◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
The Pirates are in first place, and this episode of Bucco Brew breaks down why that start feels real even with some obvious flaws. The guys dig into a bullpen that has been shaky, the value Carmen Mlodzinski brings as a starter versus a reliever, Braxton Ashcraft’s emergence, and an offense that has been good enough to support strong starting pitching. It is a positive episode with honest discussion about what still needs cleaned up as the Pirates head home in a strong early-season spot.
Watch or listen now. And fuel up with De Fer Coffee & Tea using promo code NS930 for 30% off.
Comments· 0
The Debate
Should the Pirates move Carmen Mlodzinski out of the rotation and into the bullpen?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.
With Anthony DiNardo and Jim Rosati.
Chapters
Key takeaways
1
Braxton Ashcraft is already one of the Pirates' top two pitchers. He has a 2.12 ERA over 17 innings and walks almost nobody, and he can break through the ceiling Mitch Keller has if he pitches enough innings.
2
Carmen Mlodzinski helps more as the fifth starter than in the bullpen. The Pirates are 3-0 in his starts, and moving him to relief would not win back the games they would lose with José Urquidy starting.
3
Signing Lucas Giolito (3.41 ERA, 145 innings last year) would immediately make the Pirates better. He is the only free-agent starter left who would.
4
The Pirates' .187 average with runners in scoring position won't last all season. When it goes up, this league-average offense will score even more runs.
5
Reynolds' throw that missed Lowe and Lowe falling after catching a pop-up let in the two runs that cost Sunday's game. With sound defense the Pirates would have swept the Cubs.
Yeah, no, it's a it's been an exciting first part of the year.
Saturday's game was wild.
It gave me that jolt of like, oh, this is what it's like to watch stressful games when like, that they actually might mean something.
We haven't had that.
Like we've had games that have been wild and crazy games, but they've never really met any meant anything.
But Saturday's game, like when I do that postgame show, so I was like locked in.
It was and got my heart rate up.
It's one of those differences like last year.
We're frustrated and it sucks like this team's terrible.
Gosh darn.
Can we be good?
And like this year, it's like because it's so meaningful.
It's stressful and frustrating in an opposite way, which obviously comes out in a very good outcome.
But yeah, you're stressed.
And because it's like, man, like this is the Cubs.
Like this means something.
You're fighting for something, not just we suck.
And they came through.
They came through.
And like you said, I was on the postgame yesterday and I know, we started off talking about the inning.
Everyone knows what we're talking about because, for the same reasons, like there's a new level here.
There's some accountability like you gave that game away.
That sucked.
But again, big picture.
You did go into Chicago and he took two out of three from the Cubs and Wrigley.
Like you come out of that feeling positive.
Now, yes, there's things we need to clean up here, folks, because these are problems.
And there's stuff that you could you should be able to correct.
Like you should be able to correct throwing the ball at a second base.
You should be able to correct catching a flat ball.
you should be able to correct throwing strikes.
These are things you need work on.
So you can make sure you take that next step.
Right.
Like we talked.
I think you can talk about on the postgame show, like learning how to win.
Right.
They don't fully know how to do that yet.
That's a work in progress.
But that is how they were able to win Saturday.
Same time.
That's how they lost Sunday.
But two out of three in Chicago.
Jim, first place.
Wave the L, Chicago.
Yeah.
You brought up a good point there of just like knowing how to win.
And it actually brought me back to you.
I know we're going to dive into like the actual bullpen itself.
But like Justin Lawrence's comments after the game yesterday hit me in that like you could tell.
But it just it means more this year.
Right.
I feel like in the past, not that it didn't mean anything in the past, but I think the players knew that they just they weren't a good team.
Right.
And so it was like, yeah, we lost because we were the worst team.
Like that's we're going to lose more games than we win.
But he said a few quotes at the end of the game yesterday.
And these are the Colin Beasley of the Post Gazette.
But he mentioned, a couple of times and we're playing really good baseball right now and feels like not the first time that I've messed up our momentum.
I've never played on a team of this caliber before.
So he goes out and mentions like, I've never been on a team this good before.
And then he also says, I've never had a coach like Bill Murphy, believe in me the way he does.
DK, everybody.
You talk about all the additions and stuff that we made for this team and how I was supposed to be a big part of that.
I get it.
It's early.
If I do what I'm supposed to be doing.
But if I do what I'm supposed to be doing, I think our record is even better.
And he said, I'm just letting the guys down right now.
So I think one thing that is coming from this is like the guys before when we talked about like accountability and stuff there seemingly wasn't any because it's like, what are you really going to be accountable to?
And now I feel like there's more accountability just with yourself because it's like, Hey, listen, like we're good.
And so like, I need to be good or else I'm letting this team down.
So I don't know.
I hope Justin Lawrence figures it out.
he was really good last year before the injury.
You've talked about his stuff.
His stuff is still good.
if you go and look at his stuff plus numbers, like the stuff is still there.
His issue is he's just not throwing enough strikes consistently.
Like you got all over the plate, but it's interesting to just hear the players talk like that because we've never, I've never heard a player say that for the pirates in a really long time about like, yeah, I've never been on a team this good before.
Like I'm letting them down.
Like, I feel like I feel like in the past, at least in the previous seven, six years of this decade, it's been, yeah, well, we didn't have it today.
We'll try to do better, but like no one, no one actually believed that they were any good.
This team believes they're good.
Can I take it like another step further to, cause that's all correct.
Like, absolutely.
Like, absolutely.
However, also in the same sense, do you find that it's easier to let a coworker down or your family member down?
it's not easy to let either down, I guess.
Okay.
But like, who do you feel more disappointed in?
I guess where I'm getting at here.
Yeah.
It depends on what the job is, I guess.
We talked about the culture and the vibe, and the way I'm saying this is past years, there were coworkers this year, like this group sees more of family.
And, again, like, do I, do I really care if I let Becky down?
I do, but like, I'll get over it tomorrow's a new day, whatever.
But if I'm letting, my mom, my brothers, my, whatever, like those are my guys, those are my people.
If I let them down and it's disappointing, I'm, I let you down.
I can't believe I did that.
And I say again, because again, like, yes, there's the winning aspect of it, but like, this is a much closer group of players and you see it with them.
it's a whole different vibe this year completely.
Like you've been seeing it, especially in the pictures.
I feel like, and like with the Paul and Bubba and all of them, like, so I think there's that, it's harder to let this group down than previous groups because who cares?
And, like you guys are cool, but we're just here for the ride.
yeah.
Yeah.
I don't, I don't, I'll just say this.
Like, I know that the players know they're better and I think they're like, they recognize that, like, they recognize that they're better and they recognize it.
Like, Hey, I need, if you mess up, I need to do better.
Right.
For sure.
And there is a very common goal on this team.
That's bringing them together.
And he failed everyone from reaching that goal yesterday.
So for sure.
but anyways, yeah, like is hoisting the cone, which is hoisting the cone.
Absolutely.
That is the common goal.
as Billy Cook said on 412 day, the cone, that's what he thinks.
Can we talk about that for a second?
So the Pirates social media team puts out a video yesterday was 412 day, April 12th, 412.
And they're going around asking like, what do you like most about Pittsburgh?
And everybody's, given good answers, you're, the landscape, how beautiful it is.
Like things that people would normally say, yeah, Billy Cook, he just gets, he just says cone.
And I don't know how much longer we're going to be able to get away with saying Braxton Ashcraft is not one of the top two pitchers on this team because I think Braxton Ashcraft is one of the top two pitchers on this team.
And that's saying a lot because I do think very highly of Mitch Keller, but who?
Braxton Ashcraft has been absolutely outstanding since one, his promotion, but two, being moved into the starting rotation.
He's got a low twos ERA.
I want to say it's like 2.16, somewhere in that area as a starting pitcher for his career.
Like he is just.
And you're seeing him going deeper now.
He's racking up more strikeouts, the control, like all like the thing about this team that's the most been the most frustrating has been the walks Braxton Ashcraft ain't walking anybody.
Like he's striking out eight, nine batters every five innings and he's walking one, maybe two.
He's been, he's been really good.
And I think we've I think we were all really on board of Braxton Ashcraft breakout year, like coming out of spring training.
We all saw him, we all saw him, we all saw what he looked like and he is doing every bit of that right now.
17 innings through his three starts, 2.12 ERA.
He absolutely shoved against the Cubs.
I, yeah, I, if he can stay healthy and if he can put up, 140, 150 innings this year, like it's going to be a really nice season for him.
I think as a starter, a 2 16 fifth as a reliever is a three 11 fifth as a starter, 27.4 K percentage as a reliever, 22.9.
Like he got better once he got into the, in the starter role.
like this dude is, his whip is a one on nine.
He has a one on nine whip.
He's just, we were debate.
Yes.
It's a good point.
Like we were debating.
And I think most of us like, weren't shocked.
Like said, like, will it be Braxton or Bubba who has the better season?
And I think a lot of us is like, I wouldn't be shocked if it's Braxton Ashcraft, who has the better year.
And at this point in time, I think it's like, yeah, is he going to be the second best reliever on the team?
Second best pitcher on the team point blank, like better than Mitch, better than whatever.
Like it's going to be Paul and Braxton.
And I think we're there.
Mitch has a ceiling.
He does.
He's very valuable.
He's a very good pitcher, but he has a ceiling.
Braxton can absolutely smash through that ceiling that Mitch has.
He just has to, he has to do what Mitch has done.
He has to put the innings in.
And if he can put the innings in, he can absolutely be the second best pitcher on this team.
So he's giving them a chance to win every single game.
It may or may not look the prettiest.
He's, he labors through innings.
He's, there's traffic on the bases at times, but Pirates are 3-0 when he starts.
They are.
Do we want to get into some Carmen Mlodzinski reliever starter talk?
Sure.
We can, yeah, we can transition to that.
I think.
All right.
Before we do, let's tell you all about Defer.
Defer Coffee and Tea is an employee, a family and employee and owned.
Defer Coffee and Tea is a family and employee owned and operated a business.
They believe that coffee and tea are one of life's simplest and most accessible pleasures and when enjoyed, thoughtfully can open your eyes to the here and now.
They have five locations across the city of Pittsburgh, including their flagship in the heart of Pittsburgh's historic strip district.
Don't forget to stop by Defer's new location downtown on Penn Avenue, right across from the Benidum.
Grab a cup and fuel up on your walk to PNC Park.
Mobile ordering is available.
Check out their Instagram for more details.
And of course, Jim, tell everyone where they can save 30%.
Yeah.
If you go to Defer.coffee, load up your cart, put in promo code NS930, you'll get 30% off your order, which I need to place another order.
I was making my coffee this morning and I've got maybe, I probably got a week's, I probably got a week's worth left.
So, you know what, maybe when we're in town this weekend, I'll just swing by, grab a, grab a couple of bags.
That's right.
Just swing by, Jim, grab a cup on your walk to PNC Park afterwards.
Yeah.
I have a subscription, so I get it every month.
So I'm good.
I love it.
So nice.
But, Carmen Bajinsky makes an interesting point here.
And after what we saw yesterday and even throughout the season, but obviously yesterday, I think we have a good debate on our hands.
Now, Carmen Bajinsky won the fifth starter, rightfully so.
And even today, when you look and say, who should be the fifth starter, would you rather have Carmen or would you have, or Katie?
It's easily Carmen.
Would you rather have Barco or Carmen?
Carmen, right?
Clevenger or Carmen.
Clevenger's in trouble there right now.
The answer is Carmen.
Like who is the best fifth starter on this team?
Right now, the answer is Carmen.
The problem is.
You and I are okay with it.
It makes sense.
But man, Carmen is such a weapon in the bullpen.
And that weapon is a real weapon in that bullpen.
And they're missing that weapon right now.
And again, like I just, I'm perplexed because I don't think it's the wrong answer.
Putting him in the fifth starter.
He's certainly been capable.
He's like, you said, the three, as I mentioned, that's still 20% of your games.
They still matter.
But they are missing Carmen at his best.
And I don't know where to go from here with that.
I guess Jared Jones is coming eventually, but that's still a month and a half away.
Hopefully.
What are we doing?
Yeah.
Yeah.
And this was the debate going into this year was you can have this shutdown multi-inning reliever.
Or you can have a fifth starter that is going to keep you in the games.
Right.
Because I think we all saw the stuff.
We saw the difference.
Alex did a really good job of laying out.
That Carmen Mlodzinski is a completely different pitcher right now than he was the last time he was starting.
So I was I was 100% on board with like, let's try this again.
I was on board with that.
And so far, he's like, again, he's not going deep in the games.
14 and a third innings in his three starts.
I think five and a third is the longest start he's had.
Maybe even just five.
But like I said, he's not going deep.
But 2.51 ERA.
He's striking people out.
He's limiting walks.
He's putting together solid starts and giving the team a chance to win.
Can I just add something just on that?
Yeah.
He still has the third most innings as a starter.
Like, to your point.
Yeah.
He's doing what everyone else is doing.
Starters in general aren't going all that deep, to be honest.
But yeah.
So the question is, like, is this team better off if he's in the bullpen and you're using him using him there?
And I think the answer to that question is still no.
Like, would he help this bullpen out tremendously?
Absolutely.
Like, absolutely.
But do you go 3-0 in those fifth starter games if he's not starting?
Like, if you're if José Urquidy is the guy, do you go 3-0?
Probably not.
Maybe you go 2-1, but more than likely you're probably 1-2, right?
And so, like, do you steal two other games?
And really, to make it make sense, do you steal three more games other than that?
Because Mlodzinski's in the bullpen.
And I just don't see it.
I think he does more to help the team in the fifth starter spot than he would right now in the bullpen.
Now, the underlying point here is, I think we when we talked about this last time we were setting up the show, like, they could use a fifth starter right now.
Like, Jared Jones on this team would make the team a lot better because then you have the option to put Mlodzinski into the bullpen, use him there, deploy him how you want.
And that bullpen all of a sudden looks a lot better than it is right now.
There are not too many other options, though, internally to solve this problem.
Like, what's there is what's there right now.
In AAA, like, no one's pitching well in AAA.
So, like, who are you going to call upon right now to fix that middle inning problem?
Like, you would hope that Brandon Bidouac comes up at some point, but he's been getting shelled.
Cam Sanders is another guy.
And it's like, we all, Cam Sanders is a guy, right?
Like, let's call it like it is.
He's a guy.
So, you just got to go with the guys that you got.
And right now they're going with the guys that they got.
And the middle relief certainly seems like a problem.
I'm pretty comfortable with, Mattson, Soto, and Santana.
Like, those three I'm really comfortable with.
Everyone else, though, it could be really nice or it could be really bad.
Yeah.
So, like, is this your feel is it's going to be weak until Jared comes back and just fight through it?
ultimately, again, like, I know the bullpen has given issues.
Now, Montgomery has done the job more than Lawrence.
Like, I'll give that credit to Montgomery.
I'm not trying to put them together.
But both absolutely make you pull your hair when you watch them pitch often enough.
Lawrence has caused more losses, obviously.
Arkiti, he provides length, but he hasn't done.
Like, he hasn't looked good.
He has not been up there and he just said, OK, you know what?
This is a good sign.
This is why you brought him in.
And then with Hunter Barco, he has moments, but, yeah, you know what?
He looks as if, like, he's not ready to be the dude yet, for sure.
Not the guy that we thought.
Not the, like, hey, he should win the fifth starter role because he does not look like that guy at all.
So, yeah.
Yeah, like, Carmen would absolutely fix, I shouldn't say fix.
He would certainly boost this bullpen.
You would feel a lot comfortable with Carmen in there, with his bullpen could do again.
But then that fifth starter position just opens up and it's like, man, 20% of these games, though, are going to be frustrating because it's, yeah, Carmen's been doing his job.
And now who are you going to put there?
So, yeah, like, I don't, I don't really know the answer right now.
It just sucks because he's the answer for two things and one of them is going to suffer until, I guess, Jared Jones comes back.
that's just where we're at, right?
So, like, with that being said, did this team really miss out on, like, bringing in a true fifth starter or someone to fill in?
Yeah, I think that's the, I think that's it right there.
Like, if you could have brought in, like, how we were talking all spring, like, when are they going to bring in that lefty, that veteran lefty starter and that just never happened?
Yeah, I think that's what they're missing.
Like, someone who can be that fifth starter, that's, that would certainly help things.
But like I said, Carmen's doing a good job, but Carmen being there is taking away from the bullpen.
So, either go out there, they should have either gone out there and gotten another reliever, and they didn't, or they should have gone out there and gotten a fifth starter.
They should have done one of the two.
They went out there and they got Soto for the bullpen, and I guess they acquired Montgomery through a trade.
But, like, that was it.
Then they rolled with just what they had.
Right.
And they didn't add anything to the starting rotation.
Which could have been fine because you're thinking Carmen's in there.
Like, that could have been fine because, again, you think Carmen's in the bullpen.
But now there's a fifth starter.
Now it doesn't look fine.
And, again, like, let me say this.
The bullpen is frustrating right now.
But it's also been fine.
It's an average, it's an average major league bullpen.
It's got a 3.84 ERA, which is pretty much dead middle of the majors.
I think one thing you got to remember about bullpens is most of them, most of them stink.
Most middle relievers stink.
The Pirates are just one of those teams where their middle relievers are going to frustrate the hell out of you every other time they pitch.
And they've got enough in the back end that boosts them a little bit.
But, this is essentially a league average bullpen to this point.
They're walking a lot more batters than average.
They're sixth in the majors in walks in terms of bullpen walks.
But, overall, they've been middle of the pack.
So, that's definitely the weakness of this team right now.
The rotation as a whole has been outstanding.
They're the third best starting rotation in Major League Baseball right now in terms of earned run average.
So, you look at that and you live with the third best starters to go along with the 17th best relievers because they're going to combine for a pretty good staff overall.
And the offense has done good enough to this point to provide them with enough runs to get through it.
They've been a league average offense dead on league average.
100 weighted runs created plus on the year.
Which is, that's what we said.
So, the recipe for this team making the playoffs is a league average offense and then pitching staying healthy.
Right.
So far, that's been the case.
So far, they're in first place.
There are certainly gaps.
And I think the bullpen can be something that can be improved over the course of the year.
So, like, they just got to figure out a way to get through these first few months because you can boost the bullpen at the deadline.
Like, there are always random relievers on the waiver wire who you're going to, like, find interesting and like.
So, like, at some point, somebody will be DFA'd where you're like, I find him a little more interesting than José Urquidy.
Or, I find him a little bit more interesting than Justin Lawrence, maybe.
Like, there's going to be relievers like that available throughout the season.
So, we'll see what happens.
that's how they got Dennis Santana.
Dennis Santana was DFA'd.
So, yeah, those guys are out there.
You go through a lot of relievers over the course of the year.
Some of them stink.
Some of them, they're good.
Right now, they're average.
Yeah, I think it's part of it.
And I do want to state here as well.
Well, I do think there is still some upside in these guys that you're upset over right now.
the season's early.
If they've been fine and then these past two weeks happened in the middle of June, it would just suck.
But you would think, all right, they're probably going to change things around.
It just happens that it's really early right now.
And, Justin Lawrence cannot just locate that frisbee pitch that he has.
But it's still really good.
And he's done it in the past.
I know it was a small sample, but he's done it in the past.
And you just imagine, like, that's all he really has to do.
Like, he just has to throw it more for a strike.
It's unhittable.
But when all you have is the fastball, that looks like, it's one of the two.
And when that's, that sweeper he has, is nowhere near.
Like, you're just sitting fastball on him.
So, anyways.
But here's a good point.
And I want to bring this up here.
Nestor Cortez and Patrick Corbin are both still free agents.
Now, I'll say this.
Corbin is not with the Blue Jays.
But I like this idea because I bring this up.
There are still some free agents.
Now, Nestor Cortez also is out nine to ten months of surgery.
That was the end of last year.
So, he's not going to come back until after even Jared Jones is ready to come back.
So, it's not really the true answer here.
But the idea of this.
There are people out there.
Like, maybe a Giolito.
like, there are starting pitchers out there.
If you've identified maybe Carmen Mijinsky is best as a bullpen guy.
Let's get a fifth starter here.
You're talking about guys that are DFA'd.
What about maybe hanging free agents as far as starters?
Like, is this a good time to maybe reconsider?
Like, we should go and add that guy?
Or is it also maybe just, you know what?
We regret it to some level.
But it's also just too late.
Because, like, these guys got to ramp up.
And by the time they do, Jared's probably coming back anyways.
if you're going to add anybody, it's Lucas Giolito.
I don't really think anyone else boosts this team too much.
Giolito's healthy.
He is, like, he's ramping himself up apparently.
Last update was over the weekend.
He's maintaining a pitch count of around 75 during, like, live batting practice sessions, simulated games, things like that.
And he's coming off a pretty good year.
3.41 ERA last year.
Two war, 145 innings with Boston.
Like, I'm not really quite sure what he's looking for.
I'm sure there were teams that have kicked the tires on Giolito.
He's, obviously, nothing has fit what he's wanted up to this point.
But, like, he's 31 years old.
He's healthy.
You would imagine at some point, some team is going to get desperate enough to sign Lucas Giolito.
Are the Pirates in that boat yet?
I think signing Lucas Giolito immediately makes his team better.
Like, that's the question you're asking me?
Yeah.
I have no idea what Lucas Giolito is wanting.
Like, is Lucas Giolito wanting a $20 million deal, and that's why he's still out there?
Because I'm sure teams have offered him reasonable contracts up to this point.
I don't understand why you wouldn't.
But, like, or is, like I said, is he just, is he holding out for some contender to be like, you know what, we need some starting pitching?
Is he waiting for the Braves to finally pick up the phone and meet whatever number he wants because the Braves are having arms, people's arms fall off, every week?
Right.
That's the other question of this is, like, what does he want?
Because it's a shock to me that he's not signed right now.
Yeah, I don't understand how he's not a Braves.
It's just the writing's on the wall.
Like, it's going to happen.
But it hasn't happened.
So I don't know what's going on with Lucas Giolito.
I really don't.
How is he not pitching right now for any team?
Right.
Like you said, after the season he had and such.
But since he's not, is it possible?
Yeah, I don't.
I don't know.
But I'm entertained by the idea of this.
Because, again, like, I truly think this team with another starter just looks really good.
Because, again, this sucks.
Because, Carmen, you're doing fantastic.
I hate to try to take you out of this, because that's what happens.
But it's like, you're doing really good with this team.
This team could just really use a Carmen Mlodzinski in this bullpen.
Like, I just feel like that's the past.
Like, think about the past few years.
Like, they've had that guy, the Carmen, the what's-his-face Ortiz, right?
Like, the year before.
Like, this bulk guy who was really good and successful in that role has really helped his team.
Yeah, well, there are a certain number of players on this offense who are having really good seasons.
As a whole, they're still, like I said, they're average.
But, again, that's significantly better than what we've been used to.
I will say this, they've been, like, the long ball has certainly helped them to this point.
And, home runs help.
The one thing I wish they would get a little bit better here is just, like, hitting with runners in scoring position because that is a, that's a huge issue right now.
And, like, the thing with runners in scoring position, it's eventually, it's, I don't think it's going to be this bad all year.
they're hitting 187 with runners in scoring position right now.
And that has severely limited their ability to expand some leads that they've had, been limiting them to win some games that they probably should have.
But, again, they're 9-6.
I expect that number to go up.
Like, they're not going to hit 187, again, with runners on scoring position all season long.
That number's going to go up eventually.
And when it does, they're going to score even more runs than they are right now.
But, overall, you've got a positive run differential.
You're scoring more runs than the other team.
They're, for the most part, they're doing their job.
Nick Yorke has been the guy who stood out to me as far as, like, was not expecting this performance at all.
He's been really good.
Bryan Reynolds is doing what you'd want him to do up there.
You'd want a little bit more from some certain guys.
But I think what's nice about this is we talked about Konnor Griffin getting called up and how, like, he's not really going to be, like, Konnor Griffin's not going to be a good offensive player right off the rip.
Like, it wasn't going to happen.
Like, he's 19 years old.
He's barely played above double A.
But the rest, like, there are enough good players on this offense where, like, he doesn't have to be really good right now.
He can take this time to adjust to major league hitting.
Now, he's got to figure it out eventually.
He can't hit 138 all year long.
But I have pretty good confidence that he will start figuring out how to hit major league pitching.
It's just, it's going to take a while to get into it.
So, yeah, they need to, I would like more consistency with runners on base.
But I don't have too many complaints about this offense so far at all.
I'm with you.
I don't want to say it's fluky, but right.
it's a small, it's 15 games.
So, the numbers with the runners in scoring position is a small sample in a sense.
And, yeah, I think it will normalize a bit.
Now, again, like, if we're in the middle of May and June and this is still that way, then it's like, okay, like, that's something to worry about.
Like, is it the project?
What's going on?
Why can't they hit with the runners in scoring position?
Yes, that's been a problem in the past.
But also, like, the offense was bad.
So, it was the same.
like, and relatively speaking, like, the numbers with runners in scoring position was the same as normal every other time.
It just, it sucks.
It's just terrible.
It's bad.
Right now, the offense has actually been good, right?
Like you said, it's league average.
So, I would just imagine that's probably going to boost up at some point also.
Three of the 25 worst defensive fielders in baseball.
But, what's ironically funny.
But, again, O'Hearn, I'm fine with O'Hearn being there.
Like, I expected O'Hearn to be there.
And, like, that's fine for a right fielder.
That is completely fine.
But, the other two need to do better.
The best outfielder we have is a first baseman.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Again, like, that's not including me.
You're fine with it.
Yeah, but, yeah.
But, at the same point, it's like, that's not how this is supposed to be.
Yeah.
Reynolds and Cruz need to be better out there.
Yeah.
Right.
Anywho, anything else that you want to talk about?
Again, I wanted this show to be positive still because, like, despite these warts that they have, despite the bullpen being wild, despite the defense being shaky, they're still, they're 9-6.
They're 9-6 through 15 games.
They're in first place.
They're coming home.
Seven-game homestand.
You got an opportunity to, win a few more games here.
I think they've got a really good opportunity to go 5-2 this homestand.
If you go 4-3, you take it.
But, I think you got a pretty good chance of going 5-2, especially with the skeins going twice.
They're in a good spot right now.
And, I tweeted it out yesterday that, the 2025 Pittsburgh Pirates won one road series against NL Central opponents.
One.
They won one of them.
The Pirates, so far this year, have played two of those.
And, they've won them both.
Pirates have won more road series against NL Central opponents this year, on April 13th, than the 2025 Pirates won all year long.
So, they're in a much better spot.
They're sitting pretty right now, on top of the standings.
FanGraphs loves their playoff odds.
If you look at that, I know it's super early for playoff odds, but the FanGraphs puts the Pirates right around 60% playoff odds right now.
So, which is the highest they've been in a decade.
So, we, I'm enjoying it so far.
They're playing good baseball.
This team is good.
Like, they are a good baseball team.
They're going to be in this thing all year long.
And, it's been a fun start to the year.
Yeah.
No, absolutely.
And, like you said, it is April.
It is early.
Of course it is.
But, it just shows the difference.
If you recall, a year ago, those odds were this quickly.
Right?
they were out of it.
They were out of it this early last year.
the odds, I don't know what they were, but I guarantee you, because I know we're talking about at that point in time, they were single digits.
If it wasn't like one.
Last year, at this point, they were, they had 6% playoff odds.
6%.
So, there you go.
Yeah.
just, again, so wildly different this year, this baseball team and the way they're playing and such.
So, yeah, they have a very, again, the schedule has been, I'm not going to say rough, hard, but it hasn't been easy.
they've played quality teams so far to this point.
Coming out 9-6 with all these things that we're talking about, the warts that they have.
They're still one of the better teams in the NL at this point in time.
So, there's still things to be happy about.
There's still things to be very positive about.
This team seems like they're very capable of fighting all year long.
That's what they're doing right now.
And they have a very advantageous homestand right now.
They have the Nationals, who are actually better than the Mets at this point in time.
So, there's that.
They're not the worst team in the NL East.
The Nationals are hot, too.
The Nationals just went into Milwaukee and swept the Brewers, by the way.
James Wood is just tearing it up right now, too.
So, yeah, he's broken out.
His quiet slump is no longer there.
He leads the NL in home runs now, doesn't he?
Or is that Jordan Walker?
He's got five.
So, he's tied with Cruz.
So, anyways, yeah.
So, right now, though, today, Skeen's pitching.
Bandle has a money line, minus 225 for the Pirates.
So, again, you're hoping they come out at least today.
Yes.
Yeah.
And then, of course, Jim, it's Saturday.
Paul Skenes's will pitch again on Paul Skenes's bobblehead night.
But we're all in attendance because it's the NS9 tailgate where tickets are sold out.
Sorry if you didn't get your ticket.
You can no longer sit in our section.
You can still come to the game.
And you can, of course, come to the tailgate.
So, we'll be having a lot of fun beforehand, during, and after.
I'm excited.
Yeah.
It's going to be a fun weekend.
If the Pirates can go in, take this series against the Nationals.
If you win three out of four against the Nationals going into this weekend, going into the tailgate, it's going to be a really good time.
It's going to be a really good time regardless.
But it's going to be a really good time regardless.
Comments· 0
Should the Pirates move Carmen Mlodzinski out of the rotation and into the bullpen?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.