◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
This week’s NS9LIVE! dove deep into the growing hype around Konnor Griffin as Pirates spring training heats up in Bradenton. Post-Gazette reporter Colin Beazley joined the show to share firsthand impressions, noting Griffin has stood out daily with elite tools, maturity, and confidence well beyond his 19 years. The crew also debated whether Griffin could realistically force his way onto the Opening Day roster and what he must prove in games to make that leap. Beyond Griffin, discussion touched on the fifth-starter battle—where José Urquidy currently holds the inside track—and the potential impact of Marcell Ozuna’s mentorship on Oneil Cruz. Overall, optimism is rising around a pivotal Pirates season taking shape in camp.
Watch or listen to the full episode now and join the conversation with fellow Pirates fans.
Comments· 0
The Debate
Should the Pirates sign another starter before Opening Day instead of handing José Urquidy the No. 5 spot?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.
With Anthony DiNardo, Jim Rosati and Tyler Sweeney.
Chapters
Key takeaways
1
Colin Beasley says Konnor Griffin will be the Opening Day shortstop. He finds it hard to imagine anyone better suited to play short on March 26, 2026, though he'd understand if the Pirates take the patient route.
2
Urquidy isn't enough at No. 5. The Pirates need one more starter, ideally a lefty like Tyler Anderson, because the rotation is in trouble if anyone goes down after the Oviedo and Burrows trades.
3
The 1–4 starters are good enough to carry a dud at No. 5, and Mlodzinski, Barco and Harrington are fine fill-ins. Still, with payroll already at a record high, they should get creative and push to sign Lucas Giolito.
4
One of Skenes, Keller, Ashcraft and Chandler will probably miss significant time. Ashcraft and Chandler have never handled a full starter's workload, so the Pirates need a cushion.
5
The one real worry about Griffin is how fast he rose. Like Profar and Buxton, he could struggle when he first arrives in the majors, even if he becomes a star later.
Yo, you're listening to the North Shore Nine Podcast, presented by FanDuel. This is NS9 Live. I'm your host, Anthony DiNardo. With me, we have Jim, we have Ty-Ty, we have a special guest tonight, live in Bradenton.
Colin Beasley from the Post-Gazette. How you doing, Colin?
I'm great. Happy to be here with you guys. Happy to talk some buckos.
Is that a, what fish is that behind you?
I don't know.
Are you aware?
I do not know what fish this is, but Jason and I are sharing a house down here, and we're just taking all of our radio hits and podcasts and whatever from this exact spot.
We feel like it's right to have a co-star, right, to have this fish here with us. So you'll know exactly where we are.
I don't, I'll have to get back to you on a name. Like when, I feel like that's something that has to be decided between the sanctity of me, Jason, and our photographer, but we'll get back to you on that.
So before we get into things, this is your first spring training, right?
It is.
What's that been like?
it's what's, I hadn't been to spring training since I was like 12 years old, just going to, going to games in Arizona.
And it's, in time away, you forget that it's just baseball heaven, to be honest, regardless of what side the rope you're on, whether you're there media or working or just there as a fan, it's special.
Obviously the warmer weather is great. being somewhere that's not as cold as Pittsburgh or wherever it's really nice to be somewhere warm, but it's just baseball.
Like you're getting to see that these major leaguers do like some basic infield outfield drills. you get to see them take batting practice.
It's something that's a really special experience and just feels like pure baseball. I'm really enjoying it.
Good stuff. you've written a lot of really good articles and I want to touch on some things that you've written over the last couple of days, while we have you on here at the beginning.
But before we dive into that, do we want to do our stupid random question? Do we want to get that out of the way?
I want to ask you a bunch of questions and I want to have them answered immediately.
Sounds like something. All right. What did I just enter? I don't know, but let's go ahead. Let's bring up the wheel. Colin, you, are you aware of this?
I'm aware of the wheel. Yes. Wouldn't it be awkward if you spin and land on me?
That would be awkward. It would also not be as fun. I think so. Yeah, you might have to, why would I go like, I know. Yeah, there we go.
We've Tyler down there, but I do want to point out before we actually, you know what? I'll point it out at the end of the show. Let's go ahead and spin the wheel.
While it's been, we're going to hope it is.
So we're going to ask a random person, a completely stupid question.
All right.
Sportsnet Pittsburgh, former pirate Alex Presley. Okay. All right. I think I like our odds on this one.
I'll get the question ready.
Okay. So just to let the viewers know, the stupid question today is what's a completely normal thing that instantly makes someone look suspicious?
So that's the question we're going to be asking former pirates outfielder, Alex Presley. Colin, do you want to weigh in on that question?
I was hoping he wouldn't ask me that question. I'm trying to think.
I don't, I don't know. I don't, I'm, I'm drawing a blank on that one. One thing that's tough is about being in, being in Florida is I've ended up on a very different schedule than usual. This feels like the middle of the night to me.
Usually I'm someone who goes to bed at like 1 p.m. 1 a.m. But now all of a sudden it's, it feels like bedtime at 9 p.m.
You got a great, thank you. It's, yeah, I try. I won't get one of those because it's going to be 58 freaking degrees Monday and Tuesday.
No, it's supposed to be sunny. It'll be sunny. It'll be all right. Okay. So while we're waiting on, while we're waiting on Alex to get back to us though, let's dive into, let's dive into spring training.
so first thing I want to talk about, Colin is, you wrote an article on the fifth starter rotation, like the fifth starter, competition going on right now.
and it seems like with what's currently in camp, there's Hunter Barco, there's Jose or Keity, there's Thomas Harrington.
There's Carmen Mlodzinski, Wilber Dotel, Antwone Kelly are there in camp, but they don't really have much of a shot. I don't think I'm making the major league team.
So, I want to just pick your brain a little bit on those four. Are you sensing that like, this is one of the bigger competitions going on right now?
Yeah, I'd say so. What the heck is, I don't know if you can hear the sirens behind me. That's. Oh yeah.
Huh. Okay. They drove past me. They're not, they're not coming for me. That's good for you. yeah, I do think that this is one of the bigger competitions in camp.
I do think that it's pretty much up for that one rotation spot. I, Paul Skenes and Mitch Keller will be there. I expect Ashcraft and, Bubba Chandler to be starters as well to begin the season.
I, to, I feel like Jose or Keity is probably the likeliest of the four, assuming that no one else has signed.
I think that there's still a good chance that someone gets signed and death depth is added and something changes there. But I think it Rokidi has probably the inside track just because he has that major league experience because of his injury history and the limited innings last year.
And, coming off of that injury, you can't guarantee anything, but given what he has been and his experience and his working with Bill Murphy and, just what he's been in his resume, I think that he probably has the likeliest chance.
However, I still certainly think guys like Harrington or Barco or potentially even Mlodzinski have a shot at it.
Do you think if they end up going that route, do you think it turns into a piggyback situation?
With Erkidi?
With Erkidi.
Do you think they end up going piggybacking if he's the fifth starter?
Honestly, that's something I'm really interested to see, exactly how they handle it.
I asked Don Kelly if like a six man rotation was a possibility and he didn't, he didn't seem to think so, at least at the beginning of the season, just based upon how the schedule lined up was the reasoning he gave.
But I do expect the Pirates to be somewhat creative with how they manage their innings for all their guys, not just Erkidi.
I think that considering injury histories for Ashcraft in particular and Bubba Chandler doesn't have much of an injury history or he stayed healthy, but he also is young.
So maybe you end up in this situation where Erkidi combines with Mlodzinski or Ashcraft's innings are limited and you get creative there.
And maybe that leads to something strange, like even if say Hunter Barco ends up being the fifth starter, you probably wouldn't want him going full throttle right at the very beginning, given his history as well.
I think that it, that's one of the reasons why I think that Carmen Mlodzinski is more likely to start in the bullpen just because you have that piggyback option.
And you can be creative with how exactly you manage your innings and get through nine each game.
And like, so go with Mlodzinski there, it's been talked about like, he's in the, in the battle for the fifth spot.
And we saw last year, him being the starter going to the bullpen, he really excelled at, right.
There's a lot of talk of like, why maybe him being in the rotation is still enticing, his pitch mix, right.
The shape of his pitches when he like trusted them and built upon them and such.
So like, I want to ask you right now too, do you think there is like a true possibility of Mlodzinski being in that fifth role?
And also with that, do you think that, he could perform better than he would have did last year that people should maybe buy into, Hey, you know what?
Give it a second shot.
I think there's a possibility. he figured out some things last year and tweaked his pitch mix a little bit.
And Jason wrote an article about this and what specifically Mlodzinski changed to have success in the bullpen.
And however, and then the other thing that's worth noting is that it makes sense to have him build up as a starter and make sense to have him be part of that competition.
It's easier to have someone start as a starter and then go back to the bullpen instead of the other way around.
Like trying to ramp a guy up would be very difficult. And where, whereas having a guy for go through a lesser workload is perfectly fine.
There's no downside to it. I think that he's probably best suited for a bullpen role.
Like that's where I'd have him considering how valuable he was last year. However, it's not like the pirates are losing anything by giving him a shot to be in the rotation.
You might as well have all your options out there and have him built up just in case.
I want to talk about Thomas Harrington a little bit because he seems to be the forgotten piece of this.
He was a, top 100 prospect just two years ago. There was, there was some hype coming in and then he just floundered in the majors when he got his shot and didn't look good when he got sent back to AAA.
It was a rough year for him. And so like in your article, it talks about how, like, it wasn't the year that he wanted, he looked back to see, what was it that went wrong and build from there.
So like, I want to know, like, what has the feedback been on Thomas Harrington that you're hearing and like, has he learned from that past season, to take that next step forward and put his name back in this mix?
I haven't gotten to see too much of Harrington throughout spring training so far. I think that's something we'll see more of once we're into actual games, but yeah, I do feel like he's somewhat forgotten because of his struggles in 2025.
I talked to him about this and it was really interesting to hear his perspective and hear how he's learned from it. It wasn't the year he'd hoped for. He thinks that it taught him some lessons.
He thinks that through those couple appearances and seeing how big league hitters attacked him, that he learned some things and we'll be able to take that into, like it, he took that into the off season and can take that into this year, just in terms of lessons he's learned adjustments he's made.
I also think that he probably like, he dealt with a groin injury at the end of last season. I wouldn't be surprised if that's something that he was dealing with it, dealing with even before that. And if, and once that was fixed, that was something that's helpful for him.
That doesn't, isn't to say that he's going to be a completely different pitcher this year. And there's definitely adjustments that need to be made and lessons, the lessons learned have to result in actual tweaks, but it was interesting to hear his perspective and hear what he said.
You also wrote about Marcell Ozuna being a mentor to Oneil Cruz and just to expand upon that Carlos Santana held that role a couple of years ago.
And that was Oneil Cruz's best season in the majors when Santana was there with him.
So I guess just expand, talk about that a little bit, just what you've seen as far as that relationship.
I know Marcell Ozuna has only been in camp for three days, so there probably isn't a whole lot there, but like, what have you said your own article about it, like, but like, what have you seen?
Or what have you heard from Ozuna and Cruz in terms of like how that relationship's looking?
Yeah, I understand that Marcell Ozuna is a bit of a hot button issue considering the, some things that are in his past and some of the legal issues he's gotten into, but just purely speaking baseball, purely speaking in the clubhouse, he's a guy who has a stellar reputation.
Reputation that I heard from Atlanta.
I saw it firsthand when I was interning in Atlanta, got to see him just in a couple games covering the Braves.
It was clear how his teammates viewed him and how much he was loved in that clubhouse.
He's someone that just has a stellar baseball reputation as someone who helps his teammates get better, both Latin guys, American guys, whatever, brings a clubhouse together.
In terms of Oneil Cruz and specifically, it was really interesting to see how he's approaching that.
The first time we spoke to Marcell Ozuna, he was asked specifically about Cruz and he was just like, yeah, there's some things that I can teach him.
And if he works the way that we're going to work, I think that there's going to be results there.
And then the very first workout, they go into stretching circles and Ozuna just makes a beeline for Cruz.
Just immediately, that's the first guy he's seeking out.
I think that relationship is something that's only going to help Cruz because as we all know, the potential is there.
He's flashed it.
Potential is something that my readers get mad at me for mentioning all the time just because, yeah, like it's there.
It's just frustrating to see when it doesn't show up.
So I think that's a relationship that really could have real dividends this year.
I really think that relationship and having a guy who's been there and done that and a countryman like Marcell Ozuna is something that can be really helpful for Oneil Cruz.
I don't know whether he's going to make the opening day roster.
I don't think anyone knows in February 18th.
I don't think Ben Cherington or anyone who puts the team together knows whether Konnor Griffin is going to make the opening day roster.
But from the first week or so of camp, it's very clear that this kid is really good.
Every day as we're watching, he does something where it's just like, man, this is different.
This is a 19-year-old who's putting balls onto the batting cage or homering at my BP or looking really good in preps.
I remember today there was a throwdown from Endy Rodríguez just to him covering second base, and he made a stellar pick and threw home, and Spencer Horvish just pointed at him.
It was just a good baseball player.
He's doing something impressive every single day.
Now, obviously, it comes with a caveat.
He's 19 years old, and there's a lot of pressure on him.
He's the consensus top prospect.
There's – like, the world is on his shoulders.
As of right now, he's done everything right.
Like, we've – I've been very impressed with how he's handled himself, how he's looked in BP.
Obviously, he's putting on a show.
I think that it's something where the Pirates will want to be careful with him and try to do what they can to minimize the pressure on him.
However, he's also looked the part of someone who's really good and can help the Pirates right now, even though he is 19 years old.
And, like, I want to add here, because it's week one.
Not to try to make, like, a mountain out of a molehill or, like, a tuna out of a mackerel, maybe, if you may.
But what does Conor have to do in spring that you think for him to actually make opening day roster?
Because I think it's plain and simple.
Like, he'll be probably the best shortstop on the team in spring training.
But what does he have to do to make sure that he's on the opening day roster?
His little mackerel comment, it's just a DiNardo quote.
That's all.
He's so old.
That's good.
That's good.
I'm just trying to nail this fish.
It's bothered me.
And Jim sent a flounder, and I couldn't hold myself from laughing earlier.
It's definitely not a flounder.
I didn't even do that on purpose.
Yeah, I didn't even do that on purpose.
I didn't want to cut you off, but I really did.
That's good.
All right, but to answer your actual question, I do think that Konnor Griffin has – I don't know.
I think he probably needs to leave no doubt.
Like, I don't know exactly what the number is.
If he's – I'm someone that thinks spring training stats are generally overrated and overblown.
Like, there's – it's something where it's a small enough sample size that you will know more from watching the games and actually seeing it than whatever a guy's batting average or slugging percentage is after however many spring training at-bats.
However, with that said, if Griffin bats 400 and is hitting for power and is handling defense and is base running well and continues to say and do all the right things, then, yeah, I think it would be a really difficult decision for the Pirates to have to send him to AAA.
I think it's pretty clear that he's someone that can help the Pirates right now and could handle shortstop right now.
I understand games haven't been played and it's been batting practice, but it's clear how good this kid is.
That's not to say that he's going to make the opening day roster or isn't going to make the opening day roster.
I just think that if he plays well and plays to what we believe he can be, then he would certainly give the Pirates a difficult decision regardless of what they choose.
So, basically, we're hoping he's more of a Mike Trout than a Mike Karp.
Nailed it!
There we go.
I love you, Tyler.
That's good.
That's good.
That's...
That's...
You really just...
You really just dragged it all together there.
Getting a Konnor Griffin comparison and, yeah, well done.
That's how it's done.
Let me ask you this.
If you knew absolutely nothing about any player heading into this last...
These last two weeks, you knew nothing.
And you just showed up randomly and started watching this team.
And watching him in batting practice, it stands out.
It's something where, like, all we want to do is watch it and record it.
And Jason and I, by having two people down there, we're trying to record as much as possible and get different angles and see different at-bats and diversify our content.
But whenever Konnor Griffin is at-bat, we both want to watch it.
Like, that's what it is.
And there's no such thing as too many videos of him, considering how good he is.
So, yes, he stands out in a really good way.
It's unbelievable that he's 19 because he looks like the real deal.
All right.
Before we let you go, it's February 18th.
Will Konnor Griffin be the opening day starting shortstop?
Yes or no?
It's funny.
We're actually working on an opening day roster projections article right now.
I'm going to say yes.
I think that it's just off of what I've seen.
It's tough to imagine a world where the Pirates decide that there's someone better suited to play shortstop for them on March 26th, 2026, than Konnor Griffin.
I'd understand if they want to be patient.
I'd understand if they want to play this the way most prospects play this.
However, it looks pretty clear to me that he's the best suited to play shortstop and someone that can help the team right now.
So, right now, my answer is yes.
Love it.
Love it.
Now, do you anticipate, much like a swordfish, an extension happening?
That was really bad.
I assumed that there was going to be another fish pun made.
But swordfish, that's tough.
I'm trying here, man.
That joke floundered.
It's a tough grouper.
Yeah.
I expect there to be talks.
I think that there's going to be real conversations.
I think that both sides understand what they have.
And if a number is given that the Griffin party is interested in, I think they'd be willing to make that a deal, considering the situation and how highly touted he is.
I don't know exactly what the number would be.
I'm sure that the Griffin camp is once a lot more than Jackson Cheerio numbers.
I don't think that number would get the Pirates anywhere specifically close.
I don't know exactly where they start being interested, whether it's 100 or 130 or 150 or exactly where they land in there.
But I expect those talks to happen.
I expect those talks to be very serious.
But I don't know enough about where either side would come in on to say, yes or no, this will get done.
All you got to do is get your hook in them.
Nailed it.
What's sad is the entire time, Jim never took the bait.
Colin, where can everybody find your stuff?
I was going to say, can I go home now?
All of my work is at post-tosette.com.
We've got coverage from Bradenton, multiple articles each day.
That opening day roster projection will be coming out soon.
And you can also find me on Twitter at Colin underscore Beasley.
I'm posting videos, my stories, my insights, whatever, all that on Twitter.
I would very much appreciate you guys checking it out.
Love it.
Like I said, great work so far down there in Bradenton.
And, yeah, looking forward to what you bring us next.
Thank you.
I'll do my best.
Just for you three.
Just for you three.
Appreciate it.
Anytime I want to come back on the cast.
You're welcome.
I'm leaving.
We're in again.
Some high praise there, though, for Konnor Griffin continues to just come in.
I'm excited, man.
I've never been more excited about a Pittsburgh Pirates season in at least eight years, seven years.
Which doesn't say much, but that's where I'm at.
Do we just want to dive into Konnor Griffin talk right now?
Yeah.
Because I'm getting worried, guys.
There's too much positivity around them.
Can we talk about this Fangraph's top 100 write-up real quick?
Yeah.
I just want to highlight something.
And, like, we've all had Eric on the show.
And, like, Eric is usually very, like, he watches what he says about players.
Like, he's pretty careful to hype people up.
Like, when he's putting numbers together, he's usually pretty conservative.
Like, for the most part, Fangraph's, I feel like, out of all the places, is known for being the least excited about players.
Just because, like, they're very much, hey, like, a lot of prospects bust.
And, like, here are the things about this guy that could be the reason why he doesn't end up being as good as you think.
But I want you to, like, listen to some of these things.
Listen, this was Fangraph's top 100.
Griffin is a freaky five-tool superstar with big power and enough contact ability to weaponize it.
He's about to be one of the best young players in the game.
He's not only clearly the best prospect in baseball, but one of the top handful of prospects ever evaluated during the current era of Fangraph scouting, which goes back a little over 10 years.
I don't know what you say to that.
Like, that's the beginning.
Right.
But, like, they're essentially saying, hey, listen, this guy's number one.
He's number one by a lot.
And he's about to be a superstar.
I'm excited to see him.
Like, honestly, that's where I'm at.
I'm just excited to see him.
And what you just said there, Jim, it's almost scary.
We were like, don't expect him to look like Jared Jones, you guys.
And look what he did.
I don't know, man.
The more I see of him and just watching him from last season, and again, we haven't seen games yet.
We're seeing batting practice.
We are seeing live BP, so he is hitting off of live pitching right now.
But the more and more I see from him, the more and more I read about him, I feel like this guy is going to be pretty good.
I feel like he's going to be pretty good.
There is just in the last decade, there hasn't been there's been guys like Wander Franco was a guy who everybody just knew was going to be a star.
And he was, off field stuff aside, Wander Franco was a star.
Vlad, another guy who people just knew he's going to get up there and he's going to hit.
And that's what he did like there are too many players that talent evaluators speak about in this light.
Like there's always a thing where it's like he's got the potential to do this.
He's got the potential to do this.
There's this one thing that he needs to work on.
There's really like nothing here that says otherwise.
Like there's a chart here too.
I'm going to just share real quick just so everybody can see it.
But at the end of the write-up, it goes on to say the probable outcomes of, Konnor Griffin's future value.
Like it says there's a 50% chance he's a 70 plus future value player.
Guys, a 70 plus future value player is a hall of famer.
Like that's what that is.
So fan graphs right now is basically saying there's a 50% chance.
This dude's going to be a hall of famer.
And then there's a 25% chance that he's the step below that, which is like really good player and perennial all-star and maybe a hall of famer.
You're cut.
And the step below that is like, he's an all-star.
Like they're essentially saying here that it's a, it's a 90% chance that Konnor Griffin's an all-star.
And then there's a 15, the 10 to 15% chance that he's not.
But like, I don't know how you can't not get excited about this guy.
It's just absolutely incredible.
the things that people are saying about him.
And you just heard Connor say that knowing absolutely Colin, you just heard Colin say, no, if he went into camp knowing nothing about anybody like Konnor Griffin's been the most impressive guy on the field.
And there are multi-time all-stars on that field.
There's a guy who's gotten MVP votes on that field.
He's saying Konnor Griffin's the best looking one so far.
And I think one of the more impressive things that has happened with him is when he got drafted, there is a good chance that he was going to be in center field.
Like he was projected for an outfield role.
Yep.
He's improved the shortstop to the point where I think fan graphs mentioned it, how good he's gotten there.
So you, the mentality is there.
Obviously the skill sets there, the ability to be coachable is there.
I got to stop because if Jim keeps talking, we're getting a little erotic here.
Jim was so excited when he saw this, fan graphs article.
I don't think I've ever seen Jim as excited as he was when he read that first, like two paragraphs that first day.
Has anyone wrote anything like this on any player?
Cause again, like this seems quite outlandish, but also keep in mind, like where it's coming from, who's writing it.
And like, this isn't, this isn't someone vested into it.
Like MLB pipeline.
This isn't someone who's with the pirates organization or ties to the pirates writing about this.
This is completely independent outside.
And again, like it is Eric.
Eric is the type though, who, he said it like when he believes something, he believes it.
Whether it's too early or whatever.
Like when we talk about Nick Gonzales, why Nick Gonzales fall off his list so quickly.
He's like, cause the things that he does, I don't believe it.
So I'm not going to hang on to him here.
I'm running him off already.
He believes this.
Yeah.
And there has been one other prospect.
the other prospect is wander.
Like, let's just call it like wander was given an 80 by fan graphs.
And Eric said in the chat right after this was dropped that he considered putting an 80 on Konnor Griffin.
but he ultimately decided not to, but wander did get an 80.
So you do have to like, okay, he's the other guy.
but like, that's the guys that we're talking about who they have made projections like this before.
They're really good.
They're really good ballplayers.
They don't miss on these types of dudes.
Like most.
And for him being just top of the board everywhere, those type of guys don't miss.
Not lately.
They haven't.
And like, there are guys, the top prospects bust all the time, but not at the level that they're saying this is happening.
Right.
Like Jared Kelenic busted, but no one ever talked to about Jared Kelenic like this, like players like that bust all the time, but players that they talk about like this typically have a pretty good hit rate.
Like, I feel like the consensus one ones, it's a pretty solid track record.
And that's what we're talking about.
Like we put it in perspective of baseball America.
we just had a post on that of all the baseball Americas since baseball America existed, the preseason number one ranked prospects.
And like what percentage of the war and stuff.
And I think it was only like, was it eight that had under 10 war, but also with that eight, four are still active, you know?
And obviously that includes like Roman Anthony last year.
So like when you're one, you're destined to be a solid player at the bare minimum.
And while those one, ones don't get right ups like this, or they're not unanimous.
A lot of times your number one prospect, it's like, eh, I'm going to give a one a, but there's a one B and a one C and a one D.
This is unanimous across the board.
And as ESPN says, as fan graph said here, like, and it's not close to the second guy.
It's not even close.
That's why the pirates farm system had such a large value attached.
So when ESPN did then the farm values and the past or number one farm system, it's because Konnor Griffin was far and above everyone else.
As far as the value he provides dollars wise, take out Connor and he's the pirates are middle of the pack, which also, by the way, when you take most teams, number one prospect out, that's going to put them probably middle of the pack.
As well, but he just pointed out, like, it's not close between him and number two.
Yeah, I guess to wrap everything up, like it, you got to be excited about this kid.
And I understand fans who were like cautious about this because we're pirates fans.
Shit happens.
Like we've dealt with a lot of shit, right?
things have gone poorly for us for 30 years.
Nothing but bad stuff has happened to us.
and so I understand, I understand the hesitation to like completely buy in to this guy.
And if you, if you're someone who says, you know what, I'll believe it when I see it at the major league level.
Like, I have no qualms with that line of thinking because yeah, like you haven't, you haven't seen any of these guys pay off or if they have paid off and become good ballplayers.
Like they've never, it hasn't mattered.
The pirates haven't won anything with any, anybody.
So I understand that line of thinking.
I'm not saying that like you have to be excited about this guy.
What I am saying is I am excited about this guy and I'm looking, I'm really looking forward to seeing what he looks like in spring training against live competition.
I'm not one to put much value in spring training stats, but I think you can at least like look at players though on a baseball field and your eyes can tell you a lot, regardless of the stats.
And every time I've seen Konnor Griffin, he's looked really good.
so I'm looking forward to spending some time, seeing him in person, to just get some, get some eyes on him and try to figure out like, Hey, is this like, are my eyes seeing the same thing?
Everybody else is because everybody else sees the next reincarnation of Mike trout.
Apparently that's shortstop.
Yeah.
And I think, man, people are just getting, they're getting their pirates brain in their brain.
Like the Brad Eldridge of the world, like every prospect that we've gone through that just didn't work out.
It's not to this level.
They're not even close.
Like not even remotely close.
They were top 100 guys.
They're not even remotely close to a consensus one.
If I have a concern, it's more that he did rise very quickly.
It's really only been a year.
We've seen some guys like that, like Drix and Profar, Byron Buxton jumped up there real quick.
They all turned out to be pretty good major leaguers.
It just took them a little bit longer.
Like they had struggles in the majors.
That would be maybe my only concern here is that it might take him a bit.
If he comes up, he might struggle.
It's not doubting that he'll be a good major league baseball player at some point.
who was, the B brew brewer, brewski, brew baker, like just in the pirates realm of things.
Right.
But like arms get injured often.
The pirates have been lucky to some level opposed to other teams, and you just never know when someone's going to down and I'm good with our key, like getting the fifth start spot to start the season, but he's a perfect candidate of a guy who could
get injured very quickly.
And then you're going to someone else already, the reason I like him, if he's going to be the fifth stars, then Barco goes to trip play and you can manage, you can give him like the Paul Skenes treatment, or even like the Bubba Chandler's
treatment to some level.
It's like, okay, go out there and pitch two innings at a time, three innings.
Let's ramp you up.
Let's monitor those innings to bring you up.
that's why I do like him to win it right now with what's available, but I'm a absolutely all in on them.
Bring another arm because I think this team lacks depth.
I think Tyler said, I agree.
What about even like maybe a Patrick Corbin?
Like I'm cool with the Patrick Corbin.
Also, I just think a guy who's going to eat innings, think of like the rich Hills of the days, like just give me a guy who has a rubber arm.
It's going to eat some innings, cover your fifth spot.
I'm cool with that right now because we have other guys that have talent and let's get them in there for the playoff run.
I'm going to, I'm going to agree a little bit with what each of you said, but I'm also going to disagree.
I think, I think the depth is there.
I think one through four is good enough that fifth starter just needs to be a dude with like a working arm that you can throw out there and doesn't completely embarrass himself.
and then I think, and I think Urquidy can do that.
it's been a while since he's done it.
That's, I think probably my biggest hesitation for two years.
I would say that's my biggest hesitation with Urquidy is he hasn't like Urquidy hasn't been good since 2022.
That was a while ago.
Oh, the while ago we were a 2022.
That was like a whole different world.
But that, at that point, that would be my biggest concern with Urquidy.
But as far as the depth standpoint, like I'm comfortable having, like, if you need to have Mlodzinski make some starts, I'm comfortable with it.
If you need to have Barco make some starts, I'm comfortable with it.
If you need to have even Thomas Harrington make some starts, I'm comfortable with it.
I know a lot of people like got a really sour taste in their mouth about Harrington last year, but like, I feel like Thomas Harrington is a capable backend starter if you need to call upon him.
And again, I think one through four are so good that like, you can afford to have a dud at number five.
It's not ideal.
Can I, can I throw something against you though?
I haven't finished my thought, but you can go ahead and yeah, go ahead.
Go ahead.
Go ahead.
I'll say ideally I'm not done though.
Like with what they've got, I'm okay with it, but ideally I'm going out there and I'm getting another arm and I'd honestly like, hell your payroll is already as high as it's been ever.
Why not just push it a little bit more and be like, Hey, Lucas G Alito, nobody signed you yet.
Like, what would it take to get you in here?
Like, what would it take?
Because like, maybe you can get creative with him like how, the tie have gotten pretty creative with some pitchers.
Like the Padres got pretty creative, with, who's the guy that the Padres just signed.
shoot, Walker Bueller, Walker Bueller, but also they signed, no, nobody I'm thinking
of someone else then, but I think G Alito, I would certainly make.
A push on to see like what you can do to bring him in.
And maybe it looks like a one year deal with a, with like a mutual option and like a really high buyout.
So like, maybe you're not spending a whole lot on him this year and there's a buyout next year.
Like, I don't know, try to get creative with a Lucas G Alito deal.
that would be my number one thing.
Cause if you bring G Alito in, then all of a sudden one through five, I'm very comfortable with that.
And then you've got her Katie as your number six guy, stick them in the bullpen to start the year as a long man.
If you need to, cause he's out of options.
So like, yeah, like just roll with that.
Patrick Corbin, I think I'd be okay with too, just because I feel like a left-handed pitcher.
He's going to pitch a little bit above his weight playing in half his games in PNC park.
So like, I feel like that could work.
and like, if you can get Patrick Corbin super cheap on a one year deal, then yeah, I think that would work as well, but I don't think they're in a bad spot right here.
Like I think with, I think what they got will work, but it could be, it could be a little bit better.
All right.
And you answered that there, but what I want to throw at you, because I do see this talked about a lot and that's like the path you were going, one through four is so good that like whoever's your fifth, like it doesn't matter and such, but like,
I think what's a real possibility people are missing out on.
and that's why I want to have this conversation and like dialogue.
There's a real possibility that, and I hate to say it, I'm not trying to jinx anything, but like putting things perfect perspective, Braxton Ashcraft gets injured and he's out for the year or he's a guy who easily could be out for the year.
And you're not guaranteed those four guys, it could be Bubba Chandler that goes down.
Like there's a good chance that one of those four is going down for a lengthy period of time.
So now you're dealing with skeins.
We'll say it is Ashcraft, like it's skeins, Bubba, Mitch, and then you're fighting for four and five to get through.
So now is it, and again, we're thinking in this scenario, are keys gone?
Also, like you have a Harrington and Mlodzinski, which is also taking me off the ball.
But you know what?
Like, that's why I'm all four.
And I want to keep preaching as I keep quote tweeting things.
You never have enough pitching on Twitter.
Like, I really think this team needs another arm.
Absolutely.
Absolutely.
At this point, because of that scenario, like you might not have those four in the playoffs.
So like, I think you also need to put that into the equation that, middle of the year, if something does happen, then like Jared Jones is about to be inserted into this rotation as well.
So I don't know.
I think they got enough.
And like, if you need Antwone Kelly to make a spot start, fine.
Like Antwone Kelly can make four major league starts right now.
Like they, I think they've got guys who can do it.
I agree with you.
Like pitchers get hurt.
Pitchers get hurt all the time.
So like, you have to almost expect somebody's going to get hurt at some point.
but I think, I think they're in a good spot.
I said, can it be better?
Sure.
Can always, it can always be better.
Like you mentioned, you can never have too many arms.
but I think they're in a pretty good spot right now.
And as far as like who I would probably go with just based off of what's like, who's in camp right now, I would go or Katie at this rate, mainly just because as we've mentioned, like you need arms to get you through 162 game season or Katie is your one guy who's competing
for this spot.
Who doesn't have any options, right?
So or Katie is your guy and maybe you can DFA or Katie in a month and a half or two months.
If it's not working out, like he's not really, you're not putting a ton of money into her Katie, but like he's someone who can at least get you through the first couple of months, hopefully.
And then there's Jones.
Then there's Barco.
Then there's the backups coming in, down the road.
But I think you start off with her Katie just based off of who's in camp right now.
Barco with the option, Harrington with the option, Kelly dotel.
They both have options.
Maginski's in your bullpen.
I think that's, I think that's the way you go.
but yeah, I think you could always add another harm.
Yeah.
I think we're all on the same page as being the, they could use another arm.
It would help, but I'm with the Nardo.
Like I don't like where they're at.
One of those four will go down.
And the problem is if one of them go down for the season, they're in trouble.
Like you got to fill those innings.
Ashcraft has not eaten a lot of innings in his career.
Whether you're listening on the podcast or catching us on YouTube, if you enjoyed the show, please give this video a thumbs up.
And don't forget to hit that subscribe button if you haven't already.
It really helps us grow.
And if you're listening on the podcast, a quick review goes a long way in helping others find the show.
Plus, be sure to tell a friend about us.
There's always room for more here in the NS9 community.
And for those looking to support us a little more, consider joining our Patreon, become an MVP member, and get exclusive perks while helping us continue to bring you more of the Pirates content you love.
Comments· 0
Should the Pirates sign another starter before Opening Day instead of handing José Urquidy the No. 5 spot?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.