◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
NS9LIVE! dove into the Pirates’ biggest remaining Opening Day battles, from the fifth starter race to the shortstop dilemma, while also mixing in a classic Jimalytics breakdown of the ABS challenge system and a fun smash-or-pass reaction to PNC Park’s new food items. It was a lively mix of roster talk, Pirates optimism, and the kind of chaos that makes this show what it is.
Watch or listen now and get ready for Opening Day.
Comments· 0
The Debate
Should Carmen Mlodzinski stay in the bullpen while the Pirates use Urquidy and Clevenger as the fifth starter?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.
With Anthony DiNardo, Jim Rosati and Tyler Sweeney.
Chapters
Key takeaways
1
If Konnor Griffin makes the Opening Day roster, Alika Williams is gone. If Griffin is sent to Indy, Williams will be introduced in front of 45,000 people at Citi Field.
2
The real problem is that the Pirates never got a third baseman. With one, Jared Triolo could play shortstop until Griffin is ready, and Alika Williams wouldn't be needed.
3
Changed their pick from last week: Carmen Mlodzinski should be the fifth starter because he's looked the best and is easier to trust than Urquidy or Clevenger.
4
Keep Mlodzinski in the bullpen, where he thrives. Use up José Urquidy and Mike Clevenger as fifth starters until Jared Jones or Barco is ready.
5
Hunter Barco ranks behind Urquidy and Clevenger for a rotation spot, and it's an open question whether he becomes a major league pitcher at all.
Yo! Welcome to NS9 Live, presented by FanDuel. I'm your host, Anthony DiNardo. With me, we have Jim, we have Ty-Ty,
what is up, fellas? What's going on, guys? One week close to opening day, boys. Are we excited? I, yeah, I'm getting there. we talked on Monday. Like, the World Baseball Classic, just, it got me amped up. I'm ready for the season to start, for sure. Yeah, and you hit it on it, you hit it on it, Jim, during the, Bucco Brew. I really want something like that to happen with the players. Like,
when you said, all right, I need this to happen for the Pirates, watching Paul Skenes pitch in that type of situation. Yeah, I need that.
Yeah, it was fun. I'm excited. I love spring training. We're down there for two weeks. That was exciting. Now we're back. And it's just like, I'm officially at the point now, especially since there's no games on Sportsnet. Pittsburgh was one more game in like the last 10 days. Yeah. So like, I'm ready for the regular season to begin. I'm ready to see Paul Skenes in New York City, shoving against the Mets.
I'm ready for this. I'm so ready for the season to begin. And I'm ready to see Konnor Griffin on opening their roster.
Same with the extension. Yeah. And then they did a night, they did a night game tonight too. So, they beat the Tigers three to one, Braxton Ashcraft just shoved. It was on TV. So no idea what he looked like, but the numbers all look pretty impressive.
also the win clinched a winning season, a winning spring for the Pittsburgh pirates. It's our first winning spring since 2017. You guys, it's been nine years since they've had a winning record in spring training. and I said, I don't, I don't know if what that correlates to, but Hey, it's been a while since they've had a winning record in spring. And so they finally got it this spring. So that's cool to see.
Take that all you naysayers. Yes. Guys, we know they've been bad and they've lost a lot in spring. So maybe now it changes. Yeah. You never know.
I'm also like, I'm ready to move on from this whole positive Tyler thing and just be realistic again. Cause right now I'm just, I'm super positive and it's hard not to be at this point.
Well, next week we've got our season preview over under prediction episode. So that's your chance, I guess.
Yeah. I don't know. We'll see what happens with it.
I got a question for you, Tyler.
Yes.
What the hell are you looking at?
You're looking everywhere but us as we're talking.
Half the problem is that I just rearranged everything.
So I'm okay.
So there we go.
I was like, yeah, guys, I'm really excited about this season, but I'm going to be my old self.
I'm like, Tyler, I'm right here.
Yeah. Are you though?
No.
All right.
So what do we got on the docket for tonight?
Well, we're going to start things off with the really stupid question.
Okay.
But yeah, there's been some news, not fully baseball related, but I want to say this is always a fun time of the year.
The pirates released the new food items at PNC park.
Let's talk about those smash or pass.
Let's talk about this last week of spring training and Jim, are we bringing Jimalytics back?
We got some Jimalytics tonight.
We've got, you know what?
This might be the first time ever, but I made it two PowerPoints for tonight.
Two different power points.
Two points.
Why don't I do this?
I hope everybody, I hope everybody's ready.
The people are needing some Jimalytics.
Not really.
We all hate them.
but let's, of course, let's get into like the really stupid question.
How's that sound?
Let's do it.
I want to ask you a bunch of questions and I want to have them answered immediately.
So we know how this works, but before we spin the wheel, Jim, do you want to let us know what the question is today?
Yeah.
So the question today is if you had to live in one TV show universe, what are you choosing?
So that is the, that is the dumb question for today.
So yeah, let's spin this thing.
Are we going to get an answer this time?
By the way, I want to say Dan Samborski did DM us back last week and he was like, guys, I apologize.
the Twitter DMS are pretty bad.
Will Taylor.
Pirates prospect will Taylor.
And I'll say this, the spring breakout rosters were just announced today.
And will Taylor is going to be participating in the spring breakout game on Friday.
So yeah, I guess I'll shoot that over to him.
Go ahead and send that over.
Also teaser.
If you may, since that game is on Friday, it is a spring breakout and we like to get the juices pumping a little bit before the season.
it's our spring break.
Also spring break, spring training.
We're going to do a post game show after that.
So tune in after the, spring breakout game.
We'll have our NS nine post game show, spring training, spring breakout edition.
So hopefully that'll be a really good time.
We got some interesting answers here.
We do have some interesting answers.
You know what?
Slow down.
It's even pulling out the Pokemon.
I feel like that would actually be fun.
Like being able to like catch little animals and walk, wander around the earth and just like fight people with them.
Like that'd be, that'd be pretty cool.
I might go with Pokemon.
That's a, that's not a bad one.
Yeah.
Solid.
That is not bad at all.
I was trying to think of a show that has a bunch, like only has rich people.
Couldn't think of one.
You can do like entourage.
The problem is you wouldn't be the rich person.
You'd be like, yeah, that's true.
Right.
You'd be the lawn boy.
Yeah.
It depends how we define universe.
Yeah.
All right.
It sucks.
I never think about these answers when we do the questions.
So I never have one prepared.
I don't know what I would do.
Who's going to be the crazy person that wants to live in game of Thrones time.
I like community.
Community.
TV show community.
Yeah.
Community would be good.
Someone says always sunny.
That would be a good one too.
That'd be fun.
You know what?
Just give me a 50 show.
I live in that universe and then I'll invent everything that's ever happened in the last 75 years.
There you go.
All right.
There it is.
All right.
So let's jump into Jim Olytics.
Unbelievable.
Eric Sebrowski.
As Anna Kendrick says.
Boom.
I love that.
I love that.
So today we're going to talk about the ABS challenge system.
What seems like that's going to be really cool about this is we've got pretty awesome reporting for the ABS challenge system, which, hey, it's baseball.
There's stats involved.
Like when something new gets introduced, we want to be able to track it.
We want to be able to tell who's good at it.
We want to tell who's bad at it.
We want to tell who's like the most advantageous, when it comes to the ABS system.
So now that we're about three and a half weeks into spring training, it's still a really small sample size for the ABS challenge system.
But we have like ABS challenge leaderboards and stats that are out right now.
And there's some pretty cool stuff that's being included with this.
So I just wanted to share what we've got going on in terms of ABS challenge statistics.
Well, you guys excited?
Is everybody excited for this?
Nothing gets my juices going more than this, Jim.
I know.
I'm waiting on this to find a way to make Henry Davis the greatest catcher ever.
That's exactly what it's going to be.
Stay tuned.
Stay tuned.
All right.
So we've got ABS reporting and you guys, it's pretty awesome.
So quick overview just so far this spring.
Challenges are 52%.
People are 52% overall at overturning balls and strikes.
There's been 1,564 attempts.
812 have been overturned.
So it's pretty 50, right?
That's pretty good.
That stands out more than, or I should say less than I thought.
I don't know.
The Pirates probably bring that down a good bit.
All right.
Batters are not very good at it right now.
44% as far as the batters go.
They've had 732 attempts.
323 have been overturned.
And then when it comes to the fielders, so we're talking catchers and pitchers, they are 59% successful at overturning these calls.
And to even take it one more step further, what's even more interesting, let me take off the overlay here just for a second so you can see.
does this, there we go.
Boom.
Okay.
pitchers have only challenged 31 calls all spring.
Catchers have had 801.
So it looks like teams are pretty much relying on the catcher to do the challenging and not necessarily the pitchers.
The Pirates particularly stand out here.
They haven't had a single pitcher challenge a pitch yet this spring.
Good.
I like that.
That's the way it should be.
Everyone follow Chris Sale.
It's good coaching.
So heavy catchers on that.
All right.
So how do the Pirates stack up?
So let's compare the Pirates to the rest of Major League Baseball when it comes to the ABS challenge system.
There's 30 teams in Major League Baseball, you guys.
The Pirates rank 29th.
They're quite bad.
Well, it's not that they're bad at it.
Let's go.
It's not that they're bad at it.
It's just that their opponents have had 14 more calls overturned than they've had.
So only the Dodgers are worse at this.
So if you look at the bar graph here, you can tell the Pirates aren't the worst when it comes to getting calls overturned.
But what they are the worst at in Major League Baseball, they've had the most calls overturned against them than any other team so far this spring.
So, yeah, it's really not that they're bad at it.
It's just like they've been the most unluckiest, I guess.
They've been...
Which naturally, of course.
I feel like me and Jim, me, Cody, Doug, we saw probably all 14 of these in that Braves game.
That Braves game is going to account for, yeah, a lot of this, I think.
So, yeah, so far, the ABS system hasn't been that kind to the Pirates.
As N. Volantine says in here, umpires can't call schemes.
Like, yeah, like, we'll get to that.
But Skenes is definitely a culprit here.
And he's only had, I think, two spring starts, maybe three, but I think only two.
I think just two.
I think just two as well.
All right.
Let's look at the hitters, though.
So, which Pirates hitters are gaining the most from this?
And I want to talk about this a little bit more because there's, like, a lot of data on this screen.
But what's going to be really neat about watching this throughout the entire season is that they've calculated, like, an expected challenge rate.
So, like, if a pitch should be challenged, like, StatCast is going to register that as, like, an expected challenge.
So, those players who aren't challenging pitches that should be challenged, they're actually going to, like, it's going to hurt them in this metric where it comes to overturns versus expected.
So, the best player so far for the Pirates at the ABS Challenge system is the Password.
He's had three pitches challenged and the hitters have lost two of those.
But yeah, that's it.
Like I said, not a lot of data to go off of right now, but it is cool that like we're going to have this throughout the season and we're going to be able to look and see really like who's good at this, who's bad at this.
And like, where are they missing?
Like, are they missing because they're just losing challenges or are they missing because they're not challenging enough?
Like this is going to measure both of those.
It's going to be cool.
I don't really know how much stock you can put into a lot of it.
Like, skill wise, what can you really do at least catching and pitching wise hitting wise?
Yes, it's going to be very valuable.
And I think that's probably where you see the value.
Yeah.
If you're a hitter and you can overturn those calls that, either put you down one two and instead now you're up to one like those are going to be the big ones or like there's a big situation and you get you get called out on strikes and,
it was clearly a ball.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Being able to flip a count from like one, two to two, one is going to be huge for like a Bryan Reynolds.
Yeah.
Yeah.
That's the one thing that stinks this year, because like the one person that was really interested to see.
Utilize this is the guy who has a fifteen hundred OPS with Texas right now.
And that's Andrew McCutchen.
Anywho.
Another topic for another day.
Another topic for another day.
But yeah, again, like this is the other part of this.
again, we talk about ABS.
Should it be in baseball?
Should it not?
I know there's it's polarizing to some degree, but I think most people are into it, especially the way that they've done it right, like a challenge system, not just every calls done by, a computer.
But yeah, this is like.
This is interesting again, like this is becoming like a skill again, I like this thought of it.
Who really knows the strike zone?
Who's making the challenges when they should?
I like it.
I like it a lot.
Once we get all this available size in.
Yeah.
All this is available on baseball savant stack cast website.
And yeah, I said it's it gets pretty in depth on this stuff.
Yep.
All right.
Well, speaking about all those players, we got one week left of spring training and then we're heading north.
There's still some roster spots that are open.
There's still there's still some battling going on.
We know this fifth starter is a big battle that's happening right now.
We know the shortstop position is a battle.
Two players remain in the sense of position battles, position players that aren't on the 40 man.
Like, is Garcia coming up north or is he going to go to AAA?
things are getting interesting right now.
So I don't know how you want to how do you want to leave this off here about this next week?
What are we looking forward to seeing?
Yeah.
You know what?
Let's talk about it right after this ad read from Cody.
This episode is brought to you by IQ bar, our exclusive snack hydration and sponsor IQ bar, protein bars, IQ mix, hydration mixes, and IQ Joe mushroom coffees are the delicious low sugar brain and body fuel you need to win your day.
The ultimate sampler pack is a great way for you to try all IQ bar products and flavors.
You get nine IQ bars, eight IQ mix sticks, and four IQ Joe sticks.
All IQ bar products are clean label certified and entirely free from gluten, dairy, soy, GMOs, and artificial ingredients.
With over 20,000 five-star reviews and counting, more people than ever are fueling their lifestyles with IQ bars, brain and body boosting bars, hydration mixes, and mushroom coffees.
The ultimate sampler pack includes all three.
My personal favorites so far have been the almond butter chip and the iced tea lemonade hydration mix.
It's just really full of flavor.
I love starting my day with it.
And I couldn't imagine starting my day with anything else other than IQ bar products.
Right now, IQ bar is offering our podcast listeners 20% off all IQ bar products, including the ultimate sampler pack plus free shipping.
To get your 20% off, text MLB to 64000.
That's MLB 64000.
Message and data rates may apply.
See terms for details.
My favorite part of that ad read is the 64000.
I love it.
There was no flub.
6400.
There was not a flub.
Oh, I felt like he needs an IQ bar.
Yeah.
So next topic, right?
There's one week left of games.
There's still some position battles here.
Like we, who's going to be the fifth starter?
Who's going to take up these final bullpen spots?
Who's going to be the shortstop on this team?
What does the left side of the infield look like?
And like, what is the bench look like here?
So yeah, there's some interesting things going on.
I do want to start with just like the position player side of things like Tyler Callihan.
he was two for three played third base.
His spring OPS is eight 55.
And again, like spring numbers or spring numbers.
but I, Nick Yorke started off the spring, like super duper hot.
And he's since cooled down a little bit.
they'd get a hit today, but like Callihan coming on board, you wonder if like, was that move made just because the pirates don't really want Nick Yorke to be on the bench?
I think if, I think if Konnor Griffin doesn't make this team, I probably still have York in there somewhere, but I'm, we talked about this last week too, but like, I think Tyler Callihan's on this team.
Yeah.
Yeah, I do too.
Just like the versatility that he has being able to hit from the left side, which they're missing on the bench.
they've got Mangum like for, as far as like an infielder who can play third base, you can play second base, you can play corner outfield.
Like the versatility is just nice there.
yeah, I just, and then also like if it comes down to it, where Griffin is on this team and you got to send York to triple a and like York's getting everyday at bats.
The good news with this lineup and the way that they've gone out and put it together this offseason is in past years, you had a bunch of guys starting or getting the majority of
playing time who like really probably shouldn't have been this year.
You look at the starting lineup and at least one through six, right?
Cruz, O'Hearn, Reynolds, Ozuna, Brandon Lowe, Horwitz, those six guys, like those are everyday players.
So.
If Griffin's in there, then there's a seventh you're catching situation is you're catching situation.
It is what it is like they're going to both whoever it's going to be Barton Davis unless something happens between now and opening day, but.
And Triolo is your third baseman at that point.
So like you've got a set lineup of like starters and then your bench is your bench.
Whereas last year it was like, hey, Adam Frazier, you're playing a lot all of a sudden, right?
You're not going to see that this year, hopefully, because of the caliber of starting talent that they've got.
Yeah, I agree.
It's really what Jack says right here.
It's nice to only be upset over the 26th guy.
And that's a rat.
I want to actually like compare this to like the Josh Van Meter situation, because Callihan's a little bit of an older, not quite like Josh Van Meter, but you know what?
Like he's an older prospect.
He has some interesting minor league numbers, but it doesn't translate.
But the thing is like Josh Van Meter came over and it was like, how many plate appearances did he get that year?
Was it like 400?
Like you're talking about, right?
Like this is a situation.
Like, is this guy going to make the team?
And if he does, he's making it as the 26th guy.
So that's why it's also to me, like, I'm not, I'm not up in arms about this.
It is what it is.
It's the 26th guy.
If this was five years ago, he's not even making the team because there's only 25 guys on the roster, you know?
So like, here we are now.
I just look at it.
Like you mentioned, do I want Nick Yorke or do I want him?
And really, I don't find Nick Yorke that attractive defensively.
You going to say something, Jim?
I was going to say, let's assume Konnor Griffin's not on the team for a second.
You don't feel comfortable putting anyone else there.
Nick Gonzales was a subpar second baseman last year.
When you take a subpar second baseman and you put him at shortstop, he's going to be even worse.
If Konnor Griffin's not on this team, I think, I think you start Jared Triolo at third.
And I think you start Nick Gonzales at short, but Alika Williams is on your bench to substitute, to go into shortstop late game situations when you're up.
And because you can't, you can't afford to have a shortstop who you don't feel comfortable with, late in games that are close.
And so that's where I think Alika Williams may fit in this.
I can't believe I'm saying this right now, but it's all like they did go out there and they got a lot of offense.
So like they might be able to afford to carry just a glove first shortstop on the bench who can provide defense at the end of games.
And like, you're not giving him any at bats, you're not giving him hardly any at bats.
Like don't start them maybe once every other week.
Right.
But like that's, there's there may be a role on this team like that.
I don't think maybe, I think it is the role because it seems like Konnor Griffin's probably going to go down from maybe some other things have come out.
Guys, can we, I'm here to give you the voice of reason.
Jim, again, I'm not saying you're wrong.
I'm not, I'm not refuting you in like, this is a terrible argument.
I'm just also saying you're wrong.
Get that out of your head.
Just get, who are we DFAing to make Alika Williams on the 40 man roster for the two weeks that he's going to be here until Konnor Griffin comes up?
The exact same person you would have DFA'd when you, if you put Konnor Griffin on the roster, because then what you do is you DFA Alika Williams when it's time to call up Griffin and he just takes his roster spot.
Like it's the same move.
It's just made a little bit different.
I get it.
But no, you will, you go get Callihan for this situation.
I, so you're saying you would rather have Triolo at short, Callihan at third, than Triolo at third, Gonzalez at short, and just Alika as a glove only option off the bench.
Fellas, Alika is not making the team, but he is.
I, here's what I'm going to put it.
I'm going to say it right now.
If Konnor Griffin makes the opening day roster, Alika is not on the team.
But if Konnor Griffin is sent to Indy, Alika is going to be introduced in front of 45,000 people at Citi Field.
Yeah, I fully agree.
Now, the only flip side that I think you can maybe pivot, and I think they missed the boat on it, was maybe having Gonzalez at third and letting Triolo play short.
But with what they've done this spring, I feel like that's not happening.
And I don't even love that, it's just shortstops at least taken care of there.
But I don't love that either.
Yeah, I'm not saying I love, I love these situations.
No, I don't like this at all.
It's the situation that we're in.
So then, we all agree, Konnor Griffin is your opening day shortstop, right?
But I also know Mlodzinski is going to dominate that role.
It's not like I have faith in, if Urquidy doesn't make the fifth starter, I don't have faith that he's going to be the multi-inning reliever or Clevenger.
Clevenger I have more faith in, but he's not going to be Mlodzinski.
So again, that's the trade-off.
What is the trade-off?
Clevenger or Urquidy as their fifth starter, as opposed to Mlodzinski.
What's best for the team?
Again, as I mentioned, that's 20% of the games, the fifth starter still.
I think it might be the fifth starter.
I think that's probably the more important role, especially right now.
Thinking about this, too, is you're looking for the first two months.
So it's a short-term fix, and that's why I feel like maybe Mlodzinski is the guy.
But I would just love for Urquidy to win it and give us two solid months.
Yeah, so if you haven't listened to that episode of Offbeat, Alex went into Karam Mlodzinski and the changes he's made.
It was a really good episode, and it did open my eyes a little bit as well.
At the same time, though, no, he's not my fifth starter.
Because even now, we're still only throwing three to four innings, which is basically his bullpen role.
sure.
Last outing, five innings, two runs.
He looked good.
Sure.
And he held up.
That's what's important, too.
The two runs came early.
Sure.
Which happens.
I'm burning the living hell out of José Urquidy, and I'm burning the living hell out of Mike Clevenger, if he's still here at that point.
And I'm going to let Karam Mlodzinski thrive in the role that I think is best for him, which is in the bullpen.
And I would understand if he is the fifth starter.
I just don't think it's the best spot for him.
I'd rather just burn the arms we have.
It's fair.
It's a long season.
I would rather that, too.
I could see that happen.
I don't think I'd rather have that happen, though.
I would rather, like, if I had my choice here, Karam is the fifth starter.
Remember last year when we were saying, like, oh, yeah, that's really cute that Karam Mlodzinski wants to start.
I like that thought.
But, no.
Here we are.
I also just hate all three options, to be honest with you.
I don't hate the Mlodzinski option.
I don't like it.
There, you could do way worse.
You could, but it's not like Urquidy or Clevenger.
That's fair.
And it's more that, like, I just, I hate taking him out of a role that he could thrive in.
Yeah.
No, that's fair.
Hamilton brings up a good point.
And I said this is, like, per Ethan on MLB Spreadsheets.
But Clevenger has to be added to the 40-man by three.
Upward mobility clause there.
So, if another team wants Clevenger, he basically needs to be added by this weekend.
So, we'll, we may know what's going on there relatively soon.
Yep.
Outside of that, yeah.
It's great to be able to complain about the fifth starter spot as well.
And, like, we're complaining about 26-man spot and the fifth starter spot.
Yeah.
And it's, like, also, the reason we're doing it is because they have talent that they're going to hold down.
Which, again, makes sense.
it's not, like, these guys stink.
Yeah.
Some other news that came out this week.
Evan Sisk was optioned, meaning that Mason Montgomery, I would assume, is going to make this team.
The other way, I guess, you could pivot here, if you're the Pirates and you want to get more creative, is Montgomery has options.
And so, if you want to just hold on to as many arms as possible, you could option Montgomery.
You could start the year with Joe LaSorsa, who hasn't been very good during his major league career.
He looked good in the World Baseball Classic.
He also has an upward mobility clause that needs to be triggered, I think, to be getting in next week.
So, there's that option.
There's also, and, like, hear me here, if the goal, if the reason why Hunter Barco wasn't your fifth starter is because you want to make sure that you're monitoring his innings, isn't another option here that you just start Hunter Barco in the bullpen?
Well...
As your second lefty?
You could.
And I actually, I do like that, because, again, my whole thing, I would love, now they didn't add another pitcher, so it's not going to happen, but I would love this year of, like, Carmen Mlodzinski and Hunter Barco being, like, the two long men, having a righty and a lefty.
Again, that's not going to happen, but I do like that idea.
You could.
You're ramping him up, essentially.
Nah.
Nah.
No, I want him to learn on the job, pitching, starting, getting stretched out.
I want him to get through an order three times, if he can.
I know it might not happen in AAA, but I want him to work through a lineup.
I'm not ready to put him in the bullpen yet.
I think there's still too much learning to do with Hunter Barco.
I want to see him in AAA.
Yeah, I guess my point here would be, if you're putting him in AAA, you're probably using him almost like a reliever anyways.
Because you're not going to throw too many in.
Like, you're not going to use a lot of Hunter Barco's innings in AAA this year.
So I would.
I don't think he's ready.
Well, that's a fundamental difference, though.
Yeah.
So really, you're just coming at that he's not ready.
Because honestly, like, if it were, if all things were equal, like, Barco's probably been my fifth starter.
Yes.
Like, right now.
He's eighth on my list, probably.
I am.
That's where the difference comes in.
You know what?
That's a fair conversation.
I'm just lower on Barco than the rest.
Yeah.
That's all.
So you're putting Clevenger and Urquidy ahead of Barco?
In terms of starting for this team this year, I'm just not there with Barco right now.
If you're putting Urquidy and Clevenger ahead of him, then you're out on Barco altogether as, like, a major league pitcher.
Not really.
I'm just not.
He's 25 years old.
If you think so.
And I've seen him pitch in other than him.
When I watch him pitch, I'm like, eh, not quite there yet.
Not really.
Honestly, I do question if Hunter Barco is going to be a major league pitcher.
I do.
All right.
You're out of your mind.
Tyler, all the way back.
We'll find out.
Spring training's over.
Tyler's ready.
He's ready for the season.
Let's go.
We'll find out.
Do you want to move on to our last segment?
Yeah, because I'm hungry.
So the Pittsburgh Pirates today.
Let me.
We'll intro it.
Yeah.
So the Pirates, they released the new food items at PNC Park.
So, again, I think this is always a fun time of the year because this is all just subjective stuff.
It's food items, right?
Everyone loves to discuss food and have their hot takes.
last year was like the renegade dog.
Actually, that was two years ago, huh?
Either way.
That was a while ago, I think.
Maybe I gave her a lot of ish.
I ate it.
Yes, there's pictures.
I ate it.
It was good.
It was really good.
So, but we had, speaking of hoist the cones, there was that one year they had like the cone with all the stupid stuff on that.
And yeah, there's always interesting stuff.
So, I always look forward to this day.
So, let's talk about some of these food items.
Yeah.
So, the Pirates, so, yeah, this is fun.
Get involved.
So, we're going to play Smash or Pass right now.
We've got, they introduced nine new food items today for PNC Park for this season.
They only, they only introduced four pitch pictures of what these things look like.
So, we're going to, we're going to look at the four items that are new at PNC Park that have images to them.
And we're going to Smash or Pass these items.
So, I think everybody knows how to play, but that's what we're going to go with.
So, we're going to start with the Boracua dog.
It's a Puerto Rico-inspired hot dog with a Pittsburgh twist.
This specialty hot dog offering with sofrito beef, Smallman Street deli sauerkraut, yellow mustard, American cheese, ketchup, braised onion, and potato sticks, all served on a roll.
So, Boracua dog, guys, smash or pass?
Smash.
Smash.
I'm going to be real boring.
I'm just telling you right now.
I'm smashing every goddamn thing on this menu.
I gave away all my takes.
I'll tell you more about them when they come up.
But, like, I'm smashing the hell out of this right now.
This is an absolute smash, right?
Like, if you're passing on this, like, what's wrong with you?
This is a banger.
This is a smash.
Yeah.
Yes.
And, again, like, that's why I also brought that up.
Like, when I saw the Renegade dog, I was like, ugh.
But I tried it.
And I was like, this is really good.
And I'm not trying to compare this to it.
But it's like, I feel like you got to give some of these weird things an opportunity.
That's what I learned from the Renegade dog.
And, like, this just has all these different flavors.
This absolute smash.
I can't wait to put that in my mouth.
Do we have clarification?
Is this a, like, normal-sized hot dog?
Or is this like the Renegade dog?
This looks like a normal-sized hot dog.
So, the Renegade dog, the one problem with it was that it was a foot-long dog.
It would get soggy in the middle.
It didn't work as well.
Looking like that, I'm all in, boys.
Well, and actually, also, Tyler, maybe they learned from this.
Because the Renegade dog, wasn't that on a, like, a bun?
Yeah.
This is on a roll.
It was a lot of work.
But that's what I'm saying.
Wasn't that just, like, an extra-long bun?
Yeah, it was.
It was just a roll.
It was like a jumbo dog.
Yeah.
So, again, like, maybe they learned from that.
Maybe.
And the potato sticks on top, I haven't had a potato stick since I was, like, six.
And I would smash the hell out of those.
Smash.
The only thing I'll say here, lose the ketchup.
I think I'd agree.
Ketchup is for children.
Yes.
Replace it with mustard.
Yeah.
You know what, though?
On this, though, with the conglomerate, maybe the ketchup works as opposed to the mustard.
No.
Ketchup and kraut's not going to work together.
Yeah.
I don't know about ketchup and kraut.
Yeah.
Like, that's too Pittsburgh, I think.
Like, we don't need ketchup on everything.
All right.
Just, it's so many people.
We ready for,...
Yes.
Yes.
The heavy hitter dog.
Smash.
It's a full, foot-long hot dog with cornbread coating, yellow mustard, and pico de gallo.
And it's served in a special baseball bat boat.
That's smash.
You know what, guys?
I'm going to pass on this.
I don't know what it is.
I...
I don't like corn dogs.
Like, corn dogs are the worst dogs.
The worst.
And I don't want anything to do with this.
That's...
I'll say that's fair.
The corn dog is the worst, but it's still a corn dog.
Comments· 0
Should Carmen Mlodzinski stay in the bullpen while the Pirates use Urquidy and Clevenger as the fifth starter?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.