◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)◆NEWSPirates, Chas McCormick Agree To Minor League Deal
◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)◆NEWSPirates, Chas McCormick Agree To Minor League Deal
Bob Nightengale says the Pirates could listen on Oneil Cruz as they search for bullpen help, but Alex Stumpf believes that approach misses the point. Cruz was producing at an All Star level before his injury, and no relief pitcher can match the impact of a center fielder with his ceiling. The Pirates need multiple relievers, not another hole in the lineup.
Watch or listen to the episode and subscribe to North Shore Nine for more Pirates coverage.
Comments· 0
The Debate
Would you trade Oneil Cruz for an elite reliever like Mason Miller at the deadline?
From Alex Stumpf’s take on the show
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.
With Alex Stumpf.
Chapters
Key takeaways
1
This deadline isn't the time to trade Oneil Cruz. With two years of team control left, a move this winter is far more likely than one at the deadline.
Alex Stumpf
2
Reynolds, Valdez, O'Hearn and Mangum have all been good, but that doesn't make Cruz the disposable outfielder. He still has the highest ceiling of the group.
Alex Stumpf
3
No trade for relief pitching gets back Cruz's full value. Even Mason Miller, who may be having the best reliever season since Eric Gagne, will finish with less WAR than Cruz.
Alex Stumpf
4
Trading Cruz for a reliever creates a new hole in center field. A potential All-Star center fielder is much harder to find than someone who can throw the seventh inning.
Alex Stumpf
5
The Pirates should trade prospects for relievers, plural. He sees no scenario where trading Cruz makes the 2026 team better or gets it into the playoffs.
You can have several ideas or beliefs that are fundamentally true, and whenever you combine them all, you get something that's just wrong. You lost the plot.
Alex Stumpf
This is a Pirates team that needs to add relievers this trade deadline. That is absolutely true.
Alex Stumpf
This is an offense that has succeeded and continued to perform at a very high level without Oneil Cruz. That is true.
Alex Stumpf
That doesn't mean that you should trade Oneil Cruz for relievers. It's not the time to consider an Oneil Cruz trade.
Alex Stumpf
Good morning and welcome to OffBeat here on North Shore Nine presented by FanDuel.
Alex Stumpf
My name is Alex Stumpf and this is a daily look at your Pittsburgh Pirates.
Alex Stumpf
It's come down to this.
Alex Stumpf
This has been a rumor that's been circling around for a while and I thought we were just going to be able to ignore this.
Alex Stumpf
But then USA Today's Bob Nightingale went on foul territory and he dropped some information on the Pirates.
Alex Stumpf
The first was walking back slightly his claim that he put in his Sunday column about how the Pirates would like to add this deadline, but maybe not increase payroll.
Alex Stumpf
Now I pointed out that they have, between trading the number 34 pick and the Joey Barr trade, freed up about $4 million of money they were going to spend that they haven't.
Alex Stumpf
And I'm not saying that's a huge chunk of change, but that's not insignificant.
Alex Stumpf
That could bring in a player or two, pay a third of their salary each.
Alex Stumpf
So he walked that back a little bit, but then he doubled down saying that the Pirates would be willing to listen to Oneil Cruz and whatever you have needs in the bullpen and maybe the rotation.
Alex Stumpf
They might consider it a trade.
Alex Stumpf
Now I, just to hit the inevitable here, Oneil Cruz is not going to be a lifer in Pittsburgh.
Alex Stumpf
I think there is an expiration date at some point on his tenure here in Pittsburgh.
Alex Stumpf
And theoretically, this trade deadline is one of those potential dates.
Alex Stumpf
I don't think it is.
Alex Stumpf
I don't think it is.
Alex Stumpf
This winter could potentially be.
Alex Stumpf
He has two years of team control left.
Alex Stumpf
So if not this winter, maybe the winter following.
Alex Stumpf
It's one of those.
Alex Stumpf
Yeah, it could theoretically happen.
Alex Stumpf
I just don't see it happening now.
Alex Stumpf
I think this winter is far more likely.
Alex Stumpf
Not to say that it is likely that O'Neal is going to get traded this winter.
Alex Stumpf
But if you were to ask me, is he going to get traded this deadline or this winter?
Alex Stumpf
No question.
Alex Stumpf
It's the latter.
Alex Stumpf
And I know you can look at this and be like, are the Pirates planning for life without Oneil Cruz?
Alex Stumpf
And I, there are enough breadcrumbs here that you can see that the Pirates have made contingency plans in center field.
Alex Stumpf
We've seen one in Jake Mangum, who has hit over 300.
He has an OPS around 770 entering play on Tuesday.
Alex Stumpf
He's done really well.
Alex Stumpf
He has done very well.
Alex Stumpf
But he was always brought in to be the extra outfielder.
Alex Stumpf
He has done great with this opportunity.
Alex Stumpf
I just don't know if you count on him to be an everyday center fielder.
Alex Stumpf
At least for a whole season or, henceforth, future years.
Alex Stumpf
The, Justinson Garcia trade is the first time whenever I really thought like, okay, that could be life after O'Neal.
Alex Stumpf
Because he can play center field.
Alex Stumpf
The Pirates and Red Sox had long been discussing a trade for a starting pitcher for an outfielder.
Alex Stumpf
And the way it was described to me was that trade took over a year to come to fruition.
Alex Stumpf
From whenever both teams, started talking, the names they were discussing, whatever it eventually came down to.
Alex Stumpf
How about Oviedo for Garcia?
Alex Stumpf
And just trading around some other pieces to make that work.
Alex Stumpf
To even it out.
Alex Stumpf
But that was the first time, especially whenever the Pirates are like, yeah, we feel very confident with him, et cetera.
Alex Stumpf
Then I'm like, okay, that could be a possibility.
Alex Stumpf
And I think they needed to come into this year with a very soft center field plan.
Alex Stumpf
That didn't involve Oneil Cruz because he had a very bad 2025 campaign.
Alex Stumpf
He did hit 20 homers.
Alex Stumpf
He did steal 38 bags, but that was not the Oneil Cruz the Pirates hoped he was going to be.
Alex Stumpf
They wanted him to be that guy who could just take control of a game and win it.
Alex Stumpf
And we have seen him do that in the past.
Alex Stumpf
This draft, they take Derek Hurriel with their first overall pick, fifth overall.
Alex Stumpf
And he's not major league ready yet, but if they wanted to hang on to Oneil Cruz for another year or two, it's reasonable to assume that he could be the heir apparent.
Alex Stumpf
So they have some options for whenever they do move on from Oneil Cruz.
Alex Stumpf
It's not like that's it.
Alex Stumpf
They have nobody else in center field, so you can't consider it.
Alex Stumpf
And actually, they have some outfield depth right now.
Alex Stumpf
Spencer Horwitz is starting a rehab assignment with Loe Bradenton.
Alex Stumpf
Esmerlyn Valdez has been outstanding up at the major leagues.
Alex Stumpf
So you look at it's like, okay, they actually have some outfield depth right now.
Alex Stumpf
Maybe you trade from that outfield depth.
Alex Stumpf
And they're not going to trade Reynolds.
Alex Stumpf
They're not going to trade O'Hearn.
Alex Stumpf
I see no reason why they should trade Valdez unless some team is convinced that he's the next Aaron Judge and will pay such a price for him.
Alex Stumpf
So I get how you look at that and be like, yeah, it's Cruz.
Alex Stumpf
All signs point to, he is the most disposable member of this outfield.
Alex Stumpf
And I really disagree with that.
Alex Stumpf
Because as good a season as Reynolds has had, and how he should have been an all-star.
Alex Stumpf
And how great Valdez has been at the start of his career.
Alex Stumpf
And the presence and the OPS that O'Hearn has brought to this club.
Alex Stumpf
And Jake Mangum, who has been everything they could have hoped for, really.
Alex Stumpf
And has handled center field duties very well.
Alex Stumpf
That doesn't mean Oneil Cruz is disposable because Oneil Cruz still has the highest ceiling out of all those guys.
Alex Stumpf
And I get we've talked ceiling for a while.
Alex Stumpf
And I don't know if he's ever going to fully reach his ceiling in Pittsburgh.
Alex Stumpf
But were you not paying attention to what he was doing before the injury?
Alex Stumpf
He really was looking like that type of impact player the Pirates hoped he was going to be.
Alex Stumpf
We're going to take a quick break.
Alex Stumpf
We'll be right back.
Alex Stumpf
This episode is brought to you by IQ Bar, our exclusive snack hydration sponsor.
Alex Stumpf
IQ Bar protein bars, IQ Mix hydration mixes, and IQ Joe mushroom coffees are the delicious, low sugar, brain and body fuel you need to win your day.
Alex Stumpf
The Ultimate Sampler Pack is a great way for you to try all IQ Bar products and flavors.
Alex Stumpf
You get 9 IQ Bars, 8 IQ Mix Sticks, and 4 IQ Joe Sticks.
Alex Stumpf
All IQ Bar products are clean label certified and entirely free from gluten, dairy, soy, GMOs, and artificial ingredients.
Alex Stumpf
With over 20,000 five-star reviews and counting, more people than ever are fueling their lifestyles with IQ Bars, brain and body boosting bars, hydration mixes, and mushroom coffees, the Ultimate Sampler Pack includes all three.
Alex Stumpf
My personal favorites so far have been the Almond Butter Chip and the Iced Tea Lemonade Hydration Mix.
Alex Stumpf
It's just really full of flavor.
Alex Stumpf
I love starting my day with it.
Alex Stumpf
And I couldn't imagine starting my day with anything else other than IQ Bar products.
Alex Stumpf
Right now, IQ Bar is offering our podcast listeners 20% off all IQ Bar products, including the Ultimate Sampler Pack, plus free shipping.
Alex Stumpf
To get your 20% off, text MLB to 64000.
Alex Stumpf
That's MLB 64000.
Alex Stumpf
Message and data rates may apply.
Alex Stumpf
See terms for details.
Alex Stumpf
Whenever Cruz went on the injured list, he had played in 64 games with 14 home runs, 44 RBI, 21 stolen bases, a 350 OBP, 472 slugging.
Alex Stumpf
That was good for a 123 WRC+.
Alex Stumpf
He was producing 23% more offense than the average hitter in baseball.
Alex Stumpf
And he was in a bit of a lull power-wise.
Alex Stumpf
He was still finding ways to get on base.
Alex Stumpf
And that's such a big part of the maturation of his game, to just find ways to make an impact, even whenever you don't have the power going.
Alex Stumpf
We know he's fast enough.
Alex Stumpf
If he draws a walk, he can just steal second.
Alex Stumpf
That's effectively as good as a double at that point.
Alex Stumpf
There's a lot of ways he can impact the baseball game.
Alex Stumpf
And I get that he probably won't ever reach that full, fullest potential.
Alex Stumpf
Because the fullest potential of Oneil Cruz is an MVP.
Alex Stumpf
Whenever you hit as hard as he does, and you throw as hard as he does, and you run as fast as he does, his ceiling is the best player in the game.
Alex Stumpf
And I get he's not going to reach that in Pittsburgh.
Alex Stumpf
But he's still really good.
Alex Stumpf
And you don't throw away really good players whenever you are trying to make a run this year.
Alex Stumpf
I know he's been absent from the lineup, but that doesn't mean you don't need him.
Alex Stumpf
As good as Jake Mangum has been, that 771 OPS is still significantly less than what Oneil Cruz has produced.
Alex Stumpf
You could be like, oh, they're going to bring back Mason Miller.
Alex Stumpf
First of all, that is a purely hypothetical trade.
Alex Stumpf
Second, this is a line or a bullpen that needs more than one arm.
Alex Stumpf
I don't care about having the best closer in the game if your bullpen's just going to blow it in the seventh or the eighth.
Alex Stumpf
This team needs multiple relievers.
Alex Stumpf
Third of all, you're allowed to trade prospects for major league players.
Alex Stumpf
This is the year you do that.
Alex Stumpf
Yeah, if you want to explore, major league player for major league player, maybe you could open up, the amount of teams, expand the amount of teams you can make a trade with right now.
Alex Stumpf
But I really don't get the logic of trading Oneil Cruz right now.
Alex Stumpf
Except, I've been hearing trade Oneil Cruz for years.
Alex Stumpf
People last trade deadline.
Alex Stumpf
Whenever Cruz was in by far the worst year of his career.
Alex Stumpf
They were clamoring, just trade him, get rid of him, start over.
Alex Stumpf
Boy, how stupid would that have been if you saw this guy who, even after a stint on the 60-day IL, is in a pretty good position to be another 2020 player where he's going to produce, a 120-something WRC+.
Alex Stumpf
What he does on the base paths and everything.
Alex Stumpf
Like, trading him last year would have been such a catastrophic mistake for a multitude of reasons.
Alex Stumpf
One of the biggest being, you're not going to get his full value back.
Alex Stumpf
There is no trade where you get Oneil Cruz's full value back whenever you trade him for relief pitching.
Alex Stumpf
Oneil Cruz will be worth more war at the end of the year than Mason Miller.
Alex Stumpf
As dominant as Mason Miller is, he is having maybe the greatest season we have seen from a relief pitcher since Eric Gagne Cyung.
Alex Stumpf
He has been outstanding, brilliant, every single word.
Alex Stumpf
I don't think there's any chance he lands in Pittsburgh, but if he does, that would be such a get.
Alex Stumpf
Some might even call it the Chris Archer trade of 2026.
Alex Stumpf
He's a great player, but at the end of the day, Oneil Cruz plays more.
Alex Stumpf
He makes a greater impact offensively than you could ever make by throwing just one inning.
Alex Stumpf
You cannot trade Oneil Cruz, and I don't mean that in like the, you shouldn't.
Alex Stumpf
Like, no, you can't trade him and get a fair value back in relief pitching.
Alex Stumpf
And while we did talk about how maybe they need to get another starting pitcher here, it's not dire enough that you trade Oneil Cruz to get someone like that.
Alex Stumpf
This guy has been, he has the potential to be the best hitter in the lineup.
Alex Stumpf
And I feel like we could finally say that now because for two months, two and a half months, he was.
Alex Stumpf
I get their concerns that this is now a 60-day IAL trip.
Alex Stumpf
And that anyone coming back from a hand, especially power hitters, you have a raised eyebrow.
Alex Stumpf
I totally get that.
Alex Stumpf
The people who were saying last year, whenever he was in the worst year of his career, you say, oh, just give up on him, trade him, be done with it.
Alex Stumpf
There are no discussions of him on the injured list.
Alex Stumpf
Be like, oh, just be done with it.
Alex Stumpf
Get relief pitching back.
Alex Stumpf
Get a need back.
Alex Stumpf
Well, you know what's going to be a need if you trade Oneil Cruz for relief pitching?
Alex Stumpf
Center field.
Alex Stumpf
Do you know what's a lot harder to find?
Alex Stumpf
A potential all-star center fielder versus someone who could throw the seventh inning.
Alex Stumpf
I really don't think this discussion point makes any sense.
Alex Stumpf
And I think there is a lot of bad faith of people who have just wanted to trade Oneil Cruz for years that are really latching on to this right now.
Alex Stumpf
This guy, it's going to take about a week of him being back in the everyday lineup, wherever you're like, oh, yeah, Oneil Cruz, he's a good baseball player.
Alex Stumpf
This isn't object permanence.
Alex Stumpf
Just because he hasn't been in the lineup doesn't mean he's gone forever.
Alex Stumpf
This is a really good hitter.
Alex Stumpf
This team needs bullpen help.
Alex Stumpf
Trade prospects to get the relievers.
Alex Stumpf
Relievers, plural.
Alex Stumpf
This winter, at the winter meetings, I was told, we are going to acquire hitters, plural.
Alex Stumpf
Do it again.
Alex Stumpf
Relievers, plural.
Alex Stumpf
Because that's what they need.
Alex Stumpf
There is no scenario where you trade Oneil Cruz and you 100% fix your bullpen.
Alex Stumpf
So why bother?
Alex Stumpf
And even if you could, Oneil Cruz is going to be providing more value for you than any relief pitcher would.
Alex Stumpf
I really don't like this trade.
Alex Stumpf
Whatever comes this winter, if you want to explore it, hear him out.
Alex Stumpf
Even now, this trade deadline, I guess, hear him out just in case someone makes a really stupid offer.
Alex Stumpf
But I do not see any scenario that the 2026 Pirates get better by trading Oneil Cruz.
Alex Stumpf
And if the goal is to make the playoffs, period, full stop, you don't do that by trading Oneil Cruz.
Alex Stumpf
Anyway, thank you for listening to OffBeat here on North Shore Nine presented by FanDuel.
Alex Stumpf
If you haven't already, be sure to subscribe wherever you find podcasts or check us out on YouTube to see my smiling face.
Alex Stumpf
Thank you so much for listening.
Alex Stumpf
We will talk again tomorrow.
Alex Stumpf
All right, that wraps up this episode of North Shore Nine.
Alex Stumpf
Thanks so much for tuning in.
Alex Stumpf
Whether you're listening on the podcast or catching us on YouTube, if you enjoyed the show, please give this video a thumbs up.
Alex Stumpf
And don't forget to hit that subscribe button if you haven't already.
Alex Stumpf
It really helps us grow.
Alex Stumpf
And if you're listening on the podcast, a quick review goes a long way in helping others find the show.
Alex Stumpf
Plus, be sure to tell a friend about us.
Alex Stumpf
There's always room for more here in the NS9 community.
Alex Stumpf
And for those looking to support us a little more, consider joining our Patreon, become an MVP member, and get exclusive perks while helping us continue to bring you more of the Pirates content you love.
Alex Stumpf
Thanks again for all your support, and Let's Go Bucs.
Comments· 0
Would you trade Oneil Cruz for an elite reliever like Mason Miller at the deadline?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.