I'm just saying, no, things start at the top, though.
It's like, it does not seem like there's some accountability in this organization, right?
We've been fundamentally bad for years.
Like anybody, you know what I'm saying?
If tomorrow I hired you as the general manager of the Pittsburgh Pirates, you would make your standard press conference and saying, we're going to play hard and tough.
We're going to be fundamentally sound.
They all say it.
They all say we're going to be fundamentally sound.
And then it seems like no effort is put into fundamentals.
And there's, you can't bench everybody every game.
I understand that.
But it does not seem like anybody cares that, we just did four stupid things in the game.
You know?
Yeah, and I need to, I'm going to push back on you here.
I'm going to stick with my guy, Sean, here.
Sean Hooper, friend of the show.
No one gave up.
I didn't say anybody was lazy.
Yeah.
It was a bad series.
I said, you're not fundamentally sound.
And I understand that.
And I feel like this season, there has been more of a sense of accountability than in years past with Derek Shelton.
There's other things you can complain about with Don Kelly, and I've started to complain about them as well.
But this team, like, look at what happened today.
They tried.
They, I didn't give up hope until Isaac Mattson gave up five runs.
But in the fourth inning, you have bases loaded.
Horwitz walks in a run.
In the fifth, you have, I had it up here.
You had Bryan Reynolds hit a double that if Roberto Clemente were the number 19, it would have been a home run.
Yeah, but.
This team continues to try and try.
And then in the seventh, it's a 5-4 game after Brandon Lowe hits a home run.
Like, this isn't the Pirates of the past.
This is a Pirates team that isn't going to give up when things get bad.
And this is just a bad series.
And it sucks.
It's a 5-game skid.
But then it's a worse problem, Cody.
Because they didn't give up.
I agree with you.
And they had fight.
And they came up short in every game.
So what is that?
Is that a talent problem?
We're just not as good as the Cardinals?
you know what I'm saying?
Yeah.
If it's not.
I would say yes.
Because guess what?
You have Bryan Reynolds, who from what I've heard for the last year or so, has advocated to play first base.
And look what he does today in right field.
Because he's not an outfielder anymore.
And they insist on playing in the outfield.
Like, it's a talent issue.
But also, it's a general management issue.
Whatever you want to call it.
Like, there are issues.
Yes.
But they're blatant.
And like, you just got to change them.
And the guys know that the issues are there.
Bryan Reynolds knows that he is not a right fielder anymore.
He should not be out there.
And then look what happens today.
He's going to try his hardest.
But guess what?
He misses that ball that could have gotten us closer to the end of the inning.
So that Madsen doesn't give up five runs.
And then you have his throw home.
That was a dribbler.
It was a four hopper to home plate.
And then that same play where he drops the ball, he throws the ball to third instead of throwing to a cutoff man that could have got Walker at second.
Okay.
But that's not lack of talent.
That's lack of fundamentals.
He threw the wrong plays.
No.
The lack of talent comes from him aging.
He knows he's aging.
He knows he shouldn't be in right field.
It's the player.
It's the problem with the organization not listening to the players.
He has told the organization, work me out at first base.
And then he said, no, you're more valuable to us than right.
And then look what happens.
Yeah.
He gives up, what was that, two runs today?
Well, I agree, but there is no solution to that because we've got two first basemen in, O'Hearn and Horwitz.
again, you could get rid of Ozuna.
You could put Reynolds as a DH and, run some other people through there.
that's fine.
And that's the thing is, Alex talked about it on his offbeat this morning that he touched on it at least, that Marcell Ozuna not being able to play the field handcuffs you.
Yeah.
And if you don't sign him to a $12 million deal, then guess what?
You got Ryan O'Hearn that can play the field and he could be a DH.
You have Brandon Lowe who could play the field and be a DH.
You have, then you have Bryan Reynolds who could play the field at a more, at a position that fits him better, like first base.
And he could be a DH.
And Cruz as well, right?
But then again, you still have the problem is that, and I said this when they signed Ozuna, last year we were, past couple of years, we've been a team of middle infielders where nobody can play shortstop and everybody's out of position.
Now we're a team of five DHs, the, we all were surprised by the Ozuna signing for a lot of reasons, right?
First of all, we spent 12 and a half million to get an actual hitter who now has not been hitting.
I still think he'll sort that out somewhat, but he was always going to, right.
We were always going to now have a terrible outfield defense every single game.
Two out of the three guys were going to be subpar and Magnum's not playing that well out there.
We're just honest.
Like he's does some things well and he, but man, he's been, he's done a lot of things wrong.
And I don't remember if Tyler said it last night, but I think we've talked about it that his at bats, not pretty.
Like he's swinging it thing.
Like he'll swing at a first pitch strike in the dirt and it's like, let them throw you, like make them throw you a strike.
You don't have to swing at everything, but that's Mangum's that's Mangum's game.
Mangum's game is I'm going to hit something outside of the zone that dribbles so I can run out the ball to get to first.
I get that.
But when you're in these positions where nobody's hitting, nobody's, well, they're hitting, but they're just not hitting well.
But when you're in these positions where you need better at bats rather than, scrappy at bats, which we knew Mangum was the scrappy guy.
You need to put it together.
You need to be a little more patient.
And I get it.
He's a 29 year old or 20 or what?
He's 30 now.
He was a rookie last year.
He's only been in the major leagues for a year and some change now.
And he's doing what he can do to survive.
And I think he knows that.
But doing that and having these bad at bats on top of the lack lapsed defense that he's had, which was supposed to be part of his calling card.
Right.
It just doesn't add up.
To me, that's a bigger concern because if you're going to have bad at bats.
How can you sit here and, like, advocate for him to still be out there?
It's hard.
Yeah, right.
It's, look, I was an advocate all last offseason from the trade deadline on saying we should trade Bubba for a legitimate outfielder.
make a package for Jaron Duran or somebody like that because we need a good defensive outfielder.
We need a good offensive outfielder.
We need someone who can put out there every day and not think, gee, how soon can we get him to DH?
so.
Right.
Yeah.
Cruz has played a little better defensively.
he hasn't made the glaring mistakes, you know.
But, yeah, it's a mess.
And, look, it's not getting cleaned up.
They're not overhauling this roster.
They're not trading, Harwitz, Reynolds.
they're not trading two or three of these guys, right?
most likely the only scenario is that they'll give up on Ozuna.
And that's not been their history.
They did not give up on Tommy Pham.
They did not give up on Roddy Tellez.
They don't really give up on guys.
They keep saying it's coming.
So, they haven't given up on Triolo.
They haven't given up on Nick Gonzales, which today looks smart.
But, yeah, it's – Yeah, and we've obviously already gone a little off the rails.
Yeah, we sure have.
We're not doing a postgame show.
It's just been – it's been one of those series.
Like, you get to the finale of it and you're like, it's a five-game losing streak.
You don't really want to talk about what happened.
You just want to talk about getting past it.
Like, talk about it.
Talk about what happened in these last five games and just get past it.
But, yeah, it wasn't until that fifth inning that it felt like there was any hope either.
Like, it's – Right. Yeah.
That also hasn't really been their MO, right?
Like, they've had games where they score first or they've had games where they score in the first five innings.
And you're like, great.
Like, this feels good.
Even if we're down by a run or two, they've at least gotten on the board.
And it just feels like that's been deflated these past four or five games.
Like, I don't know.
I don't know, Doug.
Yeah, it's – I'm such an deflated state.
I'm usually the positive guy, too.
Right.
Every single team in baseball is going to have a five-game losing streak.
It's early.
We end April at 500.
Again, when we did our little prediction show, none of us were predicting this team to have 95 victories.
It was all 83.
So, 500 at this point is not such a bad thing.
Yeah.
They definitely score more runs than they have in the past.
Skenes is godlike, but he's not quite a god.
So, it's – he had an off day.
It's fine.
Yeah.
That won't – Doug, that won't happen until he's in pinstripes, right?
No, stop.
That's how negative I am right now, Doug.
I'm already thinking about it.
It's going to be Dodger blue.
It's going to be, a kid was born in California and the Dodgers.
So, look, win two out of three against the Reds, sweep the Reds, we're all feeling good again.
We're all back, hoisting our cones.
Well, that's the thing.
The Reds are playing, I guess, good baseball.
I've heard – I haven't paid too much attention to the Reds, I'll be honest.
But from what I've heard, it's like, how are they this good?
Like, it's not a they're good.
It's a how are they this good?
Right.
That's the sentiment I've gotten.
So, yeah, you have an opportunity to come in.
You're still at home.
It's your second time seeing them.
Go out and sweep.
Like, that's the thing about this team, Doug, is they have the offensive potential and the offensive skill set to do this.
We've seen it already.
Like, they've gone out there and put up, like, five, six, seven, eight, nine, ten runs.
They have the ability.
It's there.
It's just a matter of pulling it out.
You've got to pull it out.
In a Paul Steen start, right?
That should have been enough.
It should have been enough.
And due to, pretty much a team effort, it wasn't, right?
It was bad defense.
It was bad pitching.
It was, starting pitching.
It was bad relief.
It was a combination of these things.
And even scoring five runs, they probably should have scored more.
They had more opportunity to score runs that they didn't, they weren't as efficient.
We're so happy with five runs, though.
But, like, yeah, they may have been able to score more.
I don't want to get too – this is frustrating.
This sucks.
Five-game losing streak in the division at home.
It's just the worst.
But it can still be turned around.
Again, everybody in the chat and all of us, all of us at North Shore Nine have said that this team has flaws.
the hitting – there was still going to be some issues with the hitting, and there has been.
It's been better, but there's still been issues.
We're afraid of the outfield defense and the defense as a whole.
It's been terrible, right?
Our base running has not been as bad as it was last year, maybe.
And our middle relief is awful, and it's burned out.
And if there's – Ben Cherington should be on the phone right now trying to find somebody, acquire somebody, something.
Because it doesn't even matter if they're good, effective pitchers.
They're going to – like, their arms are going to fall off.
So, that's where – that's the biggest area, I think, that the easiest way that they can improve the team is improving the bullpen.
Right.
And the first place you've got to look is the NL East, right?
Yeah.
You've got the Mets falling apart.
You've got the Phillies falling apart.
Hell, maybe even look up in Boston because they fired their whole coaching staff.
Some wild things happening.
The I-95 corridor, man.
Let's – yeah.
Right.
These teams should be willing to do something.
They should be willing to shake something out.
There are teams early in this season that may be up for a fire sale in May, you know?
So, like you said, like, Ben, go out there.
Get on the phone.
Yeah.
Ring somebody up.
This is the roster he put together.
Bring up your buddies in Boston.
See what they're thinking, you know?
Right.
This is the roster that he put together.
The flaws have been exposed immediately and often.
And, yeah, so let's do something.
Right.
It's it.
But I still think, like I said, this is not a lost season.
No.
You're only 500 at the end of April.
That's the thing.
Like, that's why this is so frustrating and we're not like, well, the season's over.
Like, no.
That's not the deflated state that I'm in.
The deflated state is, man, I see how good this team is.
I know how good this team is.
This five-game losing streak sucks.
And we got to get past it.
And you know that this team is going to be better than the record that's out there right now.
Don't know how much better.
They're going to have to prove that themselves.
But this team is better than a five-game losing streak in April.
Yeah.
quite frankly, if this team wins 84 games, we would consider it a success.
Right.
And, they're not exactly there.
Right now they're on pace to win 81 games.
So it's not the end of the world.
But, yeah, it's as always with the Pirates, it's not just losing.
It's the way they lose.
Right.
It's like, starting with the Monday night loss.
It's just, again, part of the frustrating is that they fight back, make it 5-4, make it 6-3, and then it's 11-3.
And then it's 10-4.
The bullpen doesn't hold up.
Yeah.
And you're just like, oh, man.
And it's not, like I said, it's not just a bullpen.
There's, someone drops one in the outfield.
It's not called an error, but it is an error.
someone can't make a throw that they should have made.
the pitcher takes the throw to third base when he should not be standing in front of them.
that was yesterday, but, just these dumb things that they do that, like, what do you, what's going on here, so.
Yeah, and I don't know.
I feel like we're done here already, but I wanted to throw in from Pirates PR, they said today that this is the first time in Pirates history that three players in the month of April had 20 or more RBIs.
You had Cruz with 26, Brandon Lowe today with the home run with 20, then O'Hearn with 20.
The fact that you're doing things like that early in the season, you have the offensive production, something we've been missing for years, Doug.
That's another reason not to throw away this season.
Reynolds got 19.
Yeah, we almost had four.
Now, I know that a lot of you don't, can't appreciate the magnitude of, but, well, part of that, too, is that the season didn't used to start until mid-April back in the day or whatever.
But still, this is a team that's had Willie Starge over Roberto Clemente and Dave Parker and Honus Wagner and Paul Wainer and Archie Vaughn and Ralph Kiner and, Lumber and Lightning.
this has been a team, our pitching history is not the significant part of our history.
It is our hitters.
Or as they keep calling them now, the batter runner.
I've never noticed that before.
And this year, both Joe Block and Greg Brown are saying, and then the batter runner.
They used to just call him the runner.
When did he become the batter runner?
It's a weird thing.
Anyway, we've had lots of really good batter runners over the years.
And for this to be the first team to do that, two of them are, it's the exact formula that we asked for.
The two guys signed, done it.
And then Reynolds and Cruz, like I said, Reynolds is at 19.
But it's like, okay, and then we've gotten, those guys in on it, too.
So if we had middle relief, if we were a little more fundamentally sound.
And look, the starters haven't been great here in this last couple, stretch either.
Comments· 0
Should the Pirates move Bryan Reynolds from right field to first base?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.