◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
In this episode of Bucco Brew, Anthony DiNardo and Jim Rosati dive into the latest Pirates offseason developments as pitchers and catchers prepare to report, including the signing of Jose Urquidy, ongoing trade rumors, and the team’s continued search for offensive help . The duo breaks down the potential fit of Marcell Ozuna, evaluates the buzz around Isaac Paredes, and explains how either move could reshape the lineup and defensive alignment. They also discuss the unsettled fifth starter spot, bullpen roles, and the crowded catcher situation heading into spring training. With baseball season officially in sight, the excitement is building as camp approaches and roster battles loom. Before you tune in, don’t forget to fuel up with De Fer Coffee & Tea and save 30 percent with promo code NS930 at defer.coffee.
Be sure to watch or listen to the full episode on YouTube or your favorite podcast platform, and join the conversation with North Shore Nine as the 2026 season gets underway.
Comments· 0
The Debate
Would adding Marcell Ozuna and Isaac Paredes make the Pirates an 80-win team?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.
With Anthony DiNardo and Jim Rosati.
Chapters
Key takeaways
1
Stop comparing Isaac Paredes to Jared Triolo. The real question is Paredes at third with Triolo at short versus Triolo and Nick Gonzales, and Paredes is clearly the upgrade over Gonzales.
2
The worry about Paredes at PNC Park is overblown. Away from Houston he still hit .259/.349/.434 for a 122 wRC+, which would have made him the Pirates' best hitter last year.
3
If the Pirates add both Marcell Ozuna and Isaac Paredes, the lineup is legit and this becomes an 80- or 81-win team on the playoff bubble.
4
José Urquidy doesn't solve the fifth starter spot. He has thrown only 33 innings across all levels in two years, so the Pirates still need another arm like José Quintana or Tyler Anderson.
5
Endy Rodríguez has no shot at the Opening Day roster. He hasn't hit in the majors since 2022 and should rebuild in Triple-A.
Yo, you're listening to the North Shore Nine podcast presented by FanDuel. This is Bucco Brew. I'm Anthony DiNardo. That's Jim Rosati. Welcome, Jim. It is baseball season.
Yeah, Super Bowl Monday, day after the Super Bowl, no more football. Yeah, baseball's right around the corner. Pitchers and catchers report in two days.
Awesome. I'm excited. And it's warming up for me. It's going to be mid-70s all week. I am excited.
Yeah, it's getting warm here, too. I think it's supposed to be in the 50s today, so hopefully that melts the remaining snow on the ground that's been here for a few weeks. But yeah, spring is in the air.
The warmth is coming back. I love it. Amen. But how about that Super Bowl? Patriots lost. That's all I really care about. The Patriots lost.
I agree. But the Patriots lost. Patriots had no business even being there. They were just a bad team that got into a good situation on their way into the playoffs.
And yeah, I bet a lot of money that the Seahawks were going to cover the spread because I was pretty confident. And yeah, that happened. So thank you, FanDuel.
I love it. I love it. But yeah, like you mentioned, pitchers and catchers report this week. So like real things are about to start happening opposed to the fake things like Ben Cherington and the Pittsburgh Pirates being on free agents and trade ships, which we have more to talk about today.
Yeah, still a couple of rumors floating out there. every time Ben Cherington has gotten in front of a microphone over the last month, which isn't often, but every time he has, he's continued to say that he wants to add players to this team.
So far, we haven't really seen much. We did get the José Urquidy signing last week. So we can, I guess, talk about that a little bit. We'll do, we'll dive into some pitchers and catchers stuff towards the second half of this show.
So we can, we can throw Urquidy in there, but José Urquidy's in the mix. Clevenger signs a minor league deal. I wouldn't really read too much into that. I don't, I don't know what he's going to do exactly, but yeah, there's still, there's still a couple of bats out there.
And the pirates are linked to at least two people that I know of, whether it's a free agent or a trade. So yeah, we'll see. oh, and Cutch is still out there too. He put out a video yesterday, basically saying that he's not done.
That video was fire. It was just take any messaging meeting, just anything, whoever created that video.
Just props because that was a amazing video. It gave me the chills.
Yeah, it was a good video.
Right. So yes, we have a lot to talk about today. And before we do, as always, let's tell you about our sponsor of today's show.
As always, Defer coffee and tea is a family and employee owned and operated business. They believe that coffee and tea are one of life's simplest and most accessible pleasures.
And when enjoyed thoughtfully can open your eyes to the here and now they have five locations across the city of Pittsburgh, including their flagship in the heart of Pittsburgh's historic strip district.
Don't forget to stop by the fairs, new location, downtown on Penn Avenue, right across from the Benetton. Grab a cup and fuel up on your walk to PNC park.
Mobile ordering is available. Check out their Instagram for more details. Of course, the website is Defer dot coffee.
And when you go there, Jim, tell everyone once again, how they can save 30%.
Yeah, go to Defer dot coffee, load up your cart, put in promo code NS930.
That's NS930 into the promo code field there and you'll get 30% off your order.
Boom, 30% baby. NS930. Get yourself some Defer coffee tea.
It's warm.
So what do you want to talk about first, Jim?
Let's talk about.
Let's talk about Marcell Ozuna.
Okay.
Another DH.
Yeah, he's, I guess, if you are looking at the free agency market and you're and you're looking for somebody who could qualify as that, quote unquote, impact bat, right?
Like he's like the only guy left who could fit that description.
DH only.
He's not in the field.
So that's what makes this a little bit of a weird situation is you sign him.
It means it means maybe Bryan Reynolds scoots back over to left field even.
So and then it means Jake Mangum's probably your fourth outfielder, which probably a pretty role for him.
Yeah, to be honest with you.
But yeah, there continues to be some noise here.
I usually don't talk about like stuff on Twitter that I've, from people I've never heard of before.
But I do want to point out and I want you, this, but over the over the evening, there's a guy out of the Dominican Republic who seems to be a radio host.
Jonsen Pujols.
This guy.
he has 173,000 followers on Twitter.
His YouTube page gets tens of thousands of views every show.
He's had Marcell Ozuna on his show.
He has major league players from the Dominican Republic on his show all the time.
So I'm just going to say what it says here.
Five hours ago, he said that things are looking good.
Hopefully they get a deal done soon.
This is regarding the Pittsburgh Pirates and Marcell Ozuna.
And then an hour ago, he tweeted out that they just told him that Marcell Ozuna and the Pirates have made progress in their negotiations for a one year deal.
The parties are close to an agreement.
So take that for what for what it is.
Jonsen Pujols.
I don't know him.
Buster Olney follows him.
Jim Bowden follows him.
And yeah, like he's North Shore Nine now follows him.
His YouTube page is he has had Marcell Ozuna on his show multiple times.
So I don't know.
I don't know what that means.
But the Pirates, I think, and Ozuna, there's clearly some interest there, if anything.
So, like, if it's Ozuna, that's a nice bat, you know.
I'm not a huge fan of the guy.
I don't think we need to go into that.
But it's a nice bat.
It does put your defense in a little bit of a tricky situation.
And then it also puts your relationship with Cutch on the fritz as well.
But yeah, take that for what it is.
It seals the deal.
Jonsen Pujols.
That's what he's saying.
Early today.
That stuff's interesting.
I want to look more into his page.
Because, like you mentioned, there's some validity to him.
So it's not just a rando on Twitter.
Right.
I wasn't sure.
Yeah.
It's not just some random guy.
So it is a person who has some sources, I'm sure, based off of what.
So now with that said, like, I'm with you.
And we discussed this to some level with Ty on NS9 Live or maybe a sicko sound off.
I forget.
But it's not a good fit.
Like, the problem with this team heading into this offseason is they need a bat.
So you find them where you can get them and figure it out later.
That's like the motto, right?
Because you're not going to.
This is the Pittsburgh Pirates.
They don't have their choice.
It's not like we're going to get that guy and call it an offseason.
No.
They're going to sit on their hands and knees and praying and begging, hey, please come here.
Hey, please come here.
And for the ones that say yes, then they figure it out.
And that one person was Ryan or her.
Everyone else came through trade.
But again, like, adds to that clog we're talking about some.
So, like, adding Marcell Ozuna to this lineup, it makes the lineup better.
Like you mentioned.
Like, that bat, that's legit.
That makes this team, this lineup better, this offense better.
But it just makes the roster construction compounded.
Like, where does he fit?
Then where does everyone else fit?
Like you mentioned, like, that's like a big difference between Cutch and Ozuna.
When we say bring back Cutch, we feel he can maybe play the field a little bit.
Ozuna can't.
Now, you can argue Cutch can't either.
that's fine.
That's an argument.
That's a fair argument.
We do believe that he could probably play the field once a week or so.
So, that helps him out.
But also, like, he's coming in as a part-time player.
Like, you're not bringing in Cutch to be the full-time DH.
You're bringing him to be a part-time player.
Face lefties the majority of his time.
Ozuna, you're bringing in to be a full-time player.
So, he's there at DH, which means it's no longer like Spencer Horwitz, Ryan O'Hearn, Bryan Reynolds on the right side.
DH, implementing at the right side.
This imaginary position on the field.
That's now, like you're mentioning, Ozuna.
So, like, then where does Ryan Hearn fit?
He's playing a position that he really doesn't play now.
like, he was a first baseman who, of course, that plays well enough to play BDH.
But you have Spencer Horwitz as well, who's a first baseman.
And they, both of them are good defensively at first base.
So, you're putting somebody in a position that they are not really good in.
And you already look at the outfield.
And, hey, everyone loves to complain about Oneil Cruz.
And we've seen how Bryan Reynolds has trended the past few years.
So, like, now the defense in the outfield is just getting really bad.
And that's the thing that he excited you about, Mangum.
like, you come in here.
He provides really good defense, that left field, like, that can use that.
And now you're going to replace that with Ryan Hearn.
And I'm not saying, like, it's a bad replacement.
What I'm just saying here is talking about is, like, yes, the Ozuna fit makes this team's defense take a hit.
Now, is the tradeoff worth it for that bat?
probably so.
This is, like, we did discuss this.
Like, you have to find ways to get bats in.
And then you figure it out.
And that's what they're doing here.
It's just, again, like, it's just not a perfect fit.
That's why the true, like, third baseman made sense.
Like, go get those guys.
Well, you missed out on all of them.
So, here we are trying to plug circles into square pegs.
Yeah.
you mentioned that, like, it doesn't really fit.
The bat certainly fits.
Like, it's what the lineup is looking for.
The lineup's looking for a right-handed hitter who preferably has some power.
And that's exactly who he is.
He's going to be 35 years old this season.
He is coming off a little bit of a down year where he was injured.
But even in his down year, 755 OPS, 114, weighted runs, creative plus.
He had 21 homers.
He's a year removed from a 154 weighted runs, creative plus season and 39 homers.
He's two years removed from 140 weighted runs, creative plus and 40 homers.
So, he's a guy who hasn't really, it is possible that this is the start of that downswing.
Like, that's always possible.
But he's also not, like, that old.
He's still 35.
And if he's a DH only, like, maybe that extends his career longer.
So, yeah, from a fit standpoint, offensively, he fits the lineup really well.
And, yeah, but you, it probably means that O'Hearn is now moving in the right field all the time.
And that's your, that's your, like, that's a rough outfield.
Like, you're going to, you're going to have to rely on Oneil Cruz to cover a lot of ground there.
It's not that Bryan Reynolds is slow by any means, but, his reaction time is some of the worst in baseball, according to StatCast.
And O'Hearn isn't necessarily going to cover a ton of grass.
So, yeah, it definitely puts a lot of pressure on Oneil Cruz.
If you do this, maybe Jake Mangum being in there is late inning replacements helps towards the end of games and to spell some of the other guys.
But, yeah, take it for what it's worth.
And we've heard a few people mention how the Pirates are in on Ozuna.
He is the best possible bat you could probably acquire at this point.
Yeah, 100%.
Now, there's also some smoke about a trade.
There is.
For a third baseman.
That makes some sense.
But, of course, with most guys, especially at this age, the stage and offseason, there's some warts here.
So, Isaac Paredes.
Now, he's been a really good hitter.
He's been a very good player.
However, when you look at his skill set, when we look at his bat profile, and you line up with PNC Park, that's not the sexiest.
That's really not the ballpark you want to fit him into, right?
You're going to say, hey, I'm going to take this player out and put him in the one ballpark that's going to be really good at.
It's the one that he's going to be leading.
It's going to be the Houston Astros, right?
And if you're going to look at the one ballpark that, like, I probably don't want to put him in because it's going to hurt him the most, it's PNC Park.
So, there's a lot of controversy over him because, like, does he actually make an improvement?
Because he will be going to the Pirates who play at PNC Park.
And, well, Jim, if you look at his baseball savant page, you see blue bubbles.
So, blue bubbles mean no good, Jim.
Stay away from blue bubbles.
There's some blue bubbles.
Hashtag analytics.
There's some red bubbles, too.
there's a little bit of both.
I think this is where I stand with the, with Paredes.
You acquire him if you can get, you don't want to be trading for the guy who has an 8-10 OPS, right?
Like, because he's only really going to do that in a couple of spots.
Pittsburgh is not one of those spots.
But, according to StatCast, he had 20 homers last year.
If he would have played at PNC Park, he gets 11.
So, he essentially cuts his homer total in half.
Now, 81 games aren't played at PNC Park, though, right?
So, take that for what it's worth as well.
So, you think, a 20 homer season, it doesn't go down to an 11 homer season.
It goes down to a 15 or 16 homer season, which is still significantly better than what you've been getting out of the third base position.
I look at this as, I feel like a lot of people, when they're, when they're, when they see.
Can I give you a little bit of pause here, as well?
Yeah.
Because I also want to put some context to that.
That was also in just 102 games played.
Yeah.
So, exactly that over, like, a full season, which he's pretty much done all of his career.
it's not that long of a career, but that's also not just 17 homeruns if it's a full season.
Yeah.
I think the, I think people, whenever they're talking about Paredes, they're looking at it a little bit wrong.
Like, it's not a matter of, like, who would you rather have start at third base?
It's not, would you rather have Triolo or would you rather have Paredes?
It's really, would you rather have Triolo at third and Gonzalez at short, or would you want Paredes at third and Triolo at short?
Because I think that's what we're talking about here.
I don't think it's, I don't, I don't think we should be comparing Paredes to Triolo necessarily.
Because, honestly, you put Triolo at third base over the course of entire season, his defense is really good.
He's probably giving you three war.
we've seen it.
We saw it with Ke'Bryan Hayes.
We saw it with Triolo.
Like, yeah, there's going to be stretches where Triolo looks awful.
And then there might be some stretches in there where he looks good.
But I think that's the wrong conversation to have is don't compare Paredes to Triolo.
Who would I rather have?
I think the conversation here is like, is Paredes, would you rather have Paredes in this lineup than Nick Gonzales?
And I think the answer to that question, at least for me, is absolutely.
I think he's an upgrade there.
And I think you push Triolo to shortstop.
And then when Konnor Griffin's ready, it doesn't, it doesn't force you to put Konnor Griffin on this opening day, in this opening day lineup either.
Which, hey, if he's, if he's forcing the issue, then by all means, just force the issue.
But it doesn't force you to be like, all right, well, Konnor Griffin, you're the guy at 19 years old.
It doesn't force you to make that decision.
So what I'm curious about here, though, is it seems like the Astros are asking for a lot here.
And to be honest, like they should.
Right.
Because he's a perfect fit for this team, for the Astros, like the best version of Isaac Paredes is a Houston Astro.
He lifts the ball in the air to the poolside.
Like the best place to do that is Houston.
So yeah, like if you're Houston and you want to acquire this guy, you've got to pay me like you're acquiring an 800 plus OPS third baseman.
The issue is once you go somewhere, that's not who he is.
So, yeah, it's going to be weird.
I don't know.
The one spot that concerns me is his, he had limited time in Chicago and he was not a good hitter there.
Right.
But I think, I think over a course of a season, it's still worth adding that bat.
Like if you can get Paredes for not giving up a whole lot, like if you can go Joey Bart and a prospect, then I think you do that.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah.
I want to add in a few things here.
And again, just double down, I've been hammering, like you need to stop looking at this.
Like you mentioned Trillo versus Paredes or Trillo versus anyone.
And it's, would you rather have that person plus Trillo or Trillo and Gonzalez?
Like who makes you better?
And yes, Paredes and Trillo makes his team better.
So absolutely.
And I just think that the whole PNC Park thing is overblown.
And I want to stress, it's true.
I'm not saying you're factually incorrect.
What I am saying is he doesn't turn into a complete pumpkin because he's no longer with Houston.
That he's like going to be this below average hitter that provides no value.
And well, but Trillo probably could be better than him.
Stop it.
Stop it.
Stop looking at blue bubbles and just saying, oh, this guy's going to be really bad.
Understand some things, put some context to it.
Learn a little bit more about what the bubbles mean and whatnot.
Not just like, oh, there's a blue bubble.
So he's not going to be good.
And all he pulls stuff and Savant says it'll be 11 home runs.
So all the, that's just it.
Just 11 home runs.
Cause all 162 is played at PNC Park.
when this dude played away last year, when he was outside and I'm calling it Minute Maid Park cause screw whatever it is now it's Minute Maid Park.
But when he was away, I'll start with the home.
When he was in Houston, the best ballpark you could imagine for him.
249 batting average, 354 on base, 481 slugging.
Good for a 134 way to runs created.
Plus that's a really good hitter, Jim.
And since he's only good at home and that ballpark, which plays to his strengths, he clearly was terrible away, right?
right.
The blue bubbles would say so, Jim, right?
Oh, sounds like you're about to tell us.
Well, when he was away from the best ballpark that suited him and all the other ballparks.
259, 349, 434.
Good for a 122 way to runs created.
Plus Jim, would that be the best hitter on the Pittsburgh Pirates last year?
Yes.
Okay, I'm done.
I'm done.
Done.
Oh, wait, there's more.
He hasn't played at Minute Maid Park his entire career, Jim.
He's had a whole entire career of playing baseball and what?
It's 566 games.
And what has he done every single year outside, but let's just say before he turned 23 years of age, very limited time.
He's never had a season of less than 115 way to runs created plus.
He's a hitter.
This guy does not strike out.
He makes good contact.
The guy also gets on base double digit percentage walk rate every single year, every single year under a 20% K rate.
This guy is a hitter for all the reasons you like Ryan O'Hearn and Spencer Horwitz.
And I know the profile is different.
They're not pool hit heavy like he is in a sense.
But what I'm saying, though, is like they're just hitters.
This guy is also just a hitter.
He makes contact with the baseball.
He does good things with it.
He does hit away.
He does hit home.
I think we're just created this complete narrative that he is going to be the most basic, worthless hitter when he comes to the Pittsburgh Pirates and just be part of the problem they have.
No, like that.
No.
So those 11 home runs he hits in Pittsburgh, I send the 20.
How many of those are also doubles in spacious left field?
Stop it.
Stop it.
Oh, but Jim, but Jim, when you look at Paredes time at PNC Park, he's played there, Jim.
He's played there.
41 plate appearances.
He's a 203 17 543 hitter.
He's bad at PNC Park with a 200 batting error.
Oh, but wait, he had four home runs in the 41 plate appearances.
How can that happen?
He can't hit home runs in PNC Park.
Oh, you're right, Jim.
Nine in nine games, four home runs at PNC.
Right.
And since he went to Chicago and was so bad there.
Yeah, I know, Jim, his 104 plate appearance.
We're taking the smallest sample size to create this whole narrative on a player who's done nothing but been a good player slash hitter.
Because we're just trying to find ways to make this guy as a terrible player.
It's dumb.
It's stupid.
Stupid.
In honor of Bad Bunny, a stupido.
Stupid.
Stupid.
Yeah, I'm not going to say there aren't a little, is it?
My concern with Paredes isn't necessarily that he's going to come over here and be bad.
My concern is that I don't think you're going to be getting an 800 plus OPS guy.
No.
I think you get a 750 guy, but guess what?
That's like the best hitter on the Pirates.
Yeah, that's a good hitter.
So if he's available to you and you can get him without costing your major league team a whole lot or anything at all, then I think you've got it.
You've got to get it done.
Like you've got to add more bats to this lineup.
And quite honestly, like, if in a week from now we're talking about this team has added Ozuna and Paredes who then like the conversation completely shifts
to like, this is an 80 win team and 81 win team.
We're right on the bubble there.
Like you start looking at this lineup and it's legit.
It's like straight up.
It's legit.
The catcher position is then really your only real like big weakness, catcher and shortstop.
But you assume at some point that shortstop is going to turn into a strength.
You assume, you assume.
Yeah.
You hope, but you're right.
But that, again, that puts some context, this picture of like, yeah, like it's really just the catcher and that's a good thing.
So I'm with you.
I am a hundred percent with you.
The one thing that does worry about the Paredes trade, and that's why, again, like when the Suarez free agent signing happened, it got us a little in the feels here.
It got us a little on alert because what's he going to command?
You talked about Bart and a prospect.
Does a Hunter Barco fall under the level of prospect?
he is technically a prospect, right?
And the thing that worries me about the trades now, right?
Is the fact that you're now taking away from the major league talent that you need this year.
So you mentioned this lineup that now looks good, but the strength of this team was backed on starting pitching and how good it was going to be.
And there's now potentially three pitchers plucked from this rotation this year.
And that's a lot of depth and potential quality.
Now I think Oviedo burrows, you saw what they could be.
Hunter Barco is a lot of unknown to him, whatnot, but like that's talent there.
And that's come from your strength.
And now you turn this strength into a weakness and sense of depth for sure.
there's still top end talent there.
There's the guys that are there still talented and they, have good arms, but you've plucked three from that.
Does that hurt you now?
And that's what, that's why like these I'll welcome a praise for a trade, but also like it's going to sting, I feel, and I'm not sure I'm prepared for that sting.
Yeah.
a Barco would certainly cut into the depth quite a bit.
Like, I don't think Barco is going to start in the majors this year, but like Barco is probably your, like your first guy up at this point.
So when you, if you, if you remove Barco from the equation, then that, then that changes things.
I think I would still do the deal.
If Barco like has to be the guy, I wouldn't feel great about it, but I think it's still something like you would just have to do it and then figure out a way to find that starting pitching depth another way.
there's still plenty of minor league free agents out there that you could, you could sign like, and I'm not probably talking about minor league free agents, talking about free agents with major league experience that you could probably sign to minor league deals.
And who could be your capable sixth or seventh starter if you need them a few times through the rotation.
So I wouldn't be like, I wouldn't love it, but like if you have to do it, to do it, then I said, you've got to add, you've got to add more bats to this lineup.
And that's that, if that's the way to do it, then you do it.
I would prefer to give up more of like a lower level pitching prospect that doesn't like hurt you in 2026, but you might not have, you might not be able to.
And that's the problem.
So yeah, I'm not ready to stamp if I'm going to be okay or not with it yet.
Cause I'm not ready to say that yet, but I just know like, that's not, that's not ideal for this team.
And that's why a, like a free agent where only thing you're giving up is financial capital.
Then that's better.
Cause if it was like, you're mentioning true prospects, like this team can absolutely afford to give up prospects, but this is in the territory of like this air quotes prospect.
That was looked upon to help this team in 2026 compete and go somewhere.
And I, like that's not, we're trying to entertain one of them fine, but three, right.
Three guys that were stamping to help you out for this rotation this year.
That's a lot, but I do like Brady's.
I do like the fit, even if it's not the perfect fit, for PNC park, I like him as a fit on this roster and the way it'd be constructed then, because now you did fill that hole at third base.
Triolo does now become your shortstop until Konnor Griffin's ready.
And then he slides into that super utility role, which I think he just, again, can flourish at.
There you have it.
There you have it.
Pitchers and catchers report in 48 hours, Wednesday, February 11th.
It's a glorious day.
We are two days away from, I guess, do we want it?
This whole beat writer situation, let me just say real quick, it sucks.
Post cause that shutting down sucks.
MLB.com, restructuring Alex, no longer being there.
That sucks.
One of my favorite times of the year is like all the beat writers going into spring training and, pulling out their iPhones and posting these iPhone videos, which, technology has gotten a lot better since the start of Twitter.
But like the best was like back in like 2010, when you'd have people uploading phone videos to Twitter and it'd be like Paul Mulholland, like the outline, the shady outline of Paul Mulholland
throwing an 89 mile an hour sinker to, and we ate it all up and it was like, oh man, give me more of this stuff.
Now it's come, it's come a long way, but that's like my favorite part of pitchers and catchers reporting is just like, you get all the videos from all the reporters who are, you get the pop of the glove.
You get to see, you get to see guys get, throwing their bullpens.
So yeah, we get to see that in two days right now.
I can't wait.
Yeah, love it.
Absolutely love this time of year.
So pitchers and catchers are reporting on Wednesday.
The rotation right now still has some question marks.
I don't know who right now that number five starter is.
There's currently, I'm sure, a competition based off of people who are reporting to camp.
I think there may still be a couple, there, maybe there's another minor league free agency deal out there to add someone else in the mix.
Maybe there's another major league deal to add someone else in the mix.
But, as of right now, that number five starter, you're probably looking at José Urquidy, who they just signed last week, certainly being in the mix there.
You're probably looking at Carmen Mlodzinski being in the mix for that spot.
And you're probably looking at Hunter Barco being in the mix for that spot, like as things stand right now.
Like those are probably the three guys who like realistically have a chance.
And maybe the solution's a mixture of the three, like with piggybacking and such.
But yeah, as of right now, the way the roster stands, like that fifth starter role is completely up in the air.
I agree.
But I think ideally today, as all things stand today, ideally you want Carmen Mlodzinski in that bullpen role that he's, he also flourishes in and you, ideally you probably want Hunter
Barco to start off in the minor leagues, which is why you're trying to bring in a fifth starter.
So I think right now it's, Irquidy or Keity, sorry.
but I also want to say this, I have this feeling the pirates aren't wanting to go like that they're still, I don't look at this as like that solved the fifth starter.
I feel like they're still probably want to go out and get another pitcher to be the fifth starter.
Is that how you take it as well?
Or do you feel like this is the major league signing?
I feel like there's gotta be another one.
I don't, I'm not very comfortable with Jose or Keity in my rotation right now.
he hasn't pitched a lot and he's been injured, so there's that he hasn't pitched a lot though in the last three years, in the last three years, this guy has 33 total innings pitched
in the last two years, sorry, 33 innings pitched across all levels in the last two years.
And only two of those innings are in the major leagues, and they weren't good, but it was two innings.
so yeah, I'm not like, I'm not completely comfortable handing a spot to this guy.
Now, the good news here is like, he used to be good.
Thank you.
There is, there is at least historical evidence of Jose or Keity being a major league starter.
It's just, the last time he pitched in the majors wasn't great.
So I'm not make a great fifth starter for this team.
If he's healthy and back to where he was.
Absolutely.
Yeah.
Like if we're talking 20, circa 2022, Jose or Keity here, sign me up.
Yeah.
I just have no idea if he's that guy anymore.
That was, that was four years ago and he basically hasn't pitched since then.
so I don't know what to think with Jose or Keity.
I don't know if you're looking at him for just depth.
I think ideally you are getting one more picture here in the mix though.
because I agree with you.
I love Carmen Mlodzinski in that like swing man role where he can give you multiple innings.
He can, he can bridge the gap between the starter and the backend of the bullpen because you still have guys like Braxton Ashcraft and Bubba Chandler who aren't going to give you seven innings every
time out there because that's just not who they are at this point in their careers.
So like you need someone to bridge the gap.
And Mlodzinski's that guy, like he's, he was awesome in that role last year.
For sure.
I love Mlodzinski in the bullpen, but if you're saying, Jim, you've got to pick a fifth starter right now, I'm going Carmen Mlodzinski.
Like it's, he's, he is the best guy for that role right now as the roster is currently constructed.
But again, that leads us to why they probably need to get another guy.
Yeah.
Because that's, that is not the best spot for him.
And also back to the whole Paredes trade, like, again, you're taking Barco out of the equation.
So at this point in time, it's Mlodzinski or your kitty.
And yeah.
Right.
So I do think like you mentioned, that's how I look at this also, he gives it's, they brought in Clevenger, the minor league deal.
They brought him on the major league deal.
And I feel like they're both looked at in almost like the same light as like what the role might be.
It's depth.
Maybe they're also like a bridge, a bullpen pitcher as well.
I think there's some flexibility with the, both of those guys.
Obviously again, Clevenger's on a minor league deal.
So you don't have to worry too much about him in that sense.
But yes, I do believe that like, this doesn't solve the fifth starter.
They are still looking to acquire who the fifth starter is going to be.
John brings up a good point here too, in the comments that it's also going to like, the position battles are going to look weird this spring because like Jose or Katie is seemingly fighting for a spot.
He's not even going to be in camp a good chunk of this spring training.
He's pitching on team Mexico in the world baseball classic.
So, that's just one of those, it's just another thing you got to keep an eye on.
Like, cause you're not going to be able to see Jose or Katie and spring training games, especially at the beginning half of the spring.
So, Hey, we're going to have to watch some team Mexico WBC games to see what's going on with her Katie for a while.
Yeah.
But either way, it's an interesting name.
So I welcome the signing.
I have no problem with the signing at all.
So to me, again, this is one of those signings where you can't get upset about it.
Can't really get overly excited about it.
Like it's just the signing.
There's some upside it's limited.
I said it's a, it's a low risk, low reward type signing to me.
He's not going to go out there and become like, Oh, if he can be vintage this, then there's a potential he can like help carry this rotation.
It's like, Oh, if he can be healthy and whatnot, he can be a fifth starter.
Yeah.
But that's what this team needs.
So as another arm, you always need to add more arms, especially this time of the year, they're going to start, coming in, but I do hope that they go out there and find somebody else, like the José Quintana's at Tyler Anderson's.
Like we keep talking about more and more, someone on those lines still going to be affordable, but that's a guy that you can certainly plug in and feel good about being at your fifth starter.
Yeah.
And to be honest with you, I'm surprised they aren't at least trying Mason Montgomery out in that role.
I would, if it were me, I would at least try it like, yeah, but it seems like they're not doing that.
Yeah.
Well, I know Mason also like stamped on reliever, but again, that's just his mindset.
Like he could easily say like, Hey, let's try you here and I'm sure he'd welcome it.
But again, like you're saying that the stuff's nasty, like that's a guy that has potential.
If you can really harness this, like he could be a force possibly in the rotation, but I don't know.
I just, there's a ton of upside there that I at least, like it makes me like, at least want to try it, but I understand.
I understand not.
All right.
Let's talk catchers real quick.
It's a, it's a position we haven't really spent a ton of time at.
but catchers also reporting with those pitchers, Henry Davis, Joey Bart for now, but there seems to be, I don't know.
There seems to be Jason Mackey of the post-gazette is 100% convinced that Joey Bart is going to be traded before the start of the season.
and he would make sense going to the Astros in a trade as, their backup, like that would make sense if they're looking for someone, to help their major league team.
But you've got four catchers on the major league, on the, on the 40 man, on the 40 man roster between Davis, Bart, Flores, and ND.
And he hasn't played hardly at all in the last couple of seasons, just due to injury.
So, this will be our first look at him in a while.
It's just like, no, he needs to just get back into baseball.
Yeah.
I think being the triple a makes a whole lot of sense at this point in time for him.
Yeah.
I think, I think Andy's like, I think Andy's like a lock to be in triple a, regardless of what happens.
Flores is the guy where like, if Bart gets dealt, then like Flores and Davis are your catchers.
I don't think Flores has any other path of making this team though, unless Bart's traded.
I agree.
Not the way it's constructed at this point in time, but you're right about, Mackie and Bart.
Tyler and I talked about this and I, if I were to bet, I'm betting that he's on the opening day roster, things obviously can jab praise Houston wants part.
It sounds like if that deal goes down, but I felt like if that deal doesn't go down to me, like that's it.
Like the pirates might be looking, but let's go back to like last trade deadline.
Like teams didn't look at bar.
Like they didn't even value him as a catcher.
It was like, if we bring him, he, this is a bench bat.
He's like a right-handed bench bat.
That's how a lot of teams valued him in the trade market.
And that's why he wasn't dealt at the trade deadline.
So I don't foresee a whole lot of suitors or guys knocking on the door to get Joey Bart, in this off season, sounds like Houston's one and probably one of one.
So if that trade doesn't happen, that's the, to me, it's like, that's, it's that trade or nothing for Joey Bart who'll be on this roster.
So, but let's just say it does.
And again, it makes the team better.
I do think you're right.
It's going to be Flores and Henry Davis at this point in time with Andy being in triple A. But I, again, like an ideal situation is that you probably want both of those in triple A. Again, I'm going to give up Joey Bart for a better bat somewhere, but like Joey Bart
and Henry Davis makes sense on this major league roster as far as catchers situation goes in a vacuum.
I think as things stand right now, like those are your clear top two guys.
Good point from Hamilton here.
He talks about Andy and then like an outfield option.
I want to go back to seeing Andy as that.
Just you can plug him anywhere.
guy.
I feel like he just brings a lot more value that way.
And you're looking at a team where like we've starved for people who can play in the outfield for one.
So like if Andy can get back to hitting the way he was when he was the minor league player of the year and he can play outfield for you every now and then all of a sudden, like Andy becomes this completely different guy on your 40 man that you can deploy in
a myriad of ways.
He was thrusted into the first pace position last year, which that's not the best fit for him.
I think we can pretty much agree there, but like if he's catching and then he can maybe play some second base every now and then, and then you could plug them into a corner outfield spot.
Like if he can do that and hit a little bit, then all of a sudden he, that's how I think that's how Andy regains his value because he is still just 25 years old
at this point.
As of today, yeah, he's 25.
It'll be 26.
And it's just like, it's none of it's going to matter though, unless he can hit again.
So a hundred percent, I don't disagree with that at all.
that's what made the hendy catcher tandem so deadly because Henry Davis was going to hit.
Obviously he was going to hit, right?
He's going to be a monster offensively.
Can't really feel too much.
And Andy is a good hitter.
Also can play everywhere.
So that's how you find at bats for both of them.
Well, neither of them have been good in the major leagues at all.
So, but yeah, like that's where Andy provides value.
that versatility.
the VAR show comp and the idea of it was, Endy Rodríguez, he can play catcher.
He can play second base.
He can play first base.
Maybe put him in the outfield.
You can play all over the place and give you a good defense.
But the gym, like the problem is in the league where he's had more than five games played.
He hasn't been good offensively since 2022.
That's a big gap.
He's been injured at back-to-back seasons.
We don't really know what he is.
And maybe he doesn't even know what he is yet.
So again, going back to the, like, and again, like, yes, I want him utilized in that sense, but I just feel like it's best suited that he goes back to AAA and like, just become a baseball player again, find yourself, get back into yourself because he's not going to
play every day.
It gave him, he does make the major league team.
He's not getting a whole lot of play time at the major leagues and doing so.
So start off in AAA.
Let's get Indy back.
Let's get that dude back.
Hopefully it's there, but like, that's where you're going to find it.
And then let's progress you to the major leagues if it's deserved.
And there's a spot for him, but yeah, that's my two cents on it.
Yeah.
I agree with you.
Bullpen.
The bullpen seems set to be honest.
Like, I don't even see too many battles here.
Like Santana's in Soto's in Mattson's and Lawrence's in Maginski's in.
I guess there's a battle.
Like, do you carry two lefties?
Or three lefties with Montgomery and Sisk.
Yohan Ramirez is sitting there without any options.
And they gave him, they tendered him a contract.
So like, you got to imagine that he's probably getting a job.
and then your other guys on the 40 man, Bedouin, Nicholas Sanders, Harvin, like those four, I could see as I think a lot of it maybe depends on what happens with that fifth starter
role.
But if Maginski is that number five starter, does Urquidy go to the bullpen?
Or do you want to make sure Urquidy's a starter?
So you put him as a starter in Indy and that bumps up, Bedouin, Nicholas Sanders or Harvin.
I think if you're looking at guys like Nicholas is probably that next guy.
Like if you're comparing Bedouin, Nicholas Sanders, Harvin, Nicholas is probably that next guy.
I do really like Bedouin and I really like Harvin's stuff a lot.
I'm surprised Cam Sanders has surprised, has survived this long into the off season.
Like I feel like he's maybe he's like the next 40 man casualty, but once spring starts, you can start adding guys to the 60 day IL too.
So that, frees up at least a spot with Jared Jones.
So you may or may not need to do anything there, but yeah, I feel like the bullpen.
It's pretty set like a couple battles here and there, but not really, not really a whole lot.
It's going to be like Sisk, Montgomery.
I said sack right here.
Nicholas, Sisk, Ramirez, Montgomery.
fighting for two, for like three spots.
I agree.
I guess I don't have much to add to that.
Like, yeah, it just, it just is what it is with them.
and the thing about your Kyle Nicholas, yeah, it's there.
Yeah.
And I think they like, they all know the roles too.
It's not like you're, who's going to be a closer, who's going to be set up.
Who's going to be this.
those roles are all defined.
It's just like, who's going to be the middle relievers and perfectly.
I'm going to be okay having two lefties like with Soto and Montgomery is the stuff Montgomery possesses.
There's a lot of good things there.
They can harness that.
He's a true weapon.
Now there's potential.
He has a terrible spring, an absolute terrible spring.
And what Bill, what Bill Murphy's preaching to him, he has to find in triple a, like there is that scenario and that exists, but I'm absolutely okay.
Having like him and Soto on the roster is two lefties for this bullpen.
But after that, they're like Kyle Nicholas, also like good stuff.
this rotation, I'm sorry, this bullpen does have guys that have possessed stuff.
Like Sanders is not one of those guys, but the guys that he's fighting with and the roster and stuff like Kyle Nicholas, but while Harvin, like they have really good stuff.
That's what you want to find in a reliever.
And that's also what I'm interested, with pitchers and catchers.
Like this is the first time like Bill Murphy puts on the jersey and we see him, we've heard of, heard him speak here and there or whatnot.
But like, he's going to have now the effect on these pitchers.
Let's see what this guy can do.
Let's let Bill cook.
Yeah.
Very limited playing time, but stuff plus does love Cam Sanders stuff, by the way.
But no, you're right.
I think Ramirez is on this team regardless, just because of the lack of options and like everyone else that we've mentioned has options.
And when it comes to these like six, seventh, eighth guys out of the bullpen, the biggest thing is just like having those guys available.
So like Ramirez, I would be shocked if he doesn't break camp just for the fact that he doesn't have options and you're, they aren't going to want to lose an arm.
Whereas all these other guys we're talking about, Bidouin, Harbin, Nicholas, Sanders, they all have options.
So like, if it comes down to it where it's like, eh, I can't really make a dip.
I can't really make the choice between these two guys.
You go with the guy without options.
This is where the famous, you're not always bringing the best 26 up.
And that's why you also deal with, you need to last a season.
You bring the best 26 up and it's, causing casualties to guys that have these contracts and you're going to lose them.
Then, well, you don't have someone to bring up in May.
Yeah, because it's pitchers and they're going to get hurt.
We've all done the sport quiz every year.
And how many pitchers do we fill out on that thing?
20.
There's 25 pitchers every year that ends up being used over the course of a major league season.
So then you start, you have a twins relievers.
Yeah.
So like if you have a healthy pitcher at the start of spring training, who doesn't have options, he's coming north with you.
That's just how it works.
Unless it's just totally.
Unless he's, yeah, unless he's just, yeah, but right.
Like you're right.
And that's the thing.
Which Ramirez isn't that he has his moments.
I think we all know who he is at this point.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Not great, but he does possess stuff.
That's why he was here.
Yeah.
And big bank is gone.
Sadly, I'm going to shed another tear for that, by the way.
All right.
So, yeah, pitchers and catchers report on Wednesday.
Obviously, we'll have NS9 live that night, too.
So we get to talk some more about it.
But anything else we want to discuss and talk about before we head out of here?
I think.
I think that's everything.
Yeah.
I'm good with that.
Two weeks, though, Jim.
Where will you be in two weeks?
Two weeks?
I will be.
two weeks from today, we'll be like two days into our spring training trip.
I'll be doing I'll be doing Bucco Brew live on location from Bradenton.
So, yeah, looking forward to that.
And I'll be sleeping in because I won't be there that week.
So it'll be you and somebody else.
I get to sleep in and not get yelled at.
You know what?
Maybe it'll be me and Dougie Fresh.
I'm good with that.
I think the people are good with that.
But, yeah, two weeks.
Two weeks.
You already.
yesterday, well, I guess two weeks from yesterday would have been the first game of spring training.
We'll be at.
So, again, we'll be doing shows before every post.
I'm sorry.
Shows before every game at Lecom Park.
So each week, I think there's four.
Works out perfect for each week that we're there.
But, yeah, you'll be there the first week.
I'll be there the second week.
I'll be there the first weekend because, again, it's just a drive for me.
So I'll be there for the first weekend.
Then I'll come back for the second full week as well.
It's going to be awesome.
I can't wait.
It's exciting.
And it better be warm.
If you guys bring the cold, I swear to God.
I'd be fine with, like, 60s.
But, no, I prefer.
So I swear to God.
I prefer, like, 80.
80 and sunny.
Let's go 80 and sunny.
Mid-70s is perfect.
Even low-ish.
73 is fine.
Below that.
80s, though, make it, like, because there is one day where, like, we take an off day.
80 and sunny would at least make for a good beach day.
70 is cutting a little close there.
Yeah.
As long as, like, the one year where it was, like, 50s.
Oh, that was terrible.
Outside of that, so as mentioned, we'll have NS9 Live this Wednesday.
Back to the point on Friday.
And, yeah, I don't think anything else really in the works.
You did a card pack opening, if you guys haven't checked it out yet.
So, yeah, I did one with Easton Carmichael and Seth Hernandez a couple weeks ago, and did one with Gustavo Melendez over the weekend.
So, yeah, check that out.
Yeah.
And outside of that, go ahead and like, subscribe, do all the fun stuff.
It's baseball season, so we're absolutely ramping up.
And just to tease it again, it's coming.
I don't know, but we have some big news, some big news coming.
Again, I gave you dates.
If you saw the story, I gave you dates to look at your calendar for.
If you want to go to PNC Park, circle those dates.
We'll tell you shortly why you're doing that.
But what's cooking?
I don't know.
I don't know.
Something is, though.
But I'll start with that.
Quick update, too, before we leave.
Fan duel over under win total up to 77.5.
77.5.
Come on, man.
I still feel like that's a little low.
It is.
I feel like that's good value.
It has gone up, though.
Yeah.
It has gone up.
I bet it when it was at 74.5.
Smart, man.
But I still think it's, again, it's a very, it's safe.
I think you can bet over that and feel good.
Ben's never done that before with the Pirates.
He has.
That's a good point.
However, he's also never signed a free agent worth $30 million.
That's true.
That's true.
He's never signed a free agent worth $7 million.
Good point.
All right.
We are out of here.
We'll see you guys later.
We love you all.
Bye-bye.
See you guys.
All right.
That wraps up this episode of North Shore Nine.
Thanks so much for tuning in.
Whether you're listening on the podcast or catching us on YouTube, if you enjoyed the show, please give this video a thumbs up.
And don't forget to hit that subscribe button if you haven't already.
It really helps us grow.
And if you're listening on the podcast, a quick review goes a long way in helping others find the show.
Plus, be sure to tell a friend about us.
There's always room for more here in the NS9 community.
And for those looking to support us a little more, consider joining our Patreon, become an MVP member, and get exclusive perks while helping us continue to bring you more of the Pirates content you love.
Thanks again for all your support, and let's go Bucs.
Thanks again for all your support, and let's go Bucs.
Thanks again for all your support, and let's go Bucs.
Thanks again for all your support, and let's go Bucs.
Thanks again for all your support, and let's go Bucs.
Thanks again for all your support, and let's go Bucs.
Thanks again for all your support, and let's go Bucs.
Thanks again for all your support, and let's go Bucs.
Thanks again for all your support, and let's go Bucs.
Thanks again for all your support, and let's go Bucs.
Thanks again for all your support, and let's go Bucs.
Thanks again for all your support, and let's go Bucs.
Thanks again for all your support, and let's go Bucs, and let's go Bucs, and let's go Bucs.
Thanks again for all your support, and let's go Bucs.
Comments· 0
Would adding Marcell Ozuna and Isaac Paredes make the Pirates an 80-win team?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.