The Pirates faced a left-handed starter one more time in 2026 and were promptly shut down in a 5-1 loss to the Cardinals to break the Pirates 5-game winning streak. Brandon Lowe provided the only offense in the bottom of the 2nd inning with a solo home run to right field for his 34th long ball of the season. The Pirates put together another bullpen game and it did not go well as Brandon Eisert gave up 3 runs in 0.2 innings and Khristian Curtis gave up 2 runs in 3.2 innings. Jim and Doug break this one down on the NS9 Postgame Show powered by Primanti Bros. You can watch or listen here:

Here’s my 3 takeaways on this game…

One More Awful Performance Against a LHP

The Pirates faced one more left-handed starting pitcher Wednesday night with Cardinals starter Matthew Liberatore on the mound and it went about as you’d expect from watching this team face a lefty this season. Coming into this game, Aiden Stepansky of MLB.com recapped their numbers this season versus a southpaw:

@AidenStepanskyView post on X ↗

That’s pretty bleak. If you’re looking for reasons the Pirates didn’t make the postseason, an 18-33 record against a LHP is right up there with the injuries excuse and Paul Skenes struggling. Liberatore gave up the solo home run to Lowe to give the Bucs a 1-0 lead, but that was his only blemish. Liberatore settled in, going 5.2 innings with six hits allowed, walked zero, struck out six and gave up just the lone run. Liberatore got the win and before you think maybe he was a tough lefty to face this season, he wasn’t. Liberatore finishes the year 6-14 with a 5.23 ERA and a 1.47 WHIP. But those season numbers for lefties haven’t mattered much this season because when they face the Bucs, they’re all Sandy Koufax. Fixing this issue is crucial for competing next season. I’m just glad we’ve likely faced our last left-handed starter in 2026.

I’m Tired of Bullpen Games

While we are likely done with left-handed starters, I wish we could be done for bullpen games as well. Unfortunately, we’ll probably see one more before we close the books on this 2026 season. In this game, Lake Bachar made the start and had a scoreless 1.2 innings, but then Eisert and Curtis combined to give up five. Antwone Kelly finally got to pitch for the first time in about a week and tossed two scoreless innings and Kirby Yates finished it off with a scoreless frame on his return from the IL.

I’m sick of the bullpen games. We have the extra pitcher spot and we have a litany of starting pitching prospects in the minors and currently with the team. Just start Kelly or Wilber Dotel or Khristian Curtis or give me Hunter Barco for a start or two. I understand the stock is super low right now with Barco, but he’s received some time in the Majors last year and this season, but he’s yet to make a start for a team that went nowhere last year and that’s out of it now. That doesn’t make sense to me. I’m fine with a bullpen game every now and then when it calls for it and I understand Braxton Ashcraft hit the IL late in the year and didn’t help, but can we please sign a veteran starter arm next season? That was one move the Pirates usually make for pitching depth, but failed to pull the trigger on it last offseason. Injuries will happen and even then the Pirates pitching staff was fairly healthy for most of the season and here we are crawling to the finish line with two bullpen games a week. They’re not the most effective way to deploy your bullpen, but they’re also a tough watch.

Five-Game Winning Streaks

The Pirates five-game winning streak was snapped in this loss Wednesday night and that win streak matched their season high from early in the season. The Pirates started 1-3 and then ripped off five straight wins from March 31 to April 5. They never saw another winning streak that long until this week. Their problem was when they started this win streak, they were 75-77, you need to start those winning streaks when you’re already three games over or five games over and really take off. Instead, their five-game win streaks will bookend the season essentially and in between they hovered around .500 all season before falling behind in the second half of the season.

You can always get hot and stack some wins together when you have a pitching staff that has the potential like the Pirates rotation does. If they can find a little more consistency, sign a veteran arm to provide depth and innings and fix Paul Skenes from whatever ailed him, maybe these winning streaks will hit more often in 2027.