◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
Bucco Brew opened with a lively breakdown of Team USA’s 2-1 win over the Dominican Republic, with plenty of love for Paul Skenes stepping up on the big stage and Pittsburgh showing out in the WBC. The episode also dug into what that atmosphere means for players like Skenes and Oneil Cruz heading into 2026. From there, the conversation shifted to the Pirates’ fifth starter battle, where Carmen Mlodzinski is starting to make a real case. They also hit on NS9 announcements, including the April 18 tailgate.
Watch and listen now, and save 30% at De Fer Coffee & Tea with promo code NS930.
Comments· 0
The Debate
Should Carmen Mlodzinski be the Pirates' fifth starter instead of a multi-inning reliever?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.
With Anthony DiNardo and Jim Rosati.
Chapters
Key takeaways
1
After Skenes held a Dominican lineup with 5 MVPs to one run, nobody can say Tarik Skubal is better. Paul Skenes is the best pitcher alive.
2
The DR got rung up on clear balls in two big moments. That shows why ABS challenges are needed: bad ball-strike calls shouldn't decide high-leverage spots.
3
Carmen Mlodzinski should be the fifth starter and Mike Clevinger should take the multi-inning bullpen role. A starter you can trust matters more than a reliever.
4
José Urquidy's fastball fell from 93 to 90 by the fourth inning. A right-hander throwing 90 without elite command or secondary pitches won't work in 2026.
5
Hunter Barco won't make the Opening Day roster, but expect plenty of him in 2026.
Yo. Welcome to the North Shore Nine podcast presented by FanDuel. This is Bucco Brew powered by Defer Coffee and Tea. I'm your host, Anthony DiNardo. With me, we have Jim Rosati. Jim, back in the house.
What's up, buddy? Good morning. Happy Monday. Happy Monday. Happy USA victory. It's a victory Monday. Yeah, what a game. Honestly, what a tournament so far. Everything that was hyped up to be. It was. It was. What a game. Yeah, just the
tournament in a tournament in a hole, really. I don't know how excited I was going into this World Baseball Classic. I'm always like, you know what? I'll watch the games if I'm available. They'll be fun. But it seems like, I don't know. It seems like this go around. Has been really good. Like just outstanding baseball games being played.
the Venezuela one against team Japan knocks Japan out. That was pretty exciting. And then. Yep. Italy just doing Italian things. Yeah. Italy doing what
they're doing is pretty incredible. it's basically a team of guys who, they're all from America. There's not too many actual Italians on that team.
But yeah, we've both figured out we could have played if we were good enough. We got DiNardo and Rosati here. yeah, I think as long as your name ended with a vowel, you were eligible. So that's how that Italian team's going. but no, they're playing awesome. They're in the, they're in the semi-finals. So there's. Yeah. What? Italy versus, Venezuela tonight.
to see who goes on to face team USA in the finals. So yeah, it's fun. It's fun. Venezuela team, super fun. The Dominican team that team was incredibly talented, and very fun to watch, that game last night. we'll get into it, but man, it was the, just the, like every pitch seemed like it was important. It was like a game seven of the world series.
Type of that. Well, that's why I love the WBC. in a way it exposes how boring United States version of baseball is because I just feel like everywhere else. these, like you watch the Dominican league, that's the environment is down there, you know? And it's just like, they bring that, they bring that energy to all these games. And it's just so fun to witness it.
We have to witness it from afar. it was cool. Also something, the beat writers were there because of obviously the representation of Pittsburgh. just a travel away from Bradenton to Miami.
So just like getting their feedback of that environment also, man, I wish I was there.
Yeah. Last night would have been a great baseball game to go and watch. Like if there was, if there was a game in this tournament that I could have gone to see, it would have been last night.
And like you mentioned, I think, Jason Mackey was there. Colin Beasley was there.
Not only were the pirates represented, but like the city of Pittsburgh was represented.
You had, you had, you had Paul Skenes on team USA. You had Gregory Soto, Dennis Santana, Oneil Cruz on the Dominican Republic.
And then on top of that, you had David Bednar who, Mars area high school alum. he pitched the seventh inning, a shutout seventh inning was interesting.
He made it, made sure it was interesting in classic David Bednar fashion, but he got the job done.
And then, in the ninth inning Bethel park, Mason Miller closing it out. So yeah, it was like I said, very well represented like Pittsburgh showed out in this one.
It was, it was cool.
Yeah, they did. And like you said, it was cool because it wasn't just the pirates, the team, it was the city of Pittsburgh, again, David Bednar, who also was an ex pirate and Mason Miller as mentioned.
So yeah, Pittsburgh was on the map last night in a big way and they came out victorious.
So it was a really, it was a really fun and cool game to watch.
I felt, and the fact that it was two to one was interesting.
I know a lot of people before, you watch the pregame, it was talking like, seven to three, seven to two, some runs being scored.
And there was offense that there absolutely was some offense there, but the pitching and defense came through.
So yeah, I want to talk more about, the game and stuff.
So let's do get into that.
As you mentioned here before we do a little word of responses, Defer coffee and tea.
So Defer is a family and employee and owned operated business.
They believe that coffee and tea are one of life's simplest and most accessible pleasures.
And when thought, when enjoyed thoughtfully, can open your eyes to the here and now they have five locations across the city of Pittsburgh, including their flagship in the heart of Pittsburgh's historic strip district.
Don't forget to stop by Defer's new location downtown on Penn Avenue, right across from the Ben and them, grab a cup and fill up your walk on to a PNC park.
Mobile ordering is available.
Check out the Instagram for more details.
And of course that is at Defer dot coffee, Jim, tell everyone how they can see themselves 30% as you see on that code on the bottom right of our screen.
Yeah.
Put everything you need in your shopping cart at Defer dot coffee and put in promo code NS930.
It's NS930 and you'll get 30% off your entire order.
Good stuff.
Great stuff.
Yep.
Speaking of great stuff.
Paul Skenes didn't have his great stuff last night.
And on top of that face, the pretty damn good lineup, Jim, you're probably not getting, even the LA Dodgers are looking at this lineup and saying, how can we accomplish this next year?
If of course there is baseball.
So with skeins, not even having his best stuff playing for him last night and him facing this DR lineup that has guys that are probably going to be an MVP talks year in and year out.
The guy showed up.
I know it was only 4.1 innings, but he showed up.
He led this team to a victory.
One run he allowed.
And of course the bullpen came through and the clutch, right?
And they did their job also as mentioned, but Paul Skenes came through in the big stage.
And as you mentioned, Pittsburgh, the pirates were on scene and he did the damn thing, man.
Yeah.
Final line for in a third innings.
He did get up six hits, one run, zero walks, two strikeouts.
The only run was a junior Caminero solo Homer.
it was a great tournament for Paul Skenes to overall 1.08 ERA.
I think he pitched eight and a third innings and gave up just that one run.
But yeah, you mentioned, not the best, I, again, I got, I MF wags here says it in the, in the, in the comments section.
Like, I don't know if you can say it wasn't his best stuff because like this lineup was incredible.
well, think about it.
So like, was he, was he doing typical Paul Skenes things?
Maybe not, but he was facing a lineup of Fernando Tatis Jr.
Like, I feel like the most important thing is just like, can you get through this lineup?
And he was able to get through it pretty much twice.
and giving up just the one run, I said, from a stuff standpoint, I didn't really break down the stuff.
Like he didn't have a ton of swings, eight swings and misses or on the fastball or on the splitter, his breaking stuff.
Well, first off, he didn't really throw a ton of them.
Didn't throw a ton of sweepers.
Didn't throw a ton of curve balls.
Didn't throw, didn't throw a lot of the change ups either, but it was, it was heavy fastball splitter combo yesterday.
And yeah, like 20 was overall 20% whiff rate.
You're used to seeing that number being a little bit higher for Paul Skenes, but.
He also isn't facing a lineup full of, MVP caliber players every single day.
So, I'm not going to knock the stuff.
you're just not going to have a five inning, eight strikeout, no run performance against the lineup like this.
Like no one can do it.
And I get that, but also hitting two batters addictive of maybe Paul Skenes on having his best stuff and leaning on the fastball because he didn't have, his best stuff.
Like he wasn't really locating.
Well, the home run that's more of a, yeah, but again, but yeah, that's why I can say like he did it.
when does Paul Skenes also hit two batters in four and a third innings?
Yeah.
Yeah.
He can't really put that on the hitters, the lineup.
So again, I do think there is an argument to me.
He didn't have his best stuff last night, but like, I want to highlight, like, that's what makes Paul Skenes.
I feel like Paul Skenes, because I said time and time again, in 30 starts, you're going to have 10 starts.
You have your best stuff, 10 starts where, you're fighting through it and 10 where you just don't at all.
There's many times, not to say many, but it's like any picture you go out there, you still don't have your best stuff with you.
He knows how to get guys out.
it's the ultimate pitcher, right?
He's not just a thrower.
He is the ultimate pitcher and he was relying on the defense.
it was a lot of soft contact last night that was being made and whatnot.
And again, like that's just what makes Paul Skenes so great.
Because again, like I want to highlight, like he didn't have his best stuff with him last night, but he still got through this elite lineup giving just one earned run.
Yes.
The one was off of a mistake and was a home run to junior Cameron arrow.
And that's where, again, like kudos to Cam and arrow, like he's a stud as well.
They're all studs.
You let that one hang in and he blasted that one out of the park.
It happens.
Right.
But it was a solo shot because he wasn't allowing, at that point in time, of course, many base runners on and he just fought through and found a way to be victorious because that's what Paul Skenes does.
As long as he's, as long as he has a little bit of offense and another, he got just that little bit that he needed last night to still have that.
And of course, don't get the victory, but like, that's what happened.
Like it was also, it was funny that the pirates are pirates, the team USA scores, two runs, but that's all I needed last night.
Yeah, I'll concede to like, it probably wasn't his best game ever, but again, that, like you mentioned it, that points is just how good the guy is, right?
Like he went up against, yes.
this team, this Dominican Republic lineup is one of the best lineups ever put together on a baseball field.
Somebody said it last night that game was probably the greatest collection of talent you'll ever see.
put on a baseball field.
And like, that includes major league all-star games.
Like those lineups last night were better than all-star lineups, right?
Because in the all-star game, you've got people who sit out and like every once in a while, you'll get a couple of people who get into an all-star game who maybe shouldn't be there.
Like those lineups last night were pretty insane just to like run through some of that.
Like there were four rookie of the year winners in the lineups last night, 32 silver sluggers, eight gold gloves, four platinum gloves, 51 all-stars and five MVPs that played last night.
Just an outstanding game.
and yeah, like I said, skeins showed why he's so good.
I know there's like a lot of this debate between like, Hey, who's the best pitcher in the world?
Like, is it school or is it skeins?
I feel like last, like, I feel like a, like a lot of the national people will tell you it's scoobal.
Well, it's not like after last, I'll say after last night, like, I don't know how anybody could look at this and say like Paul Skenes isn't the best pitcher alive.
Yeah.
I just want to throw in there.
Like it might've just been to hype up the game, but when David Ortiz is talking, when they're a rod was talking, Paul Skenes, the best pitcher on the planet.
Like that's how he's being introduced.
They weren't debating.
They weren't saying, Hey, maybe him or school board.
He's maybe one of the best.
It was highlighted.
He's the best pitcher in the planet.
Now, again, I'm sure as to help hype up the game, if you talk to them afterwards, right, they might have that debate, but.
Yeah, man, it's just so cool seeing him on the national stage like this.
And like you mentioned that lineup and he just goes out there and shoves.
And if like, this is one of those situations too.
Like if you said USA was only going to score two runs, I don't know.
That sucks.
I would have said they were, I would have said they were done.
And this team held this lineup to just one run again, led by Paul Skenes is 4.1.
And then afterwards, just the Pittsburgh boys coming in and shutting them down.
So a couple, a couple of like topics I want to talk about just stemming from this game.
One.
I was always iffy on ABS challenging, but like it last night, not prove that we need ABS challenging.
You talking to someone who is ready for team USA or ready for team DR?
Cause that gets wasted.
Like, but right.
Like a game.
I think that the behind the whole thing, like I don't, I'm not a huge fan of like challenging a ball one in the second inning or a strike one call.
Like, eh, that doesn't mean a whole lot to me, but like in enormous moments when the game is on the line or it's a high leverage situation, it's nice to like, make sure that those calls are right.
At least in the, in a sense of like, there's no egregious ball strike calls that are deciding games.
So that was one thing where like, if there was one thing that sucked last night, it was man, this game.
Like there were two big moments where the Dominican Republic got rung up on clear balls.
But again, it goes to show you, Hey, that's why ABS exists and why it's going to be in place this year is games like this or just really games.
Like games in general should no longer be decided by really bad ball and strike calls in a big time situations.
So that's, I guess that's refreshing to see.
you can, you can go back and forth.
We can go back and forth and talk about how much the human element should be a part of the game or not.
But like, it sucked that game was decided like that because it was such a good game, like incredible talent on both sides.
And an umpire messed a couple of things up.
Yeah.
the right thing to say is you didn't do enough to win the game, but I'm sure, people in the DR or even fans are walking away from that.
Just saying like, what if, and that's what the ABS was designed for.
So I'm with you.
And I think spring training, it gets overused.
I don't think it's going to be used as quite as often as it has been, but again, like it is spring training.
That's why you do use it.
the players are getting adjusted to this and such, but like, yes, that's why ABS was implemented for moments like that.
Because like, get it right.
It's not to be out there challenging every pitch.
It's to ensure that those ones and those big critical moments, you know what, let's have a better look at this because I'm not walking back to that dugout.
When I just stood watching ball four and now you're striking me out and deciding a game, that's where it absolutely is critical.
And I think there is a, there is room for it in this sport.
And I do like ABS.
I think visually too.
I think the fans can get behind it and get into it, but I will say this too.
Like it is funny because like Paul Skenes did get some strikes that were borderline and there, and there were balls and, as Pirates fans, we're going to have to get accustomed to this also because Paul Skenes is the best pitcher on the planet.
And he now does command that respect from umpires.
So when they somewhat give him those strikes, they could come back.
So I'm also interested in how the Paul Skenes effect comes.
Not that he's Greg Maddox by any means, but he has some filthy stuff that sometimes they're balls.
Yeah.
And then put, and then just combine that with Henry Davis has shown to be a really great framer where he's stealing some of those strikes.
So like how much of Henry Davis's value, gets taken away because of this, I'm sure there's going to be balls that he steals and turns into strikes throughout the game.
some borderline ones, but it's not going to be as bad as it's not going to be as, I don't think it's going to be as, evidence.
As before, just that catcher framing skill.
Yep.
The other thing, the other thing last night led me to think about is.
DiNardo, I have the itch for a big time baseball now.
Like I dude, like this game, I, it's just, it was, it was a fun, it was just such a fun game.
Every pitch was so much fun.
And first off before I wasn't sure how much I love this tournament being in March.
I love this tournament being in March.
It is like, there's nothing better for the major league baseball season in terms of like a promotion or like, getting your fans amped up than this.
Like I'm opening day being a week and a half from now is like killing me.
Like I, like, I gotta wait another 10 days for baseball.
Like, are you kidding me?
but it's more than anything.
Like just, and also seeing Paul Skenes on this stage and seeing Oneil Cruz on this stage.
And like I said, the pirates have been pretty well represented throughout this tournament, seeing these guys in big moments in big games.
I need to see them do that on the pirates.
Like I got, I need, I need big time baseball games in Pittsburgh.
Cause it's been so long.
It's been, it's been over a decade since we've had games that really matter that much.
It has, it has, it's addicting.
Like now that I've got a little bit of a taste of it's like, all right, pirates.
I need some more of this.
Give me some more of this.
That's also what I like the WBC also.
Like you're talking about like, as a fan perspective towards the sport, like, absolutely.
like that, this is great.
It's great promotion.
It's a wonderful thing to have at this point in time.
I feel like for baseball, but like also look at it in the players thing.
Like you mentioned, Paul Skenes is on that big stage.
And like, we know how cerebral Paul is, and having him around all those people.
It's like, who knows how much more he's even taken back from this.
Cause this USA takes it serious, but like, especially the other countries.
they do, this is big, for again, the country, the team and everything.
So it was like having all of them in this big environment and now coming back and like getting that taste.
Like you said, you're craving it.
I wonder how much Paul's craving it.
I know it's a pretty good bit, but it's like all the players individually, like coming back from that.
And also it's like, I'm fired up, like now I'm back in pirates camp and, maybe Oh, no crew's sake as well as, like this was a, this was huge.
Like I want this also.
And the parts are building something here.
So it's like, how much are they coming back to camp craving that also?
And it's like, guys, let's effing do this.
I want to, I want to get back there and playing this type of baseball because that was fun.
And, AJ was here just not too long ago and he's talked about this environment that never witnessed, but I just witnessed something that he keeps, he talked about that was similar to this and like, yeah, let's do that.
So I don't know.
I hope maybe it gets the players juices going also.
Some, not only does it get the players juices going, but like it's valuable experience too, that a lot of these players don't have like Paul Skenes.
Now Paul Skenes is pitched in some pretty big baseball games.
He went to LSU, he's pitched in Omaha, he pitched in, big time college baseball games, but he hasn't pitched in anything all that big in the last couple of years.
There's all-star games, right?
And you can tell he takes those pretty seriously.
But so there's a couple all-star games, but the world baseball classic though, it's just on another level from all of those things and the atmosphere adds to it.
Like Paul Skenes going through that experience last night is a big developmental moment for him.
that's the, he's never going to face a team like that ever in the majors, right?
Like if the pirates somehow end up in the world series and they're facing the Yankees or the blue Jays or the Mariners or whoever it may be, that lineup is going to be not even half as good as what he just faced and the atmosphere might not even be on similar levels.
So it's like just going like Paul Skenes, being able to go through that last night is huge because now, ultimately the goal of all this to tie it back into the pirates is we
want Paul Skenes pitching in big time games in October and that's, it's great practice.
That was great practice last night.
That was outstanding practice for what you're going to see in a post-season game where you've got to win and he showed up and he probably learned some things from it.
And the next time he does it, hopefully this October, it's going to even be better for sure.
For sure.
And to go back, like you mentioned the dude shove again last night, we had a discussion about it, but the game before was the complete opposite.
that guy was feeling himself, no one was touching him.
And, it comes out of this two games that like you mentioned, like, I just feel like this is invaluable stuff, again, for a player like Paul Skenes who craves this so much.
this guy wants to, when you said about, taking the all-star game serious and this is the guy who doesn't, he takes everything serious.
I, nothing is like, Oh, it's just an all-star game.
Let's just have fun.
No, it's, how much can I take back from this?
How much can I learn?
See all these minds going to be around.
I'm going to be on the big stage here, throwing out the first inning, like I'm going to disappear.
And unlike Paul Skenes, he doesn't disappear from the bright lights.
What is happening?
I thought I fixed this camera.
I don't know.
That's two shows in a row where you just disappeared too.
So the point was fine.
Nah, that's a good point.
But anyways, yeah, no, you're absolutely right.
And again, it's just, it was cool to see, but more than anything, it gave me that, it gave me that itch where it's like, okay, it's time to see some, I want
to see more of this.
Yeah, absolutely.
Yeah.
Well, anything more on the world, on the world baseball classic?
I don't think now we didn't, we talked about him more last week, but just to say like, it was nice seeing, Oh no Cruz.
It was limited, but it was nice seeing what Oh no Cruz did this WBC, because that's a guy who bought out as well as every opportunity.
And even with last night he was, he did pinch hit was a big moment.
He didn't strike out.
Wasn't the prettiest at bat, but put the ball in play.
Advanced runner almost beat it out.
Like I'll just say that.
Yeah.
The dude almost beat out an infield single up the middle, just like a routine grounder to shortstop.
Yes.
Yeah.
So like he didn't strike out, make contact.
They didn't do much in that, which thankfully, cause again, we're rooting for team USA, but he had the ability to tie the game or, win the game, a walk-off Miller's up there
of pitching, he throws gas and it was a, it was a full count at one point or was it just two and two where he, it was a two count.
but I thought it was a pretty good, I bet.
he took, he took a first pitch breaking ball and I feel like Oh, Neil Cruz, especially in that type of situation is going to lean on being aggressive.
So like taking that first pitch now, it wasn't a very competitive pitch.
It was like way outside.
So that was just, that was on Mason Miller.
but then took another change up down, in the dirt and yeah, it was a huge moment for him to step up in and he's facing a pitcher.
That's insane.
I think he struck out, Cam and arrow on four pitches, just basically fastball, then got him with a slider to end the at bat.
it was filthy that one.
Yeah.
Mason Miller's nasty.
So yeah, it was a good, he hit it hard, hit it a hundred miles per hour, expected batting average of 300.
Like if he's doing that against that type of talent and he's that dialed in, yeah, hopefully we end up.
All right.
Yeah.
Part of me, I wasn't really sure what to think in that situation because an Oneil Cruz home run would have walked it off for the Dominican Republic.
And it's like, man, that would be really cool.
But then at the same time, I was like, I don't, it's like, I want USA to win.
So, right.
Right.
It was, that was, that was a fun moment in last night's game as well.
So for me, it was like maybe the best scenario he got out, but it didn't strike out.
He put the ball in play.
And again, like he also beat it out.
And then you mentioned it was a hundred mile an hour hit.
Like it wasn't like this soft hit.
he hit the ball hard and still almost beat this ball out.
So again, you want to understand why people get excited about Oneil Cruz, even on the ground out, he makes it look exciting.
Exactly.
So that was funny.
That was really it.
But also dude's fast and he hustled and he tried.
So maybe that too, like just the atmosphere of all this, maybe we see an entirely different Oneil Cruz this year.
It would be very nice.
Yeah.
It would be very nice.
40 back on the table, right?
Hey, I, 40 homers is a lot.
That's a lot of homers.
20, 40 is on the table.
Absolutely.
All right.
Almost did that last year.
Like Tyler pointed out on Friday.
Yep.
And that was a terrible season for him.
And he almost put up 20 homers, 40 stolen bases.
Yep.
Yep.
All right.
We're going to get, we're going to take a quick break from our sponsors and then we'll be back to talk about the fifth starter situation.
Boom.
This episode, this episode is brought to you by IQ Bar, our exclusive snack hydration sponsor.
IQ Bar protein bars, IQ Mix hydration mixes, and IQ Joe mushroom coffees are the delicious, low sugar, brain and body fuel you need to win your day.
The ultimate sampler pack is a great way for you to try all IQ Bar products and flavors.
You get nine IQ bars, eight IQ Mix sticks, and four IQ Joe sticks.
All IQ Bar products are clean label certified and entirely free from gluten, dairy, soy, GMOs, and artificial ingredients.
With over 20,000 five-star reviews and counting, more people than ever are fueling their lifestyles with IQ Bar's brain and body boosting bars, hydration mixes, and mushroom coffees.
The ultimate sampler pack includes all three.
My personal favorites so far have been the almond butter chip and the iced tea lemonade hydration mix.
It's just really full of flavor.
I love starting my day with it.
And I couldn't imagine starting my day with anything else other than IQ Bar products.
Right now, IQ Bar is offering our podcast listeners 20% off all IQ Bar products, including the ultimate sampler pack, plus free shipping.
To get your 20% off, text MLB to 64000.
That's MLB 64000.
Message and data rates may apply.
See terms for details.
Jim, ever since I've had an IQ Bar, I've yet to mispronounce José Urquidy's name incorrectly.
Look at you.
Just saying.
Speaking of José Urquidy.
Not the greatest start yesterday.
Let's talk about this fifth starter battle because I know we've been talking about it.
I feel like, every show and of course every show it's relevant, but we're now three weeks into this.
It's getting closer.
we're now, what, 10 days to opening day.
And yeah, with that being said, like the battles really mattering, who is going to be the fifth starter when of course they need one, but Urquidy made sense.
He lines up.
He, the history of being injured is there, but when he's not injured, he's been productive.
He comes from Houston, Bill Murphy, knows him familiar with him.
There's that Mike Clevenger, potentially an option as well.
That guy was a stud back in the day, but it's been a while since he's been that dude.
There's Hunter Barco, like on the outside looking in, he's a lefty, he's within the organization.
There's talent there for sure.
But I think ideally, right.
We talked about the pirates probably want them to ramp up and that would happen in triple a first is cover.
Mlodzinski coming out of the woodwork and winning this job.
And if so, rightfully so I'll say this.
I am most comfortable right now with Carmen Mlodzinski in that role.
So then you just have to weigh, is it better to have Carmen in that fifth spot or is it better to have Carmen where, he's going to be a dominant lights out multi-inning reliever
and that's valuable in its own right.
If you haven't checked it out, Alex Stumpf.
Well, first off, if you haven't heard, Alex Stumpf is doing a daily 15-minute show Monday through Friday with us.
So make sure you check it out.
His Monday episode is already out.
But on Friday, he talked about Carmen Mlodzinski and really just how last year went for him, how he started off the season as a starting pitcher, got knocked around specifically against
left-handed hitting, got sent down, worked on some things, came back and he was really an entirely new pitcher, came back with a new pitch arsenal, added a new splitter.
And that splitter is what he used to attack left-handed hitters the second half of the season.
And in the second half of the season, left-handed hitters like did nothing against Carmen Mlodzinski.
So that's the makings of a starter.
One is, can you get left-handed hitters out as a right-handed pitcher?
And two, can you do it more than once?
can you do it a second time?
Can you do it a third time if necessary?
We don't know the answer to the last two questions, to the last question there.
Like, can he do it more than once with this new arsenal?
Because, he was a reliever the entire time.
But with the improved results that he got versus left-handed hitters, I'm leaning towards let's find out.
Because if Carmen, out of all those guys that we're mentioning here, and I'm taking Hunter Barco out of the mix just because I just don't see Hunter Barco making this team.
Right.
I think there's a path.
I just don't think it's going to happen with the arms they have available on opening day.
I just don't think it's going to be on the opening day roster.
But out of those three guys, those three brothers, the Urquidy, Mlodzinski, and Clevenger, Mlodzinski has the highest upside, and he's probably got the highest floor, too.
So, like, at this point, that's probably where I'm leaning towards.
Urquidy has not looked good.
You have a couple options with him where you could either send him to the bullpen, or, like I said, it hasn't really been officially announced, but Alex hinted to it when
Urquidy was signed that there may be some advanced consent here on an additional option for him.
If that's the case, and the Pirates are able to option Urquidy to AAA to continue to work on being a starter, and then you can call him up if needed, maybe that's something that they do here.
Right.
I do think Clevenger, March 20th, so that's what, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, that's Friday.
So, by Saturday, you could see a roster move for Mike Clevenger because he's got an opt-out in his contract.
That's thanks to Ethan at MLB Spreadsheets.
So, my guess here, and from where I'm sitting, Mlodzinski, fifth starter, Clevenger to the bullpen to take that multi-inning relief role because I think it's more important to have a starting pitcher
who you can trust than a reliever.
And the upside with Mlodzinski with this new pitch mix, it's interesting enough that it makes me at least want to try it out.
And you know what?
If it works, awesome.
If it doesn't, you should be able to quickly pivot without really doing a whole lot of damage here.
a fifth starter is 20% of their starts.
20% of the games.
Like, it matters, you know?
I don't want to, like, just throw away, like, oh, who cares who the fifth starter is.
it does matter.
If that fifth starter is terrible and they're allowing, like, think about this.
Think about how Mlodzinski looked last year in that role, right?
If you're constantly giving up runs and looking that bad, you're throwing away, almost 20% of your games in that sense.
So, like, there is something that matters to it.
It's like you're saying, the relativity to it.
Does it matter more to have maybe a marginal upgrade than what Urquidy is or Clevenger at that fifth starter?
Or having that lights out in the bullpen as this long guy, multiple, used multiple ways.
And, again, like, I think ideally Mlodzinski as that reliever, that weapon in the bullpen.
Going back to, like, again, we talk about how, like, DaVinci was used in Houston for quite a bit.
So, it's like the problem is I want and need Urquidy to do more.
I want and need Clevenger to do more because, like, I want and need them to win that spot.
So, it's like going back to the Colin Conner quote that leaves no doubt to say, Carmen, just go back to the bullpen.
We're good.
But they're not doing it.
And that's the problem.
They're not.
So, now you have to concede what is best for the team.
Is it best to have Carmen there as the fifth starter?
Which, again, is still 20% of the starts, 20% of all your games to some level.
Or having him in that multi-inning role.
And at this point in time, because of how they're looking, I'm starting to lean that way.
Now, there's still some time and I still also go back and just feel like, you know what, Bailey Falter looked like trash in spring also.
And then his first five innings in Miami was trash.
And we were trashing Bailey Falter.
And then it was like, you know what, that was one of the best fifth starters we could have asked for in a long time.
And maybe it's just hopium coming in as well.
That, like, hey, maybe Arkady is just having a bad spring.
And the underlining metrics don't look good.
But, hey, they don't look good for Bailey Falter either.
And it's not like Arkady is much different of a pitcher than Bailey Falter.
It's like he was a strikeout artist and now he's not.
And he's lost it.
he's doing what Arkady does.
It's just not happening.
So, I'm still mixed, man.
I'm still torn.
I'm not sold yet on Mlodzinski.
But I'm absolutely open to the idea.
And what Alex said, and also, and of course, if you're listening to Alex, maybe we've made a mistake having you on because I'm tired of you changing my mind.
I listened to Offbeat.
I'm like, damn it.
Alex changed my mind on something again.
I was really opposed to having a Mlodzinski.
But, like, now hearing him say it, this stuff's all valid.
and I'll say this.
After seeing his last start, like, dude's got some stuff.
Dude's got some stuff.
And he has pitching really effective, this spring.
Maybe, again, I'm open.
I still want.
I'm still leaning and pushing.
Like, someone win this job.
But if they're not, I feel okay with Carmen Mlodzinski getting the fifth starter role this year.
Much more than it did last year.
And even seeing what he did last year when he got the role.
I'm still more comfortable right now in him winning the job.
Yeah, it's going to be an interesting case here because I feel like right now, like, Mlodzinski looks like the best option.
Like, if you just let's pretend that this was truly a competition and it was like, okay, best pitcher wins it.
Yeah.
It's not even a race.
Like, it's Mlodzinski, you know?
It's not close.
And I want to point something out here.
And I'm going to share a screen just so, present with the visual.
If you're listening to the show, just know that I'll walk through this as well.
But the thing I want to point out more than anything, one, like, he's getting that.
You can see that splitter is what he's leaning on against lefties.
Against left-handed hitters, he's throwing that splitter.
They're 47% of the time.
The splitter also had a 36% whiff rate when he threw it.
But the thing I want to present to you and point your eyes to is this velocity chart where it breaks down velocity by inning.
Like, his velocity started off at 95, then went to 95.3 in a second, 94.2, 94.6, 94.1.
So, like, what that shows me is, like, the stamina's there.
It's not that he's breaking down, as the game goes on, it's continuing through.
this, and he threw 70, one thing I hate about the new baseball savant.
Okay, so he threw 64 pitches, right?
And he maintained his velocity throughout his entire outing.
José Urquidy yesterday, if you look at it, look at this velocity by inning.
So, I'll zoom in.
I don't know if it doesn't need to work.
But started off at 93, dropped to 92.4 in the second, then 92.2 in the third, and then 90 in the fourth.
His fastball lost three miles per hour from the first inning to the fourth inning, which shows me just, like, can this dude actually pitch that long?
Like, he's never really been known for having an outstanding stuff in terms of his fastball.
And, he hasn't really pitched a lot these last two years.
So, like, how much can you really expect from this guy, especially going deep into a game?
So, like, is José Urquidy maybe better suited off for a role where he only, he can just go max effort for one or two winnings?
Because I'm telling you this, José Urquidy, if he's throwing 90 mile per hour fastballs in the fourth inning, like, it's not going to work.
Oh, no.
But the other stuff in the command isn't good enough for him to throw 90.
And it's not as if he gets by because he throws heat.
But there's still a difference between 93 and 90.
Yeah.
90 as a right-handed pitcher in Major League Baseball in the year 2026 is not good.
Not good.
Unless you have pinpoint control and you're extremely, and you have extremely good secondary pitches, 90 from the right side just doesn't work.
And Urquidy doesn't really have those other qualifications.
He's fine.
He's well-rounded.
But, like, there's no elite option there to throw you off.
So, I just wanted to share that because I feel like that was a big red flag for me this weekend was Urquidy broke down.
And, again, it's March 16th.
So, he's going to get another start.
He's still building his arm up.
But he broke down pretty good.
You can't be throwing the ball 90 miles an hour in the fourth inning.
And, again, Mijinsky has shown that at least the velocity holds up throughout the outing.
Yeah.
that's what we're alluding to.
It's a two-way street.
Like, it's not even just that Urquidy's not holding up.
But, as you point out, Mijinsky and, like, the damage in that game from Mijinsky was all done early.
It's not like he fell apart and then they scored the runs.
home runs out.
It happens.
It was a two-run homer by Adley Rushman.
Right.
Like, it happens.
That's going to happen.
That's the only runs he gave up was those two runs.
And he continued to maintain throughout the start.
That's what was impressive.
that's what's making you sit here going back and thinking, like, maybe we can try this experiment as a starter again.
Because Paul Skenes went 4.1 and gave up a home run.
Carmen Gens goes 5 and gives up two runs as a fifth starter.
Like, that's, again, like, that's perfectly fine.
That's what you're wanting from your fifth starter.
So, again, like, this isn't just the fact that those two aren't winning it.
It's like, oh, we've got to default to Mlodzinski.
This is, part of it is they're not winning it.
But the other part is, Mlodzinski?
All right.
Things are different.
and again, I always hound on this.
If things are different, I'm open to hearing it.
It's not just like, oh, the results are better.
But I think it's the same as last year.
Right?
he came in last year.
We talked and discussed.
He worked on the splitter.
He worked on the pitch mix, right?
He adds that curveball, which has been tremendous.
And that's what he's, like, bringing into this year.
And things are going to be different.
And it's like, let's try it again.
Let's run it back.
But we're going to run it back as a different pitcher almost entirely.
And so far, he's looked fine.
So, again, this isn't just the fact that these two aren't winning the job.
It also is part of the fact that, like, Mlodzinski is different.
And he's doing things that you want to see from a fifth starter.
So, he's actually winning the job.
And, again, it just comes down to, is that difference between Urquidy as a fifth starter and Mlodzinski as a fifth starter way more than Mlodzinski in that bullpen role.
And now that being, like you mentioned, maybe an Urquidy or something.
I don't know.
But, again, that's still 20% of your games as a fifth starter.
It matters.
Yep.
Last year, the Pirates went 3-6 with Carmen Mlodzinski as, like, a regular starter.
Now, keep in mind, I think, as a team, they were, like, 8-20, like, halfway through that stretch.
So, there's that.
They were just a really bad team last year.
But they lost twice as many games as they won with Mlodzinski starting.
Yeah.
What I was going to say is, in that same stretch, they also go 3-6 with Paul Skenes.
They probably went 2-7.
Right.
Exactly.
But, anyways, it's interesting.
I'll let you say that.
these next 10 days, there's still something you want to watch is these three guys because this fifth starter battle is interesting at this point in time.
Yeah.
Everybody's probably going to get at least one more start.
Maybe even two.
No.
One more start for the most part.
And, again, as Ethan points out in the comments here, like, a decision might have to be made on Mike Clevenger, by the end of the week.
Yeah.
Who do you feel is the safest?
Clevenger or Erkiti?
What do you mean by safest?
To make the roster an opening day.
I would still say Erkiti at this point just because he's the one on the 40-man roster.
But, I could see.
I could see.
I'm starting to get to the point where I don't know if both are going to make it.
But, I am leaning more and more towards Clevenger being on this opening day roster.
In terms of, like, that's what I think.
I would say that, too, because I feel like, yeah, if there's a guy that is also suited for the bullpen role because they're not winning the fifth starter, I feel like that's more of a Clevenger than Erkiti.
Yeah.
But, you talk about, he is already on the 40-man.
He's getting paid a salary.
Right.
So, again, that is why this whole battle is interesting.
There's a lot of things that could implicate the opening day starter or opening day roster.
Yeah, I think if you're the Pirates and you start with Clevenger in your bullpen on opening day, the reason why you're doing it is just like, hey, I'm going to use this guy to get me through, a couple months.
And maybe I catch lightning in a bottle.
But, like, if we're talking about who's going out there and impressing and winning the job, like, Clevenger hasn't won the job by any means.
Right.
Erkiti certainly hasn't.
And so, if this was something that was up for grabs, yeah, Mlodzinski's making the most of the situation so far.
There it is.
Well, I have nothing more to add on the fifth starter.
But I do think people, and that's what I think we're trying to do here, I do think people need to take the Mlodzinski thought seriously.
There is some validity to it.
This isn't just like, oh, the Pirates, like, they're idiots.
They're just doing the same thing over and over again.
There's something a little bit different.
Now, I'm not here to tell you that Mlodzinski is the answer.
I'm not here to tell you that he will be a good starter.
But there is some intrigue on that.
So, let's find out what happens, I guess.
Outside of that, do you want to talk about some announcements?
Yeah.
So, we've already dropped the information about the tailgate.
We'll see you guys on Wednesday for another NS9 Live.
Bye-bye.
See you guys.
All right.
That wraps up this episode of North Shore Nine.
Thanks so much for tuning in.
Whether you're listening on the podcast or catching us on YouTube, if you enjoyed the show, please give this video a thumbs up.
And don't forget to hit that subscribe button if you haven't already.
It really helps us grow.
And if you're listening on the podcast, a quick review goes a long way in helping others find the show.
Plus, be sure to tell a friend about us.
There's always room for more here in the NS9 community.
And for those looking to support us a little more, consider joining our Patreon, become an MVP member, and get exclusive perks while helping us continue to bring you more of the Pirates content you love.
Thanks again for all your support, and let's go Bucs.
Comments· 0
Should Carmen Mlodzinski be the Pirates' fifth starter instead of a multi-inning reliever?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.