◆NEWS2026 Non-Tenders: National League◆ROSTERRHP Noah Murdock elected free agency◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSPlayers Avoiding Arbitration Prior To The 2026 Non-Tender Deadline◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers
◆NEWS2026 Non-Tenders: National League◆ROSTERRHP Noah Murdock elected free agency◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSPlayers Avoiding Arbitration Prior To The 2026 Non-Tender Deadline◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers
The Pirates broke their four-game losing streak Wednesday night with a 7-0 drubbing of the St. Louis Cardinals at Busch Stadium. After 6 tries, the Pirates finally managed to win their first game of the season against their division rival. Pittsburgh also ensures they do not fall below .500 and improve to 25-24 on the season. The Bucs were powered by an elite 5th-inning outing from Carmen Mlodzinski and a 15-hit game from the offense that kept pressuring the Cardinals arms all game long. Tyler and I recapped this game on the NS9 Postgame Show powered by Primanti’s Bros which you can watch/listen to here:
Carmen Mlodzinski made headlines last year when he revealed that he was willing to hang up the cleats if the Pirates didn’t give him a chance to be a starting pitcher. The 2025 experiment was largely unsuccessful, but with an injured Jared Jones, he was given another shot to establish himself as a Major League starter. With Jones on the cusp of being ready to return to the majors, Mlodzinski has been good enough that the Pirates have to ask real questions about moving him out of the rotation. Carmen pitched a spectacular 5 innings, as they were 5 shut out and relatively stress-free. Surprisingly, he only struck out one batter, but he averaged 1 runner on base per inning, and he is rocking a respectable 3.96 ERA on the year. For a guy who was projected as a 5th starter, that is something you take even if he is never the most efficient starter we have ever seen. As long as Bubba Chandler continues to struggle, Mlod has a serious chance to remain the 5th starter and he has earned it.
As things sit on May 20th, Nick Gonzales still has a batting average of over .300. I was absolutely convinced this would have shrunk back into the 200s by now, and yet he continues to mash the baseball. He came through Wednesday night with 2 hits and a sac fly to give the Pirates a major boost in a close game. Gonzales won’t hit baseballs incredibly hard, but he has shown development this year in cutting down on strikeouts. With a team that strikes out a ton like the 2026 Pirates, someone who will reliably put the ball in play in all parts of the field is badly needed. He helped the Pirates build an early lead in this game when they couldn’t score with RISP by simply getting a sac fly. These are the small margins the Pirates haven’t been converting in this losing streak. Who would’ve guessed before the season Gonzales would be batting leadoff and no one would be complaining about it?
The Password really struggled in AAA to start the season before coming back from injury and hitting 3 homers in one game for Indianapolis. He went 2-for-5 in this win and manned center field quite well. The biggest compliment I can give him is that he is very competitive with his at-bats, similar to Konnor Griffin when he was called up to the big leagues. With the power Garcia possesses, the ability to play all three outfield positions, and a lack of production from Jake Mangum, the Password should have the talent and the ceiling to stay on the Major League roster when Ryan O’Hearn is finally healthy. It will be a big month for him, as O’Hearn is out for a while and will be given ample time to prove that these good beginnings aren’t just a fluke.
Comments· 0
The Debate
When Jared Jones returns, should Bubba Chandler go to the bullpen so Carmen Mlodzinski stays in the rotation?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.
With Tyler Sweeney and Neil Lucas.
Chapters
Key takeaways
1
With Mlodzinski at a 3.96 ERA over 10 starts and O'Hearn hurt, Bubba Chandler should go to the bullpen when Jared Jones returns. You have to pitch your best five.
2
Counterpoint: Mlodzinski is the one who goes to the pen. Bubba is too valuable to the rotation and the team is counting on him.
3
If Jhostynxon Garcia keeps playing like this, he'll make Jake Mangum redundant very fast. He has far more upside and can play all three outfield spots well.
4
Konnor Griffin's .738 OPS at age 20 puts him 16 points above the rookie Bobby Witt Jr. barometer. If he keeps that up, the Pirates have something special.
5
The Pirates won't be a playoff team if Dennis Santana isn't good.
Alright, what's going on, beautiful people? It's the North Shore Nine podcast presented by FanDuel. I'm Tyler. With me is Neil. We're listening to the North Shore Nine postgame show, Powered by Permanent Brothers, where we're finally giving away sandwiches.
Neil, the Buccos win this one 7-0. It's about time they look okay.
Yeah, what a rough stretch of four games.
Like, it's one of those stretches where, like, the baseball's been so bad that, like, even when they took the lead to start this game, at no point until, say, like, we went up five runs, did I feel comfortable.
It was 3-0, and I wasn't comfortable, you know?
Like, so, good win. Finally, we get one over on the Cardinals this year.
It's been a long time coming, but finally.
God, it's nice to beat the Cardinals, and as our friends here in the chat are mentioning, they might start without the Sammies.
Yeah.
The Sammies are here. Make sure we drop the hashtag, raise it. You'll be entered into the giveaway for some Permanent Brothers sandwiches.
Like I said earlier, the Buccos win this one 7-0 over the Cardinals.
Before I really get into the game, and I'm sorry, if you guys know me, you should know where I'm going with this, but I'm not even going to really talk about the game for, like, just give me one minute here.
One minute.
That tarps-off shit is so annoying.
I hate that so much, and I understand we're people that raise cones and drink out of cones at our tailgate.
God, what a bunch of dorks just out there taking their shirts off, swinging them around, yelling useless stuff.
I hate the Cardinals so much.
Was it because of the Cardinals, or did it remind you of all the rain delay games you've had to do this year?
It's pretty accurate, Neil.
Yeah, here's the thing.
If it was another team doing tarps-off, I think I'd be okay with it.
But, like, people from St. Louis shouldn't be allowed to have fun.
So, like, I don't want to see that.
Get them off the field.
Like, this is the – these guys were nowhere to be seen when the Cardinals went 500.
God forbid you go 500 for a year.
Nowhere to be seen.
They leave the stadium.
They're saying the ownership doesn't care, blah.
And now they come back because they're on a hot streak to start the year.
Yeah, no.
Hate it.
And someone in the chat does mention it.
I think it's actually Steel City DW.
I won't put it up here just because of the swear words on there.
But some of the things they're chanting, like, chill, guys.
Like, come on.
The best fans in baseballs wouldn't do that.
No.
No, it's supposed to be a family-friendly environment for everyone there.
Yeah.
So, piss on the Cardinals.
Yes.
And the Pirates did piss on the Cardinals tonight.
And they did that behind a Konnor Griffin 4-5 performance.
Yeah, it's just, if you told us going into this year that we're in, what, mid-May, late-May, Carmen Mlodzinski started 10 games, 396 ERA over 50 innings,
I think that's something anyone bites their hand off at.
Like, I think that's about as well as you could have possibly hoped it could have gone.
And I understand, like, I think the fact that he hasn't really striking a whole lot of guys out is worrying as a starter.
Like, you're really just not going to get away with that forever.
Yeah.
But, like, for the time being, I think my answer would be move Bubba to the bullpen, because you've got to go, like, unfortunately, especially with O'Hearn injured, like, you can't be potentially throwing games away.
You've got to pitch your best five pitchers.
Yeah, they're going to have some decisions to make there.
I'd probably send Mlodzinski to the bullpen and live with what you have.
Yeah, I guess that's true.
Does Bubba help the bullpen more?
Does it hurt the bullpen?
Like, the bullpen does need the most help.
It does, but I think Mlodzinski is the guy that goes to the pen at that point.
Bubba's too valuable to this team in the rotation, and they need him, and they're counting on him.
But all things considered, Carmen Mlodzinski without an opener, which, did that surprise you that they didn't go an opener tonight?
Not really, but I also, to be honest, I didn't really, the thought didn't even cross my mind until you brought it up.
So, yeah, it was not, it wasn't really of a concern.
Just with, like, Wetherholt's coming up.
Top of the order.
You got to get through him, and my God, that dude's going to be a problem for the Pirates for a long time.
There's something about NL Central guys from Pittsburgh.
There's something about them.
I don't.
He's going to be an issue.
We finally like, were able to deal with Ian Happ now, and now J.J. Wetherholt is coming out of the woodwork.
It's so annoying.
His OPS would be, like, 600 if he didn't play the Pirates ever.
Yeah.
what, two for, two for two off of Mlodzinski to start.
Yeah.
He's going to be a problem.
But I thought they might go with an opener just to, get through that, basically.
Herrera after that today.
And then you got Burleson, another lefty.
It could have been a spot where you maybe give Evan Sisk the opener spot.
But it worked out.
No complaints here.
Yeah.
I'm happy to say something the Pirates did worked out.
Yeah.
Yeah.
you couldn't go to, you couldn't go.
I think they could, because you couldn't go to Montgomery, they're probably not, like, too thrilled at the idea of going to an opener.
Montgomery's been the opener guy.
But, yeah, like, it just, he breathes.
I won't say he breathes through it, but, like, again, I don't think he was really all that much danger going through this.
The 5th inning, I agree.
And he was clearly getting gas.
Yeah.
But I just can't believe that he threw 90, with 5 innings, he threw, what, like, 100 pitches?
95 pitches.
And he only got one strikeout.
That's crazy.
It was definitely a battle.
And I thought it might get away from him there in the 5th.
I'll say this, because I've had an issue with this for the last couple weeks.
He is going to make Jake Mangum redundant very fast if this is how he's going to keep playing.
Because he looks nice.
I like him in center.
I liked him in center tonight.
I liked his bat.
very calm, cool, and collected two for five.
It was huge.
And he's just continuing that hot streak he had after he came back from injury.
I've liked a lot of his at-bats at this point, I think.
I wasn't really enthused by him during, like, when the trade happened.
During spring, I think he started to grow on me a good bit, because you saw how well he played defensively.
You saw the approach change.
The swing and miss stuff is always going to be there a little bit.
But I think you saw pitch selection, swing selection, get a good bit better.
he stays back on a down-and-away slider today.
He's?
It's two games.
So, it is what it is.
But, there's definitely a ton more upside with him than a Jake Mangum that you mentioned.
Yeah, we haven't seen the power at the MLB level yet.
But I agree.
I think we talked a lot about this when Konnor Griffin was coming up.
And, like, everyone was like, there's no reason to panic.
He looks like he belongs.
The two games, I'd say Passford, looks like he belongs.
Yeah.
Very professional at-bats.
And he just happens to be getting on base.
And I understood why people didn't like the trade.
I was iffy on it, because I was a big OV80 guy.
But I do think these are the type of trades you have to make as the Pirates.
You have to be hitting on these guys.
And so, if Garcia is going to be a guy that can be an outfielder for us, that helped us win this year, that's a big trade win for us.
And also, just like you saw today, he's playing center field.
That's huge.
He can play all three.
And he can play all three well.
He can.
And I don't want to gloss over the guy, because he's sitting there on our overlay.
I'm once again going to mention Konnor Griffin had four hits today.
Yeah.
I know they're all singles, so they're not super exciting.
I think one was an infield, at least one was an infield single.
I'm drawing a blank on two of them.
But he hit the ball hard.
I think he topped out at like 111.
Exit velocity.
He's still doing the thing where he's going the other way with it.
At some point, yeah, you want to see him starting to use what his dad called Connor's corner at some point here.
But for a 20-year-old rookie, a 738 OPS almost in the June, I don't have a single complaint.
No, he's 16 points over my Bobby Witt Jr. barometer in terms of OPS.
Like, that's all I care about.
If he's performing like rookie Bobby Witt Jr., we have something good on our hands.
I gotta be honest, it's like watching him, and I don't think it's going to stick, but I'm getting, I get a lot of, like, just from approach at the plate and how he's able to use his speed.
I get a lot of Starling Marte vibes from how he's been playing.
Like, that infield hit where, like, McGeevy didn't get there all that slowly, and it was still not a contest.
And just being able to use that speed, being a terror on the base pass, like how fast he can go first to third, he's just going to steal hits in a way that I don't think we've had since a Starling Marte-type player.
I don't know, like, it's a fun player, and if the power comes along, then that's just a really unfair player to have on your team, too.
Like, Starling Marte with 25-30 homerun power is a crazy good player.
And I know metrics haven't loved him to this point, defensively at least, but I think he's played a very good shortstop.
I think early on, he got screwed with the metrics, and no, he didn't play as well as he could have right off the bat, but this last probably four or five weeks or so, he has been really good defensively at shortstop.
And, that's the position that we were worried about, maybe wrongfully so, because the outfield's a nightmare, but he has played really well defensively, I think.
Yeah, it was crazy, like, when, I don't think it's right, I don't think it is right now, but I think Savant had him at, like, first percentile range at shortstop.
And I think anyone who watched him with their eyes were like, that's absurd.
Like, and no, he looks the part, as Jim says, like, he's a three DRS, you know.
So, like, I don't know, like, I feel like he does everything well.
Like, I'm not going to say superstar at anything yet, but again, he's a 20-year-old rookie.
So, yeah, just an impressive day from him.
I think he had a really nice hit opposite field today, too, like, using all parts of the field.
I love watching him play.
It's nice.
I'm glad we excited, dude.
Yeah.
Before we get into the rest of this thing, let's go ahead and kick it over to Cody to tell you folks about the IQ Bar.
This episode is brought to you by IQ Bar, our exclusive snack hydration and sponsor.
IQ Bar protein bars, IQ Mix hydration mixes, and IQ Joe mushroom coffees are the delicious, low-sugar, brain and body fuel you need to win your day.
The Ultimate Sampler Pack is a great way for you to try all IQ Bar products and flavors.
You get nine IQ Bars, eight IQ Mix sticks, and four IQ Joe sticks.
All IQ Bar products are clean label certified and entirely free from gluten, dairy, soy, GMOs, and artificial ingredients.
With over 20,000 five-star reviews and counting, more people than ever are fueling their lifestyles with IQ Bars' brain and body boosting bars, hydration mixes, and mushroom coffees.
The Ultimate Sampler Pack includes all three.
My personal favorites so far have been the Almond Butter Chip and the Iced Tea Lemonade Hydration Mix.
It's just really full of flavor.
I love starting my day with it, and I couldn't imagine starting my day with anything else other than IQ Bar products.
Right now, IQ Bar is offering our podcast listeners 20% off all IQ Bar products, including the Ultimate Sampler Pack, plus free shipping.
To get your 20% off, text MLB to 64000.
That's MLB 64000.
Message and data rates may apply.
See terms for details.
What's that number again?
64000?
64000.
And make sure we drop the hashtag raises here in the chat.
Yeah.
Let's get them up.
How many are we at right now?
We are currently at 104 entries, which, come on, those are rookie numbers.
Let's bump those up.
The four-game losing streak hurt a lot of, hurt a lot of morale.
It did.
But hey, the Buccos are not under 500.
No.
Just stay above it.
Thank God.
Good for fifth into the division because life sucks.
But that, you know what?
You never know.
Never know what could happen.
The Bucs have to start losing since like 90% of their starters are injured, but who knows?
Another piece of today's game I wanted to talk about a little bit, and we're seeing it play out a little bit with the lineup.
Endy Roderick gets another start.
The catching situation, Neil.
We're seeing a little bit of a timeshare with Endy and Henry right now.
I'm seeing that with Joey Bart as well.
But I don't know if I expected it with Endy coming up.
I thought maybe Henry would take the lion's share.
Endy does have two hits today.
He finishes two for three.
Walks twice.
The at-bats look significantly better than Henry Davis' at-bats, and that bar is extremely low.
Don't get me wrong.
Yeah.
The at-bats are significantly better.
Where are you at with that?
Yeah, it's definitely better than Endy.
It's definitely better than Davis just fouling balls offensively.
So, like, every time he barrels it.
I'm trying to temper expectations.
Just, he didn't hit very well in AAA.
Right.
And he just doesn't hit the ball very hard for me to, like, really believe that this is, like, a sustainable thing.
But at the same time, when your catchers are, like, your other two catchers can't hit the baseball, you got to ride this out.
So, cautiously optimistic, but I'm not willing to say, like, yeah, he's our future starting catcher.
Like, I understand that's watching a Davis bat, but I do think his value to the pitching staff can't be understated.
I would fully agree with that, because I think, even just watching the day, like, I've always been pretty high on Endy's upside defensively.
Like, I just think he can, I think he can move really well back there.
I think the twitchiness is really good.
I think the framing can be really good.
He's just a little bit sloppy, I think.
And, like, Henry just is very polished back there right now.
I think he, we know he calls a really good game.
Obviously, like, Endy must have called a good game at night.
And if we're going to give catchers kudos every time a guy throws, or the pitching staff throws a shutout, you got to give Endy some credit here.
But, there was that pop-up today that was a little bit messy.
There's some balls in the dirt, or some curveballs, or sliders that he looks a little bit iffy on.
There's also the arm issues, two-elbow issues in three years is going to cause some concern.
But there comes a point where you can't be awful offensively like Henry Davis has been.
No, that's fair.
I think the biggest thing Henry has over Endy is just time with a lot of these guys.
Henry got to catch the vast majority of these guys in AAA before he even got to the majors, while Endy was recovering from a whole lot of injuries.
So, like, I do think that helps Henry a lot, because I think he's just way more comfortable with these guys.
But, yeah, there is some diminishing returns when your OPS is in the 400s.
it calls to mind a catcher we used to have, and we didn't like him very much when he started lecturing us about the intricacies of catching, which is not what you want from your number one overall pick.
Yeah, and I think Davis is certainly capable of being a really good backup catcher in this league, which I never thought I would say because I didn't think he would ever be able to catch.
But, he's a hell of a defensive catcher.
It's just upside-wise, man.
Like, Endy has that upside to me.
And watching Henry Davis swing the bat makes my eyes bleed.
You don't like the little spring action he's got going on?
I haven't seen that dude hit a ball to center field while he hit one this week, probably, or over the weekend.
But, very few balls go up the middle with Henry Davis.
And watching Endy at the plate is just so much more watchable.
When Davis finally learns not to get under every single baseball, it's over.
It's over for the league.
Yeah, I feel like you just got to keep giving Endy starts if he's going to keep hitting like this.
Really good showing tonight.
Yeah, big part of the win.
Let's talk about the bullpen a little bit here.
We always have to.
We always have to touch on it.
He made it painful there for a second.
Like, Yohan Ramirez, there is a point, and I tweeted it, getting out should not be this difficult.
I thought we were losing.
Like, when Yohan hit his second batter, I'm like, all right, well, it was nice while it lasted.
It was nice.
But now I'm going to have to get on and talk about another loss.
oh, my gosh.
I can't believe we got out of that inning on scathe.
Yeah, it was ugly there.
Yohan does get through, and it happens with, I believe, yeah, that was the same inning, the Jake Mangum play back by the wall, which, to be fair, Jake Mangum made that look a lot more difficult than it should have.
My podcast thought it was the best catch you've ever seen.
I feel like most right fielders make that play.
most right fielders catch that or are under that ball before.
Moving on after that, because naturally we're going way more positive.
Justin Lawrence comes in after that.
Who was not either placed on the IAL or DFA today.
But he does get two strikeouts.
And it was one of those days where the stuff looked nasty.
And maybe that's just because they were in a big lead.
He didn't really didn't have to worry about it.
Yeah, Yohan.
That's the Justin Lawrence that's good.
Yohan into Sisk into Lawrence and you don't give up a run out of that.
That's a big win.
Yeah.
Can't complain.
We got to do that when it's a one run game, too, though.
Like, it's got to happen when we're not up seven runs.
But you know what?
At this point, we can't we can't be complaining.
Yeah.
And you mentioned Yohan briefly there.
But like, Yohan came in a tight game and it was ugly, but he got through it.
After that, the Pirates added on and were able to hold him after that.
So a lot of these guys, you want to see them do it in a tighter game, but I'm convinced for you that ball, the one that made the main gum adventure play.
Did you think that was going off the bat?
I certainly did.
I thought it was going off the wall.
OK.
I was like, that's a home run if I've ever seen one.
If I say that was going to be a home run, then I wouldn't be able to criticize the play.
Fair enough.
And Dennis Santana misses bats finally again.
Nice to see him just slowly get on track.
Yeah, we need him.
They need him bad.
We can.
We're not going to we're not going to be a playoff team if Dennis Santana is not good.
Yeah.
Full disclosure here.
I miss that Dennis Santana outing because I was trying to set up the show and it happened very quickly.
Which is good.
That's that was like early season Santana.
We're like, oh, you look down and suddenly there's two outs like it's.
That's the good stuff.
That's the good stuff.
Yeah, he was good.
Mostly everyone was good.
Yeah.
it's nice having a clean bullpen performance.
Yeah.
Once again, the Buccos win this one.
Seven, nothing.
You ready to give away some Sammies here?
Yeah, let's give away some sandwiches.
All right.
Let me remember how to do this because.
No more.
All right.
Screwy.
All right.
We are up to 119 entries here.
Let's go ahead and.
Pretty good.
The first drop.
If you haven't gotten it in yet, make sure you drop that hashtag.
Raise it.
And here we go.
Our first winner.
Is going to be.
Harley.
Congratulations.
Harley.
Fan of the show.
At most of our tailgates.
You know where to find us.
Send us an email with your email that is associated with your Permanent Brothers account.
Congratulations.
Let's move on to the next one.
Winner number two.
Dbauer12.
Congratulations.
Send us over your email associated with your Permanent Brothers account.
You can send that to NorthshoreNight at gmail.com.
And we will get those loaded on there for you.
Congratulations.
Both of our winners here.
Get that set back up.
Buccos win this one.
7-0.
it's nice.
Like, nice, easy win.
Nice, easy win.
Arsenal wins the Premier League.
It's been a good week.
Who cares about whatever you just said?
I don't even know.
Sorry.
Not everyone can be as cultured as I am.
Well, if you'd like to win some more sandwiches here.
According to FanDuel, the Buccos are favored tomorrow.
Minus 130 to get a win over the Cardinals.
Afternoon game.
Pop on in.
Get some more Sammies.
Why not?
Yeah.
It'll be fun.
All right, Neil.
You got anything else for tonight?
No, I'm good.
Let's get out of here.
Get out of here with the win.
Thank you all for hanging out.
We'll be back with you guys tomorrow.
And then we should have a North Shore Nine live tomorrow.
I think it's just going to be me and DiNardo.
But since Jim's out gallivanting the world as usual.
As always, man never works a day in his life.
Exactly.
All right, folks.
Appreciate you all for hanging out.
We're out of here.
Peace out, Griscouts.
All right.
That wraps up this episode of North Shore Nine.
Thanks so much for tuning in.
Whether you're listening on the podcast or catching us on YouTube, if you enjoyed the show, please give this video a thumbs up.
And don't forget to hit that subscribe button if you haven't already.
It really helps us grow.
And if you're listening on the podcast, a quick review goes a long way in helping others find the show.
Plus, be sure to tell a friend about us.
There's always room for more here in the NS9 community.
And for those looking to support us a little more, consider joining our Patreon, become an MVP member, and get exclusive perks while helping us continue to bring you more of the Pirates content you love.
Comments· 0
When Jared Jones returns, should Bubba Chandler go to the bullpen so Carmen Mlodzinski stays in the rotation?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.