◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)◆NEWSPirates, Chas McCormick Agree To Minor League Deal
◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)◆NEWSPirates, Chas McCormick Agree To Minor League Deal
After one series, Bucco Brew came away with a pretty balanced first impression of the 2026 Pirates. The big positive was the offense looking more alive, especially with Brandon Lowe and Ryan O’Hearn immediately making an impact and showing the kind of power this lineup has badly needed. The frustration, though, was familiar: the Pirates created chances, but they still struggled to cash in with runners in scoring position. Anthony DiNardo and Jim Rosati also spent time breaking down Carmen Mlodzinski’s first start, which was encouraging enough to at least feel better about him holding down that fifth starter role for now. On the other side, the bullpen’s stuff flashed, but the walks remain something to watch closely. The episode also touched on Jim’s weekend in Indianapolis, where Konnor Griffin continues to be a major storyline for Pirates fans.
Grab some coffee at De Fer Coffee & Tea and use promo code NS930 for 30% off your order. Watch or listen to the full episode now.
Comments· 0
The Debate
Should Carmen Mlodzinski stay in the rotation as the fifth starter, or go back to the bullpen?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.
With Anthony DiNardo and Jim Rosati.
Chapters
Key takeaways
1
The Pirates should have added a right-handed lefty-masher for the bench; a lineup heavy with left-handed hitters like Horwitz, Lowe, O'Hearn and Cruz will struggle against left-handed pitching.
2
Against lefties, Jared Triolo is a better leadoff choice than Jake Mangum. His walk rate is 10.1% to Mangum's 3.6% and his on-base percentage is .331 to .309. Calling for Mangum is going on vibes.
3
Carmen Mlodzinski is the best option for the fifth starter spot, but he's probably still better as a reliever. His start didn't settle that.
4
Prediction: Konnor Griffin makes his MLB debut on April 6 against the Padres, after about nine games at AAA.
5
Don't expect Griffin to be an All-Star bat at 19. A league-average hitter would be really good, and his speed and defense would still help the Pirates win.
Yo. Welcome to the North Shore Nine podcast presented by FanDuel. This is Bucco Brew powered by DePair Coffee and Tea. I'm your host, Anthony DiNardo. With me, we have Jim Rosati. Jim, happy Monday. Happy 1st.
I guess opening weekend of baseball is over. So completion and welcome back from Indianapolis.
Yeah, it's good to be back. It was a fun weekend in Indianapolis. The Indians were swept, unfortunately, but yeah, it was a really good. Apparently, the number one prospect in baseball was down there while I was in town. So got to check him out a little bit. And yeah, it was a good it was a good trip. Indianapolis is a fun town. If you've never been to Indianapolis.
Victory Field's outstanding. Like I would recommend doing some like weekend trip to Indianapolis at some point during the summer just to check out the Indians and Victory Field. It's a it's a nice it's a nice downtown. If you like Pittsburgh, I think you'll like Indy. It's like small, compact. Everything's right together all within walking distance. Lots of restaurants, bars all within the stadium. And yeah, plenty of places to stay downtown. Good spot.
Is it a nice little downtown gym? Yeah, we need to. I need like a visit Indianapolis sponsorship, I think, after that.
Nice. Well, yeah, while you were out parading in Indianapolis with the marching bands, there was there's real life baseball going on MLB baseball in New York City, where the Pirates were taking on the Mets. Now they only took one out of the three. So a little disappointing. Paul Skenes's start was not good. He only lasted to two outs, Jim.
Yeah, that's dumb. But there's some takeaways we want to talk about, on this show about this series. And I think the two takeaways that we're going to really discuss today is the offense.
And Carmen Mlodzinski, we have the postgame shows, we broke down every game in depth on those. So go listen to them if you want to and haven't. But I think on this show today. Yeah. Like we want to discuss this new offense.
That was the big key. This offseason is, what was this offense going to do? What was Ben Cherington going to do to improve this offense? And we saw a lot of moves that way.
And then also the big story was who's going to be the fifth starter. And I know I think most of us assumed it was going to be someone other than Carmen Mlodzinski, right?
There was your key. There was Hunter Barco. There's maybe Mike Clevenger. Maybe they're going to bring in.
I think all, actually, all of us thought they're going to bring in a fifth starter, right? And then it turns out to be Carmen Mlodzinski. And he did make the start yesterday, 4.1. No walks, 8K, 6 hits, 2 earned.
So, yeah, I think there's something to talk about a little more in depth in there.
So, before we do, though, of course, to tell you all about Defer Coffee & Tea, Defer is a family and employee and own operated business.
They believe that coffee and tea are one of life's simplest and most accessible pleasures and when enjoyed thoughtfully, you can open your eyes to the here and now.
They have five locations across the city of Pittsburgh, including their flagship in the heart of Pittsburgh's historic Strip District.
Don't forget to stop by Defer's new location downtown on Penn Avenue, right across from the Benidum.
Grab a cup and fuel up on your walk to PNC Park. Mobile ordering is available.
And check out their Instagram for more details.
And, of course, Jim, as always, tell our beautiful people how they can save 30%.
Yeah, go to Defer.coffee and load up your cart.
Promo code NS930, five, four, three, no, two letters, three numbers.
And that'll give you 30% off your entire order.
There it is.
So, yeah, let's dive into this.
So, again, I know you're in Indianapolis.
You did catch up and watch some of the games.
So, just, overall big picture.
What was your takeaway, more or less, from the series?
You know what?
if you would have told me going into the series, like, hey, the Pirates were going to take one out of three, that would have been a very reasonable outcome here.
you're going on the road.
You're playing a pretty good team.
Odds are you're losing two out of three, right?
And that's not a disaster to lose two out of three in an away series against a good team.
You're going to lose series.
This one, I guess, just happened in a very strange way.
Like, that opening game was wild.
The Pirates hit three homers.
They scored seven runs.
And then Paul Skenes just didn't get out of the first inning.
A lot of our concerns came to light in that first game.
But outside of that, man, again, like, I don't want to, I don't want to make this overblown.
But they weren't throwing a lot of strikes.
Yesterday was a little bit different.
Yesterday, that's, I think the biggest reason why they won the game is because the bullpen was able to hold up and the bullpen did come through yesterday.
But way too many walks given up this series by the bullpen.
Now, you were seeing, like, there's stuff within this bullpen.
they have a lot of swing and miss, right?
They have a lot of electric type of stuff for the most part.
But they got to throw strikes.
they have to throw strikes.
And that's what they weren't doing.
And it helped bite them in the ass, more or less.
So, yeah, an early takeaway from the bullpen, I guess, is, like, just throw strikes.
Because you saw, like, yesterday, when Mason Montgomery throws strikes, he can look really good.
Now, he allowed two hits.
And like I said, like, that doesn't bother me too much.
His stuff is so good.
If you're just filling up the strike zone with his type of stuff, he's going to strike out batters.
Not three walks in the 1.1 innings with two strikeouts, like his first time.
So, yeah.
Overall, as a unit right now, the bullpen giving up way too many walks.
Yeah, I'm not going to get...
It's one series.
They pitched a lot of innings.
They pitched the third most innings of any bullpen in the majors.
I agree with you.
Like, they definitely walked too many people.
17 innings in this series, 14 walks.
That's a lot.
But you said the strikeouts were their 22 strikeouts.
So, they were striking out well more than a batter per inning.
All in all, though, they did a good job of limiting damage after those walks because the third most walks in the majors through those first three games, 4-2-4 ERA as a unit, that's not good.
Like, you need your bullpen ERA to be lower than that.
But based off of how they pitched, I would have expected that number to be quite a bit higher.
And I thought they did an outstanding job in yesterday's game, picking up for, the lack of how long Carmen Mlodzinski was able to go.
They also had to deal with, an extra innings game in here.
Like, they just...
They were worked a lot.
They were worked a lot this series.
Santana came up big, in his three innings.
Soto, I thought, looked outstanding.
You mentioned, Montgomery, Lawrence, Mattson.
It was really just that opening day.
Like, opening day, they looked pretty shaky.
The rest of the series, like, you can live with what that bullpen gave you.
But opening day was rough.
Opening day was rough.
no ifs ands, doubts about it.
Like, that was just a bad game overall for pretty much anybody who picked up a baseball on the pitcher's mound for both teams, really.
But after that, they settled in.
But you're right.
They got to throw strikes.
Their stuff is too good.
You saw Montgomery yesterday.
Like, the stuff is too good.
If you just throw strikes, you're going to get people out.
Because you're nasty.
You're just flat out nasty.
I think he threw 13 pitches yesterday and got three strikeouts with him.
Same with Mattson.
Mattson threw 13 pitches yesterday.
Picked up two strikeouts.
These guys have really good stuff.
Just need to attack hitters.
I think they'll be okay.
I'm not going to get too concerned over one weekend.
And the things that are concerning to me after the first weekend are more that, one of the things like with Montgomery in particular.
Like, Montgomery, we know, has control problems.
Like, you're just going to have outings like that where he drives you batshit crazy because you're looking at the stuff and you're seeing how nasty it is.
And he just can't find the zone.
Like, you're going to have outings like that from Mason Montgomery.
He's just going to come with the territory.
I don't know if at this point, he's going to all of a sudden just learn command.
But right.
Yeah, it's I think the bullpen's okay, though.
I want to see more of it.
The arms are all interesting.
Like, they all have really good stuff.
And I guess the good thing about that is when they do get themselves in trouble, they've got a shot of getting themselves out of it, as we've seen a few times because of how good that stuff is.
Yeah, no, for sure.
that's like the gift and the curse of this bullpen.
Yeah, like you mentioned, they went first off 17 innings.
That's two games.
the bullpen pitched two out of three games, essentially, this weekend.
That's wild.
And, like you said, the four point two for everybody that speaks because the first game was also like the second game.
They let off the inning, I think, four to five times with a walk.
And I think in the one time they didn't, it was a hit batter.
So, like, technically, it wasn't even a walk, but it was it was a hit batter.
But again, you also saw the enticing stuff that they have, and how even with the walks, they were able to limit the damage when done.
So, you mentioned the 4.24.
really, that was mainly Hunter Barco, I feel like, those extra innings you can debate.
But anyway, yeah, like there was certainly a lot of positives out of this.
you feel like the pitching is going to hold up.
What you really want to take away was the offense was there.
Of course, it was mainly the two acquisitions, but the offense was there.
And maybe let's dive more into the offense as a whole.
your offensive leaders are Brandon Lowe and Ryan O'Hearn.
No surprise.
And Henry Davis, Jim, Henry Davis coming up clutch a little bit as well this weekend.
That was good to see.
But, like, I think the biggest takeaway seeing so far to the offense is the hits are being collected.
Even the walks, like, they're getting on base.
They're just having a tough time right now in this series as it seems like the Pirates MO scoring the guys.
I believe 8-4-39.
I'm sorry, 6-4-39 with runners in scoring position on the series.
You're not going to win a whole lot of games doing that.
Again, the positive, 39 opportunities with runners in scoring position.
typically a Pirates game is, after a series, you might hear they had 15.
they had 39.
That's a positive.
6, got to do better.
Absolutely.
just to go through numbers there, the 39 at-bats with runners in scoring position, 6th best in baseball.
So, through the first weekend.
So, yeah, like, they're doing a good job of getting people on base and getting into a position to score.
The 154 batting average, though, with runners in scoring position, 27th in baseball.
So, it's just, and I think this is what's a little frustrating because this is the problem this team has had, right, for a while.
Is being able to capitalize when guys are on base, when guys are in scoring position, being able to string hits together.
Being able to hit the ball over the fence has been this team's problem, too.
Which we, it seems like they at least have a couple guys who can do that, which is really helpful.
You hit the ball over the fence, you have a much better chance of winning those baseball games.
So, yeah, I guess if you're, if you're like, if you're, if you're looking at this in a way of things to be negative about, that's it.
Because you can look at last year's team and the year before that and the year before that and the year before that.
And it just, it seemed like they could never score a run.
They get somebody on base and then the guys behind them just couldn't move them over, couldn't have situational hitting, couldn't get him in, whatever it took.
To get him in, they couldn't do it.
And this weekend, you saw, you saw a lot of that.
You saw a lot of people on the base pads.
You saw a lot of people left on base.
You saw, Bryan Reynolds in particular look rough out there.
Marcell Ozuna, who, if there was any doubts there, it was like, man, he declined last year.
He's getting older.
Is he going to keep declining?
And he didn't have a good opening weekend.
So, another guy who needs to bounce back.
But I would say, Reynolds and Ozuna and Oneil Cruz, we can talk about him a little bit.
Those three certainly didn't do anything this weekend to ease any of your concerns that you have with those guys.
That's when Jake Mangum made his first start, and he batted ninth.
But then this third game, he batted fifth.
I want to talk a little bit about Jared Triolo lineup.
First off, I guess, with the lead off.
Do you think this is now Don Kelly said, too, also that Oneil Cruz is going to face lefties this year.
It's not that as if it's like a true platoon.
He is going to face lefties.
Also of note, his second hit came off of a lefty.
But do you see Jared Triolo in the lead off spot versus lefties as a thing this year?
Maybe.
Maybe.
for his career, it's let's face it.
Jared Triolo is not a great hitter for his career, even versus lefties.
He's better against lefties than he is righties, but he's still a 95 weighted runs created plus 702 OPS.
He does have a 331 on base percentage.
So if like there is some like he's not the worst lead off hitter against the lefty.
It's just you'd wish you I think that's the one thing I wish this team went out and got this year that I feel like they didn't particularly for their bench is like a lefty masher.
They didn't go out and get one of those guys.
They didn't get an Andrew.
Andrew McCutchen would have been a good guy.
I'm not going to go too far into that.
But like they there's a lot of guys out there who like they have jobs essentially because they can hit left handed hitter left handed pitching.
And the Pirates didn't really go out and get any of those guys because this is a pretty heavy left handed lineup.
You've got Horwitz.
You've got Brandon Lowe.
You've got Oh, her and you've got crews.
You're probably wanting those guys to you're going to have to have those guys face some lefty pitching throughout the course of the year.
Now, you don't want them all facing lefty pitching all the time.
So I said that's where, maybe going out there and getting that right handed bat who can play an outfield position.
It's just I think you need him getting every day at bats right now.
Do you really want him just sitting on the bench playing once every five days or so?
I don't know.
He also didn't look that great in Indy this weekend, but then it's just one weekend.
He had a really good spring, but the Pirates need somebody like that.
And the fact that like Billy Cook is that guy right now, it's not that's not very it's not very encouraging.
But yeah, right now, to answer your questions, who else are you going to put there?
that's a problem.
You could you could put you could put Reynolds there.
Maybe you could put Mangum there.
But also, like you look at Mangum splits like Mangum is much better against righties than he is lefties.
Right.
You're putting Triolo versus Mangum head to head versus left handed pitchers like Triolo has been the better hitter of the two.
So I don't have a problem with it, with the way this roster is presently constructed.
I think there's another guy who's sitting in triple A right now who had a really good weekend and is the number one prospect in baseball, where if he were on your team, he might be a pretty good option against left handed pitching.
So maybe this is somewhat temporary because, spring training can be somewhat telling.
It is spring training.
You're getting guys in there.
But, that was nice.
Don Kelly was putting Oneil Cruz in the leadoff role.
And I was mentioning, like, even as well, I think to some level, like, oh, I hope this is the thing.
Now, Ono has to produce, obviously, for me to be like that.
But if he is producing, I like Oneil Cruz in the leadoff spot.
I really do.
But they were also rolling with Triolo there.
And is this going to be a thing?
And he saw this first opportunity, versus a lefty when Oneil Cruz was out, that it went to Jared Triolo.
And that's why I want to bring this up, because there was a lot of discourse.
Jared Triolo walks three times as much as Jake Mangum.
On base percentage for Mangum, 3.09%.
On base percentage for Triolo, 3.31%.
So, like, again, you're just – based on vibes, sure.
Like, I understand how you would want Jake Mangum at leadoff because he's that spark plug.
He's that guy who can get things going.
And he is.
Like, he is that guy.
That's what he's on the team for.
And I have – I think Jake Mangum is going to help this team a lot this year.
It's just if you're looking for a leadoff hitter, the main goal of the leadoff hitter is to get on base and Jared Triolo gets on base more than Jake Mangum does.
You can look at the batting average, right, and compare the two.
Sure.
But you look at that and, yeah, like, Jared Triolo is better.
Nick Gonzales is another person being mentioned here in the comments.
And one thing about Nick Gonzales is – I'm not entirely sure why people think he's, like, better than Jared Triolo because their career outputs are almost identical at this point.
And guess what?
Jared Triolo, also a better hitter against lefties than Nick Gonzales.
So, Nick Gonzales, career on base percentage against lefties, 308.
Triolo's 331.
Like I said, it's not – it's really – you just – again, based on vibes, you're like, oh, Nick Gonzales swings the bat.
He gets these hits when I feel like he needs to get hits.
But it's like the numbers show that out of these guys, it's – Triolo's a fine choice.
Now, the best choice – He's not a fine choice, but he's the best choice.
The option is you don't have good choices.
That's a good point.
This lineup is going to struggle against left-handed pitching right now, as is, because they didn't go out there and get someone who can mash lefties.
Like, that would help this lineup a whole lot.
So, like, they're going to have to piece it together.
They're going to have to win the way that they – they're going to have to win the way they're going to have to win.
They're going to have to scratch across a few runs.
They're going to have to get to the bullpen.
They're going to need good pitching.
That's how they're going to win against lefties.
Unless – I think the answer to this question is sitting in AAA.
I think you've nailed that, because that's going to be the problem.
It's not going to be Uno Cruz versus lefties.
Like, we know, even if Uno Cruz is facing lefties often enough, I don't foresee him, of course, leading off versus lefties.
So, yes, this is going to be interesting right now to see who is going to be batting leadoff versus lefties until, I guess, Konnor Griffin gets up here April 9.
if you really want to get, like, who's the best versus lefties, he can't run, but he can get on base and hit the ball.
Maybe Joey Bart's the answer there.
I don't know.
But, like, right now, there's just not a good – there's not a lineup that you can put together out there against lefties where it's like, man, these guys all hit lefties.
It just doesn't exist.
Right.
Okay.
Yeah, so that was a little bit of a talk I want to discuss here.
But, again, that's – like you mentioned, it's a fine choice.
It's the best choice on the team at this point in time.
Yesterday, though, Jared Shull in the five hole, no.
You can do better than that, right?
Like, he shouldn't – you can make the argument, as we did, that he's leading off because that's the best amongst the choices.
But as the fifth hitter, no.
You're either leading off or you're, like, bottom three.
Outside of that, anything else offensively that you want to talk about before we get into, Carmen?
No, first weekend in the books, they performed just fine as a unit.
I said, you want to see more hits with runners in scoring position.
But, overall, they're essentially – we talked about them needing to be a league average offense.
They're 14th in the majors right now.
105 weighted runs created plus.
And runs scored, they are 17th.
So, they're right there in the middle of everything.
And, like I said, we've been saying the whole time that if they can be an average offense, like, this season's going to be okay.
So, as far as this weekend goes, offensively, I was fine with it.
I said, you want to see more people step up in big situations.
But, it's 162-game season.
We saw three of them.
So, it's a pretty small sample size at this point.
All right.
I agree.
before we cut to Cody and go to our next topic here, is there any takeaway just from the three games so far that maybe you're thinking differently from anyone offensively,
whether it's good or bad?
Maybe it's, like you mentioned a little bit here, Marcell Ozuna.
are those worries from other people?
I think we're okay with it, you know.
But, like, do you look at them and say, maybe he is old?
It definitely creeps in your mind.
there's, I think Alex said it on his show last week where, he's not a fan of that signing.
Like, the bat speed's down.
There are a lot of reasons to think that Ozuna is declining.
He's still been a pretty good hitter for a pretty long time.
So, like, I'm still, I still think he's, I still think there's something in there.
But you never know.
You never know.
That could creep into your mind there.
But the biggest takeaway for me is just, like, the ability to hit the ball over the fence.
Like, that's it.
That's what this team has been lacking so long.
And it seems like they finally have a lineup that can do that.
They have some guys who you can, who are going to do that.
Like, Brandon Lowe hit 31 homers last year.
Now he's going to hit 162.
He's got, he's on pace for 162.
It's just that it feels good to have a guy like that on the team where, like, that can happen at any point in time.
Like, at any at-bat, Brandon Lowe can just pop one over the fence.
We've been missing, we've been missing guys like that.
Right.
Okay.
Well, cool.
Well, let's go ahead and kick it over to Cody.
And we'll come back and just let you know as well, speaking of Brandon Lowe, that's who Alex talked a lot about today on Offbeat.
So if you want to hear more about Brandon Lowe and what Alex had to say about him, make sure you check that out as well.
That dropped today before we went live right now.
So, yeah, we'll be back.
We'll talk about Karim Mlodzinski in the number five starter.
This episode is brought to you by IQ Bar, our exclusive snack hydration sponsor.
IQ Bar protein bars, IQ Mix hydration mixes, and IQ Joe mushroom coffees are the delicious, low-sugar brain and body fuel you need to win your day.
The Ultimate Sampler Pack is a great way for you to try all IQ Bar products and flavors.
You get nine IQ Bars, eight IQ Mix Sticks, and four IQ Joe Sticks.
All IQ Bar products are clean label certified and entirely free from gluten, dairy, soy, GMOs, and artificial ingredients.
With over 20,000 five-star reviews and counting, more people than ever are fueling their lifestyles with IQ Bar's brain and body boosting bars, hydration mixes, and mushroom coffees.
The Ultimate Sampler Pack includes all three.
My personal favorites so far have been the Almond Butter Chip and the Iced Tea Lemonade Hydration Mix.
It's just really full of flavor.
I love starting my day with it, and I couldn't imagine starting my day with anything else other than IQ Bar products.
Right now, IQ Bar is offering our podcast listeners 20% off all IQ Bar products, including the Ultimate Sampler Pack, plus free shipping.
To get your 20% off, text MLB to 64000.
That's MLB 64000.
Message and data rates may apply.
See terms for details.
All right.
So, yes, as mentioned, the Pirates got their one victory this series with Carmen Mlodzinski on the mound starting.
There's been a lot of controversy around that.
Why are they trying to do this again?
Why are they running it back?
We've seen this already, Jim.
He is not a starter.
Did yesterday's start erase any doubts in those people's minds, do you think?
Or, I think both of us were also, were open to the idea.
We, I think, wanted him in the bullpen, but were open to the idea.
He won it.
We're okay with it.
Did this maybe solidify us?
You know what?
This was the right choice for you.
I think it's solidified that it was the right choice for me.
I don't think it eases anyone's concerns on whether or not he's a starting pitcher, though.
So, I think the answer to your question is yes on both, or maybe no and then yes.
I don't know how you asked him.
But, yeah, you look at it, and the knock against Mlodzinski is he can't see guys a second or third time through the order, right?
And when he's in the bullpen, he's seeing people one time through, and he's dominating them.
What we saw yesterday was two times through the order, looking really good.
Third time through the order, I think it was, what, triple-single, and then pulled.
So, he only faced two guys three times and gave up a triple and a single.
Now, those two guys were Francisco Lindor and Juan Soto, two perennial MVP candidates.
Right.
So, if your mindset going into this was, Mlodzinski is a reliever, he should be a reliever because he can't give you length.
He didn't really do anything to change your mind there yesterday.
On the flip side, if you're saying, hey, like, Carmen Mlodzinski is the fifth starter because he's the best option, and he can give you the most out of that spot, and yeah, maybe he's better in the bullpen than he is as a starter, but there's no better options for that fifth
starter spot.
I think those people are also right.
Like, I think we, I think he showed yesterday that the upside of Carmen Mlodzinski is way higher than José Urquidy or Mike Clevenger or Hunter Barco.
I like Barco.
I think he's going to be an effective major league pitcher, but I got right now you're giving me those four names and Carmen Mlodzinski looked really good yesterday.
he struck out eight dudes in four innings, no walks.
You take that from a fifth starter, and we've been talking this whole time where like that fifth starter role, it's not necessarily going to be your normal starter.
you're going to get creative with it.
Maybe you throw in a opener every now and then, maybe you throw in a long, a piggyback option behind him.
We didn't really see that yesterday.
I guess if you want to say like Yohan Ramirez was that option, like Yohan Ramirez bridged them to that seventh inning.
So, but yeah, like if your argument is Mlodzinski is the best choice, I think you're right.
If your argument is that he's better as a reliever, you're probably right too.
Okay.
and I think that's fair based off yesterday's start for sure.
I did though.
I will say this.
I came away encouraged.
I came away saying, you know what?
I want to see more.
I felt like last year, we're open to the idea.
Also, we didn't think it was going to work.
And again, like he hasn't started since, double a, he wasn't even good then.
Like, why are we doing this?
But let's see it out.
Right.
Let's give him an opportunity before we completely bash it.
And I feel like right away it showed like, Oh, okay.
Yeah.
Like this is why we didn't want this.
And he continued to show it.
And what was it showing?
Like, yeah, it looks really good.
The first time through, like as a reliever would, as he does as a reliever, because he had a really good 2024 season in the bullpen.
Right.
And it just all falls apart and it continued to do that.
And it continued to do that.
And yesterday, even though we only went 4.1 innings, right?
So you have, like you mentioned, you have that mindset of, Oh, Hey, he doesn't have length.
Those 4.1 innings were actually really good.
And I understand the third time through triple to Lindor off a splitter single to one Soto off the curve ball.
The two pitches we talk about, which is why he could be a starter.
It's ironic that those were done the second time through the order for strikeouts, which was on top of the first time was four strikeouts.
He looked good the second time through that was a key to me.
Now we're facing the second time, right?
Lindor came up.
Soto came up.
Bo Bichette, one, two, three, like you mentioned, parental MVPs for the first two.
they're all-stars.
that one through three is a very good one through three in baseball.
Probably one of the best one through three.
Karma just is going to face this year.
You have Lindor Soto and Bichette second time through the order.
Now it's time to hone in.
Now who is Karma Bichinski to see the starter role?
Boom, strikeout.
That was a statement to me.
Here's the second time through the order.
Those three dogs up the bat and I struck out the side.
All three of them sent back down.
I said, oh boy.
Okay.
Are we cooking here?
Karma Bichinski threw all four pitches.
The four seam, the two seam, the curveball, the splitter.
He looked good through the slider here.
three of them, I think.
But like he featured what was talked about and why he could be the starter.
And he looked, he looked pretty filthy.
So I also want to say this, I think it was what, 85 or 88 pitches in the one 4.1 innings he threw something at that level.
85.
if you watch the game, you saw his third baseman, who by the way, is a second baseman duck at a line drive coming at him.
You saw his shortstop, which is the third baseman.
Just not field a routine grounder right to his glove.
And then you saw the right fielder, who is the first baseman, played a ball off the wall that led to that triple.
So it's not as if he had some help behind him, even in those two earned runs in 4.1.
Maybe the pitch count doesn't get that high to begin with to go those 4.1.
If he just had some defense behind him and he, I know it's baseball and things happen, but it's like, that's also why this team, like, this is what makes you a little bit of an easy, like Jared Cholo should be playing third.
And if he's playing 30, probably makes that play.
But then again, I say that and he made that play a short.
yeah, they didn't do him any favors behind him as well.
Maybe that was just a double as it should have been instead of a triple, that doesn't score and he looks even better or he goes a little bit more deeper into the game, but at any rate, I do want to say he, as a pitcher through those, what 20 batters
that he faced, he looked good.
He looked good.
So I do want to see more.
I'm not over this experiment.
I'm not stamping as like, oh yes, he is the fifth star.
This is done.
Sealed.
Delivered.
I'm saying each start, I'm going to take a little bit away.
And right now I want to see that second start.
Carmen Vizinski looked filthy against a really good lineup.
Yeah.
it's a small sample size, but fan graphs, seventh highest pitcher of war on the season.
Carmen Vizinski.
Which you're going to do that when you have a strikeout to walk rate the way, the way he does, his FIP is negative 0.55.
So like, yeah, like from just a pitch ability standpoint, like he pitched his ass off and yeah, I think that's why you say like starting him, starting him here is the right decision, but I, but I still don't think he's done anything necessarily to ease
the, like, he did give up the triple and single, like there is that.
So it's like, could, is he going to be that guy who gives you four lights out innings every time?
And then, he starts falling apart in the fifth.
If he, if that's the case, then you could say he'd be better off just being used two innings at a time, every three games, because you can, you can plug them in where you need
them against the right people.
So yeah, I think both sides are still correct in their assertations here.
Like, I think he is the best spot, the best, the best starter for the fifth role right now.
And I think if you think he's a better option for the bullpen, I think you're probably still right here.
we'll see, we'll see.
if Carmen Mlodzinski is a, if Carmen Mlodzinski is a reliever, right.
And say José Urquidy is the fifth starter, maybe the pirates lose that third game of the series, but maybe they win the second one, right?
Like maybe they win the first one or the second one with Mlodzinski in the bullpen.
So I think at the end of the day that you're still looking at a one and two team, but he, I, at this point, like Carmen Mlodzinski is a good pitcher.
It's just like, what type of good pitcher is he?
And I think that's still to be determined, but I want to see more of it.
Like you said, I want to see more of it.
Yeah, no doubt.
He is a good pitcher.
Like if you're thinking he's not a good pitcher, then you're just wrong.
But right.
It is the role.
And it's funny you say that because I wanted to put it this way.
I think the ironic part is, this doesn't help anything you mentioned, but at the same point, it's like, yes, if he was in that bullpen role, they probably win game two.
But the argument was, but Hunter Barko is your, if he's your fifth starter, you said Urquidy and you didn't see a whole lot, but it's like if Hunter Barko is your fifth starter, they also don't win yesterday.
So it's a wash right now.
We haven't really seen.
That's why the fifth starter is also important.
Like I said, it's still 20% of your starts.
But anyways, yeah, we'll move on.
TB, TBD, I guess, to be the continued, to be determined and being the fifth starter.
But again, I'm encouraged on that.
So let's wrap this up then.
Let's have you talk a little bit about your Indianapolis trip and seeing that number one prospect in baseball, which by the, again, by the way, what is his name?
Outstanding opening weekend in Indianapolis for Konnor Griffin.
Walked three times, stole two bases.
He went five for 10, two doubles in yesterday's game.
One of them missed being a homer by four feet or so.
The other one, just a laser into the opposite field, right center field gap off a fastball.
Velo on the fastball wasn't super high.
It was like a 93-mile-an-hour fastball.
But he got all of it.
Got thrown out at third, trying to stretch it into a triple.
Probably should have just stopped at second, to be honest with you.
But he looked good.
He looked really good.
And I think what stood out to me were a few things.
One, defensively.
The dude can play shortstop.
And if there's one thing that this opening series taught us, if Konnor Griffin's playing shortstop and Jared Triolo's playing third, then maybe it's also a whole other series.
Does Jared Triolo get that tag down in the first inning on Oneil Cruz's throw on opening day?
If Konnor Griffin's playing shortstop, does that routine grounder to Triolo get fielded?
And Carmen's able to maybe go a little bit longer.
He doesn't have to throw more pitches.
And he does something different.
There was another play that Triolo dove on in the hole where, does Connor get there?
Because he's got a little bit more range.
He's more athletic.
He's faster.
I don't know.
So, I just, I do know this, that if Konnor Griffin were the Pirates shortstop right now, defense would be better than it is right now.
Because you'd be moving your gold glove infielder to his more natural position of third base.
And you've got Konnor Griffin, who just won a minor league gold glove, fielding shortstop.
So, your left side of the infield, you've got two rock-solid defenders.
Offensively, is he a finished product?
Absolutely not.
He's 19 years old.
Like, there's still plenty of things that he's never seen before and needs to work on.
He's going to be attacked in ways that he's never seen before in the majors.
At AAA, he saw some pretty good pitching this weekend.
There was consistent 96-97 velocity being thrown at him.
I didn't see him necessarily square up any, like, really fast fastballs.
But he had really good at-bats against fastballs, where he was fighting balls off, drawing some walks.
So, it was a really good opening series for him.
One more week here in Columbus coming up.
And I don't know, man.
Like, I'm getting the sense that Konnor Griffin's going to be in Pittsburgh before that April 9th date.
Or by that April 9th date.
I just, I've got a feeling.
I've got a feeling it's going to happen.
I don't think the Pirates are going to do it unless they feel really confident that they can extend Konnor Griffin.
Like, just knowing how the Pirates operate.
I can't see them calling up a 19-year-old and essentially saying, let's go and then give them up a free agency at age 25.
I think if they're going to do it, they're going to have to be really confident in these talks that they're having that, hey, like, we're going to get something done with this guy pretty soon.
But, yeah, I don't know if he's going to be there during the home opener, but I could, like, circle that Padres series following the opener.
I could see this week in Columbus, and then instead of heading back to Indy, hey, team's going west to Indy, Connor.
You're going east to Pittsburgh.
I could see it.
There it is.
I'm up for it.
This is the scenario and why I didn't want to be, like, in any uproar about, like, him not making the opening day roster because we talked about this scenario before as well.
we would have put him there.
I would bring him up just as you said, right?
But I understand why they didn't.
And I'm also not going to go crazy because I still think there's a situation where they bring him up while he's still PPI eligible, right, because it still helps both parties.
So maybe just get him down there, get comfortable for a week or so, then come back up.
That's still in play.
It's still a very highly possible outcome of this.
And if that is the case to me, nothing truly lost.
I guess you could argue, like you mentioned, maybe they went two out of three of Connors here just simply because of the defense.
Maybe.
Maybe.
But big picture, nothing truly lost in doing that.
Maybe it helps him become the better version of himself as a 19-year-old.
Again, you can debate that all day long.
But I do also have this feeling, I've had it for some time, that if he gets sent down, it's not going to be a, you're down there for one, two, three months type of scenario.
That's why I took the under with Tyler when we put that out there.
It's April 9th.
I feel like he's going to be up here while he is PPI eligible.
He will be back.
So, I still remain with that mindset until I guess I'm proven wrong.
And I guess also he does need to show that on his side, he's ready for that.
And so far, like you mentioned, so good.
So, keep it up, Connor.
We'll see you soon.
I'm going to say, I'm going to say, I'm going to say April 6th, Major League debut against the Padres.
That's my guess right now.
I could be, I could be wrong, but I just, I get the sense that he's not going to be there very long because he's good.
He's just really good.
And by that point, you're giving him nine games in AAA and, 60, 70-ish plate appearances.
The other thing too, the offense this weekend, the Pirates are one of only, the Pirates are one of only three teams without a stolen base.
And, Connor had 65 of those last year and he had two over the weekend.
So, I think they could just, they could use the athleticism.
They could use the defense.
The bat's not going to, I don't think the bat's going to be incredible right off the bat.
Like, it's going to take a while for him to adjust to Major League pitching.
So, like, don't expect him to come up here and be this Fernando Tatis Jr., Bobby Wood Jr. clone.
Like, I don't think that's what he's going to be at age 19.
He could be that at age 22 or 23, but he's not going to be that guy at 19.
But I think what he could be at 19 is someone who doesn't look overpowered or doesn't look overmatched at the plate.
Like, someone who can handle the, he can handle it.
He's going to give you speed on the base pad.
He's going to give you good base running.
He's going to give you really good defense.
And those are things that the Pirates need.
But, yeah, from an offensive standpoint, like, don't expect Konnor Griffin to come up here and be an all-star offensively.
I think if he's a league average hitter, like, that's really good.
Right.
Really good.
Yeah.
Also, to put those things in perspective, because you mentioned, like, Bobby Wood Jr., he gets comped him all the time.
Like, also, Bobby Wood Jr. wasn't Bobby Wood Jr. when he first came up.
And that was age 22.
he was just right around a league average hitter, but he still was over a two-word player.
And why was that?
Because of his speed?
Because of his defense.
And he saw what his defense can do.
Paul Skenes saw what his defense could do in that World Baseball Classic.
So, again, even if he's not this version of an MVP-caliber-type player offensively, he's still helping contribute to win to this team, just on the defense alone.
So, like you mentioned, with him and Triolo both on the left side, this defense looks a lot better than what it currently does.
So, yeah, there's that.
Good stuff.
Anything else that you want to highlight from your Indy trip other than Conor?
There are more people, Jim.
Yeah, there are more people.
I made a pretty lengthy Twitter post last night.
But, Esmerlyn Valdez, like getting pushed to AAA, that's aggressive.
It's an aggressive move for him because, he got bumped up to Altoona, middle of last year.
He played 51 games in Altoona.
Took him a while to adjust.
His second month in Altoona, like, did an awesome job.
So, and then lit up the Arizona Fall League.
We were down there during that tear he was on in the Arizona Fall League.
So, sending him to AAA, that was an aggressive push.
But I'll say this.
Like, he looked really comfortable there.
Had some really good at-bats.
Walked a few times.
Was hitting the ball the other way.
Didn't look like he was doing too much.
He was taking what the pitchers were giving him.
So, I was very pleased with what I saw from Esmerlyn Valdez.
Comments· 0
Should Carmen Mlodzinski stay in the rotation as the fifth starter, or go back to the bullpen?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.