◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)◆NEWSPirates, Chas McCormick Agree To Minor League Deal
◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)◆NEWSPirates, Chas McCormick Agree To Minor League Deal
The Pirates’ weekend against the Phillies was bad enough before the Ryan O’Hearn injury added another problem to the pile. On this episode of Bucco Brew, we break down the sweep, the quiet bats, the shaky pitching, the defensive issues, and what the Pirates do now with O’Hearn expected to miss time. Who gets the next opportunity, and how much does this change the lineup?
Watch or listen to the full episode now. Bucco Brew is fueled by De Fer Coffee & Tea. Use promo code NS930 for 30% off online at defer.coffee.
Comments· 0
The Debate
Should the Pirates call up Esmerlyn Valdez over Jhostynxon Garcia to replace the injured Ryan O'Hearn in right field?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.
With Anthony DiNardo and Jim Rosati.
Chapters
Key takeaways
1
Jared Triolo is not the answer in right field. He's on the roster for his glove at third and his ability to cover shortstop, not to play the outfield.
2
Jake Mangum works as a fourth outfielder, defensive replacement and pinch hitter, but he shouldn't be playing every day while Ryan O'Hearn is out.
3
If I'm Ben Cherington, Esmerlyn Valdez meets the team in St. Louis and starts in right field. He's earned it with an approach that looks advanced for a 22-year-old in AAA.
4
Calling up Tyler Callihan would be a bad move. It really means Jake Mangum plays every day for the next four weeks, and Callihan is basically a left-handed version of the Nick Yorke they just optioned.
5
If it isn't a prospect, Ronny Simon makes more sense than Callihan because he's actually producing in AAA. Adding him to the 40-man could also force Justin Lawrence off the roster, and fans would welcome that.
Yo. Welcome to the North Shore Nine Podcast presented by FanDuel. This is NS9 Bucco Brew powered by Defer Coffee and Tea. I'm your host, Anthony DiNardo. And with me, we have Jim Rosati. And Jim, happy Monday.
Happy Monday. It's that we miserable weekend is over.
Yeah. Hopefully it's the last miserable weekend though. That's the thing.
Yeah.
This was bad.
It was really bad. It was definitely their worst. it was, I think it was their worst weekend of the year.
Yeah. Yeah. That's absolutely fair.
Yeah. I feel like typically, especially home with big crowds, like they've performed well on the weekends. It's been like those midweek series that have been getting to them.
This weekend though, that was, that was rough. Starting Friday, like Friday with that just epic meltdown. And then you would, you were hoping for some answer, some response. And you just, you got nothing.
You got nothing out of these guys.
I would have to say it's probably the Mets series. The last, like the worst weekend before this one was probably the Mets series. And that wasn't even like the full weekend. That was also on a Thursday where it started. But still like that game was bad. That series was bad.
They won one of the games. Yeah. Well, yeah, they won one of the games and, but also, things picked back up. Things have been relatively good for this season. the St. Louis Cardinals series is a low point. That was a four game series. Also midweek. Yeah. Bad weekend. Very bad weekend.
And of course it was against the Phillies cross town, cross state air quotes rival. it's not much of rival, but again, it's Pennsylvania. It's Philadelphia. You want to troll them. You want to have good things. And it started looking that way at first on Friday, they jumped out to a big early lead. You thought that game was in the bag.
They ended up losing that in horrible fashion. Thanks to the bullpen. But then Saturday comes and Bubba looks bad. The offense doesn't show up. Sunday comes Paul skein shows up. He gives a five earned in his start. Offense doesn't show up again. Like they just found all kinds of ways to lose every, all three games.
Throwing some bad defense in there. Like everything just looked bad. Yeah, it was, it was a all around bad weekend. Hopefully, skipping town, heading on a plane, going somewhere new, like creating a new setting. Hopefully that resets them a little bit. We'll see. They got St. Louis coming up and then Toronto. So, two teams who, on paper, the Cardinals aren't good, but then you look at the standings and,
and what they've done lately. And they've just been, they've just kept winning. Like ever since that pirate sweep, they just keep winning baseball games. And they're having a few players having really good years. Like Jordan Walker still hasn't cooled off. Like from before.
And yeah, they're figuring out a way to win some ball games. So it was going to be an interesting road trip. They have an opportunity here to bounce back and answer. And they've, to their credit, like every time, every time they've had like that lowest,
lowest of lows this year. And you're like, man, is this going to be the start of, is this, is this when it's over? Right. they've responded. Right. And let's see if they do it this time.
Yeah. That's a good point. that's a word we've used resilient. That's what they've shown. They've might've been, might've taken a little longer than you hoped. you thought maybe a few times in that like Cardinal series, like, okay, this is the time we can make a stop here.
Stop the bleeding. They got swept in four games and they got swept in three games in this one. Like you can't, you can't make the losing streaks prolonged. that's the biggest difference.
You're hoping to see from this year opposed to last year. So let's stop the bleeding. you're going into St. Louis, you're playing the Cardinals. Yeah. the Cardinals, we know they have, but like, it's again, just seeing this, like they're 27 and 19, Jim, the St. Louis Cardinals, the team that once again, you just look past this year, they're going to be the basement dwellers.
They're 27 and 19. they're firmly like in the wild card right now.
Yeah. They just keep, like I said, they just keep winning. I think I saw a graphic the other day. They won like 13 of 18 or something like that.
They're just on a roll. Yeah, they are. They are on a roll. And yeah, the NL central still to this point, May 18th, five teams still all above 500, which is just, it's wild.
There's four American league teams now with, there's more NL central teams with a winning record than AL teams with a winning record on May 18th.
Again, just wild again. And that's why like, it sucks. I know a lot of people, a lot of fans are down on the season and here we go. And it's still, there's still over 500. Like there's still in the thick of things. They are just, they're in a really tough division. it's just wild to think.
It's crazy that they're crazy that they're in fifth place. They're in last place being one game over 500. Yeah.
Now, what is frustrating about this is the fact, coming into this year though, Jim, do we not think there are like in probably between like an 81 to 84, maybe 85 ish win team?
Yeah. I think that's fair. I think all the, most of the projection systems had them around like 82 to 84 wins.
Okay. And not that they couldn't win 87 or such. Right. But like, that's probably safely like where they're going to be.
Like, isn't this the downside, I'm going to say the word downside. Isn't this the downside to having a team that's like that?
You're probably not going to get too far above 500 into the standings. You're probably not going to get too far below.
You're just always going to hang around 500. And what does that mean? It means every week you're back or every week it's over.
And that's like, that's, what's going to be frustrating this year for, and especially I think two things we live in a society now that it's instant gratification.
You can't wait it out. 162 games is just way too long. You don't have the patience for 162 games.
So we're in that culture right now where you don't have the patience to be a baseball fan, which makes it fun and interesting in itself, but also like, is that, yeah, like that's what you're going to be dealing with right now with this pirates baseball team.
There's still a game over 500. They're still on pace for like an 83 win season, which is right where you put them at most people.
Yeah. I made a joke the other day in the, in the game chat that we have in our discord where it's like, I don't know how any of you people are still alive after watching 20 plus 162 games, because it seems like everyone just like lives or dies with every single inning.
Essentially. And it's like, guys, it's not like, it is like these losses count. Right. And I don't want to be misconstrued in saying that like these games don't matter.
They do matter, but there's 162 of them. And you just got to always remember that. I said, it's really frustrating to lose a game, but you can make the playoffs and you're going to lose like last year. The reds made the playoffs and they lost 80 times, right?
You're going to lose a lot of games over the course of the season. And yeah, in the moment they suck, but like take a step back, take a step back.
They're 24 and 23 on May 18th. The season's not over. Like nothing's over. They're very much in it, whatever you want it to be, whether you want it to be a divisional race,
a playoff race, whatever it is, they are in it right now. are they playing good baseball right now? No, but they were playing good baseball last week,
earlier in the earlier in the week. So it's just, it sucks because I think we're all conditioned at this point to have like football brain when we're watching stuff where like everything matters so much. And in baseball, it's just, it just doesn't, it doesn't matter all that much from game to game.
Now you start stacking losses and that's a problem, but yeah, it's frustrating. I know we do post game show. So, we're part of the problem.
I guess you could say like we do instant reactions 162 times a year. but that just it is what it is. Like there's 162 of these. You're going to have bad games. You're going to have bad stretches.
You just got to have more good stretches than you have bad stretches. Right. There it is. That's it. Like in the grand scheme of things,
the best of the best lose 72, that much different from 90. Not really. you have that many games.
You lose 72 times. It feels like you've lost forever. You're it's a 91 season. That's you're in the playoffs. You lost 72 times. Those 72 times you came out saying, Oh my God, we're never going to get there.
This is it's over. So anyways. Yeah. again, fans are great. Y'all can fan however you want. Like I'm not here to tell you how I'm never here to tell you how I'm just, I will offer some perspective on that.
It's there's still, that's, what's going to be frustrating about this team. This team isn't built to be a, like a 90 win team.
They're built to be, they're probably going to be about a low eighties win team. And that means probably about half the time you're losing and half the time you're winning.
And it's not going to be pretty. There'll be moments where it's pretty and there's going to be moments that it's ugly. And that's what we're enduring right now. Right now we're in the ugly. Hopefully now here's the difference.
It's like, again, like they have to stop it. They have to start winning. Okay. Because if you keep losing, then that's not a low eighties win team. That's a mid seventies win team.
And that's the problem. That's how it was like last year. And you're not going to be in a playoff. So anyway, St. Louis is again, they're not big series, but like, this is going to be a big series for them.
It's going to be nice. Like they need to stop. You need to stop the bleeding. They're going to St. Louis is in division, right? Start stacking some wins, start stacking wins against the NL central.
Like you were previously as well. Like they fared well against the NL central, but this is your chance to start climbing back in those NL division, NL central division standings.
And get St. Louis out of there. Like what is St. Louis doing in there? You can do something about that.
Yeah. this is a big series. Cause you can't let, you can't let three games get to four to get to five, to get to six. Like you've got to, you do, you have to turn things around.
And the Cardinals are a team that you're looking up at right now in the standings. And you're already like at the end of the season, you want to be able to look back and say that you won your season series against everyone in your division.
If you do that, you've probably got a pretty good likely hit hood of winning your division and the Cardinals right now, they're Oh, one three against them or Oh, and four, sorry. Oh, and four.
So they've got some making up to do against the St. Louis Cardinals right now. They're three and a half games ahead of them in the standings.
Make up some ground to win two out of three this week in St. Louis.
That would go a long way. and then heading into Toronto with, Bubba schemes and Keller, you hope you can maybe steal a series there too. Right. And just, that's looking ahead, but yes, starting the St. Louis series, like stop the bleeding, pick up a win, figure out a way to win tomorrow, any way possible.
And, start the road trip off strong. Cause yeah, you can't let this continue to slide.
Right. Cardinals with a plus two run different, sorry. Plus three run differential pirates. Now the plus 18 this weekend really killed that, but, that's where we stand.
Cardinals are zeros aren't great.
12 and 11 at home while the pirates are 11 and 10 on the road. So it's unfortunately at the stands right now, or again, take paper away how they've been playing. It's a pretty even matchup, with these. Now they are going to miss Paul Skenes, but ironically enough, Paul Skenes doesn't beat the Cardinals.
So maybe that's a blessing because he's what now own five against them. Yeah. Good point.
So, yeah, he's missing the Cardinal series. So thank God. I don't have that bum here to pitch.
Yeah. I am interested to see how they respond because they've been relatively healthy all year too.
And with the loss of O'Hearn, which, we're going to talk about that, with the loss of O'Hearn, that's like their first main piece that's gone down.
Yeah.
It sucks.
It sucks.
It does.
He's been really good.
He's been really good this year.
Yeah.
He's the steady guy.
again, him and loud and great additions.
LOW.
Now Hearn was in a, like a little mini slump and he turned around.
that's, that was the talk of, how he did turn around.
He turned around a big way and they're still having things come out on the broadcast about conversations with him and he turned around.
And while this conversation would happen, he's out now.
So that sucks.
Cause like he was coming back around and like, again, so take away that little mini slump.
He had loud.
I feel like he's been good, but more on the streakier side, like home runs will come in bunches.
Although those are bad for the past.
Cause like you mentioned there, Owen three, when he has multi home run games, but his offense at times comes in stretches.
I'm sorry.
It comes in streaks where I felt like O'Hearn was just steady Eddie.
they talked about like, didn't know how to ball blocks.
Like, I don't know how to define it.
You just can't.
But when you say professional hitter, people know what you mean.
But he can hit some home runs here and there, but the dude just goes up there and the dude just hits and he's been very steady for this lineup and him being out for possibly four weeks is going to be a bit of a blow.
Yeah, that's, it's a big blow.
and you hope the pirates have some plan here because Saturday and Sunday, you mean Jared was the starting right fielder and it's like, come on guys.
Like this can't be the plan that if one outfielder goes down, your plan, your plan can't just be outfielder, Jared Triolo, Jim, let me introduce you to the Pittsburgh
pirates.
That can be their plan.
Man.
Yeah.
I, they've got to have something up their sleeves.
One of those two would certainly get people excited.
We'll see what we'll see what they do.
And one of those two would absolutely make sense.
It would make sense.
But yeah, we'll see what they do.
Let's talk about some options and such.
before we do, let's tell you a little bit about Defer coffee and tea.
Defer is a family and employee and owned operated business.
They believe that coffee and tea are one of life's simplest and most accessible pleasures.
And when enjoyed thoughtfully, can open your eyes to the here and now they have five locations across the city of Pittsburgh, including their flagship in the heart of Pittsburgh's historic strip district.
Don't forget to stop by Defer's new location downtown on Penn Avenue, right across from the Benidum, grab a cup and fuel up on your walk to PNC park.
Level ordering is available.
Check out the Instagram for more details.
And Jim, why don't you tell everyone how they can save themselves 30%?
Yeah, go to the defer.coffee, D E F E R.coffee, load up your cart, put in promo code NS930.
The one you see over there in the corner below DiNardo and that's nine three zero.
And we'll give you 30% off your entire first order from Defer.
Boom.
There it is.
Good stuff as always.
So yeah, with Ryan O'Hearn out, Jared Tricolo has played back-to-back games in right field now, both games, not pretty defensively.
Like we saw, they had the one diving attempt, which credit to him as not being a right fielder.
That was a good attempt.
He made the diving catch in right field.
The very first time he was in right field, what last year, which was like, oh wow, look at that.
Almost seemed like the same play happened.
He missed it this time, but then he has a throwing error yesterday.
There's a ball between him and Mangum, which it just looked like he wanted no part of it, which is what made Mangum have to go chase it and dive and not even come near it.
Not that this outfield has been good by any means.
I'm not here to try to tell you like, hey, if Tricolo wasn't there and that was round or hurt instead, that ball would have been made.
Probably not.
But regardless, Jared Tricolo is not the answer.
You know why Jared Tricolo needs to be on the team?
Because he plays really good defense at third and he can play shortstop if you need.
That's why he's here.
Not because he can play right field.
Correct.
Well, when I saw him in the lineup on Saturday, I was like, okay, whatever.
Lefty starting pitcher.
They want to load up the lineup with righties.
I get it.
I get it.
You know.
Sunday, though, they went back out and did it again.
I was like this.
Are they going to bring up an outfielder or are we just going to do this the whole time?
Yeah, it's going to be interesting to see what they do here because just based off of the roster as it currently is, you would think that just the next man up is Jake Mangum, right?
And you're going to go Reynolds, Cruz, Mangum in the outfield, in that deployment, Mangum and left, Cruz and center, Reynolds and right.
And that's going to be what you roll with the majority of the time.
Like he's not he's definitely not off to a good start of the year.
He certainly has things that he needs to get under control.
I think he's just fine on your team as a fourth outfield option.
I got a late inning defensive replacement, someone to maybe provide a spark as a pinch hitter here and there.
But I don't think you need to.
Because there's people in here like I like Jake Mangum and take that to the oh, you think Jake Mangum is good.
Please stress how you like Jake Mangum on this team.
Once again, I like Jake Mangum as a fourth outfielder.
I like him getting sparing playing time when the when the time calls for it.
I don't think Jake Mangum needs to be playing every day.
And so far, he hasn't been right.
But with this injury.
You've got to do something here because I don't think the answer is just, oh, we'll just play Mangum every day.
I don't think that's the answer.
I have a feeling that for some reason they're going to do that.
But we're going to we're going to roll through the options, I guess, that they have available to him.
Yeah, well, I think one that's glaring, but maybe it's not as much of a slam dunk as possible because like of a recent injury and his slow start is the password Garcia.
out of camp, there was a big battle of like he should make the roster.
he was killing it in spring.
He should come up.
But to make sense of things, and I think it was the right call, like he's not going to get every day at bats.
It's probably best for him to go to AAA and develop.
And it was really bad to start off.
Now, we've heard that he's battling through something and maybe he was battling through that.
And that's why it was so bad.
He put him in the aisle since he come back from the aisle.
That guy has been mashing.
Now, I know some of the stats, since returning and being in May come from lower levels, but he did do is mashing.
And now there's in AAA.
He's still mashing.
So I know short sample, but this was a guy that you traded for.
he's made the majors already for the Red Sox.
I'll be a very small sample, but he's made the majors.
So he's still getting every day at bats like that solves everything.
he can be your starter.
He's getting every batch.
You're not worried about the development.
So I think he's a very valid option, Jim.
right.
Certainly a valid option.
Yeah.
This month, he's been playing a lot better.
Now, half of that has been on a rehab assignment in Bradenton.
Half of it was this week in AAA.
He started off the year terrible, though.
You mentioned it.
He had one hit in his first seven games in AAA.
And that just put him in like a really big hole when you go one for, one for 28 or whatever it was, one for 30.
Like, you're going to, you're going to be having some bad numbers.
then it comes out just shortly thereafter that he's been dealing with a back injury.
He gets placed on the IL, sits for about two and a half weeks.
And they did mention that like he's, they think the reason why he wasn't playing well was because of that back injury.
So, yeah, he comes back on rehab, his first, his first rehab game, homers, third rehab game, homers, fifth rehab game, homers, first game back from AAA.
even I was in attendance, saw him hit three homers back to back to back and three different at bats.
So, yeah, he's certainly starting to look the part quite a bit more.
And like you mentioned before, when we were in Bradenton, like there were two people who, there were three people who stood out to me that first week that we were down there.
It was Nick Yorke who was hitting the ball really hard at that time.
And it was Josephson Garcia who was having really good at bats, playing good defense, hitting the ball.
He had a really good spring, especially like that first half.
So, yeah, he was competing for a spot in spring.
So you would imagine he's certainly in the mix here as someone to come up.
And I feel like this was something that I had been talking about all along was, Jhostynxon Garcia, you need to get him every day at bats because at some point and that something's going to happen to someone in the outfield.
Cause that's just what happens.
So at some point, someone's going to, something's going to happen to someone in the outfield.
And that's when you can call this guy up and just plug them into the lineup, and keep everyone in their current role and then just continue along.
So this off season, this was what I was thinking what would happen is the first time an outfielder goes down passwords, password gets the call and he steps in.
That's it.
And that's why it made sense because as a fourth outfielder, he's not going to get a whole lot of bass.
Like if an injury happens and open, like we said, I think we, I forget how we word it.
Cause I think it was a different scenario, but regardless, like if Mangum's injured, he's, that's not the guy you call up probably still.
Like, you're not calling up password.
That's when you maybe call up somebody else.
Maybe some of the non roster invitees, you're like, some, the Wenzel Davises, like those types, right?
Someone that you don't really care about.
That's going to piss fans off.
That's the guy because you're not playing him every day.
But if it's a starter that goes down, that's when you call up the password.
And that's what happened.
Garcia being down.
Now the thing about password too, is he also plays good defense.
Like that was also a calling card.
That was also a reason why you might bring him up.
there's more than just the bat, but he plays good defense and it's in all three outfield spots.
And that's something that parts haven't had any of this year.
So like, I'll say this, even if you like, if you do call him up, which makes a lot of sense, even if the bat doesn't translate right away, like he's going to help you out somewhere.
It's going to be defensively.
Like you're, you'll see something most likely, hopefully again, but, like he'll at least provide value there.
you can definitely play defense.
So there is that, but the bat has been hot lately.
in the month of may, especially, going here, he's batting three 68, four 32.
It's looking eight 95.
It's got a two 25 way to run screen.
Plus now.
Yes.
Like you mentioned, some of that is absolutely in the lower minors during the rehab assignment.
But just with triple a, I know it's small sample.
It's all small sample, but we're looking just in the triple a numbers here as my fan graphs is fritzing out.
So there's no data available.
You're looking just for like this past week.
Yeah.
Yeah.
he hit three 75, four 74 OVP 1000 slugging.
So 1474 OPS this past week in a triple a, there you go.
So anyways, there was certainly some pedigree with him.
The early part maybe wasn't so much talent as it was injury.
And now that he's healthy, he's, he seems to be back playing well.
So I'm definitely good with the password coming here.
Definitely good.
What's another option though, Jim?
The other option that fans would like is Esmerlyn Valdez and he's a year younger than Jhostynxon Garcia is 23.
And like you mentioned, he's got majorly playing time.
Valdez just turned 22 just a few months ago.
He's getting his first taste of triple a.
He's got 180 plate appearances under his belt.
248 average, but this is what's pretty exciting about him.
He's walking about 18% of the time.
He's got a three 83 OVP.
He's got a four 62 slugging percentage.
The strikeouts are down.
The walks are up.
He's got seven homers on the season.
He's just been steady all season long.
He's just been like consistently good.
He's been the Ryan O'Hearn of the, of the Indianapolis Indians.
I guess you could, you could call him that he's been the guy who's been given you really good at bats and occasionally hitting the ball over the fence.
So it's, and he's been playing right field.
He's been playing a little bit of left field too.
He doesn't look too out of place out there.
Like he's been doing it more and more and more.
This could be a time where like, if you're looking at like, who's the most deserving, right?
Cause you could say Garcia, you're just coming off the IL.
You had five games in triple a, you really, it was only four starts.
I believe go ahead, ramp up a little bit more.
Valdez you've been playing every day for all season long.
You've been looking good.
Like in terms of who deserves a promotion the most, it's probably Esmerlyn Valdez.
Yeah.
I'm good with either.
I know a lot of people are more familiar with the password and there's a lot calling for the password.
And again, not to take away, like if he is the call makes sense.
I'm good with it.
Let's roll baby.
You better be starting in right field in St.
Louis.
or left field, however you want to work this, but if it's not him, and if it says Esmerlyn Valdez, I am also good.
Like to me, it's a coin flip.
I really don't know who, if I'm forced to make the call, I don't know who, I guess the one thing is like you mentioned, Garcia is mending.
Like he's just coming back where Valdez has been there.
He's been doing it.
So like offensively, maybe there's a little more trust in Valdez in that sense, safetiness of that.
But Garcia can certainly play defense where that is absolutely Esmerlyn Valdez's limitations there.
He's not the best defender.
it's fine.
Now in this outfield, like it, he is a perfect Pittsburgh pirate.
You know what?
Like he fits right in that.
None of them are really good defenders.
So it's not going to like, it's not going to take away.
It's not like, Oh man, look Esmerlyn Valdez's being exposed out there compared to what has been there before.
As long as he can hit, he's going to be perfect.
He'll be Ryan O'Hearn up there in the major leagues too, in that sense.
But yeah.
So again, like he's, he has his limitations defensively for sure.
But for the offense, yeah.
Like I felt like, he started off with a bang.
He cooled down a little bit towards late April.
And when I say cooled down more like in the power department, because power is like his calling card powers back up in may, he's hitting some home runs again, but it's just the development of Erzmerlin Valdez.
Like that's just something I, again, I hope he becomes a major leaguer.
I hope he becomes a good major leaguer because that's something that I feel like this developmental team can stamp because in the lower minors, I felt like that's a cool story.
Like we saw the power that was cool, but just striking out almost like 40% in low way, you know?
And then the other Greensboro is like 30% decrease in 30%.
It's not where you write off a prospect say, Oh, there's your cook.
There's no way.
But when you're striking out that much, it's like, you're probably not a major leaguer.
You know what?
Like Mason Martin, like a good example of that.
Like, yeah, that power is great.
When you're striking out this much, like you're probably not going to mount anything.
And well, he didn't.
And like, Esmerlyn Valdez was going down that path, like, yeah, it's a cool story, but what's going to happen in the upper minors and then can he do it?
Probably not.
Well, he did.
He's cut the strikeouts a lot last year.
Then it's like, okay, this is a legit prospect this year in AAA, like even more.
The contact rate isn't great, but it's fine.
It's passable.
He's been more patient at the plate.
I just love the story of Esmerlyn Valdez and I just love the person and player of Esmerlyn Valdez.
So there's a little piece.
There's a little bit in my heart that wants Esmerlyn Valdez up here over Garcia in that sense, because like, what a great story he's been.
Yeah.
I would love to see Valdez and if it was my pick, this is, this is who I go with.
Like right now on May 18th with the current situation that's happening, my pick would be Esmerlyn Valdez.
He deserves the chance right now.
and like you mentioned, like just a great developmental story because he was, he was put on the radar in 2024, which is crazy.
It was just really like two years ago, but that's when he led, he led, the Florida state league with 22 homers.
And I was like, okay, like that's something, right.
But like you mentioned, he was striking in 31% of the time.
You're not a serious prospect.
If you're striking out 31% of the time in low a, like you're just not.
Then last year you saw the power continue 26 homers.
You saw the strikeout rate cut to 25%, which is more in line with, okay, we can work with that.
and then this year strikeout rate dropped to 22%, which is even better walk rate sky high.
I've seen him a few times this season.
We saw him in the Arizona fall league last year.
The thing that impresses me the most about Valdez is just the approach.
especially when he was, especially when he was like new to the level, like I saw him that opening weekend in AAA and he really wasn't trying to do too much.
Like it would have been super easy for him to like, okay, I'm in AAA now.
Let me make a splash and try to lift everything and pull everything.
But he didn't, he was like, I'm going to just take what people give me.
And it, and it ended up meaning he took a lot of walks because he wasn't chasing and it led him to a lot of just like base hits opposite, like opposite field singles, just line drive
base hits the right field.
It was just, it was an impressive approach that I don't recall ever really seeing from him because when he was in the Arizona fall, like he was, he was in mash mode.
Like he was just launching baseballs.
And so there's a question here from Bucko commish saying like, is there any worries about not being able to pull the ball?
And it's so to answer the question, like, no, I think what he was doing, especially early on in this year is he was just like, you know what?
I'm going to take what the pitchers give me.
I'm going to learn a little bit about AAA and you just saw him peppering pitches to right field lately.
It's been a little bit more different.
He is pulling the ball more.
his homer that he hit this week was, Deadpool, he crushed it.
So like he can do it.
Like he's to the point where I think he's adjusted to the level and he's feeling more and more comfortable.
And I think that's the reason why I would give him this promotion is just like the approach that he has at the plate.
It seems so advanced for a 22 year old at this level, I'd give him a shot because if he can take that approach that he had, especially early on in the year where it's like, okay,
I'm not going to do too much.
I'm just going to take what the pitchers are giving me and it's leading to a walk or a base hit.
And then as he gets more comfortable, he gets more aggressive.
Like I think I, this is, if I'm Ben Cherington, my move tomorrow is for Esmerlin Valdez to meet the team in San Lewis and be my starting right fielder.
I love it.
Sorry.
I'm like in the, and then we'll try to pull something up right now.
I'll add this to while you're looking that up, like in terms of, I know, like, we have Dan Zimborski on every year too.
And, so we talk a little bit about the Zips projections, like Zips likes Valdez.
Zips likes Valdez more than they like Garcia.
Zips projects Valdez right now, as he is, have a 724 OPS in the majors, which is essentially league average.
Garcia, on the other hand, Zips is projecting at 684 OPS.
Now the difference is Garcia is going to provide you a little bit better, a little bit better defense, but yeah, you got a spray chart up here.
It looks like, yeah, this is Esmerlin spray chart this year.
Those balls are everywhere.
He pulls, he hits away, hits dead, like it's everywhere.
I just, there's not much I dislike about Esmerlin Valdez, again, like, defensively, he has limits.
Where will he play?
Like, where's his official position?
If, and when he makes the majors and is a mainstay, that's going to be determined.
Hopefully he can be a little bit of like what a Ryan Hohern is right now.
like the offense is good enough where it's fine.
It's possible in the outfield for him.
This calling card is going to be the bat.
And so far, like that is what it is.
Like he is hitting now.
And that's also like, again, to me, like what's impressive is the fact that it did not Greensboro.
Like when he got the promotion to Greensboro, there was, there was certainly an adjustment period.
I'm sorry, not Greensboro, Altoona.
We're from Greensboro to Altoona.
There was certainly an adjustment period.
He didn't go to Altoona and just start raking.
It took some time, but the thing was after a bit of time, the raking, it came back.
He was hitting in Altoona.
And then of course he goes to Arizona Fall League.
And yes, that he was the story of baseball, just in baseball.
Everyone's talking about Esmerlyn Valdez when he comes to triple a, like, I felt like there wasn't like an adjustment period for him, as you're talking about, like he just, he went to triple a and he just started producing like from day one.
through the end of April, he had a one 27 way to run scrated plus, it wasn't like, ah, it's through April and it's like a 90, you see him starting to turn on and now it's in May and like, oh, and now in May we're doing
good.
He's still doing good.
He was doing good.
He's just simply been doing good.
And like you mentioned, it's in ways that it looks legit.
there's everything about his game right now just seems like he's a for real prospect.
I would love to see Esmerlyn Valdez like get reward and say, you know what?
I know it's because of an injury.
That's not cool.
It's not great, but we need you.
You're deserving of it.
You've earned it.
Here's your call kid.
He's going to come up with the biggest smile.
And, there's that.
Yeah.
And I think the other thing too, I like about Valdez and I found this out in the fall league too, when we were talking, to some folks down there, it's like, he's hitting the fastball extremely well this season in AAA, but he also like, he can hit breaking
balls too.
And he's punishing sliders right now.
So like you think like, those are the two pitches you see the most in the majors are fastball slider.
And those are the two pitches that he handles.
So I just feel like it's a good fit.
I know there probably is going to be an adjustment period for Valdez.
Like they're like, you have to expect it, but I think it can be quick.
And I think if he's able to keep the approach that he's had all season, that adjustment level, that adjustment period can be limited because he's not trying to do too
much.
Like if he can stick to that approach where I'm going to wait for my pitch, I'm not going to chase pitches.
I'm going to draw walks when they're there and I'm just going to take what the pitcher is giving to me.
I think he could have success at the major league level.
So yeah, I would give him a shot and I'd be like, Valdez, you earned this.
Just don't do anything different.
Like do what got you here and see how it goes for a month.
Yeah.
I just want to add some things here.
You mentioned about the chase.
he's not chasing 24.23% of the time his chase rate, 67 percentile.
Like that's strong.
He's not chasing pitches.
He's not swinging the bat a whole lot.
He's only swinging 41% of the time, which is 25 percentile that, like you said, like he's waiting for his pitch.
Like when he sees the pitch that he wants, he swings and he does damage and he certainly does damage.
The one thing that does worry me though, is the contact rate.
It's still, it's not, it's not great.
Now, again, it's passable.
It's fine.
He's doing what he's doing with it.
Like that, I'm not looking at that saying like, Oh, Whoa, he's not going to, this won't translate, but that there are still some concerns.
There's still some swing and miss to his game.
Again, the strikeouts have certainly dropped.
He's getting on base by walk, but the contact rate, it's not elite.
It's not good, but with everything else in this game, it can be fine.
Yeah.
Yeah.
that's certainly the knock right now.
I think his defense is good enough that especially if you're replacing Ryan O'Hearn, like you're not, I don't think you're going to notice a drop off between right field defense with Ryan O'Hearn and Esmerlin Valdez.
Yeah.
Well, let's do this.
Let's go ahead.
Well, do you have anything else on Garcia or no, that Valdez would be my pick as of right now.
All right.
Love it.
Let's go ahead and kick it on and over to Cody and we'll talk about some other options that are technically on the table.
You won't like this episode is brought to you by IQ bar, our exclusive snack hydration and sponsor IQ bar, protein bars, IQ mix, hydration mixes, and IQ Joe mushroom coffees are the delicious low sugar brain and body fuel.
You need to win your day.
The ultimate sampler pack is a great way for you to try all IQ bar products and flavors.
You get nine IQ bars, eight IQ mix sticks and four IQ Joe sticks.
All IQ bar products are clean label certified and entirely free from gluten, dairy, soy, GMOs, and artificial ingredients.
With over 20,000 five-star reviews and counting, more people than ever are fueling their lifestyles with IQ bars, brain and body boosting bars, hydration mixes, and mushroom coffees.
The ultimate sampler pack includes all three.
My personal favorites so far have been the almond butter chip and the iced tea lemonade hydration mix.
It's just really full of flavor.
I love starting my day with it and I couldn't imagine starting my day with anything else other than IQ bar products.
Right now, IQ bar is offering our podcast listeners 20% off all IQ bar products, including the ultimate sampler pack plus free shipping.
So, Jim, those are the two sexy names, the two prospects, the two guys that people are probably
familiar with, they know of, the young talent, upcoming, let's see them, let's see the kids, right?
The fruits of our labor in this development that's changing around.
You're seeing some hitters, but it's the Pittsburgh Pirates and it has been Cherington still.
And those are the ones that make sense that would make fans happy.
So, we know deep down that's not what's going to happen because fans don't tend to be happy.
We're not allowed to be happy.
It finds a way to stab us in the heart.
We're Pirates fans.
We can't be happy.
Right.
So, even though those are too logical in our eyes, logical call-ups that could happen.
What are the logical call-ups in Ben Cherington's eyes, do you think?
Let's start with the first one, the guy that, I don't know, maybe Ben's been trying to acquire time and time again and finally got his hands on him this offseason with a trade from the Reds?
Yeah.
If you're looking for someone who would make a decent bench player because of the versatility and by decent, like a decent is in quotation marks here.
But someone who would make a bench player, someone you could play at third, someone you could put in the outfield, someone you could put at second.
Tyler Callihan is the other member of the 40-man roster who's in Indianapolis who could theoretically be in line for a promotion.
Acquired late in the spring.
And yeah, like you mentioned, all accounts seem to point towards the Pirates have been after Tyler Callihan for some time.
Like, they've been wanting Tyler Callihan from Cincinnati for a while and they finally got him.
They got him this offseason.
Late in spring training, didn't really have a whole lot of time to make any impression.
He goes to AAA and it hasn't been the greatest start for Tyler Callihan in AAA at all.
This week when I saw him, he did.
He did Homer this week when I saw him.
So there was that.
But overall, he's hitting 225, 299 on base percentage and a 369 slugged percentage in AAA.
That's good for a 73 weighted runs created plus.
That is quite.
Poor.
But he's on the 40-man roster.
He has position flexibility.
And Ben Cherington seems to like him a lot.
Most importantly, that last part.
And like the thing about that is, well, if you call him up, Jim, then you can still allow Ezmerlin to develop.
You can still allow Garcia to develop.
you're not touching them.
That's why you brought in Callihan, because he's made the majors.
You don't have to worry about his development.
You call him up when it's needed.
And you know what, Jim, even though you said all those numbers about AAA.
Yeah, but it's a slow start in the month of May, he's got a 104 way to run his credit plus.
He's a league average hitter in AAA.
So he's fine.
There you go.
There you go.
There you go.
Yeah.
Now in the month of May, he's batting 259, 317, slugging 500, even though he's striking out almost 32% of the time in the month of May.
Yeah.
This one is the one that's going to piss fans off.
And ultimately, again, like you made the trade for him.
It was a, it was like a nothing burger trade.
at the time that, yeah, Kyle Nicholas, he has stuff for sure, but so does Justin Lawrence.
We're talking about Justin Lawrence to be DFA'd Cincinnati Razor talk about Kyle Crick.
Like, why is he on this team whenever he's on the team?
So that's why the trade was like a nothing thing.
Like, yeah, there's certainly stuff there, but is Kyle Crick really going to become a major leaguer ever?
Probably not.
And that's why you get a guy in return who you say, is he ever going to be a major leaguer?
Probably not.
And that's what we're talking about.
That could be someone that Ben calls up because Ben liked him.
And we know about players that when Ben wants someone and he gets his hands on them, it usually means they're not good.
So, but he's going to find out.
Well, yeah, the last person that, well, you know who Cal Callihan reminds me of me.
Maybe this is a poor comparison, but in terms of someone where like someone that Ben Cherington identified as in we need this guy and then they finally got him.
Hey, it sounds a lawful lot like our boy Tuke.
Oh, yeah.
Ben was trying to acquire Tuke of Pita Marcano for years, was finally able to do it.
And yeah, we all know how that turned out.
But yeah, same thing here.
Callihan was someone who's been on the radar for the Pirates for a bit.
They finally get him.
He's still like young ish.
He's 25 years old.
So, like, I guess you could still call him like a fringy borderline prospect.
He doesn't technically qualify as a prospect because of all the service time he got from when he ran into a wall and spent a year on the IL.
But yeah, this would be a pick that I would not be too thrilled with this because this isn't what you need.
Like, the dude, like, put his body on the line for a 71-win team last year.
Gets hurt.
Injured for the rest of the season.
The Pirates, I think, pretty much just, like, do him a solid.
They're like, yeah, we'll bring you back.
Thank you for risking your life for this terrible team.
They bring him back on a minor league deal.
And he has raked.
He has raked an Indy.
Now, your typical, like, he's not really a prospect anymore.
He's been in AAA for three years.
So, like, you would hope that he's pretty much got this level down.
But he's hitting 341.
He's slugging 486.
He's getting on base at a 425 clip.
He's hitting the ball really well.
He can also play corner outfield, left field, right field.
The Pirates have not used him in the infield at all ever since acquiring him.
It's only been in the outfield, which, if you remember correctly, he got, ceremoniously DFA'd by the Marlins last year after I think he made four errors.
Oh, it was either three errors in, like, one inning or four.
It was awful.
He made a bunch of errors in second base.
He was, like, crying on the...
It was rough.
It was rough.
It was, like, one of the roughest innings you'll ever see a player have.
So, the Marlins are, like, we can't keep you anymore.
Like, you're...
This is not going to work.
Pirates pick him up and had some limited playing time in the majors last year.
Didn't really do anything with it.
he played eight games for the Pirates.
But, yeah, he's been crushing the ball.
Been crushing the ball in Indy.
He would require a 40-man roster move to be added to the team.
So, that is the other wrinkle in all of this.
But, Ronny Simon is certainly, if you're just looking at results, he is more deserving than Tyler Callihan.
Let's just say that.
I agree.
So, this is the one that, yeah, like, fans are going to say, oh, my God.
And, that makes even more sense of Dotel coming up if that's the case.
The issue I'm going to have with the Ronny Simon call-up, though, is it's still.
What that means is everyday outfielder Jake Mangum.
Mm-hmm.
And, like, I think that's just what I'd like to avoid.
Like, I want to keep Jake Mangum as the fourth outfielder.
So, in my eyes, like, the answer has to be Garcia or Valdez.
I just, I have my doubts that's what they're going to do.
Which just, I don't know.
It doesn't make much sense to me to not go that route.
Like, you are, you gotta, you gotta win some games.
I think you gotta go with upside here.
And, those two guys offer that.
I agree.
And, I think everyone who's listening right now, opposed to two players' parents, if they're listening, all agree.
Parents might agree, too.
I don't know.
But, no, I'm with you, man.
I am absolutely with you.
But, I think there, it's not a right case.
There is a case for the other two, as we mentioned.
But, I think the right call is one of Esmerlyn Valdez or Garcia.
So, we'll find out soon, though.
That's for sure.
I'm sure, within the next 32 hours, we'll know.
So, there's that.
And then, fans will be pissed off either way.
I'm sure, actually.
Actually, I said those two will still be pissed off.
I think if it's Valdez or Garcia, you won't see too many people upset.
Somehow or another, fans will.
Because, like, Ben's going to do something.
Like, that's.
We're Pirates fans.
We can't be happy.
That's true.
It's not going to be.
Something's going to happen.
It's not going to be what we want.
Yeah.
But, either way, there's that.
Let's go, Bucs.
They got the Cardinal Series coming up.
And then, of course, Toronto.
But, you'll be at the Toronto Series also.
I will be in Toronto for that Series.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Doug might be in St. Louis.
You going to be in Toronto.
So, there's that.
Although, Doug doesn't sound too positive about being in St. Louis anymore after this Series.
But, he did have intentions of going there.
I know that.
Anyway, so, that's our show.
Anything else that you want to say before we get out of here?
No, I was trying to find out, like, with this slide that the Pirates had, what they had them at in terms of a win total over and under on FanDuel.
I don't see them on the board right now, but they are currently, to win the NL Central, plus 950.
Plus 950.
So, their odds have significantly dropped over the last week or so.
They're third.
They're third by a lot behind the Cubs and Brewers.
That just means more value.
More money for your correctness of them winning.
There you go.
Hey, Cubs are 4-6 in the last 10.
Slide starting.
PCAs yelling at fans.
I know, right?
Did you see that?
Yeah.
After the lights go out.
Yeah, just a terrible person.
Just a garbage human being.
Just like we knew he was.
There he is.
He is what we thought he was.
Link is in the description here.
June 13th is our tailgate.
Go ahead and get yourself your tickets to go to the game.
Now, I'll say this.
I haven't looked.
We all know Doug's a man of the people, though.
So, I take this for his word.
But as things stand, no days off.
Rotation lines up.
Paul Skenes is slated to start on our tailgate again.
June 13th.
That's going out quite a bit.
Yeah.
Hey, but again, it's Doug we're talking about.
Trust Doug with all of my heart.
So, June 13th is our tailgate.
Go ahead and get your tickets.
Come with preloaded $10 value on it.
Also, after the game, we'll be able to go out and play catch.
As mentioned, it's your opportunity to try out for the Pirates bullpen.
So, bring your glove.
Warm up your arm.
Be ready.
Outside of that, check out Alex's Offbeat.
Monday to Friday.
That show is out already.
And we'll be back tomorrow with a postgame.
Yep.
Yeah, let's go win some games.
Desperately.
And plurally.
Games.
Yes.
Rosati curse across the border.
Can't wait.
Yeah, we'll see how that works.
Maybe the border stops the curse.
We'll see.
Maybe that's.
Also, it hasn't been a curse this year.
I was going to say, to be fair, it hasn't.
Yeah.
So, maybe crossing the border brings it back.
Maybe you left it at the border the last time you were there.
I haven't been to Canada in a while.
Oh, I thought you were there last year.
My bad.
Never mind.
All right.
Well, we'll see you guys later.
Love you all.
Appreciate y'all.
Appreciate you guys.
Like, comment, tell your friend to tell his friend to subscribe.
See you guys later.
Bye-bye.
See you guys.
All right.
That wraps up this episode of North Shore Nine.
Thanks so much for tuning in.
Whether you're listening on the podcast or catching us on YouTube, if you enjoyed the show, please give this video a thumbs up.
And don't forget to hit that subscribe button if you haven't already.
It really helps us grow.
And if you're listening on the podcast, a quick review goes a long way in helping others find the show.
Plus, be sure to tell a friend about us.
There's always room for more here in the NS9 community.
And for those looking to support us a little more, consider joining our Patreon, become an MVP member, and get exclusive perks while helping us continue to bring you more of the Pirates content you love.
Thanks again for all your support, and Let's Go Bucs.
Comments· 0
Should the Pirates call up Esmerlyn Valdez over Jhostynxon Garcia to replace the injured Ryan O'Hearn in right field?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.