◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
The Pittsburgh Pirates’ brief flirtation with Framber Valdez was a reminder of just how quickly optimism can turn into reality in baseball.
For a few hours, it felt like something big might be brewing. Reports suggested the Pirates were “aggressively” pursuing the left-hander, and fans allowed themselves to imagine what an already strong rotation could look like with another frontline arm. Then, almost instantly, it was over. Valdez signed elsewhere, forcing the organization—and fans—to pivot in real time. The Pirates Answer Is Adding Fr…
In truth, this was always more rumor than reality. Valdez was likely outside Pittsburgh’s realistic price range, and the timing of the reports had all the fingerprints of savvy agent work. Still, the buzz mattered. It showed that people around the league at least view the Pirates as a team worth linking to impact players. That hasn’t always been the case.
Now, the focus shifts back to what actually lies ahead. Mitch Keller remains the rotation’s stabilizer. Paul Skenes, Jared Jones, and the young arms still represent the organization’s greatest strength. If the Pirates add anything pitching-wise, it will likely be a familiar, lower-cost veteran who can eat innings rather than a headline-grabber.
Offensively, however, the questions remain. Third base and left field are still unsettled. The lineup still lacks a true middle-of-the-order force. And with spring training approaching, the clock is ticking.
The Valdez rumor didn’t change the Pirates’ outlook—but it highlighted the frustration of a fanbase waiting for a real breakthrough. This team has the pitching to compete. Now it’s on the front office to prove that “interest” and “aggression” can turn into meaningful action.
Comments· 0
The Debate
Should the Pirates trade for a true third baseman like Paredes and make Jared Triolo a super-utility man, instead of starting Triolo at third every day?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.
With Anthony DiNardo and Tyler Sweeney.
Chapters
Key takeaways
1
Hot take: if he's healthy, Mike Clevenger breaks camp in the Pirates' bullpen. His spring last year (12 K/9, 1.5 BB/9, fastball back to 94) points that way, and he can beat out Evan Sisk or Yohan Ramírez for one of the last spots.
2
Signing Valdez was the only scenario that justified trading Mitch Keller. With Valdez gone, nobody the Pirates can acquire is worth moving him for, and Keller starts the year in Pittsburgh.
3
Prediction: by mid-spring training the Pirates sign either José Quintana or Tyler Anderson. Both are cheap, left-handed, veteran innings-eaters who have pitched for Pittsburgh before.
4
Marcell Ozuna can't play the field and would push O'Hearn or Reynolds into left. If the Pirates go that route, they should just bring back Tommy Pham, a right-handed bat who can handle left field.
5
The real third-base question isn't whether a new guy beats Triolo, it's whether he beats Nick Gonzales. Adding someone like Paredes and keeping Triolo as a 400-PA super-utility man makes the team better.
Yo. Welcome to the North Shore Nine Podcast presented by FanDuel. This is NS9 Live and I'm your host, Anthony DiNardo. With me, we have Tyler. Not with us is Jim.
And also not joining us tonight is Frambois Valdez. So, how do you do, Tyler?
Oh, man. I thought we were on a great track. We talked earlier, had a good game plan coming into the night show.
The Frambois Valdez rumors were starting to heat up. I don't think any of us thought that the Pirates were going to get him.
But it was a fun topic. It was a fun little exercise. And three minutes before the show, bang, gone.
Had to create a whole new overlay.
I didn't even know what happened. Honestly, I sat down. You're the one who joined the stream before the show and said, well, we got a pivot.
I was like, hey, Tyler, how's it going? Like, no, we got a pivot.
I was like, what do you mean?
It would have been Frambois Valdez just signed with the Detroit Tigers for, was it three years?
115? Yeah.
Whew.
Yeah.
That's a big enough.
We're definitely in that one.
Yeah, I think that one's a little bit out of their price range.
They couldn't meet Suarez at 15. So, you know what? What's another 100 million?
Yeah. And look, Frambois is a really good pitcher. He'll probably do good things there.
That's a lot of money. And it is what it is, man. That's OK.
Yeah.
Go get yours.
Yeah.
Go get yours, buddy.
Again, at the very least, we thought we had a talking point tonight.
I guess we might as well just talk a little bit about it at this point in time.
it was earlier today that Ken Rosenthal put out there that the Pirates are aggressively, the most aggressive, aggressively going after Frambois Valdez, the lefty starting pitcher who,
it's funny because, like, I think, this isn't like us or anything.
It's just that was a guy people thought, like, hey, Billy.
Oh, God. Now I'm going to forget his last name.
What's the coach's?
Billy Murphy.
Murphy. I was going to say Martin. It's like, it ain't Martin.
Billy Murphy comes from Houston.
There's some ties there. It's, PNC Park, if you're a lefty, that's somewhere to go.
Some people are talking about, is this maybe like a one-year prove-it deal that he needs to do because of the whole situation of, him throwing the ball at the catcher, crossing him up.
But apparently not so much.
Yeah. Apparently that didn't hurt him as badly as people thought it might have.
Right.
Maybe the Pirates drove up his price a little bit here.
Well, it probably was a good bit of agent work there and good work by the agent for sure.
Because he got him some money.
Yeah. Or at least those guaranteed years or who knows.
hey, I was actually the one that made the graphic today and posted it out.
And that's what I posted in the caption.
do you think they actually are in on him?
And they're being aggressive and trying to pursue?
Or is this just agents trying to create a narrative?
And it is funny because, like you mentioned, it all happened the same day.
Now, the timing made sense, which, again, if you're an agent, that's how you would play it.
Like, oh, the Pirates have been in on some big names.
again, they have been attached.
They were attached to Schwarber.
They were attached to Suarez.
They were attached to Polanco.
They're attached to quite a few guys, the guys coming over from overseas.
They missed out on all of them.
If I'm an agent that I'm trying to get from or paid, I'm going to say, oh, there's a perfect opportunity.
Oh, you missed out on Suarez?
Oh, you know what I'm hearing?
Ken, you know what I'm hearing?
Buddy, Pirates, they're trying.
You see it?
They're trying.
I'm hearing this.
I'm hearing this.
I can tell you firsthand.
Pirates, they've stepped up, man.
Now they've missed out on Suarez.
Man, they have stepped up.
They're all in on all in on from or get it out there.
And Ken goes, oh, OK.
Hey, guys, Ken Rizenthal here.
And the Pirates are aggressive on Framper Valdez.
And what happens the same freaking night that we go to post a show?
He signs.
That's how it's done.
Kudos to the agent.
For real.
Kudos to that agent.
Hey, it stinks.
It's like only because the recent Suarez stuff.
And again, I didn't really think they were going to get him.
Not at all.
I didn't think this was really an option.
It was a fun little rumor.
But with the Suarez stuff that happened and with the Valdez crossing up his catcher, like there are a lot of thoughts out there.
I think that nobody would want him.
Or at least he would have to take a discounted deal.
Like you said, a prove it deal.
Right.
There were those thoughts.
Not so much.
No one wanted him.
But the market's not as robust as it could be.
So maybe, hey, let's reenter, get a one year deal and say, hey, guys, I am a nice guy.
Right.
just have your little PR year, be a great teammate, and then get back to the market in 2020 when the lockout's over.
Right.
But, and really, I was thinking that just because, him doing the mental gymnastics like Suarez, the market wasn't there for him.
It ended up being a one year, $15 million deal.
The stars look like they might be aligning here as well.
Maybe this is that stars aligning moment.
Well, didn't work.
The agent played us.
Good for him.
I'll at least say this.
And I guess this ties up some things, too, because, again, that was Ken Rosenthal who had that message.
And it was followed, rather quickly by Jason Mackey.
Seemed like he cross-checked some sources.
And Dan Zangrilli also, I think, said something earlier to the tune of this.
And it's just like, I don't know about that.
Like, that's not what I'm really hearing.
And, again, like Mackey came out and he was like, there's interest.
There's certainly interest.
But as far as, like, being aggressive and all this, the smoke that's appearing right now, I'm not really hearing that.
They would like him.
Like, there's definitely been talk, right?
But it seems like it's probably going to be a long shot if it happens.
Well, one, I'm sorry, three years, $115 million.
Yeah.
Yeah.
That's a long shot.
Yeah.
All right.
You got to pivot now.
We had to pivot on the show.
The Pirates have to pivot off that.
You know what, though?
The difference is we have to pivot in three minutes.
The Pirates have now taken successfully about 34 days since O'Hare and something like that.
Yeah.
Oh, actually, longer.
It's like 40-some days.
Yeah.
And they had all that time to plan this as well.
We had three minutes.
Yeah.
Yeah.
We don't get that luxury.
You know what?
We could just tell everyone we have a good show.
We're interested in having a really good show tonight, fellas.
Yeah.
We are very interested in having a good show.
I'm thinking, at the very least, next week.
Can you just leave?
Sorry, I was playing my Ben Cherington there.
Yeah.
I was just leaving.
Well, at the very least, I'm thinking next week I might try to be a little more aggressive with my thoughts.
There you go.
That's good to hear.
I'm thinking about it.
I'll write about it.
Thank you.
You know what?
Put that out there.
I'm telling my sources that.
You got it.
Yeah, man.
Like I said, it's not disappointing because, again, I don't think any of us really thought it was going to happen.
So much of the fact, hey, Greg Hoyle, if you're on the show right now, last night you tweeted an idea.
Is there a potential they could pivot and go after Frambois Valdez?
And I said, I don't see that happening.
Then the news broke today.
And you said, hey, maybe I was on to something.
Well, now I'm back to being right.
But, yeah, we still have some things to talk about.
We're going to go back to, I guess, the original things we were going to talk about before the Frambois stuff.
But before we do that, Tyler, I think we need to do something that the people need.
I want to ask you a bunch of questions.
And I want to have them answered immediately.
It's the North Carolina's really stupid question.
Now, last week, we got left on red.
Our very first unsuccessful attempt at doing this.
Now, this week, we're going to try to get back into the win column.
We do have a question.
Tyler, why don't you tell everyone what the question is?
Okay.
Today's question is going to be, as soon as I find it here, because I texted it to you.
If you could erase one minor inconvenience from human life forever, what are you picking?
Hopefully, this week, we have more of an answer rather than a reader.
We'll find out.
Oh, the pun!
Oh, that was good work, Tyler.
That was good work.
Let's see who that will be.
So, let's go ahead and spin this wheel.
Let's find out who's going to get asked the question this week.
Oh, my God.
You're sending it.
I have my doubts.
We're going to get back into the win column.
I think we're going on a losing streak here.
This is a very bad night for us.
It's all around.
It's a terrible evening.
We're missing out on Frambois Valdez.
Now, we're about to miss out on Livy Dunn.
For the people listening to the podcast, yes, it's landed on Livy Dunn.
Of all the people on this list we have had an interaction with, we talked to, there's open dialogue.
Except for Livy Dunn.
We're like, you know what?
Let's put her on there.
Let's shoot for the stars.
If it comes up, let's see what happens.
Well, I guess we're going to find out what happens.
You told me I have to do it?
Oh, I'm not sending that.
All right.
Well, then you got to carry the show.
Well, I'm just hoping that these stupid question things aren't done when we go over to.
Oh, I'm on a heater.
Oh, boy.
You know what the sad thing is?
This is one of my favorite questions that we've had.
This probably is my favorite question.
Of all the questions we've asked, this one.
And there are so many good first world country answers.
Batteries dying in your remote.
I'd fix that tomorrow.
Just dead batteries in general I could get rid of.
Stubbing your toe.
If there's a way to fix that.
Forgetting a password is a good one.
Just don't forget the pirate's password.
Don't leave him on a plane.
And one of my biggest inconvenience, I think, in my life is turning in a timesheet every two weeks.
I hate doing that.
I don't know why.
I just hate doing it.
You know what?
I've come accustomed to hating.
Now you mentioned that.
Travel logs.
So bad.
So bad.
Sending emails.
Just emailing.
I hate emails.
Well.
Bad internet connections.
Oh, there it is.
There it is.
I have my answer.
And it came from the chat.
And I can't believe I forgot it.
Jack running out of chapstick.
That is my answer.
That is 100% my answer.
That's absolutely a title.
And that is a loyal viewer right there that knows it.
I keep that thing on me.
I keep that thing on me.
One minor.
You know what?
I didn't really actually think about this question as far as answering it.
There's so many.
There is a lot.
I don't know.
Let's keep the show moving.
We have successfully reached out to Libby Dunn and dropped with a question.
I don't feel we're going to get an answer.
But I tried.
I'm very curious what her minor inconvenience would be.
We tried, though, Tyler.
We were close.
We were definitely aggressive in our pursuit to get an answer tonight.
I just really want to know what would be a minor inconvenience to Libby Dunn?
Podcast is reaching out to answer a stupid question.
Fair enough.
All right.
So back to today's news.
So, again, the Pirates did not land Frambois Valdez.
But they did get a pitcher.
He's not Frambois Valdez.
But I'll say this.
At one point in time, he was definitely a very interesting and a solid pitcher.
That was Mike Clevenger.
He had – actually, was it Tommy John?
Before I just threw that off?
Yeah.
He had a lot of stuff, I feel like.
He's been hurt.
Yeah.
That's a good call.
So many times.
If he didn't have Tommy John recently, he had it at some point.
So, with that said, really hasn't pitched much in the majors over the past two years.
He was in – well, he has been in Chicago.
But when he last pitched for pretty much a full year, he was in Chicago.
Pitched pretty effectively.
he had 131 innings pitched, came with a 3.77 ERA.
But, I want him to go back to his, like, his times, coming up.
when he was with Cleveland, this dude was a stud.
He got traded to the Padres.
Had some really good years with the Padres.
And that's when, again, things went wiry.
Goes to the Chicago White Sox.
Doesn't finish out his time there.
But he signs for a minor league deal with the Pirates.
Now, again, for a team that had a lot of pitching, they don't really have a lot of good depth.
I just look at this as that.
Like, hey, here's an arm.
It's a minor league deal.
Invited to spring training camp.
Let's see what's left.
Hot take.
Clevenger's going to start the year in the bullpen.
On the major league team.
I don't think there's a doubt in my mind he will.
As long as he's healthy, I think he will break camp in the pen.
And last year, coming into the year with the White Sox, he was going to be in the bullpen.
Last year, really bad year.
injuries just derailed the entire season.
He really didn't pitch.
The year before that, not much there either.
Like, he's been down for a while.
You're not really, I guess, counting on this guy.
But if he's healthy, I think he breaks camp with this team.
And you look at last year's spring training.
He was outstanding.
Six innings, 12 strikeouts per nine, one and a half walks per nine.
I know it's spring training, but it showed the stuff was starting to come back.
You saw the fastball play up a little more last year.
He's back up 94.
If he's healthy, I think he breaks camp in the bullpen.
That's interesting.
And I guess I never thought of it as a bullpen situation.
I was looking at it as like, yeah, starter depth.
So Mike Clevenger has basically been.
This is a team that can use some depth, but also could definitely use some depth in the bullpen, like you're mentioning here.
OK, I got to marinate on that, I think, a little bit again, though, like the guy has arm talent.
Yeah, he's really dealt through a lot of injuries and injuries can certainly derail that talent.
And that's the one thing I do want to talk a little bit about here as well.
you didn't have like successful seasons last year in the minors where he was for the most part.
Like I told you, he had very limited innings pitched in the majors the past two years.
When he was up for the majors last year, again, it was like what, 5.2 innings pitched, like whatever, 7.94, right?
Like whatever.
In the minors, though, in AAA, 100 innings pitched, 4.2 ERA.
The year before that, just the 21 innings pitched, 5.4 ERA.
Like it hasn't been outstanding.
You look at the peripherals, like you mentioned, the velocity is back up, but they're like middle of the road.
It's nothing like stands out and just says like, oh, like this is going to be back or he's washed, you know?
Like I'm not also getting the impression of like, oh, he's washed.
It's just, he certainly doesn't seem the guy that he was.
So I guess to your point, maybe the bullpen speaks a little bit here.
And I would guess at this point, it probably comes down to Yohan Ramirez and Mike Clevenger.
Cause if you look at the bullpen, the last two spots are Evan Sisk and Yohan Ramirez.
I think that Mike Clevenger can beat that out.
Now I think they might add more.
They might add more to the pen here.
It's a spot.
They could probably add a little more and we'll see what happens, how it shakes out with some of these younger guys.
Okay.
Sorry.
I was reading the chat there and said something about Azuna and was afraid that he got signed somewhere else as well.
And we were just going to get derailed.
Not again.
When you get to like the seventh, eighth guy in that bullpen, there's not a guy that, I'm really clamoring to hang on to.
So if Clevenger shows up as a spring, like he did last year and does it against some of the better talent and doesn't do it in like the mop up duty late crap.
I think he breaks camp in the pen.
I guess the way I look at that is maybe though, still, maybe the fact that if it's a minor league deal, maybe he just sits in the monitors until there's a bigger need.
Either way, the bull, either, or I, you bring up a good point.
I'm interested to find out where the pirates see the fit.
Is it rotation depth or is it bullpen depth?
I guess we'll find out in spring.
I guess we'll probably find out maybe in a week, pitchers and catches report.
Maybe there'll be some indication.
I don't know.
Maybe Ben Cherington will speak and let us know.
We'll probably have to wait.
Yeah.
Just the way I look at it.
It's a 35 year old pitcher that has a ton of injury history.
If you're trying to get anything out of them here.
It's not going to be in the rotation.
I think that ship sailed.
Okay.
If you're trying to get anything out of them, I think you put them in the pen.
Go from there.
Gotcha.
again, like I don't hate it.
Also, it's a minor league deal.
There's no reason for anyone to freak out.
Right.
Anyone.
Anyone who's talking about like dumpster diving or whatever, like it's, this is just what you do.
You stack arms, you stack arms.
The problem is not getting other guys like, and again, from Revaldez isn't the problem.
they didn't need a from Revaldez essentially for this rotation.
The problem is not getting players on the major league team that can take you out of that hump and make you a good team.
But anytime someone does this type of deal, like it's whatever, it's whatever.
They're still doing the right things.
They find a guy, some intriguing stuff, something that's interesting.
And they decide like, hey, let's bring that guy in.
We need potentially some depth somewhere.
So it's just, yeah, like it just is what it is.
He does have something that's interesting though, as far as his arm.
Can I have one more like little caveat into it?
You got it.
I think you know where I'm going.
He's a guy you can piggyback with.
You can definitely mix him and, well, I don't know if you would mix him and Mlodzinski.
They're similar, I think.
But either way, he can fit that role.
Yeah.
I think you can.
So maybe some of his starter background.
he could be a two to three inning guy possibly.
you throw another guy in there, Chris Devenski.
I've always loved.
I don't know how much is left in that tank, but this is a great team in 2018.
And then you also have like eight-year-old Konnor Griffin knocking on the door, which I think I still would take.
And if it's the beginning of the year, we still have Tyler Glass now.
There you go.
But yeah, again, I don't think we need to talk too much more about Clevenger, but there's obviously not too much more on the show we need to talk about either.
So, but no, there it is.
It's again, just whatever.
So let's pivot from there.
Unless did you have something else?
Is there an answer yet?
Not yet.
Dang.
I checked my texts.
Nothing in my texts.
Let me check my direct messages.
Check your email.
Yeah.
Oh, yeah.
We have a PR person's contact information.
We can just reach out to them.
Yeah.
We'll have our people contact our people.
Our people is Frambois Valdez's agent also, by the way.
All right.
So, again, yeah.
Pivoting back to that.
So, obviously, our conversation and all of our talking points about Frambois Valdez out the window.
I thought it was going to be pretty interesting, though.
because it takes you some places.
Like, if you were to add Frambois Valdez, like, does that mean maybe a Mitch Keller trade is lined up?
Is this the way of, like, you know what?
Let's add to his strength and keep Mitch Keller and just make this rotation, like, completely lights out?
Or is it like, you know what?
We have this trade on the back burner.
If we can do this, then we can maybe do that.
Is there maybe a trade for Mitch Keller to add a third baseman?
I don't know.
There's a lot of lakes to this, a lot of ways that it could go.
That's all out the door.
So, now it's just simply back to where we were.
Like, what are we doing with our base?
In left field.
And, yeah, to the degree.
And shortstop at the beginning of the year.
So, what are we doing, Tyler?
Well, you mentioned if they were to sign Valdez.
And, also, that would be three Valdezes on this roster.
Mitch Keller was here after they traded Michael Burroughs, I felt.
You know?
they traded Oviedo for Password.
And that was like, well, that makes sense.
And then once they traded Burroughs, it just seemed like, well, they really can't afford to trade anymore starting pitching.
Like, regardless if it was Mitch Keller or somebody else, it just seems like at this point in time, just after those two are gone, that everyone in the rotation is probably safe unless they were to make another trade for another pitcher or sign someone else.
Like, I don't even think, like, a José Quintana adding him is a situation where, like, okay, now we feel good about trading Mitch Keller.
Maybe.
Like, maybe you can talk me into that.
But, yeah, it was like at that point, I felt like Mitch Keller is pretty much safe on this roster until this morning when I heard about Fromber.
And that's when I was like, that's the scenario.
Like, that is a scenario where, and the issue with this is it's very MLB the show.
It's like, oh, yeah, just do this.
Just do all these moving parts, right?
Just do these things that are virtually impossible to make all of them complete.
But it's like, yeah, if maybe there was something in the back burner lined up, right?
But, like, hey, there's an opportunity where you think we have this deal on the table.
And when they missed out on Suarez, Ben looks and goes, maybe we get Fromber.
Like, you know what?
Maybe let's do it.
Like, maybe let's push a little more chips in here.
Let's go get Fromber because I know I can trade Mitch Keller for this guy.
So then the money starts evening out also.
Like, if he is $30 million a year, which clearly it's more.
But you're assuming it's going to be $30 million a year.
Well, now, when you trade Mitch Keller's contract, that's, you're really only adding about $13 million to payroll.
If you're willing to do $15 million for Suarez, like, you're in that ballpark still.
And you are upgrading your starting pitcher with him also, you know?
So, like, there is an upgrade there.
You're still within the money.
And, again, like, what's that trade with Mitch Keller bring back to?
I don't know.
But maybe there's an upgrade there somewhere.
So, yeah, like, you could make sense of it.
But now that ship's gone because there's not really another starting pitcher that you can do that to, at least on the free agent market.
No, not at all.
I'm completely with you.
Like, I wasn't, I probably wasn't going to $30 million for him.
But if he would have fell into the 2025 territory, I definitely would have been more intrigued.
And at that point, yes, I think you do have to probably, or at least, I don't think you do.
I would have kept them both and been fine with it because it's not my money.
But in the Pirates situation, with the money they have, I think they probably would have had to move on from Mitch Keller.
But that's the only scenario I would have done so.
At this point, I'm riding with Mitch Keller for now.
Really, you can't afford to get rid of him.
They still need another arm.
You get rid of him.
The only guy you've had to basically throw over 99 innings in a season, and that's Carmen Mlodzinski also.
Who you want to be in the reliever role.
I'll say that with Braxton Ashcraft, 69 innings last year or something like that.
That's who's next in line for, like, major league innings.
You just can't.
Like, that's why Mitch Keller is so valuable to this team.
You got to have some glue here on this rotation.
There's a lot of young, intriguing arms.
And all of them could be better than Mitch Keller.
Every single one.
That's what's cool about this rotation.
They're sexy.
But, Tyler, there's a lot of unknown.
There's a lot of, not a whole lot of major league experience.
Mitch Keller at least provides you that stability.
Every fifth day, he's going out there, and he's giving you at least six innings, which is today's game.
That's what you're asking for.
He's going to do that for you.
From day one to game 162, hopefully plus.
He's going to do that for you.
And that means a lot, especially to a rotation like this.
Paul Skenes, you assume he's going to do the same thing.
And he's probably getting closer to 220 innings than the 180.
That's probably what he's doing this year, you hope.
So, having those two guys to really anchor this rotation, really provide those innings, relieves a lot of pressure on the younger guys also.
Without him, that risk, man, that's tough.
So, yeah.
So, where do you go pitching-wise from here, DiNardo?
It's still the same to me.
none of those other guys we've been talking about, your Tyler Anderson's, your José Quintana's, they're still on the table.
They're still out there.
I would venture to, I think this team ends up with either Quintana or Anderson by the end of.
I'd say by mid-spring training.
Like, they will end up with one of those two arms.
This team just loves some familiarity.
And both of them, just, they make so much sense here.
They're going to be cheap.
They're with their left hand.
They're vets.
They eat innings.
It makes too much sense to go that route.
Right.
And I want to add something to that.
I can't really speak so much for Tyler Anderson because I never heard too much about him.
Also, he was here earlier in the regime when things weren't as rosy.
Not that they've been by any means.
But you have heard José Quintana talk about his time here and how he did like it in Pittsburgh.
it almost seemed as if he had the choice, he would have rather stayed here instead of getting traded and maybe come back the following year.
so again, like, and he was also well-respected.
The clubhouse loved him.
The pitchers loved him.
So there is that connection.
there is that.
I know it's not home for José Quintana, but like, hey, come back.
You liked it here.
We're better now.
Let's do it again differently.
So again, like I'm with you.
Like one of those two makes all just a ton of sense.
And they both have been here before.
I'm just looking at it.
Like Quintana is still a solid pitcher.
Like I know the peripherals are starting to fall off a little bit.
The strikeout rates dropped last year, but he still eats a good bit of innings.
And results wise, you're not finding that many other places.
Like, I hope to God Hunter Barco can go out there this year, throw 131 innings with a 396 ERA.
I hope.
Right.
I'm pretty sure José Quintana can do that.
You almost want to just book it.
Right.
Like if that's on the table right now, pen to paper, let's go.
For sure.
And again, like the fact that he is a lefty, like.
I know like you mentioned, the peripherals aren't what they were.
That's for sure.
That's for sure.
But he's still a solid enough pitcher.
And like, you're looking at your number five.
And when you think about like your Bailey falters, Bailey fall.
And I still, I still to this day, like, I'm sorry.
I'll toot this horn a little bit.
I'm not pounding the table.
What's that?
I would take him right now, man.
I still don't understand that trade.
Like if Bailey falter is still on this team.
That's right.
He's not also like, he's not sexy.
He's not the, Oh, he's got all kinds of stuff in, like he can, he has his high ceiling.
It's just, he just goes in there and he just does it.
And it's not great, but it's also not, it's not bad.
it certainly was way better than we ever expected.
He's cheap.
It's like $3 million in arbitration.
But anyways, and you got the best version of Bailey falter here.
Like they knew how to use Bailey falter for all their faults.
They knew what to do with him.
Maybe he could, maybe that's on the table here.
Maybe the pirates do want to reach back out.
And is there something out there where we can bring them back?
I don't know.
I'd be interested in that as well.
I kept them, but I know, but how you said about using him, that's where I was actually going with this.
Like, again, like he, they are lefties that ballpark plays to their strengths.
PNC plays up for lefties.
That's why when you hear a lot of people talk about, and that's included, like let's go out there and get a lefty.
It's not so much, it's not so much that, well, the rotation's missing a lefty.
It's just all things equal the lefty version of a player.
Like you said, he throws his left hand.
If you were that person, if you're the guy that the Cardinals just traded for, I forget how to say his last name with the Mariners, with Donovan, right?
If you're the guy who can throw with both hands, you're throwing with your left hand at PNC Park because you're going to play up there.
And that's the difference.
All things equal, the guy that throws his left hand probably has a better season than the guy that throws his right hand at PNC Park.
And that's why you got the lefty because you get better value in that sense.
So again, that's why these two just make a lot of sense because they're probably coming in single digits, well, single digits, in nine digits, nine figures, not 10 figures.
And they'll play up.
They'll have a better season that you probably would anticipate someone of their caliber having.
So, and that's why I let these do so well at PNC Park.
That's why every year I feel like they go after a lefty free agent and train them to the deadline because that's what happens.
And it works.
Like almost every lefty they brought in here, save for Andrew Heaney, it worked out.
Yeah.
It was working out really well for Andrew Heaney at first.
He just, I think Father Time just caught him.
Bailey Falter might be available at some point here.
He's out of options.
There's no room for him.
I'm throwing it out there.
There's a planet that Bailey Falter could be a pirate again.
All right.
That's too much Bailey Falter talk.
All right.
Let's move on.
But yeah, I think that makes sense.
But, again, like to the third base thing.
Is Paredes an option?
Is, who else did you mention?
Well, we've heard out, boom, brought up a ball, a bunch.
I mentioned Paredes.
Who else did I mention?
I'm forgetting.
Oh, Ozuna.
Yeah, the actual connection.
Oh, yeah, Ozuna.
There's ties.
That was also come about that the Pirates are interested in Marcell Ozuna.
So, there's a possibility for third base, but there's also a guy that seems like the Pirates are talking to, and that is Marcell Ozuna at this point in time.
He makes sense.
on paper, he does.
He's still a good hitter.
No.
He's not a good defender.
That's the problem.
He can't play left field.
Really, maybe I was wrong with saying he's a good fit.
He's a good fit in the fact that he hits with his, on the right side of the plate.
He can't play defense.
He'd have to DH.
At that point, you're probably going to have to put O'Hearn in left field.
Reynolds in left field.
I don't love either of those options.
I'd just bring Tommy Pham back at that point.
That's what your short was about yesterday.
Yeah, just bring back Tommy Pham, dude.
He hits on the right side of the plate.
I don't know.
I'm stuck on the right-hand thing and the left-hand thing.
But he can play left field at a very capable, rate.
He hit really well after he fixed his eyes.
He could be a bench bad here.
He's definitely not sexy.
But if we're going down the Azuna path, like, you might as well just go with Tommy Pham or Andrew McCutchen or one of those other options that aren't garbage human beings.
And that's – I'm talking about Tommy Pham, too.
I like Tommy Pham.
He don't do Marcel Azuna stuff.
Yeah.
It's just – like, you're right.
Like, that bat, I would love that bat in this lineup.
But where does that one fit?
we discussed Cutch.
Cutch is going to be more of a limited role.
We know what he is.
Played his strengths.
We'll let these up there.
Maybe he can play the field.
Because also, too, I do feel – and I've said it.
Andrew McCutchen probably – I still believe he can play the field sparingly.
Marcelo's going to can't.
Like, just cannot.
Like, that's – we're not entertaining that.
That's what creates this to be such a situation.
Because also, he's not a part-time player.
You're adding that bat because he is a full-time player.
And that's what makes everything interesting.
So, when you do add the full-time DH, then where does your current first base DH go when he gets squeezed out of DH?
And, well, he's already squeezed out of first base because of Spencer Horwitz.
I guess he goes to left field.
Or right field, as you mentioned.
But then, we've seen the Bryan Reynolds experience – experiment in left field.
And that got onto right field last year because it was so bad.
It's – you're just making your defense a lot worse.
And to some level, like, it is what it is.
Get the bats.
Find a way.
But it's just, like, this offseason has just brought nothing but DH and bad second baseman over.
And I do say it because, like, Brandon Lowe fits that mold.
Like, Brandon Lowe's bat's so good that, you know what, like, his defense is bad.
It's not good.
But because of how good the bat is, you're fine with it.
But you can only have so many of those players before your entire team is just terrible defensively.
And as a team, like, they don't collectively have the bats to make up for it.
Like, you're not saying, like, oh, it's Manny Ramirez out there.
Like, if you sign Ozuna, it's basically like Ben Cherington watched Moneyball for the first time or read the book.
Oh, damn.
Or they just don't care about defensive positions.
Miguel Ando heard of the Padres?
Yeah, breaking news.
Not – it's not Livy.
Livy did not text back.
But we do have some breaking news.
Yeah.
Ando or to the Padres.
So that was also a possibility?
No.
God, no.
Give me Jarrett Triolo over that every day of the week.
No.
Absolutely not.
We did that already.
We're not doing it again.
I'm not debating on that.
He wasn't really on my radar.
But it is another piece that's falling.
And pieces are falling.
They are.
And the Pirates' still last Major League move was December 23rd with Ryan O'Hearn.
Yeah.
You know what's starting to scare me a little bit is that they're going to do something stupid.
Like, we're getting to the point where everything's going to be gone and they're going to do something dumb.
Tyler.
What?
Ben Turner got hired in November of 18?
At what point since that time have you said, oh, they've done something smart?
Something that's going to set this franchise back for when he's fired after this year, which is a very – it's a real possibility it's going to happen if this continues.
Yeah.
And I'm afraid he's going to panic and do something.
We will find out.
But – It could just be signing some dude to a three-year, $10 million-a-year deal that just is not worth it.
Is Ozuna worth that?
I wouldn't give him three years.
Oh, my bad.
I didn't know he said three.
Yeah.
Is Ozuna worth signing right now?
I think I probably need a little more clarity on left field, I think.
Because, right, it's just so – like, it's that right side of the field in general, and I'm putting DH on that side as well.
Mm-hmm.
It's just such a log jam.
It is.
Because, like, Brennan Brandon Lowe should probably be your DH.
I guess if you're going to have sides that have those, like, those are the sides.
If that's the diverse team you're going to choose, right, you either have to have a glove and no offense or offense and no glove.
You would separate them that way, but it's – yeah.
It's either one or the other.
You don't get both on this team.
you get Azuna.
You have your catcher figured out.
You go to first base.
You have Horwitz there.
Right field.
Probably got to be Reynolds.
You go left field, O'Hearn, center field's going to be Triolo, DH Azuna, and then Triolo and – Or center field Cruz.
I went out of order there, but you'd probably go O'Hearn, Cruz, Reynolds, Triolo, Gonzalez.
you can do it.
Your offense will be better.
Your pitching staff's going to hate you.
We'll find out.
that is one thing I've said last year, and I do find it interesting.
But, with pitching being so good, and especially a rotation that has strikeout guys, like this rotation can certainly be – Paul Skane certainly is, right?
Is defense maybe not as valuable as it used to be?
there aren't as many balls in play.
So, theoretically, there's not as many chances to display your terrible defense, like there used to be in the past, where glove really mattered.
And, again, if you're also a team that's – think about the 13, 14, 15, those rotations were more reliant on having the shift, getting the ground balls, like making contact and getting the outs, where this rotation feels to be a little more strikeout.
Let's go after them, let's strike out on Jared Jones and Paul Skane's out there.
Ashcraft can do it.
these guys are attacking guys.
Maybe defense isn't as valuable as we're accustomed to it being.
I would agree with that probably, like, four or five years ago.
That's the problem, is that it feels like the Pirates would be behind on that trend.
Because strikeouts were a huge thing, like pre-COVID, into COVID, sticky baseballs, spider attack, that entire era.
Strikeouts were huge.
I think we're starting to see them – I haven't looked into the numbers, but I think we're starting to see them slowly dwindle down.
That's completely anecdotal on my end.
I have no idea if that's true or not.
But at the very least, that shift's going to come soon, where balls in play are going to be at a premium again.
Because the game always – it's cyclical.
It's going to happen.
So, if you were going to go all in on the bats and not worry about defense, I think the time to do that was about five years ago.
Maybe it's still the time to do it, but – Well, I'll say this.
The K rate in 2019 for pitchers was 23%.
Last year, it was at 22.2.
So, it is down almost a percentage point.
Just 1%.
Okay.
That's not a ton, so – That's still substantial.
It is, but – It's something to us.
Like, last – 2024 was 22.6.
So, down from the year before that, 22.7 in 23.
So, you are seeing that trend to some level.
It has been decreasing.
So, we're going to get back to trying to figure out how to get ground balls and do all that fun stuff while the Pirates are trying to figure out how to get strikeouts.
But, to make a reference here, also in 2013, 19.9%.
So, again, you still do see the difference between back in that era where, like, hey, three pitches or less, pitch to contact, and this era.
I guess the other thing you can do, like, you can probably get creative with it and give O'Hearn some DH day and just split whatever duties left over in the position with however many guys you have.
Like, there's ways they can do it.
They'd have to get creative with it, which they're going to have to get creative no matter what if they want to win.
Don Kelly is going to have his work cut out for him.
So, maybe it is the right thing to do is just acquire as many guys that can hit a baseball as possible.
Maybe that's what you have to do.
positions be damned.
Let's just get guys that can hit baseballs and we'll figure it out from there.
Maybe that's the mindset.
I don't know.
Well, I always felt this team certainly can't be picky.
They got to get them where they can.
And that's why, like, the Brenda Brandon Lowe trade made a lot of sense.
And O'Hearn, it's like, that's not ideal.
But you take what you can.
It's just, like, now we're also this far along and we're still going down that path of, well, this still isn't a good fit.
And this still isn't a good fit.
And there's just not.
You had some good fits.
They didn't come.
And so, yeah, with the Ozuna, again, that bat, that type of a player in a sense of, again, like that bat, no position.
It's good enough that we'll figure it out.
But, yeah, it's not ideal.
This is going to be the 2026 not ideal Pittsburgh Pirates.
I guess just see what happens.
You make a good point, though, too.
And I think about that, like, Don Kelly's going to have a lot of work cut out for him.
Like, how is he going to do this?
you throw in the piggybacking stuff with starters, the positionless baseball, because that's basically what they have right now.
you know what, damn it, maybe you just go get a Ozuna.
Like, let's just get bats.
I don't want to watch terrible baseball.
I would like to see the ball get hit.
Yeah.
Screw it.
Just do it.
There it is.
And I do, just to touch on Pirates, too.
Like, if you can make that trade.
That's really, as far as, like, third, as far as third baseman goes, that one makes the most sense to me.
You can, you can go down the path of the Vientos and the Beatys.
Alec Bohm, I don't think, is a possibility at all.
It's really coming down, like, to me, Houston or New York.
I don't think either are just, like, available.
It's not like, here, we're trying to get rid of these guys.
And if you do, they probably want Major League Talent in return.
That's what makes it more difficult, also.
But, like, a Paredes, if that were to come about, I know there's a lot of disconnect in the sense of, well, he fits Houston ballpark.
And you take him out of Houston, and he's not good.
And there's some truth to that.
that is the perfect ballpark for him.
The absolute best place for him to play is in Houston.
However, I don't think it's totally in this scenario where, if he's not in Houston, this guy's a scrub.
And I feel like a lot of people are labeling it out to be that.
Like, don't go after him because he's not that good outside of Houston.
And that's not really true.
That's the perfect ballpark for him.
But this guy's not a scrub once he leaves.
I would welcome Paredes, also.
He might not be the three-WAR player that he's been in Houston.
But, again, like, he's good.
And I think having, what I also want to talk about is having an actual third baseman, you might want to debate if they're better than Triolo.
I'll let you have that debate.
I'm not going to be part of it.
We can have it another day.
But I think the issue is, the question isn't so much, is this person better than Triolo?
I think really the question is this person better than Nick Gonzales?
Because Triolo's best situation is being a utility guy.
Like, what you want to have is the third baseman and Triolo.
Because what you have now is Triolo and Gonzalez.
So, does Paredes and Triolo make you better than Triolo and Gonzalez?
That's where I'm at.
So, even if the guy is as good as Triolo, that guy and Triolo on their team make this team better than not having that guy.
I'll say this.
I would welcome Paredes.
I would.
He's an upgrade at third base, obviously.
You mentioned the home and away stats there.
He's still an above average hitter away.
Right.
A lot of people like to point to the underlying metrics, the expected stats.
Look, it's been like four years.
He's outperformed them.
They apparently don't apply to him.
There are guys like that just works that way.
Like, those things aren't always right.
You look at Jake Wilson.
I would welcome him.
You would think he's a terrible hitter.
Well, Jack Wilson wasn't a great hitter.
Yeah, apparently worse than I thought on that trivia game.
Yeah, he's a pretty bad hitter.
But I would gladly take him.
But I don't know if I agree with, because maybe I'm just crazy.
I want to see Jared Triolo play third base every day at this point.
Let me see how many war he can accumulate.
We saw Ke'Bryan Hayes.
Ke'Bryan Hayes sucked offensively.
Jared Triolo's already done, had seasons significantly better than Ke'Bryan Hayes.
His rookie year was so much better.
I know it was lucky.
Well, maybe not, because Ke'Bryan Hayes had that one year.
But still, I think in totality, the things Jared Triolo has done at the plate are so much better than Ke'Bryan Hayes.
And I think he's better than him, and I would take him there.
I'm just going to ride with it.
At this point, if we're not getting Paredes, I'm just going to ride with Triolo.
I keep saying it every episode, but we keep throwing all these other names out that I don't like Andy Hart.
Give me Triolo.
Okay.
But Tyler, is the goal to be better than Ke'Bryan Hayes?
Comments· 0
Should the Pirates trade for a true third baseman like Paredes and make Jared Triolo a super-utility man, instead of starting Triolo at third every day?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.