◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)◆NEWSPirates, Chas McCormick Agree To Minor League Deal
◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)◆NEWSPirates, Chas McCormick Agree To Minor League Deal
NS9LIVE! opened with a fun conversation about the World Baseball Classic before shifting into the main topic: predicting the Pirates’ 2026 Opening Day roster. The crew broke down each position group, debating key battles like Henry Davis vs. Joey Bart behind the plate, Nick Yorke’s chances, Tyler Callihan’s fit, and the biggest question of all — whether Konnor Griffin has done enough to force his way onto the roster. They also worked through the pitching staff, discussing the fifth starter battle, bullpen construction, and which players could be left off the 40-man roster. Alex Stumpf also joined to preview the debut of his new daily NS9 podcast, Offbeat.
Watch or listen now and get ready for Opening Day.
Comments· 0
The Debate
Should Konnor Griffin be the Pirates' Opening Day shortstop at age 19?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.
With Anthony DiNardo, Jim Rosati, Alex Stumpf and Tyler Sweeney.
Chapters
Key takeaways
1
Joey Bart makes the team and ends up getting more starts than Henry Davis by mid-season, because Davis has hit terribly all spring and ABS may close the defensive gap.
2
If the Pirates want to win this year, Konnor Griffin has to be the everyday shortstop. He has faced the toughest pitching of any Pirate this spring, he leads the team in homers and he looks like he belongs.
3
Jhostynxon Garcia shouldn't make the team as a fifth outfielder. Sitting behind Cruz, Reynolds, O'Hearn and Mangum would make him last year's Canario, so he's better off playing every day in AAA.
4
It would be shocking if Hunter Barco were the fifth starter. With about 130 innings at most, he would have to be sent down or shut down early, and his spring command hasn't earned the job.
5
Don't lock Carmen Mlodzinski into an opener role. He's too valuable in middle relief getting the ball to Santana, Soto and Mattson.
Yo, welcome to NS9 Live, presented by FanDuel, I'm your host, Anthony DiNardo, with me, we have Jim, we have Tyler, and we have the Alex.
Stump, what's up, Alex?
Hey, what's up, guys?
Not much.
Good.
There we go.
I guess that's a better response.
Yeah, there we go.
Great start.
Podcasting, that's for here.
It's nice to have somebody that knows what they're talking about on the show.
Yeah, for once.
So, it's nice to have Jim back.
Thank you.
Thank you.
It's good to be back.
How about this World Baseball Classic?
No.
How about Mark DeRosa coming out and saying that they wanted to win.
It's weird that they want to win this game because their ticket's already been punched.
And then they go and lay a complete egg.
But it looks like they're going to advance.
Italy's up 6-0 right now.
So, unless the game goes into like 15 innings or something, some really weird stuff would have to happen at this point for the USA to not advance.
But, man, what a failure that was.
That was awful.
you have to worry about load management.
You have to worry about load management after like three games.
It's a real crisis.
They were one of the few teams that have like an off day, too.
Like, they had two games, an off day, and then two games.
So, like, they didn't even have to.
Yeah.
I don't know.
It was.
Hopefully, they get their act together in the playoff round.
It's just such a pirate-y thing.
It's all.
just unbelievable.
Is Francisco Cervelli going to get a managerial job next year?
Just for simply knowing the rules?
Just for winning a couple games and knowing the rules?
I don't think so.
Hey, he's doing a heck of a job, though.
The Angels are always out there.
America's team.
America's team.
Yeah.
All right.
Well, at least they got the advance.
So, all things remain okay, I guess, to some level.
But, yeah, they had to win.
They needed to win, Mark.
Way to go.
But enough of that.
Let's talk about the Pirates, who are actually maybe good this year.
Yeah.
No, we're going to get into.
So, our show tonight is mostly going to be around predicting the opening.
Day roster.
I feel like we haven't really spent a whole lot of time just, like, talk.
We've spent some time talking about, like, specific position battles.
But, like, let's take a step back.
Look at the whole 26-man roster as a whole.
And let's throw out some predictions.
We've got two more weeks, essentially, before the team heads north.
So, two more weeks of games.
So, that's going to be the bulk of this show.
But also, we wanted to have Alex on at the very beginning here.
Because, if you haven't heard, Alex is doing a daily podcast on North Shore Nine.
It's going to be called Offbeat.
And the first episode, it's going to air every day, 15 minutes, Monday through Friday.
And it's going to be Alex's show.
He's going to be talking whatever he wants to talk about.
And the first show is going to be tomorrow.
So, I'm excited for that.
So, Alex, I'm pretty pumped.
What can everybody expect from Offbeat?
Well, I'm pretty pumped about it, too.
The way I am approaching this is I want to be able to touch on what's going on with the ball club, what I'm hearing, what I'm seeing from inside the clubhouse.
I want to be able to have a different type of platform.
I haven't really had the last couple years to present this info.
So, like, tomorrow's episode, the premiere episode, I'm talking about Konnor Griffin.
And it's not just, does he make the opening day team?
But it's what I've heard, in regards to, like, a contract.
If something like that is possible.
What is his status for making the opening day team?
Does he have to have a contract to make the team?
So, there's a lot of information that I have there.
I'm like, well, this is just a perfect outlet for that.
So, it's not always going to be something like that.
Sometimes it's going to be, a little more analytical.
Sometimes it's going to be a little more calming.
Sometimes it's going to be, bringing on a guest and having an interview.
But, like, yeah, I'm looking forward to this.
Like you said, these are going to be 15-minute bites.
Hopefully, it could just be part of your morning routine or whenever you decide to consume podcasts.
Now, that's just incredible.
Because I've been anticipating this debut.
I've been excited for this debut.
But to drop the Konnor Griffin extension news live from that show tomorrow, you outdid yourself.
Well, recorded, pre-recorded, but dropping the Konnor Griffin extension news on the show tomorrow.
You outdid yourself, buddy.
Oh, wow.
Okay.
Well, it better get a lot of downloads if we're going to go that route.
I'm just doing what I'm hearing.
Basically, you're going to tell us that the extension's done.
We're just waiting until we debuts.
Yeah, pretty much.
Yeah, sure.
Okay, perfect.
We'll go with that.
Whatever gets the buzz.
So stay tuned tomorrow to Yellow Journalism, the podcast.
I think what I'm just most excited about is we do the post-game shows daily.
And so that's just going to be an immediate emotional reaction to what we just saw.
And so we're going to have that.
So all of our viewers, listeners, you're going to first get the immediate emotional reaction to what we just watched.
And then in the morning, they'll have your 15-minute blitz there to really talk about really, like I said, whatever it is that you're seeing there.
And the fact that, we're watching the game as fans, you're there as a, as the media, you're in the media room, you're in the clubhouse, like you're talking to the players, you're talking to the coaches.
So I just like the different dynamic that it's going to bring to the podcast.
So, yeah, I'm super excited to just throw this into the mix of what we've got going on here.
And I think the viewers and the listeners out there are going to like it a lot.
So, yeah, I'm pretty pumped.
Same here.
And I like the fact that it's going to be a daily, like anytime I've ever done a podcast, it's been like a weekly show.
Like Noah and I, back in the day, we would record like hour-long podcasts, once a week.
And it's like, well, this is something that's a little different than that.
Like, let's see how that approach goes.
So I'm looking forward to it.
Short, concise, or to the point, easily digestible.
So, yeah, a 15-minute show.
Like, everyone can watch or listen to a 15-minute show every day.
You would think.
You would think.
You would hope.
Let's hope.
We'll find out.
Let's hope.
Yeah, we'll find out.
No, but it's going to be awesome.
I'm looking forward to it.
And, yeah, first episode tomorrow.
We're going to try to drop these, like, early morning so that, whenever you wake up, they are there, ready for you.
Yeah, and we know you're a night owl, so that makes some sense.
That's just the baseball schedule.
Yeah.
I can't wait to listen to something really stupid on a postgame, and then Alex is going to debunk it in the morning, and I'm going to feel like an idiot.
Mm-hmm.
Yeah.
Well, but that's going to be, like, the good thing about it, right?
Because, like, we're going to be watching something, and we're going to be either, like, really mad about something or, like, why in the hell did this happen?
And then, like, in the morning, Alex is maybe going to be able to tell us why something did happen.
So, no, I think it's going to be a pretty cool dynamic.
I agree.
But speaking of feeling stupid, let's get into our next, or our first segment here.
I want to ask you a bunch of questions, and I want to have them answered immediately.
So, I think this is Alex's first time being on the show while doing this, right?
Or, no, you were on before?
I was on whenever you texted Antwone Kelly, I think it was.
Oh, so you're on for the debut.
Yeah.
Okay.
All right.
Well, cool.
So, we'll run it back.
You brought us good luck.
So, let's go ahead and do this one more time.
Jim, why don't you go ahead and give...
While you're bringing up the wheel there and spinning.
Today's question, today's stupid random question is, if animals had jobs, which one would be the most annoying co-worker and why?
That's our stupid question for today.
So, give it a spin.
Let's spin this.
Let's find out.
Who are we going to ask today?
Oh, dear Lord.
Oh, dear Lord.
Oh, dear Lord.
Do we have enough time to read this answer?
From FanGraphs, Dan Zimborski, the mastermind of Zips.
Awesome.
Do you want to go ahead and shoot that over to him, DiNardo?
I'm sending it right now.
Okay.
Alex, I was waiting for DiNardo to take this off the screen here.
But, there we go.
Boom.
You don't have to hang on the whole show.
You've got a show to record.
So, we'll see you in the morning.
See you guys in the morning.
Looking forward to it.
All right, Alex.
Have a good one.
Thanks for hopping on.
Bye, buddy.
This episode is brought to you by IQ Bar, our exclusive snack hydration and sponsor.
IQ Bar protein bars, IQ Mix hydration mixes, and IQ Joe mushroom coffees are the delicious, low-sugar, brain and body fuel you need to win your day.
The Ultimate Sampler Pack is a great way for you to try all IQ Bar products and flavors.
You get nine IQ Bar, eight IQ Mix Sticks, and four IQ Joe sticks.
All IQ Bar products are clean label certified and entirely free from gluten, dairy, soy, GMOs, and artificial ingredients.
With over 20,000 five-star reviews and counting, more people than ever are fueling their lifestyles with IQ Bar, IQ Bar.
With IQ Bar's brain and body boosting bars, hydration mixes, and mushroom coffees, the Ultimate Sampler Pack includes all three.
My personal favorites so far have been the almond butter chip and the iced tea lemonade hydration mix.
It's just really full of flavor.
I love starting my day with it, and I couldn't imagine starting my day with anything else other than IQ Bar products.
Right now, IQ Bar is offering our podcast listeners 20% off all IQ Bar products, including the Ultimate Sampler Pack, plus free shipping.
To get your 20% off, text MLB to 64000.
That's MLB 64000.
Message and data rates may apply.
See terms for details.
All right, so Dan Zamborski is the recipient of our stupid question.
But no, I'm super excited for Offbeat.
I just think the dynamic of it is going to be really cool for what we're doing.
Yeah, I fully agree.
I'm also very excited about this.
Oh, for sure.
Which wasn't hard to do.
And also, just put this out there, because based on those YouTube comments on, like when I had Alex on to talk about this, no one's leaving.
Like, Alex didn't replace anybody.
Doug's still here.
Sorry, Paul.
Neil's still here.
Also, sorry, Paul.
Alex is on the show.
But yeah.
Everyone's still here.
We're just adding Alex.
We didn't have to replace anybody.
So, there's that.
All right.
So, we want to dive into this topic?
Yeah.
You're going to do your thing, aren't you?
No, I didn't create a PowerPoint or anything for this.
Oh.
I didn't.
But I think the best way to do this is essentially to go through just each position group.
We'll do catchers, infielders, outfielders.
We'll do starting pitchers, we'll do relief pitchers, and really just see.
I'm curious on if we have similar thoughts, if it's all going to be the same.
I think we're going to have a little bit of differences here in terms of some of these final positions.
But yeah, let's get going.
So, we're going to predict the 2026 Pirates opening day lineup.
Not lineup, but roster.
And just with the information that we have right now, the players that we have right now.
Yeah.
Let's kick this off.
So, it's 13 pitchers, 13 position players.
Just to be clear, we're doing this based on what we predict, not what we want.
This is a prediction, correct?
Prediction.
Not necessarily what we would do, but it's going to be a prediction.
Yes.
Yes.
So, this is what I think is going to happen.
To answer John's question.
Yep.
All right.
Catchers.
Catcher group.
Does anybody have more than two?
Does anybody have the team carrying three catchers?
No.
No.
No?
All right.
Does everybody have the team carrying Henry Davis?
I think he's going to remain on the team for these next two weeks, and Joey Bart is going to be the second catcher.
I agree.
Joey Bart will be on this team, but the only place I disagree is that I think he does end up getting more starts than Henry Davis by probably mid-season.
Is that a hot take?
it's not hot.
It's just lukewarm.
Let me, because I'm curious.
Why is that the case?
Guys, Henry Davis has been terrible at the plate the entire spring.
Count him.
Every other spring, Henry Davis has been good at the plate, and he's been bad in the regular season.
So, he's just, he just does the opposite.
He's saving all of his hits.
Counterpoint.
And Tyler.
He's going to be even worse than in the regular season than he ever has.
No, I just.
I ask this because you're the one who really brought up the point about, is the automatic ABS going to take away value from him?
Yeah, that's, I think that's something we're just going to have to, that's just something we're going to have to monitor.
I don't, it's hard to tell right now, because I think we've seen it work both ways as well.
I think I've also seen Joey Barton not challenge some pitches that I thought he should have.
So, it could probably work both ways.
It's going to come down to, I don't know if Henry Davis is going to hit.
And if he can't hit, and Joey Bart can just be closer to league average, with ABS, maybe Joey Bart's not atrocious.
Behind the plate.
Maybe.
I don't love the situation in general.
Yeah, I think it's going to be really similar to last year, where, I guess technically Bart had more playing time, but it wasn't by a lot.
Like, I think the two of them split time fairly evenly.
Yeah.
I think you could see three to two, or it'll be pretty similar.
But I think Joey Bart ends up getting more.
I do think that's interesting.
last year, it was very decisive on who had the better catcher ERA, who handled the staff better, right?
In that sense.
But I think this is a good talk.
it's going to be a wait and see type of situation.
But it's going to be interesting of, how much more value does Joey Bart get because of ABS and how much value does Henry Davis lose because of ABS?
And does that maybe normalize a little bit?
So, yeah, I don't think that's a hot take necessarily, but I want to hear you work it through and talk about it because I'm sure that's going to be something we'll be talking about throughout the year this year.
For sure.
So, I don't think there's much question about catcher.
Indy's having a good spring, just to bring that up, but I think it's clear Indy's on the outside looking in.
Yeah, I think Indy only makes this team if Bart gets traded or if there's an injury of some sort.
And even then, I don't know if Indy's the third catcher.
Flores may even be the third catcher at this point just because Indy hasn't played in so long.
Like, do you really want to put him in the majors right now after, barely getting any at-bats the last two seasons?
So, I think Indy's squarely on the outside looking in.
Flores, I think, still has a shot if something were to happen.
But, yeah, right now, both those two, I don't think, are making the team.
I agree.
Yeah.
I guess, like, the caveat to that, too, is would you rather have Indy in the majors and have Flores still developing in the minors opposed to being, like, a backup?
That could come into play also.
So, hopefully, right now, at this point, Bart just doesn't get traded because I think I'd rather have Bart starting the season than what he would potentially bring in to help this club otherwise.
So, I guess there's that.
Yeah.
No, I'm with you.
Okay.
Infield group.
Infield group.
This is where I think things are going to get a little interesting.
And I think the versatility there, like, the fact that he can play some infield, he can play some outfield.
He's a lefty bat, which, like, right now, they've got Mangum on the bench.
But, in my scenario here, you've got Gonzalez on the bench.
You've got Mangum on.
We haven't gotten to the outfield yet, but Mangum's going to be on my bench.
So, like, having that lefty bat there to go along with Nick Gonzales, who can also play a little bit of infield and a little bit of outfield, I'm bringing Tyler Callihan north with this team.
Is Cruz, Brandon Lowe, Reynolds, O'Hearn, Ozuna, Horwitz, Griffin, Triolo, Bart, Davis, York, Callihan, Mangum.
Yeah.
I have Cruz, Brandon Lowe, Reynolds, O'Hearn, Ozuna, Horwitz, Gonzalez, Triolo, Bart, Davis, York, Callihan, Mangum.
Okay.
All right.
So, all three of us have Callihan.
That's interesting.
So, yeah.
Actually, no.
Callihan's gone if Griffin comes up.
Yeah.
A couple people asking, like, why Callihan over Garcia?
And I think the answer to that is, like, if you were to say who's better, I think Joe Sinson Garcia is the better player.
But, like, who's better suited for that specific role at this moment in time?
Like, that's why I'm picking Callihan.
Like, Joe Sinson Garcia is 23 years old.
He's got nine major league plate appearances.
This outfield is very jam-packed.
Like, you've got four guys in these outfields to fill these three outfield spots already.
And Cruz, Brandon Lowe, O'Hearn, and Mangum.
Where, like, you're going to want to play these guys a lot.
So, Joe Sinson Garcia, I don't know where he's going to get playing time.
And so, that's where I feel like Callihan just makes a better fit.
Because I'm more comfortable giving Callihan three plate appearances a week, right?
Whereas, like, this spot, that spot, that, like, fifth outfield spot, that guy's not going to play hardly at all.
And so, like, what do you want Joe Sinson Garcia to do?
Do you want him to start six games a week in AAA?
Or do you want him to play once a week in Pittsburgh?
And I think it's more valuable for him to get that everyday playing time in AAA.
And then, if something happens to one of those four guys, which, let's face it's an older outfield.
People are going to get injured this year.
It's just how it's going to, like, that's how it works.
It's baseball.
I think last year, the Pirates used 11 different outfielders, right?
So, like, someone's going to get hurt at some point.
And then, if someone gets hurt, then, like, Garcia's the first guy up.
Because there's then going to be a little bit more playing time with him.
So, yeah.
Garcia, I just don't see room for him on this roster as is.
But he's going to play a part in this team at some point this year.
It's just, I don't want him rotting on the bench.
Because that's what he's going to do.
Like, if Garcia's on this, like, that 26th man, that fifth outfielder, they're going to rot on the bench because you can't sit O'Hearn and Reynolds and Cruz and Mangum.
You can't sit two of those guys.
You can sit one of them, but, like, you can't sit two of those guys.
you're going to be last year's Canario.
Like, that's not going to be good for his development.
we joke how many times you hear that.
Like, you forgot Canario was even on the team until he slid into the lineup, the one day every two weeks or something.
How's that going to be good for him?
like, we talk about the Conor thing.
So what's good, best for the team and the player?
Well, it might be theoretically best for the team that Garcia is there.
But how much more is it really make the team better if it's Garcia playing once every four or five days opposed to Callihan?
When Garcia could be in AAA actually developing and maybe turn into a force that you're going to need for the future as well.
So, yeah, this is, like, I know a lot of people always argue, you just simply bring your best 26 up.
And there are actually real-life scenarios where you can't really do that.
And one of them is because you have a prospect who is better suited to play every single day to make sure you get the best version of him for his entire career or at least his entire tenure with the Pirates opposed to having him play and have 200 plate appearances in the
majors this year.
That's not why you made that trade.
That's not why you traded Oviedo.
So you can not develop a guy so we can have 200 plate appearances this year.
It comes on the upside.
Garcia has upside.
Nick Yorke's not much older than him, but Nick Yorke doesn't have the upside that Garcia does.
I'm not necessarily ready to, like, give up on Nick Yorke, but I will agree with you, like, that Garcia has more upside than Nick Yorke.
Like, I think Nick Yorke, like, Nick Yorke, if all goes well, he's probably a utility guy.
Like, that's probably who he is.
I think he's going to be a good one.
Yeah.
I think he's going to be a good one.
But, like, but Garcia's ceiling is much higher.
And so, yeah, like, I'm not, I'm not stowing Garcia on my bench to get to pick up a pinch hit here or there when, like, he needs to be getting every day at bats.
okay.
So there's our 13 position players.
So we want to move on to the pitching staff.
Yes.
I think this one's going to be a little bit easier.
he can, but, teams he plays for just, don't win things.
No.
Yeah.
those four are on my team.
Okay.
Definitely.
Who's your fifth starter?
Oh, no.
Say his name.
Let's see if you learn how to pronounce it, DiNardo.
Well, it's, or KD, but I don't, I don't know.
I, you know what?
The thing is, I feel like he's going to make the team.
I don't know if it's theoretically, technically is that as the fifth starter, if that makes sense.
Yeah.
I think he's your fifth starter.
Okay.
So who's your fifth starter?
It could be, it could be him.
I think he's making the team.
We're projecting.
What are we doing?
I know.
I know this is, this is so tough because honestly, like, I'm feeling Clevenger.
I'm feeling Clevenger and I don't know which one I want and which role.
So I was one or I'll get, I'll just throw or KD there or KD is the fifth starter, but I'm not going to, I'm not saying he might not be the, you're a pushover.
But this is also like, I'm trying to put on Ben's hat, like not mine, putting on Ben's hat.
What am I predicting for them to do?
And they're tough.
Yeah.
I think he's the fifth starter.
I don't love it.
I really don't like it, but I think it's the best option they have.
And we'll get into all the other scenarios that they could use them with.
Cause I think a lot of that's going to be discussed in the bullpen part.
But on top of that, as we're discussing here, like Clevenger's showing some swing and miss stuff.
It's the fifth starter.
I'm not saying like Clevenger's back, but he's been interesting to me.
Neither's looked interesting to me, to be honest.
So I asked this question, I asked this question on Twitter.
So just to share, I don't know if the voters took this as who they want as the fifth starter or who they pick as the fifth starter, but Hunter Barco was the overwhelming favorite
here.
57% of the votes going to Barco, 18% to Urquidy, 16% to Mlodzinski and 9% to Clevenger.
So that's what the, that's at least what my followers think.
I would be shocked.
I would be shocked if Hunter Barco is the fifth starter.
Same.
Cause you got, like I said, when you get to the, this like opening day roster, like this isn't, this isn't your final, this isn't your final thing.
Like this isn't what you're going to look like at the end of the year.
This is, what are you going to deploy at the beginning of the season that puts you in the best position to pitch all the innings that you're going to need to cover over the course of the entire year.
And that's where in Barco's case, it's hurting him because Barco has a limited amount of innings.
He's got 130 ish, probably tops.
If Hunter Barco is your opening day, your fifth starter, like you're going to have to either send them down at some point in the middle of the year and just like rest them for a month,
or you're going to have to shut them down early.
And I don't, I wouldn't want to do that.
So I think Barco has, it'd be real tough for Barco to make this team on opening day.
I'm going to say José Urquidy, mostly for the fact that he's on a major league deal.
I don't think he's looked good, but I think Carmen Mlodzinski certainly, I think, I think Maginski is just so valuable in that long relief role that I don't want to take him out of it.
I think if you're looking at the three remaining options, Maginski is like the best one, but then it's like, okay, well, what's best for the team?
Is it best for the team for Maginski to start every five games, or is it best for Maginski to be able to go three innings in the bullpen when you absolutely need somebody to get, seven, eight, nine outs for you?
I don't, I don't, I don't know what the answer to that is.
I have a feeling they're going to, they're going to use him that way though.
So I'm going to say Urquidy gets the, gets the fifth starter.
He starts off the year in the rotation.
I don't think José Urquidy finishes the year in the rotation.
Old prediction.
Yeah.
Has he ever?
Yeah.
Yeah.
Like five years ago.
Okay.
Yeah.
So we're all on the same page though, that Hunter Barco is not on the opening day roster.
I do not have Barco on the roster.
And I know you gave your reasons there, but I'm going to be honest.
It's because to me, it's, he hasn't been good enough.
That gives me any confidence to put them on the opening day roster.
that's fair.
I actually like, I've never been thinking of it in that sense because I've always felt like they want to try.
It just makes perfect sense that he's not going to start an opening day because of limits.
You want to like ramp them up.
And it's not that, again, like it's not like or Keity or Clevenger, like Mlodzinski to some level is just like bombing that you have to like, they're doing well enough that I think Hunter Barco is safe, be tucked away into the minor leagues at this point in time.
But yeah, I guess also like, he's not doing it really anything to win it either.
I'll say this.
Like, I think he's having a Jared Jones performance.
Yeah, like I think Hunter Barco looks the best out of all those.
Like, if you're like, who's the best starting pitcher?
Like, I like Barco a lot and he's not having a terrible spring.
He's throwing, he's walking more people than you'd like to see.
But like to your point, Tyler, he hasn't, he hasn't done that.
Like in order for Hunter Barco to win this job, he was gonna have to go out there and just have like, and like win it.
He was like Colin used the phrase, leave no doubt for Konnor Griffin, right?
Like in order for Hunter Barco to break camp with this team, he needs to leave no doubt that like he's the guy and he hasn't done that.
He's, I thought he's pitched fine.
He's been fine.
His stuff is nasty.
He's striking out a lot of guys, but he's walking a lot of guys too.
but yeah, he hasn't, he hasn't done the necessary things to take that job.
Yeah.
He's working on a lot of stuff as well, but yeah, he just, he needed to be lights out and he wasn't.
Well, there's still two weeks, but I agree with you to a point.
That's what makes this question right now.
So difficult.
Yeah.
There's still two weeks.
All right.
Bull pen, bull pen.
Let's just run through the locks.
I think, Dennis Santana, all three of us, Doug's Dougie's boy.
So, like, there's plenty of other ways to go about that.
But, yeah, he's got a 5% strikeout rate.
That's not, that's just not going to get it done as a right-handed reliever.
So, can I ask you guys, are you piggybacking that fifth starter spot?
Or are you just giving it to either Yurkiti or Clevenger?
I've been talking about this for, I feel like since the offseason began.
I do love the idea of, I don't want to call, like, a true piggyback.
But, having two guys, like, if you use Clevenger in that role, or Yurkiti, and a Mlodzinski in that role where, like, they can be bulk guys at some level.
Like, I just like, I like how the Pirates have been utilizing that role.
And to have two of them, of course, preferably one is a righty, one is a lefty.
But, regardless, to have two of those guys, I think, can add true value.
Especially for a team that has innings worries in their rotation.
So, yeah, I do like it.
I think they're going to get creative with that fifth spot.
I do.
I don't, I, because, you just think of, like, do you trust Yurkiti to go, like, three times through an order?
I don't.
And maybe they, maybe they do this in terms of, like, an opener, or they, like, maybe Carmen goes out there and he pitches two innings, and then Yurkiti comes in, and he pitches four, and then all of a sudden you're in the seven, right?
Like, maybe that's how they go about doing it.
Maybe it is.
Maybe it is, like, a piggyback situation.
But they're going to, I think they get creative with it, either with, like, an opener, a set opener, or, like, a three and three type deal.
So.
Here's what I don't love about that, though.
Like, I know you mentioned Mlodzinski, but I don't want him opening up anything, because if you look at this bullpen, I don't love the middle relief.
Getting the ball to either Madsen or Soto and Dennis Santana is very important.
That middle of the pack here is very risky.
Mlodzinski's a guy, I think, that if you plug him there, like, I trust that guy all day.
Yeah, the point of the opener, though, is.
Yeah, but the point of the opener, like, if you can get two, let's say you get two out of Mlodzinski, or let's say it's two and a third.
And then you get three and two thirds out of Urquidy.
You just got six innings.
You don't need to go to the middle of your bullpen anymore.
You're in the seventh.
You can go Madsen, Soto, Santana.
Boom.
So my argument there is more of not using Mlodzinski in that role.
I think I'd rather have Mlodzinski in the middle relief role, where you can plug and play him a little more and give him an inning, maybe two maximum, but he can go back to back days when you need him to.
I don't want to lock him into something, because I think he's too valuable getting the ball to a Dennis Santana and a Gregory Soto and an Isaac Mattson.
Well, I think you can still do that.
Like, all you're doing is essentially on the fifth start.
Comments· 0
Should Konnor Griffin be the Pirates' Opening Day shortstop at age 19?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.