◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)◆NEWSPirates, Chas McCormick Agree To Minor League Deal
◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)◆NEWSPirates, Chas McCormick Agree To Minor League Deal
Sammy Stafura has gone from a difficult start to one of the biggest breakout stories in the Pirates system. Since June 14, the shortstop has produced a 1.236 OPS with 13 home runs and 14 stolen bases while continuing to show the defense and athleticism that have always driven his profile. Jim and Anthony Murphy discuss what is real, when Stafura could reach Altoona and whether the Pirates might consider moving him before the deadline.
Watch or listen to the full episode now.
Comments· 0
The Debate
Should the Pirates trade Sammy Stafura at the deadline for help in the majors right now?
From Jim Rosati’s take on the show
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.
With Jim Rosati and Anthony Murphy.
Chapters
Key takeaways
1
Sammy Stafura's power surge is partly the South Atlantic League, where home runs are way up, but he has unlocked something real and his long-term home run projection should go up.
Jim Rosati
2
The red flag is still contact: a 37.6% whiff rate, 74.1% zone contact and a strikeout rate over 30% during the hot streak.
Jim Rosati
3
The homers get the attention, but Stafura's defense and speed will carry his career. He has made 2 errors in 44 games at shortstop and has 19 steals in 55 games.
Jim Rosati
4
Stafura has to be moved up to Altoona before the season ends. Ideally Wyatt Sanford comes back first so Greensboro can still field a roster.
Jim Rosati
5
With Wyatt Sanford and newly signed Aiden Ruiz at shortstop, Stafura is the kind of prospect you could flip at the deadline to help the major league team now.
What's going on, everybody? Welcome to another episode of North Shore Nine presented by FanDuel. This is your weekly installment of Bucs On Deck. I'm Jim. With me today is Anthony Murphy from Bucs On Deck. Murf, how are you doing this week?
Jim Rosati
Doing pretty good, man. Doing pretty good. How about you?
Jim Rosati
I'm doing really well. Really well. It's been a long week for me. I've been traveling a lot. Excited to be, home and excited to talk about this week's prospect because I feel like, especially lately, you can't, you can't sift through the minor league box scores on a daily basis or even like a weekly basis or however long that you check on this stuff.
Jim Rosati
But every time you look and see, like, hey, what's going on in the minors, Sammy Staffora is just doing remarkable things in Greensboro over the last month plus.
Jim Rosati
So I'm excited to talk about him, Murf. He was brought over from the Cincinnati Reds last year in the Ke'Bryan Hayes trade.
Jim Rosati
But he was a 2023 second round pick, 43rd overall out of that draft, pretty highly regarded prospect heading into the draft.
Jim Rosati
And yeah, the Pirates got him for Hayes last year, sent him to, I believe they sent him right to Bradenton for a bit and then promoted him almost immediately to Greensboro.
Jim Rosati
But yeah, excited to talk about Sammy Staffora.
Jim Rosati
So I guess before we just dive into everything, give everybody just like a 30 second high overview on who this kid is.
Jim Rosati
Yeah. Like I'm, you mentioned it, he's a pretty highly regarded prep shortstop during his draft year.
Jim Rosati
He was actually a guy that like stood out during the combine that like, over at Bucs On Deck, we all watched and all that.
Jim Rosati
We like circled his name as maybe like someone that we wouldn't have, we wouldn't have mind the Pirates like targeting in draft.
Jim Rosati
And while they didn't get him in the draft, they ended up with him anyways.
Jim Rosati
It's just, there's a lot of raw tools there that we saw maybe a little bit extra raw power there.
Jim Rosati
There's some speed has a couple of 30 stolen base seasons on there.
Jim Rosati
And I think the biggest thing with him now is the defense and like the, all the highlight reels, obviously point to like the home run power and the home run, all the home runs he's hitting.
Jim Rosati
But I think the thing that's going to carry him the most and the thing that probably going to highlight the most here, it's going to be the defense.
Jim Rosati
Well, and that's always been his calling card, like super athletic individual can play shortstop, has a good arm, has a good glove, has good footwork, fast, can steal bases.
Jim Rosati
everybody, is pretty, they think Stephore has a pretty high floor just because they're, the defense and, the fact you can play short, you can play second.
Jim Rosati
And you can probably even plug them at third really, if you wanted to like, he can play a bunch of positions and play them fairly well.
Jim Rosati
So there was always that floor to Stephore.
Jim Rosati
And yeah, so we'll talk about the defense because that is, I think it's still his, along with the speed, his top tool, but we are starting to see this year.
Jim Rosati
Some other things start to click for him and we'll go into like, is this Greensboro, is this the South Atlantic league or has he figured something out?
Jim Rosati
Like, has he unlocked something because, we were talking a little bit beforehand, but to start this season, Murphy, but, from the start of the year to June 13th, Sammy Sephora had 119 plate appearances, it was 30 games, but he was hitting 192 with an OBP of 319 and a slugging percentage of 303.
Jim Rosati
That was good for an OPS of 622.
Jim Rosati
And with the majority of that time coming in Greensboro in the South Atlantic league, that was not very good.
Jim Rosati
So just like a dismal start to the season.
Jim Rosati
He only stole five bases.
Jim Rosati
it was just, it just wasn't, it wasn't very good.
Jim Rosati
however, since that date, since June 14th, which is 26 games, this includes tonight's game as well.
Jim Rosati
He's hitting 359, 420 OBP.
Jim Rosati
He's slugging 816 Murphy.
Jim Rosati
That's a 1,236 OPS over his last 26 games.
Jim Rosati
And he's homered 13 times and stolen 14 bases in that span.
Jim Rosati
So it's been just an insane last, 40 days or so per se before he's been the best player in the pirates minor league system from a statistical standpoint.
Jim Rosati
Over the last 40 days, I think.
Jim Rosati
Yeah.
Jim Rosati
Oh yeah, absolutely.
Jim Rosati
And like, it's getting to the point to where like, you just pencil it in or like I could have put in a draft, Sammy's to for a home run.
Jim Rosati
And I could put it in the drafts on Twitter and just like, just, schedule it for whatever the next time that, Greensboro was going to play because it just seemed like it was automatic on a nightly basis that like he was going to hit a home run.
Jim Rosati
He was going to have a multi-hit game.
Jim Rosati
He was going to steal a base.
Jim Rosati
It was just, it was, it's been ridiculous.
Jim Rosati
It's we, I've seen some hot streaks of guys that gone through Greensboro, but this is like by far, like one of the just most insane runs.
Jim Rosati
I think I've seen for a minor league player right now, between June 30th and July 10th, those nine games, he homered in eight of them.
Jim Rosati
He homered in eight of nine games, Murphy.
Jim Rosati
Like, and we're talking about like, this guy is not like a, you don't, you look at him and you're, you don't think power.
Jim Rosati
six foot one 88.
Jim Rosati
He like, he's built right.
Jim Rosati
Like athletic built, like he clearly has some strength there.
Jim Rosati
but yeah, just an impressive run that he's on right now.
Jim Rosati
And I was like, you know what?
Jim Rosati
We got to do an episode on Sammy's to four because the people need to know Murphy is, and this is coming from, someone who, doesn't watch every Greensboro grasshoppers game, like you do, again, Greensboro, heavy offensive environment.
Jim Rosati
How much of this recent stretch is like real and how much of this is that's Greensboro.
Jim Rosati
I think, I think it's a nice little blend of both.
Jim Rosati
Cause I definitely think that there's some like, even just on top of Greensboro, the balls are just completely flying out of the South Atlantic league.
Jim Rosati
There's already been more home runs hit.
Jim Rosati
This point in the season.
Jim Rosati
Then there was like all of last year in the South by like it's approaching like a couple hundred more home runs already hit.
Jim Rosati
Like they're going to like blow through like the home run doubles.
Jim Rosati
they could get to the point to where they almost like double what they did the previous year, depending on how things finish.
Jim Rosati
Like, it's just insane.
Jim Rosati
The amount of home runs being hit that being said, he, there's always been some like intrigue with just like some raw power there that you can see that he was able to tap into like here and there.
Jim Rosati
So like you always thought that like, okay, well maybe there is some more that he can get.
Jim Rosati
I don't think he's going to be like this huge home run hitter, but I do think like there's, he's unlocked something to where like you can probably up the home run projection a little bit for him.
Jim Rosati
Like long-term at this point.
Jim Rosati
Okay.
Jim Rosati
and looking at, some underlying numbers.
Jim Rosati
Yeah.
Jim Rosati
I said the powers, the powers certainly there recently.
Jim Rosati
if there was anything you, I guess you could nitpick here is, the contact rate still outstanding.
Jim Rosati
He's swinging and missing quite a bit.
Jim Rosati
37.6% whiff rate.
Jim Rosati
His zone contact rate is 74.1%.
Jim Rosati
he's still striking out at over a 30% clip right now.
Jim Rosati
so like there are those sorts of things going on there.
Jim Rosati
but yeah, you've got to be impressed with just what he's doing with the bat right now.
Jim Rosati
Cause I said coming over from Cincinnati, everything that I heard on him was super athletic, good fielder, should steal a bunch of bases.
Jim Rosati
Like you mentioned back-to-back 30 stolen bases seasons.
Jim Rosati
He's going to do that again this year as well.
Jim Rosati
so like that's, that is certainly in his tool belt.
Jim Rosati
but yeah, the power surge we're seeing here as of late has been, absolutely, incredible.
Jim Rosati
So I do want to kick things over to Cody for a second.
Jim Rosati
We're going to come back here and I really want to spend some time for, on the defense and the base running, before we look at, a future outlook for Sammy Sephora.
Jim Rosati
This episode is brought to you by IQ bar, our exclusive snack hydration and sponsor IQ bar, protein bars, IQ mix, hydration mixes, and IQ Joe mushroom coffees are the delicious low sugar brain and body fuel.
Jim Rosati
You need to win your day.
Jim Rosati
The ultimate sampler pack is a great way for you to try all IQ bar products and flavors.
Jim Rosati
You get nine IQ bars, eight IQ mix sticks, and four IQ Joe sticks.
Jim Rosati
All IQ bar products are clean label certified and entirely free from gluten, dairy, soy, GMOs, and artificial ingredients.
Jim Rosati
With over 20,000 five-star reviews and counting, more people than ever are fueling their lifestyles with IQ bars, brain and body boosting bars, hydration mixes, and mushroom coffees.
Jim Rosati
The ultimate sampler pack includes all three.
Jim Rosati
My personal favorites so far have been the almond butter chip and the iced tea lemonade hydration mix.
Jim Rosati
It's just really full of flavor.
Jim Rosati
I love starting my day with it.
Jim Rosati
And I couldn't imagine starting my day with anything else other than IQ bar products.
Jim Rosati
Right now, IQ bar is offering our podcast listeners 20% off all IQ bar products, including the ultimate sampler pack, plus free shipping.
Jim Rosati
To get your 20% off, text MLB to 64000.
Jim Rosati
That's MLB 64000.
Jim Rosati
Message and data rates may apply.
Jim Rosati
See terms for details.
Jim Rosati
All right, Murph.
Jim Rosati
So let's talk about the defense here.
Jim Rosati
He's playing the majority of the time at shortstop, probably two-thirds of the time at shortstop.
Jim Rosati
The other third of the time at second base.
Jim Rosati
But what has been impressive to me is usually when you look at shortstop minor league numbers, you don't really get defensive metrics in the minors.
Jim Rosati
But you can always look at errors, right?
Jim Rosati
And it seems like shortstops always have a lot of errors in the minors because they get a ton of opportunities.
Jim Rosati
They get a lot of opportunities to mess up.
Jim Rosati
And the fields in the minors, they're very nice fields, but they're not as pristine as major league fields.
Jim Rosati
Like, they're still, like, they're just not as good.
Jim Rosati
They're not kept up as nicely.
Jim Rosati
But I think what's stood out to me, he's played now, let's see, 44 games at shortstop at Greensboro since arriving.
Jim Rosati
Just two errors at shortstop by Stefora.
Jim Rosati
So what makes him so special defensively?
Jim Rosati
It feels like he has, like, the ability to just, like, slow everything down.
Jim Rosati
Like, it's never – he never has to rush anything.
Jim Rosati
It's – like you mentioned before, like, the footwork is great.
Jim Rosati
So, he's always in good position to make the play.
Jim Rosati
And so, like, it's never, like, he's making, like, these desperate throws to where, like, he's rushing anything.
Jim Rosati
But at the same time, like, the arm is, like, really strong.
Jim Rosati
So, like, he can make all the throws that you want as a shortstop.
Jim Rosati
The footwork is great.
Jim Rosati
And, like I said, it just looks easy out there.
Jim Rosati
There are just some guys that you can tell that, like, they're going to play shortstop just because they make the position look so easy.
Jim Rosati
And it's not easy.
Jim Rosati
That's why so few – like, so many people start out at shortstop, but they all end up elsewhere because, like, it's the toughest – one of the toughest positions to play.
Jim Rosati
And he just goes out there and he just makes it look just super simple and super easy.
Jim Rosati
Yeah.
Jim Rosati
And just to reiterate that, because I haven't gotten to see him a ton, but I did see him in person right after the trade was made when he was with Greensboro towards the end of last season.
Jim Rosati
And he was struggling offensively at that point.
Jim Rosati
Like, he was really in, like, a big slump offensively-wise.
Jim Rosati
But he looked great.
Jim Rosati
He looked great out there defensively.
Jim Rosati
And it was just, like, smooth.
Jim Rosati
Like, you could just tell, like you mentioned, like, under control, slow, didn't look like he was – like you were saying, that didn't look like he was having to rush anything.
Jim Rosati
Like, he just seemed in control out there.
Jim Rosati
And I remember talking to him because, he was obviously frustrated at the time.
Jim Rosati
He was just traded to a new organization.
Jim Rosati
Like, you want to make a really good impression.
Jim Rosati
And he just wasn't hitting at that point.
Jim Rosati
And, he was really frustrated with what he was doing in the field, but – what he was doing at the plate.
Jim Rosati
But at the same time, he was like, at least I'm, like, I'm contributing to the team.
Jim Rosati
he was – he wasn't letting the offensive slump affecting him defensively.
Jim Rosati
But he was doing a really good job of separating those two, which was impressive.
Jim Rosati
Because, he was 20 years old last year.
Jim Rosati
He's still a pretty young kid.
Jim Rosati
He's going to be 21 all season this year.
Jim Rosati
He doesn't turn 22 until November.
Jim Rosati
So, again, like, lots of time for this guy to develop.
Jim Rosati
But, yeah, fielding-wise, he's everything you want to see in someone who – he can play the positions that you want him to play.
Jim Rosati
And he's athletic enough where if the bat can play, see what else he can do.
Jim Rosati
Like, can he play third base?
Jim Rosati
Can he play center field?
Jim Rosati
maybe even – like, I think that's even a possibility for someone like Staphora.
Jim Rosati
And he hasn't done that yet in the minors.
Jim Rosati
But, like, I feel like he's someone where, as he advances, if this is someone who you feel like can help you with, usually, like, maybe just try some other things with him and see how versatile you can make him.
Jim Rosati
Absolutely.
Jim Rosati
That's why you – that's why it's – that's why, like, me personally, I know a lot of teams – it's like, that's why you draft at that position.
Jim Rosati
Because if they can play that position well, chances are they can play any position well.
Jim Rosati
So, it just – it's like a built-in versatility, built-in floor with it that, well, he can play shortstop really good.
Jim Rosati
So, obviously, shortstop's going to be taking it, the major – we could put him pretty much anywhere at that point.
Jim Rosati
Like you said, try him at third base.
Jim Rosati
Try him in center field.
Jim Rosati
He has the speed.
Jim Rosati
He has the arm.
Jim Rosati
He has everything for it.
Jim Rosati
like, why not?
Jim Rosati
The other thing I want to touch on is his base running, 30 – in his first season, 30 – 20 – 31 stolen bases in 92 games.
Jim Rosati
Last year, 32 stolen bases in 119 games.
Jim Rosati
This year, he's only played 55 games, but the stolen base rate is up to 19.
Jim Rosati
And, like, really good success rates, too.
Jim Rosati
He's only been caught stealing twice this year.
Jim Rosati
He was 32 for 38 last year, 31 for 36 the year before.
Jim Rosati
He just has a feel for stealing bases, and – he's athletic enough.
Jim Rosati
He's fast enough that, especially at this level, he's taking advantage of that.
Jim Rosati
Yeah, absolutely.
Jim Rosati
just – the attention goes to the power and stuff like that right now, and for good reason, because, like, he's tearing the cover off the ball right now.
Jim Rosati
But, like, the bread and butter is still going to be the defense and the speed for him.
Jim Rosati
So, prediction time.
Jim Rosati
Okay.
Jim Rosati
at some point, you've got to move this guy to Altoona, right?
Jim Rosati
Like, you can't – Absolutely.
Jim Rosati
Yeah.
Jim Rosati
You can't just be doing this in Greensboro.
Jim Rosati
Yeah.
Jim Rosati
Yeah, – We just thought Carmichael get promoted.
Jim Rosati
are we thinking we'll see Staphore and Altoona before the end of the year?
Jim Rosati
I feel like once things start – Like, I think, ideally, you probably want, like, maybe Wyatt Sanford to get back, to take that spot back in Greensboro, just so then, roster –
Jim Rosati
they've got to still field a roster, and, the benches are getting a little light right now everywhere throughout the minors.
Jim Rosati
But, yeah, he's definitely a guy that – you mentioned the contact rates, and the contact rates are still something that, I'm still worried about and stuff like that.
Jim Rosati
So, that would be something to watch.
Jim Rosati
But, at this point, he's at the point now to where, like, maybe you want to give him that added challenge to see how he reacts to another level of pitching.
Jim Rosati
Trade deadline's coming up, too.
Jim Rosati
And he was already traded once.
Jim Rosati
I also think Staphore is someone who – he's at a position that, the Pirates do have locked up for a long time.
They just drafted Aiden Ruiz and then poured a ton of money into him.
Jim Rosati
is Staphore someone to even keep an eye on as possible trade bait to help the major league team, for the rest of this season?
Jim Rosati
Oh, absolutely.
Jim Rosati
who wouldn't want, like, a surefire shortstop who's, like, all of a sudden tapping into some, like, added power potential that maybe some people didn't think was there originally?
Jim Rosati
Yeah, I know whenever, he's been turning on here the last month or so, that was the first thing that clicked in my head was, ooh, like, he's turning himself –
Jim Rosati
like, not only is he turning himself into a pretty interesting prospect, but he's turning himself into someone who I feel like you could flip this guy and get someone to help you out right now at the major league level
Jim Rosati
because he is still far away.
Jim Rosati
he's in Greensboro right now.
Jim Rosati
He's still got two more levels to go.
Jim Rosati
But, again, he still has quite a few things to work on before he gets to the majors, I think.
Jim Rosati
But, yeah, I think he's a name that you could hear in the next week or two when it comes to a potential trade at the major league level here because he certainly seems like an attractive –
Jim Rosati
he was an attractive candidate for the Pirates last year.
Jim Rosati
I think he'll be an attractive candidate for just about everybody this year too.
Jim Rosati
Yeah, and just imagine how much of an added win that makes that trade too because, obviously it was – you're able to get out of all of Ke'Bryan Hayes' contract, you're able to get a decent prospect, and then you're able – if you're able to flip that again into something
Jim Rosati
that helps the major league team down the road, it's just something that keeps adding and adding value to the organization in whole.
Jim Rosati
Yeah, that's the thing with prospects.
Jim Rosati
Like, prospects are there to help you in the future, but prospects are also there to help you now when you need it.
Jim Rosati
So, we'll see which ones the four ends up being.
Jim Rosati
Absolutely.
Jim Rosati
All right, Murphy.
Jim Rosati
Well, hey, appreciate you joining me this week.
Jim Rosati
If you haven't yet, make sure you check out the Bucs On Deck sub stack.
Jim Rosati
We got draft signings rolling in right now.
Jim Rosati
I know you've got all that stuff going on.
Jim Rosati
Minor league season, obviously, even full swing with, going down the homestretch of the second half.
Jim Rosati
But, yeah, make sure you're subscribed to Bucs On Deck, and we'll be back next week with another episode of this.
Jim Rosati
But, yeah, this was North Shore Nine presented by Thandall.
Comments· 0
Should the Pirates trade Sammy Stafura at the deadline for help in the majors right now?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.