◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
The Pirates are starting to build some real momentum, and Saturday’s 3-2 walk-off win over the Orioles gave Tyler and Jim plenty to break down on the latest NS9 Postgame Show. Nick Yorke delivered the game-winning double in the ninth, Jake Mangum sparked the comeback with a hustle infield hit, and the Pirates found another way to win a close game late. It was the kind of finish that made the vibes at PNC Park feel as high as they’ve been all season.
In the episode, the guys talk through what made this win stand out. Carmen Mlodzinski gave the Pirates another solid effort in the fifth starter role, working into the fifth inning and continuing to show he can help this team right now even if the long-term bullpen debate isn’t going away. They also dig into Hunter Barco’s strange but scoreless outing, more shutdown work from the bullpen, and another electric moment from Dennis Santana.
The offense had its share of big moments too. Bryan Reynolds came through in the ninth, Ryan O’Hearn continued to show why he’s been such a strong addition, and Spencer Horwitz chipped in as the lineup kept creating chances all day. Tyler and Jim also spend time on the bigger picture, including the Pirates’ improved depth, the impact of the bench, and why this roster feels more capable of grinding out wins than in past years.
If you want instant reaction, strong postgame vibes, and a full breakdown of another dramatic Bucs win, this is an episode worth watching or listening to.
Comments· 0
The Debate
Should Carmen Mlodzinski stay in the rotation instead of moving to the bullpen?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.
With Jim Rosati and Tyler Sweeney.
Chapters
Key takeaways
1
Carmen Mlodzinski may be best as a bulk reliever, but he is the Pirates' fifth-best starter right now: 9 innings, 2 runs and 13 strikeouts in two starts. They should keep starting him.
2
The Pirates absolutely should not have won this game. Taking games like this one is what good teams do.
3
Through the whole Cherington era the bench was guys on their last leg. Now it's full of real major leaguers, and Mangum and Yorke proved it by winning the game off the bench.
4
Spencer Horwitz led the team in wRC+ last year and now bats seventh. That shows how much depth has been added to the lineup.
5
Bryan Reynolds has started slowly, but his approach looks steady and the hard contact will come. With Lowe and O'Hearn hitting around him, it's time to stop worrying.
This is the North Shore Nine Podcast, presented by FanDuel, I'm Tyler, with me is Jim, and you're listening to the NS9 Post Game Show, powered by Primanti Brothers, Jim's at the ballpark, Jim, what are the vibes like, my man?
Man, they couldn't be better, they couldn't be better, Jake, Nick Yorke, Nick, all right, discombobulated here, Jake Mangum brings the cone out, crowns Nick Yorke, Nick Yorke walk off double in the ninth inning,
the Pirates win 3-2, they've won four in a row, Tyler, vibes are just about as high as they can get right now.
Vibes are immaculate, the cones are being hoisted, like you said, Nick Yorke walks it off, comes in late in the game as a pinch runner, comes up in a big spot, just absolutely barrels of baseball.
Are the Pirates good?
Hey, many are asking that question.
And I think today you saw a little bit about why this team, I don't know, they seem different than last year, right?
it was a close game, it came down to pitching and timely hitting, and the Pirates, they left a lot of guys on base in the middle innings, the fourth, fifth, sixth inning, left six guys on base,
but then they kept getting chances, they get a run in the eighth, and then they, I'm sorry, they get a run in the eighth to tie it up, and sorry, I've got them all over the place.
But, yeah, Nick Yorke coming through, it's just people coming through in big spots, winning close games, you just love to see it.
Back-to-back one run wins.
You do, you absolutely love to see it.
It, this is the type of game that a good team steals.
The Pirates absolutely should not have won this game.
And did the Orioles help them out a little bit?
Sure.
Like, they just kept applying pressure, they kept base runners on, and eventually, it just broke through.
Yeah, you mentioned the Orioles kept them in this, and, that eighth inning, I don't think anybody hit the ball out of the infield.
Jake Mangum's single to tie the game was just, we talked about this when we acquired Jake Mangum, right?
It was like, you're going to see a lot of ground outs to the pitcher, but you're also going to see a lot of infield singles.
Today, you saw what probably should have been a ground out to the pitcher become an infield single, and that was a huge moment in today's game, because the Pirates, again, they were having all these opportunities, getting people on base, getting people on base, couldn't come through.
Jake finally comes through there with that infield hit.
Yeah, he does.
And also, something you need to mention, I think, about this team right now, they're hustling.
I know it's something silly to bring up, but you see it there with Jake Mangum.
He gets down the line really well.
He's always going to do that.
Another guy that's been beat up a little bit, Marcell Ozuna.
It's a ground ball.
He doesn't get down the line very quickly, but, hey, that's the game-tying run right there.
This team, top to bottom right now, they're playing hard.
Yeah, and Ozuna, he has been the recipient of all of the pent-up frustrations so far.
if this team's winning ballgames, there's not a whole lot of frustrations, but the ones that there are have been directed towards Ozuna.
He was 0-3 going into that at-bat, strikeout, groundout, and, yeah, that single, as minimal as it was, it was just a ground ball, shallow third base.
Mayo couldn't make the play.
He gets on, and that's what started things in the eighth inning.
So, yeah, it wasn't a good-looking hit, but it got the job done, and he only had one other hit all year.
So, you'll take that at that moment.
Absolutely.
Like I said, Pirates win this one today in walk-off fashion, 3-2.
They are now 5-3.
Make sure that we are dropping the hashtag raises here in the comments.
We'll be giving away sandwiches here later.
Jim, aside from all the theatrics that happened late in the game there, Kermit Mlodzinski did get to start a lot of discourse on the Internet about the reliever of her starter and where he should fit.
What did you see from the ballpark today?
Yeah.
After his first start, DiNardo, I believe it was DiNardo, asked me, like, did this change your mind or did this prove anything?
And it really didn't, right?
It was four and a third innings last time out.
The third time through, single, triple, single.
Tonight, a similar thing, right?
Like, I think we all are in agreement that, like, the best form of Kermit Mlodzinski is a bulk-inning reliever because he's really good at that role.
But I think he also showed you tonight that, like, he's, as much as everybody wants to get on him, he's still a very capable fifth starter for a major league team.
again, it wasn't pretty tonight.
Four and two-thirds innings, gave up five hits, two runs, three walks.
He struck out five, 84 pitches.
He, yeah, it wasn't the best outing, but he got two outs into the fifth.
They tried getting him to finish that fifth, and it just didn't work out.
But I think you're just going to see this with this fifth starter spot where, like, Carmen's going to go four to five, and then last time out it was Yohan Oviedo who went, two-plus innings.
At the end of the day, between those two pitchers, you're seven innings in.
You've given up two runs, and you want to look at Carmen Mlodzinski's stat line for the season.
He's got nine innings.
He's got nine innings this year through two starts.
He's given up two runs, and he's struck out 13 batters.
I think if you're saying, like, is he a starter or not, right now, I don't know if he's a starter, but he's the fifth best starter this team has right now.
And that's good enough for me for them to keep putting him out there.
Yeah, and I think there's going to be a little bit of negativity around him today, and a lot of people just want to see him in that bullpen role because we know he can thrive there.
I'll be honest with you.
I was a little bit encouraged by what I saw from him today.
I know it wasn't that pretty, but we saw him flip it there in the fourth inning once all the damage happened.
He's cruising through three.
They start to touch his fastball a little bit.
He's getting barreled up.
They end up loading the bases.
Bill Murphy has a mound visit.
He flips it, goes splitter.
I think he went curveball, splitter, and then he went heavy curveball, splitter after that.
He hadn't thrown that very much early in the game.
I'm liking the pitch usage right now.
What I'm seeing out of him does look more starter material, I think, with the usage of the pitching.
It's something Alex has touched on a lot on offbeat as well, is him working north to south.
Yep.
I think we're really seeing that work for him a little bit here.
I'll be honest.
I liked what I saw out of him.
I think you could have got five out of him.
And if he gets one more out here, we're talking about five innings of two-run ball.
You get that from your fifth starter.
I'm not mad at all.
No.
he used the splitter a lot, especially against lefties.
50% of his pitches to left-handed batters were splitters.
So, yeah, he leaned on that pitch.
And, again, like, I don't know what people necessarily expect from a fifth starter, but this is just fine.
Like, if he gives through his first two starts, what he's given you is just fine.
And I think a lot of teams, if you were to say, hey, through two starts, the fifth best starting pitcher on your team would have nine innings pitched and given up two runs.
Like, everybody would take that.
Everybody would take that stat line.
So, I think when it comes to Carmen, I think we just need to take a step back and realize, yeah, like, you know what?
He's probably better off in the bullpen.
But, like, who else are you going to have start these games?
That's my question.
Like, do you want José Urquidy to start these games?
Who Don Kelly apparently doesn't even trust to put him in ballgames at all.
Hunter Barco, we'll get to him, but, like, he definitely doesn't look like somebody I'd be super comfortable with sending out there every five games.
And he's got an innings limit this season.
We all know that.
So, like, you know what?
Carmen Mlodzinski's, like, again, he's the fifth best option on this team.
So, just keep putting him out there until he shows that he's not capable because so far he's gotten the job done.
Like, he's not going to go six or seven or eight innings.
But guess what?
It's 2026, and pitchers don't do that anyways.
Right.
And we've had the discussion as well, like, where it's best for Carmen Mlodzinski.
Is it best in the bullpen?
Probably.
But we're at the point as well where it's best for the team that Carmen Mlodzinski's in this rotation because he is their fifth best option, like you just said.
So, I'm encouraged by what I've seen.
Let's keep rolling him out there, and hopefully it just, he continues to grow in this role.
Yeah.
Gutsy performance.
Gutsy performance.
He had that shaky, obviously that very shaky fourth inning.
But I thought it was interesting sending him back out there for the fifth.
And, he picked up, he picked up two outs.
Yeah.
And you mentioned him earlier there, Hunter Barco.
He does go two and a third.
It wasn't the prettiest of performances at all.
He ends up walking three over two and a third, only strikes out one.
Yeah, a very weird final line for Hunter Barco, because if you watched him, you were like, that doesn't seem like it.
But, yeah, two and a third innings, doesn't give up a run, doesn't even give up a hit.
He walks three, strikes out one.
Yeah, it was an odd outing.
Hunter Barco threw more balls than he threw strikes in his two and a third scoreless innings.
But, hey, anytime you can limit hits, like, you've got a good chance of putting up zeros, even if you're walking batters like he was today.
Yeah.
He's a bit erratic, and I'd like to see him throw some more competitive pitches.
Too many balls that just don't have a chance.
But, he's young.
He's growing.
There's still stuff to like about him.
The fastball plays up a good bit, I think, and I love the changeup.
And then Isaac Mattson and Dennis Santana wrap up five and one-third of scoreless ball from the bullpen.
Yeah, great work by the bullpen.
Again, Mlodzinski gives you 14 outs.
Bullpen finishes off.
Doesn't give up another run.
Mattson just doing what he does, throwing fastballs, 93, 94, and Orioles can't hit it.
And then Dennis Santana.
How about that moment in the ninth inning?
I thought that was a pretty cool moment.
Dennis Santana gets Gunnar Henderson looking.
Gunnar, taps the helmet for the ABS.
And it's a strike.
Dennis Santana just waves him, waves him off the field.
I thought that was pretty fun.
It was.
But I was going to be furious if it would have been a ball there and it would have ruined that moment.
Yeah.
That did, that challenge did end up coming up big there because Nick Yorke should have struck out if the Orioles have any challenges left.
That's a good call.
Yeah, that, at bat by York.
If the Orioles had a challenge left, they could have challenged one of those pitches and they didn't have it.
Yeah.
What a shame.
You just hate to see it.
You do.
You hate, you hate that.
You hate that the game came down to that.
Yeah.
You really hate when things just don't go the Orioles way.
Right.
Right.
But yeah, all in all, a really nice five and a, five and, five and a third from the, is my math right there?
Four and a third, five and a, four and a third from the, four and a third from the, four and a third from the bullpen.
Yeah.
only one, only one hit given up to, they only struck out three in those four and a third walk for, but again, if you're limiting hits, you're more than likely going to put up zeros.
For sure.
Moving on over here.
Give me one second.
Actually, before we get moving any further here, let's hear from IQ Bar and our guy Cody.
This episode is brought to you by IQ Bar, our exclusive snack hydration and sponsor.
IQ Bar protein bars, IQ Mix hydration mixes, and IQ Joe mushroom coffees are the delicious, low sugar, brain and body fuel you need to win your day.
The ultimate sampler pack is a great way for you to try all IQ Bar products and flavors.
You get nine IQ bars, eight IQ Mix sticks, and four IQ Joe sticks.
All IQ Bar products are clean label certified and entirely free from gluten, dairy, soy, GMOs, and artificial ingredients.
With over 20,000 five-star reviews and counting, more people than ever are fueling their lifestyles with IQ Bar's brain and body boosting bars, hydration mixes, and mushroom coffees.
The ultimate sampler pack includes all three.
My personal favorites so far have been the almond butter chip and the iced tea lemonade hydration mix.
It's just really full of flavor.
I love starting my day with it.
And I couldn't imagine starting my day with anything else other than IQ Bar products.
Right now, IQ Bar is offering our podcast listeners 20% off all IQ Bar products, including the ultimate sampler pack, plus free shipping.
To get your 20% off, text MLB to 64000.
That's MLB 64000.
Message and data rates may apply.
See terms for details.
What's that number again?
64000.
I love it.
Moving on here to the bats, though.
One guy I did want to highlight, and he's struggled out the gate, but Bryan Reynolds, he came up big there in the ninth inning.
Squares up a fastball.
How was it?
101, I think.
He got a hold of it.
I didn't look up at the exit velo, but he drove that thing opposite field, one bouncer over the fence.
Yeah, he had a good game.
He was on base four times if you count the error, which another, like you talked about before, like just a hustle play, right?
And both of them came through today late in the game, off the bench.
And that's something where I feel like the Pirates have also really been missing in the entire Cherington era is just guys off the bench who can do something, right?
You're used to these guys coming off the bench where they're on their last leg in Major League Baseball.
it's like if you can't make it with the Pirates, buddy, you better be looking at condos in Tokyo, right?
Like, those are the guys they've been putting on this team.
That's not the case right now.
Like, this bench is full of Major League Baseball players.
It is.
And you said something there about, like, not everybody's got going today.
But with this lineup at this point, not everybody has to get going.
That's what's been nice.
You don't have to have Oneil Cruz being an absolute superstar.
He can go one for four and be hitting .290 with the .914 OPS right now, which is great.
Which is really good.
It is.
But he can have those off days where he just looks like the Oneil Cruz that drives you nuts.
And we don't have to lose our minds because there are other guys that can carry this team from day to day.
Yep.
It's very nice to see right now.
I hate how positive I am.
It's weird.
Because I just, I feel like something's going to go wrong here.
But let's enjoy it as it happens.
Yeah.
they clinched the series today.
So that's two series won in a row.
They win the home opening series.
Tomorrow, then you're playing with house money.
You've got, I believe, Braxton Ashcraft going tomorrow, which he's looked outstanding.
So, yeah, you've got a good chance now of sweeping the Orioles.
And then all of a sudden, like, the way this season started, that they started 0-2, you've now won four of five.
You've won two series in a row.
Just keep stacking wins.
Like, I know it's early.
You can't win.
You can't make the postseason in April.
But you can stack wins.
These games count just as much as every other game.
So, yeah, you're 5-3 now after eight games.
We were 1-2 after three.
And the sky was falling, right?
And it's been a week.
And here we are now.
You want to give away some sandwiches?
Let's do it.
Let's give away some Sammies here.
Make sure we drop the hashtag raises there in the comments if you have not yet.
I've got to remember how to do this because it's been a while for me.
But we'll figure it out.
Yeah, you've got to share your screen, right?
Thanks.
But, no, make sure you get those hashtag raises in.
If you haven't already, like the video.
Subscribe to the page if you haven't.
If you're listening on the podcast, you guys rock.
Continue to post your five-star reviews and share it to whoever's catching bucko fever.
You're out there.
Let them know about NS9.
Let them know.
138 entries.
We'll be giving away some sandwiches here.
Let's kick it off here with the first group.
We need some Jeopardy music.
And our first winner is going to be, well, that's not right.
It is Doug.
Doug, you're not eligible.
Yeah, we're going to go ahead and draw again.
Doug, if you need sandwiches, I'll go ahead and just buy them for you.
Doug, we'll get you covered.
We'll cover you.
Doug, you'll be okay.
Love you, buddy.
But let's rerun that.
Rigged.
Whole thing's rigged.
Is it your dad?
It is Gregory Hoyle.
Gregory is the all-time dude.
I'll say known Tyler fan, Gregory Hoyle.
Known Tyler fan.
Also known Jim fan.
Yeah.
Congrats, Gregory.
Congrats.
Yeah, Greg, you know what to do.
Get a hold of us with your email and sign up for the Primanti's app.
Let's draw our next winner here.
And who do we got for number two?
Number two is going to be Yellowbeard.
Congratulations, Yellowbeard.
I'm pretty sure I've seen Yellowbeard in here a good bit as well.
Yeah, Yellowbeard's a regular.
Regular.
Love it.
You know what to do.
Get the Primanti's app.
Send us your email.
Get those loaded onto your account.
Real quick here.
Let me get to some of these.
Penn becomes a member for 15 months.
Love you, Penn.
And also gives five NS9 memberships.
Penn rocks.
Oh, yeah.
Thank you, Penn.
Also, Shop begins.
Becomes a YouTube member here.
Love that.
Thank you.
Thank you.
And last but not least, definitely.
Definitely not last.
Definitely not least.
Lisa.
Sending this super chat because she's feeling that her Arizona Wildcats are going to beat Michigan tonight.
Please do.
Screw Michigan.
And nice win for the Buccas as well.
Go Arizona.
Go Arizona.
Go Arizona.
And also, go Lisa.
Love you, Lisa.
Love that.
That was a wild game.
It was.
It was.
I'm waiting on them to kick you out there, Jim.
Yeah, it was.
It was a lot of fun.
I was hoping I wasn't making a mistake by, leaving while waking up at 2.30 in the morning yesterday to drive here for these two games.
And it turned out it wasn't.
It was.
It was a good decision.
It was a good decision.
And for the record, your Pittsburgh Pirates are now plus 4,500 to win the World Series through FanDuel.
So.
I still love the odds here, guys.
Still love them.
Yeah.
I'm all about that.
I'm not quite there yet.
But, hey, you never know.
You never know.
You got to believe.
You guys.
You got to believe.
All right, Jim.
You got anything else?
Are you going to the game tomorrow?
No.
I'm heading home after this.
Headed home.
It was a great two days here.
Spent two days in Indianapolis.
Two days in Cincinnati.
Two days here.
So, I've been, yeah, I feel like a groupie at this point.
I got to go home and I got to go home and be on for a bit.
Yeah, I got to go.
I got to go to work.
All right.
Love it.
Jim, have safe travels back.
Thanks for joining me here.
Hope you've enjoyed it.
I've enjoyed watching it through you.
I wish I could have been there with you.
But we'll catch a game together soon.
Very soon.
April 18th.
April 18th.
Tailgate.
Make sure you haven't gotten tickets yet.
We've got not many tickets remaining.
But if you want to sit with us, get your tickets.
We've got the link.
I don't know if it's in the description of the video.
I hope it is.
But if the link's down there, click on it.
It's like $40 for a ticket.
And it gives you $10 in loaded value.
You get to sit with all of us.
And then we're doing a photo on the field after the game.
Yep.
Love it.
Make sure to do all that.
Check out the bio here.
And also, real quick, shout out to Sean Hooper.
Hoist the cone.
Hoist it.
Bucko's go for a sweep tomorrow.
We'll be back with you again with another postgame.
I'm on.
I believe it's Doug with me.
Hopefully, we're giving away more sandwiches.
We'll go ahead and get out of here.
Hoist the cone.
Peace out.
All right.
That wraps up this episode of North Shore Nine.
Thanks so much for tuning in.
Whether you're listening on the podcast or catching us on YouTube, if you enjoyed the show, please give this video a thumbs up.
And don't forget to hit that subscribe button if you haven't already.
It really helps us grow.
And if you're listening on the podcast, a quick review goes a long way in helping others find the show.
Plus, be sure to tell a friend about us.
There's always room for more here in the NS9 community.
And for those looking to support us a little more, consider joining our Patreon, become an MVP member, and get exclusive perks while helping us continue to bring you more of the Pirates content you love.
Thanks again for all your support, and Let's Go Bucs.
Comments· 0
Should Carmen Mlodzinski stay in the rotation instead of moving to the bullpen?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.