◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)◆NEWSPirates, Chas McCormick Agree To Minor League Deal
◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)◆NEWSPirates, Chas McCormick Agree To Minor League Deal
On this episode of Bucs on Deck, Jim Rosati and Anthony Murphy break down why Pirates pitching prospect Carlos Castillo is a name worth knowing. The two discuss Castillo’s pitch mix, advanced feel to pitch, encouraging start in Greensboro, and the key question that could shape his future: whether more fastball velocity is coming.
If you want a deeper look at one of the more under-the-radar arms in the system, watch or listen to the full episode now.
Comments· 0
The Debate
Will Carlos Castillo add enough fastball velocity to be a starter, or end up a middle reliever?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.
With Jim Rosati and Anthony Murphy.
Chapters
Key takeaways
1
Castillo's low-90s fastball isn't good enough yet. He missed his spots and walked hitters with it, and he'll need a better heater as he climbs the system.
2
Fastball velocity decides his future: if Castillo stays at 91–93 mph, you're probably looking at a middle reliever.
3
A right-handed starter can't live at 91–92 nowadays without pinpoint command and devastating breaking stuff, so Castillo has to add ticks to the fastball this year.
4
Castillo got 15 whiffs in the start Murphy saw, even with shaky control. If he's missing bats now with below-top-prospect stuff, imagine what he does if the stuff catches up.
5
Castillo's slider has an easy chance to be an above-average or better pitch, and his changeup projects to at least average.
What is going on, everybody? Welcome to the North Shore Nine podcast presented by FanDuel. This is Bucs On Deck. It's our third installment of this. I'm Jim. Joining me from a hotel room in Greensboro is Anthony Murphy from Bucs On Deck. Murphy, how you doing?
Doing good, man. Doing good. Out here watching some baseball all week. Can't go wrong there, right?
Checking out the Greensboro Grasshoppers, which is outstanding timing because the subject of today's show is right-handed pitcher Carlos Castillo.
It's one of those guys where I feel like, personally, I don't know a whole lot about him. He doesn't really show up on top 30 prospect lists.
He doesn't, if you go on fan graphs, I think he's listed as one of the other guys to watch.
You guys have him in your tier 6 ranking, but he's 20 years old.
He had a really nice season in Bradenton last year at age 19, and he's just progressing.
He just turned 20, and you think of it, a 20-year-old who's now in high A ball.
He's on a nice track, and so we're going to talk about him today.
What is there to like about him?
What is there that's maybe some things that he still obviously needs to work on?
But yeah, let's dive into this.
So Carlos Castillo, Murphy, let's just give a quick 60-second, 90-second elevator pitch on who this guy is.
So right-handed pitcher, signed part of an international class, got a pretty good size bonus.
Just under the radar, most of his thing is all about projectability right now.
There's still – it's not really what you're seeing now.
It's what you think you can see in the future.
It's got a three-pitch mix.
I've really loved the slider.
Already showing a feel for the change-up.
Two different fastballs it shows sometimes, like a four-seamer and a sinker.
Really likes the sinker.
Just a guy who like – he's young, but he's shown some ability to like pitchability early on that you're just hoping for this stuff to take a step forward.
Well, you talk about just how young he is, and he does seem pretty advanced for his age.
He was playing in the Complex League in 2024.
That was when he came over stateside.
Pitched pretty well there.
Got a taste of full-season ball with Bradenton at the end of that season at age 18.
Spent pretty much the entirety of last year in Bradenton.
I think he had one relief appearance in Greensboro towards the end of the year, but he spent pretty much the entire year in Bradenton.
He made 20 starts, 3.84 earned run average.
Got a ton of strikeouts, but pretty decent walk rate.
And I think with him, he's now two starts into his season in Greensboro.
Listen, you got to see him firsthand on Thursday night.
He made his second start of the year.
I went back.
I watched his first start of the year.
I think he threw four shutout innings his first start.
And, the things that stuck out to me was pretty good feel of the breaking stuff.
He's got a slider.
It's pretty tight.
But when he locates it's a really good pitch.
The thing that stood out for me, though, was just like consistency with the fastball.
It's not that great.
It's like low 90s.
He wasn't really hitting his spots with it.
He was a little wild with it.
Had some walks.
And I think that's something where, as he moves up in the system, he's going to have to get a better fastball.
That was my take.
So I'm interested to see what you saw from him in person on Thursday night.
Yeah, I think the fastball velocity is going to set him apart of where he projects.
he can probably, if he sticks in like the 91, 92, 93-ish range, it's like you're looking at probably like a middle reliever with that.
it's a good enough slider.
It's foul.
Yeah.
Yeah.
So you're hoping that the fastball starts to play up a little more.
Like you said, he's super young.
There's still plenty of time to add more.
He has a good frame that I feel like could add some muscle, like, within the next couple of years.
So I think that would be key.
But like you said, like the command was off a little bit on Thursday when I watched him.
But like he – when he attacks hitters with that slider first, like working backwards, like he – it really sets up like the sinker and stuff like that to maybe not be as much of like a strikeout pitch, but like to generate a lot of weak contact.
He threw a lot of like the sinker in on like righties and got some like pretty weak contact with that.
And then getting ahead early in the count with the slider, even if he doesn't throw too hard, it set up a couple fastballs like up in the zone that he was able to blow by if, hitters.
So he mixes the pitch as well.
He's shown some good – he showed some good – a good field to pitch, which was impressive for his age, which was the thing that drew.
Because I was down in Bradenton there for his stateside debut, and he's a guy that just stuck out there.
I didn't know much about him at the time and just been following along the progress.
And really at this point, it's just like you're just hoping that stuff just ticks up.
Yeah, I was talking with Pirates director of player development, Michael Chernow, and I asked him, for his thoughts on Castillo.
And he said what you just said there, right?
He's a poised 20-year-old who can really pitch, seeing velocity continue to progress as he gets older, feel for the change-up, and can spin a breaking ball with signs of above-average command.
Chernow also went on to say that he has a chance to be an under-the-radar starter prospect if we see the velocity continue to creep up.
So hand-in-hand with what we're saying there.
There's a good framework here.
Like you mentioned, the pitchability, he did seem like it's a starter's arsenal, right?
Like he's got the pitch mix.
It's just a matter of you got to add some ticks to that fastball.
You can't really be a right-handed starting pitcher and throw 91-92 nowadays unless you just have pinpoint accuracy and just devastating breaking stuff.
Like it just has to be better than that.
And I think those are the things that we need to see Castillo work on this year.
Yeah, definitely.
And I think one of the – it speaks to it too is like you don't see – how many like 19-year-old kids do you see like put up like a near triple digit when it comes to innings pitch?
He threw 95 last year.
So that just speaks to like maybe he doesn't have like overpowering stuff, but he was able to make things work with that – and had a sub-4 ERA to go along with it in low A, which at 19, that's still – I would still consider that young to be pitching at that level, especially pitching like the entire season there.
So that's a good point.
Yeah, you don't see too many 19-year-olds get that close to 100 innings pitched in Bradenton.
And they're in their first season of full season ball.
Yeah.
So let me ask you this.
Like I said, you got to see him in person.
What should – why is it that Pirates fans need to know who this guy is and what should they specifically be looking for whenever they just see his name in box scores and things like that over the course of the season?
Well, I think like the encouraging thing to take from that is like we're talking about like how we need to see like an uptick in the stuff and everything like that.
But he was still able to – like he got 15 whiffs that night that I was there, even with like the control of me.
So he's still figuring out ways to miss bats with stuff that probably is like behind where, most kids and stuff like that are, where like, what you see from like top prospects and stuff like that.
So if he's already able to maneuver and do that stuff now, just imagine what he can do if that stuff catches up to where he's at.
And we all know what the Pirates have been able to do when it comes to like pitching in their system.
So the longer he's in there, if they can work their magic as he keeps moving up there is definitely a kid to at least keep your eye on.
Yeah, so I guess expand upon that a little bit too for me because like I said, it seems like right now, better command, better fastball.
What exactly – again, 20 years old, is there the potential here that he can get that fastball up into like the mid-90s?
I think it's definitely possible.
like I said, the frame definitely points to like him being able to add some muscle and he's still at the age to where like another growth spurt or something like that shouldn't be like out of the question.
So like if he fills out a little bit more, like he has the arm action.
It's a very loose delivery.
Like it's all – he's probably – he's like one of those kids that like in almost a way like you think of like Levi Sterling to where like when he was drafted, like okay, well, maybe down the road.
Like Sterling had a much more projectable frame than Castillo has.
But it's like the same thing too.
It's like he has all the tools that you see that, okay, well, other guys who have done this have been able to increase their velocity like down the road.
So like that leaves the door open that potentially you think that it could happen here.
It looks like sinker, slider, change-up, curveball.
That's pretty much the pitch mix there.
Did you see anything new this past week that stood out as something that you hadn't seen previously?
I didn't really see anything that – make it seem like it was a curveball.
It really just seemed like it was four-seam sinker, slider, change-up.
Okay.
But like I said, the slider, easy I would say is like easy chance for it to be like an above average or better pitch.
The change-up too, I would think it could be somewhere around like at least an average pitch.
Yeah, it looks like just looking at his numbers from last year, he used that change-up almost exclusively against lefties is what you would expect from a right-handed pitcher.
But yeah, you definitely want to – you want to have something if you're a starter to get lefties out.
That's for sure.
Yeah, I did see – he did drop in a couple righty-on-righty change-ups, which I really – like I always like make sure I check that off.
My book is like a little bonus for when I'm watching a pitcher live.
That's always a plus to see.
It just shows to the comfort that he has with the pitch.
Yeah.
Last year, just 3% of his pitches to righties were change-ups.
Yeah.
If he's dropping a few of those, that means he's maybe getting a little more comfortable with it.
Mm-hmm.
Okay.
Well, Carlos Castillo.
Again, just somebody to keep an eye on.
It's his first full season in Greensboro.
Again, just turned 20 years old.
Yeah, an exciting prospect.
Like I said, not overpowering stuff quite yet, but I think you got to look at, again, the pitchability, look at the pitch mix, look at the potential here.
And yeah, if he can add some – add a little bit of VLO, you're quickly starting to talk about someone who could be a starting pitching prospect that we're talking more about down the road.
Exactly.
Yep.
All right.
Well, Murphy, I'm going to let you get to bed.
It's late there in Greensboro.
Like I said, you're at your hotel.
Appreciate you hopping on here.
Everybody can find your work on the Bucs On Deck sub stack if they're not already subscribed.
Make sure you check that out.
Amazing coverage just across the system.
And we're going to be here every Saturday morning at 7 a.m.
Comments· 0
Will Carlos Castillo add enough fastball velocity to be a starter, or end up a middle reliever?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.