North Shore Nine finally sits down with Pittsburgh Pirates GM Ben Cherington for a long-awaited conversation. The episode digs into the criticism that has followed his tenure, the moves that helped strengthen this roster, and whether he deserves more credit for where the Pirates are now. They also discuss this offseason that brought in players like Ryan O’Hearn, Brandon Lowe, and Marcell Ozuna. Watch or listen now.
We Criticized Ben Cherington… Does He Deserve Credit Now?

With Anthony DiNardo and Jim Rosati.
Chapters
Key takeaways
- 1
Cherington stuck to GM speak and didn't reveal much about why the Pirates didn't spend like this in earlier years.
- 2
His real answer came down to resources: dealing David Bednar and Ke'Bryan Hayes at last year's deadline freed up the room to spend this offseason.
- 3
With payroll over $100 million for the first time on Cherington's watch, the read is that he simply didn't have the money to spend before.
- 4
Even at 10-6 and in first place, the Pirates will need more pitching help to get through the season.
- 5
Cherington argued the Pirates' record with high school pitchers drafted after the first round is one of the best in baseball over the past 10–15 years.
Players discussed
Full transcript93 paragraphs · show
*Drums of the game*
Yo, welcome to the North Shore Nine Podcast presented by FanDuel. This is the WNS9+. I'm your host, Anthony DiNardo. With me, we have our co-host, Jim Rosati. Jim, happy Thursday, well, Tuesday, but Thursday for y'all watching.
Tuesday, right now, Thursday, when this is aired, we're going to be traveling, to Pittsburgh for the first NS9 tailgate, Thursday night. So we pre-recorded this special episode for everybody on Thursday night.
Yeah. First off, I'm excited because that tailgate is coming. The pirates are balling out right now. Cones everywhere. I can't wait. I can't wait. We're gonna have our many brother sandwiches. We'll be tailgating before the game. It's going to be a good game.
It's gonna be a fun day. You guys don't have plans. Come out there. We'll see you guys on Saturday, 12 o'clock. We'll be, doing our tailgate. So come see us, come check us out and then let's go to the game. Have some fun.
Let's do it.
Let's do it.
Yeah. How about our guest today?
How about our guest spend some time in the making, huh?
Yeah. So, I originally asked, to see if we could have Ben on, back when we found out he was retained as general manager and, just some scheduling things. We haven't really been able to work it out until just now. But, yeah, the pirates are hot. we've always been pretty critical of Ben Cherington. So shout out to him for coming on the show. we tried to make it not like super,
like we were beating him up, but we, I felt like we asked him some questions in terms of like, Hey, why didn't we do this earlier, Ben?
So that was a thing, like a peek by the curtains. Like it was, there was a point of like, Hey, is your, it's maybe your opportunity to talk to the fans. we have some, it's not gonna be a cakewalk. We have some difficult questions to ask.
And then he went and had the all season. Yeah. And it's like, well, he went and yeah, it's like, geez. All right. Well, now we got to switch things up a little bit.
Yeah. For real. we're going to ask you, why don't you start doing these things? And then he did it. And now it's like, well, like there's not much to ask anymore, but we ask a little bit, we go back. And then of course we ask some stuff in the future now. So give it a listen. We're going to have Ben come on. So let's go and get into it.
All right. So I want to welcome to the show, Ben Cherington, Pittsburgh Pirates, general manager, Ben, thanks for hopping on North shore nine for a little bit.
Pleasure to be here guys. Thanks for having me.
So I just, so we're just going to jump right into this, Ben. I, we've been pretty critical of your tenure over the last seven years.
So I want to just rewind back to September. things weren't going great. I asked you to come on the show. We were finally able to like work things out to come on now.
But since that point you've acquired for all stars, you signed the number one prospect in baseball to the largest deal in team history.
So I guess my question is, did you do all of that just to make this podcast appearance a little bit easier on you?
the, I think, the answer to that, the great, the great constant that we know about working in this business is that, if we're not delivering well enough to our fans, there's going to be criticism that comes with that as the nature of things.
And, that's the goal every day is to find a way to get better. So we deliver better. And, that didn't start last September or October.
that's been working hard at this for several years and, Pittsburgh's a great baseball town that, I think our fans deserve, more than what we've been able to deliver.
And we've been working really hard at that. we were excited at the end of last year.
It was a very disappointing outcome. and at the same time, I felt it was very clear to me that there was an opportunity ahead of us, with players who were already here and players who we thought we could add and things that were going on in our clubhouse.
And, so I was equally disappointed by the outcomes of the season, but, excited and motivated by the off season of what was to come.
So I want to talk about that off season that was to come because yeah, like you mentioned, it seemed like, you had the opportunity to do some stuff this off season. you were able to successfully execute on bringing in impact players and injecting them into this major league roster.
What was the plan going into this off season about that? And how were you able to execute on that as opposed to previous off seasons?
It just, you, on paper, this is the most talent you've brought in over an off season. So like, what was different this off season?
Yeah. I think there's a few things that were coming together. one is this stuff builds over time, like, Bryan Reynolds and Mitch Keller and Oneil Cruz, or just to name three guys are all, really important parts of this team.
They've been a huge part of our, early outcomes. And all three of those guys have been pirates for longer than I have. So, and then there's a whole bunch of guys that are brand new in 2026 and a whole bunch of stuff in between.
So it's really hard to look at any off season in a vacuum, it's influenced by what's happened in years past. And it's a, it's a build toward whatever you do today. so it is a continuation. That's one part of it. I think at the same time, we did make some decisions last July, partly out of, the disappointment of where we were, we made some decisions that, we felt like we had to.
to acknowledge where we were, to acknowledge where we were, not decisions. We necessarily intended to make going into the season, but acknowledging where we were.
And some of those decisions did, we felt were necessary and put the team in a stronger position going forward. Some of them were difficult. but they did also create some flexibility, some additional flexibility coming into this off season.
and then I think, I think the last piece really was just, really just confronting as an organization and aligning more strongly, or as strong, as strong as I have felt we've been aligned, on just, the only thing that matters is putting the team first.
And if we're going to deliver better to our fans, that's what, that's where our focus needs to be. And, let's do everything we possibly can to do that.
I feel like in previous off seasons, we've heard muttering of pirates being on some free agents and many of them maybe not come into fruition or whatnot. this year, again, much different, so like, maybe like, what was the plan this year? And, what was maybe the difference that you're able to, acquire the guy that you're really targeting?
Yeah, again, I think, I think a number of things come together. We did have a little bit more payroll space combination of reasons for that combination of just natural, progression increase over time. with some moves from last summer to, open up a little bit of flexibility combination. Those things came together to create a little bit more flexibility. So that does give you, it does put you in a position at least to engage, with, some different free agents than maybe we have in the past.
I think my experience talking to free agents this off season, as disappointing as 2025 was what I was getting back from free agents was the same thing that we were saying internally, which was that there was opportunity here. We could, do the, do the right work, do good work consistently, continue to build brick by brick, in terms of how we were building the clubhouse, that there was a foundation of talent, certainly on the pitching side that gave us a chance.
And players were attracted to that. So yeah, we explored several, opportunities, didn't land all of them. but that going in, no team lands all of them and nothing ventured, nothing gained. That's how I thought about it. going into the off season, we were committed to, certainly improving the offensive depth, in September, October, you don't know how you're going to do that. You just know, you have to do it.
And you got to explore a lot of things in order to land some of the things that, will help you do that. Wanted to add to the left side of our pitching staff, in ways that we could. I think the one thing that we. Aimed to do and maybe didn't quite do, as much of, as we went into the, as we got through the off season, be in, not fully anticipating, you don't know what trades are going to come your way. We ended up trading.
Vieto burrows. so in the background, like, let's see if we can backfill that may be one area that we didn't do as much of. but things can happen anytime, right? Like we can, we can, keep looking out for those opportunities as we get into the season.
as far as the guys that you acquired right off the bat there, Ryan O'Hearn, Brandon Lowe, you mentioned a piece there about like adding brick by brick, adding to the clubhouse. and you're not the first person I've heard mentioned from the front office, talk about just like, not just the caliber of talent, but like the players were guys like Ryan O'Hearn and Brandon Lowe and Marcell Ozuna. We've heard his impact on, Oneil Cruz, that he's had already were those people that you were targeting, not only just for their talent, but for like what they could bring to the team itself.
You always want to know as much as you can about both. And, when you're talking about major league players who have a track record on the field, in some ways, that's the easy part projecting what you think they're going to be on the field. You're just, you're going off of what they've done in the past, to some extent, and it's not certain, but that gives you a pretty good guide. the off field part of it is harder to predict perfectly or accurately, partly because it just is period. You don't, you're not, you're not, you're not in the same room with these people.
You're trying to get that information through conversation, due diligence, tapping into network and relationships. But even if you know that about a person, I don't think you really know how it's going to work until, that group of people is actually in the room together.
in our clubhouse together. cause one person might, we're all different in different environments to some degree. And, so you don't really know. So that's the part we want to know as well as we can. We never know perfectly. it's an important part of the assessment and calculus. We'd never know for sure. I will say that, the best team cultures I've ever been around or observed are ones where they're just keeping the most important thing, the most important thing.
all the time. And, energy is going toward how do we win the game tonight and whatever the outcome is, what do we learn from that? And how do we do it again? The next day sounds very simple. but often things can create distractions, and the good team cultures and good teams generally are ones that minimize those distractions and, keep the energy on the most important thing, which is the game on the field.
so we were aiming certainly, you certainly aim to do that in, bringing a collection of people together that you think will give us the best chance to do that. You don't know for sure. Nobody knows for sure until, that group is together and we find out.
Yeah. And like you talking last year was disappointing and I think a lot of people can understand that sentiment. but with that came opportunity. So I guess my question also too, is, again, like Jim mentioned, we've been critical on things.
And I think a lot of things that we wanted to see was like making that push, maybe after in 2024, 2025, adding onto the team. And that is something you guys really did this year. What was different about this year, and making those acquisitions opposed to maybe like the past few years?
Yeah, I think it just goes back to what I said before about, a number of things coming together. it wasn't, we didn't work any harder this off season, than we did the previous off season, off season before that.
There was no like difference in effort level or what we were trying to accomplish. we've gone into each of, at least, at least into 24 and 25, certainly with, only focused on improvement and winning more baseball games.
and all of our effort was towards that. We didn't execute well enough, clearly. if there's a difference, this off season, again, I think it just goes back to those things.
I mentioned coming together a little bit of, it's a continuation of work over time. It's players mature players who are already here maturing and being ready now to contribute, either contribute even more contribute some, in some cases, a little bit of opportunity opened up, with moves last summer.
and then just, again, I think, I think, I don't think the effort was any different. I do think we were more fully aligned organizationally on, what were the most important thing was.
and I think that kept us focused on, even when it was really hard, kept us focused on, is this the right thing for the team? Is this best? Is this the bet we're making? doesn't mean you're going to be right. Like we're going to be wrong sometimes, but, we need to keep it all the time about the, about the team. If we're going to deliver, to fans at a higher level.
yeah, like I said, just echoing what DiNardo said, it was nice to see this off season. It was one of those things where I was like, man, why couldn't we have done this a couple of years earlier? But, definitely want to, want to thank you for your time. And I said, definitely wanted to appreciate you coming on here, but, shifting focus. Just one more question before we let you go. We talked a lot about the offense. It's getting a lot of, a lot of, it's getting a lot of attention right now because it's improved and it's, just scored 16 runs yesterday.
But I want to talk about the pitching staff because that's something where, you've built that is something that you built from the get go. it's a homegrown staff. It's something where you're the only team in major league baseball, all five starters and pitchers homegrown.
You've been in other organizations. You've won in other organizations. What is it that's, that separates, this one that, the current Pittsburgh pirates, when it comes to just scouting and developing their pitching, because it's something that you've done a great job at.
Well, I'll get back to that question. I think it's, it is important to note. Can you reference the improvement in the offense? It's, look, we've seen, we've seen some good things. it's 16 games. It's 10% of the season, a little less than 10% of the season. It's a small sample. there are some things that have been encouraging. There's some things we need to clean up too.
We haven't played cleanest baseball in there every day. so we need to, I think what I'm most encouraged by is that the people in the clubhouse players and staff and people in uniform are, really staying in that in present in the moment.
Like, never mind what happened yesterday. What do we have to do today? pitch to pitch, whatever cliche you want to use their cliches, but they actually are true. that's what baseball teams need to do. So we just got to stay there. But to your question,
yeah, I really think that skill in identifying pitching, with the pirates certainly predates me. That was one of the things that when I got here, I had heard about that. I think learned pretty quickly that I think particularly with the amateur scouting staff, they had spent a lot of time and developed a real competency in, as a staff, their ability to identify, evaluate, and project pitching, high school pitching, including, which is not an easy thing to do.
and you take the first round out of it. and you take the first round out of it. If you go back and look at high school pitchers, the pirates have drafted after the first round, deeper in the draft, just take the first round out of it. it's gotta be, one of the better, if not the best tracker is just in that demographic over the past, let's say decade, 15 years or so that predates me. what's happened, I think since then is that we've added to that competency,
with some changes in the development model, both people, both people, resources, technology, like using tech and data more freely. really just trying to make it custom to the pitcher. there's no pirates blueprint for what a pitcher needs to look like, it's just up to the pitcher. What is the best version of this pitcher? How do we provide this pitcher with the resources to be their absolute best? And guys change over time. I think if a guy named like Carmen Mlodzinski,
Carmen Mlodzinski is quite a different pitcher today than he was four years ago. obviously we drafted him, relatively high in the draft. We believed in him, but this is a guy who continues to evolve. He evolves partly because of his own skill and work ethic. Hopefully partly because,
we're putting in a position to have the resources, just go explore things, try the next thing, push the next, push through the next door or whatever it is. and if we get, if you combine those two things, the strong scouting. So you like identify the core traits, and then put them in an environment where they can just keep exploring the next thing.
There was no limits. We don't want to put like a ceiling on anybody. good things can happen with that combination over time. So I think, I think it's a little bit of that, but that ability to identify the high school pitcher has been going on for a long time here, certainly longer than I've been here.
Well, Ben, thank you for hopping on here. Hopefully you enjoyed it. Maybe you'll come back. but real quick, have you hoisted any cones yet?
Have you yourself hoisted a cone?
We do have a couple of cones up in the suite and there's a couple of flying around the office. So we will, we will pick them up and down. I do like the cone. I think symbolically the welder's helmet's great. Everybody loves home runs, but, the traffic symbolizes the pitch to pitch grinder mentality that we need. And so I like both of them, but the cone is, taking a special place.
So wild. It is wild. And Saturdays are big tailgate. We're going to have hundreds of people there. We've ordered 120 cones. So we're going to be handing out cones. So look for us, look for us Saturday.
We'll do. All right.
Thanks, Ben. Thanks guys. See ya.
Thanks a lot, Ben, but well, Jim, there it was Ben joined the show. We got a quick 15 from him. pretty punctual and it lasted 15. So he's not, he's not used to NS9 rules like that, I guess.
Yeah. It was actually on time stuck to the time. yeah, it's, he's very, he's very good at, his GM speak. I don't think he gave us too much there. but as I appreciate him hopping on here.
There, the one thing I really wanted to get into was like, why did you do all this year? But like, we couldn't do any of this, in previous years. And it seemed like his go-to there was, I just had more resources this year.
It's what it sounds like. It sounds like they had more payroll. They had more flexibility. They dealt, he didn't say it by name, but dealing David Bednar dealing to Ke'Bryan Hayes last year, the deadline just freed up more opportunity for them to do stuff. So that's, that was the answer.
Sure. And also payrolls over a hundred million dollars for the first time that he's had. So I guess that was it. So it sounds like he didn't have the opportunity to spend that much money before.
That was what I got from that. Same. But what that said, it's water on the bridge, all this stuff that in the past that we want to talk about is in the past right now.
The Pirates are, and again, this is Tuesday as we're talking, but they are in first place. They just smashed the nationals 16 to five. the offense looks good. The pitching looks good. there's not a whole lot of complaint about right now in Pirates world. So, Hey, let's move forward. Let's wish for the best. There's nothing more that we want than the Pirates being the playoffs, and here we are. So, yeah. So again, just really want to thank Ben for coming on and maybe some more in the future, huh?
Yeah. Hopefully have them on again. Yeah. yeah. And you mentioned the hot start. like I said, it's Tuesday, but as of right now, the Pirates are 10 and six and FanDuel has them at plus 102 to make the post season. So basically even money right now to make the post season. And, my guess is that hasn't been the case for a Pirates team in a really long time, probably since 20, probably since 2016.
Certainly not any time when our guest was on. Yeah. Early 2016 maybe. And then before then. Yeah. Maybe 18, maybe 18. I bet they weren't at some point.
Even money. But even with that being said, we're talking about 2018 and that's like the most opportunistic view of this point.
Like eight years ago. Right. It's been a while. Right.
But like Ben said, it's still early. There's still a lot of baseball to be played. they've got to overcome a lot of obstacles here. They think they're going to need, I think they're going to need some help when it comes to their arms just to get through this season. But yeah, so far so good.
That's it. So I guess we'll see you guys Saturday. Right now I'm on a plane. I'm on a plane right now. If you're watching this.
Yeah. I'm driving. I'm probably somewhere in Ohio somewhere driving. but no, I'm excited for this weekend. we'll be there Friday night at the game. the two of us, Dougie fresh will be there as well.
And then Saturday, the whole crew minus Cody will be at the game. Everybody will be there except for Cody. and yeah, come out to the tailgate noon, 12 o'clock per man. He's confirmed everything. We got everything coming at 12. we've got roughly 200 sandwiches or show or so are going to be showing up to that tailgate. So get there. first come first serve. If the sandwiches are out by the time you get there, that's on you. That's your fault. We got 200 of them.
Right. And those are full sandwiches. They're half sandwiches. Oh, they have. Okay. Yeah. Yeah. So yeah, there's a lot of food. So definitely come out there. And, yeah, Friday night, Zambelli's fireworks night. I'm excited about that. Good to see them Zambelli's. So let's do this. We'll see you guys later. We love you all like subscribe, follow along, enjoy this journey this year. Bye. Bye. See you guys.
All right. That wraps up this episode of North shore nine. Thanks so much for tuning in. Whether you're listening on the podcast or catching us on YouTube, if you enjoyed the show, please give this video a thumbs up and don't forget to hit that subscribe button. If you haven't already, it really helps us grow. And if you're listening on the podcast, a quick review goes a long way in helping others find the show. Plus be sure to tell a friend about us. There's always room for more.
More here in the NS9 community. And for those looking to support us a little more, consider joining our Patrion, become an MVP member and get exclusive perks while helping us continue to bring you more of the pirates content. You love. Thanks again for all your support and Let's Go Bucs.
We'll see you next time.


Comments· 0
Do the 10-6 Pirates need to trade for more pitching to keep their hot start going?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.