◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
Sicko Soundoff was live tonight on Twitter Spaces, with Tyler and DiNardo taking calls and letting Pirates fans turn the offseason into a full-on therapy session. The conversation was not just about whether moves were good or bad. It was about the bigger picture, how the Pirates are allocating their resources, and whether those choices actually line up with what this roster needs to take a real step forward.
That framing is what made the Gregory Soto signing such a lightning rod. Tyler’s argument was not simply anti-Soto. It was about opportunity cost. If you are going to spend money and use roster spots, where does it matter most? Is a bullpen add the best use of resources when the lineup still needs more thump and the rotation depth can get thin fast? Some callers liked the idea of adding a proven arm who can help you win tight games early in the year. Others agreed with Tyler’s point that these dollars and moves need to be aimed at the biggest weaknesses if the Pirates are serious about closing the gap.
From there, we zoomed out and walked through everything the Pirates did this offseason to add, move by move, and debated whether the total package feels like a real push or just a collection of incremental upgrades. That is where the room split. One side saw clear improvement and depth. The other side said depth is fine, but impact is what changes your season.
We also revisited the Oviedo for Garcia deal through that same lens. Not just evaluating the players, but what it says about priorities, risk, and how this front office chooses to spend its chips.
By the end, it was the same question over and over. Did they spend smart, or did they spend safe?
Comments· 1
The Debate
Was Gregory Soto worth $7.5 million of the Pirates' $103 million payroll?
Tim S.🐣Prospect· 271d ago
Thanks for your coverage. I greatly enjoy it!
With Anthony DiNardo and Tyler Sweeney.
Chapters
Key takeaways
1
For 2026, the Pirates would be better off with Yohan Oviedo in the rotation than with Jhostynxon Garcia. This is the year to compete, and Oviedo makes the team better now.
2
Spending $7.5M of a $103M payroll on Gregory Soto was 'an absolute mistake.' He's a pitcher with a 4.00 ERA every year who walks too many hitters, and it looked like a panic signing Cherington would regret.
3
Jim calls being glad the Pirates missed on Kyle Schwarber 'one of the dumbest things you've ever said.' Schwarber at $25M is twice the player Ozuna is at half that price, and Soto is the second-best reliever on the team.
4
Cherington has been GM for seven years and could have been signing free agents all along. The Pirates aren't victims of the market. They made their bed by waiting until his last year to spend.
5
This is at least a .500 team without question, an 81–83 win club. The 80+ wins line at +112 is a good bet.
Yo, you're listening to the Norse for Nine podcast presented by FanDuel, yes, so we'll be in beautiful Bradenton, it's gonna be glorious, I'm excited, you're excited, and this is our last show before we are in Bradenton.
So, Tyler, you had some talking points you want to present tonight, which we've been hearing a lot of, I guess, these talking points in the community for the past few weeks, so why don't you kick it off for us?
Yeah, man, like, one of the things I've brought up here, and there's a, so the Pirates did a lot of things this offseason, let me reset that.
A lot of things they did, I don't have any complaints about, I think they were the right moves, I like a lot of it, I think they improved their team a heck of a lot, but I'm just curious here, where do people stand?
If we look back at this, coming into this offseason, we were thinking $30 million might be the amount they have to spend in order to get back to where they were in 2025, around $93 million.
Now they are, basically at $103 million.
Did the Pirates spend that efficiently?
That is really my question tonight.
And I think if you look into this a little deeper, like, if it was a perfect world, there were things we could change, sure.
I think they did a decent enough job with what they had and where they were right now.
However, at the same time, there are a one, two, maybe three things that they did this offseason.
Where, as we stand here on February 20th, I'm not sure that the Pirates would have done that, if they could look back in retrospect and see what all has happened.
There are some things that they've done this offseason, I'm not sure that they would do that over again.
Yeah.
And I'm curious to see what everybody thinks about that.
Yeah, I think it's a good point.
And, obviously, hindsight is 50-50 for Cam Newton, otherwise 20-20.
But I think part of the problem is, right, when you look back, maybe we could have done things differently and been more efficient.
But at the end of the day, I think, ultimately, you also realize that the Pirates weren't really in a situation where they could be very picky and choosy and say, like, here's the plan.
Let's attack this plan to a T and accomplish the mission because it takes two to tango.
And what their plan could have been was, let's go after this guy.
And this guy's like, well, no, you're the Pirates, and I don't want to play for you, right?
I don't trust you.
So I think what you're alluding to is more earlier in the offseason.
Is that correct?
Perfect.
Okay.
And I think that could be it.
it's like we attacked.
We know we could get this guy.
So let's go and get it because it's there and it does help us.
But maybe at the end of the day, you look back and it's like, well, now that these other cards fell, maybe we could have done that early part different.
And to be honest with you, I think a prime example of it is the Oviedo trade.
Okay.
I know that wasn't really a spent money type of situation.
But if I am Ben Cherington right now and I'm looking at the way this roster is constructed, the way this team stands right now, I would rather have Yohan Oviedo right now than Garcia.
Curious what people think about that.
I think Oviedo helps his team a heck of a lot more than Garcia will this year.
And let's be honest, this is the year that this team needs to compete for 20, 27, 20, 28.
Be damned.
This is the year they need to go.
We don't know what's going to happen in 20, 27.
We don't know if there's going to even be a season played.
Right.
Even if there is how much of a season.
Right.
So I think if you really looked back at it, I don't know if the Pirates would still make that move.
Because the way this rotation is set up right now, I think Oviedo makes them a heck of a lot better.
Maybe not a heck of a lot, but I feel a lot more comfortable about this team if Yohan Oviedo is a Pittsburgh Pirate.
Yeah.
So let's hear your voices, guys.
if you're on YouTube, the link is pinned there.
That takes you right to our Twitter spaces.
If you're in the Twitter spaces, go ahead and request.
You can join because we do want to hear your takes and your thoughts on this.
Because I think you can certainly question it.
And, of course, most teams have these same questions.
Like, this is an outlier.
we're not trying to be greedy in a sense.
But let's take a look back at this offseason.
And it does.
Like, it's funny.
It started with that trade.
that was basically the very first move Ben Cherington made.
Traded Oviedo, got Garcia, and another, low-level prospect.
There's something there with him.
But, again, he's still so far away.
At the time, I think that was also your viewpoint.
Does this really make 2026 better?
The trade's fine, in a sense.
You have these rotation arms as depth to trade away.
And they did so.
And they got an interesting prospect who's MLB ready, or at least close to it.
But now that you had Brandon Lowe come in, now that you had Jake Mangum come in, now that you have Ryan O'Hearn, now you have Marcell Ozuna, and you also traded to get some of those, some other arms.
I think that's where you're coming into play here.
It's like, well, now that you know that, would you have rather have kept Oviedo so you're not worried about the depth?
Because that's a hot topic right now.
The rotation's solid.
There's a lot of talent.
But is the depth truly there?
Oviedo as a number five starter for this team in 2026, like you're talking about.
Now this rotation looks really good, and there's depth everywhere.
You feel very comfortable with the depth, and you feel very comfortable with the upside.
And does that make this team better in 2026 than Garcia being here?
And I think that's the question you present.
So, yeah, that's what I want to hear from other people as well in their thoughts, or some other thoughts you might have.
Yeah, I think we can look back at a lot of this.
we can critique and criticize things, but like you said earlier, it does take two to tango.
Some of these guys, like, if we really wanted to get into the nitty-gritty, yeah, sure.
Sure, they should have signed Eugenio Suarez over Marcell Ozuna.
Sure, in a perfect world, that's great.
Right.
It didn't seem like he wanted to come here.
So I'm not going to beat the Pirates over the head about that, although I'm not happy about it.
I wish they would have found a way to make it work.
But it does take two to do this.
More of when we get into some of these moves that they made, like, another one that has been brought up a good bit is the Gregory Soto trade.
Or acquisition, I should say.
You mentioned the password trade there earlier.
This one as well, the Soto signing.
I was pretty much on board off the bat.
I hated this thing.
I don't like this signing at all.
I still really don't like it.
I think he's a solid pitcher.
I don't like the allocation of funds with him.
I don't think $7.5 million is...
I don't think he's worth that to the Pittsburgh Pirates.
I don't think it's an efficient spending of resources.
And then they win the Pirates.
I want to add to that, because I want to make sure you're getting that point off.
It's not so much that you don't like him, the pitcher.
Right.
You just more or less don't like the allocation.
When there's a finite amount, and at that point in time, we're thinking maybe it's only $30 million.
At this point, it's about $40 million.
But using $7.5 million of that finite amount on this reliever, that's more where you're coming into play, right?
Exactly.
And if we're looking at a $103 million payroll right now, $7.5 million of that going to Gregory Soto, to me, is absolutely silly.
Well, to me, that is an absolute mistake of a signing this offseason.
So I look at it this way.
That's a guy they were targeting.
That's a guy they liked.
And that's a guy who's willing to sign right away.
And so at the time, it's like, let's get this done.
We got it.
We solved our left-handed reliever situation here.
So I guess, to your point, if you fast forward and now you're getting Mason Montgomery, does that now make you feel not so much foolish, but so much to that degree of, like, well, now did you want to use that $7.5 million on Gregory Soto?
Or were you, Tyler, I'm asking you, are you comfortable with having, like, a Mason Montgomery for that and then being able to use those $7.5 million somewhere else?
I would be more comfortable with Mason Montgomery plus probably someone other than Gregory Soto on the cheaper end.
Oh, okay.
So keep adding, but find...
I would have found a different left-handed option than Soto.
Okay.
At the end, we're talking about a guy that has a four ERA every single year.
He's erratic, he walks too many guys, and he blows up too often.
Yeah, the FIP looks great.
Results matter.
Now?
$7.5 million for this guy.
I really didn't...
I didn't like it then, I don't like it now.
It's, again, it's $7.5 million for any other team.
It's dropping the bucket.
I think they could have done a lot better with that.
I think for God's sake, just pay David Bednar $9 million in arbitration and call it a day.
Now, I'm with you on that.
Trust me.
And you know that.
actually, what should have been done was last offseason, signed to an extension, like a three-year extension, probably cheaper than $9 million per year based on what he was coming off of, but staying home, getting that guaranteed money.
Anyways, moving past that, I think that's all a fair point.
Now, to play devil's advocate, the Pirates certainly liked Soto.
it seemed like that was the guy in their eyes.
And this is also a team who's done very well in their acquisitions of pitchers.
So, like, what I understand what you're saying, like, he has had a four-year array pretty much every year, right?
Like, what he does, what if they know, like, hey, this is the guy we know we can do X, Y, Z with.
He comes in, and, like, this is, like, one of those better seasons he has.
My problem is that I don't feel like that's what they did.
Okay.
I feel like this was almost a panic acquisition where they didn't think they were going to get much, and they spent money on this guy just trying to make a move.
Okay.
And I think looking back at it, I think if you give Ben Cherington some truth serum, I think he would regret this move.
Some truth serum.
Oh, boy, I would love to give Ben Cherington some truth serum.
Maybe that's what we do tomorrow.
We're going to give Ben Cherington some truth serum.
Just joking.
Just joking.
We will no longer be doing shows at Leacom Park, fellas.
Sorry.
Our credentials have been rebutted.
Just joking.
No, I love everything you did this offseason, Ben.
Please let us come back.
But, again, I think these are all fair points.
if you knew exactly what was going to happen this offseason, maybe the password one's still out there, though.
I can also see, like, hey, that's available for, again, like, I understand in 2026 he might not help out.
But you have your opportunity, your chance to get someone with that type of power, that type of upside.
And, again, with all that also comes the risk of he's a bust.
And you don't get any of that.
so I'm not trying to just type him up.
if you want to know what we have to say about him, listen to our show.
The trade was made.
And, we pulled up all these concerns.
But there's still a guy with some upside.
And if you can acquire a guy like that for the next six years, maybe it still is worth it.
Like, I understand it might not help 2026, but we'll still find a way.
And at the same time, they did, right?
Like, this might not help 2026, but they did find some nice offense to go around.
So, like, you're not relying on Garcia.
And that was our biggest point there, too.
It's like they didn't make the trade to say, like, oh, we solved left field.
They didn't.
They've added on.
They got Mangum.
They got Brandon Lowe.
They got O'Hearn.
They got Marcell Ozuna.
You know what?
So, like, they've made enough moves this year to improve the offense to a degree I think they feel comfortable with.
Sure, you can debate third base or not, but they've certainly improved.
However, of course, we understand the rotation and where that stands.
Like, I can't truly follow.
Like, I still think you could probably make that move because you're still adding offensive talent into this system that is lacking it.
And, to find a long-term solution while you're still fighting short-term around it isn't a terrible thing to do.
But I certainly can agree with you that keeping Oviedo does make the 20-20-16 better.
And ultimately, right now, that is what matters.
It is, and I'm very curious to hear everybody else's opinion here.
Go ahead and click that speak button.
We'll go ahead and let you in so that you can give your thoughts on the offseason here.
I know Bucko Mike wants to talk.
He always does.
Everybody but Bucko Mike is allowed to come on because I'm still getting DMs by Bucko Mike.
Just I'll get a random DM.
Three o'clock in the morning, I'll get a DM by Bucko Mike.
And what's it say?
Skeen's arbitration, $120 million.
That's it.
That's all it is.
Still these silly comments.
Yeah, we got some frequent flyers in here.
We got Bucko Mike.
We got Greg.
There's another person in here that likes Louisville a little bit too much that I don't really need to hear speak.
Right.
Sean.
King Baraki, I want to hear you talk some too, even though you're in Chicago right now.
By the way, I don't know if he saw this, but I think it's Pirates.
Adjacent relevance, right?
He's with the White Sox now.
He hates the Cubs, apparently.
He was talking about that in an interview with the White Sox and how he grew up a White Sox fan and he hates the Cubs.
I just found it funny because he's with the Cubs for how long?
Maybe that's why he was bad there.
He just hated himself.
who doesn't hate the Cubs?
I don't know.
Again, to get back to our original point, I don't think this was not a bad offseason.
I think long-term, Oviedo for Garcia is probably a good move.
Where the Pirates are right now, I don't know if I still would have made that move.
After trading Oviedo and after trading Burroughs, I am not super comfortable with this rotation.
Yeah.
It's all fair.
It is all fair.
I think we all anticipated the move was probably going to be Mitch Keller just because also you get that salary relief.
So, that gives you $17 million to also add another pitcher, right?
I guess you can say Jose Irquity, but Irquity, sorry.
But, like, again, that's not safe.
That's not like, oh, this is definitely the number five starter.
That's just like, here's somebody who can battle for a spot.
So, yeah, again, I think that is all fair.
Outside of those two, though, do you think there's anything else they're looking like in hindsight?
To me, those are the big two.
I think if you're looking back in hindsight, more of it would be the guys you missed on.
So, like, you look at – and it's probably more if you shift some money around in other places.
Like, they probably could have went with – and it's not a great option, but, like, Mike Tauchman's not a terrible outfielder.
If they wanted to put some money elsewhere, play him in the outfield, that probably would have worked out.
Obviously, I already mentioned Suarez being an option that would have loved to go after.
I think, though, one of the things that – just looking at the way this shook out and the amount of money they spent, I am almost glad they didn't get Kyle Schwarber because I don't know if they would have spent any more.
They might have been hunting for scraps after that.
The whole Schwarber thing is very interesting because you can argue – we can certainly have that argument if they're truly in on him.
they were truly in on him to an extent.
They gave their best offer, apparently.
But just, like you said, like, just pretend that happened.
They have $10 more million after Kyle Schwarber that – so far they've spent.
they're going to spend $30.
They've spent $40, essentially, this offseason.
So, you can imagine there's just, like, $10 million more to go with.
Like, are they extending themselves to go still also get O'Hearn or also get this Lowe trade done?
Which, I guess the Lowe trade doesn't really change too much.
But, Gregory Soto's gone.
Like, that happens, and that's it.
You have $3 million more to work with.
so it's like, yeah, I don't know, man.
It's very interesting what would have happened if the Schwarber thing transpired.
Right, like, if they would have spent, let's just say he goes for $25 million, then what?
Like, are we talking about Urquidy, Tauchman?
Then what?
you're Tommy Pham coming back?
Man.
There's...
So, the way it shook out...
The way it shook out here...
I think I am more comfortable that didn't happen.
And maybe they would have spent more if they would have got Schwarber.
Maybe they would have.
But the allocation, to me, was more good than bad.
There were just a few spots in there that I don't know if I loved.
Yeah.
I think it's all fair.
I think they got good value, at least market price on everyone.
even like the Gregor said, like, I understand where you're coming from.
The percentage, there's payroll.
But, like, that's his value.
That's his worth.
So, it's not like they went out and just, like, gave him, like, $10 million.
It's like, wow, you also overpaid for this.
it's wild.
it's about the going rate for what he is.
So, like, yeah, I think in hindsight, I think the other one, too, is, like, just going out there and maybe have to overextend yourself a little more than you're comfortable with, but maybe getting one of those third basemen.
That way, it's, like, truly solving a problem.
Because I guess my thing is, like, do you want to spend $18 million from those third basemen or the $12 million you're doing on Marcell Ozuna?
I think that's fair.
Now, obviously, Marcell Ozuna is, like, one year, likely, and you're out of here.
So, like, there's not the long-term commitment where the other ones do, but at the same time, like, that helps solve your third base issue because I don't think there's really a solution there for long-term either.
Like, there's not a third baseman coming up that you're saying, like, hey, I don't want to sign these guys who are going to pass the torch to, it's nobody.
who's going to be third base in the future that's in the system right now?
Like, Murf Gray's not going to be that guy anytime soon.
Hopefully, like, he does become a prospect and he is a solution later on, but it's not going to be for another two years, like, at the very minimum.
Yeah, and I think in a perfect world, like, they probably get Okamoto.
Yeah.
In a perfect world, he comes to the Pirates, and a lot of things are solved.
I think everyone's, like, that's, I think that's a valid question.
Marcell Ozuna, I get the bat.
It certainly plays.
But he also isn't a great fit, and he puts other people in their best situation.
So it lowers their value.
And if he went and got a real third baseman, everyone's put in their positions to give true peak value.
So it might cost you a little bit more, but I think everyone's in a safer situation.
And, of course, that puts Jared Trello in that super utility role, which also, in my mind, I could be wrong, but, like, in my mind, that puts him at his peak value.
So I just feel like, yeah, that's another, like, look back.
But, again, they are the Pittsburgh Pirates.
They can't really be choosers.
So they were dealt the hand they were dealt.
They made the most of it.
And, honestly, we are talking about a team that I think can contend for the playoffs.
I think we got some more questions.
Yeah, we do.
Carter wanted to talk fair, but he went away.
I guess I'll let Jim on.
Oh, Carter, come back.
Carter, please.
It was Carter.
Carter, please come back.
We got to deal with Jim now.
This is just a podcast now.
Who's letting Jim on?
Well, apparently Twitter's not, because.
There we go, Carter.
We're letting you on instead.
Oh, let's go.
As long as it lets him.
Thanks for letting me come on here.
Appreciate it.
Thank you for coming on, man.
We were panicking.
Oh, sorry.
Well, dude, if I'm the only one to show up, this show is going to be pretty bad.
I'm sorry.
I was just.
You're better than the other option for sure.
Thank you.
I love Jim, though.
I can't.
I cannot lie.
Never mind.
Sorry.
I just want to talk about how you say they're giving the hand that they're dealt when it comes to signing people.
I don't believe that.
Ben has been the GM for seven years now.
They could have just been signing guys from the very beginning.
And then up until this point, they try this offseason.
Well, I'd be lying if I said they just started to try this offseason.
We've heard reports about Okamoto.
Oh, not Okamoto.
Yeah, we heard reports about Okamoto.
And then even before that, we heard points about Soto Imanaga.
Yep.
Even guys like Sean Minaya, I heard that they tried to sign him to a pretty decent contract.
It's just to the point where I don't think they knew how to do it to the point where you have to overspend, especially if you are the Pirates, to try to get guys.
And I appreciate them trying now, like getting Ozuna, getting O'Hearn, and even trading for Brandon Lowe is a great start.
For doing it.
It's just, I know you probably talked, you guys talked about this 800, 900 times about how U.S. did happen already so many times.
It's just, they could have been doing this years ago.
It sucks now that they did it even more so to the point where this is obviously Ben's last year.
So, it's even more desperate to the point you get at.
But, it's, I'm happy for what they did.
And I'm happy that they did what they did now.
It's just sad that we couldn't get the high-ranking free agents now, which would have been, it would have been a perfect year to do it now.
imagine getting Schwarber or Akimoto.
I still do think they get a third baseman, and I still do think they get a starting pitcher.
And I'm pretty happy for what they did right now, especially if they signed Conard Riffin to an extension.
But I appreciate you guys hearing me out, and I would love to hear what you guys think about this stuff.
I know we're probably the same talking points, but I appreciate it, guys.
Yeah.
No, of course.
And I appreciate coming on.
I appreciate you.
Yeah.
And I do want to say something here, and you bring up a good point.
And, yeah, we probably have said this like 900 times, probably even longer, because you're correct.
it's not so much that they're playing the hand they dealt because like, oh, whoa, us.
They made their bed, and they're lying in and out.
Like, that is the majority of the problem, because they waited until like this year to essentially say like, hey, we should maybe do something.
This is the problem.
like, yeah, people don't trust the Pirates.
People look at the Pirates and like, you were a 71 team last year.
Like, are you going to win?
Are you going to invest?
If I come here, do I trust that I'm going to have a winning team around me?
this goes back to 2022, 2023.
the one thing we talked about in 2023, when they added Carlos Santana, Rich Hill, it was like, hey, you guys should have been doing like, this is the bare minimum, but like, this is something you should have been doing for a while.
Let's start building that culture.
Let's maybe get some guys here long term.
So there's a foundation being built, because when you get to this moment, people are going to say, yeah, I see what you're building.
I want to be part of it.
So that's a good point.
And that's 100% correct.
like, this isn't just a, oh, poor Ben Cherington.
Oh, poor Bob Nutting.
Oh, poor Pittsburgh Pirates.
They created this.
But the realization is, because of what they created, they were dealt this hand this offseason.
Ty?
No, I'm glad that Carter brought that up there.
Because it is a bed that they made.
The reason that they had to go do all these things right now is because they did nothing the last few offseasons.
And they didn't develop well enough.
They missed on too many drafts.
And Ben Cherington missed too often.
That's why they had to go out and acquire so many outside acquisitions.
So, yeah, he's completely right there.
I agree as well.
Like, I like what they've done this offseason.
But, yeah, this is a sins of the past type of deal.
They're trying to make up for what they've screwed up the last six years.
Now, we just got to hope it works and that the Paul Skenes and Konnor Griffin draft picks are good enough to dance around the other issues they've made or that they've created.
And I know Connor hasn't proven anything yet.
But we all know the hype around him.
And it's wild that, this team could have, if Konnor Griffin lives up to even close to the hype, even just close to it, and Paul Skenes on the team together.
like, I go back and think about the 2013 to 15 teams.
And the reason I do is because there are a lot of similarities to some level.
those teams are built off of pitching.
Never do they have, like, an offense that's going to blow you away.
Oftentimes or not, it was, like, in the bottom half.
It was just good.
Now, it was never at the bottom, right?
It's still trending towards the middle.
But it wasn't like they were blowing you off, because of their offense.
Like, this is a team that was built off of pitching.
And the offense was just good enough to get by.
And I feel like that's what the Pirates have emulated right now.
the bullpen isn't anywhere near what it was back then.
the bullpen was dominant then.
So that's a big difference.
But we understand what the pitching is.
We understand what the offense is.
They've done enough to get them close to league average, I feel.
So, like, with that said, they had Cutch back then.
And that's a big difference.
Like, they had the MVP of the league on their team.
But, like, this is also a team that might have, as we're mentioning, Konnor Griffin.
And if he's close to what he is, not right away.
But, like, this is a guy who might be contending for MVP also.
So you're talking about, like, maybe one of the best infielders in baseball and the best pitcher in baseball, all on the same team.
And, yeah, that makes a huge difference.
For sure.
And I think Jim's raising his hand because he wants to talk.
I think he needs to take himself off of you.
What's up, guys?
Hey.
Hi, Jim.
Hey, long-time listener, first-time caller.
Tyler, can you repeat what you said about Kyle Schwarber?
Probably not.
You said something along the lines of you're actually happy they didn't get Schwarber.
And what I meant by that there, Jim, was that with the resources they spent, I'm glad $25 million of it didn't go to Kyle Schwarber, and then they had to fill it up with the rest.
I would have loved Kyle Schwarber, of course, what they spent.
The allocation of that would have been a little tough.
That's one of the dumbest things you've ever said.
Yeah, I don't think so.
Dude, who cares what you do with the rest of the money?
It's Kyle Schwarber.
You have Kyle Schwarber.
Like, it's $25 million.
That's twice as much as what they spent on Marcell Ozuna.
And he's twice the player that he is.
You wouldn't have had to have gone out there and even gotten Ryan O'Hearn.
You could have gotten out there and signed Mike Tauchman or whatever because you just signed Kyle freaking Schwarber.
So, no, I don't think it would.
Being afraid of what they would have done with the other resources had they signed Kyle Schwarber is crazy talk.
Crazy talk.
So, one, bad take, Tyler.
Two, also, another bad take.
Gregory Soto is the second best reliever on this team right now.
Okay.
Good for him.
I don't think you could have gone into spring training with Mason Montgomery and Evan Sisk as your left-handed relievers.
you were like, ERAs and the fours, but better FIPS.
Like, dude, his numbers are good.
Like, you look at the underlying numbers, which is how you measure relievers.
It's small sample sizes.
You can't really go by ERA.
You got to go by the other stuff.
And by all accounts, Gregory Soto still has every bit the good stuff that he had when he was putting together All-Star season.
So, I'm happy with the Soto signing.
I think if you gave Ben Cherington troop serum, he'd say he's happy with the Soto signing.
And, yeah, I wouldn't want to go into the offseason with Sisk and Montgomery.
And if you needed to add another lefty who wasn't as good as Soto, we wouldn't be in as good of a situation here.
So, I just wanted to come on here and yell at you for a little bit because we'd gone, like, 30 minutes with no one else talking.
So, shout-out, Carter.
It's been the best part of the show so far.
We need more people talking on this outside DiNardo and Tyler.
Get some other voices.
I'll hang up and listen.
Yeah, I'm glad you did because one thing I want to say, these front office apologists.
That was so.
People like them will never make it in the podcast game.
So, I hope this guy never intends on starting a podcast.
Yeah, we're talking about a reliever.
Like, he's allowing over a base runner an inning.
He allows someone on base every time he is in the game.
More often than not, some moms, too.
Because he walks so many damn people.
Not consistent.
He's never going to be a back-end guy, a reliable back-end guy, because he's not consistent enough.
And he's not.
He never has been.
Well, he has.
He was better with the Tigers.
But the last three years, he has not been that guy.
We have another request there, Tyler.
I love how Jim just triggered you, because I wanted to make sure we were clear.
You like Soto as the player, just the allocation of the funds.
You said yes.
And now Jim's triggered you enough that now you're just shitting all over Soto.
Yeah, I have to.
Because we're talking about a guy.
We're talking about a guy.
This is why Jim's an evil person.
He has not been that good since 2022, because he allows too many base runners, and he's inconsistent.
He walks too many people.
That's it.
They've got enough of those dudes, and I don't want to spend $7.5 million on them.
Well, they're going to give him the Ray Sears treatment this year.
Yeah, he might be a fine seventh inning guy.
I don't want to spend $7.5 on it.
Anyhow.
Anywho.
Kenyon wants to speak.
What's going on, Kenyon?
Let me make sure I can do this correctly.
Tyler's fired up.
This week one with Tyler and Jim in the same house is going to be something now.
Kenyon, what's going on, my friend?
Hey, guys.
I might sound like the other quarter that just popped on, but that's actually my twin brother.
I'm not even.
Oh, nice.
Oh.
Not joking.
I was one of the main guys that did the whole protest and stuff like that.
Our team, not his type shit that happened last year and stuff like that.
But I'm just here to say that I'm happy to see, even though I hate the owner and stuff like that, I'm happy to see that the Pirates are going to be competitive this year.
I only went to three games last year.
It was opening day whenever me and my group got that plane and banner and got everybody to go, I got that plane and banner and then the whole sell the team chance on opening day
and stuff like that.
I was there.
And then I was there for the last game of the season and stuff like that.
I'm definitely excited to come out and support the Pirates again.
Not changing my side.
I still hate Bob Nutting to the death and stuff like that.
I'm honestly happy the lockout's coming and I'm happy that the salary cap and floor is going to make Bob Nutting spend the money that he definitely does have to spend.
So, I'm excited.
Let me ask you something.
I think it's a fair question.
Because with what you've done, you and your group have accomplished, there's been a lot of discourse around that as well.
is this detrimental to the team and what they're doing or is this going to send a message?
And I think it's clear to look, the attendance was down last year.
So, there was certainly a thought that payroll might not even reach the $93 million it was at last year.
Like, it could go down.
that would be what they typically do.
That would be align themselves on how they operate their payroll.
Now, it's only $10 million.
It's only $103 million now.
We're not talking about they just blew the glass off the ceiling here.
And blew through it.
But they spent more.
So, I want to ask you, do you think what you guys have done, and you're hearing the sell the team chants around the stadium often, do you think that message was received by Bob Nutting this year?
I'm too humble to ever admit that my group or anything about that was the reason that happened.
There's only, like, 10 actual people that are staying in constant contact with each other.
Well, and just expand it from this, you guys personally and that individual group, but just collectively, as a lot of fans were in Pittsburgh, do you think this was more like, hey, message received with Bob Nutting?
Well, if I'm being 100% honest, no, because if you look at the payroll that we had in 2013, 14, 15, it was higher.
And then adjusting for inflation in this year, no.
It's like $100 million now is definitely not as much as what $120 million or whatever the highest payroll was in 2015.
It's not comparable.
It's like, it looks good on a chart and stuff like that, $100 million, but it's definitely not worth as much as what it was back 10 years ago.
Yeah.
My bank account says so, too.
Yeah, same, man.
No, I...
Well, appreciate it.
Appreciate it.
Yeah.
I appreciate you there, Canyon.
Keep doing what you're doing, man.
we got to do what we can here.
Hey, man, I'm always...
Me and my group are always thinking of new things.
We were the guys who did it during the Pitt game, Notre Dame, stuff like that.
We're always thinking of shit to do.
We were the guys that, like, that one famous video of Bob Nutting getting yelled at on the rotunda.
That was us.
We're always thinking of shit to do.
Every day, we're coming up with new things.
Appreciate the call here.
Yeah, thanks, guys.
I appreciate you coming on, but I'll leave you with this.
It's not Bob Nutting who feels the pressure of us.
It's his family that feels the pressure.
I know that for certain.
I'll leave you guys with that.
I appreciate you guys having me on.
I appreciate all you guys do.
Thank you, guys.
Yeah.
Canyon, Carter, appreciate you both coming on.
The twins.
The twins.
We got a special guest here.
Waiting on her to load up.
I think it is.
I think Greg has to just unmute himself.
Well, there was another one coming in.
Hey, guys.
You had me on speaker.
There's Greg.
There he is.
What's going on, Greg?
Hey, guys.
You had me on speaker with the last guy, so I left my mic on mute.
I didn't want to.
I appreciate you.
We're still working through this whole spaces concept.
Oh, yeah.
Oh, yeah.
I completely understand.
I wasn't really going to come on tonight, but because I think a lot of people are not going to like my opinion about this.
But I think Ryan O'Hearn, I wouldn't have done the Ryan O'Hearn deal.
I would have definitely allocated that money towards the third base.
I don't know.
That's my thing.
Like, the third base was the biggest hole.
I think O'Hearn is definitely better than Cutch.
That would have been her.
I appreciate that take, Greg.
I believe at the time.
I do appreciate that take.
It's a little different.
When they signed O'Hearn.
It's something that I think.
we're going to see what happens with it, obviously.
But that's something in the back of my head, too.
like O'Hearn, I like him a lot.
Positionally, it's a weird fit here.
Like, there's a lot of weird fits here.
Exactly.
Exactly.
And I agree with you on Gregory Smith.
I wouldn't have been giving him seven and a half million.
There's no way.
I think Jim jumping on there criticizing.
I don't agree with Jim there.
So, what you're saying is Jim is just full of terrible things.
I wouldn't have done it.
No, not always.
No, definitely not.
I think Jim got a lot of good opinions.
But I think he just messing with Tyler, that's all.
Well, he's wrong.
But, Greg, we do appreciate you here.
I appreciate you having my back here.
Even after last week when you jumped back on, I was like, I didn't just listen because of Tyler.
Well, no, that's the way I made it sound, though.
you're just how I found North Shore Nine.
That's basically what I was trying to say.
See, here we go again, Greg.
What the heck?
No, you're my boy, Tyler.
You're definitely my boy.
I'm sure we have a few more here.
I would have used the O'Hearn money, and I would have got a – What would you have done with the O'Hearn money?
Sorry.
Sorry, guys.
I would have got a third baseman with it.
I would have definitely – I would have offered Okamoto definitely more.
I think he was the missing piece.
I could do without Ahimeo Suarez.
I'd rather have Azuma than Suarez, honestly.
But I would have used that O'Hearn money and got a third baseman and signed him for, 40 or something for sure.
Yeah, I think that's a fair point.
But I'll let you guys go.
Well, Greg, as always, we appreciate you.
Even if you like Tyler, but, hate more on Jim because that's the correct take.
I'll allow Tyler Love as long as you hate on Jim.
No, I appreciate Greg too much.
He's the best.
All right, we got Bucko Mike in here as well, and then we got another one after that, but let's get Bucko Mike in.
As soon as he unmutes himself, there he is.
Hello?
What's going on, Bucko Mike?
Yeah, not too much.
Jim's takes are terrible as normal.
They – them trying to sign Schwarber and then have allocated another $15 million towards other people, they wouldn't have been able to fill all the holes that they needed to fill this offseason like they did.
Soto, Gregory Soto was – I agree with you, Tyler, on this one.
He's not really that good of a signing.
They spent 8% of their total payroll on Gregory Soto, which watching AL Central Baseball like I have over the last 20 years or so.
Because you're not really a Guardians fan.
We are really aware.
That's pretty much all I have.
Oh, one other thing, Tyler.
I did hear some rumors about you, some sources that you were – got busted in Brayden for picking up some Ukraine booty.
I don't know if there's any – what the truth behind this was, but it was reported by a Tony DiNardo that you got busted for picking up a woman without her green card.
I hate this man so much.
You need to let us know about that.
So, thank you.
Appreciate you, Mike.
You're the best.
Bucko Mike got shooters everywhere.
He does.
He's got sources everywhere.
That's why he's the man.
What is wrong with this guy?
You know what?
All I heard was I agree with Tyler.
I disagree with Jim.
Good points there.
We got Alexander in here as well.
Wants to share his thoughts.
It does take a little while for X to load in spaces, as I've learned.
But, hey, a couple people back-to-back that agree with Tyler and call Jim dumb.
It's a good day.
I can't wait for an instant tomorrow.
Can't be mad.
Can't be mad at all.
I feel bad for Doug having to pick up such a loser at the airport, bringing him to the Airbnb.
Yeah.
It was supposed to be me and Doug here tonight.
It's going to be an awkward conversation with Doug and Jim.
Someone so beloved by the people, and then someone so hated and wrong.
Yep.
Did we get Alexander on?
I don't know what's happening with spaces.
He was accepted, but there we go.
What's going on, Alexander?
Pretty good.
I'm the guy from Washington State.
I remember.
What's going on?
Yeah.
Not too much.
I'm listening.
And all these scenarios that you came up with, they've already happened.
And I think it's just dwelling on what we did wrong.
And I think every team has that issue.
hindsight, like you said, is 20-20.
But what do we have now?
We have maybe everybody's talking about Jared Triola.
Nobody's talking about Jared Triola.
Everybody's talking about feeling third base.
Have we ever, has he ever been told you are our third baseman?
because it seems like whenever he gets consistent playing time, he does well.
When he bounces around is when he doesn't hit.
Do you agree with that?
So I do.
I actually do.
I said it a couple shows ago.
On that message.
I did say it a couple shows ago that I was curious what would happen if you put Jared Triola at third base every day and just see what happens.
The problem is that I don't know if the Pirates are in that situation where they can allow that to happen.
Because if he struggles, they're in trouble.
If he hits like he did early last year or the year before that, hell, even the beginning of his rookie year, they're in trouble.
Yeah, but you could say that about any play.
You could say that about a lot of players.
Ozuna's a question mark because last year wasn't that great.
I keep on telling myself, well, it's because of his hip.
And so now that his hip is supposedly OK, nobody's spoken.
Is he 100 percent?
He passed the physical.
Is he doing all right?
I'd assume so.
I don't.
I don't know.
Yeah, we don't know.
Yeah, exactly.
Obviously, he's 35 years old.
There's some there's definitely some risk there.
Yeah.
But we're talking about we are only two years from removed from him being in fourth place of an NL MVP.
It's been a while since I've had a guy like that as a D.A.
also, by the way, which that says something.
Right.
I am actually optimistic about this year, which scares me.
So I'm just saying.
But, I really think that Triolo, I'm sure he's hearing all this negativity that's actually towards him.
We need a third baseman.
We need a third baseman.
And I'm sure he doesn't hang around social media.
Like all the time, because it probably I think it would be very depressing if I was in his position to know that nobody wants me and I was talking about replacing me.
I could use that as a motivational tool.
And I guess he can.
he's.
I think he'll do fine.
I really do.
I think.
He'll probably be right.
If he gets around 700 OPS, that would be awesome.
And I agree.
He's around 700.
Yeah, I do, too.
For sure.
we've been talking for how long, like if Ke'Bryan Hayes could just be league average.
How valuable that is.
So what you're really describing is that if you have a 500 OPS now, the defense isn't as good as a Ke'Bryan Hayes, but it's still very good.
if he's going to have like a 700 OPS, you're talking about a three word player.
easily and again, like a 700 OPS does not hurt you.
that was that 700 OPS is good for a third best last year.
Basically, like that's not going to hurt the team and a glove helps you, so like we're worried about what Jared Cholo is if the glove with the offense that people are undecided on what that will bring if it's going to be first half
2025, Jared Cholo, is he going to hurt you even with that glove?
So yeah, you could get a 700 OPS.
Like, I'll take that all day.
I think the problem is, do you trust that's going to happen?
And like to Tyler's point, are they in the situation to, can they afford that?
the whole, regular playing time at third base, I do think there's something to that, right?
But I think that also he can get more or less regular playing time as a super utility, especially with his team.
You talk about Marcelo Zuno being 35 years old after a hip injury.
Even though he's a DH, probably going to get some days off.
Bryan Reynolds, probably going to get off the field some, Brandon Lowe, right?
He has an injury history.
You want to probably get him off the field sometimes.
So like, I feel like there is opportunity to have Jared Cholo play probably four times a week easily being that utility guy.
And to me, that's why I really like him in that role because he has such a good glove.
He can play it all around that him there is going to be much better than like a Nick Gonzales coming into play and whatnot.
But what I also want to add here, and it's funny because like Fort mentioned this, I feel like every time he comes on, but it's like people knowing the role.
And I think that's a good point.
Did I think that's my, that's what it would combat you with.
It's not so much getting regular playing time.
It's knowing what you are going to do, knowing what's expected of you.
And right now he knows he's going to be a third baseman and he's expected that like the everyday guy.
But like, maybe if he also knew, like you are going to be the super utility guy, he can go out there and do that role.
And succeed in it.
Whereas last year, like, I don't know what you're going to be.
You might be our second baseman.
You might be the utility guy.
You might be the third baseman.
it was like, he had a different role at the time and it wasn't until he got the third base role.
It's like, okay, now I know what I'm doing every day.
And maybe that's also why he succeeded.
Because he also played really well in 2023, right?
Or was that true?
And he was essentially like a utility guy.
Whatever you agree.
Yeah.
And I wonder, I guess also what matters is your state of mind.
And the state of mind last year couldn't have been good for the entire team.
And so they gave up.
In a sense, they did.
And so the hitting went down.
Now, everybody's really, I know it's spring training, but it's legitimately, the hopes are high, legitimately.
Having said that's contagious as far as hitting.
I'm looking at it from psychologically, it's got to help.
Players like Triolo, heck.
And having Ozuna with Cruz is a positive.
And Reynolds is Reynolds.
I think he would have done, I don't think he's affected as badly, as much as that.
But, yeah, state of mind, that's all.
Yeah.
I appreciate you there, Alexander.
A lot of good points, I think, as well.
And you also agreed with me a good bit.
So I appreciate that.
Yep.
Not confrontational.
That's me.
Hey, thanks for jumping on, man.
Thank you very much.
Thanks for both.
Appreciate it.
Lots of good thoughts.
Now, I do agree with a lot of what you just said.
Absolutely.
They do.
And, again, that's why I do feel, there is something to it.
And, again, like, playing every day, I think, can't help them.
But I think also what goes into that is, like, knowing what your role is.
And, obviously, right now, I'm the third baseman, so that helps.
I did want to just play this.
And you guys need to keep believing.
I think that's what he's saying here, also, is, like, they just got to believe.
And I think this is one thing that also is important.
this is, like, the first offseason.
I feel like the teams can, together, believe and have hope.
Like, actually, when I look to my left, I look to my right.
Like, we can do this.
I actually believe we can do it.
This isn't, like, hey, it's a new season, and, everyone has hope at the beginning of the year.
And then it's a lot of not treating these guys like robots.
But we have another call here.
Southside, Stan.
It'll probably take me about 20 minutes to figure out how to work Twitter spaces because it takes forever to get through here.
Stan, there we are.
What's going on, Stan?
Hey, just something.
I love this show and stuff.
But just looking at the whole offseason, it seems to me that there was something that was supposed to happen between the Lowe, O'Hearn, Soto acquisitions, and then Ozuna out of nowhere.
The easiest signing for this franchise to make this offseason was for cuts for one year, $5 million, fill that DA spot here and there.
Whether it's playing right field, once a week, anything like that.
What do you think that move that didn't happen was?
Was it a Beatty, Vientes, a Royce Lewis trade that just never happened?
And I think it just highlights this offseason why Ben Cherington shouldn't be the GM of the Pittsburgh Pirates at this point.
He turned the worst offense into the worst defensive outfield that we will see in the last 10 years.
I'll say this, that second part's fair.
I think if we're looking at whatever move it was, I feel like it was almost the Okamoto one.
I think that was the guy they targeted in.
And I don't think that one worked out.
They pivoted to Suarez.
He didn't want to come here.
And then I think they had to make a move to just get one more bat.
And I think that's where Ozuna came in.
I know that based on nothing.
That's just the way it feels like that's the way it worked out.
Yeah, it just feels like there was something that was supposed to happen between the desperation of signing a 35-year-old coming off his worst season in, what, four or five years?
Since COVID, who's aging, just made no sense to me, especially when you have cuts in your back pocket for half that price.
Yeah.
Yeah.
I don't know if I can pinpoint this was the thing they're waiting on, but I think I agree with Tyler.
It was just like a plethora of stuff, and nothing came to fruition.
And, I was like, Jim mentioned it on our Bucco Brew, when you really look at the free agent market, like, there's really nothing out there.
Because we're, like, hyper-focused on third base, really.
But there's this one guy, it's not a good fit, though.
But, like, as far as a hitter goes, like, Marcelo Ozuna's out there.
He's the best hitter.
He's, like, the only guy that's an actual difference maker if you're going to look into free agency, right?
And I guess that's where, like, as you mentioned, desperation to some sense where Ben Cherington turned to.
It was, like, this is the only guy that's out here that we can add.
And, again, like, it's not a perfect fit.
you mentioned about the offense.
I'm sorry, the defense in the outfield is probably the best.
Jeez.
The worst.
Okay, let me start fresh.
The defense in the outfield is going to be the worst we've seen in a decade.
And I think that's true.
And that's not just, like, such a slight.
there's been good defenders in the outfield for 10 years.
But, oh, no, Cruz, I'm not sure where he's going to be.
Reynolds is, he had a terrible year at left field two years ago.
Right field was fine, I guess, last year.
O'Hearn's going to be, like, a mainstay.
So, like, yeah, it's probably going to be one of the worst outfielders that we've seen.
But at the end of the day, I don't hate what they've done.
And, again, going back to, like, what Carter was talking about, like, they made their bed.
I understand that.
They're laying in it.
But this is what they're dealt with.
Like, if they're missing out of Okamoto and they're missing out, if those were the pieces, well, they're missing out on them because they had better options.
Like, don't you want to go to the World Series winner last year in Toronto?
And probably remarkable there.
like, there's just a lot of things that line up on other teams going against the Pirates.
So, yeah, that's what they're left with.
And it's like, all right, let's pivot to Marcell Ozuna now.
Yeah, that's the way – that's the read I get out of it based on really nothing.
But just watching it happen, it feels like they just missed on enough guys where they felt like they had to get one more bat.
Comments· 1
Was Gregory Soto worth $7.5 million of the Pirates' $103 million payroll?