◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
On the latest OffBeat, Alex Stumpf breaks down one of the biggest unanswered questions on the Pirates roster: catcher. He looks at the upside and risk tied to Henry Davis, Endy Rodriguez, and Rafael Flores, while making the case that Joey Bart may be the one steady presence in a room filled with uncertainty. It’s a look at a position that could either become a real strength or remain a major problem for Pittsburgh in 2026.
Watch and listen now on North Shore Nine.
Comments· 0
The Debate
Should the Pirates have added a catcher this winter instead of banking on Joey Bart and three wild cards?
From Alex Stumpf’s take on the show
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.
With Alex Stumpf.
Chapters
Key takeaways
1
Henry Davis's problem isn't something force plates can fix. Stumpf cites scouts who say it's his swing path: he gets the bat head out so far in front that most of his hard contact gets pulled down the line.
Alex Stumpf
2
If Henry Davis could post even a .700 OPS, his defense, game-calling and clubhouse presence would make him the everyday catcher. There'd be no debate.
Alex Stumpf
3
Bart wasn't traded this winter, even though teams were interested, because the Pirates needed 'an adult in the room.' His worst case is still a big-league catcher, and nobody else in the room can say that.
Alex Stumpf
4
The best-case scenario: Bart stays healthy and starts about 80 games while Davis, Rodríguez or Flores emerges to start the other 80. Bart could also get time at first base or DH.
Alex Stumpf
5
Catcher was one of the team's bigger holes in an offseason that upgraded many other positions. Relying on internal improvement at catcher, center field and third base makes the Pirates' path a lot harder.
He's developed into this really good defensive catcher.
Alex Stumpf
Pitchers love throwing to him.
Alex Stumpf
He receives well.
Alex Stumpf
He calls a good game.
Alex Stumpf
I love the story that was coming out of Bradenton this week.
Alex Stumpf
That, he just kept putting down fastballs for Bubba Chandler and he kept throwing them.
Alex Stumpf
And it worked.
Alex Stumpf
Colin Beasley and Jose Negrón talked about that.
Alex Stumpf
And it was like, yeah, that's what Henry Davis will do.
Alex Stumpf
He knows what, the pitcher needs to do.
Alex Stumpf
What needs to click.
Alex Stumpf
What gets them going.
Alex Stumpf
I really like that.
Alex Stumpf
There's just one glare and hole with Henry's game is he hasn't been able to hit major league pitching.
Alex Stumpf
Consistently.
Alex Stumpf
He talked to Kevin Gorman at the start of spring training about, work with force plates, to dive into his swing more.
Alex Stumpf
I would recommend that story.
Alex Stumpf
But from what I've heard in the past with scouts is it isn't a, force plate issue.
Alex Stumpf
It's a, it's a swing path, just where he gets the head of the bat out.
Alex Stumpf
It's just so far in front that it creates so much, pull side, hard contact.
Alex Stumpf
And that basically all is hard contact is going to go right down the line.
Alex Stumpf
And just think about how many times you've seen a long foul ball from Henry Davis, or even whenever he does straighten it out enough, it's usually down the line, his home runs.
Alex Stumpf
So just coming way off the ball too far.
Alex Stumpf
There's high upside.
Alex Stumpf
There's a decent enough floor for him because of what he brings defensively and as a game caller.
Alex Stumpf
But like, as he stands right now, I don't know if he is someone that you can really count on to give a lot of at bats.
Alex Stumpf
And that stinks because what he does defensively, if he had like a 700 OPS, he would be the everyday catcher on this team.
Alex Stumpf
As far as I'm concerned.
Alex Stumpf
I don't think there's much of a debate there.
Alex Stumpf
What he brings defensively and game calling and in the clubhouse.
Alex Stumpf
It's like, yeah, just be an average hitter.
Alex Stumpf
And this job is yours.
Alex Stumpf
I think that's still achievable.
Alex Stumpf
But I don't think you can count on that right now.
Absolutely set the world on fire in the farm system in 2022.
Alex Stumpf
Came up in 2023.
Alex Stumpf
Wasn't as exciting a year, but showed that he could handle a major league workload.
Alex Stumpf
That he could handle a pitching staff.
Alex Stumpf
That he could do a lot of things that come with being a big leaguer.
Alex Stumpf
Ends up needing elbow surgery.
Alex Stumpf
Misses all of 2024.
Alex Stumpf
Comes back last year.
Alex Stumpf
Only limited to a handful of games because, again, he needed elbow surgery.
Alex Stumpf
So, he is as big a wild card as anyone on this 40-man roster.
Alex Stumpf
Because we know the upside he has.
Alex Stumpf
Can't he just stay on the field?
Alex Stumpf
Now, he said at Pirates Fest, how his arm feels good.
Alex Stumpf
and all that good stuff.
Alex Stumpf
And that's good.
Alex Stumpf
In everything that we have seen so far, the arm does look good.
Alex Stumpf
He had a cut stealing, I believe, this past week.
Alex Stumpf
Where the ball didn't even, the guy at second didn't even have to put the glove down.
Alex Stumpf
Like, it was just perfectly spotted.
Alex Stumpf
Or, actually, it was whenever I was there two weeks ago.
Alex Stumpf
Time flies.
Alex Stumpf
Yeah, but, like, he has that high upside.
Alex Stumpf
We know he could be a potentially plus hitter.
Alex Stumpf
But we've pretty much seen him miss two years of development, potentially.
Alex Stumpf
And he just hasn't stayed healthy.
Alex Stumpf
So, I don't know how many eggs you could put in that basket.
Alex Stumpf
Rafael Flores did a lot of things right last year.
Alex Stumpf
Did a lot of things right this offseason.
Alex Stumpf
Spent a lot of extra time at Pirate City to better know these new pitchers in the system.
Alex Stumpf
He is a top 10 prospect.
Alex Stumpf
He was the headliner in the David Bednar trade with the Yankees.
Alex Stumpf
And basically, everything I heard from, league sources was like, if anyone in that trade is going to pan out, it is going to be him.
Alex Stumpf
High pedigree.
Alex Stumpf
Potential.
Alex Stumpf
He does a lot of things that you want him to do with the pitching staff.
Alex Stumpf
But it's the wild card of he's a rookie.
Alex Stumpf
And how much can you put into a rookie?
Alex Stumpf
Who's not a top 100 prospect.
Alex Stumpf
Who barely has any experience at the AAA level and the major league level.
Alex Stumpf
How much can you put into that?
Alex Stumpf
So, you have three guys there who...
Alex Stumpf
There is a scenario where all three pan out.
Alex Stumpf
Or at least two of them pan out.
Alex Stumpf
Or hell, even just one of them really pans out.
Alex Stumpf
And the catching room is set.
Alex Stumpf
They have someone who has offensive upside, who manages the game well, who pitchers like throwing to, who do everything that you want a catcher to do.
Alex Stumpf
There is a chance that at some point this year we're going to look at the catcher room and be like, that is a strength of this team.
Alex Stumpf
There's also the potential that none of them pan out.
Alex Stumpf
And they really don't have anything to go with.
Alex Stumpf
Like those three guys, I would say all have high ceilings.
Alex Stumpf
I would say they also have low floors.
Alex Stumpf
Which brings us to Joey Bart.
Alex Stumpf
The guy who, in my opinion, probably has the lowest ceiling, but has the highest floor.
Alex Stumpf
And is the guy who has the pretty much guaranteed roster spot here.
Alex Stumpf
Someone who...
Alex Stumpf
I don't know if Joey Bart is going to set the world on fire.
Alex Stumpf
But you need someone to just be a steady force in that catching room.
Alex Stumpf
And that's Joey Bart right now.
Alex Stumpf
Is that what...
Alex Stumpf
They should have right now, though.
Alex Stumpf
Should they bank on Bart being this big guy like we saw in 2024?
Alex Stumpf
Or is the sub-100 WRC plus hitter that we saw last year more indicative of what we are going to see in 2026?
Alex Stumpf
This episode is brought to you by IQ Bar, our exclusive snack hydration sponsor.
Alex Stumpf
IQ Bar protein bars, IQ Mix hydration mixes, and IQ Joe Mushroom Coffee, of the delicious, low-sugar, brain and body fuel you need to win your day.
Alex Stumpf
The Ultimate Sampler Pack is a great way for you to try all IQ Bar products and flavors.
Alex Stumpf
You get 9 IQ Bars, 8 IQ Mix Sticks, and 4 IQ Joe Sticks.
Alex Stumpf
All IQ Bar products are clean label certified and entirely free from gluten, dairy, soy, GMOs, and artificial ingredients.
Alex Stumpf
With over 20,000 five-star reviews and counting, more people than ever are fueling their lifestyles with IQ Bars' brain and body boosting bars, hydration mixes and mushroom coffees, the Ultimate Sampler Pack includes all three.
Alex Stumpf
My personal favorites so far have been the Almond Butter Chip and the Iced Tea Lemonade Hydration Mix.
Alex Stumpf
It's just really full of flavor.
Alex Stumpf
I love starting my day with it, and I couldn't imagine starting my day with anything else other than IQ Bar products.
Alex Stumpf
Right now, IQ Bar is offering our podcast listeners 20% off all IQ Bar products, including the Ultimate Sampler Pack, plus free shipping.
Alex Stumpf
To get your 20% off, text MLB to 64000.
Alex Stumpf
That's MLB 64000.
Alex Stumpf
Message and data rates may apply.
Alex Stumpf
See terms for details.
Alex Stumpf
So, Joey Bar comes in 2024.
Alex Stumpf
Off the waiver wire, off the scrap heat, has a really good season, hits 13 home runs in 80 games, has a 121 WRC plus.
Alex Stumpf
Last year, OPS drops 100 points.
Alex Stumpf
Yeah, he got on base more, but he wasn't the same impact hitter.
Alex Stumpf
The Pirates needed a little bit of impact from the right side of the lineup.
Alex Stumpf
He didn't provide it.
Alex Stumpf
Now, they have Ozuna now, and they've added O'Hearn and Brandon Lowe, and maybe Reynolds could have a bounce back here.
Alex Stumpf
Maybe Cruz could take a bounce back here.
Alex Stumpf
I don't think there's going to be as much stress on Joey Bar's shoulders, but just what he does defensively, he needs to hit first.
Alex Stumpf
He needs to be a bat-first catcher to be an impact player, in my opinion.
Alex Stumpf
Pitchers can throw into him, he can call a good game, but just the blocking, the throwing, the framing, it just has not graded well in these two years in Pittsburgh.
Alex Stumpf
So he needs to hit more.
Alex Stumpf
So he needs to hit more.
Alex Stumpf
What was different?
Alex Stumpf
I'm going to give a little love here to Davey Andrews of FanGraphs, who wrote an article in November, which looked at how Bart moved off the plate a little bit.
Alex Stumpf
And then he did this weird inverse where most of his damage in 2024, especially slug, was on the outside part of the plate.
Alex Stumpf
So he moves a couple inches off the plate.
Alex Stumpf
He handles inside pitches better, but then struggles on the outside, comparatively speaking.
Alex Stumpf
So it's like, was that the right call?
Alex Stumpf
But I think it goes a little further than what Davey said.
Alex Stumpf
Bart shortened his swing in 2025.
Alex Stumpf
It had a lower tilt, a different attack angle.
Alex Stumpf
It generated a little less speed.
Alex Stumpf
Now, none of this was, eye, the cartoon, the eyes come out of the skull like, wow, that's completely different.
Alex Stumpf
But it's a lot of little things that added up to this wasn't the same impact hitter that he was in 2025 or in 2024.
Alex Stumpf
And they need him to be an impact hitter because there's not a lot of damage on the right side of the lineup once you get past Reynolds as a switch hitter and Ozuna.
Alex Stumpf
Can he do that?
Alex Stumpf
I think there is still a higher level of upside offensively for Joey Bart.
Alex Stumpf
I don't know if that means moving back in.
Alex Stumpf
I don't know if that means reevaluating the swing, but like he could make an influence as a hitter.
Alex Stumpf
Can make that impact.
Alex Stumpf
He does a lot of things well.
Alex Stumpf
Like he's been more patient at the plate.
Alex Stumpf
He's taking less first pitch strikes.
Alex Stumpf
He knows the zone better and he's attacking in the zone more.
Alex Stumpf
Like these are things that you want from a strong hitter.
Alex Stumpf
All the tools are here.
Alex Stumpf
I'm just trying to see how this guy went from hitting 13 home runs in half a season to hitting four.
Alex Stumpf
Like I had that image of Homer waking up Bart, every time he hit a home run.
Alex Stumpf
And I genuinely lost it in 2025.
Alex Stumpf
Like which folder did I put this in?
Alex Stumpf
Like that was a bit surprising to me that it took so long between home runs for him last year.
Alex Stumpf
I think most of his slug is going to be on the outer part of the plate.
Alex Stumpf
How does he tap into that?
Alex Stumpf
Is it moving closer to the plate again?
Alex Stumpf
Is it trying to re-lengthen that swing, those extra couple inches that he lost last year?
Alex Stumpf
There are a couple different ways they could go about it.
Alex Stumpf
Don't really have a lot of data to pull from in spring training, unfortunately.
Alex Stumpf
So this is still more hypothetical at this time on what he ends up doing.
Alex Stumpf
But like I see the upside here.
Alex Stumpf
And that's good because he's really the only catcher in this room right now that I'm like, yeah, he can start.
Alex Stumpf
He is maybe not the most exciting catcher in the division.
Alex Stumpf
Actually, in a division with William Contreras, I don't know if it was even really a conversation.
Alex Stumpf
But the Pirates need him to be a hitter.
Alex Stumpf
They need him to be a stabilizing force in a catcher room that has three wild cards in it right now.
Alex Stumpf
That's why Bart wasn't traded this winter, even though I heard interest from teams this winter.
Alex Stumpf
The Pirates needed an adult in the room.
Alex Stumpf
They needed someone that they, like, you know what, his floor, his worst case scenario is still a big league catcher.
Alex Stumpf
Where I don't know if you can really say that with anyone else right now.
Alex Stumpf
Like, Henry Davis' worst case scenario is like what we saw in 2024.
Alex Stumpf
Whenever he just couldn't hit and he was optioned and he, that was just a really rough year.
Alex Stumpf
Endy's worst case scenario is what we've seen the last two years.
Alex Stumpf
He just can't stay on the field.
Alex Stumpf
He can't throw.
Alex Stumpf
He can't do what you want.
Alex Stumpf
Like, so far this camp, we have seen him throw.
Alex Stumpf
We have seen him do everything.
Alex Stumpf
But whenever you have back-to-back surgeries, your red flag's got to be up.
Alex Stumpf
The number one predictor of future injuries is past injuries.
Alex Stumpf
Flores, it's the most boring analysis I have here.
Alex Stumpf
He's young.
Alex Stumpf
He's just a wild card right now.
Alex Stumpf
He is just a prospect.
Alex Stumpf
Could be good.
Alex Stumpf
Could be good.
Alex Stumpf
We don't know for now.
Alex Stumpf
Bart, I could see him.
Alex Stumpf
If he is in a position where he just starts 80 games again, he stays healthy, he starts 80 games, and one of those other guys emerges and starts 80 games, I think that's the best case scenario for this team.
Alex Stumpf
And that doesn't mean, okay, then you kick out Bart.
Alex Stumpf
No, there are other ways you can use him.
Alex Stumpf
I saw him taking some first base drills down in Bradenton.
Alex Stumpf
There's really not an answer at DHB on this year.
Alex Stumpf
So there are ways he can make an impact in 2026 and in 2027.
Alex Stumpf
But he has to show that he can impact the baseball, especially on those outer pitches again.
Alex Stumpf
If he's able to do that and he's able to tap into his offensive upside, then yeah, the whole catcher room, I think, does a lot better this year than what we saw in 2025.
Alex Stumpf
If he doesn't, I don't know how much this room improves.
Alex Stumpf
And this is an offseason where so many offensive positions were improved.
Alex Stumpf
And this was one of the bigger holes on the team.
Alex Stumpf
Not saying that the Pirates need a ton of offensive contributions from catcher, the path gets a whole lot harder if you're not going to get impact players from those positions
Alex Stumpf
that you just hope for internal improvement, like center field with Oneil Cruz, like catcher, like third base.
Alex Stumpf
So we're going to see what happens here.
Alex Stumpf
I think Bart has shown that he deserves this opportunity again.
Alex Stumpf
And we're going to see what happens with the other trio if someone can emerge there.
Alex Stumpf
Because Pirates need two catchers.
Alex Stumpf
And at this moment, there's only one that I feel pretty confident about.
Alex Stumpf
And even then, I need to see more from him in 2026.
Alex Stumpf
I think he would say that he want to do more in 2026 offensively too.
Alex Stumpf
Thank you so much for listening to OffBeat here on North Shore Nine presented by FanDuel.
Alex Stumpf
This is a 15-minute podcast.
Alex Stumpf
We do it every single weekday.
Alex Stumpf
I will see you all Tuesday.
Alex Stumpf
All right, that wraps up this episode of North Shore Nine.
Alex Stumpf
Thanks so much for tuning in.
Alex Stumpf
Whether you're listening on the podcast or catching us on YouTube, if you enjoyed the show, please give this video a thumbs up.
Alex Stumpf
And don't forget to hit that subscribe button if you haven't already.
Alex Stumpf
It really helps us grow.
Alex Stumpf
And if you're listening on the podcast, a quick review goes a long way in helping others find the show.
Alex Stumpf
Plus, be sure to tell a friend about us.
Alex Stumpf
There's always room for more here in the NS9 community.
Alex Stumpf
And for those looking to support us a little more, consider joining our Patreon, become an MVP member, and get exclusive perks while helping us continue to bring you more of the Pirates content you love.
Alex Stumpf
Thanks again for all your support, and Let's Go Bucs.
Comments· 0
Should the Pirates have added a catcher this winter instead of banking on Joey Bart and three wild cards?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.