◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
The Pirates are still searching for their first win of the 2026 season, but there were at least some encouraging signs in Saturday’s extra-inning loss to the Mets. On this NS9 Postgame Show, Tyler and Nathan break down a game that felt frustrating at times but also showed glimpses of what this team could be when things start clicking.
The biggest positive was Mitch Keller, who delivered exactly what the Pirates needed. He worked efficiently through six strong innings, keeping a talented Mets lineup off the board and giving the Pirates a chance to win. It’s the type of outing that should set the tone for this rotation moving forward.
Offensively, the story was a bit more complicated. The Pirates collected plenty of hits and consistently put runners on base, but couldn’t come through in key moments. As Tyler and Nathan discuss, that’s the difference between a win and a loss in games like this. The opportunities were there — they just didn’t capitalize.
There were still some bright spots beyond Keller, including a strong showing from Jake Mangum, who impressed both at the plate and in the field. The guys also dive into lineup decisions, bullpen usage, and a few key moments that ultimately swung the game.
It’s only game two, and while the record isn’t where they want it to be, there’s still plenty to build on from this one.
Comments· 0
The Debate
Should Don Kelly have pinch-hit Spencer Horwitz for Nick Yorke in extra innings?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.
With Tyler Sweeney and Nathan Osler.
Chapters
Key takeaways
1
Hunter Barco shouldn't have pitched the 10th at all. The host would have gone to Urquidy and said the writing was on the wall once Barco came in.
2
Nick Gonzales is not a five-hitter for this team. Sac bunting with your No. 5 hitter, no outs and two on, was the wrong call.
3
Don Kelly had to get Spencer Horwitz, 'your best hitter last year,' an at-bat in extras instead of letting Nick Yorke hit with runners on.
4
Jake Mangum can play every day, but he fits better as a fourth outfielder and late-game sub because he doesn't hit for power. His hits are mostly singles and infield hits.
5
Gregory Soto has been fine so far, but his walks will blow up on him and he'll lose some important games because of them.
This is the North Shore Nine podcast presented by FanDuel.
I'm Tyler, with me is Nathan.
Nathan, what's going on our first post-game show together ever?
Yeah.
Our second podcast together.
That sucked, brother.
That sucked.
It's not opening weekend for the Pirates without getting walked off on every year, isn't it?
Yeah.
The Mets beat the Pirates 42 today.
Lou Bob hits a walk-off three-run home run.
That was a tough one.
Game two, and it's already a tough one.
Yeah, especially with tomorrow, which you guys will talk about tomorrow, but it's a Carmen Mlodzinski, one of those starts where it's like, is he a starter?
We were talking about either would you rather have him or Triolo lead off.
I think he's going to play against lefties, unlike Oneil Cruz.
I don't think Cruz was benched because there was the whole argument.
Was Cruz benched because of the first game?
I don't think that's.
I think it's because you're playing a lefty.
Cruz pinch hit today.
If he was benched, he would not be hitting in a situation.
I don't think Cruz plays today if he was actually benched.
I agree.
There was a little bit of discussion there about whether this was a benching or.
Don Kelly did say before the game that it was a planned day off or just a planned spot where they weren't going to play him.
A chance to get Nick Yorke in the lineup and Mangum in the lineup.
I do think there's something to be said that the way he played on Thursday probably didn't help the cause.
Like if he would have came out and homered twice.
I don't know if they would have sat him on the bench today.
Yeah, it's interesting.
But like back to Mangum for a second.
I'm intrigued with what he can do.
I don't.
He's one of those players where it's like, is he going to replicate what he did in Tampa?
And he's another one of these guys I see a lot of people argue about on social media.
Is he good enough to be this everyday guy?
I think he can.
But I think the fourth outfield spot just suits him a little better because like he doesn't have that power.
He's not going to give you a lot of pop.
It's going to be a lot of singles.
If you look at his like savant chart last year, it was a lot of infield hits.
It's actually interesting to look at, but he has those traits where it's like, Oh, I want this guy playing every day.
So I don't know.
I look at Jake Mangum like that spark plug type of thing, that type of a player we talked about at all spring.
He's one of those like scrappy guys you just want to root for.
And it's going to be interesting to see what they do with Mangum this year.
He's going to play.
I think a lot every, like he might be one of those guys to come in late in the games and take over for say Cruz.
If he's not hitting certain days.
Oh, her.
And maybe if you want to move him to first mid game, take Horwitz out and Mangum goes to the outfielder.
You shift that around.
That's the role I see Mangum doing right now.
So it's interesting.
It was a solid debut.
It was also nice to see Ozuna get that hit in extras.
I wish like, I wish if it was Mangum on first and not Reynolds, I think Mangum scores on that, but it's one of those things like, do you send Reynolds?
I wouldn't have sent Reynolds because he was going to be out by a mile.
And that's another thing I saw people arguing on social media is like, you should have sent Reynolds.
I'm like, he was going to be out and then we'd be yelling about that.
So yeah, I would not have sent Reynolds there.
I think that was the right call there.
There was another situation as we jump ahead here in the game.
The 10th inning.
Pirates did get on the board there the first run of the game.
And then of course the Mets score as well because it's extra innings in the Manfred role just allows both teams.
They might as well just spot them a run in that extra inning.
Like this Manfred role.
Everybody just scores.
Yeah.
But both teams score there in the 10th and the 11th there.
And I would rather have Horwitz hit in a situation like that rather than Nick Yorke in extra innings with runners on base.
So it's going, it's one of those things.
It's a, it's a yucky loss to have only in game two.
I'd rat like if we, if this was a game, if this happens again, like I wish this would have happened like middle of the year when there isn't like as much attention and there's not as much like focus on like, Oh, this isn't all happening now.
It's like, Oh, this is, this is like the Marlins.
Series last year.
It's like, Oh, we're getting this all out of our, what's going on?
Like, I think in that series one, there's like two walk-offs in like four games or is it three walk-offs?
I've tried to block out that entire series from my brain.
I think it felt like a lot.
It felt like a lot, but yeah, it sucks with you.
Like it, if everything gets put under a microscope at this point of the season, like if this was June, I don't think I would be complaining about anything that happened today.
It would have just been a stupid baseball game that they lost.
I'd probably be complaining on me, but it would, it would be smaller complaints.
Like I would just be mentioning like, why is Nick Yorke hitting an extra innings?
And then I'd probably move on and go get them tomorrow.
It's March.
What is it?
28th.
I don't even know what day it is anymore.
It is March 28th.
Yeah.
March 28th.
So everything that happens is just getting put under a microscope and it's going to keep doing that until they, especially until they get on the board here with a win.
Yeah, I, my thing with this team right now, I knew coming into this year, we were going to be tested with our patients with defense and pitching in the bullpen.
And in the first two games, we have seen defense come to question.
We saw it two days ago with Cruz, a couple of bad throws by Reynolds to home.
We didn't, it's not really worth talking about, but I didn't think like the one that got just by Jerry Trillo at shortstop.
It's like, do you think he could have got that?
If he got a better jump, it's like, that was an interesting one.
Extra.
I think it was an extra innings.
It was.
Yeah.
The only thing about that one, I think would probably be, I don't know where he's getting an out anyhow.
Yeah, that is true.
It was a tough play.
But before we get to more of the good stuff to happen today, basically Mitch Keller.
Yeah.
Let's hear from Cody, who tells you about delicious IQ bars.
This episode is brought to you by IQ bar, our exclusive snack hydration and sponsor.
IQ bar protein bars, IQ mix hydration mixes, and IQ Joe mushroom coffees are the delicious, low sugar, brain and body fuel you need to win your day.
The ultimate sampler pack is a great way for you to try all IQ bar products and flavors.
You get nine IQ bars, eight IQ mix sticks, and four IQ Joe sticks.
All IQ bar products are clean label certified and entirely free from gluten, dairy, soy, GMOs, and artificial ingredients.
With over 20,000 five-star reviews and counting, more people than ever are fueling their lifestyles with IQ bars, brain and body boosting bars, hydration mixes, and mushroom coffees.
The ultimate sampler pack includes all three.
My personal favorites so far have been the almond butter chip and the iced tea lemonade hydration mix.
It's just really full of flavor.
I love starting my day with it, and I couldn't imagine starting my day with anything else other than IQ bar products.
Right now, IQ bar is offering our podcast listeners 20% off all IQ bar products, including the ultimate sampler pack, plus free shipping.
To get your 20% off, text MLB to 64000.
That's MLB 64000.
Message and data rates may apply.
See terms for details.
6400.
64000.
I love that ad.
That was great.
But let's talk about some positive things from the day.
And really, that is Mitch Keller, who just continues to throw quality start after quality start.
Really, just from the jump today, I thought he was pretty good.
I was a little concerned in the first inning there.
It looked like the velocity might be down a little bit.
I think he was still down a touch throughout the day, but with the weather, I'm not too worried about that.
He was really good and really efficient.
Really good.
Yeah, I liked what I saw about, I brought it up at the beginning of the show, like Mitch Keller did his job.
And the job I wanted him to do this game, especially after game one, was give this team innings and give this bullpen a rest.
Because we saw game one, you basically had to use almost every single pitcher that was a part of this bullpen.
Because you got a shocking start out of Paul Skenes.
And I think despite anything else that happens, like you were not getting a lot of innings out of Paul Skenes in game one.
The way, based off how things looked early.
But Keller gave them six innings.
I wanted five or six.
He gave them six and he probably could have went seven, possibly.
I think maybe what went into the decision to take him out is the play that Mangum made to save him right there.
That was a hard hit ball.
And it was like they were, the Mets were starting to make harder contact in that inning against Mitch Keller.
So it was one of those things like maybe they are starting to figure him out finally.
Yeah, I think that's a good point of what you just mentioned in the sixth inning, because he struck out Alvarez to start the sixth.
Lindor hit a rock at 106.5.
Soto singled after that at 107.
And I know that's, those aren't easy guys to get out and they're going to hit the ball hard pretty often.
But then Bo Bichette squared him up at 97.
So I think you might be onto something there as well.
It probably was a combination of not wanting to really push him too far with his first start of the year.
And also, yeah, the Mets were starting to tag him a little bit there.
Yeah.
He only had 77 pitches also.
So he didn't even hit 80 pitches today.
Like you said, it could be just because like cold weather could be what I said about hard contact, or it could just be like, maybe that was the plan.
If he got through six clean innings just to preserve him, because it is his first start of the year.
You don't want him going out there and like hurting himself over working today because the bullpen behind him, besides all the walks, did their job until the walk off, basically like Lawrence struggle, but immediately got the two Ks.
Soto was able to finish that inning.
Dennis Santana kept it where it was.
And then Barco, it is what it is.
But I want to ask you about your guy, Gregory Soto.
I know this is someone that you've been like, I don't know about using that money on Soto.
I've liked what I've seen out of him these first two games.
No, I don't really have many complaints about him so far.
He's been pretty much what you think he would be, though.
It's a little bit erratic.
He throws a lot of balls.
It's going to blow up on him here at some point.
And he's going to lose some important games, probably, because he walks too many people.
But so far, so good out of him.
he came in on a tough spot today with Lawrence Sowing getting through two-thirds of an inning and really not looking very good.
But Soto came in, cleaned that up.
He's looked good so far.
I'm just waiting on the other shoe to drop.
Yeah, and you brought up Justin Lawrence, too.
Like, I was wondering this in the Discord during the game.
It was crazy.
Like, before his injury last year, Lawrence was practically looked unhittable.
Now he just looks a little wild to start the year.
I don't know.
Like, what's your take on Justin Lawrence so far this season?
I know it's only game two, but it's one of those things where it's like, I don't know.
He looks a little different right now.
Yeah, he just doesn't have command of that sweeper right now.
It's very inconsistent, it looks like.
great movement on it, but he's having a hard time throwing it for a strike.
And when he has a hard time throwing it for a strike, he's in trouble because he's the type of reliever that loves to spam that pitch.
Yeah.
Am I worried about him going forward?
Not necessarily, but he's got to figure this out pretty quickly because he's a very important middle relief part of this team.
Yeah, this bullpen has been the question, I think, for a lot of people.
Some people think it's going to be a strength.
A lot of people think it might be a weakness.
And right now, too many walks.
Like, the whole end of this game, walks will haunt.
And we are clearly seeing that right now.
Like, two walks for Lawrence, one walk for Soto, one walk for Santana, one walk for Barco.
You can't have that, especially out of the bullpen.
I can understand maybe one or two walks from your starting pitcher.
Keller didn't have any today.
Did good with that.
Like, even Skenes on the opening day had a couple walks in that first inning.
It's one of those things, like, I hope this pitching staff gets it all out of their system and they can play, like, some clean baseball tomorrow and salvage a win before they head to Cincinnati.
Because it's early, but that might be a big series already in Cincinnati.
It may be a hole.
We saw what happened last year.
They dug themselves in a hole they could not get out of.
Yeah.
And if you blink, it can happen really quickly.
And it's crazy.
Like, compared to last year's team, this team could easily get themselves out of that hole.
It's a way better offense.
But it just stinks seeing this hole like, we've seen it before.
The hole is, like, starting to be dug.
They got a little spoon out getting ready to start digging.
But, yeah, it's a frustrating loss.
It really is.
It sucks that Luis Robert is the one that hit the home run after this offseason.
Everyone's like, oh, maybe we're trading for Luis Robert.
I wish we did.
So, this did not happen today.
But, yeah, get it out of their system.
Hopefully, Sunday is a lot better.
Well, I'm on the show today.
So, naturally, it was going to be a painful extra inning loss.
The only thing this game was missing was a rain delay.
Oh, jeez.
So, you might want to avoid shows with me, Nathan.
Well, it's funny.
I opened up StreamYard to get ready to go when Barco had the bases loaded in the 10th.
And I was like, oh, here we go.
Right when I hit the link to join, Barco gets out of it.
I was like, oh, I'll turn off StreamYard.
And then, immediately, Luis Robert, Jr., a couple minutes later, teaches me, you're going live.
Yeah, I was up and down the steps probably three or four times today.
We'll see how he works as a starter in round two of that.
Well, actually, like round three of that, I guess.
Here's a question before we go.
Mm-hmm.
The hypothesis many have had with Mlodzinski was Barco was going to be his backup.
It's José Urquidy, isn't it?
Probably.
Yeah, if he didn't throw today, it's possible.
So, tomorrow, I'm expecting Mlodzinski Urquidy in action, back-to-back.
Or, hey, maybe they don't, maybe they're not going to have a bulk guy with Mlodzinski.
I want Carmen to prove me wrong so much.
I hope he goes out there and just owns the Mets.
You know what you should do?
Jump on FanDuel and take it, plus 144 for the Buccos money line tomorrow.
Oh, yeah.
It sucks.
Tough loss.
Move on.
Yep.
Appreciate all you guys hanging out with us.
We'll be back with you tomorrow for another post-game show, hopefully giving out some sandwiches from Primanti Brothers.
Nathan, any last words?
I guess my final words are it's only game two, but I can't keep saying that forever.
It'll be like game 45 and be like, it's only game 45.
But, yeah, it's only the second game of the year.
It sucks.
The Mets are a team that is loaded with talent.
Soto, Lindor, Bo Bichette, Jorge Polanco, almost a Pittsburgh pirate, by the way.
It's one of those things.
It stings, especially in walk-off fashion, especially since they got walked off on, like, by the Marlins a couple times last year on opening weekend.
Hopefully, they're playing a lot better baseball tomorrow and maybe against the Reds, too, so they can go into PNC Park, maybe with a winning record around this time next week.
So, we'll see.
Hey, just save one here and then sweep the Reds.
It'll be fine.
Yeah, you got skeins against the Reds, at least.
All right, we're out of here, people.
Make sure to like, subscribe, stay tuned with us all year.
Gonna be a fun one.
Peace out, Red Scouts.
See ya.
All right, that wraps up this episode of North Shore Nine.
Thanks so much for tuning in.
Whether you're listening on the podcast or catching us on YouTube, if you enjoyed the show, please give this video a thumbs up, and don't forget to hit that subscribe button if you haven't already.
It really helps us grow.
And if you're listening on the podcast, a quick review goes a long way in helping others find the show.
Plus, be sure to tell a friend about us.
There's always room for more here in the NS9 community.
And for those looking to support us a little more, consider joining our Patreon, become an MVP member, and get exclusive perks while helping us continue to bring you more of the Pirates content you love.
Thanks again for all your support, and let's go Bucs.
Comments· 0
Should Don Kelly have pinch-hit Spencer Horwitz for Nick Yorke in extra innings?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.