◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)◆NEWSPirates, Chas McCormick Agree To Minor League Deal
◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)◆NEWSPirates, Chas McCormick Agree To Minor League Deal
The Pirates’ rotation picture is beginning to sharpen as Spring Training moves into a critical stretch — and the battle for the fifth starter spot is quickly becoming one of the most compelling storylines in Bradenton.
Right now, it looks like a three-man race between Jose Urquidy, Carmen Mlodzinski, and Hunter Barco. Urquidy brings the most established big-league track record of the group, while Mlodzinski offers familiarity and internal confidence after bouncing between roles last season. But it was Barco who grabbed attention this weekend, turning in an impressive outing Sunday that firmly pushed him into the conversation.
And the bigger takeaway? The Pirates may have legitimate pitching depth pushing from below.
Multiple young arms have flashed early in camp, with Antwone Kelly, Wilber Dotel, and Kristian Curtis all showing encouraging traits in their appearances. Whether it’s velocity jumps, sharper secondaries, or improved command, this wave of pitching prospects is giving the organization more options than it’s had in recent springs.
With Neil and DiNardo arriving in Bradenton for their first full week on site, this next stretch of games becomes especially important. From tracking how the fifth starter battle evolves to identifying which young arms continue to separate themselves, there’s plenty to watch as roster decisions inch closer.
Spring Training is entering the phase where roles start to solidify — and for the Pirates, the rotation competition is far from settled.
Comments· 0
The Debate
Should Carmen Mlodzinski stay a high-leverage reliever instead of competing for the fifth starter spot?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.
With Anthony DiNardo and Jim Rosati.
Chapters
Key takeaways
1
If Konnor Griffin keeps hitting like this, with seven balls over 100 mph, nobody stands between him and the Opening Day shortstop job.
2
Jose Urquidy probably has the inside track on the fifth starter spot over Mlodzinski and Barco because of his veteran presence and experience starting in the majors. He's seen as a bridge through April–June while Barco builds up and Jared Jones returns.
3
Not convinced Carmen Mlodzinski works as a starter, since he ran out of steam after the second inning last year and is best locking in for one or two innings. Still, the Pirates would be dumb not to try it in spring.
4
Antwone Kelly will be in the Pirates bullpen at some point this year. Along with other young arms, he'd be a solid option and not just a band-aid during the dog days of July.
5
After Rich Hill and Andrew Heaney left Pittsburgh with ERAs near six, the front office may rather trust young arms with better stuff than spend $5 million on a Patrick Corbin–type veteran.
Yo. Welcome to Bucco Brew, powered by Defer Coffee and Tea. This is the North Shore Nine Podcast presented by FanDuel. I'm your host, Anthony DiNardo. With me, we have... Oh, we don't have Jim. We have Neil with us.
Neil, welcome to Bucco Brew. I think this is their Bucco Brew debut, right?
Second time.
Second time.
I was on a little, a long time ago for Pirate Fest. the one where they had all the balls. They used controversy with all the people they were selling. It was...
Yeah, that one. I do recall, because you were there, so we had you on to talk your Pirates Fest experience. Yeah, this year was a lot better than that one, so that's good.
Yeah, this offseason seemed a lot better than that one, and therefore, the spring training seems a lot better than that spring training.
they're 8-2.
Oh, like you said, Buckos are going to the World Series, right?
Yes, yeah. There is no team better than the Buckos right now in baseball.
Absolutely.
So, with this Bucco Brew, we figured we'd talk a little about, like, the fifth starter role, and then from there, maybe lead into the depth of the pitching, because, again, we've talked about, well, I shouldn't say we, because we haven't been here, but, like, us as the brand, I feel like we talk about Konnor Griffin every single day, and there's at least two shows a day, so that's at least twice a day.
Rightfully so. Producer Cody says sometimes three shows.
Yeah, like, he has taken full attention at spring training. and it makes sense. Like, I think, what is it? He's the first teenager to homer three times in the history of spring training. Like, that's a pretty big deal, and we're rightfully excited.
Yeah. After watching that offense last year, having, like, a phenom shortstop prospect is a cool thing to have.
Right.
But we have talked about him a lot over the last week.
Yeah, but again, like I mentioned, like, rightfully so. he just hit his third home run yesterday. Of course, it was his third hit.
All homers. But, you look at the numbers within the numbers. he's had, what, seven hard hit as well?
Seven over 100 miles an hour, which is what you're looking for. Like, at spring training, the results don't matter.
It's about the process.
Yeah.
And even though he's not getting, like, singles or whatever, and I think Doug yesterday was like, I wish Konnor Griffin would hit a double.
And, like, it's everything you want to see from a kid that young.
And, I don't think there's anyone in his way from getting the opening day shortstop position if he continues like this.
It's all on him. and we're going to probably use that quote over and over again from Colin Beasley, where, like, leave no doubt.
And that's the thing. Like, obviously, you can say, like, it's been just three hits.
and, like, that's not great.
The batting average isn't great.
But when you look at exit velocity, what we talk about was seven over 100 miles an hour.
That's something that's predictive.
Like, you mentioned, that's what you want to see in spring.
Spring training stats don't matter.
Well, the thing in baseball, too, is small sample size.
Yeah.
Like, extreme small sample size.
What can you take from the small sample?
there's been a little bit of unluckiness, right?
Like, that one also could have been a home run.
He could have, we could talk about this fourth hit, which is four home runs.
Yeah.
like, he's been hitting the ball very well.
So, again, we talk about baseball.
Once the sample starts to normalize, because of what he is doing right now, you assume and expect things will look, obviously, better.
And, that average will be there.
He'll hit actually more than, what he hits for home runs this year.
Yeah.
You would think so.
I'm forever scarred by Kevin Newman in terms of spring training stats.
Sure.
Like, 2021 has been the, like, I can't ever trust anything that happens results-wise in the field.
But I can tell, I like to think my eye test is good.
When you have, like, 30 hit balls that are all, like, 60 miles an hour and your batting average is 750.
Yeah.
That, you might look and say, like, maybe this isn't sustainable.
No.
Therefore, it wasn't.
But on the other side, when you look and see seven balls hit over 100 miles an hour, one was robbed at the fence also, which could have been the fourth home run.
Maybe balls will start dropping for him in the real world.
So, again, we're not going to talk about Konnor Griffin as we open about Konnor Griffin.
We do want to talk about the fifth starter spot here.
Coffee and tea are one of life's simplest and most accessible pleasures.
And when enjoyed thoughtfully, you can open your eyes to the here and now.
They have five locations across the city of Pittsburgh, including their flagship in the heart of Pittsburgh's historic strip district.
Don't forget to stop by Defer's new location downtown on Penn Avenue, right across from the Benidum.
Grab a cup and fuel up on your walk to PNC Park.
Mobile ordering is available.
Check out their Instagram for more details.
And of course, that is the bear dot coffee and yourself.
I'm not sure if you're even aware you should, but I'll make sure we tell the people and yourself.
If you go to Defer dot coffee, you can save yourself 30% just by using promo code NS930.
Of course, NS930 for the 30% on your very first order.
So if you go online, they say they have plenty of products, plenty of coffee, tea.
And again, just those items that you can purchase 30% off.
Use code NS930.
Beautiful.
Sounds great.
I'm not a coffee drinker, but I might be a good gift.
Sounds like a good Christmas gift.
It is.
It's a very good Christmas gift, but don't wait 10 more months to do so.
No, exactly.
I didn't take the deal right now.
It's also a great spring training gift.
Yeah.
But yeah, so again, getting back to like that fifth starter spot, there's a few names that are battling for it.
And again, like when you mentioned Hunter Bachar, who did have a start yesterday, we talked a little bit about yesterday on the recap, but to go a little bit further, I think about the starter position.
there's Jose Irquidy, who they signed.
He has experience.
He was with Houston system.
Bill Murphy, obviously very familiar with them.
You will look at some degree.
He's the veteran.
Now he doesn't have a whole lot of major league innings logs behind him.
No.
But he is the presence that comes in.
Like I've been here before and I've won.
And we hired guys from Houston to work on the pitching staff.
He's probably very familiar with the guys on the staff.
If I had to guess, I would say he's probably got the inside track just based off his veteran presence and like familiarity with pitching in the majors at a start level, as opposed to Mlodzinski or Barco.
Right.
But I think a lot will ride.
Like, you know what we see, especially tomorrow when he plays face off against the Colombian team.
But if I had to guess, I think the Pirates are probably looking at him.
I've heard that like the Pirates really like this guy.
as they should, he's been a fine pitcher.
It's really just been the injuries that have derailed him the past few years and such.
So he hasn't had those innings.
Like when he was with Houston and, he's part of the rotation.
And he was a mainstay there.
He was productive.
You know what?
There was nothing, there was nothing that shined.
It wasn't like, Gerrit Cole when he was in Houston back in the day, like this guy was just a complete ace and solid in that sense.
But he was, he was exactly what you want.
And not even a fifth starter, like a fourth starter, even a three starter.
Yeah.
I'm in the ERA mid threes, he logged some innings, that the strikeouts weren't high, but it was just effective pitcher.
And we know what this rotation has.
It has a lot of, I keep saying like the sexiness, there's a lot of stuff in there.
Right.
But there's not a whole lot of, we've done it before.
Healthy.
This is going to, he has what, like 70 innings since 2023.
Something like that.
I think it's like that.
And so like, that's a big problem that you don't know exactly how much that you can really give you in terms of that.
But I could see him as like a nice thing that gets you through like April, May, potentially even June.
And then if you're worried about like the arm load, then like you can, that's when you bring up Barco or you start piggybacking him with Mlodzinski.
Cause I know they like Mlodzinski as a starter as well.
And so just like trying to find ways, the bridge gaps way they use Luis Ortiz before they traded him to Cleveland.
So I would be interested if he even has a rotation spot for the whole year, but I definitely do think he starts on the MLB roster.
But I'm excited to see him pitch because I, it's always cool to see like what guys look like coming back from injury that long, especially when he used to be a good pitcher.
He was a good, reliable pitcher.
And like, I think you make a really good point too.
Like I do think in the best situation, maybe that's not the best way to put it.
I could probably, the best situation is the most talented pitcher to start there from day five or day one.
But like, I think what makes the most sense, like what the Pirates probably wanting to see is him to reclaim a bit of that form to show like, Hey, I can handle that five spot because in like this ideal world, you want him when he's healthy.
Like if you're concerned about the healthy, well, he's healthy now.
Yeah.
Give me the innings, because like you mentioned about maybe calling Hunter Bachar up late.
Like, that's why I think of this ideal world Hunter Bachar doesn't have the innings.
He has that injury past as well.
it's like, you're still ramping him up.
You're still trying to get him to where you want him to be.
Like maybe next year's the year we start thinking like full load, but this year's not the year.
So like, I keep talking to like to some level, you probably want him on that.
Like Bubba, that skeins low where it's like, Hey, we're going to put you in triple a go out there and pitch three innings and come out to save those innings for later than the year you have equity giving you those innings now, right.
Hopefully effective, but also like, keep in mind, then Jared Jones come back at the end of May.
So it's like, let's get those innings now while you're healthy in here, because we do have some reinforcements coming.
Yeah.
I also was forgetting about Jared Jones, but yeah, he's probably coming in or equity doesn't, well, it doesn't have a spot in the rotation, but even so, I feel like he's a good guy that can slot into your bullpen.
Like I know we talked about this with Jared Jones.
I'm just like with Mlodzinski, like, making sure he doesn't have to go six innings each time he's coming back from a major injury.
So I think when you have all this pool of like talented, but like injured pitchers, it's not ideal, but you can finagle it where like you're basically like creating starts out of the aggregate with multiple people instead of like, burning
through people's arms, like Oviedo in 2023.
And then that's what I really want to, no one wants to see like irrequity, like suffering to 150 innings.
His body clearly can't handle it.
Right.
Right.
Absolutely.
But again, you mentioned a good point there too.
Like if he is healthy, like you do have arms come in, like, he's also a guy that could give you like the ball gettings in the bullpen.
it's not as if like, he's just gone and thrown away.
Jared Jones comes in and he's still pitching effectively.
Right.
Or Hunter comes in like, you can still put them and he's also like, in the bullpen at a much different look, I think he could be effective.
It's not going to be like, I'm a Carmen Jansky where it goes from, the rotation to the bullpen and he just turns it up a whole nother notch.
But he'll certainly be a completely different look in the bullpen and right.
Like obviously he'd give you those multiple inning, use it a different way.
Yeah.
We saw how they've been using that reliever role for the past few years.
Like maybe he's a starter for two innings and then you bring in Hunter Barco or whoever it is, Jared Jones.
But yeah, there's certainly a role on him, but I do think it makes sense.
And, again, it was just one start.
You didn't see much.
You mentioned tomorrow he'll be starting against Columbia.
You do want to see more out of him and see what he has, but I do think he has effective stuff to be a starter for sure.
Yeah.
and I think, in terms of where the market is, what it looks like right now, in terms of free agent starting pitchers, I don't really blame them for like sticking with equity instead of like trying to go drop like 17 million on Lucas Giolito.
I feel like, I feel like I'm pretty sure Bob is feeling pretty good about that.
And Bob doesn't want to get that either.
Yeah.
So I'm excited to see him and it's like a new shiny toy.
You don't exactly know what we're going to get out of him, but I am excited.
So, yeah.
And, again, we talked about Hunter Barco or something to read and to talk a little more about him, we spent a lot on Jose at this point because we think he's going to be there, but Hunter Barco, I think obviously like when he does make the rotation, it's most
likely going to be, after the first few months in my point of view, but like when he does, we're seeing what he can do.
And this is why there's a lot of talk about this rotation, how good they can be.
Cause Hunter Barco yesterday, I know we didn't get to watch you watch it.
So I can't say it on like a, that perspective, but seeing what transpires, look, it's looking at stack cast, seeing the swing and miss stuff, seeing how many strikes he threw, how effective he was, like this reiterates and doubles down of like how good of a pitcher
he actually can be.
Yeah.
it sucks.
Cause I really want to, we really want to watch him.
Like we wanted to watch Ashcraft pitch against Houston.
We wanted to watch, Barco yesterday and we couldn't watch either, but no, in the Savant bubbles and the Savant stuff, what's great, 11 whiffs, a hundred percent whiff right on the fastball.
I think, and seven, I think it was on the slider was two out of three.
Maybe 11 lifts regardless.
Like it's like a really good performance.
He went three innings, zero runs to give up zero hits.
I think it was just a walk.
And the stuff looks filthy.
There was one hit in the game yesterday.
I think there was one unearned run out of it too.
Okay.
So, like everything you want to see out of a young prospect, like good stuff, striking people out, making people look stupid.
Like, I feel like Barco has surprised me.
I didn't think he looked as good coming out of spring training.
Yeah, for sure.
And I want to highlight again, like you mentioned, like the fastball, seven swing and misses out of 15 swings on the fastball.
Yeah.
This wasn't like the secondary stuff, which also did look good according to that.
But like I said, he threw a predominantly fastball as well.
Yeah.
he attacked these hitters and they still could not hit it.
they couldn't make any type of contact.
So yeah, like he has this stuff.
It's just like, can he log the innings?
Can he last?
That's something you're probably looking this year to still like rebuild, build up or I should say, or like maybe next year, a lot of these guys you feel more comfortable with, that's the, like, that's the worry this year with this rotation.
the rotation is, there's a lot of really good talented pitchers.
It's just like, are there, are there innings there?
Yeah.
How are we going to get the innings?
So again, when you talk about these guys, but to throw in that too, like, so there's Hunter Bachar we talk about.
And that was put out there that the Pirates approached him like that.
We're interested in looking at you as a potential starter as well.
Is that, is that just like, Hey, let's see what happens.
Is it also just like, Hey, we're going to need some innings in spring training as well.
Cause it's WBC that's happening.
We're going to lose some pitchers.
So let's say, let's entertain you as a starter to see what happens.
like Jason Mackey put out there an article just talking about the stuff that he's like revamped and how comfortable he felt more at the second half of the year with his pitches that he didn't have the first year.
Like he incorporated a splitter.
He was talking a lot with like David Bednar about it.
the pitch sequence thing, like the first half when he was the starter, he wasn't real comfortable with a lot.
And then the second half when he went back to the bullpen, all that also came together.
Where it's like, well, if I had this, I probably could have been an effective starter.
also the curve ball incorporated.
Like, so he was a different pitcher second half.
And with that, he didn't really get the opportunity to start again to prove like, Hey, I can't do this.
So again, like I'm not opposed to seeing it, I firmly in my mind, I'm like, Hey, Carmen, just be the dude that you are in the bullpen because that's an effective weapon, but I'm willing to entertain seeing it.
Yeah.
I don't know how you feel on that.
if there was another starter here, like if they had managed to get Quintana back or something like that, I think it'd be, no, you're going to the seventh inning role.
That's just where you're going to be.
And we're going to be really good in the seventh inning because of that.
Right.
But I think, with Jared Jones coming back from injury with Barco and Urquidy, like not necessarily having like the best bill of health.
It does make a lot of sense to try this out again.
Yeah.
Am I convinced it's going to work?
Not really.
I think he's just, he's so good focusing and locking in for those one to two innings when you really need it.
And when I watched him last year, I know he didn't have like all the pitches, but you could tell he really started running out of steam after that second inning.
And that's okay.
Like, I think he's going to be a really effective reliever.
But that said, the Pirates would be dumb not to try it.
Like, that's what spring training is for.
Like, you should be trying this type of stuff out.
Do I, and so we'll watch him.
I'm excited to see him in the bullpen this year.
And if he wins that fifth starter spot, it means that he beat two good pitchers.
Like, Barco's look good.
Yeah.
And Urquidy, hopefully, add like a, good career boost at this point.
So, I can't be too mad no matter what happens.
Yeah.
No, again, like that is a really good perspective.
So, if he does win it, he beat out some dudes that you thought could win it too.
So, that probably means that's, he looks really good doing so.
Yeah.
Last year, did he have any competition for that fifth spot?
Bubba.
Bubba, yeah.
Like I said, I guess you could argue Bubba.
Yeah.
Which it was, there were some up and downs, but was he going to make it out there?
And he didn't.
like, you could maybe say, but it wasn't, it wasn't like this year, I think.
Like, that's maybe a good point.
Yeah.
it wasn't like how it is this year where some of these guys, like Hunter Barco could make it, like, absolutely.
I don't think there's like a worry of, service time.
Well, innings, more or less.
But like, I feel like it's almost like he has like the Jared Jones.
Like, if he goes out there and proves it, he's going to start.
Yeah.
and if not, again, if other people beat him out, then it makes them more comfortable put him in AAA to do this thing.
So, like, it's a true competition.
I know it is.
And it's one of the more exciting things to like watch because like you can't take much result-wise from Pipsman Fraternium, but you can take what pitchers look like and how their pitches look because even though they're going out and just like messing around with their stuff, it does show like what is being worked on and how their pitches
have developed.
And so, if Carmen Mlodzinski has actually developed a couple new pitches like that curveball, like you said, and it makes him an effective starter, that's just another huge win for us.
And so, that's going to be fun to watch too.
So, I'm excited.
And like, eventually, like, obviously when these guys come, maybe he is relegated to the bullpen.
Like, that's still the weapon there.
Like, you still want to see this stuff.
And it's what's a takeaway here is though, it's oddly enough, like, we haven't really seen Carmen pitch much.
No, it's weird.
We're 10 games in and he hasn't really pitched at all.
Right.
So, hopefully, we get to see more of him.
Again, obviously, with the WBC, hopefully, we'll see more of that.
But like, going back to what you said too about like what they're trying to see, who's pitching well.
The team knows what they're working on, what they're trying to accomplish.
They're zoomed in seeing how that's going.
Like, hey, do this with a fastball or do, this week's sequencing or whatever it might be.
They're looking on that.
They're not focused on the results and it's like, okay, he's doing this.
We feel comfortable.
Like, yeah, that fastball is nasty in this way.
That will play.
Even though the secondary stuff might got lit up.
That's not what we're worried about today.
Yeah.
or like if it was the curveball, like, how do I feel about the curveball?
That curveball, that's coming in.
Yeah.
That's what I need to be an effective pitcher and that's working.
Okay.
Now I feel more comfortable.
So again, it's not so much the results that are mattering.
Yeah.
It's what they're trying to accomplish and how well they're doing with that.
Almost like going back to the bubble quotes.
Hey, when I did that first thing, exactly what I wanted.
And that first thing looked great.
Yeah.
The setting game was toast.
It was trash.
But like in Bubba's eyes, at least in that sense, like that didn't matter.
I did what I came out to accomplish.
Now to some level, like I still want to throw strikes, but yeah, that's what I'm trying to put the track.
I'm not trying to absolve Bubba, but I'm trying to say that's the mentality.
Like, what are they trying to do?
Did they accomplish that?
That's what they're looking into in some level.
But like, I want to bring this up.
So it's a good question.
Steel City does asks, does ask, is the ideal fall rotation, Skenes, Keller, Ashcraft, Bubba.
And Jones.
And I would say, yeah, like, I think ideally that's what you're hoping to have.
It's hard to dispute.
like if Jared Jones is coming out as your fifth starter, that's a really good rotation.
Like, yeah, it is a playoff rotation.
And as cool as like an equity, like resurgence would be, or Barco resurgence.
Like, I think those are your five core guys.
All of them in some capacity approved.
They've been able to pitch at the MLB level.
I know like in Chandler's case, a little bit of Jones's case, it's been a little bit of a short sample size.
But the stuff is there.
And like all of like Skenes, Jones, and Skenes, Jones, and Ashcraft and all those guys have shown the ability to pitch with sub three RA stuff.
Oh, for sure.
And that's something most teams don't have.
So yeah, these guys are just trying to bridge the gap until we get that fully healthy rotation.
If we ever get that fully healthy rotation.
And that's why it's always an if.
And that's why you always need arms.
We're talking like it would still be nice if they add another starter into the mix.
Yeah.
It doesn't seem like that's going to be the case, at least at this point in time.
But absolutely, I think that's the ideal thing.
Like you mentioned, like numbers are numbers.
those five guys, that's the thing about them.
The talent those five guys have, all of them can be one, two, or threes in a rotation.
So you're talking about some of those being like a four or five or whoever that might end up being.
like this is a five, these are, those are five guys that you trust.
Like they can go out there.
They can compete hands down.
They can go out there and win you a game.
And what's really fun about the playoffs is we get there.
Like big if.
Right.
But like, it's like you're not pitching a full five man rotation.
Like you're going like one through three, one through four.
And then you might just have Jared Jones come in and pitch two to three innings twice a week and just shut people down with this fastball and slider.
And that's also a really cool tool you can have.
You could do that with Bubba.
You can do that with Ashcraft, whichever way you feel comfortable.
And then you can even bring in Barco and Urquidy and guys like that to bridge that gap.
And so you have like this army of starters who all have great stuff.
I've all proven they have the ability to pitch well and they really help bridge those long playoff games together, especially if you're in a seven and a seven game series.
So yeah, for sure.
Really looking forward to that.
But like if we make the playoffs, I feel like that's a very distinct possibility.
Absolutely.
Absolutely.
So, we're talking about this fifth starter battle.
I think it would be cool to touch a little bit on like the depth as well outside that people don't really know too much about.
Also, before we do that, we do want to tell you a little bit about this as well.
So this episode is brought to you by IQ bar, our exclusive snack, hydration and coffee sponsor IQ bar protein bars, IQ mix, hydration mixes and IQ Joe mushroom coffees are delicious, low sugar, brain and body fuel.
And that's what you need to do.
The ultimate sampler pack is a great way to try IQ bars and flavors.
You get nine IQ bars, eight IQ mix sticks and four IQ Joe sticks as well.
IQ bars products are clean label certified and entirely free from gluten, dairy, soy, GMOs and artificial ingredients.
And like what's cool over 20,000 five star reviews and counting more people than ever are fueling their busy lifestyles with IQ bars, brain and body boosting bars, hydration mixes and mushroom coffees.
Their ultimate sampler pack includes all three.
What's cool is like they're sending us down here for spring training.
So we get the fuel up on the IQ bar protein bars as well and whatnot, which I think we all need.
this has been we just got here.
Listen, I'm tired.
I'm tired.
And it's going to be even more tiring when we're out in the sun all day.
So we're going to need these.
Yeah, absolutely.
So as of right now, IQ bars offering our special podcast listeners 20% off all IQ bar products, including the ultimate sampler pack plus free shipping.
To get your 20% off text MLB to six four thousand text MLB to six sixty four thousand.
I'm sorry.
Text MLB to sixty four thousand.
That's MLB to sixty four thousand messages.
Message and data rates may apply.
See terms, more details.
So, yeah, go get yourself some IQ bars to fuel up for your beginning today.
So Defer coffee and tea.
Yeah.
IQ bar.
You're set.
You're ready to go.
Yeah, perfect.
So, yeah.
So going back again, we talk about the fifth star going back to talk a little more about the depth of pitching, because that's something we talked about.
Like this team doesn't have a whole lot of depth, but I know Jim's argued this point.
And again, that doesn't determine for one to go like get another fifth starter.
But there are some like that next tier of prospects, like these interesting arms, like the Antwone Kelly's who pitched, right?
Like, I feel like that next tier of pitchers, they're not really there yet.
Like, they're not fighting for an opening day roster spot.
You know what?
Yeah.
They're not ready.
They're not progressed enough.
But there's one I was.
I would say a Brandon Bidois might be fighting for an opening day spot.
Besides that, I agree.
Most of these guys are still like a year or so away.
Yeah.
But.
That's fair.
But I'd look at that more like in the bullpen.
Yeah, for sure.
Okay.
So, and that's fair.
And that's a guy.
Yeah.
Like keep an eye on him.
Yeah.
Well, yeah.
And I just think that like, when you talk about Curtis, you talk about Dotel, you talk about all these guys, like they're definitely like a year away, but they have been fun to watch.
And like a lot of their ERAs aren't the best, but like you can just tell, like these guys have at the very least a bullpen in the major league ceiling.
Like Dotel specifically.
Well, no, floor.
What?
Floor.
Floor, right.
Floor, yeah.
That changes things a lot.
Definitely the floor.
You are right.
And like, Dotel gets the first start of the spring training and he comes out and like shocks everyone.
Maybe I should pay more attention to prospect list.
But for me, it's like he wasn't even on my radar.
It's like, oh, this is fun.
Yeah.
And then he comes out and pitches like that.
And no, I don't know what the pirates have tapped into.
But clearly, they have learned how to properly develop pitching because you're getting guys like popping up every single year about guys to get excited about.
And all three of the guys that you just mentioned have really good quality stuff.
And a little bit of we've been able to watch with them.
It's nice.
It's a lot of fun.
Yeah.
No complaints.
Yeah, absolutely.
the thing that pirates have done well is develop pitchers.
That's why we're talking about these starters right now.
a lot of them were developed by this regime.
And even the ones that weren't, like your Mitch Kellers, Mitch Keller was really bad to begin his career.
it's like you've got to hand it to this regime to some level.
I know they, go to tread.
You can give tread a lot of credit as well and whatnot.
But, like, there's a lot of, hey, this regime allowed that.
He did this turnaround under this regime.
And whatever you feel about Mitch Keller, I know he's polarizing as well.
Yeah.
But, like, he's a very effective pitcher for what he does.
And he's going to – this team needs a Mitch Keller this year.
But, like, what they have done well is develop pitchers.
And, we've talked so much about the guys that we talked about earlier.
And I feel like these guys need to be talked about to some level as well.
Because, like you mentioned, they're probably your way.
However, I do think there's definitely a world where you could see any one of these three helping out the team this year at some point.
Yeah.
I said they're not battling for an open day spot.
But, like, there could be a day, we're talking about death or injuries happen.
there could be, like, hey, it's July.
I'm not trying to jinx anything, but X player went down.
This one's happening.
Like, we need to make, some spot starts.
And you're seeing Antwone Kelly make that or Wilbert Ertel make that or Khristian Curtis make that.
You talk about – I know you jokingly said ceiling by accident.
But, like, there's also, like, the possibility – like, we do think they certainly could be starters.
But they could also – maybe they need help in the bullpen.
And, like, what if you had Antwone Kelly in the bullpen?
Yeah.
Like, all the three of those guys, I think the thing about them is if they're not starters, they have their stuff to be really good bullpen arms as well.
I fully expect Antwone Kelly to be in the bullpen at some point this year.
Okay.
Like, I feel like he's probably going to project that way anyway.
But, like, he's just that good.
And if you look at, like, how the Pirates do bullpen or how any team around the league does bullpen, there's going to be, what, 15, 20 guys or so who are going to take bullpen innings during the season.
We've all taken Alex Thelm's Sporcle quiz at the end of the year at minimum.
And so, like, whenever you see, like, the eight guys that are on the roster are not going to be there the whole year.
You're going to DFA guys.
Some guys are going to get injured.
And so, no, I 100% think some of these guys – maybe not Dotel because, like, he's been starting in his whole minor league career.
I imagine they want to keep it that way.
But I definitely think Kelly or Bidois or other guys like that will 100% be called up at some point to, in the dog days of July, try to get us through some games.
And I think this guy wouldn't just be, like, a bad band-aid.
I think they should actually be pretty solid guys in that role.
Oh, I think, yeah.
I think all of them right now could be solid in that role.
Yeah.
That's what we're saying.
Like, it's not – like, they're not – you want to make them starters.
You're hoping.
You're developing them as starters, right?
You haven't made a decision on anything like, okay, this guy's not a starter.
All of them can absolutely be starters, which is why you said, like, the floor, is at least a reliever because if not, they could be effective relievers.
And I think almost all of them, all three of them, I feel like, if they're fighting for actual, like, bullpen spots, there's a real battle there too.
Like, I feel comfortable – one of them in the bullpen, like, today to some level.
But, yeah, like, they pump gas too.
At least Wilbur and Antwone Kelly, they pump some gas.
These guys have this stuff that, like – I also think there are some possibilities where you might see these guys make some starts in the year.
it's not that they can be part of, like, the mainstay of the rotation.
Hopefully.
Hopefully, we're not there.
That's a big problem.
Yeah.
But, like, I feel comfortable where if you're not going out there to get the other fifth starter to really get you, like, if these guys, one or two of them gave you, like, two to four to maybe five stars or something like that, like, I'm probably okay with that.
Yeah, and, like, they're going to, like, break the glass in case of emergency type starters.
Yeah.
But, like, Sherry – Right now.
Yeah, right now.
For now, yes.
we've talked about Antwone Kelly or, Zotel or Khristian Curtis, in two months, like, holy crap with these guys.
Like, it might change.
But, as of today, their perspective is right.
Yeah, but, like, Cherington's gone on a lot about how he wants, like, what, nine or ten guys who can take the ball at any given time and start.
Right.
And when you trade away guys like Oviedo, guys like Burroughs, which are going to be losses, I think both are going to be good MLB pitchers this year, you do have to replace that depth.
And it's been next man up.
And that's really cool, and that's really good to see.
And, not to compare us to the Yankees because I'm not sure it's, like, a big, like, comparison, but, like, the Yankees keep loading up on guys.
Like, every year the Yankees are shipping off highly touted prospects for MLB talent because they just are able to keep replacing people in the system.
And so if the Pirates are able to do this where they're able to bring in wows every year by, like, trading from the surplus and then bringing in three more guys like a Kelly, like a Dotel, as more depth, and that's close to, like, your MLB talent,
like, that's a really good system to have, especially for a team like the Pirates that can't develop hitting in the same way they can't pitching.
Yeah.
you mentioned the Yankees.
I always go back to the Dodgers.
It's a different reason, but I think the Dodgers give the perspective of, this is exactly why you need arms because even the Dodgers can't get through a season without 10 pitchers at least, you know?
Like, 75% of the Dodgers' rotation is on the IL at any given point.
Right.
Yeah.
it was at one point, like, yeah, like, their IL had more of a payroll than the Pirates' entire payroll.
That's another story, another topic, another thing we're alluding to, but, like, yes, like, you absolutely need arms because guys will get injured.
Yes, that's always been, like, our worry about this rotation.
Adding another starter wouldn't hurt, but let's also maybe talk about the depth that is there, and, there certainly is talent.
So, again, I do want to bring up, especially those three at this point because I think that's, like, that next tier where there's a lot of people that don't really know who they are, right?
And I think this year could be a big year of, like, you're going to find out who they are, you know?
So, like, for the personal development, but also for the team because there could be situations where they're needed.
And I don't say I'm confident that they'll be there, but I'm confident that at that point in time, it'll be okay.
it's not like a white flag, and it's like, oh, God, we got to throw in, I don't want to say names because we've done a lot of stuff behind the scenes about guessing the best Pirates from 2020 to 2025, and it's a bit sad.
So, I don't want to bring up names that, like, had those roles in the past.
So, we'll just forget it.
But you know what I'm going with.
I feel better that it's those guys than some of these retreads that we brought in, like, 2021 that have to give you innings.
Well, that's going to be my next point.
It's like, I wonder if the Pirates have all just burned from, like, Rich Hill and Andrew Heaney.
Like, not that they're good guys, but, like, those guys were leaving Pittsburgh with ERAs close on six.
And so, I wonder if the calculus in the front office right now is we could go out and burn $5 million on Patrick Corbin or a Rich Hill type or an Andrew Heaney type, or we could simply just let our young guys who have better stuff work their magic
and see how that goes instead.
Yeah.
And I think that's a valid way to go about this because, like, I don't – since Quintana, has there really been, like, a good veteran one-year deal that we've brought in that people – like, for the whole time he's been here, people have liked?
that's a good point.
Yeah.
that is a good point.
I guess no.
Yeah.
I guess no.
That is the answer.
That true veteran, like, that guy you're talking about specifically, they brought in arms that weren't veterans.
But, like, I go to Bailey Falter in a sense.
Like, I know it's not the same situation.
Yeah.
But Bailey Falter was that guy that's like, well, who is he?
And then it's like, oh, okay, this trade isn't so bad after all.
It actually worked out very well.
Yeah.
To the point when he got traded to Kansas City last trade deadline, I blew up.
What are we doing here?
What's going on?
Yeah.
So, I guess what I'm trying to hear it say also is, like, but it's debatable.
Yeah.
you can absolutely have this debate.
Like, what you are saying and that perspective, if that side is more of the power to the thinking, that's a true debate that you can have.
there's merit to that.
And it does seem at this point, if there's not another star that's come in, I was always fully anticipating there would be since it's already March.
It still can happen.
Yeah.
It still can absolutely happen.
There's still guys available.
even in the comments, I can talk about Patrick Corbin, Tyler Anderson.
if we're still there.
If we got Zach Littell on a one-year deal, I'd be the happiest man in the world.
Yeah.
That would be great.
All three of those, I think the other two are going to make, like, I'm not going to be the happiest man in the world.
Okay.
I'm saying that if Zach Littell is your fifth starter.
Yeah.
That's a really good reputation.
And that's what I'll allude to.
Like, that'll certainly make me feel safer.
And maybe what they're doing is because there's still, you mentioned three guys that are still available that would make you feel that way.
Maybe they're just waiting it out.
it makes sense.
I know it sounds cheap, but like the Pirates way, like we're comfortable with any three of you, so whichever one's left, and now you're desperate and you're willing to take this $3 million deal, whatever in their eyes is like, then you're the guy.
Yeah.
Because it's like, it could be either one of you.
We don't really care.
So whoever's last and desperate, that's the one we want.
Maybe that is the case.
We'll find out.
Cause I know people have stated here, like it's been still looking for a fifth starter.
he said he is, but the action show, like nothing's happened yet.
Yeah.
Not hearing too much about it.
So in my eyes, maybe that's just what happened.
They're just saying, who's going to get desperate and take this piece of pie that we're offering, which is very below market.
Yeah.
But at that point in time, that's what you're just going to take.
Yeah.
It was like, you have to play baseball.
I would be a little worried just because like, when you look at guys like Jordan Montgomery and other guys who signed so late in spring training recently, like they almost never have good seasons.
There's something about being an MLB camp clearly, like from the beginning of spring training that helps guys like get ready for the, for the season.
Like you pitching your own, like simulated games isn't the same effect as being in spring training games.
And so I would be like a little like concerned about that.
But at the same time, again, like, if Giolito or Littell are there for a fair price, you have to go get those.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Very fair.
So, again, I think that wraps up what we want to discuss here and talk about.
Cause again, we have so much content to give you.
We'll be live today.
Of course, at noon for our podcast at Lee calm, where it's a whole, mostly all new faces.
There's still some carry over Doug's still here.
Cody's still here.
but we got Neil in the house.
We have Nate in the house, at this point in time.
So noon we'll do that.
We'll have, of course, our wrap up.
And I don't know if there's an emergency podcast for fifth starter.
We'll be live for that too.
So make sure you're of course subscribing, following along with all our socials.
anything else that you wanted to say here?
No, just excited to be here.
All right.
Me too.
Me too.
So here for the full week for home games, Monday, Tuesday, Thursday, Friday, Wednesday night, we'll be live at the cut for NS nine live at eight o'clock.
So if you are in Ratington area, you want to come join us, definitely do so.
It'd be a good time.
and then outside of that, I guess we'll just, we'll see you in like three hours, three hours.
How's it going guys?
You see us at Lee calm, say hi.
We'll see you guys later.
Bye-bye.
Bye.
All right.
That wraps up this episode of North shore nine.
Thanks so much for tuning in.
Whether you're listening on the podcast or catching us on YouTube, if you enjoyed the show, please give this video a thumbs up and don't forget to hit that subscribe button.
If you haven't already, it really helps us grow.
And if you're listening on the podcast, a quick review goes a long way in helping others find the show.
Plus be sure to tell a friend about us.
There's always room for more here in the NS9 community.
And for those looking to support us a little more, consider joining our Patreon, become an MVP member and get exclusive perks while helping us continue to bring you more of the pirates content.
You love.
Thanks again for all your support and Let's Go Bucs.
Thanks again for all your support and Let's Go Bucs.
Thanks again for all your support and Let's Go Bucs.
Thanks again for all your support and Let's Go Bucs.
Thanks again for all your support and Let's Go Bucs.
Thanks again for all your support and Let's Go Bucs.
Thanks again for all your support and Let's Go Bucs.
Thanks again for all your support and Let's Go Bucs.
Thanks again for all your support and Let's Go Bucs.
Thanks again for all your support and Let's Go Bucs.
Thanks again for all your support and Let's Go Bucs.
Thanks again for all your support.
Thanks again for all your support and Let's Go Bucs.
Comments· 0
Should Carmen Mlodzinski stay a high-leverage reliever instead of competing for the fifth starter spot?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.