◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
Carmen Mlodzinski was the story in a fast, clean 2-0 Pirates win over the Nationals, and the NS9 Postgame Show broke down exactly why the opener plan with Mason Montgomery worked so well. Anthony DiNardo and Jim Rosati also dug into a dominant night from the bullpen, Ryan O’Hearn staying hot, and what Mlodzinski’s strong start could mean for this rotation moving forward.
Watch or listen now for the full breakdown and all the postgame reactions.
Comments· 0
The Debate
When Jared Jones returns, should Carmen Mlodzinski stay in the rotation instead of moving to the bullpen?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.
With Anthony DiNardo and Alex Stumpf.
Chapters
Key takeaways
1
The opener 'isn't real baseball' and should be outlawed, but it worked perfectly here. Mason Montgomery got through James Wood and the lefty-heavy top of the order, so Mlodzinski could pitch into the 7th without seeing them a third time.
2
The Pirates' record is probably better with Mlodzinski starting than with him in the bullpen. With José Urquidy as the fifth starter, they might be 0-4 in games where they scored 4, 3, 2 and 2 runs.
3
The Gregory Soto signing has been vindicated. Tyler called it a waste of money, but Soto has struck out 15 in 9⅔ innings and allowed one run. Only Mason Miller and Mason Montgomery have more strikeouts among relievers.
4
Marcell Ozuna looks better at the plate, with five batted balls over 100 mph and clutch hits with runners in scoring position. A tear within the next month wouldn't be surprising.
5
The debate over what to do when Jared Jones returns is premature. No rotation gets through a season with five starters and no injuries, so the Pirates should figure it out when it happens.
Yo, welcome to the NS9 post-game show, this is the power buy from Andy Brothers, this is the NS9 podcast presented by FanDuel, I'm your host Anthony DiNardo, and Jim, we got a Pirates victory today, 2-0 they beat the Nationals, with Carmen Virginski giving six innings of relief.
Yeah, it was a quick game, Pirates won 2-0, get your hashtag raise it's in there, I'll say this, number 42 for both teams pitched an outstanding game.
Got this game over with, super quick.
Stop it.
I had a quote tweet Alex Stumpf for that stupid joke, and now you're next.
Anyways, though, but yes.
It was a good game.
It was really nice to see, it was, it was like you said, quick, it was easy to watch, but the Pirates also won that made it good, but also, I just want to say this, Don Kelly, a lot of scrutiny over last night's game.
Him managing, doing too much per se, the Pirates, losing the game, and then he follows up that with not having Carmen Virginski start, he has Mason Montgomery, Jesus, I'm all over the place.
big slugger in the minor leagues, couldn't make it, but hey, found a, found a new way to make it as a major leaguer.
Found a home as a dominant lefty reliever.
Yeah, so Mason Montgomery starts today, and of course, everyone's wondering, oh, here we go again, just, the stupid opener, what are we doing here?
Jimmy made a short on it, and ultimately, it seemed as if it worked out very nice.
It worked to perfection.
there's no other way to put it.
It was, it worked perfect, and yeah, we can get into the reasonings, but if you, if you watch, I put out a video earlier today.
I'll say this, I hate the opener.
I think it should be outlawed.
It's not real baseball, in my opinion.
I want to go back to the old days, where starters just pitched six, seven, eight innings all the time, like, back in my day.
That is my, that is my probably biggest, like, old man yells at clouds thing, is like, we need starting pitchers to pitch more innings nowadays.
But, you know what, this is a, this is a thing that's allowed.
It's smart in certain circumstances, and it was really smart to do today that Washington Nationals have some pretty good left-handed hitters in their lineup.
You look at James Wood, you look at CJ Abrams, you look at Daylon Brandon Lowe.
So, if you can get on the other side of those guys before putting in Mlodzinski, then, like, it's, it makes sense to do it.
And, on top of that, it also means, and you saw it today, like, Carmen Mlodzinski was able to go deeper into this game because he didn't have to face James Wood a third time.
He didn't have to face Daylon Brandon Lowe a third time.
They didn't get up.
They wouldn't have, he wouldn't have had to pitch to those guys until the eighth inning.
So, he was able to go all the way into the seventh inning because of the way things lined up.
Again, I hate the opener and, like, everything that it stands for, but it has a purpose, and it's served that purpose today, and it worked perfectly.
It just, it worked perfectly today.
So, let me say this.
I don't hate the opener, but I get it.
Now, I don't want the game of baseball going to, like, everyone pitches, like, two innings.
Like, I want a starter, right?
In a sense, though, the design of this is, for this game, like, exactly how it came about.
Carmen Mlodzinski, for one, struggles going through the third time in the lineup.
Now, obviously, when you go to the third time in the lineup, you reach the top of the order.
That part's usually pretty good, right?
So, if you're going to third time, that's an easy way to knock you out.
Like you said, this is a good way of going through the third time in the order, but not facing the heart of it until the second time.
Right?
So, if you want to go deeper in the games, you get the hard part out of the way, and then you're going to third time on the lesser talent, per se, if you get there, if you're lucky enough to get through it, right?
So, like, it is a way of lengthening your start.
That absolutely is.
That's where Carmen struggles.
So, what do you do?
You eliminate the struggle.
You make it easier.
If he were to go six today, and Mason Montgomery were to come in afterwards, that's what happened, except it was reverse.
The difference, though, is if Montgomery didn't start, there's a good chance Mlodzinski only goes five.
Now, you're adding more, to the bullpen, which, again, that bullpen could certainly use the help today.
so, like, I don't hate the opener if it's done right, done well.
I don't need it for everybody.
Like, Paul Skenes does not need an opener, you know?
But, like, Carmen Mlodzinski is a perfect candidate for the opener, and especially because the top of the order was a very heavy lefty.
That's where his struggle comes into.
So, go ahead and get, Montgomery in the best possible situation for him, facing those guys, which he did a fine job of, and now Carmen go Cruz, which is exactly what he did.
Perfect.
Yep.
Yep.
Again, like, the people he faced three times today were the five, six, seven, eight, and nine hitters.
Without an opener, he's facing the one hitter, James Wood, who hit a ball almost out of the ballpark against him, two, three, four.
Like, he's just facing better hitters, if you reverse this.
And, like you said, he maybe gets knocked out of the game an inning earlier.
So, yeah, it worked out perfect.
It couldn't have gone better.
Shout out to, Mason Montgomery did a great job of setting the tone.
He did give up that double in the first inning, and it was like, well, if he gives up a run here, then that's no good.
But he was able to put up a zero in that first inning, get on the other side of James Wood and Dalen Brandon Lowe, and then give way to Mlodzinski.
And Mlodzinski was just outstanding all night long.
It was just a really good game for the pitchers in general.
We talk about how just walks have been just a disaster for this team up to this point.
And, only two walks today by the entire staff, and those were both by Mlodzinski, but you can take those if he's only going to give up two hits over six innings.
So, yeah, great job.
Montgomery, Mlodzinski, Soto, Santana, all of them did really well.
I do want to point out, Mlodzinski's most used pitch today, the splitter.
He threw it 42% of the time, and he really just, like, spammed lefties with that pitch.
He threw that pitch 30 times to left-handed hitters today, only four times to righties.
But he got four swings and misses on it, nine swings and misses total on the game.
The velocity carried all the way into the end of the game.
He actually finished the seventh inning.
His last inning was the highest velocity he had all game on his fastball.
So, like, he got stronger as the game went on.
It was a really good performance by him, by everybody.
But, for a number five starter, this ain't number five starter quality, innings he's putting up there.
And, you said, like, they're 4-0 in these games.
So, in the same mindset, if Carmen Mlodzinski isn't the fifth starter right now, they're probably not 4-0 either.
You know what?
Like, the record, honestly, he's probably done them better as the starter.
Like, the record, even with the bullpen mishaps and situation, the record's probably better with him as the starter right now than if he were to be the reliever.
And, maybe it's José Urquidy's number five starter.
Because, like, if he is, you show those runs supports, the run support.
You show those runs they score, Doran Mlodzinski starts.
If Urquidy's the fifth starter, are they maybe 0-4 in those games?
You know what?
So, like, again, like, that's the dilemma.
I know a lot of people sigh that he's best suited as this bulk innings reliever, and I tend to side with that.
But, I'm starting to lose sight of that as we continue to see him start and say, you know what?
This isn't any more just fine.
This is actually good.
This is good.
This is, dude, this team has five studs right now as far as their starters.
It's not just four and give me a fifth.
Like, there's five studs.
They're good.
Like, plain and simple.
These guys are good.
This is a really good pitching staff.
It's a really good starting rotation.
And, like I said, we gave Don Kelly a lot of second-guessing last night.
I wasn't on the postgame.
You weren't on the postgame.
But, I think, there was some questioning of his decisions last night.
Tonight, he did.
He did everything perfect when it came to handling the pitching staff.
Not a complaint in the world.
And, again, with Mason Montgomery starting, Karmicinski taking over.
And someone put in the chat here, too.
Like, I hate the whole, now this, like, becomes, like, part of stats stuff.
Like, oh, he's the first reliever since it's like, that's the part I hate about the opener.
He's still the starter.
He's still, like, he's still the starter.
Don't put him in bullpen stats now because of this.
That I hate.
But, he came in.
Like, it was just perfectly executed.
This shows exactly why the starter became a thing.
Shout out to Tampa Rays for mainly really hammering this.
So, this has been done in the past before.
But they made it a new thing once again.
The Pirates have utilized it.
And, like I said, this was a perfect scenario.
It was executed perfectly.
And, on the same side, like, the offense did enough.
This wasn't a high-powered offense.
this wasn't the one where they came out and just obliterated the other team.
They did enough.
And then the real bullpen came on and held it down.
it was just a 2-0 ballgame.
2-0 very early.
Washington Nationals could have came back at any point in time and tied this game or, took the lead or whatever.
And they stepped on their throats.
They made sure it didn't happen.
Again, Greg Rissetto comes in.
Dennis Santana comes in.
All do their part even afterwards.
This is a really good game.
Yeah.
this was like a 2025 Pirates win,.
they scratched across a couple runs early in the game.
And then they put up seven straight zeros.
Like, the offense only had five hits today.
Like, this game was won on the backs of the pitching.
And we've said it all offseason where, if they could just get a little bit more offense, they're going to win more baseball games.
But their pitching is good enough just to win some games by itself.
And that's really what today was.
There wasn't really anything going on offensively today.
Shout out to Lisa, by the way, for the four nine super.
Not only did the Bucks win tonight, I am following my last tax return as I write this.
Woo.
I know she's excited.
Yeah, that is.
That is big.
That is big.
yeah, going back to it, the, I just can't say enough about this pitching staff.
I want to talk about Gregory Soto too.
I think there were some Tyler had differing opinions from me on Gregory Soto.
I was, I was a huge fan of the Gregory Soto acquisition.
Tyler said it was a waste of money so far.
Seems like I'm correct on that one.
And so I just want to make sure everybody remembers that.
but another, he's been, he's been money.
he's now nine and two thirds innings.
He struck out 15 batters.
He's only given up one run on the year, been just outstanding against lefties.
He's been a really good setup, man.
And somebody who they've used in the ninth inning a couple of times as well.
That's why you and I did like the signing, when it broke in the winter meetings and we talked about it, we had Alex come on as well, for a little bit, like we did like it.
And one of the reasons you like it as well is because he does have some closer experience.
he's at the tigers.
He was an all-star, like you trust him enough that he can be used in a plethora of ways.
And that is what's nice.
when Dennis Santana can't come in and close it out, there's still him there.
And you trust that.
So, he has done a fantastic job so far, again, like he's shown some arachnist, he has some walks early on.
He's not perfect and that's fine.
That's perfectly fine.
But over a course of a season, I, he's going to help this team out way more than he's going to hurt this team.
So yeah, at this point in time, the 0.93 ERA, he's been a reason why this bullpen has been as good as they have.
And then the next guy, Dennis Santana, just, gosh.
Talk about not being able to say enough, good things about someone.
Dennis Santana just continues to win over Doug's heart.
Like he's just so good comes into just shut down.
He's just so good.
He's just so good.
He's just so good.
He's so good.
He's so good.
he's so good.
Rear ERA, the Pirates that keeps lowering and lowering and lowering.
It's just baffling like how good he is because you're putting him in the names of the Melanson's and the, just going down the list of relievers that this team has had, that's been, shut down over these past few decades.
He's up there with them.
Yeah.
he just throws strikes, right?
Like that's, he throws strikes.
He locates well, he's got a pretty decent slider that he can throw where he wants to throw it and he just induces weak contact.
his strikeouts aren't any, he's six strikeouts in nine innings.
It's not like that's anything crazy.
He just, people can't hit him.
And a lot of pitchers with really good stuff, I think could learn a lot from Dennis Santana where it's like, Hey, if you can just like, you don't have to be perfect.
They don't have to be perfect pitches.
If you got good stuff, throw it in the zone.
And I said, Dennis Santana stuff isn't even that nasty.
It's like his stuff plus is pretty pedestrian, especially for a lever.
It's 93.
His slider is his best pitch, but like the other stuff really isn't anything special.
It doesn't grade out special in any way, but he locates it.
He throws strikes, makes people put it in play and they can't hit it.
For sure.
Absolutely.
And again, nine innings he has on the year, two hits.
Two hits.
Two hits.
He's not the overpowering guy.
He's not, a raw dish Chapman who's coming here, tossing a hundred miles an hour and such.
he's, that's why I find it is just funny because like, he's the one that gets looked over and over again because he's not out there over empowering guys, but he just gets the job done and he's done it for a long period of time.
So having him and Soto in that back part of this, bullpen, it's shown, it's been pretty damn good.
Yeah.
One quick note on Soto.
There's only three relief pitchers in baseball with more strikeouts than Gregory Soto right now.
But yeah, again, that's the thing about Mason Montgomery, when they add a trade, you knew he has nasty stuff, get the strikeouts.
It's the walks with, how's he going to handle the walks?
And that's been an experience.
We've had some very successful appearances and some that are very shaky, but today, as you mentioned, to go back to it, he definitely performed on that first inning.
Yeah.
first inning, if we was going to touch on that, cause that's where the only offense happened, it didn't start out great.
So it was a really rough start to the game for the pirates offense.
but then Bryan Reynolds worked a walk, his first of three on the day.
Ryan O'Hearn with his first of three hits, our solo Zune is getting going a little bit.
He got, he got another hit there, singles in Bryan Reynolds.
for essentially what ended up being the game winning RBI.
and then Nick Gonzales, beats out an infield single.
So, a good little two out flurry there for the pirates after starting off.
Not that great in the first, you would have loved to have seen them add some more throughout the game, but, the fact that they were able to get two runs in after strikeout was nice.
Yeah, I absolutely agree.
That's something the 2025 pirates wouldn't be able to do, but right off the bat, two strikeouts and it's like, oh, here we go.
But they're able to string some things together.
And once again, of course, who's the big part of that, it is Ryan O'Hearn.
we talk about him, I feel nine in nine out.
Like that's just the Mr. Consistent, he's involved in everything good, barely anything that's bad on this team.
And yeah, he comes through today with three hits, his batting average back up to three 33 on the year.
Awesome.
Awesome.
overall the offense seven K's on the day, it wasn't like they were striking out a ton to, they were making some contact crews.
Looked iffy, but he had two strikeouts today, no hits.
But, what I do want to say too, is to go back with Ozuna, like, yes, you know that he hasn't turned it on yet.
it's not like, oh, okay.
Ozuna is he's broke out.
He's the guy that you wanted to see sign for the DH role, but there are signs, there are signs.
He is looking a lot better right now.
he's not striking out a ton or anything.
Not that he really was before either, but he is making a little bit better contact.
I think like, let's go back to last night when Tyler was talking about, like I wouldn't be surprised at a month from now, we're talking about Konnor Griffin going on a tear again, not saying that Marcelo's is going on a tear, but I could almost say the same with that.
Like if in the next month he is on a tear at this point in time, I wouldn't be surprised in that sense.
He does look better at the plate, making a little more contact, harder contact.
So there is that.
And then again, like if he does get going, that's just a whole nother aspect of this offense that, just get becomes more complete.
Well, the other thing too, what's been nice about his, he's still, I don't know if he's heating up.
He had one hit today.
He had two hits yesterday.
He had one hit the day before.
So he's on a three game hitting streak.
We'll give him that.
what's been nice.
That's doubled his season output.
Right.
What's been nice though, is that the hits are coming in good spots.
like yesterday, RBI, he was one for one with runners in scoring position today.
He was one for two with runners in scoring position.
So if you are going to hit one 18, make those, make those hits count.
Cause before he was, he was really costing this team some opportunities to score some runs the first two weeks of the year.
So it's been refreshing to see him come up in spots where he needed to get something done.
And he got it done.
These last two games.
Correct.
We're still playing right now.
If Marcelo Zunda doesn't get a hit.
Oh yeah.
Yeah.
Right.
Oh, I just wanted to see something real quick here because again, like correct.
However, in like the past, Oh shoot.
Now I missed it.
I think it was five games.
He has five hits over a hundred miles an hour, five events.
I've batted balls, five events.
Right.
So again, like it's, he is looking better at the plate.
He has been hitting the ball a little bit harder to make him more contact on striking as much.
So again, that's all Matt.
I'm not, that's all I'm saying.
He has looked better recently.
He's looked better.
He's looked better.
I agree.
Which again, he needs to, and this offense surely could use it, because again, you add him, get back to, again, if he at least provides last year's stats, was the down year for him.
But we talk about even that guy this year adds onto this offense in a tremendous way that, it's an element that they didn't have.
So again, it, if he can get going, we already see what the pitching is doing, that offense to add that bat into it as well with what they're already producing with, like this team becomes a little bit more complete.
So I just want to give a little bit of shout out to Marcell Ozuna right now.
If he's heating up, he's looking like, yeah.
And not even just complete, but like, let's be real.
Oneil Cruz and Brandon Lowe aren't going to be, like, I think that we're going to see good seasons out of those guys, but like, they're not going to have like, 1100 OPSs.
I think we can probably say that.
So like those two are going to cool down a little bit.
And we've seen how streaky Brandon Lowe has been already this year, just in, three weeks.
But when those guys aren't being otherworldly, you need other guys to hit.
And so like Ryan O'Hearn's been that steady hand all season long.
Bryan Reynolds has been pretty steady for the most part all season, except like the very beginning.
And so it would be really nice if those two were to start cooling off a little bit, which is bound to happen.
it's bound to happen.
Brandon Lowe is not going to hit three homers every two games.
Having Ozuna heat up and make up for that would be really nice.
Yeah, absolutely.
So again, outside of that, very solid game.
Got to give more shouts to Carmen Mlodzinski and, that's a whole other conversation, but he's making this whole decision of when Jared Jones comes back.
interesting.
Like what does happen?
I think a lot of just assumed Carmen goes to the bullpen at this point in time.
There's talks, there's debates of what's going to be best for this team.
Carmen, just going back to the bullpen doesn't just seem like a, just a sure thing.
Can I just say something?
I don't like these talks at all.
I don't think we should just be assuming that the pirate, the 2026 pirates are going to be like the first ever starting rotation to just never have injuries either.
Like stuff's going to happen between now and then like, let's not act like this, the pirates aren't going to be the first team ever to have five people only start games.
Like there's going to be things that come up, you're going to need arms, this conversation about like, what do you do when Jared Jones comes back?
You know what?
We'll figure it out when that happens.
Who knows what I'm saying though, Jim, I think it's fair to say though, is I think the assumption though, is like Carmen goes to the bullpen.
Maybe there's a healthy rotation.
Like he goes to the bullpen.
And right now the way he is pitching, he's giving every argument that he stays in a rotation.
I guess I'm just like, I don't care right now what happens when Jared Jones comes back.
Do not.
I'm just trying to give props to Carmen in saying that again, he's pitching his ass off.
He's proving himself that he deserves to be in this rotation.
He's not an afterthought.
He's not just the filler of when guys come back.
I belong here.
So with that said though, if you haven't gotten your hashtag raised, it's in, go ahead and do so.
We're going to give away some sandwiches.
Two winners going to win.
We have four to give away to a piece right now.
There's 167 entries.
So getting those in and Jim, what are we doing tomorrow?
We got a day game.
So we got, we actually got a lot of stuff happening tomorrow.
We've got a offbeat episode of offbeat coming out tomorrow morning with Alex Stumpf.
We've got a day game.
So we'll have a post game show following that, hopefully celebrating a series win.
me, you, we're going to be traveling and Doug, me, you, Doug, Neil, all going to be traveling in.
So we're not going to have an NS9 live, but we are going to have a WNS9 plus where, you and I sat down with pirates general manager, Ben Cherington.
So that will air tomorrow evening.
and yeah, hopefully, FanDuel's got the pirates at minus one 66 tomorrow.
They're favorites.
If they give me a 50% profit boost, I'm probably going to take that too.
Are you just going to continue to try to speak these into existence?
You know what?
They keep coming through with these profit boosts when I need them.
So yeah, I'm trying to speak that into existence.
I love it.
I love it.
You're going to become, you're going to add plant allegations with us in FanDuel now.
Yeah, seriously.
All right.
Well, let's go ahead and get it.
We got 169 entries.
Let's go ahead and draw our very first winner of the night.
And of course, if you haven't yet, go ahead and like the video.
Make sure you subscribe if you haven't yet.
Get those notifications on when we go live.
Our very first winner.
What a name.
Nivlem Pittsburgh Mopo.
I think it's Pittsburgh Emo something.
Emo Po.
Sure.
But yeah, congratulations.
Email North Shore Nine, all one word, North Shore Nine at gmail.com.
Email us and we'll get those sandwiches out to you.
There it is.
All right.
Let's go ahead and get our second winner.
Got some more entries.
We're now at 171.
So the last winner of the night is Starship Velvet.
Congrats, Starship Velvet.
Congrats, Emo Pittsburgh.
We appreciate you guys.
You guys got to get fed tonight.
So go ahead and make sure, again, if you don't have the Brandy Brothers app downloaded, make sure you download it.
Sign up for them.
Whatever email you have associated with it, let us know in the email.
North Shore Nine at gmail.com.
We'll get those out to you within the next week.
Typically, you'll have those on the app.
So you can get your free sandwiches.
So you can get your free sandwiches.
Jim, Pirates win again.
They're still in first place.
I believe the Reds won again, too.
So that makes them both tied.
So, hey, first place Buccos, though.
How about that?
Tied for first place Buccos with the Reds.
11-7.
The Pirates are apparently the only team who can beat the Reds.
Yeah.
With ease.
No problem.
Just the Reds.
But no, win tomorrow.
Take this four-game series.
That would be a really nice start to this homestand.
If you take tomorrow's game, then a 5-2 homestand is pretty realistic.
Comments· 0
When Jared Jones returns, should Carmen Mlodzinski stay in the rotation instead of moving to the bullpen?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.