◆NEWS2026 Non-Tenders: National League◆ROSTERRHP Noah Murdock elected free agency◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSPlayers Avoiding Arbitration Prior To The 2026 Non-Tender Deadline◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers
◆NEWS2026 Non-Tenders: National League◆ROSTERRHP Noah Murdock elected free agency◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSPlayers Avoiding Arbitration Prior To The 2026 Non-Tender Deadline◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers
Henry Davis belted a solo home run in the 7th inning to give the Pirates a 2-1 win over the Cubs on Memorial Day. Davis’ 4th home run was the difference in this one as Carmen Mlodzinski, Wilber Dotel and Gregory Soto combine to limit the Cubs to one run in a low-scoring affair. The Pirates move to 28-26 on the season and will continue their seven-game homestand. Cody and Doug recapped this win on the NS9 Postgame Show powered by Primanti’s Bros. You can watch/listen here:
I won’t lie to our followers—I was very concerned about how in the world the Pirates bullpen was going to cover four innings in a low-scoring, tight ballgame. At one point Justin Lawrence was warming up, and I was even more concerned. But Don Kelly called on Wilber Dotel and stayed with him for three huge innings and he was electric. Dotel saved the game for the Pirates in my opinion. It can’t be understated that he pitched the 6th, 7th and 8th innings and allowed just one run while striking out four and NO walks, which is huge for this bullpen. Dotel has looked so good and I love that they brought him back up to pitch out of the pen.
Dotel to the pen was move number one to help fix this bullpen. Move number two will likely be Carmen Mlodzinski to the bullpen when Jared Jones is activated. And more three and beyond comes at the deadline when you have to pick up an arm or two. Mlodzinski pitched well and got through five with just one run allowed, but I’ve said this before—I just like what he can provide for the bullpen in a multitude of different roles. I think this was his last start in the rotation for now.
Alex Stumpf talked about the Pirates moving Spencer Horwitz up in the lineup on Monday’s episode of OffBeat, which you can listen to here:
Horwitz is now sporting at .389 on-base percentage, and the Pirates moved him up to leadoff Sunday in the finale in Toronto and Horwitz homered on the first pitch he saw for his 5th of the season. He led off again Monday and went 2-for-3 with a walk and a run scored. Why not get that .389 OBP at the top of the lineup? I liked Oneil Cruz in the leadoff spot as well, but he’s been struggling as of late and is not as consistent in getting on base as Horwitz is. Plus, with Ryan O’Hearn out, you kinda need Cruz in the middle of the order with his power. And so far so good as Horwitz has continued to produce in the leadoff spot past two games.
In his career coming into Monday’s game, Horwitz has led off 41 times in his career and is slashing .298/.372/.466 with 6 HRs in that leadoff spot. That’s an .838 OPS. That’ll play. I would leave him in that spot for now against righties.
PLEASE STACK WINS!
This game was probably the worst pitching matchup of the Cubs series that the Pirates would have, and they got out of here with a 2-1 win. I’ve been banging the table for them to start stacking some wins at home and go from around .500 to six, seven, eight games over .500 and get ahead of some of the teams in your division finally. Every time this team takes a step forward, it always seems like they take two steps back. But this week is a big opportunity with a seven-game homestand against a division rival and then the Twins. And so far, you’re 1-0 on the homestand and 28-26 overall. Please don’t go backward. Let’s continue to pitch well, score runs and put a nice stretch of games together. I’m not saying to 7-0 this homestand (sure would be nice though), but let’s win five-of-six and start putting things together.
Monday was a nice start and win against the Cubs, who by the way have now dropped nine straight games. Let’s keep winning and pass them in the standings. Fly that L, Chicago.
Comments· 2
The Debate
Should Spencer Horwitz replace Oneil Cruz as the Pirates' leadoff hitter?
Pete G.🐣Prospect· 180d ago
Well Said, How about a 4 game Sweep against the Cubs ?
Ryan🐣Prospect· 179d ago
Thanks, Pete. We are halfway there! Hopefully Bubba Chandler can keep it going today against old friend Taillon.
With Cody Kohlman and Doug Ford.
Chapters
Key takeaways
1
Carmen Mlodzinski shouldn't be the one bumped from the rotation when Jared Jones comes up. He's learning to start at the big-league level and has done everything to prove he belongs.
2
Wilber Dotel's 5.00 ERA at Triple-A came from starting. He fits best as a two-to-four-inning long reliever, which is the way teams used to develop starting pitchers.
3
Don Kelly was right to fight the Griffin call, but he was wrong to keep arguing after New York confirmed it on replay. Frustration over missed check swings all season is what's really behind it.
4
Spencer Horwitz should lead off instead of Oneil Cruz. Horwitz has a career 135 wRC+ in the leadoff spot and 19 walks there, while Cruz runs too hot and cold for the top of the order.
5
Marcell Ozuna should bat seventh to ninth, behind Jhostynxon Garcia and Konnor Griffin. Moving him down isn't a demotion but another chance to drive guys in.
That first inning was seven, three pop-ups, seven pitches.
Seven pitches, three pop-ups.
I was quite excited.
And like Greg Brown said on the broadcast, thank you to the S&P stats department.
They found out this was the first time since 1993 that there was a first inning, one, two, three inning with all three outcomes.
Tim Wakefield.
R.I.P.
Tim Wakefield.
Man.
R.I.P.
You young people don't know.
That 92 season...
I don't even know.
He came up on, I think, July 31st against the Cardinals on a Friday night and struck out 10 Cardinals.
I was, my friends and I were supposed to go out and I'm like, I can't, I'm sorry, the game's on ESPN, this guy, first time, no, we can drink all night long.
I'm like, you know.
That's like the opposite of what happened in Good Will Hunting.
Yeah, exactly.
I don't need to find about a girl.
I don't need to see a girl.
I gotta watch this game.
Yeah.
Sadly, I married that girl and that did not work out well.
One in seven.
So, Carmen Mijinsky starts the game.
Like we said, he was dope.
He went...
What were the numbers here, Doug?
86 and 50.
Not bad.
We like that.
He goes five innings, gives up five hits.
One earned run on that home run.
Three walks, two strikeouts.
So, wouldn't say he burned down anybody, but he was consistent and he pitched well.
And, like, if you didn't look at the stat line...
You'd probably say, that was a great outing.
He gave up a run.
It was phenomenal.
You know what I'm saying?
He gave up a run.
Look, he was seven pitches in the first inning.
After two, it was 23.
So, and then the third inning, he was like 46.
he lost what he had going there early on.
But because, again, because of two good innings, like he was able to go through, he was effective.
He handled them.
again, Carmen Mijinsky is theoretically our fifth starter.
Right?
he is a back-end rotation guy.
He's a guy that we're always talking about being on the bubble, that thing.
And he went five innings and gave up a run.
Yeah.
You just can't, you can't ask for any more than that.
Sure.
Would I like six or seven innings?
Absolutely.
Five innings, he gave up a run.
He did an outstanding job.
he's turning, look, he's new to starting, right?
yes, he did some of the minors that he had at college, but then they converted him to a bullpen.
he's learning at the major league level.
And I'm not in such a hurry to get him out of the rotation.
I obviously want Jared Jones up here in the rotation.
I want to see what he's capable of.
But, Carmen Mijinsky isn't necessarily the guy that I would remove.
And I know what a weapon he is in the bullpen.
Yeah.
I know what a weapon he is.
And that's what I'm starting to realize here, Doug, is like all year long, we're like, well, we know Mijinsky's best in the bullpen.
We know that's where he's going to do this team the best, is if he's coming out of the bullpen.
But he's done everything to prove that he is a starting pitcher.
And today proved that as well.
Like I said, he didn't burn anything down.
He wasn't lights out.
No.
He only gave up one run.
He was effective.
He wasn't shoving, as the kids like to say.
Right.
He was exactly what you want as a fifth starter.
And I think today made that conversation even harder when it does come to bring up Jared Jones of who's going to go in that bullpen.
Who's coming out of the rotation?
I just.
Could they go six man?
Could they do a six man rotation?
You know.
That to me doesn't make sense right now.
But you are going to have to start saving these arms, right?
Maybe giving them a little more rest.
Right.
But right now it's like, what do you do?
It's a big, it's a, it's a good situation you want to be in.
You're glad that you have that question mark.
No.
Right.
The problems, the problems of deciding, which good thing to do.
Right.
It's so much better than the problems we've had in the past with, what's the lesser of the two evils?
now we're looking for the greater of the two goods.
Right.
It's not, yeah, it's no longer what's the lesser of two evils.
It's just which of these good outcomes has a better ROI.
Right.
Right.
And we're, yeah, we're not, we're not giving a guy a job, right?
These guys have earned jobs and, competition is there, right?
You don't think Carmen Bajinsky knows that Jared Jones is available to start in four or five.
he started last night, so he could start in four days.
You don't, you don't think Carmen Bajinsky is aware of that.
You don't think it's maybe helping his focus and raising his game.
I believe it is.
Right.
But, yeah, just like I said, he wasn't striking people out.
But look, like we said, the three pop outs in the first.
Then you have a fly out and a ground out.
Gives up a single, a walk, and then strikes out Swanson.
I keep my notes.
I keep track of what everybody did in every at-bat.
Speaking of, PCA hates Spencer Horwitz, and Horwitz just loves to laugh at him.
But, yeah, just like you look at the outcomes of all these at-bats against Bajinsky, and you're just like, that's a stopper right there.
He stopped this lineup that, to be fair, hasn't been hot.
Like we said, they're on eight game losing streak coming into this game.
But they're also a team that could spark at any second.
And he just doused them with water.
Well, over the past seven years, how often is like, again, even today, the Cubs pitcher went his career high in innings.
You know what I'm saying?
Like, over the years, we have been the bomb to soothe, a limping and hurt team.
You can't tell me the Cubs weren't a little excited about coming to Pittsburgh, given the history they've had with us.
gosh, I don't know, the last 10 years has just been terrible how they've just, taken our lunch money every single series.
And that, Carmen Bajinsky, again, a guy who's battling for his spot, comes in and, shuts him down for five innings.
their pitcher has been pitching pretty well.
We got just enough out of him.
And, yeah, this is, to me, this game is a step forward and, it's hard to isolate when that'll be.
And, if they lose the next three or blah.
But this is so often, this was a surefire loss.
Like I said, I went into this game just nervous.
Like, it's just, oh, here we go.
Oh, look at, look at this, man.
Our people are fantastic.
There we go.
They're just fantastic.
Hey, you guys, can either of you explain to me why the heck Dotel was rotting in Indy the past month while the Penn stunk would have won four more games with him.
And I think that's a great way, Doug, to transition.
Thank you, Michael B., for the $5 donation.
We appreciate that.
But I do think this is a great way to segue into Dotel and just talk about how dominant he was today.
Like, oh, I forgot to change the bottom here.
Did I, did I put it in here?
I did.
That's what it should say.
Sorry.
No vacancy at the Wilbur.
This dude was insane today.
He had four strikeouts in three innings.
He's that long.
Like, I've said this before, I feel, is that Dotel is that long reliever.
He's that guy that's going to go in there for more than just an inning and be able to handle himself because he's a guy that I think they eventually want to put in the rotation.
Like, they're not going to shy away from giving this guy innings, and guess what they did?
They gave him innings today, Doug, and he was extremely effective.
Yeah.
In fairness, he was not pitching that well at Indy.
His ERA at Indy was five.
So that might be part of the reason.
He came up here and he's been, wow.
Since he's been up here, he's been really good.
not since his entire, times that he's been here, he's been quite, pitched quite well.
Look, all of this good pitching and, there's still guys like Antwone Kelly down there.
And, obviously some of these guys coming up along the way.
It's going to make some, for some interesting decisions.
And, I think we'll see some trade, like, there's a, you can never have enough pitching, but everybody's after it.
If you can get someone to overpay for one of these guys, you might have to take advantage of that.
So, yeah, it was, that Dotel, got four strikeouts, three innings.
He gave up one hit.
He didn't walk anybody.
I, what more can you ask for?
All right.
again, it's just outstanding.
A stellar outing from a young guy against a good team, albeit a good team, not playing well.
there's, Greg Brown talked about the hidden vigorous.
Like, look, they're all due.
You know what I'm saying?
they are due.
They're due to run off a 10-game win streak because, they're now lost nine straight.
And they're like I said, two at 13 or something.
baseball, things balance out over a long season.
And let's get through these next three games.
Let's smack them around.
Let's, just suck the soul right out of them and then let them balance out.
Right.
But, yeah, back to Dotel.
I know you mentioned his AAA ERA.
It was high.
But do we think that's because he was a starting pitcher in AAA?
Like I said, like, I think this is the spot for him right now is to come in as the long relief guy, do two to three, maybe four innings if you really need it, if somebody blows up at the beginning of a game.
like Yohan Ramirez was doing early on in the season.
To have that long relief guy that you don't need to rely on him for the, to go five innings as a starter.
I think that's going to help him a lot.
You know who liked that performance more than anybody?
And there, Paul Ols mentions Greg Brown's Mr. Ed reference.
A horse is a horse, of course, of course, unless, of course, though.
Yeah.
I know Mr. Ed.
I had no clue.
My brother had to point it out to me.
It was funny, though.
it is from, it is from the 60s.
Right.
That's why I was shocked my brother knew, because he's only 40 years older than me.
I was 42, I think, when that show came out.
But yeah, like you're saying, like, bringing up these young guys to fill these spots.
It's what they need to do.
And I understand why it's taking it a little longer.
You want them to get their bearings about them.
Right?
Some of these guys have just been called up to AAA as well.
Like, Bidouin spent most of last year, I believe, in AAA.
So it's like, he had to get his bearings about him in AAA.
And now he's here in the majors.
And Bidouin is doing pretty decent.
And similar thing with Dotel.
He started, I believe, in AA.
Went to AAA, I think, at the end of the year last year.
Started there this year.
Like you said, had the 5 ERA.
But my caveat is, he's a starter.
And that means there's more room for error there.
If you put him in these isolated situations where he's only pitching one to three innings a game, I think he's going to give you a lot more.
Again, those of you who don't get the Mr. Ed reference, also don't get it.
This is how you develop starting pitchers back in the day.
There were four-man rotations and not five-man rotations.
And you had guys that would pitch out of the bullpen.
They were called long men.
You would bring up a rookie.
I remember guys like Bruce Keeson, like World Series hero type guys.
He'd come up.
He'd pitch out.
He would start the second game of a doubleheader.
We had a lot of doubleheaders back then.
Then he would pitch.
A game would be stopped for rain.
He'd come back and pitch the last six innings, that thing.
That's how you develop your starting pitchers.
They didn't just come from AA or come from AAA and just zip right into the rotation like they do now.
You let them learn at the major league level.
And so this is just a great way.
Again, if you have Dottella up here and he's giving you three innings here, three innings there, that thing.
And if somebody gets hurt or somebody becomes ineffective or, like I said, rain delay situation, doubleheader, you've got this guy right there.
So, yeah, it's great.
It's a great way.
It's a great way to develop these guys.
It's a great way, as you said, to get their feet wet.
And, baseball is a different game now.
You're going to use five pitchers a game, it seems like.
So you want a guy.
You need a guy that could be effective like that and come in and just handle his business.
But now we'll move on to the man of the ninth, the new closer.
We've got to call him that, Doug.
I know you don't like it, but you've got to go with Soto as a closer.
I want Dennis Santana to be elite.
I don't care if it's in the eighth inning or ninth inning.
Because I liked, early last year, we, when Bednar was still here and that thing, we pitched.
We'd bring him in at the most important time of the game.
He'd come in the, sixth inning with two guys on and then out and then pitch, one and two third innings.
I'm all for that with my guy.
I just want to get him back.
he can pitch.
He can be an opener every time.
I just want him to be effective again.
And your puppy's in the background backing you up.
I can hear.
He's like, listen, he's talking about.
Yeah.
Boo supports that tape.
Exactly.
But Soto comes in and Soto is lights out.
He threw 14 pitches, just looked like nobody was going to get anything on him.
He strikes out the first two batters.
Looked like he was about to strike out Carson Kelly.
Carson Kelly grounds out to, I believe, second base.
Bing, bang, boom, zip, cap, zap, kazoo, whatever you want to say.
The Pirates beat the Cubs, and it was on the backs of the pitching.
Yeah.
They were the stars of the game for sure.
Yeah.
It's, that's, this team needs good pitching to win, right?
This team is based.
Its strength is pitching.
And Soto, we feel good about him again, right?
We got a little nervous there.
We got a little nervous.
And, yeah, he was, he was lights out.
And he's been lights out, I think, his last two appearances.
And, I'm here for it.
It's, it just reminds me of so many games of my youth.
these two to one quick afternoon, played in daylight type things.
And, yeah, just everybody comes in and just does their job.
It's great.
Yeah, the pitching was great today.
And before we get to the hitting, we got to throw it over to our friends at IQ Bar.
This episode is brought to you by IQ Bar, our exclusive snack hydration and sponsor.
IQ Bar protein bars, IQ Mix hydration mixes, and IQ Joe mushroom coffees are the delicious, low-sugar, brain and body fuel you need to win your day.
The Ultimate Sampler Pack is a great way for you to try all IQ Bar products and flavors.
You get nine IQ Bars, eight IQ Mix Sticks, and four IQ Joe Sticks.
All IQ Bar products are clean label certified and entirely free from gluten, dairy, soy, GMOs, and artificial ingredients.
With over 20,000 five-star reviews and counting, more people than ever are fueling their lifestyles with IQ Bar's brain and body boosting bars, hydration mixes, and mushroom coffees.
The Ultimate Sampler Pack includes all three.
My personal favorites so far have been the Almond Butter Chip and the Iced Tea Lemonade Hydration Mix.
It's just really full of flavor.
I love starting my day with it.
And I couldn't imagine starting my day with anything else other than IQ Bar products.
Right now, IQ Bar is offering our podcast listeners 20% off all IQ Bar products, including the Ultimate Sampler Pack, plus free shipping.
To get your 20% off, text MLB to 64000.
That's MLB 64000.
Message and data rates may apply.
See terms for details.
So, Doug, the bats were a little, I don't know, slow to get started today.
But I really want to pick up the offense with this Konnor Griffin hit-by-pitch situation where Don Kelly gets thrown out of the game after a challenge.
So, what I saw, what I understood to be happening, which was wrong, I will preface that my thoughts on this were wrong.
Like I said, I was having a hard time focusing, really.
And it was just a lot going on at that point.
It looked like Griffin got hit by a pitch.
And he was taking his things off.
And he was walking to first.
And then I missed the part where the umpire said he didn't get hit by the pitch.
So, my understanding of this, while I'm watching, is that Don Kelly is saying, no, he didn't get hit by the pitch.
And then they prove him correct.
And then Kelly argued it anyway.
So, I'm confused at this whole situation.
And it turns out, no, the umpire did not think he got hit.
The replay comes in.
And I will say, I don't think he got hit by the pitch.
Every single replay I saw at the beginning was like, I don't think it hit him.
And Greg Brown keeps saying, he ran to first base.
Why else did he run to first base?
He ran to first base after he got the ball hit off the knob of his bat.
The kid knows how to sell it.
That's what you do as a batter.
You're supposed to sell it.
Like, that's the name of the game.
Now, when they show after it was resolved and, Donnie was out, they showed one where they kept, look at the seams.
It did look, maybe it hit his helmet and veered off, but not enough to overturn it.
No.
Right?
That's the other thing.
You need this.
So, I thought, we should read this.
We got to thank, we got to thank Michael there.
We'll get to it.
We have to talk about this.
We have a Marcell Ozuna problem.
It's getting worse.
I would sit in more games and move him to seventh or eighth.
He stinks.
We will get to that.
We will get to that.
But thank you for the $5 donation.
Thank you for reminding us, Michael.
Yes.
But yeah, like it just, even the case, even the case that the seam started to move differently.
No, I don't think that was the case.
I don't.
Yeah.
Yeah.
I'm sure we have Twitter to look at.
We have all these other resources to look at, but that's exactly what New York is looking at.
Also, they have the tools to freeze frame this, to look at it at every angle that they have and determine that this did not hit Konnor Griffin.
And it didn't.
Now I do commend Kelly for arguing the call, like, but to the same extent you did that after the challenge.
He was complaining after the challenge, and it's like, you can't do that.
Once the challenge is challenged and it's confirmed by New York, that's the call.
Like, that's, you just, you can't do that.
Steel City DW, man.
Just gifted 10 memberships.
Welcome to our 10 new members.
Thank you there, Steel City.
It just, our fans are the best.
Our chat people are just great.
Can't wait to see you in a couple weeks.
But, yeah, just, like, Kelly arguing that after the fact, I think it's just, like, I think it's just a case of things have been building up over the season.
He may have had a barbecue to go to.
Maybe.
seriously, he might have had a barbecue to go to.
He is a Pittsburgher, probably had a little barbecue to go to.
when the craving hits, he couldn't wait to the end of our show, to enter, to get his hashtag raised, get it in there, and win some sandwiches to Permane's.
He had to run out, and, he was craving the slaw.
What can I say?
But, yeah.
Like, looking back at the last couple of days as well, he got tossed in Toronto as well.
Same with Phil Murphy.
They both get tossed in that one game.
And it's like, okay, what do we do?
Like, I think there's just frustration on what's happening behind the plate with some of the calls, mainly the calls of swing, like, check swings.
And I'll be honest myself.
It seems as though the umpires don't know what a check swing is anymore.
Yeah.
And umpires used to be very good at that.
Yeah.
There used to be a lot more consistency with check swings.
It's like, look, boys, you've only got one job left.
We've got balls and strikes covered.
You've just got to be able to tell if he swung or not.
That went against the other night.
That still annoys me.
It really seemed like there used to be a lot of consistency with the check swing, and it just doesn't seem like it's there this year.
So I think that's where a lot of this frustration is coming from, is that Don Kelly is just like, he's tired of it.
He's tired of what's going on behind the plate and missing calls and all this stuff.
And I don't agree that he should have argued the call after the challenge.
But I think beforehand, yes, you should go back there and be like, listen, this has been happening all year.
Nobody knows what's going on.
And then you say, let's challenge it.
You know?
Like, that just seems like the course of action that should have happened.
Yeah, it's, and ultimately we got a better result because the guy had to throw a few more pitches, right?
You know what?
The guy threw more pitches and Connor still got on base.
So, yeah.
And then, unfortunately, Garcia grounds out into a double play.
Yeah.
Now, I don't know.
Was that Ozuna or Garcia?
It was Garcia.
Yeah, it was.
Okay.
Yeah.
We're still happy with him.
But, yeah, it's, it didn't seem that big a deal.
I don't think that, obviously his ejection didn't fire up the team or, there was no tangible benefit from it or anything like that.
I don't, even us who want to criticize every single thing he does, I don't think we'd have said, man, he needs to get out there and fight for Connor and show that, it's just like, it seemed like a weird spot to do that.
But, hey, whatever.
You just don't know.
You don't know, like, that home plate umpire may have blown a call last year that Don Kelly still pissed him.
But, there's, that's one of the great things about baseball.
I still remember a guy telling a story, like, in spring training, a guy hit him, he went out and charged the mound, or he threw close, and he charged the mound.
And they're like, why'd you do that?
Eight years ago, he hit me, you know.
And this is my first, like, he had switched from American League to that, whatever.
So, these guys hold grudges, you know.
Now, Doug, I know you say, hey, it didn't fire up the guys, but you look at the bottom of third, the very next inning, I know you have a Davis strikeout, but then Horwitz gets on.
And then Brandon Lowe hits his 12th double of the season and hits in Horwitz.
So, that gets us on the board.
I want to ask you about Horwitz at leadoff.
Because DiNardo, probably your all-time favorite person.
I am prepared, Doug.
I have notes on that.
Your all-time favorite person calls Oneil Cruz the catalyst.
And every time he does that, I always want to quote, what was her name?
Regina?
Regina George?
No.
Mean Girls?
Mean Girls, yes.
And say, fetch isn't going to happen, right?
You know?
Fetch isn't going to happen there, DiNardo.
But, you know.
Oh, man.
And then our Alex Stumpf today on Offbeat was discussing why he thinks that Horwitz should be the leadoff hitter.
And I think he's persuaded me.
I love our corporate overlords.
I love DiNardo.
I've got to get on record with saying that.
But I think maybe Spencer Horwitz might be the better leadoff hitter.
And he's got a 381.
Well, I don't know what it is now.
But coming into the game, it was a 381 on-base percentage.
And I do, like Oneil Cruz in the middle of the lineup.
And where do you fall?
Who do you want to be the leadoff hitter?
So, Alex did have Offbeat this morning.
I have not listened to it yet.
Now I'm starting to wish that I did.
Yeah, you're missing out.
It was good.
You should all go back and listen.
I'm definitely listening after this.
It's just, you know.
I worked those off hours.
So, I woke up right before the game started.
I had to focus on one thing.
But during the game, I did look up Spencer Horwitz's career leadoff stats.
He's a 298 hitter with a 327 on-base percentage and 466 slugging.
Altogether, he's a 135 WRC+.
I know DiNardo and Jim go crazy for those numbers.
I love WRC+.
Looking at it, compared to other spots that he's been put in the lineup.
He's been put in the lineup at fourth the majority of his career.
But he has better stats as a leadoff hitter.
So, it's hard to compare because he's only been batting leadoff for half the time he's been batting fourth in the lineup.
Where he has some of his better stats.
But the average is better at first.
He has more...
He doesn't have the same RBIs.
He doesn't have more RBIs.
But, comparatively speaking, in the lesser amount of at-bats, he has more RBIs.
He's getting on base more that way.
He's, like you said, Doug, he's that catalyst.
He's the guy that needs to be first in the lineup.
He knows how to get on base.
He draws the walks.
He has 19 walks in the leadoff spot.
it's trending that direction that Spencer Horwitz is your leadoff guy.
He's not the power hitter that we thought he would be.
He is the guy that's going to get things started.
Yeah.
And he's definitely going to be more consistent than Cruz.
Right?
Yeah.
Exactly.
The consistency as well.
Michael B.
Michael B. is spending like a drunken sailor, and we love it.
So, I'm hoping that Spencer's leadoff.
It wasn't working with Cruz, in my opinion.
I thought Nicky G would be good there because he's hitting over 300 and gets on base a lot and has speed.
Yeah.
I would, Cruz is not the prototype leadoff hitter.
It's worked a lot of ways.
he has been a catalyst quite a bit, but I do think Spencer Horwitz is better.
I would like to see Cruz in a position to drive in more runs and take advantage of that power some.
And just quite frankly, he's not as consistent.
And one of the things I really, value from a leadoff, from any hitter, obviously, but it's consistency.
If you can get a guy on first base to start a game is quite a lot.
That's a good thing, you know.
So, I think I'm on board.
I think Alex Stumpf, once again, has made great points.
That's why you should be listening to OffBeat, Monday through Friday every morning.
It's a great way to start your day.
Get your IQ bar, 64000, and listen to Offbeat with Alex Stumpf.
But, yeah, I feel like the only reason Cruz has been slotted in that spot is because that's the spot where he himself has gotten himself started.
That's where he gets himself – he needs that more than the team needs that.
And, like, that's just an observation.
I don't have any numbers to support that.
But observing it throughout his career, it seems like he gets the most hits and the most good at-bats when he bats first in the lineup.
Now, how has that affected the team, though?
Look at last year.
The team wasn't that great.
Sure, Oneil Cruz was hitting home runs early in the season, doing all this, getting on base.
But then what happens when he goes through these cold spells?
And we know he does.
And that's fine.
It's the hitter he's become is he has really hot streaks and really cold streaks.
You can't have that guy as your leadoff batter.
You've got to have a guy like Spencer Horwitz who has the stats to back it up that say he gets on base, whether he singles, doubles, walks, whatever.
And from one from one alleged drunken sailor to another, let's talk about what Michael wanted to talk about earlier with Ozuna before we get out of here.
Ozuna's strikeouts are becoming a problem.
He's in spots where guys are on base.
Am I able to see how many he specifically left on base?
Because I think it was quite a few today.
But he's just not coming through.
And he has.
Like, May has been great for him.
Or not great, but it's been better.
It's been serviceable so far in May.
But you got to see that consistency.
And we thought we were seeing it.
But it just doesn't seem like he's catching on.
Yeah.
He teases us for a week here or there.
Historically, Ben Cherington does not give up on anybody before June and has somewhat been rewarded with that.
Right.
we wanted Tommy Pham out of town.
We wanted Rowdy Tellez out of town.
And they both had great Junes.
And so, I wonder if that's what Ben Cherington's hoping for, counting on, believing will happen.
So, there's a, he should be batting seventh, eighth, ninth.
And that gets a little frustrating, too.
Because, then we're turning that, those last three outs are pretty automatic.
Although, Henry did Homer today.
Yeah.
We haven't even gotten to that.
Yeah.
I know.
Yeah.
Amazing.
Henry Homer's.
And, we're, what are we, 30 minutes in?
Yeah.
33 minutes in.
We haven't discussed that yet.
But, yeah, I just, it seems like there's more value in throwing the younger guys that have shown that they can hit ahead of Ozuna.
And that, honestly, that sets up another opportunity for Ozuna to prove himself, right?
Because if Griffin's getting on base, if Garcia's getting on base, and you put Ozuna in that seven or eight spot, guess what?
He's hitting those guys in.
I have to read this.
Let me read this.
I'm sorry.
I'm going to interrupt you.
Because my name is Doug, and my broadcasts get more super chats than DiNardo's.
Again, I did not say that.
Steel City DW said it was a $10 gift.
Everybody's going after DiNardo today.
DiNardo, again, he's one of my personal heroes.
But, the people are speaking.
That's all I'm saying.
But, yeah, like, I know, like, everybody thinks that if you're moved down in the lineup, that's a demotion.
But in reality, I think this is just giving Ozuna another opportunity to prove himself.
Because you're going to put guys in front of him that can't get on base.
So it's the same situation.
It's just he'll have less opportunities to screw it up.
Yeah.
look, sports is a meritocracy.
It is about production.
It's about earning your way.
And he's not doing it right.
And look, the guy is a professional.
Yeah.
I think he'd be the first to tell you, yeah, I haven't not shown that I deserve to be coming up in the leadoff position or, so I'm sorry, cleanup position.
He knows he needs to be better.
Baseball is very simple.
this isn't like, judging a guard in NFL, right?
Like, where, there's not real counting stats to explain, what he's doing.
Man, the chat is on fire today.
I know.
Look at Jack.
Jack gives us five subs.
We appreciate it, Jack.
You're the man.
More members.
More members.
So, yeah.
Yeah, that's all I have to say about Ozuna.
quickly, before we get to our giveaway, let's talk about Henry Davis.
Hasn't been looking great.
You heavily critiqued his swing the other night.
We posted that clip.
But he gets on to one today, and he sends it 413.
I think it was 103 off the bat.
It was a nice-looking hit, Doug, and he knew it.
He did the bat flip and everything.
I know.
But should he?
this is the guy that his team, I still remember Cam Newton being down 28 to nothing with 30 seconds left, scores a touchdown, and then does this.
It's like, you're not really Superman today, buddy.
Sorry.
And that's what that was.
No, to be fair, it wasn't like he Jose Bautista did.
No, I know, but it's like, you're still in the position where you should just be putting your bat down, your head down, getting around the bases, and, you know.
look, he hit a home run.
He should be excited.
And it was an important home run, obviously.
It was the difference in the game.
Yeah, like you said, difference in the game.
He gives you the winning run on that home run because nobody else seemed to be able to do that.
Everybody's running into the ground ball outs, the double plays like Garcia did.
But, yes, Henry Davis hits the home run, gives us the winning run.
Now, is he going to do something with this?
Is he going to ride with this momentum?
Like, that's what the question always is.
That's what the question always is with Henry Davis.
You see something good.
Yeah.
You see something good, and then you're like, well, what are we going to do with this?
Yeah.
And then he doesn't capitalize on the momentum.
Tyler and I have been on the past two shows, and, the question I posed to him and then we talked about yesterday is how soon is, Endy Rodríguez getting those, getting more at-bats than Henry?
And, Henry maybe staged it off a little today.
But, and again, competition is good.
Yes.
so, right.
Look, we'd all be thrilled with Henry going on a run.
it would be great.
Just finding some consistency and just getting to like, his average over 200, get on pace for 15 home runs.
And, it's like, we're not, given how good his defense is and how good a job he's doing calling the games and, we know what a hard worker he is, that thing.
Like, okay, you don't have to be Mike Trout, peak Mike Trout.
But, you got to be better than hitting 130 or whatever he's saying, 144.
Well, folks, I think that's all we have to say about today's game.
It was a good one.
It was, it was long, but it was good.
It was a good pitching matchup.
And then, Pirates scored two to one.
But, Doug, I think I know what the people really want.
This is what they're here for.
This is what they're here for.
They are here for sandwiches.
Got 169 in there.
Nice.
170.
There it is.
Good luck, everybody.
Can we get a couple more, folks?
No.
We need a few more raises.
We need two.
Going once.
Going twice.
Hit like.
Subscribe.
Join.
Join us.
Join us.
Look how much fun we're having.
Come on.
Tell a friend.
Thank you, everybody, for the donations today as well.
that was awesome.
You guys are outstanding.
Corey, Patrick, Gary.
Congratulations, Corey.
Corey, Patrick, or Gary.
Or all three.
CPG, baby.
Only two of those guys get a sandwich.
Yeah.
Yeah.
One of those guys is going home unhappy, right?
And one more winner for two sandwiches.
Got MW Pitt.
MW Pitt.
Congratulations, folks.
If you've been here before, you know what to do.
If you haven't, email us at NorthShore9 at gmail.com.
That's where we will get your info.
Let us know your email that you signed up to the Primanti Brothers app with.
And that is how we will send you your stuff.
Your Sammies.
Get your Sammies, baby.
So, anyway.
There's Corey.
Corey says, finally.
He finally won.
Congrats, folks.
Three guys to feed there.
So, yeah.
Thanks again, everybody, for joining us.
We're three weeks away from our tailgate.
And I'm looking forward to it, man.
Hopefully, the team gets on a good roll.
hopefully, they roll into this thing 13-2 or something.
It'll be a lot of fun.
Either way, we'll be there.
We'll have a good time.
There will be sandwiches there.
There will be cones there.
Cody's going to be there.
He missed last one.
Yeah, I'm excited.
Yeah.
So, come join us.
We have a blast.
I'm looking forward to my trip.
My trip to Pittsburgh.
My first one of the year?
Yes.
It's the first time I'm going to Pittsburgh this year.
Comments· 2
Should Spencer Horwitz replace Oneil Cruz as the Pirates' leadoff hitter?