◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
The Pirates pulled off one of their wildest wins of the young season, beating the Cubs 4-3 in 11 innings at Wrigley Field. NS9 Postgame breaks down Braxton Ashcraft’s dominant outing, Oneil Cruz stuffing the stat sheet, and how Pittsburgh found a way to survive a game it nearly gave away. It was messy, dramatic, and somehow ended in a series win in Chicago.
Watch or listen now for the full breakdown.
Comments· 0
The Debate
Will Braxton Ashcraft get Cy Young votes this season?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.
With Jim Rosati and Doug Ford.
Chapters
Key takeaways
1
With Skenes going five innings and Keller pulled after 77 pitches, the Pirates are the only team without a 100-pitch start yet. Donnie Kelly is overmanaging and should trust what may be the league's best rotation.
2
Braxton Ashcraft will be in the Cy Young conversation if he can pitch enough innings. He has a 2.12 ERA, and the Cubs whiffed on 75% of their swings against his curveball.
3
Fans calling for the Pirates to DFA Oneil Cruz or send him to Triple-A are wrong. His upside is high and within reach, and his better two-strike approach and new success against lefties prove it.
4
Don't bench Marcell Ozuna at 2-for-39. Keep giving him rest days and move him down to sixth or seventh so he stops batting in big spots.
5
This team has to win its first NL Central title. The front office should be adding relievers and possibly a third baseman now, not waiting until the deadline.
And I said, well, we'll get into – there's a couple people I really want to highlight in this game.
And he's one of them.
But, yeah, that 11th inning, you're thinking, okay, well, now lefty against Brandon Lowe.
Brandon Lowe really didn't look good in that at-bat.
He was check-swinging.
Like, it didn't seem like he was picking up pitches.
A little dribbler back to the pitcher.
And Caleb Thielbar could have just thrown – he could have underhanded this thing to first if he wanted to.
He had a ton of time.
He throws it away, and the Pirates score a run.
They're gifted a run.
Shout-out, Cubes.
Thank you, Cubes.
They cubed big time there in the 11th.
And, yeah, that was the lead.
That was the lead.
And then you go to the bottom half, and it's like, all right, here's the Yohan Ramirez experience yet again.
And he gets Nico Horner to dribble it back to him, Doug.
And then Yohan does exactly what you want.
Yohan does exactly what Thielbar does.
He throws it away.
Like, has all the time in the world.
Throws it away.
It should have been one out, runner on second.
Now it's no outs, runners on second and third.
And then he just freaking buckles down.
Matt Shaw, shallow fly out to right.
Bregman, pop foul out to first, intentionally walks Ian Happ.
And then at this point, I'm just like, they're going to walk in a run here.
Like, that's just how this game is going to continue on.
And I thought he was going to.
He got down 3-0 to Suzuki, but then gets Suzuki to foul out to O'Hearn.
And, man, Doug, if this was, if Lanny for Terry were still around here announcing games, it would have been the biggest, no doubt about it, you would have ever heard in your life.
Oh, yeah.
Man, just hearing you recap it has stressed me out.
And, exhausted me.
I'm like, oh, wow.
That was something.
Yeah.
What an ending.
What an ending.
and I guess, like, to us, it's so unfamiliar.
We don't win.
Especially when we play sloppy and walk people and make errors and don't, bring in the guy from third and, not have it called a double when it's actually a double, that would have scored another run earlier in the game.
All this is the stuff that happens to us and then we lose.
And we're frustrated and angry and are chanting, sell the team.
And I'm, saying it's a good day to fire Ben Cherington, that thing.
We won this game.
It's so odd.
We don't win these games.
It was.
Yeah.
This is a game that we're not used to winning.
Like I said, this is at least the second game now in the last week or so that the Pirates have just absolutely stolen from their opponent.
I, he never really got the attention he deserved in the minors, right?
Because he was hurt.
And so we wrote him off as injury prone or said, oh, he's going to have to be relegated to the bullpen.
But when he pitched, he pitched lights out.
And now it seems to me that he's not injury prone.
He was just injured, right?
That the cupboard wasn't bare when Ben Cherington got here.
Cause you had guys like Braxton Ashcraft in the cupboard that, he is a really good pitcher.
You know what he had a career high in strikeouts today.
he's just, he's just nasty.
He has great composure.
He's got a great, arsenal of stuff.
He seems to know how to pitch him and Henry seem on the same page.
I, this is like, two years ago we were not talking about this guy at all.
And now here he is.
And I, maybe the second best pitcher on the team.
Right.
And I don't want to diminish anything that Keller's doing right now, but he's wow.
I'm starting to get on the extent Ashcraft, bandwagon here.
So, yeah, he's really good.
He's really good.
I'll, I'll say this, like he, this was, this was the best I've seen him look, I think, in a game.
And you mentioned earlier, like pulling him a little bit early.
He's still, he's had the injury issues in the past.
He's never really had a full season workload.
You're going to get to the point where like the innings are going to start really adding up for Ashcraft.
So like, I understand being careful with him, especially early on.
So I get why you're pulling him in the fifth here, but with him, I could make excuses for it.
Yeah.
But like, five innings, he gives up four hits, only one walk strikes out nine.
Doug, he has a 2.12 ERA.
I'm pretty sure that takes his career ERA as a starter down to roughly right around 2.16 or so he's been stellar.
He's been absolutely stellar, ever since being promoted from the minors, really being eased into the majors through the bullpen.
And then, working his way into being a starter again, career high eight strikeouts last time out breaks that today with nine strikeouts.
The Cubs couldn't hit him like they couldn't, they couldn't even like touch him, 16 whiffs on the day, six of them coming on his curve ball.
He had a 75% whiff rate on his curve ball today when he threw a curve ball and the Cubs swung at it, they swung and missed 75% of the time on the slider, 63% of the time swing
and miss.
the stuff was just the breaking stuff particularly was just not even being touched today.
And he really attacked the lefties in this Cubs lineup with that fastball and curve ball, threw in a few splitters in there as well, but just an outstanding, just an outstanding
And I said earlier, I was like my hot take of the year was Ashcraft getting Cy Young votes and if he gets enough innings, Doug, I think he's going to put himself in that conversation.
Yeah.
Yeah.
I'm thinking he looks like an all-star pitcher right now.
You know what I'm saying?
And it's hard to fathom that, I began being a pirate fan, we don't get four or five guys, we know skeins is going to be there, someone else.
And then we'll see what happens.
But yeah, Ashcraft looks like an all-star right now.
Like he looks like a guy that's going to get Cy Young votes.
Innings will be the concern health.
he only, he's only pitched 118 innings.
Like he might get to one 50 this year, but they're going to have to do some stuff.
They're going to have to skip a start.
They're going to have to maybe piggyback him here, there, that thing.
But, he's just, what an asset, what an outstanding, development story for the pirates.
And, yeah, I'm going to see the pirates play the Rangers after the tailgate and I think he'll pitch Wednesday.
So I'm pretty excited about seeing him live.
Oneil Cruz, Doug, this is, this is what we've been praying.
For the whole time is this, he started off last year, like really hot where he was like the only person on the team doing anything, but he, I don't think he ever looked this good at all last year.
No, this is entirely different.
Yeah.
Yeah.
It's the way he's doing it.
He's hitting lefties.
He's getting on base.
He's stealing bases.
Doug four for five today with a walk.
He was on base five times.
He stole three bases.
His season numbers.
Now he's hitting three 45 with a 400 on base percentage.
He's slugging six 18 OPS over a thousand.
We're 14 games in as far as he's going.
And this is the best baseball I've ever seen Oneil Cruz play.
Yeah.
I'm a little old and a little addled, but maybe I forget the meaning of words, but I don't think any of what you just said equals lazy.
I don't think, it's funny.
People come at me all the time.
Oh, we should DFA Cruz or just give him away for nothing.
Send him to triple a.
I'm not, and this is why now look, he's got, he won't do that.
Yeah.
This is why, right.
Because his upside is so high and is attainable, right?
His upside is attainable.
look, he had a great two months last year.
I don't want to get, too excited, but this is different.
He with two strikes, his two strike approach, we saw it in spring training.
Like he wasn't trying to crush everything.
He wasn't trying to light up stack cast.
so it's, again, he just, he goes the other way.
He's hitting left.
He put in the work too.
Right.
Again, I don't know how lazy he was if he's developed that much against lefties in their off season.
but yeah, it's, he's stealing bases.
I bet on him to steal the most bases in MLB this year.
And I was loving today's game.
I'd like to see about 15 more of those.
So, yeah, it's five stolen bases on the year after today.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Cause he got off to a slow start with those, but yeah, he's running now.
he's an emotional guy.
I hope he stays within himself, but, keeps just feeding off the vibes and off his success and just, keeps this going.
I, and again, I guess it's unfair to expect him to be a three 50 hitter with a thousand OPS, but Hey, I can dream.
Yeah.
this is, this is the, this is what we've always dreamt about when it comes to Cruz.
He's hitting balls over the fence.
He's hitting extra base hits.
He's stealing bags.
He's, outside that first series against New York, Doug, he's been, he's been everything you could ask for.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Right.
That, again, he's still not going to win the gold glove out there, but he's not make, those just terrible, mistakes and stuff, that thing.
Another guy I want to talk about, Nick Yorke just keeps hitting, just keeps hitting Doug three more hits today for Nick Yorke, including his third double of the year.
He also has an OPS over 900, over 900.
He's batting three 79.
and his versatility was super useful today.
Like being able to start him at third, move him into the corner outfield.
So you could get some pinch hitters that you, that you like, he's been, I was not expecting much from Nick Yorke going into the season.
Like, I know he had that nice start to spring and he was hitting the ball hard, but it was like, Nick Yorke's probably going to be the 26th man.
hell we were doing roster predictions and I was like, I think I'd rather have Tyler can at Callihan.
Well, I look dumb now for saying that because Nick Yorke has been just a huge asset to this team as a bench player.
And now with Triolo sideline for a while, he's going to have a much higher, larger role and he just keeps performing.
Yeah.
I, when we acquired him and then never played him, never brought him up, I, people have mocked me for saying, look, I just want to see him get a chance.
I'm not, I did not expect this, but this is why I wanted to see him get a chance.
This might be in there.
He was a good hitter all through the minors, right?
He's not going to be a power guy, but he's got a good approach at the plate.
It looks like he can hit some doubles.
And again, he does have some versatility, which is again, games like today are perfect example.
Why you want that versatility, right?
Cause yeah, we, Donnie had to pull out all the stops.
He had to use all the tools in the tool bag.
So yeah, it's, again, how long does it last?
I don't know, but I'm looking forward to watching him.
we saw him in the spring.
I was down there for two full weeks.
He looked good.
Kevin Newman hit 700 in spring.
So, it's easy to dismiss stuff.
We've seen lots of guys have good starts, but he's got a good approach at the plate.
He's locked in right now.
It doesn't feel fluky, right?
It doesn't feel fluky.
I don't know if it's sustainable, but he looks like a professional hitter.
And I think you tweeted out today, so nice to have a lineup that's got, decent hitters, throughout it.
And, again, this is something we haven't had in a long time where, five through nine were just easy out.
So, yeah, the issue today was just hitting with runners in scoring position.
Like they were two for 19 today with runners in scoring position.
And one of those hits probably shouldn't have been a hit that Brandon Lowe hit in the 11th was rolled a hit, somehow.
but you look at that and, two for 19 with runners in scoring possession, just some quick math here means they were 10 for 22 without runners in scoring position.
So like they were, they were, this lineup was hitting the ball.
They were getting on base and, everyone really outside of Ozuna has had, their moment this year.
Ozuna will also get to him, but everyone else has had their moment.
And it's really just a matter of just like looking professional up there.
I said, Cruz, great game.
Brandon Lowe that he's been cooled.
Like he's been real cool lately.
Like they had that monster series against the Mets and then he's cooled off a bit.
But even with that, like those two walks that he had in this game, just keeping the line going, handing it off to Reynolds.
Like he's still got a three 52 on base percentage, Brandon Lowe.
He's hitting two 22, but like, he's getting on base.
Like I liked the signing when we signed up, but I didn't think I was going to like it this much.
No.
Yeah.
He was an all-star last year.
He looks like an all-star this year.
That's for sure.
Yep.
Horwitz.
Same thing.
Like he'd been struggling, throughout the year, but he's also come through a few times when you really needed him to Konnor Griffin, again, 19 years old.
Like you're going to expect some lumps with him and some bumps along the way.
But you can see the potential there.
He's already contributed a bunch as well.
The catcher position, I guess, is like the only position where you can say I've never really done anything.
Carry over from last year.
Yeah.
I, the thing is like when I watch Konnor Griffin and I watch either some of these other guys struggle, Konnor Griffin's having good at bats.
He doesn't look overmatched.
He's making some decent contact.
he's hitting the ball hard.
Last year we had so many guys that walked up to the plate, the Swinskis and the Bays and Henry and Triolo that, they're like, what is this odd shaped stick in my hand for?
Like they had, they just looked like they had no idea, no chance.
And that's usually, it was, three strikes, you're out type situation.
That's not what's happening.
Even if they're not producing, they're making the guy throw 10 pitches.
they're right.
They're drawing some walks.
Griffin had a sacrifice fly today there.
It's productive outs, productive at bats.
Yeah.
We need some improvement from some of these guys for sure.
But other than catcher, there's, it seems like we're getting decent at bats at, one through eight through the lineup.
Yeah.
143 entries into the Primanti brothers contest.
So make sure you're getting your hashtag raise.
It's in there before we give those away.
Doug, Marcell Ozuna, we talked about the double play earlier.
He also struck out today.
He was went over for, he did walk.
So we at least did one positive thing today, but he's now hitting Oh 59 on the year.
He's two for 39 right now.
And Doug, I, they've already given him some time off.
Like that he's the guy who they sit to give these other players a day as a DH.
But like at some point, I don't, when do you either just sit them there?
Cause you're better off without them.
Or do you, do you just maybe move him down in the order?
Cause I feel like right now he's just, he's hurting the team a lot because he's coming up in big situations a lot and he's doing nothing.
Yeah.
I wouldn't, you would sit him some, I'd still give him a little rest and, cause again, you've got guys that can play if he's sitting, and last year you just said, no, just bat him forth every game.
There's nothing else to do, but I, so I wouldn't bench him yet.
Again, everybody's citing the, in his 40 home run season, he was five for 59.
I don't know if I buy much into that, but I probably would move them down a little bit in the order.
you could, York and Gonzalez seem to be somewhat productive.
I don't know.
You could like move them down to sixth or seventh or something and just, not bring them up in some of these tougher situations.
That doesn't necessarily hide the bat, but, I don't, it would be silly to give up on him at this, but look, we didn't give up on Rowdy.
we didn't give up on Tommy Pham.
We didn't, well, there's a lot of guys that did not have his resume that we gave, until June or so to figure out and they figured it out in June.
so I think, you gotta ride it out.
It's, and fortunately other guys are picking it up, but yeah, we need to be better with, runners in a scoring position and he'd be a great, step in helping them.
Yeah.
He, I'm with you.
Like, I'm not ready to just like completely write them off.
He's shown for a really long time that he can hit.
I think they're doing a pretty decent job of giving him some days to reset.
And I think, moving him down in the order, maybe not the worst idea in the world, but yeah, you can't, you can't give up on the guy after, you signed him for $12 million.
Like you committed quite a bit of money to this guy and he's hit his entire career.
So I think you got to give him a little more time.
I know it's really frustrating right now because he looks completely lost up there.
Yeah.
That bat looks so slow.
He cannot get that barrel out there.
Yeah.
You just gotta, you gotta, you gotta keep playing them and hope he comes around.
So, and I think like, he's not going to do this all year.
Like I don't know if he's going to, turn into the guy he was pre injury last season, but, he's not going to do this all year.
I think, I think we all know that.
Yeah.
You're absolutely right.
it's, or I was right.
You were agreeing with me, but yeah, we're right.
So yeah, let's give him some time and hope he snaps out of it.
yeah.
hopefully starting this week, starting tomorrow, it'd be great.
But, yeah, with that said, I still don't, I still, I didn't like the signing when it happened.
I still don't like the signing now, but we got him and we've, we gotta, he's gotta start hitting and you need him to hit.
Yeah.
Look, this team needs to win the national league central.
They've never won the national league central.
That's an embarrassing thing for a team with the great tradition that the pirates have.
This team needs to make the playoffs.
This team needs to, they need to be working right now on improving the team.
Like they don't need to wait to the trade deadline and be buyers, which they do need to be buyers at trade line, but they're going to have to acquire some relief pitchers because a couple of them are going to die any day now.
And, we could still get better at third base or, who knows who, that's up to them, but that they should be working on, improving this team.
And at some point, how long can you, can you wait on somebody?
And, it's time that like, this is it.
Like, don't, you can't be wasting this opportunity, right?
They're a good team.
The division does not look overwhelmingly better than them.
this, you've said it.
the goal is the playoffs.
Well, let's keep, so you can only, you can only wait so long on some things.
Yeah.
With that said, they're nine and five with them.
So yeah, you hope that, once he gets going, you just, you keep winning.
So he picks it up when somebody else cools off.
It's, that's how it goes in a baseball season, right?
Not everybody's hot all year long.
So that's how it goes.
All right.
I think it's time to give away some sandwiches.
What do you think, Doug?
I, absolutely.
These ones should taste especially good after today's victory.
We're at 149 entries.
Let's get to 150 real quick.
while we're waiting for you to get that, make sure you hit like subscribe to the page.
If you haven't hashtag raise it in the comments, Doug, the pirates are, underdogs tomorrow plus one Oh eight money line against the Cubs, Bubba versus Tyone.
So yeah, they've been, underdogs in both games of the series and my bank account reflects that, I love getting them at plus money.
You got Braston Axcraft pitching today.
Plus money was an under.
I just, I boosted it to plus one 86, I think, which was outstanding.
Yeah.
It worked out great.
All right.
Let's give away some sandwiches.
We're at 151 entries.
You guys are awesome.
Thanks for hanging out with us after that win on a Saturday, late afternoon.
Again, we're going to give away two sandwiches to two different people.
First winner is.
It is going to be Mr. Bacon pants.
That's a, that's a great name.
Way to go, Mr. Bacon pants.
That is Mr. Bacon pants, right?
Yes.
Don't be calling him Billy bacon pants.
Mr. Bacon pants.
Make sure you email North shore nine at gmail.com.
just give us your email address associated with your Permanee brothers account.
And we'll get that.
Those two sandwiches loaded for you.
next winner, miles Altman, three, five, zero, three shout out miles.
the drill North shore nine at gmail.com.
pretty sure is one.
Yeah.
Has one before.
Right.
And miles has definitely won before.
I don't know if he's won this year, but I think it was last year.
Yeah.
Yeah.
It was, it was funny.
I was actually walking out of the home opener, I think.
And I was walking out of PNC park and all of a sudden someone just yells my name and I'm walking and he's like, it's miles from the chat.
So you're a celebrity, Jim.
So you are a celebrity.
Congratulations.
All right, Doug pirates, Cubs tomorrow.
They're going to look for the sweep again, Bubba versus Tyone, two 20 start time.
I'll say, they already won the series, so, you don't want to get too greedy, but man, a sweep over the Cubs in Chicago would be awesome.
I think you go for the sweep.
Cause you were supposed to lose today and you stole that loss.
So tomorrow would be the game that you're going to, would win to like win the, win the series, theoretically, if this game went the way it would have gone in the past has gone many times.
So we might as well just sweep them.
We might as well.
I hate the Cubs.
Yeah.
I hate the Cubs.
the term June swoon was invented for the Chicago Cubs, right?
from the start of the national league East up into the nineties, they had been on first place in the NL East in June, more than any of the other teams and had not won it.
Didn't win it until, I think 1984.
And then once in 1989, that was it, they were, they would be on first place on June 1st and they would swoon and I loved it every year.
Embraced it.
You know what?
Let's just make them swoon right now.
Right.
Let's April swoon, April swoon real quick too.
I want to shout out Johnny D 92.
He became a YouTube member today.
Appreciate you there.
If you're a YouTube member, it's 99 cents and you get access to all the cool emojis in the chat.
So appreciate everybody.
Awesome.
This was a fun one.
Again, I like that game was, that game was wild.
It was a wild game to watch.
Just a rollercoaster of emotions.
I called it fun.
If it was, it was fun at times, but this post game was very fun.
You guys were awesome.
if you're watching or listening, appreciate you all.
And, yeah, Doug, let's sweep them tomorrow.
Okay.
And sweep them tomorrow.
Let's ride into, to next week on a hot streak.
And then we'll see you guys all at the tailgate on Saturday.
Good call.
It's a week away.
One week from the tailgate, canal street lot, just, north of the stadium.
If you're looking on a map, it's Northeast of the stadium over by the Nova place, the garage, but yeah, looking forward to it.
If tailgating with us isn't enough, it is Paul Skenes's Cy Young bobblehead day.
This one actually might have legs.
I'm gonna say Paul Skenes's bobblehead day, but also, Paul Skenes's, I believe is going to be in line to start that game.
Yeah.
That's how it looks.
Yeah.
So that would be awesome.
Yep.
All right, guys.
No hitter.
No hitter coming.
This was the NS nine post game show powered by Primanti brothers.
You all rock pirates win four to three and extras.
We'll see you tomorrow.
Thanks.
All right.
That wraps up this episode of North shore nine.
Thanks so much for tuning in.
Whether you're listening on the podcast or catching us on YouTube.
If you enjoyed the show, please give this video a thumbs up and don't forget to hit that subscribe button.
If you haven't already, it really helps us grow.
And if you're listening on the podcast, a quick review goes a long way in helping others find the show.
Plus be sure to tell a friend about us.
There's always room for more here in the NS9 community.
And for those looking to support us a little more, consider joining our Patreon, become an MVP member and get exclusive perks while helping us continue to bring you more of the pirates content.
You love.
Thanks again for all your support and Let's Go Bucs.
Comments· 0
Will Braxton Ashcraft get Cy Young votes this season?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.