◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
The Pirates fell 5-1 in Texas, but there was still plenty to unpack on the NS9 Postgame Show Powered by Primanti Bros. DiNardo and Doug, who was live from Globe Life Field, break down Carmen Mlodzinski’s tough night, the turning-point miscue involving Nick Yorke, and the Oneil Cruz blast that nearly flipped the game. It’s a level-headed look at a frustrating loss and the bigger picture around this team. Watch or listen now on North Shore Nine. And here’s my three takeaways from this dud.
Mlod Struggles with Third Time Through the Order Again
Carmen Mlodzinski has pitched well this season as a starter, he had a 1.77 ERA coming into Tuesday night’s game against the Rangers, but what hasn’t changed in his struggles the third time through the order.
Coming into tonight, his opposing OPS was .514 first time through the order, then .690 second time through the order then third time through the order it’s 1.167. Not good. Tonight, Mlod was at 80 pitches after four innings and Don Kelly brought him back out for the 5th inning to face the order for a third time. It did not go well:
And showers for Mlodzinski at that point as he was pulled in favor of Wilber Dotel. Not great. Look everyone in this fan base feels the need on Twitter to give their grand proclamation with every Mlodzinski start so I’m not going to overreact to one rough start. I’m fine with Mlodzinski being the 5th starter right now until Jared Jones comes back, but it’s just been the same old with Mlod when he gets into the order for a third time.
Lowe and Horwitz Injuries Hurt the Lineup
The Pirates have been really healthy so far this season, that’s why it was concerning when Brandon Lowe wasn’t in the lineup for a second straight game and then Spencer Horwitz, who was in the lineup, was scratched late tonight due to a neck injury. Lowe is dealing with some knee discomfort and was apparently available off the bench if needed in this game. With both sidelined, the Pirates offense managed just six hits and couldn’t get much off of Kumar Rocker after a first inning run orchestrated by Oneil Cruz. Rocker is a talented pitcher no question, but he owned a 5.26 ERA in his MLB career coming into this game and the Pirates need to hit a pitcher like that.
The game really could have changed in the 5th inning as after Jake Mangum singled and Konnor Griffin reached on an error, Cruz came to bat and barreled one to deep center field that looked like it was gone. And it should have been, but Evan Carter makes a great catch leaping up at the right moment to reach over the wall and rob Cruz of a 3-run homer. That was a deflating punch to the gut and then in the bottom of the inning, the Rangers added on off Mlod. Game was over right there.
Nice Night from the Pen
One positive in this game was the bullpen pitched well with 3.2 scoreless innings with four strikeouts and just two hits allowed. And it wasn’t just the back end of the bullpen this time. Dotel made his second MLB appearance and kept the Rangers off the board despite three walks. Justin Lawrence worked a hitless frame with two strikeouts and Evan Sisk struck out two as well in a scoreless inning of work. It’s nice to see those three get the job done on a night where the Pirates didn’t have to burn any of the back end of the pen this time.
Comments· 0
The Debate
Does one bad start in Texas change your mind on Carmen Mlodzinski: rotation or bullpen?
From Doug Ford’s take on the show
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.
With Doug Ford.
Chapters
Key takeaways
1
In a take he expects to be unpopular, Doug says this start doesn't prove Mlodzinski belongs in the bullpen. He gave up two runs in the second inning, so he'd have struggled as a long reliever too. It wasn't a third-time-through-the-order problem. He just didn't have it.
Doug Ford
2
Oneil Cruz belongs in the leadoff spot. He gets on base and makes things happen, like today's hit, steal and run scored in the first inning.
Doug Ford
3
Every Pirates starter will keep them in games, so this team won't have long losing streaks.
Doug Ford
4
Doug still believes Justin Lawrence can be a lights-out 8th/9th-inning weapon if he harnesses his stuff. He calls today's scoreless inning with two strikeouts a nice first step.
Doug Ford
5
Cruz's mental lapses are gone and he's making the basic plays at shortstop and center. Doug warns that last year he also looked great until May, so no proclamations until June or July.
so something's going to have to happen when that occurs.
Doug Ford
So, but Carmen's looking pretty good.
Doug Ford
He's really good all year.
Doug Ford
And even today, he wasn't as bad.
Doug Ford
Jotel throws a – throws a pitch, smashes a – a smash to York.
Doug Ford
York fields the ball.
Doug Ford
And I'm sitting behind third-by-side.
Doug Ford
he is stuck in the web.
Doug Ford
There is nothing he could do.
Doug Ford
If he's able to field that, Carmen gets out with maybe three innings – or three runs given up instead of – or, like, maybe four.
Doug Ford
But whatever.
Doug Ford
It would have been four, but by the way, yeah.
Doug Ford
Yeah.
Doug Ford
So, I haven't – I hate being that guy.
Doug Ford
I don't want to be the guy that after one bad start, one bad game, four bad at-bats, whatever, is ready to write somebody off.
Doug Ford
He's been very good.
Doug Ford
He had an off start.
Doug Ford
This team, Texas, is not a terrible team.
Doug Ford
They got some really good errors.
Doug Ford
It's, let's see what he does next time.
Doug Ford
Let's let it play out.
Doug Ford
he just didn't have it tonight.
Doug Ford
Paul Skeets didn't have it on day one.
Doug Ford
Keller didn't have it to start to go.
Doug Ford
it happens.
Doug Ford
It's part of baseball.
Doug Ford
No one's going to be perfect for 32 starts.
Doug Ford
and that's why I want to bring this up because I think a lot of people can look at this start and say, hey, this is why Carmen Mijinsky should have belonged in the rotation.
Doug Ford
This is why Carmen Mijinsky should be in the bullpen.
Doug Ford
And, Doug, I want to say something that's probably going to be unpopular to the listeners and people in the chat right now.
Doug Ford
I don't look at this game and say that this is why he doesn't belong in the rotation.
Doug Ford
I look at this game and say, Carmen didn't have it tonight.
I'll no more write him off at the start than I will annoy him after his last start when he went six spectacular innings, right?
Doug Ford
And he can't do it start to start.
Doug Ford
Pitch to pitch is practically what we're doing.
Doug Ford
Yes, there's always going to be an argument that Carmen Paginski will be more valuable to the bullpen, but if he can succeed, like he did last time, that's a very good argument to be a starter, right?
Doug Ford
So, again, let it unfold.
Doug Ford
Let's see now.
Doug Ford
Let's see what happens when Jones comes back.
Doug Ford
Let's see what happens over the next month or so.
Doug Ford
give the chance, to get more information, not do the small sample size thing.
Doug Ford
It's certainly one game, right?
Doug Ford
He's pitched really well this year.
Doug Ford
He's been a very effective, and I don't know who the fifth starter is, but, he's earned it in rotation or anything.
Doug Ford
Whatever it is, he's been very efficient.
Doug Ford
He came in with a 1.77 ERA.
Doug Ford
So, he looked really good.
Doug Ford
I'll give him a lot more room before I run him off in the bullpen.
Doug Ford
And I'm one of the ones that was against him.
Doug Ford
Like, I want him in the bullpen.
Doug Ford
he's so great at the bullpen.
Doug Ford
But if he can start as well, if he can be as good as the starter, he's a valuable man.
Doug Ford
Right.
Doug Ford
And that's a good point because I'm with you.
Doug Ford
I was heading into this year saying I want to see him in the bullpen.
Doug Ford
Let's try to get someone else.
Doug Ford
I was really hoping that, Urquidy would take it to the fifth spot.
Doug Ford
to have Carmen in this.
Doug Ford
And, like Jim mentions here in the chat, which, again, like I fully agree with.
Doug Ford
Like, just because he's better in the pen doesn't mean he doesn't belong or, shouldn't be in the rotation.
Doug Ford
Because, again, like if you're putting him in the bullpen, which you can make a case for if you want to, who is this team's fifth starter?
Doug Ford
Who is it?
Doug Ford
Who is this team's fifth starter right now?
Doug Ford
It's, right?
Doug Ford
So, like, again, like they are 4-1 in Carmen Mlodzinski's starts right now.
Doug Ford
Today, he just didn't have it.
Doug Ford
And, like you mentioned, like it just is what it is.
Doug Ford
It's one start in the new revamp year of Carmen Mlodzinski as a starter.
Doug Ford
And so far we've had good, really, quality outings where they've won every game.
Doug Ford
And then we've had today where he just didn't have it.
Doug Ford
And, again, as I want to point out, he wasn't going to have it if he was a long reliever today.
Doug Ford
he's giving up two runs in this second inning of his long relief.
Doug Ford
This wasn't a failing of him as a guy who can't go long enough or deep enough, right?
Doug Ford
He gave up those runs in the second inning, right?
Doug Ford
Then he gave up the other runs in the fourth or fifth, right?
Doug Ford
it had nothing to do with seeing a guy for a third time.
Doug Ford
And, as we've said several times already, he just didn't have it today.
Doug Ford
He wasn't sharp.
Doug Ford
and look at him, watch his podcast.
Doug Ford
I'm not sharp right now.
Doug Ford
Like, you have all of our winners.
Doug Ford
I can't throw a complete thing every time.
Doug Ford
Come on.
Doug Ford
Exactly.
Doug Ford
Exactly, Doug.
Doug Ford
Right?
Doug Ford
Tell these people.
Doug Ford
You know what?
Doug Ford
Exactly.
Doug Ford
He was, he was throwing early on.
Doug Ford
He was throwing the splitter.
Doug Ford
I'm sorry.
Doug Ford
The splitter was working.
Doug Ford
Although I was throwing the sink a little more.
Doug Ford
He got away from it then fed it a little bit more as well.
Doug Ford
But, yeah, like, it just seemed like, he wasn't doing too much with the sinker today.
Doug Ford
The splitter looked pretty good.
Doug Ford
But, yeah, they were hitting off him pretty hard.
Doug Ford
And that's the other thing I want to point out here as well.
Doug Ford
Average exit velocity.
Doug Ford
12 battered events.
Doug Ford
Average exit velocity against Carmen.
Doug Ford
100.3.
Doug Ford
Doug.
Doug Ford
What?
Doug Ford
Exit velocity.
Doug Ford
You know what a believer I am in exit velocity.
Doug Ford
Yes, absolutely.
Doug Ford
Yeah, they were squaring him up.
Doug Ford
They were hitting the ball hard.
Doug Ford
One more time.
Doug Ford
He just didn't have it today.
Doug Ford
So, I think that's all it was.
Doug Ford
I can hardly wait until his next start.
Doug Ford
Yeah.
Doug Ford
Yeah, absolutely.
Doug Ford
So, again, like, he was getting hit very hard.
Doug Ford
They were squaring up.
Doug Ford
They were seeing him well.
Doug Ford
And, again, it just is what it is.
Doug Ford
He didn't have it.
Doug Ford
And so hard, like you mentioned, Doug, they were hitting him so hard that he comes out of the game.
I still quite haven't really formed much of an opinion on him.
Doug Ford
He seems innocuous.
Doug Ford
But, got out of it today.
Doug Ford
Did his job.
Doug Ford
Yeah, so, again, offense wasn't there.
Doug Ford
Pitching was meh, right?
Doug Ford
But, again, like, I do want to talk about Oneil Cruz.
Doug Ford
We talked about, the hit he did have, the almost home run, the stolen base, the catalyst.
Doug Ford
Doug, he also had a pretty solid play in the outfield today.
Doug Ford
like, I think we've been seeing him play better.
Doug Ford
it's not been, like, super flashy.
Doug Ford
But he has been making the plays needed, right?
Doug Ford
That's something that has escaped him sometimes.
Doug Ford
But there was a moment today.
Doug Ford
Now, obviously, it was a race.
Doug Ford
It didn't really matter because hits kept coming and that scored guys.
Doug Ford
But he eliminated a run by, cutting off, getting to a ball quick enough, getting that ball rifled in, to Konnor Griffin to prevent a guy from rounding third to score.
Doug Ford
if he doesn't cut off that ball, if he doesn't get there quick enough to make that play, there's a run that scored on Carmen.
Doug Ford
Again, it happened because more hits happened afterwards.
Doug Ford
But Ono had a good game, I thought.
Doug Ford
And, again, defensively, like, he had a good defensive play or defensive game today.
Doug Ford
But I feel like that's something that he has been doing a little bit more of.
Doug Ford
what was your take on him seeing him?
Doug Ford
what our biggest frustration with Oneil Cruz has been mental lapses, right?
Doug Ford
That's really what it's been.
Doug Ford
It's that he's not seemed engaged.
Doug Ford
He doesn't run it out to first base.
Doug Ford
Or, a ball gets behind him and he doesn't charge after it, even though there's someone there backing him up, that thing.
Doug Ford
And we haven't seen any of that since the first, the bottom of the first in New York.
Doug Ford
He's making the basic plays.
Doug Ford
For the most part, seems to be throwing to the right base.
Doug Ford
I still remember that where he cut in front of Jake Mangum and picked it up and, made that perfect throw that Konnor Griffin then threw in for the relay and great throw,
Doug Ford
getting the guy out at home, that thing.
Doug Ford
Yeah, he looks pretty good.
Doug Ford
he's making the plays like, he's, what?
Doug Ford
At both shortstop and centerfield, we've been frustrated that he just hasn't made the simple, basic, fundamental play.
Doug Ford
And he's been doing that for most of this season now.
Doug Ford
He seems engaged.
Doug Ford
He seems focused.
Doug Ford
And that's always been the legitimate concern about him.
Doug Ford
I've never thought he was lazy like a lot of people like to do.
Doug Ford
So, yeah, it's encouraging.
Doug Ford
Now, remember, last year up until about May 10th or so or May 20th, he was also all of these things.
Doug Ford
again, our tailgate last year was the third week of May.
Doug Ford
And he had his 10th home run in that series, you know.
Doug Ford
Right.
Doug Ford
And so, we'll see.
Doug Ford
Like, no declarations or proclamations, at least until sometime in June or July.
Doug Ford
But so far, so good.
Doug Ford
And what else can we ask for?
Doug Ford
There's, he's making the plays.
Doug Ford
He's producing.
Doug Ford
He's a big part of why we are where we are in the standings and record-wise and run producing.
Doug Ford
Yeah.
Doug Ford
100%.
Doug Ford
Like I said, this game, there's not a whole lot to really talk about.
Doug Ford
No one.
Doug Ford
not much really happened.
Doug Ford
It wasn't good performances.
Doug Ford
But, again, I do want to highlight Oneil Cruz because, again, what he did do.
Doug Ford
And also here, he did have one strikeout.
Doug Ford
It was against the lefty.
Doug Ford
It was an eight-pitch at bat.
Doug Ford
he fouled off three.
Doug Ford
Again, it's a strikeout, right?
Doug Ford
you don't want to see strikeouts, but he has been facing lefties better.
Doug Ford
It was late in the game.
Doug Ford
The lefty came up to face him.
Doug Ford
And I thought it was a really good at bat still.
Doug Ford
Right.
Doug Ford
So, again, like, to your point.
Doug Ford
Much different.
Doug Ford
Yeah.
Doug Ford
Much different than what he's done in the past.
Doug Ford
Focused.
Doug Ford
Ono has looked every bit of, as I dub, like the catalyst.
Doug Ford
he's hitting for a decent average right now.
Doug Ford
He's getting on base.
Doug Ford
He's still on bases.
Doug Ford
He's hitting for power, right?
Doug Ford
He has his 10th stolen base on the year.
Doug Ford
As you mentioned, you bet him on, leading.
Doug Ford
He is leading right now.
Doug Ford
He's tied with Jose Ramirez for the most in baseball.
Doug Ford
He has six home runs.
Doug Ford
Almost had his seventh tonight.
Doug Ford
we see him doing a lot of things offensively.
Doug Ford
You see him doing good things on the base pass.
Doug Ford
You're now seeing him do a lot better defensively.
Doug Ford
He's not going to win a gold glove out there.
Doug Ford
It's not going to happen.
Doug Ford
But he's progressively getting better.
Doug Ford
And he just seems like he's in the game more often than others.
Doug Ford
Right.
Doug Ford
He's not a liability out there right now.
Doug Ford
Right.
Doug Ford
And that was a huge concern.
Doug Ford
So, yeah.
Doug Ford
And he's contributing in all facets of the game.
Doug Ford
Like I said, that was an eight-pitch strikeout.
Doug Ford
That happens.
Doug Ford
But, again, it was a good at bat.
Doug Ford
last year it was, one, two, three a lot of times.
Doug Ford
he was a three-pitch outcome guy.
Doug Ford
A lot.
Doug Ford
Especially from whenever Sheldon got mercifully let go.
Doug Ford
So, yeah.
Doug Ford
And also, like, it was three pitches where he goes up there and doesn't swing at them.
Doug Ford
Yeah.
Doug Ford
He just watched them go by.
Doug Ford
Right.
Doug Ford
Looking at, third strikes a lot.
Doug Ford
it just seemed like he didn't want to be there.
Doug Ford
And that's not the case this year.
Doug Ford
So, it's very encouraging.
Doug Ford
Again, it's still April.
Doug Ford
but, I sometimes often think that we shouldn't do any post-games until June 1st.
Doug Ford
so.
Doug Ford
Sorry, for Manny's.
Doug Ford
Sorry, people.
Doug Ford
No sandwiches until June 1st.
Doug Ford
No.
Doug Ford
You're a man of the people.
Doug Ford
I am a man of the people, but I feel like such a dope, I don't like this, three games in saying, this guy's a bust, and I don't do that.
Doug Ford
No, and I don't do that, but, I'm responding to it often in the chat.
Doug Ford
Get this guy out of here.
Doug Ford
He shouldn't be on my softball team.
Doug Ford
So, and to say, I don't want to come out and annoy anybody as, the second coming of Dave Parker.
Doug Ford
There you go.
Doug Ford
Yeah, so, other than that, I really don't have too much to talk about with this game.
Doug Ford
I don't know.
Doug Ford
Again, you were there.
Doug Ford
First off, also, this was the series where Cutch comes back.
Doug Ford
He didn't get in.
Doug Ford
They're facing all righties.
Doug Ford
I doubt he's ever going to start.
Doug Ford
So far, no Cutch, but did you see him pregame at all?
Doug Ford
I didn't even see him.
Doug Ford
It seems like he was keeping low profile.
Doug Ford
Of course, I was, searching for Brandon Lowe.
Doug Ford
But, that mystery was solved.
Doug Ford
So, after that, I just sat back and tried to enjoy the game.
Doug Ford
But I didn't see Cutch standing up on the railing or anything.
Doug Ford
I was looking for him.
Doug Ford
There was quite a few Cutch jerseys here.
Doug Ford
Cutch Pirates jerseys.
Doug Ford
But, yeah, there was some good amount of Pirates fans in attendance.
Doug Ford
Yeah.
Doug Ford
Well, there you have it.
Doug Ford
Well, like you mentioned, tomorrow it's Ashcraft going against Leiter.
Doug Ford
That's also, I think, what's intriguing about this series.
Doug Ford
Obviously, Cutch is on the other end.
Doug Ford
But then, like, they just faced Kumar Rocker, who stifled their offense.
Doug Ford
Kumar Rocker.
Doug Ford
We all tank for Rocker.
Doug Ford
We know those hashtags, right?
Doug Ford
Much like 2025, Kumar Rocker had his longest start of the year against the Pirates tonight.
Doug Ford
Boom.
Doug Ford
He had never gotten 15 outs in a game this year.
Doug Ford
And guess what?
Doug Ford
The Pirates have, let you get six.
Doug Ford
Doug's always, he's ready for those stats.
Doug Ford
He's ready for the Pirates for the first two stats.
Doug Ford
So, there it is.
Doug Ford
But, yeah, Kumar Rocker was going to be a Pittsburgh Pirate.
Doug Ford
We all know Leiter was going to be a Pittsburgh Pirate.
Doug Ford
So, again, like, we see Cutch is on the other end.
Doug Ford
On the other end, too, is two guys they're facing that were, just going to be Pittsburgh Pirates.
So, right now, on FanDuel, the Pirates, both teams actually are both minus 108 money line.
Doug Ford
So, yeah, there's that.
Doug Ford
But, again, it is Ashcraft versus Leiter.
Doug Ford
And, yes, Ashcraft, I know he didn't have the best start his last time out.
Doug Ford
Obviously, that was also partly on the team behind him.
Doug Ford
But he's looked every bit.
Doug Ford
Like you said, you're confident in every pitcher going out there to face whoever.
Doug Ford
And Ashcraft has been one of the better ones in baseball, not alone just Pittsburgh Pirates.
Doug Ford
Yeah, he's already got a one-four.
Doug Ford
what, three, four starts in?
Doug Ford
That's crazy.
Doug Ford
Mm-hmm.
Doug Ford
Yep.
Doug Ford
Yeah.
Doug Ford
So, there's tomorrow's matchup.
Doug Ford
You'll be at the game again, I believe.
Doug Ford
Yes, sir.
Doug Ford
Yeah, I'm planning on it.
Doug Ford
We'll see.
Doug Ford
Some really bad weather here.
Doug Ford
And my son and daughter-in-law are joining me here.
Doug Ford
But I'm expecting to be there.
Doug Ford
We'll see how it goes.
Doug Ford
All right.
Doug Ford
Well, before they kick you out, try to for the third time.
Doug Ford
Let's get out of here.
Doug Ford
We'll be back tomorrow for the post-game show, hopefully with a dub.
Doug Ford
Hopefully with a dub.
Doug Ford
Other than that, I guess, go ahead, like, subscribe, follow along.
Doug Ford
We'll see you guys later.
Doug Ford
Doug?
Doug Ford
Okay.
Doug Ford
Can I quickly say that thank you so much for all of you who came to the tailgate.
Doug Ford
I had so much fun.
Doug Ford
It was a blast.
Doug Ford
The game wasn't great.
Doug Ford
The weather wasn't great.
Doug Ford
But you guys made it a wonderful, very memorable experience.
Doug Ford
And I can hardly wait until the June 13th one.
Doug Ford
Boom.
Doug Ford
Boom.
Doug Ford
Yeah.
Doug Ford
And actually, again, that's a good time.
Doug Ford
Yeah.
Doug Ford
June 13th, we're running it back.
Doug Ford
So, they're going to face the Marlins.
Doug Ford
Come out.
Doug Ford
If you didn't come out the first time, make sure you're coming out for the second time.
Doug Ford
If you did come out for the first time, why not come out again?
Doug Ford
So, we'll see you again on June 13th.
Doug Ford
Tailgate versus the state of Florida.
Doug Ford
Tailgate hates the state of Florida.
Doug Ford
So, let's go.
Doug Ford
There it is.
Doug Ford
Boom.
Doug Ford
All right.
Doug Ford
We're out of here.
Doug Ford
We'll see you guys later.
Doug Ford
Bye-bye.
Doug Ford
Bye.
Doug Ford
All right.
Doug Ford
That wraps up this episode of North Shore Nine.
Doug Ford
Thanks so much for tuning in.
Doug Ford
Whether you're listening on the podcast or catching us on YouTube, if you enjoyed the show, please give this video a thumbs up.
Doug Ford
And don't forget to hit that subscribe button if you haven't already.
Doug Ford
It really helps us grow.
Doug Ford
And if you're listening on the podcast, a quick review goes a long way in helping others find the show.
Doug Ford
Plus, be sure to tell a friend about us.
Doug Ford
There's always room for more here in the NS9 community.
Doug Ford
And for those looking to support us a little more, consider joining our Patreon, become an MVP member, and get exclusive perks while helping us continue to bring you more of the Pirates content you love.
Comments· 0
Does one bad start in Texas change your mind on Carmen Mlodzinski: rotation or bullpen?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.